Federico Faggin’s Irreducible, Chapter 6: Is Life Different From a Computer?
Mark wishes scientists had never called it junk DNA, and Jeremy sees the same habit in the name dark matter. Leave it to us to call something not valuable when we can't explain it or understand it.
In this episode · 14 chapters
When does the robot become the human? When is the human no longer human but something else? And when is the robot no longer a robot and something else?
Mark and Jeremy read chapter six of Irreducible by Federico Faggin, on the nature of life, just after interviewing Kevin Kelly, who Jeremy says holds a very opposite opinion. They work through live information, cyanobacteria and whether a single cell can have free will.
Faggin lists seven differences between a cell and a computer, and the hosts test them one by one. Mark sets a robot that cuts the grass against the claim that robots need constant supervision, and they argue about science fiction's staying power.
Federico Faggin's Irreducible: Consciousness, Life, Computers and Human Nature, chapter 6, argues that living cells differ fundamentally from computers, and that this is why machines will never be conscious. The Thinking On Paper podcast book club reads it the same week it interviewed Kevin Kelly, who takes the opposite view, and Mark Fielding disputes Faggin's claim that robots need constant supervision.
How does a cell differ from a computer, according to Faggin?
Faggin’s core contrast: “a computer is made of permanent classical matter, while a cell is made of dynamic quantum matter.”
How are cells built differently from robots?
Cells are built from the inside out, with each cell carrying the blueprint of the whole organism. A robot, in Faggin’s words, is made of “separate parts assembled by external agents”.
Does every cell share our consciousness, according to Faggin?
Faggin argues that every cell in the body shares our consciousness and free will, which he says is the only way to explain how a single-celled paramecium behaves coherently in an unpredictable environment.
How does Irreducible end its list of cell and robot differences?
Irreducible lists seven differences between a cell and a robot, ending with: “In a robot there is no whole but only the sum of its classic parts.”
Is biology becoming more about information than biochemistry?
Jeremy picks out the book’s idea that biology is becoming more about information than biochemistry, with DNA as the recipe.
Where Mark and Faggin disagree
Mark compares Faggin’s life force to the Force in Star Wars, disputes that robots “require constant supervision”, and asks whether robots grown in a petri dish could be conscious. Kevin Kelly, interviewed the same week, takes the opposite view to Faggin.
Links from this episode
Questions
Is life different from a computer?
Faggin’s core contrast: “a computer is made of permanent classical matter, while a cell is made of dynamic quantum matter.”
What is chapter 6 of Irreducible about?
Federico Faggin's Irreducible: Consciousness, Life, Computers and Human Nature, chapter 6, argues that living cells differ fundamentally from computers, and that this is why machines will never be conscious.
How does Kevin Kelly's view compare with Faggin's?
The Thinking On Paper podcast book club reads it the same week it interviewed Kevin Kelly, who takes the opposite view, and Mark Fielding disputes Faggin's claim that robots need constant supervision.
What topics does the chapter 6 discussion cover?
They work through live information, cyanobacteria and whether a single cell can have free will.
Transcript
Mark Fielding Disruptors and curious minds, book lovers, you're tuned into Thinking on Paper Book Club. We're reading Irreducible by Federico Faggin, Consciousness, Life, Computers and Human Nature. But before we get into chapter six, I have an urgent news update from Thinking on Paper. We've just wrapped interviewing Kevin Kelly, ladies and gentlemen. Kevin Kelly, founder of Wired, author, father, thinker, futurist. He's been, since the 1990s, he's been at the Avant-Garde, the forefront.
of all tech revolution. He's been there giving advice, casting his opinions, describing the future. We interviewed him. So wherever you're listening to this, click on the previous episode or the next episode, depending on when you're listening and listen to that and let us know what you think. Kevin Kelly. Plugging the show, Jeremy, there you go. So Irreducible, chapter six, life. What is life, Jeremy?
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, I'm gonna tease our Kevin Kelly episode where you basically flip the pages and you ask Kevin Kelly to stop on his book and we read a passage of there. I don't know that we can.
Mark Fielding How much do think we can talk about Kevin Kelly in this episode of the Thinking on Paper Book Club before people go, enough of Kevin Kelly, I want to know about consciousness, AI and what it means to be human.
Jeremy Gilbertson I say we push the boundary. I say we push the boundary. Alright, so The Nature of Life, chapter 6. A lot of interesting themes are coming up. A lot of things are connecting. You know, it's balancing this... on one pole being the quantum, being quantum coupled with the idea of free will and consciousness potentially, dare I say, being fundamental. Annika Harris plug. I'm reading or I've just finished...
Lights On
Jeremy Gilbertson the documentary audio documentary lights on, which we've some very cool stuff into this. But then going back to the macro level, the classical level and what that means via animate slash inanimate. thought there was an interesting, yeah, this is really cool. Kicking it down the line. Molecules in DNA, stars in the galaxy, Neil deGrasse Tyson added a nice little note just to get us thinking about the the bigness and the smallness and the smallness and the bigness. I don't know where did you where did you what what roped you in to your chapter six aha moment?
Mark Fielding The nature of life, the nature of life, what is life? That's why I began with that. I'm gonna stick with that. And I'm gonna ask the listeners to comment below with what you think life is really about. He begins with a few quotes. We have Charlie Chaplin. We have George-Louis Bourgeuse. If it is a journey, if it is a dream, if it is a waited, if it is a plan that takes place day after day. And you do not notice it except by looking backwards. This life, which is too good to be meaningless.
So again, it's all about organic life and consciousness. And he's trying to connect the dots between what it means to be conscious and life. And essentially he's just building up the argument over and over again for why AI and why machines will never be conscious because they're not organic matter. Life is dynamic. Life is holistic, free will.
Jeremy Gilbertson But back to back to Kevin Kelly again listeners, Kevin Kelly has a very opposite opinion as our author and host of Irreducible. So if you want to hear the opposite side of what this guy thinks, listen to the Kevin Kelly episode.
Consciousness as a spectrum
Mark Fielding Yeah, because he defined consciousness as a spectrum, he, where AI will be conscious, but it won't be a consciousness the same as ours, which is kind of what Federico's getting into here when he's talking about paramecium and he's talking about...
Mark Fielding cyanobacteria and biomolecules and how they are kind of conscious? No.
Cyanobacteria
Jeremy Gilbertson So cyanobacteria, I learned about them a long time ago and just the idea that burping bacteria created the world that we live in right now. Like literally these bacterium.
exhaling necessarily exhaling and creating helping to create you know the air that we breathe breathe right now so if that doesn't tie you together into that we're all kind of made of the same stuff and and there are bigger things at play than just us but let's let's dive into this this one idea that i wrote down the idea that biology is becoming more about information than biochemistry and and and that got me thinking to what he was calling live information and how we use live information as animate organisms, right? Versus the information that happens within inanimate computers. What did you think about that, the whole?
Mark Fielding Just a clarification for the listeners, the last chapter Federico outlined his, what he calls live information which Jeremy has just referred to and he calls it matter plus energy plus information and that is only possible in live organic matter. So what was your question sorry?
Jeremy Gilbertson That's a great one. I'm steering sideways. Well, good thing we can edit this shit, Mark. Where was I going with that?
Biology as information
Jeremy Gilbertson biology being more about information than biochemistry, right?
Jeremy Gilbertson That also pointed back to DNA, right? And DNA basically being recipes for producing the things, the small things that were built and made of, right? So that's interesting, right? When you think about it, know, not being all about these biochemical processes, it's actually the information required to induce the catalysts into producing the processes.
So that was an interesting, I think that's a theory that's been around for the last 20 years. I think you references it. It's gaining more and more ground today. Back to the, the callback to computers can't give birth to other computers, which conjures the funniest images in my brain of robots in the labor room. But here's what I picked out of that. Humans built from the inside out, literally like every small piece of us.
Contains the information to build the whole of us right so that that goes back to DNA and then computers being Outside in there these pieces and parts they get kind of cobbled together and then connected and organized with with software One more thing on that that I thought was pretty cool back to the human side cells are made of dynamic quantum matter and Computers the pieces of computers are made From permanent classical matter, so there's that quantum classical
I don't have a question for you in there, it's helping me continue to differentiate between man and machine.
Mark Fielding Well, that's why we do the book club, Jeremy, so you can think in real time and let those thoughts percolate and digest and come to the surface. On this book, so call back again to ladies and gentlemen, we interviewed Kevin Kelly this week. If you want to listen to that, check it out. But one of the first questions we asked Kevin Kelly was the role of nature within technology, the role of technology within nature. And...
Jeremy Gilbertson Kevin Kelly.
Mark Fielding I asked that question because I spend a lot of time in nature and a lot of this chapter novel to me. mean life is dynamic, life is holistic. Okay, there is no permanent reality except for the reality of change. Okay, I get that.
It is important to recognise the irreducible existence of an individual consciousness in every living organism. For example, we cannot explain the coherence and intelligent behaviour of a paramecium in a widely unpredictable environment without there being a central creative function that coordinates its actions as a unit, just as we have consciousness and free will, so every cell in our body must also share the same properties. He's referred to this, alluded to this before. I like it. I agree with it. I think that...
Anyone who grew up watching Star Wars probably agrees with that. He's basically describing a life force within everything, within nature. Isn't he?
Jeremy Gilbertson but as a fundamental element of nature. again, Annika Harris, lights on. I mean, is it?
That is the force
Mark Fielding But that's what Star Wars is! That's the force!
Mark Fielding That's essentially what the force is. He's wrapping up the force in scientific... He's doing that thing of over-complicating simple ideas. That's where I'm going with this. Because I don't think... He's not the first person to say there is one universal... I mean, essentially, just as we have consciousness and free will, so every cell in our body must also share the same properties.
Jeremy Gilbertson So I look at the Star Wars.
Mark Fielding This is possible because the essence of the whole is present in each of its parts, namely in each of ourselves is present. The DNA, okay, he's saying to DNA and that links all together. But I think he's, most people understand this oneness, this interconnectedness, this holistic system of what it means to be alive and conscious in this today, any day.
Cells with free will
Jeremy Gilbertson So cells with free will, like, so this, like, the cell, one of the cells on my cheek has free will to participate in the ecosystem that is my face and my body and me make choices on its own? Is that what he's saying? don't know if I, consciousness and free will, that gets funky, right? So I am subscribing to the idea. And again, I keep calling back to Lights On, audio documentary, Annika Harris.
you know, lot of her position is that consciousness is fundamental. Meaning, you know, you can't ask more questions about it. It's an element that is just is, and it exists in all things as a piece of all things.
Mark Fielding On the free will, does that thing on your face have free will? Are we confusing our free will with the free will of a cell? Is there?
The hard problem
Jeremy Gilbertson Here's the challenging thing about it, kind of the hard problem. I think it's the references, the hard problem of consciousness, maybe. The idea that like, that we can't observe someone else's consciousness. Like I can't sit there with my clipboard and my white coat and observe what your consciousness is from an objective perspective. Like that, it's locked within, it's an inside out thing and it's something that I can't study about you, which makes it so difficult, meaning.
you can't look under a microscope and look at a cell and look at a mitochondria within a cell and be like, well, let's see what the consciousness activity is going on with this particular cell today, right? And what does that even mean? Like literally, what does that even mean? It's our perception, our organization of sensory inputs and our stitching together of a human experience. Maybe that is kind of what consciousness is. I don't know.
It's really a big bag to unpack, but it's one that I'm interested to continue to explore. I'm pretty driven to kind of figure that thing out, but it's tough. It's the hard problem.
Mark Fielding Consciousness is what gives perception and understanding to the organism, while free will allows it to act as a unified entity within its own intention based on conscious comprehension.
Jeremy Gilbertson So comprehension again, he references as the difference computers can't really comprehend something according to according to our host and author. But if you think about like a computer with sensory inputs and those sensory inputs, bringing information to the computer and the software makes, makes it seem like the computer's making a decision where it is really just subscribing to a rule that's very deterministic, right?
Jeremy Gilbertson So you can pre-program some stuff, right? But you can't pre-program this idea of consciousness, it just happens and it just is ever revealing itself in real time.
Jeremy Gilbertson Shout out to the moms in the world though, speaking of mitochondria. Did you know that all mitochondria come from the female side of the birth equation?
Jeremy Gilbertson That's the energy, the energy pieces of our body. What makes us, what gives us energy, what creates energy in our body comes from, comes from moms. It's kind of awesome.
Mark Fielding So we all get that's where you get our energy from.
Casting a robot
Jeremy Gilbertson All right, here you go. What did you think about him casting out to 100 to 200 years where, hey, robots might eventually be able to connect their genome to a 3D printer and drop by drop, literally build another version of that robot? I thought that was an interesting analogy.
Mark Fielding but that still wouldn't be conscious.
Jeremy Gilbertson Exactly. And why, Mark?
Mark Fielding Well, I want to change his thought experiment. What page is that on?
Well, because they'll still be built from the outside, not from the inside out, like we are built from inside. It would still be 3D printing itself. But what if, forget the 3D printer, I think he's creating an argument to support what he's saying with that. okay, in this distant future where robots are, AI robots are in space, 3D printing replicas of themselves. Why are they using 3D printers? Like, so, okay, you have this futuristic vision and yet they're using a printer. So for me that was like okay what if as I said in a previous episode what if they're making them in a petri dish? What if they're making replicas of themselves? Bio-organic replicas of themselves which are which contain the electrons which are building themselves from the inside out. What what if we move away from this insistence that robots are non-organic, that robots are made of bits and pieces and chips in a lab, are made from the outside in. Why we move away from that and make our robots in a Petri dish? And then I want to see if they're making themselves from the inside out, then are they capable of free will and consciousness?
Jeremy Gilbertson But if you're making them in a petri dish, that requires organic material versus inorganic. So how is it a robot? Why is it not a human?
Mark Fielding Yeah, that's what I mean. So yeah, so. Well, exactly. Well, not exactly. Yeah, but.
Well, that's a whole other episode, isn't it? When does the robot become the human? When is the human no longer human but something else? And when is the robot no longer a robot and something else? And do we meet in the middle somewhere, we create this new species that's not robotic, not human as we know it today, but something new.
and capable of free will and conscious thought.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, good grief.
Mark Fielding A robot that goes, know what? I'm not working today. It's sunny. It's spring. Sod you. I am, I've got free will. I am a, I am a semi-organic.
The crowded room
Jeremy Gilbertson Have you ever had those instances where you were in a crowded space and you considered maybe these things around me are robots. What if three or four of them are actually robots? I say this a little bit in jest because I was hanging out with a buddy years ago and we were at this weird little food hall just outside of
Naples, Florida, which was just, it was an odd little spot. No, no, no, no, no. I wish Naples, Florida. And we're sitting there looking around and he just goes, he goes, think all of these people around here are robots. And we just went on with this thought experiment for like 30 or 40 minutes, not under the influence of even a cold beer. And it was really interesting to kind of, kind of think about that. I'm not sure where I'm going, but.
Mark Fielding I think I'll say Naples,
Mark Fielding It's like a mixture of the Truman Show with this multiverse theory and the we're all in a computer game. Yeah, possibly. See, you should take that thought because.
The only genre that survives
Mark Fielding This book, right now, I want it written by a science fiction writer. And I think this book goes a long way to explaining why science fiction as a genre is... So I had this thought a while ago. I said that in the future, in the distant, distant future, like thousands and thousands of years in the future, if we're still around, the only literature which will still be read will be science fiction.
It's the only genre of human literature which will survive the eons of space. that's... You know, like, stories will survive because it's wired into us. And I think that in the far, far reaches of the future will...
Jeremy Gilbertson Why do you say that? Like physically survive or just as narrative survive?
Mark Fielding the human condition will be wrapped up in the story of science fiction. I don't think that drama and romance and mystery and all of these, I don't think they'll, people won't be reading Dracula in a hundred thousand years, but they will be reading Blade Runner, Dandroid's Dream of Electric Sheep. There you go.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, I disagree with that, Mark, because right now there's a callback to the 90s for 20-somethings, know, teenagers and 20-somethings, a callback to the aesthetic of the 90s, which to me doesn't seem that long ago, but if you really actually do the math, it's 30-plus years ago, whatever the hell, but I think there's always gonna be a callback to what was while you're looking towards what will be.
Mark Fielding I'm talking 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 100, 200,000 years into the future when we have organic humanoids everywhere.
The seven differences
Mark Fielding The fundamental difference between a cell and a computer, page 130, he lays it out seven differences, seven fundamental differences between a cell and a computer. The most notable difference between a computer and a cell is that a computer is made of permanent classical matter, while a cell is made of dynamic quantum matter. And then he outlines...
Seven. Should we jump through those quickly? think this could be quite interesting following the discussion we've just had about you and Naples
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah. Paramecium and microchip, is that where we're going?
Mark Fielding Yeah, why not? That sounds like a... Or you and me and a microchip. A listener and a microchip. What is the difference between you, listener, and a microchip? Number one, a robot is a classical reductionist and permanent organisation made up of separate parts assembled by external agents. A cell is a quantum and classical organisation, holistic, dynamic and self-reproducing made of live information that moves in and out of its porous and dynamic membrane.
Number one, okay, well, as I just said, why, but okay.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, and this is the whole illusion of boundaries too, from natural systems, right? So cells aren't these little like super neat little circles where everything stays contained. There's a symbiotic nature between the cell and the environment. you know, things like bacteria, they're inside and outside themselves all the time, Yes. Cells never the same instant after instant, right? Yep.
Mark Fielding Number two, Jeremy, hit us with number two.
Jeremy Gilbertson So chips or we'll say robots in this example number two are deterministic with the exception of input signals which come from the free will of conscious agents interacting with them, right? So this kind of goes back to like a robot having these sensors that can kind of take stuff in from the environment and then process that through their programming to make a decision, right? Where it seems like, light comes in and.
the robot puts a hat on, right, or whatever the heck it is, it's not a decision by the robot, it's a processing of the software, right? So the free will and consciousness piece of it comes into when you decided to program the robot to put a hat on when a certain degree of sunshine came in the sensor.
Robots are not autonomous
Mark Fielding Number three, robots or chips. Robots are not autonomous and require constant supervision unless they perform simple functions. Cells on the other hand are autonomous, capable of dealing with unpredictable situations, including hostile environments. Obviously, I don't think Federico has seen any films about robots, but yes.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, all right, so robots are not autonomous and require constant supervision. So he also references hostile environments. you know, parenting children requires constant supervision. Are children robots? No.
Mark Fielding And do robots really need constant supervision? I mean, like, there's the football pitch down here, there's a robot that cuts the lawn, cuts the grass, and it doesn't have anyone supervising it.
I can't wait for the backlash from this episode, Jeremy.
Jeremy Gilbertson So supervision could be considered maintenance of code, right? Rather than standing next to, okay. All right, number four. Each cell of a multicellular organism contains the entire blueprint of the whole. So this goes back to the 3D printing analogy and that sort of thing. So every drop of the robot's 3D printer powered by its genome doesn't contain all of it in the little drops. So that makes sense.
Mark Fielding Yeah, I know, I'm being facetious.
Mark Fielding DNA in every cell and I still wish that they'd never called junk DNA junk DNA because it just seems that it's anything but junk. It's like 98 % of all our DNA is junk DNA and because they called it that at the beginning it's kind of stuck and if it's stuck in my mind it's stuck in everyone's mind about how there is junk and it's quite hard to separate the word from what actually is.
Jeremy Gilbertson Leave it to us to call something not valuable when we can't explain it or understand it. Like same with dark matter, like dark matter. Like it's doing something very profound, but it's just this weird dark stuff that no one knows how to explain. Except for Vera Rubin, who did it tremendously well.
Mark Fielding Number five, in a robot information processing and communications are essentially digital with some analog input output functions while in a cell live information is used. Remember live information is matter plus energy plus information.
Jeremy Gilbertson So no matter in the processing of information in a robot.
Jeremy Gilbertson in the power supply, right?
Mark Fielding It's not in the mitochondria is it? That only comes from the woman robot.
Pavlov's cell
Jeremy Gilbertson Let's go moms, what's up? All right, number six. Robots are objective classical systems without consciousness and without free will. Cells are both objective and subjective and they have consciousness and free will, even though they are strongly conditioned by the laws of physics. Strongly conditioned. Strongly conditioned.
Mark Fielding Ding ding ding, it's Pavlov- Pavlov- Pavlov- Cell.
Jeremy Gilbertson Pavlov's Cell Fantastic. Fantastic.
Mark Fielding I'm with you on this bit about cells, cells that have consciousness and free will. It's quite hard to wrap my head around what he's trying to say with that free will where they're operating within a holistic whole. So it's not like free will me, I'm going to decide to take my hat off and go out and sunbathe. It's more that they have to do something within their system and
Mark Fielding Yeah, like I said, hard to get my head around that.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, free is free will coordinated consciousness, right? So that's something to think about too. Like you're talking about all of these things coordinated in this ecosystem of an event happening, right? Or a qualia is like the quantifiable or the attempted quantifiable aspect of the experience, right? Which has a lot to do with consciousness. But yeah, he's talked about this classical objective and quantum and conscious.
is the difference there. Number seven, bring us home, Mark.
Number seven
Mark Fielding A cell has all the classical characteristics of a machine and in addition it has the quantum characteristics that come from live information, consciousness and free will. In a robot there is no whole but only the sum of its classic parts. A cell is connected with a quantum whole that is more than the sum of its quantum and classical parts.
In summary, the crucial property is that differentiator living organism from a robot equipped with artificial intelligence derived from the consciousness and free will that communicate with the quantum portion of its cells using live information to determine its overall behavior.
Jeremy Gilbertson Man. So what do you guys think? What is life? What is the difference between man and machine? I think this chapter did a pretty decent job of putting somewhat concrete parameters behind it. thought that was pretty cool, but it's like...
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, the animate inanimate what makes things animate, you know, there used to be this magic right this little math forgot what they ended up calling it back in like the the Greek days but it was like this essentially like this magic dust that activated particles where you know now the the thought is that the magic exists within the small pieces and parts and not based not the result of a collision between pieces and parts. So anyway face melting brain melting aside, we're moving through this book. We're stepping into chapter seven, which I've made.
Mark Fielding the nature of consciousness, Jeremy, Chapter 7, which I think might help hopefully answer some of our problems and challenges with this free will part of the picture. Maybe, maybe not.
Jeremy Gilbertson Are you an expert in consciousness? Are you a physicist? Are you a neuroscientist? Are you somebody that lives and breathes to uncover and unlock what is consciousness? If you are, please send us a note. We want to have you on this next episode for chapter seven because Mark and I need a little hand holding and let's look at an examination quote of consciousness, right?
Mark Fielding What is life but full of care? You have no time to stand and stare. Jeremy, we are conscious, you are conscious. An electron can't exist without the hole, but you exist. You are conscious. Now, this is your thinking on paper.
Check in for you to use it. So take a minute, be aware, think about what you're doing, where you are, look around you, what can you see, who are you with, what are you thinking about now? Consciousness.
Jeremy Gilbertson how funny you just like you when you snapped everything stopped in that moment. If that still stays in the video, that would be amazing. another quick, all right, another quick, I know we're trying to wrap this up, but you mentioned like, what are you thinking right now and what is right now? And now is actually then because it takes 80 milliseconds to process what now is Daniel Eagleman. If you ever read any of his books, he talks about how senses hit our brain in a different time and we stitch together reality, right? One really cool example from the meditation kind of world is to understand what now really is, think about the moment right before you move something. So stay still and think about your hands, right? But don't move your hands yet. Think about, I'm about to wiggle my fingers. That's now. The about to.
right in between. So anyway, there you have it. We've teetered on some lines today, but I'm okay with it. That's what it's here for. Mark, any closing thoughts before we...
Mark Fielding Yeah, I'm gonna go speak to my consciousness and do something fun because is fun not the whole point of consciousness? I argue that it is. Thank you for listening to the book club everybody. Bring your books next week. Be disruptive, stay curious.
Jeremy Gilbertson Keep thinking on paper.
Jeremy Gilbertson Alright, little off the rails on that




