Federico Faggin’s Irreducible, Chapter 12: Does Probability Exist?

Mark and Jeremy try to fit anxiety and happiness into Federico Faggin's model of consciousness, and Mark lands on flow. Happiness is becoming, the universe is becoming, life is becoming.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 20 chapters

  1. Books as ice picks
  2. The twenty five physical constants
  3. Nature does it better
  4. Live information
  5. Probability does not exist
  6. Probability needs consciousness
  7. The vibesphere
  8. How does your interiority differ from mine?
  9. Letters, syntax and quantum states
  10. Free will cannot be predicted
  11. AI creativity
  12. Rick Rubin, and listening for patterns
  13. Anxiety and happiness in the model
  14. Are we the seities?
  15. Reverse engineering a feeling of anxiety
  16. The control panel
  17. Happiness, and the flow state
  18. Asking Claude
  19. Perhaps the question is backwards
  20. The chapter, summarised
If you’re tearing down physics and maths and probability, I think you need to be pretty steadfast in your opinions now.
Mark Fielding

Mark and Jeremy read chapter 12 of Irreducible by Federico Faggin, where he argues that probability has relevance only if consciousness exists. They work through the 25 physical constants, live information and why free will cannot be predicted by any mathematical theory.

Jeremy pictures the constants as dials on an Ampeg bass head, and Mark answers with Hendrix, one Marshall amp and a pedal. They bring in Rick Rubin and David Hume on creativity, and Jeremy reports what Claude said when he asked why information matters.

Chapter 12 of Irreducible: Consciousness, Life, Computers, and Human Nature by Federico Faggin, read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, argues that probability, mathematics and a theory of everything cannot explain consciousness and free will. “Probability has relevance only if consciousness exists,” Faggin writes, and Mark Fielding and Jeremy Gilbertson test what that means for AI creativity.

Why does Faggin say probability needs consciousness?

“Probability has relevance only if consciousness exists,” Faggin writes, because probability is about knowledge and only consciousness can know. Mark adds the statistician Bruno de Finetti’s line: “probability does not exist”.

Could a theory of quantum gravity explain consciousness?

Even a unified theory of quantum gravity, Faggin argues, would not explain life, consciousness and free will unless they were built into it.

Why can symbols alone not predict meaning?

Symbols alone cannot predict meaning. Faggin’s example: “the gray cat ate the red mouse” and “the red mouse ate the gray cat” share the same word probabilities but mean opposite things.

Can a computer have ideas of its own, according to Faggin?

A computer, Faggin writes, “cannot have ideas beyond the ones we have inserted into its algorithms”. When AI seems original, it is because we had not fully unrolled the algorithm.

Why does Faggin say quantum physics has only actors?

Quantum physics has no observers, Faggin argues, only actors, because observing a quantum system changes it: “Quantum physics is therefore telling us that there are only actors.”

Where Mark and Jeremy disagree

Jeremy defines creativity as “the unique arrangement of found elements” and asks whether a computer rearranging a scale differs from a guitarist doing it. Mark admits his view on AI creativity shifts with every guest.

Questions

Does probability exist?

“Probability has relevance only if consciousness exists,” Faggin writes, because probability is about knowledge and only consciousness can know.

What is chapter 12 of Irreducible about?

Chapter 12 of Irreducible: Consciousness, Life, Computers, and Human Nature by Federico Faggin, read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, argues that probability, mathematics and a theory of everything cannot explain consciousness and free will.

What topics do Mark and Jeremy cover in chapter 12?

They work through the 25 physical constants, live information and why free will cannot be predicted by any mathematical theory.

Which thinkers on creativity come up in the chapter 12 discussion?

They bring in Rick Rubin and David Hume on creativity, and Jeremy reports what Claude said when he asked why information matters.

Transcript

Mark Fielding Disruptors and curious minds, CEOs, founders, book lovers, conscious entities, seities. It's book club time. It's Friday afternoon. We're reading Irreducible by Federico Faggin We're on chapter 12, consciousness, life, computers and human nature. And in chapter 12, he's taking shots. He's taking shots at everybody. Probability, probably not real, doesn't exist. Mathematics, nah.

We're going to grill mathematics. Quantum gravity is exposed. The block universe. Nah, not going to happen. Materialistic assumptions of classical physics are just, yeah, reduced to rubble in chapter 12. The union of quantum physics with an adequate theory of quantum gravity as now proposed would still not be able to explain the origin of life consciousness.

and free will and therefore would not explain everything unless these properties were incorporated into the unified field. What we now know that Federico Faggin refers to as the One. The world of knowing Chapter 12, Jeremy. Before we get into life, AI creativity, observers, actors and what it really means to be quantum conscious, first impressions.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, there's as with many of these chapters, there's always a lot to unpack. I'm trying to always figure out where where a good place to start is. I'm still I'm still excited about like coming out of these chapters and excited to break these down. Like we said, what's Kafka's, you know, thinking on paper tagline that he put if it's what if books aren't swords stabbing us in the eyes, you know, we're doing something wrong. Did I did I hit any close to that? Maybe.

Books as ice picks

Mark Fielding Yeah, books are supposed to be like ice picks into the matter of your brain. think this book is a bit like, reading it is a bit like watching the Texas Chainsaw Massacre in that it starts off really nice and tame and everything's great. But there's like an echo of something tragic and doom ridden coming and you can feel it.

And every chapter you think it can't get any worse and every chapter is like, when do you end up like on a truck screaming at life What is consciousness? What am I? What is this? Yeah, it's just mad.

Jeremy Gilbertson hung upside down by your ankles. Yeah, right. No, that's a great way to put it. That's a great way to put it. Yeah, let's think about this. So you talked about this theory of everything tying quantum to gravity, quantum gravity, this theory of everything. Humans have an itch to understand, right? We want to understand things, but we also want to organize and control things. It's a really bad habit that we have.

and which leans us into this classical mindset versus this quantum mindset, right? So the thing about this science and theory of everything, he's like, that all sounds great and good, but it doesn't have consciousness and free will in it. So is it a theory of everything? I'm like, okay, that's good. And One thing that I saw in here that I was pretty excited about was this is a word I really love in a lot of things.

that I do, it always comes up, this idea of becoming. The idea of becoming, and there is becoming in the universe, meaning it's kind of unfolding in real time based on interactions, based on probabilities that will, you know, maybe subjective and objective. We'll talk about all of that stuff in a minute, but just the idea that it's emerging, it's becoming, it's not set out and stated as is. I love that. I love that word. What do you think about when you...

Jeremy Gilbertson hear the word becoming.

Mark Fielding transient. it's my understanding and thought process on this is obviously changed reading irreducible, which as we alluded to is probably the sign of a good book that becoming means it's not static. It's always, always in motion, always unfolding and always progressing in a direction forwards like and when he says the universe is becoming, it seems natural to say that. mean, what would it be if it wasn't becoming? What's the opposite of that? What's the opposite of a universe that isn't becoming?

Jeremy Gilbertson Fully scripted, fully scripted, deterministic. Yeah, yeah. So that sets us out really nicely, but in this idea of our desire as humans to understand and organize and control things, right? Let's talk about, so this quote popped out, comprehension comes up a lot in this book. Comprehension of reality or an intellectual understanding of the mathematical

Mark Fielding like deterministic, there we go.

Jeremy Gilbertson Theory of reality. I thought that was really, really interesting and comprehension being the basis for knowing, right? The basis for knowing. We could talk about that before, but instead of really knowing, it's just the physical side of this, the classical physics side of this is just we have an intellectual understanding of the mathematical model of what reality is. And math is symbolic, right? Math isn't semantic.

So this whole other side is missing and the way he teased that up, I think, is really pretty cool. Where's your brain go with comprehension? It's been a theme in this book, Comprehension as being kind of the key to a lot of things, right?

Mark Fielding Can I just go back to the becoming bit just before we go on because I wanted to... So on becoming, however, quantum physics from which classical physics emerges as a subset tells us instead that there are neither separate parts nor particles as objects, nor does probability exist as we imagined it in classical physics. Therefore, there is becoming in the universe, which cannot be predicted in any equation or algorithm. This means that the universe could have evolved in an infinite infinity of possible ways.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, for sure.

Mark Fielding using exactly the same laws. And we'll get into that infinity and how actually the actors, the seity actors choose the path, not that's why there isn't infinity. But he says these laws contain 25 physical constants. And I just wanted to give our listeners some homework for the summer, Jeremy, because on the 25 physical constants that need to be adjusted with extreme precision.

Jeremy Gilbertson No easy buttons. No easy buttons in book club, guys. No easy buttons.

The twenty five physical constants

Mark Fielding Well, no, because with these 25 physical constants that need to be adjusted with extreme precision to create the universe in which we live based on a pastoral noise. So if this was deterministic. So AI tells me there's 26, not 25, whatever. I don't even know if I'm in the right place. But of these, this is your homework for the summer. Jeremy, listener is to research some of these. So the fine structure constant.

the strong coupling constant, the quark mixing parameters, the neutrino mixing parameters, the masses of fundamental particles, the four parameters of the CKM matrix, the four parameters of the Maxi Nagawakasaka matrix, the cosmological constant, the gravitational constant, the speed of light in a vacuum, Planck's constant, the elementary charge, the Boltzmann constant, the Avogadro constant, the permeability of free space, the permeability...

of free space, the Ryberg constant, the Stefan-Boltzmann constant, the Coulomb constant, the gravitational acceleration, the gas constant, the molar gas constant, the Planck constant, the reduced Planck constant, and the Dirac constant. There you go, get reading.

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, so take this, take all of those things that you put, right? So imagine, I've always thought about this as like the, think about the reality machine. Think about we have a reality machine. It looks oddly enough like an Ampeg bass head that bass players would plug into, right? And you have these dials across the bass head, it switches and dials and all of that stuff. Imagine there's a reality bass head that has all of those constants.

Jeremy Gilbertson on it that you can just just kind of tweak along and and and make happen those are your parameters instead of treble bass gain whatever the heck it is you have all those constants that's what i think of when i think of all these parameters

Mark Fielding That's a good analogy and then so it seems way way overly complex. Surely the universe isn't that complex and surely isn't that specific surely there aren't that many dials and I just imagine on yours One you just Hendrix comes in and he just plugs into a into an amp One pedal Distortion no distortion and he creates the greatest music perhaps ever made and maybe maybe you don't need all of those dials You just need One Marshall amp and a pedal

Nature does it better

Jeremy Gilbertson Nature does it better. We talk about this all the time, man. Like photosynthesis, we're trying to mimic what nature does with quantum computing. Look how good photosynthesis does just by getting there, plugging its guitar into the amp and performing. All right, so let's jump off that side track here. And we're talking about, let's see. okay. So another thing that's echoing through this chapter that I always want to...

Jeremy Gilbertson kind of hint on and remind people and remind myself is remember that these fields he talks about are parts whole, right? They're this part whole of the One that he states and all the particles and atoms are just states of that field and not physical objects. I always have to remind myself, because we walk around, walking around space, everything seems pretty hard and like, you know, all of that stuff, but it's just...

It's really just states of a field, which is kind of mind-blowing. That's just like an overarching piece of it. But speaking of us as states of a field, this idea of live information kind of landed on me a little more clearly in this chapter because I think he comes out and actually says, we're live information. Like a great example of live information is us. A great example of really complicated live information is the earth.

10 to the 41 atoms working together is the Earth, right? So that was really cool. So it's cells, it's us, it's planets. That's what live information is to me. And that didn't really land until that analogy.

Live information

Mark Fielding Yeah, he's spoken about live information before, hasn't he? And when he first spoke about live information, it didn't seem to be to play such an important role in this theory, but he's definitely brought it back in and turned up, hasn't he? So back in chapter five, he refers to live information as matter, information, energy inside and outside the cell. So

Yeah, and so he says Earth is like the prime example of that matter information energy. And so what role does live information now play?

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, I think without information, as he says in this chapter quite a bit, without information, we don't really have this idea of knowing. There's no point in knowing if we have information, and there's no point in having information in the classical physics-bound world, right? There's no point in having information if everything is determined. If everything is predetermined, there's no additive value in information because you don't need to know anything.

To know something, you have to have information. information is living in this more quantum, the QIP theory world that he's talking about. I thought that was interesting. Yeah, we don't need information if we know everything, right?

Mark Fielding He says, what is the sense of information that is unknowable if it does not make sense at least to the system that holds that state? And I think in that sentence, there is a key.

indicator of what's to come, if what is the point of information is in no belief, it does not make sense at least to the system that holds that state, which when we unpack that later, so the seities individual conscious actors in this, they are, it does mean something to them.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, but you-

Mark Fielding Is that what he alludes to? Like, what's the point in this unknowable quantum information if it does not make sense at least to the system that holds that state? That's what it meant for me anyway, that he was referring to this idea that seities do know.

Jeremy Gilbertson So we're the state, not the system, remember, right? We're the state, not the system.

Probability does not exist

Mark Fielding Let's use some of the, so he debunks probability. So, have I jumped ahead too much there?

Jeremy Gilbertson That was kind of fun. I remember my statistics class in college just kind of chuckling a little bit about this. No, no, no, we can bounce back and forth. I'm okay with that. So start with that bool quote. Do have that pulled up? It's like right on the section of probability.

Mark Fielding Have I jumped ahead too soon though first? we have?

Mark Fielding Yeah. So what is probability? He uses a George Ball quote. Probability is expectation founded upon partial knowledge, a perfect acquaintance with all the circumstance affecting the occurrence of an event would change expectation into certainty and leave neither room nor demand for a theory of probabilities. But I prefer the quote by the famous statistician and mathematician Bruno De Finetti. Finetti? Finetti? Bruno De Finetti? Finetti?

Jeremy Gilbertson Dfinity probably, yeah.

Mark Fielding probability does not exist. And obviously, and obviously Federico, I completely agree with him.

Jeremy Gilbertson So, you know, Boole, Boolean math, ones and zeros, that guy knows some things, so that guy knew some stuff, Definetti, really interesting, I had to kind of dig into him a little bit, but his idea that probability is subjective and doesn't exist outside the mind, that kind of blows your mind a little bit, especially if you came up through statistics, and statistics is a way to predict what's happening next in a very...

deterministic mathematical manner, If statistics, can predict, you know, this thing, the likelihood of this thing happening to a certain, you know, certain percentage, right? But De Finetti, his work is, is living and breathing right now through this thing called Bayesian analysis, which is the root of recommendation engines. Like every single recommendation engine out there is, is built on De Finetti's theory. So you, you read that and you're like, that sounds pretty crazy. Like, probability doesn't exist. Wait, what? But then you're like, wait a minute, if he built...

Mark Fielding Well, we've all experienced how bad recommendation engines are so that they don't deliver what you want. So if they're based on that, then okay, there's evidence for yeah, probability is flawed. I'm following the breadcrumbs here. So in that last information that is notable, if it does not make sense, at least to the system that holds that state, okay. Here he says, probability is about knowledge and only consciousness can know therefore.

Jeremy Gilbertson Ooh, fair enough. Fair enough.

Probability needs consciousness

Mark Fielding Probability has relevance only if consciousness exists. The fact that quantum physics is about probability is saying that the physical universe is about knowing the white elephant in the room is this consciousness. And he talks about. So I think there's definitely a link between those. It's kind of making a little bit more sense.

Jeremy Gilbertson he's getting more like more solid and with with his emphasis and mic drop moments on like yo like probability doesn't make any sense if consciousness isn't around right or like

Mark Fielding If you're tearing down physics and maths and probability, I think you need to be pretty steadfast in your opinions now. I think maybe, like this is, like, okay, I'm saying this, so this.

Jeremy Gilbertson Right, right.

Mark Fielding It does get again a little bit Monty Python in places where he's looping around and the sentence kind of fragments in my mind and I'm reading like all these words over and over again. It's like what? How many times have I read this sentence and he's still saying deterministic in about eight million possible ways.

Jeremy Gilbertson Right, let's see.

Might be skipping around here a little bit, but I think this is kind of okay because we're talking about consciousness, but omniscience, you know, the all-knowing of something, right? That, you know, for instance, like the religions that are out there have a God or God up there that is supposed to be all-knowing and all-seeing and all of that. And this quote he has in here, omniscience would spell the end of consciousness, the end of existence, because there would be nothing else to know. And in his idea, One is this kind of roll up of all the seities and all the live information spun up in the vibe sphere, right? Just with the idea of trying to know more, right? The One doesn't know everything, which is interesting. So instead of God all knowing, all seeing,

Mark Fielding Yeah, Carol Dwack should interview the One. Yeah, the One is the personification of the growth mindset is the ultimate growth mindset. infinite, everlasting thirst for growth and self awareness and self knowledge. Yeah.

Jeremy Gilbertson I that was pretty interesting.

Mark Fielding I'm going to remember that every time I read somebody posting on social media about a growth mindset, would say, do you want to know what the ultimate example of the growth mindset is? Federico Faggin's The One.

The vibesphere

Jeremy Gilbertson Let's see. Yeah, this might be, this is a great reminder right here. Page 252, the field with consciousness and free will is a completely different entity that I've previously called the One. Self-knowing, parentheses, meaning of One is represented by a pure quantum state of the field, which is the superposition.

pure states of all the fields that have emanated from the One which he's called the seities the excited states of the field represent the vibrational sphere the ensemble the vibe sphere the ensemble of all live information used by the fields seities to communicate and explore their meaning so the seities associated with the organization of ourselves as live information have

Mark Fielding Vibesphere, baby.

Jeremy Gilbertson put us in the vibe sphere to unpack chapter 12.

Mark Fielding I feel like we're being used by the One. We're getting to our seities are getting to like plugged into their growth mindset, exploring this, trying to build new experiences and new comprehensions in our mind so that they can feed the machine of the One. So, okay. We're not happy with not getting well, are getting compensated, aren't we? Because the compensation is our that is the compensation, not the

Jeremy Gilbertson We're not getting compensated for any of this, are we? That's bullshit, man.

Mark Fielding the One agrees with compensation in that kind of sense. But yeah, we are.

How does your interiority differ from mine?

Jeremy Gilbertson How does your interiority differ from mine in this exact moment?

Mark Fielding Well, that's something that only our seities can know. I don't have the classical symbolic vocabulary to explain that to you or to anybody.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, you can't turn the qualia that your seities experiencing into live information that I can understand.

Mark Fielding Well, that's that's part of that's One of the main pillars of the book, isn't it? That that very question, how we answer that question is the uniqueness of consciousness and how the classical physics can't explain it only.

Letters, syntax and quantum states

Jeremy Gilbertson What did you think of the example of letters in syntax to quantum and particles?

Mark Fielding Before symbols, there is the meaning that formed them and meaning has much more depth and breadth than any possible symbolic expression might hope to capture, especially the meaning connected with emotions and creative thoughts. Yeah.

Mark Fielding I live in France, so on a language front, I spend much of my time having to speak in French and my French is as a percentage of my English, I don't know, like 3%, 5%, 12%, 20 % and I'm always at a disadvantage. So I'm aware of the power of language and the difference in the language of what you can achieve with language.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, where I was kind of, the way I looked at this piece, pretty interesting is, you know, the idea, it's a probability example, right? So the occurrences of letters, right? Versus the meaning of the words. You know, being able to predict the likelihood of the occurrence of a letter within a word versus to direct meaning using those words, right? So quantum shows,

He talks about quantum shows the probability of particles and atoms, right? Of those occurring, those instances occurring as actions generated by the field, right? But they can't predict the arrangement, only the likelihood of the occurrence of the thing, right? Just like letter order and occurrence isn't determined by the syntactical laws of language. Let me read this real quick.

The probability of appearance of each symbol in a sequence is independent of the meaning expressed. For example, in the sequence of symbols, the gray cat ate the red mouse, the probability of each word is perfectly predicted by the symbolic laws of English. If the sequence had instead been the red mouse ate the gray cat, the same probabilities would have been observed.

but the two meanings would be quite different. So the probabilities of those letters would be similar, but the arrangement of those letters turning from symbolic to semantic is not predictable.

Free will cannot be predicted

Jeremy Gilbertson Short and sweet, the free will exploration of meaning cannot be predicted by any mathematical theory. There's your mic drop. Boop.

Mark Fielding That's That's me.

AI creativity

Mark Fielding The force behind any new meaningful combination of symbols is not their syntax, but the ontological reality of the meaning that created it.

So that leads nicely into AI creativity. Is AI creative again? The question that seems to get more headline space than any other. And each week when I speak to somebody, my opinion of this changes. So we have guests on Thinking on Paper.

And they think, OK, yeah, mate, you've convinced me that, yes, AI is creative. And then somebody else will come on. They'll convince me that it isn't. And then I'm back into Federico has convinced me that it isn't. So a computer cannot have ideas beyond the ones we have inserted into its algorithms. If an idea produced by a computer seems new to us, it is only because we had not completely unrolled the algorithm that we put into its program. So.

That's a pretty strong sentence. So he's saying that an AI cannot be creative and any time that we think it is being creative, we are missing the point.

Jeremy Gilbertson I go back and forth on this One and I think it depends on definition of creativity and the One I always land on, you've heard me say it a bunch. think our listeners have heard me say it a bunch. The, that creativity is the, the unique arrangement of found elements, right? So you find some things and you put them together in a unique and novel way to make something new, whether it's a thought, whether it's an idea, whether it's a new output of some patterns, right? So if you think about it, like, I don't know, like, then you start, well, then you start thinking about what's human creativity and how algorithmic is that based on the patterns that we, that we learn, right? So think about it like it's, let's go to guitar reference, right? You and I are both guitar players. So we learn patterns. We learn, you know, a pentatonic scale, right?

All the way up and down we learn that. And the way we are creative with that is how we attack those notes, how long we hold them, what series those notes are in. But isn't that just a rearranging of the pattern of those notes? And couldn't a computer rearrange the pattern of those notes the same way? Maybe there's not feeling and emotion in it? I don't know, but I go back and forth with this, Mark.

Rick Rubin, and listening for patterns

Mark Fielding Yeah, so do I, as I was saying. I'm more from the kind of Rick Rubin, the David Hume playbook on creativity. David Hume, the beauty of things exists in the mind that contemplates them. And Rick Rubin, would feel like creativity is like hearing and channeling the whispers of the universe. And I think that kind of aligns with this seity conscious universe aspect, channeling the ether. I Rick Rubin calls it as well, the radio antenna where you're listening to and...

Jeremy Gilbertson What are you listening for patterns? You're listening for patterns, right? Are the things you're picking up signal? Signal is patterns. Signal is things organized in a moment in time, So you're yanking down patterns.

Jeremy Gilbertson Rick Rubin, come on the show and talk about, talk about Irreducible with us. I think this would, this would be interesting for you to check out.

Mark Fielding I like that. We'll get Rick Rubin on the show.

Jeremy Gilbertson Come on, come on Rick. I don't have, hey I don't have shoes on either right now. We got a gray beard, yours is way better. But god we just saw your dogs man. Wow! Good morning. Holy.

Mark Fielding So Rick Rubin, yeah. I've been walking outside barefoot Rick Rubin. So, know, I think, you know, come on the show and talk to us about the whispers of the universe. You. I want to I had I wanted to reverse engineer something, so following on from that and let's get to that in a minute. But basically, I wanted to reverse engineer.

Jeremy Gilbertson There you go. Yeah.

Anxiety and happiness in the model

Mark Fielding anxiety and happiness back into this model of how this model gets our what's the purpose of us feeling happy or anxious and how that gets there via . but before we get to that I want to speak from observers to actors because I like this I like this a lot um this maybe I like this because it's easy the analogy works we're so familiar with cinema and acting as a as a

Mark Fielding as a way the world works that we can picture this. Maybe that's why.

Mark Fielding I don't know where to start on this, so.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, while you're looking it up, the thing I think about with actors and observers, so in quantum mechanics, ever since I first learned about it, you picture this idea of like, know, things don't really happen unless someone observes them. And you picture like this dude in a white coat with a clipboard that's just looking for shit to come to life, right? And it's just like, all right, I'm gonna look, there it is. Okay, I saw it. That makes it real, but.

The observer has influence on the environment. The observer is part of the universe, is part's whole to this whole thing, right? So as you observe something, the wave collapse, right? The wave collapse generates a free will decision. So it's influence, it's not just sitting back there with your clipboard, you're actually participating, right? That's what I got out of that.

Mark Fielding Yeah, well, not we, but so the seities are. In other words, no One can actually know the state that will be found when we make a measurement because that state does not literally exist. The observer of a quantum system instead cannot observe without drastically disturbing what he observes and this changes it. Therefore, he is not an observer, but an actor. Moreover, no observer can know the state of a quantum system even in principle since quantum information cannot be reproduced.

Quantum physics is therefore telling us that there are only actors. The notion of observing physics has to be eliminated and replaced with the notion of quantum actors, because inside a quantum universe, there can only be quantum actors. And quantum actors are conscious, according to QIP, and interact with other quantum actors, which are also conscious. Therefore, the entities that interact within a quantum universe are like the thought forms and the seities So when you have an infinite number of probabilities between zero One the waveform collapses it is a conscious seity that says with free will because they have free will I choose this and that's when it collapses and that's the becoming the universe becomes just a step

Jeremy Gilbertson trying to figure out like, let's like, are we

Mark Fielding Did I just say that in public?

Jeremy Gilbertson You did, you did. So are we, we're the seities kind of.

Like we're live information, but we're the seities kind of, because isn't our consciousness the consciousness of the seity as well? Like.

Mark Fielding Yeah, the safety controls us.

Are we the seities?

Jeremy Gilbertson I know we're chapter 12 and I'm finally just asking that, but...

Mark Fielding Well, no, that was chapter 11, was it? Like we, as part of the field, the seities are using us as bodies to get to know themselves. They need us to experience that qualia, to know, to learn, to progress, to feel these things so that those conscious units which are using us, they're of the field. just, you know, when our body dies, the seities lives on. So we're like the drones.

And they're the control pilots of the drones. We are the seity drones. So yes.

Jeremy Gilbertson But when I do this, is it the seity saying, yo, flesh bag, move your arms? Or is that part of my free will decision as in partnership with the seity We're in partnership with the seity, right? It's like Bucky Fuller's Phantom Captain seity, Nine Chains to the Moon, read that One. It's kind of aligned with this idea, but I don't think I've ever asked that question.

Mark Fielding I like that, I like that, yeah.

Reverse engineering a feeling of anxiety

Mark Fielding Let's reverse engineer a feeling of anxiety. I must have been feeling anxious when I wrote these notes down. how do we reverse? I feel anxious. I think I choose anxious not happiness because anxiousness represents a conflict. that's easy to explain. So.

my quantum conflicts with the symbolic structures of my life.

my seity recognizes that those don't match. is anxiety a signal between outer classical and inner quantum?

Jeremy Gilbertson Interesting. So you think it's like...

Mark Fielding And if the One is the conscious universe that always wants to know itself and it sends out seities into the universe so that it can know itself via the seities and what is the purpose of something like that? What does the One get from my seities reporting back this qualia of anxiousness, for example?

Jeremy Gilbertson back as anxious. Recording back as anxious. So I think anxious in this instance is misalignment with the One.

Mark Fielding But that would say that the One knows that aspect. how can it be misaligned with something that...

Jeremy Gilbertson No, it's when it's so that memory talks about like the further away we become from our seity and more so associated with this us, the more we're locked into the ego believing that we are all that is. But then you sit down and you meditate and you become a bigger part of something else. It's a higher level of conscious experience. Then we start to

Jeremy Gilbertson start to think bigger and be like, hey, the little shit doesn't matter. Hey, I'm part of a bigger picture. Hey, I don't need to be anxious about this particular thing because you're more connected with the bigger thing and less focused on yourself grinding up against the environment.

Mark Fielding And that makes the One happy. And so I imagine the One with a little checklist. Yeah. Oh, Mark, Mark's seity Oh, he's doing well today. Tick. We'll go somewhere else. What are the moths doing? How are the moth? What's the forest? What's the ecosystem of the planet Earth? How's that seity doing?

Jeremy Gilbertson There's it.

The control panel

Jeremy Gilbertson There's a control panel, right? Picture like the biggest command control center in the world and yeah, the One is operating the seities and the force and the CUs and all of that. my gosh, man. Wow.

Mark Fielding Maybe there's like a Marshall stack somewhere with an almost infinite number of dials, which are all the seities of the universe all turning around trying to make this perfect sound come out of this amp, which the One is always looking for this perfect sound. It use all of these almost infinite seity dials to create it.

Jeremy Gilbertson So anxiety is dissonance in the sound of the seities All right, there you go. What about the happiness side of this fence? I don't actually like that word and I'll tell you why, but go into the happiness piece.

Mark Fielding Well, that's what I was saying earlier. So when I'm happy, when there is...

Mark Fielding balance between the inner symbolic and the classical. Is that right? Symbolic classical. The inner and the out. When there is a balance between the inner and the outer, they seity is happy because I have.

Mark Fielding ignored my ego for a while. I don't know.

Happiness, and the flow state

Jeremy Gilbertson Happiness is happiness. You mentioned happiness and anxiety together. think anxiety is driven by happiness. think anxiety is dripping, Anxiety is driven by the desire. Anxiety is driven by the drive for happiness. And happiness always has this

Mark Fielding Anxiety is driven by happiness.

Mark Fielding Anxiety is dripping in happiness

Jeremy Gilbertson if only when I'll be happy or once I get this I'll be happy and there's all these like if then Kind of statements in that and when you're you're always you're always away from it It's always this thing like man I'm never gonna get to that spot and then you start looking at the timeline you start looking at things you get anxious I'm never gonna get there. So I think happiness happiness is a tough word. It's a tough thing because being happy is a lot of people reference that as like a future state, a target. But last night, prime example, I told my wife this, we were, so my two youngest kids who, know, One's going into high school, One's going into middle school. And my wife, we were sitting in the back patio, I was cooking wings on the smoker. I had a beer, right? And we were just, you know, my kids were throwing a ball for my dog, pure like American, like whatever. But

Jeremy Gilbertson We spent like 45 minutes out there while I was cooking the wings and we ate the wings and then we ended up watching a movie. But before we were watching the movie, I looked at my wife and I'm like, that's all we need. Like that thing that we just did outside for 45 minutes, that's it. That's all we need to do. And that, I don't think that's happy. I don't think that feeling is happiness. That feeling is like, I don't know if joy is the right word for that or whatever it is, but that was like, I was like, that's the thing.

Mark Fielding It's the flow state, it's the abandonment of the ego, it's the abandonment of the past and the future. It is, to go back to the beginning of the show, becoming. Happiness is becoming, the universe is becoming, life is becoming. What beer were you drinking and what movie did you watch for the audience? Just to get to know Jeremy and his family a little bit more.

Jeremy Gilbertson Oh, what was I drinking? It was a little, it was a little light. No, it was a little lightweight beer. It was an IPA, but it was like a, what the heck was it? It was like a 4 % alcohol. want to, you know, I'm going to, no, it wasn't it. Well, no, I think it was Bell, Bell, Bell IPA. But, and then we watched the movie we watched was Tarot. We've, me and my kids have been on a tear with horror movies.

Mark Fielding Cause, was it cause?

Mark Fielding It wasn't a big famous beer brand. Okay.

Jeremy Gilbertson So we watched horror movies and we totally know we're obnoxious. Like if you watched a horror movie with us, like we've narrated like mystery science theater 3000, like it's a, it's a blast. Um, but that's the movie we watched, uh, tarot, tarot. So it was about T a R O T. So like the cards. Yeah. So basically this, this late, this girl does a, you know, tarot readings for everyone and then it all comes to life and they die. And it's like, it was really crazy, but, um,

Mark Fielding What was it called, sorry?

Jeremy Gilbertson I want to go back to, you mentioned flow state and One of my favorite people, this is why this book is really cool. Like there's so many quotes in here from so many of my favorite people that just from the past, like I don't know them, but I've read their books. I've studied them. So, Mihai C. Sent Mihai, his quote in here, he's got a book he coined flow. He coined the term flow state and, I read his book. It's fantastic. think flow the art of creativity or something like that. But the quote here says, have a naive faith in the universe that at some level everything makes sense and we get glimpses of that sense if we try. So I was like, you mentioned flow. had to call that out because if you haven't read that book by him, it's really, really pretty awesome. But flow state. Absolutely. That's exactly what that experience was. Time goes away. You you feel like you're fully present. Like that's the key, guys. That's the key. Find those moments.

Mark Fielding Bet you didn't look at your phone once.

Jeremy Gilbertson No dude, my phone is away. I put my phone away so much so that people get pissed off trying to find me during the weekends.

Asking Claude

Mark Fielding Did you have some questions that you asked with Claude? Would they fit to the end of this?

Jeremy Gilbertson yeah, yeah. I had a little partner on this journey this time. I've been using Claude quite a bit to just kind of talk through stuff that, you write questions in the margin, right?

Mark Fielding After the event though, first you read, you simulate, do your own work first before you go to Claude.

Jeremy Gilbertson 100 % 100 % this so this is this is an augmenting this is augmenting the human experience I'm not I'm not outsourcing the human experience to be very clear good differentiation I did read I read the chapter and then the questions that I wrote in my margin I started kind of asking asking Claude so the He talks about I think on page 247

You know, this idea about live information being kind of in between quantum and classical and, you know, consciousness is something that computers, right? He talks about computers can't do because it's deterministic. It's quantum. We already talked about that, but just this difference between simulated and emulated and computers can simulate experiences that are human, but they can't emulate them. I'm like, that's really interesting. There's gotta be a really interesting difference between simulated and emulated. So I,

So I kind of looked that up and I asked Claude if Claude could simulate a human. So the response popped out that, you know, what the model can do is what Claude can do, right? Have human-like conversations, patterns and responses, right? Reproduce aspects of human reasoning, generate text that feels natural and appropriate and respond to emotional cues.

in human-like ways. That's simulation, right? That's simulating the human experience. And I asked Claude, can you emulate a human? And the response was, this is much more uncertain. True emulation requires replicating the actual neural architecture of human brains, reproducing the biological processes and having that same internal mechanisms that we have. And it's impossible to understand those internal mechanisms because we don't know them.

And if we don't know and we can't teach a computer what they are to make decisions by them. So basically, yeah, yes on simulation, no on emulation. And the note that I put down after that, let's see, give me a second here.

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, so simulation is basically achieving similar results, right? In emulation, you're actually replicating the inner workings of something, which is impossible because my inner workings in my brain are private, meaning like, not private in like a weird way, but just like private, my qualia, the experience of my qualia. Yeah.

Mark Fielding He uses the word the word private to define what you're defining.

Jeremy Gilbertson So I thought that was pretty cool. That helped me land on the difference with that.

Mark Fielding using Claude in the right way there. Did you ask him any other questions? Did you ask it any other questions?

Jeremy Gilbertson I don't look at you personifying Claude.

Mark Fielding Yeah, but I corrected my error. toute suite Tell that to the One, seity Mark seity quick.

Jeremy Gilbertson toute suite The the matrix has been updated. The anxiety level on Mark seity is down.

Mark Fielding Is that going to be a new mental illness with like talking to seities? If I can I talk to my seities?

Jeremy Gilbertson Holy wow. let's see. Okay. Here's what I, so this idea of the world of classical information, right? And he says that, that the world of classical information is just averaged quantum states. What we see in the, in the, the physical world is just an average of, of the quantum states and the concept of information. talked about this previously in the show that it doesn't doesn't information doesn't make sense in that world? Cause everything's already predetermined and averaged and that, and that sort of thing. So I, what did I ask?

Jeremy Gilbertson Where's my question?

Perhaps the question is backwards

Jeremy Gilbertson Perhaps the question is backwards instead of asking what information. Okay, here's what I asked. I asked why information matters in a physical world. That's what I asked Claude. And the response was perhaps the question is backwards instead of asking why information matters in the physical world. Maybe we should ask what if information processing is what the physical world actually is? Some theories suggest that reality is fundamentally computational.

that what we call physics is the actual processing of information. So dude, Claude is talking about the vibe sphere.

Mark Fielding It sounds like Claude has read Irreducible. Yeah, that's what I was gonna

Jeremy Gilbertson Claude is talking about the vibe sphere and live information interaction. Wow. I just realized that as I read it out loud.

Mark Fielding Yeah, that's kind of what a lot of this alludes to, isn't it? In a different, maybe different language a little bit, but yeah, we are.

Jeremy Gilbertson Shouts to Claude, Dario Amodei come on the show. We unpacked your machines of love and grace. We're using Claude as an adjunct participant to book club after we read the book, after we make our notes.

The chapter, summarised

Mark Fielding Yeah, we're using a non-seity to augment our seities Let's leave with a finisher here, too long, didn't read, mic drop moment. I think the deep message of quantum physics is that 1: quantum information is the representation of the inner experience of quantum systems, some without and others with free will. That experience can only be privately known by each quantum system and is the creative source of outer reality.

2: live information represents the symbolic shareable information that can directly communicate a portion of the private experience with quantum systems to other quantum systems. live information can also be organized as living organisms. 3: classical information is the symbolic shareable information representable by statistical significant ensembles of uncorrelated life symbols that behave deterministically. Classical information cannot be organized as living organisms. It can only be used to create virtual worlds.

Jeremy Gilbertson That's a lot of stuff. That's a lot of stuff packed in there.

Mark Fielding I think that's a summary of the chapter. I love the last line of this. So he speaks the last part of the chapter. We're going back to the observer and actor in quantum systems. The observer of a quantum system instead cannot observe without drastically disturbing what he observes and thus changes it. Therefore, he's not an observer but an actor. And then he speaks about...

Mark Fielding Obviously, obviously, love hearing you just dump it. Obviously, obviously, there may be many other types of quantum actors for now unexplored since the notion of quantum actor has not been fully explored. Yeah, no shit.

Jeremy Gilbertson whoop, whoop, whoop. Hey, here's my, let me see if this pulls up. I did a little drawing here.

Mark Fielding What have you written no shit I can't read that

Jeremy Gilbertson No, I don't know if you can see that. So quantum system One, QS One, quantum system One, quantum system two, live information exchange in between. what's underneath it? That's a cell representing. Yes. Drawings. All right, there you have it. Chapter 12, we're coming to the end of Irreducible. This has been a crazy but awesome journey, mind experiment.

Jeremy Gilbertson Hopefully you're enjoying the same. We need another book. We need some recommendations. Pop it in the chat, pop it in the comments here and let us know where we should head next.

Mark Fielding Yep, we have One chapter left, lived knowing we're still trying hard sending out our seities to find Federico Faggin's seity We're having a bit of difficulty with that. So if anyone listening to this knows of Federico Faggin's whereabouts over the next 14 days, please drop us a message. Chapter 13.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, actually, just have your your seity find his seity and we'll we'll meet in the vibe sphere.

Mark Fielding They're out there. Yeah, we'll do this in the vibesphere Federico if you want. We'll do it in the metaverse even if you want. The last chapter, starts rationality is not enough. he's not done with taking down mathematics, quantum gravity and probability. Rationality is going to take down a new interpretation of physical reality. mean, join us next week.

Jeremy Gilbertson Be curious, stay disruptive.

Mark Fielding Keep thinking on paper. Keep reading books.