Has Kevin Kelly Changed His Mind About Technology?
Kevin Kelly predicts people will form strong emotional attachments to AIs, and he expects things to go wrong. This is the most powerful technology we've ever made, so therefore, we're gonna have the most powerful problems we've ever had.
In this episode · 13 chapters
- Technology as nature
- Bottom-up systems, from Out of Control to Wikipedia
- Why DAOs haven't worked
- Imagining the unimaginable future
- Google and the plan to build AI
- AI, emotions and smart glasses
- Is AI conscious? Many kinds of minds
- Advice on saying yes to the future
- Writing to think
- Working with AI
- Are aliens here?
- How to cultivate wonder
- Life advice: ownership costs and managing yourself
When I go out to look at nature, I see a kind of technology. And when I look at technology, I see a kind of nature.
Kevin Kelly, founder of Wired, has argued since Out of Control that the natural and technological worlds are part of the same force. He calls technology the seventh kingdom of life, and explains why bottom-up systems like Wikipedia still need a little top-down guidance.
Kelly explains why the first DAO stumbled on immutable rules and recalls asking Larry at Google where search was going. The answer: “We're making AI. This is all to make an AI.” He also describes writing as the way he discovers what he thinks.
Kevin Kelly, co-founder of Wired magazine and author of What Technology Wants and The Inevitable, tells the Thinking On Paper podcast that AI has not changed his mind about technology. He predicts the next big shock will come from emotional AI: when AIs are coded with emotions, people will form strong bonds with them.
Why does Kevin Kelly call technology the seventh kingdom of life?
Kelly argues that nature and technology are “two faces of the same coin”, the idea behind his first book, Out of Control. He calls technology “the seventh kingdom of life” because it behaves as a system the way evolution does in nature.
Why did DAOs struggle, according to Kevin Kelly?
Kelly says the most powerful systems are decentralised and built from the bottom up, but they still need a little top-down guidance, as Wikipedia found. He explains why DAOs, decentralised autonomous organisations run by fixed code, struggled: contracts usually need renegotiating, so their immutable rules were “not a feature, it was a bug”.
What did Google's founder tell Kevin Kelly about search?
Kelly recalls meeting Google's founder Larry at a party, before Google had a business model, and telling him he could not see the business in search. The answer, he says, was: “We're making AI. This is all to make an AI.” From the start, Kelly says, Google's agenda was to build the tools and data needed for AI.
Will people bond with emotional AI, says Kevin Kelly?
Kelly predicts people will bond with emotional AIs the way they bond with pets, and beyond, and that people will call it addiction. He compares the dependence to needing glasses: the answer is to make sure the AI is never turned off. He also expects harm: “This is the most powerful technology we've ever made, so therefore, we're gonna have the most powerful problems we've ever had.”
Do current LLMs have consciousness, according to Kevin Kelly?
Kelly treats intelligence and consciousness as spectrums, not on-off switches, and talks about AIs in the plural. “I would say the current LLMs have some degree of consciousness in them”, in the way a dog does, but not a human kind. He calls them “artificial aliens”, like Star Trek's Spock: conscious, smart and not quite like us.
Where Jeremy and Kelly disagree
Jeremy rejects the glasses comparison: “My glasses aren't going to manipulate my emotions to read a certain book.” Kelly agrees the stakes are higher because AI works on the mind, which we treat as ourselves: “We're messing with ourselves.”
Links from this episode
Questions
Who is Kevin Kelly?
Kevin Kelly, co-founder of Wired magazine and author of What Technology Wants and The Inevitable, tells the Thinking On Paper podcast that AI has not changed his mind about technology.
What is Kevin Kelly's book Out of Control about?
Kevin Kelly, founder of Wired, has argued since Out of Control that the natural and technological worlds are part of the same force.
How does Kevin Kelly use writing?
He also describes writing as the way he discovers what he thinks.
Transcript
Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds, welcome to another episode, a very special episode of Thinking on Paper. We couldn't be more excited about our guest. I'm not gonna give you a witty ramble. I think we're gonna hand it off right to Mark to dive into who we're talking to, but the only thing I will say is a lot of what Mark and I do today is largely inspired by what this individual has done for decades and decades. So I'll leave it at that. Mark, who are we talking to today?
Technology as nature
Mark Fielding We are speaking to Kevin Kelly, founder of Wired Magazine, the man behind A Thousand True Fans, The Quantified Self, the author of many books, including What Technology Wants, The Inevitable, Loads of Others. He's built his own house, cycled across America, hitchhiked across Japan, and his new book, Excellent Advice for Living Wisdom, I wish I'd known earlier, is out now.
Mark Fielding Welcome to show, Kevin Kelly. Thank you very much for thinking on paper with us. And I just want to start following off where we were in the green room just before.
Mark Fielding how has nature and being in nature framed and helped frame your life's work?
Kevin Kelly That's a great, great, great question. I like that framing. This apparent dichotomy was actually the origin of my first book, Out of Control, which was making the argument that in fact, nature, the natural organic world and the technological world are actually part of the same world, part of the same force. They're two faces of the same coin.
Kevin Kelly And that they're not as different as they appear. That in fact, technology and all the stuff around us and this high-tech stuff is actually an extension of the evolution on the planet. And I like to call the technology the seventh kingdom of life because it behaves in the same way as a system as evolution in nature does. And so...
Kevin Kelly When I go out to look at nature, I see a kind of technology. And when I look at technology, I see a kind of nature. And so for me, there isn't that harsh opposition. It's actually much more of a unity that I see.
Bottom-up systems, from Out of Control to Wikipedia
Jeremy Gilbertson I would love your thoughts on this, this interesting give and take between hierarchical systems and emergent systems and this dance that happens. have you noticed that throughout your work and how influential is that in having things come to life when things go away?
Kevin Kelly hate to reference my original book and published in 94, but written in the early nineties, which was about this very thing of the organizational of things that were really interesting and that we liked like life, like our minds, like a society. And my conclusion from all that research was that
Kevin Kelly Generally the most powerful systems you can make were ones that were very decentralized with a very flat hierarchy that were generating things from the bottom up and that was sort of written at the very beginnings of the internet world and We've since seen the power that that had And then other things like AIs and all reflecting that similar kind of organization, they're very, very flat. There's not a lot of hierarchy. But the thing about it is, is that there's some hierarchy. So they aren't completely amorphous. They aren't completely empty of any kind of hierarchy. And often the hierarchy is a result of what we call pace layers of different rates of things happening. That's how things come out. So like if you could imagine a ...
Kevin Kelly corporation or even a company or a country where you have most of the activity happening down here, there has to be some layer where people are concerned about doing what needs to be done tomorrow or today, but there's got to be some layer that's thinking about the long-term strategy that moves at a different rate, and that's where you get hierarchy. And so it turns out that
Kevin Kelly Working from the bottom up, like Wikipedia, is a great way to start something, but it's not going to take you all the way. The encyclopedia that you really, really want has to have a little bit of top-down hierarchical control, something guiding it. It isn't a large percent, but it has to be present to some degree. And I had a great illustration of that in one of the early SIGGRAPH conferences which were all based around the future of visualization and movie special effects and now we see the kind of movie generation with AI called SIGGRAPH and this was 20 years ago, 30 years, I can't remember. They had little devices where they gave to people to control a video game on the screen. So there's like 5,000 people, they've got some little kind of wireless control thing and they're going to collectively steer this thing. And the first thing they did was they were flying an airplane. So you have a Microsoft flight simulator. You have 5,000 people who are not pilots going to try to pilot a plane together. And they were able to do it. And once I was doing like pitch, the other was doing yaw and stuff. And so they were actually able to emergently fly the plane and actually to roll it. And then they were given the assignment to run a submarine collectively and capture some eggs or something that were hidden. It was a little story. And they couldn't do it. And there were too many variables. And they were just.
Kevin Kelly looking around and nothing was happening, this is going around, whatever it was. And then there was a voice in the back said, you know, aim for the top or something simple. And suddenly it just cohere and they were able to do it, the whole audience. So it just took a little tiny bit of leadership to kind of lead. And so there was this great fantastic example of how the bottom up is the main force, is the decentralized being, this distributed governance, is the way you do things. But you need to have some level of small hierarchy leadership looking ahead, trying to participate. And the same thing at Wikipedia. They've gradually added a little bit more top-down control about things. And that's the way you get the kind of thing that you really want.
Mark Fielding Sounds like parenting a little bit as you... It was more and more decentralized as they get older.
Jeremy Gilbertson It's just nudging.
Kevin Kelly Exactly, right. No, it is. There's lots of analogies of gardening and other things where you are guiding, leading, setting examples, very, very subtle, whereas most of the work is still coming from the bottom.
Why DAOs haven't worked
Jeremy Gilbertson I've been wondering why DAO's haven't been as successful as they sound to be. What do you feel about them?
Kevin Kelly actually I was to get in on the very first DAO the one that then later collapsed. Here's where I think that happened. This is sort of for me an illustration of a bigger point of the difference between rationalism and empiricism. there are a lot of things that sort of work in theory.
Kevin Kelly but just don't work in practice because there are all these other issues and involved in things other than just the rational logic of it. So it's not that we're more than just rational beings, it's that the world itself is composed and run over things other than just logic. So the logic of Daoism is really impeccable, but here's where they kind of stumbled, which was
Kevin Kelly The whole idea of them was that you had these immutable rules. And that was the attraction was that they're immutable and that once you set some things up, couldn't be subverted, they couldn't be hacked, they couldn't be derailed. They would just go on and do their thing without the failure mode that most other kind of organizations would have. But the problem is that...
Kevin Kelly If you have a negotiation that can never be changed, it's really terrible because most negotiations are always, most contracts are usually renegotiated in time because new things come up that nobody expected. And so that imutability is not a feature, it was a bug. It was a bug. And so we want something to be flexible, but not too flexible.
Kevin Kelly We don't want it to be just something that can never be changed. And so that kind of flexibility and that kind of adaptability of the contextual sense, they didn't have that kind contextual awareness. Now maybe someday in the future they could, but that's a much more complicated, elaborate thing that might need an AI to do.
Kevin Kelly But that was what it was lacking, in my opinion. And so you have this very logical abstract thing that in theory would work, but this did not meet reality, it was not contextual enough for the changing parameters of us. I mean, it required people to kind of like think of all the possible things that might happen, and you can't.
Imagining the unimaginable future
Jeremy Gilbertson It's like the human ver- it's like the business version of the path integral where you have to map out all the paths to figure out what the probabilities of one or the other.
Kevin Kelly And the thing is, reality is that there's going be something you never thought about. So I've been involved with GBN, Global Business Network in the 90s. We did hundreds of future scenarios for the Fortune 500 companies trying to anticipate where things were going. And my friend Stewart Brand has a saying that this present moment is the unimaginable future.
Kevin Kelly of the past, right? It was the past unimaginable future. so it is totally unimaginable. We did all these scenarios for these companies and not one single of those scenarios was anything remotely like what we have today because had anybody suggested today's world, it would have been rejected as simply ridiculous, right? I mean, it's like you couldn't have
Kevin Kelly It was just not plausible. And so that's the problem. The problem is that the future is sort of outside of what we can imagine. so you didn't prepare for it, so the whole thing collapses.
Google and the plan to build AI
Mark Fielding we have a book club at Thinking on Paper and we've just finished reading Nexus by Yuval Noah Harari. And there's a reference to you in there and he's speaking about when you first met the CEO, founder of Google, I think it was 2002. but essentially Google was an AI company, not a search company.
Kevin Kelly so I met Larry at a party and this was early in Google's before they had a business model. And I said, search, I don't see where you're going with this. I'm a big fan, but I don't see the business here of where you're going to go in the long term. And he said,
Kevin Kelly We're making AI. This is all to make an AI. And then it was like, aha, yes, I get it. And so from the very, very beginning, that was the agenda was to work towards the tools and the data that you would need to make an AI.
AI, emotions and smart glasses
Mark Fielding following on from that, so obviously you've been immersed in this since the beginning. Things have changed very, very suddenly, very, rapidly of late. in the last six months is there anything about AI that you have changed your mind about completely which you didn't think you would two years ago.
Kevin Kelly I don't know, I don't think it has changed my mind. Certainly has not changed my mind completely.
Kevin Kelly Yes, it is. But I, I, I have believed that from the beginning and I have been saying that for a very long time. So it's not a new thing. I, I was, I think I even wrote about it a couple of years, years ago, talking about that. The fact that it was absolutely creative. Um, this is not the past, but when I'm, I will make a prediction, which is that, um, the next big shock.
Kevin Kelly for people, the thing that will cause people to really go bananas is when we start to code in emotions to the AIs and the degree to which those emotional values and capabilities and traits will cause people to bond to the AIs that they're using. And not just in kind of like a her romantic way, but I mean in kind of like the way you bond with your pets and beyond. the pets don't have conversations with you, but now they're going to, and they'll be with you all the time. people will have very, very strong attachments and very strong emotional complexity and all the other things of, you know, having arguments or being rejected or whatever. The whole spectrum of kinds of things.
Kevin Kelly with the AIs as they become more more emotional. And it's really gonna freak out people because...
Kevin Kelly people will have strong emotions about them. And that's something we're not ready for right now. It's all kind of intellectual, sure, sure, sure. But no, there will be people who will live with these day and night. And people will be calling it addiction. But it's sort of like having glasses, which if you need to have glasses to see, the solution is not to be upset that you're dependent on it.
Kevin Kelly The solution is to make sure you always have glasses. And we're dependent on electricity. Like if electricity went out for a week, we would just be incapable of doing anything. And so the solution is not to be upset by it, but to say, this makes sure electricity never goes off. And with the AI, it's going to be the same thing. It's like there'll be people very soon who will really be dependent on having the AI is always on.
Kevin Kelly to work with them to do their best work. And the solution, not to be upset, is to make sure the AI is never turned off. Don't always have that with you because that is what you need to do your best work.
Jeremy Gilbertson My glasses aren't going to manipulate my emotions to read a certain book. the emotional piece, that's where it's going to get scary, right?
Kevin Kelly yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, yeah. The reasons why is because this is incredibly more powerful than your glasses, right? I mean, it's your mind. It's what we tend to think of as ourselves, right? kind of, the ancients always identify themselves as right here. The modern person, you're here. We've migrated up. So we associate our mind with ourselves.
Kevin Kelly We're messing with ourselves. So that's pretty dynamite. so, yeah, there's definitely, and you know, mean, things are gonna go wrong. This is the most powerful technology we've ever made, so therefore, we're gonna have the most powerful problems we've ever had. And there'll be problems coming from the fact that these things can mess with our minds, for sure.
Mark Fielding I hope that my children have their hearts broken for the first time by a real man or woman though.
Is AI conscious? Many kinds of minds
Jeremy Gilbertson our latest book that we've been reading is by Federico Faggin who came up with the Intel 4004 and he's right.
Kevin Kelly I'm not familiar with that. What's the Intel 4004? yeah, yeah, the Intel. I'm sorry, I got it. right, okay. Yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson ⁓ it's the first microchip. I guess is what, yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson he's in and studying consciousness and neuroscience and all of these other things and now he's starting to go well wait a minute like as AI comes about like a like a computer cannot birth another computer with hardware software everything loaded so is it possible for that computer to ever get consciousness like how do you bet how do you think about consciousness in AI
Kevin Kelly So I think, first of all, I like to talk about AIs in plural because it's not a single dimension. It's not even an element. think intelligence is a compound of different kinds of cognitive elements. And it's a very high dimensional space. It's not just a ladder going up like decibels. It's a very big space.
Kevin Kelly possibility space of all minds and mapped ours, we're going to be at the edge somewhere. There's not a general intelligence. There is all these very, very specific different compounds. We're like a salt. And so when we start thinking about that, the thing about the AIs is that
Kevin Kelly There multiple varieties and we're going to make many different varieties of them and some will be quite primitive and small and some will be much more complicated. And I think there is, you could think of these as a continuum. So again, intelligence is not just an.
Kevin Kelly an amplitude. It's a bunch of different things. And consciousness is the same way. I think it's going to be a whole space of conscious possibilities. And some things will have small amounts or primitive versions of it, and other things will have more complicated aspects of it. And I think life itself is that. I would say, you could say that a virus has a little bit of life, and a bacteria has more life, and the ant has more life.
Kevin Kelly And we have actually more life than the ant. And consciousness is probably something similar. There'll be different kinds, different varieties, different arrangements of it. It's not just a binary thing where it's there or not there. So I would say the current LLMs have some degree of consciousness in them. But it's in the same way that your dog might have some degree of that.
Kevin Kelly Like ours? No. And fact, it's unlikely to be like ours. Just as the intelligences of the AIs are not going to be like ours, that's the whole point of them. making them because they don't think like us. And they don't. What the L.M.' are doing right now is inhuman. It's not... A human cannot do what they're doing. And so that's why we have them do it.
Kevin Kelly is because they're not human. And so the consciousness is probably not going to be a human type consciousness, but it'll be some type. So I call these things artificial aliens. And you can think of like Spock. Conscious, coherent, smart, intelligent, not quite the same as us. But that was his benefit.
Kevin Kelly Well, yeah, they'll be conscious to some extent. Yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson were you just signaling the Spock sign over there, you're doing? Live long and prosper. Yeah.
Mark Fielding Yes! Live long and prosper. Do you speak Klingon?
Jeremy Gilbertson Very interesting. this,
Advice on saying yes to the future
Mark Fielding I'm just going to a moment of pause, thinking on paper I'm just going to read a random quote from Kevin's new book, Excellent Advice,
Mark Fielding When you get invited to do something in the future, ask yourself, would I do this tomorrow? Not too many promises will pass that immediacy filter.
Kevin Kelly Yeah, I use this all the time. I was taught this by someone at the Whole Earth catalog. When I get an invitation to talk or something, it seems, that seems kind of interesting that I say, wait, wait, if this was tomorrow morning, would I be willing to get on the plane and go? No. So, okay, it's a no. And yeah, so this kind of asking yourself, would I do this like this afternoon or tomorrow morning? Not too many.
Mark Fielding Let's do another one. Okay, I'm gonna say stop.
Mark Fielding who have highlighted this one.
Mark Fielding what you do on your bad days matters more than what you do on your good days.
Kevin Kelly Right. Particularly if you have any kind of a disciplined habit. So yeah, so you want to, yeah, that's self-explanatory.
Jeremy Gilbertson yeah, so for instance, like, you know, I'm a lacrosse coach, lacrosse player, you know, if I'm working on my game, if I don't feel like doing it and it's raining outside and I'm sick, but I still do it, that's kind of the gist. Yeah.
Writing to think
Jeremy Gilbertson I've got one here, although I'm not flicking through my book, but we can imagine you've said stop and I'm flicking through the book. write to discover what you think.
Kevin Kelly it took me a long time to kind of realize this, but I'm not, I work with writers as an editor. I work with people who love to write, who just write compulsively. They enjoy their process. I don't. And it was always a struggle. And I realized the struggle was because
Kevin Kelly I don't have the ideas that I'm going to write down. My ideas come as through the process of writing. So writing for me became a way of thinking, a way of discovering what I thought. So it's like I don't know what I think until I...
Kevin Kelly write it, which gives me the ideas. So it's not like I'm taking ideas and writing it. It's like the process of writing it generates the ideas. And when I realized that, I was like, okay. Then the whole laborious, painful process is worth it. And the fact that I'm a slow writer is because I'm thinking. It's because it's hard to think. So...
Kevin Kelly And I'm not writing fiction and stuff. I'm talking about kind of a non-fiction idea-based writing. If I was writing, telling stories or something, I think that's a very different act. But it's also true, I hear from the fiction writers, where they don't know what's going to happen with their characters until they actually write it. And then they're told. It's like a channeling. It's a weird channeling to yourself.
Kevin Kelly And so, yeah, and also the other half, which I don't think you read on that, which is that I also try and take pictures and paint and stuff in order to help myself see. The reason why I do photography is by forcing myself to see things. It's a way of seeing.
Kevin Kelly And I often don't see it until I make the picture of it. It's not like I see it and then take the picture. It's the picture is the seeing. And so, or painting, the same kind of thing. And so, yeah, so for me, this is this idea of like,
Kevin Kelly It's extended mind, because your mind is not just the brain cells. It's walking on your feet. reason why I do a lot of walking is I think we think differently when we're walking. using your hands to write or type, using cameras to see, all those things is a way of extending your brain.
Jeremy Gilbertson Pointing back to AI, how do we get people to think about these human elements?
Working with AI
Kevin Kelly Yeah, I mean, we're learning how to do this right now. I just saw a study from Anthropic looking at how ways college students were using their AIs. They're trying to figure out, they cheating or how actually are they using them? And this is a brand new tool, a couple of years old, we're still figuring out its best ways. But from my own experience in using them, I just find them an invaluable tool.
Kevin Kelly For me, the first draft of things is always the toughest because I'm a born editor and I like working with the second draft. so I use the AIs to help me think. The thing about the AIs is that they're so, they're smarty pants. They've read everything. And I have these conversations with them.
Kevin Kelly helping me understand something and it's incredibly beneficial. It's not like I'm not using the words. It's helping me think. The words themselves are, again, they're pretty good. They're pretty good writing, but what I know is that, again, the act of trying to write it myself in my own words will give me new ideas. And so I guess the...
Kevin Kelly question is going to be, will we be able to educate people to understand that that's true for them as well? Which is that, yeah, you could get something that's pretty good that they say it, but you'll get even better ideas if you attempt to make it your own. so I think we, you know, I mean, the other thing I know about using AIs for these past couple of years on daily basis is that it is a skill.
Kevin Kelly Absolutely a skill like Photoshopping or coding or anything in the sense that some people are a hundred times, thousand times better than other people because they have a thousand hours of doing it. And, it's not just clicking. It's just not clicking. And, you, you have a skill in terms of being able to ask the prompt in the right way, having, knowing what to follow up with the question.
Kevin Kelly It's like being a good interviewer, knowing what they're kind of capable of doing, understanding the differences between the different AIs and what's good for it. So it's a skill. And we're going to have to train students and people. People have to learn. And if not, then you won't be that good at it. And you won't get the stuff out of it. The other people will. And so the little refrain that people were saying is like, you're not going to be replaced by an AI.
Kevin Kelly But you may be replaced by a human who's using AI. And so I see it as an incredibly powerful tool, a thinking tool. And it's like calculators. I would have maybe been a different kind of a person maybe involved in the sciences if we had had calculators like in chemistry and stuff. Because my arithmetic was just so hard to do.
Kevin Kelly all those calculations by hand and get everything right. And so I would have to the wrong chemistry answer because I was multiplying things by hand and I just would have these errors. If I had a calculator, I would have been lot better. And now we have a better calculator, which is actually going to give me the answer. And so, yes.
Kevin Kelly I I'd love the fact that I have this thing that can give me all these facts and stuff as I'm thinking through this. I was just looking this morning, I had this conversation about, well, mean, very technical stuff on cellular evolution and stuff. And so it was just fantastic to have the answer and go back and many around and around and around and I can understand something.
Kevin Kelly within minutes. And so that, I think, is a great writing tool.
Mark Fielding Excellent, I love that as well. Jeremy has an incredible question on Awe which I want him to get to in a minute. I want to ask you about Colossus and Dire Wolf and Woolly Mammoths and bringing back T-Rex. But first, Kevin, it's time for the hot buttons. We're to do the hot buttons. So I don't know if we have a clock today, do we, Jeremy, or do we just take as long as it takes? So yeah, Daniel Kahneman, Thinking Fast, Thinking Slow.
Jeremy Gilbertson I say you just let it rip,
Kevin Kelly I don't have any birds I don't keep a life list. I use Merlin, but I don't keep a life list.
Mark Fielding you like history, you're given a time machine. Do you go back or do you go forward?
Kevin Kelly I would go forward it for sure. If it's a two-way
Mark Fielding Bitcoin: losing its way or just getting started?
Mark Fielding Jurassic Park, very likely? No way!
Mark Fielding Aliens or super intelligence which arrives first on planet earth?
Mark Fielding Can I ask you, later if aliens will ever arrive on
Mark Fielding Could you describe bees in one word?
Mark Fielding my kids are nine and six, at what age should I give them their first smartphone?
Mark Fielding Okay, thank you. Hot Buttons thank you very much. aliens, will they ever arrive? or is that...
Jeremy Gilbertson Those are great.
Are aliens here?
Kevin Kelly We'll... Okay. I think aliens are here. But they're the probes. I mean, they're not... I mean, it's like... Do their probes count?
Mark Fielding Yes. Okay. And I think that's a segue to, Jeremy, I'll hand it over to you with your awesome question on the awe
Jeremy Gilbertson that's awesome. I love the bee question mark. That was great. I was racking my brain on how to answer that one. All right. 100%.
Mark Fielding Very important bees, aren't they? Yes, save the bees,
Mark Fielding save the trees, save the whales, save them snails. That's George Carlin.
How to cultivate wonder
Jeremy Gilbertson All right, so let's get back to this. You reference imagination a lot, I think, in your writing and how important of a vehicle that is. know, Tom Waits, songwriter, musician, has been said to say we're in a deficit of wonder. People in general are in a deficit of wonder. I thought that was such a brilliant observation.
Kevin Kelly Wow, that's cool. Yeah, yeah, I like
Jeremy Gilbertson my question to you related to that as we tie those both together, if people have lost their ability to wonder, how would you recommend they explore bringing it back?
Kevin Kelly I mean, I don't know if I have a way to teach other people to do this because I know how I do it. And so I'm not a teacher. I don't have a lot of experience teaching. I've already been maybe because of that very fact.
Jeremy Gilbertson Kevin, I hate to, I hate to break it to you. You're actually, you're actually a wonderful teacher because you've, you've, you've taught me a ton. know you've taught Mark and other people a ton.
Kevin Kelly think of myself as a teacher. I do it by not losing it to begin with. That's I'm trying to say. I've never had to recover it. So I don't know how you recover it because I've never lost it. But I can tell you, maybe I can think about things that help me keep my wonder.
Mark Fielding How do you do it? I'm sorry.
Kevin Kelly I had a little, there was a little, one of the proverbs in the book, which was, you know, a great payoff is being interested in things that you're not interested in.
Kevin Kelly So one of the things, this was a technique that the futurist Alan Toffler used to do that I learned from him. You would go to these talks and you'd be at these hotel giving a talk in a ballroom for some association or company or something. And what he would do, which I started doing too, is like when you're done, you walk next door to the conference that's happening next door and you sit in.
Kevin Kelly And it's like, there's a whole new world and this insider is talking about it and you get this incredible view of, know, whatever it is. It's the barber conferences of America or whatever it is. There's some things. So you have no interest in that, but you go in and you can discover a wonder because usually if you take anything, the smallest thing seriously, there's a world there. And so, there was this idea of you know, kind of just taking something at random and paying a lot of attention to it and noticing. So noticing is one of the ways that I think you can cultivate a sense of wonder is we're taught in a certain kind of weird way to consider, we're taught that the things that we kind of notice are not important. That we, I noticed this, it's like, that's not really important. But.
Kevin Kelly If you decide that actually it is very important and that you should really follow up on whatever that is that you noticed, that's one way that you can kind of cultivate that sense of wonder because you'll discover that there's this whole other thing or world that you didn't even know was there and that's wonderful. So that's one thing is noticing and paying attention to what you notice and taking what you notice seriously. that's like Jerry Seinfeld's whole thing is.
Kevin Kelly making his whole career of noticing these things and taking it kind of seriously, these little things. Noticing, so what else for cultivating a sense of wonder?
Kevin Kelly I think you can make a habit. Last year, was it last year, I decided to write down things that I was noticing and grateful for just as a list and to kind of prompt me to try and both be grateful but also notice things again. Like when you're writing it down, you begin to pay more attention to it. So that is like...
Kevin Kelly journaling is a sort of an apparatus for sketching things that you notice or that you are grateful for or whatever. You're kind of paying attention to it. And then I think, wonder.
Kevin Kelly There's a forgetting that is, I think, part of wonder. It's the people that I know that are full of that spirit of wonder are able to come in a new way, to see something old in a new way. They're kind of forgetting what they should think about things. And when I talk about the future, when do these scenario things,
Kevin Kelly One of the biggest things that we're trying to get people to do is to forget what they think the future should be. To forget what you have been told about battleships. To forget what you have been taught about opera. And then if you can do that and go in and see it in a way, forgetting what you were taught about it, then often that wonder will come. Because it's, you can kind of see it in a different way, from a different angle. And then I have a fourth maybe strategy, was someone, Marvin Minsky, who was an AI guy, who I was convinced was not human, because he had this weird ability to approach things as if he was a Martian. He would kind of like almost ask himself, like, what would a Martian say right now or think? And it was this...
Kevin Kelly really weird thing. Like he would say, I don't get music. What's music for? Why are you doing music? And he would actually have this sort of ignorance that would generate a sense of wonder about things about music that we hadn't even thought about. It's contagious, or it's weird. And so he would look at it as if he had never was not a human looking at it. So it was a little practice, I would say, that he had adopted. And he was maybe, you know, prone to thinking that way, but he would just look at weird things and say something that only a Martian would say.
Jeremy Gilbertson I love that. We child right? Yeah. One, one follow up to that and that's a wonderful answer. I love all those ideas. What I love your thoughts on this Kevin is my perspective is that most people feel like they have to know the answers to be considered ⁓ valid in situations at work and whatever. And a little bit of vulnerability and a little bit of beginner's mind.
Kevin Kelly Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson goes a long way and that's the thing that needs to be kind of catalyzed. do you think?
Kevin Kelly a saying there, something along the lines of like, you'll be a better person if you can say, don't know, at least once a day. yeah, admitting that you don't know is really, really very powerful. And I have no hesitation about letting people that I don't know when I'm interviewing them or whatever. It's like, yeah, I mean, I'm not... The humility is also maybe part of...
Mark Fielding I don't know what I was going to say, so I'm going to have a little pause and read a few quotes from Excellent Advice for Living while we all try to get back to some kind of sanity there. That was amazing answer. OK.
Life advice: ownership costs and managing yourself
Mark Fielding What you actually pay for something can be twice the listed price because the energy, time and money needed to set it up, learn, maintain, repair it and then dispose of it when done all have their own cost. Not all prices appear on labels.
Kevin Kelly Yeah, it's true. I've discovered that in maintaining a house, that basically over the life of a house, the whole lifetime of the house will probably cost what the house cost in terms of remodels, maintenance, re-roofing, whatever it is. By the time the house is done, people will have paid the amount of the house costs.
Kevin Kelly Or like if you have a car, it's the same thing. Or if you have even like my computer. By the time I'm finished the life of that computer, I've put in upgrades or the time in terms of doing the upgrades and dealing with it and whatnot. It's just easily double the cost. And then also including getting rid of it.
Mark Fielding Okay, we'll do one last more, then I'll hand it over to Jeremy to land the.
Mark Fielding To manage yourself, use your head. To manage others, use your heart. And the next one, dance with your hips. And the third one, don't let your email inbox become your to-do list run by others.
Kevin Kelly people's emergencies should not be your urgencies.
Kevin Kelly Dyson had a great suggestion, which I kind of tried to expand in one of my books, where we should have a system that you charge people to read their email. Right?
Kevin Kelly Right, exactly. I think that would be so cool. And you have certain friends that you would read their mail for free. yeah, that would be really, really fantastic. And if someone's willing to pay you 25 cents or $5 to read their email, OK, I'll decide. But that thing's going be a cool system.
Jeremy Gilbertson All right, well, this has been a blast, Kevin. We greatly appreciate your time, your energy, your work, your writing. Your thinking has, like I said, inspired us and many others. One last question for you what's a question that you would ask? Not just our next guest, but all of our guests to better understand what they're doing and how it fits in with the world.
Jeremy Gilbertson That's awesome. Kevin, thanks so much. All right. Take it easy, Bye.
Kevin Kelly I have to go. Thank you. I appreciate it was a blast. All righty, bye
Mark Fielding Thank you. Thank you very much.
Jeremy Gilbertson Be curious, stay disruptive.




