Federico Faggin’s Irreducible, Chapter 8: What Is Panpsychism?

After chapter eight of Irreducible, Mark is weighing Federico Faggin's claim that consciousness is fundamental to the universe. I'm feeling as if maybe our consciousness is not a byproduct of events in the brain.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 18 chapters

  1. The postulate
  2. Consciousness is fundamental
  3. Panpsychism
  4. Where Faggin came across it
  5. What travels between two particles
  6. Consciousness is quantum
  7. Qualia as the experience of a quantum system
  8. Conscious experience is private
  9. A pure state cannot be reproduced
  10. Seity, what the F
  11. The definition
  12. Conscious, but not self conscious
  13. Consciousness has levels
  14. Kicking back against Kevin Kelly
  15. Free will proven by entanglement
  16. LUCA, and one miracle
  17. A constant state of becoming
  18. The true and false analogy
There’s just stuff that is beyond our current comprehension to understand and we have this stubbornness, not just you and I, Mark, but all of the human species has this need to organize, label, define, into blocks.
Jeremy Gilbertson

In chapter eight of Irreducible, Federico Faggin sets out quantum information based panpsychism and uses it to take on the problems of order, life, consciousness and free will. Creation is the one miracle he says must be accepted.

Mark and Jeremy work through qualia as the experience of a quantum system in a pure state, what a seity is, why Faggin says there is no real creativity in a computer, and his claim that quantum entanglement proves free will.

Irreducible by Federico Faggin, chapter 8, sets out quantum information panpsychism (QIP): the theory that consciousness is a fundamental property of the universe, present even in elementary particles, not something the brain produces. Read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, the chapter also argues that machines cannot be conscious and that quantum entanglement provides the conditions for free will.

What is quantum information panpsychism?

Quantum information panpsychism joins panpsychism, the idea that consciousness is a fundamental element of the universe, to the operational probabilistic theory of D’Ariano and his collaborators, which derives quantum physics from quantum information. Faggin’s addition is conscious experience.

Is inner experience quantum or classical, according to Faggin?

In Faggin’s model, inner experience is quantum and private, and describing it in words makes it classical. Jeremy’s shorthand: “inner semantic, quantum, outer symbolic, classical.”

Why does Faggin say machines cannot be conscious?

Machines cannot be conscious, Faggin argues, because “conscious experience is non-algorithmic”. Like a pure quantum state, an experience cannot be copied, only known by the system feeling it.

How does Faggin define a seity?

A seity, in Faggin’s terms, is “a self-conscious entity that can act with free will”, and he argues it exists even without a physical body. Entities that are conscious but not self-conscious he calls thought forms.

Can quantum entanglement explain free will, according to Faggin?

Faggin argues that quantum entanglement provides the conditions for free will, and that his theory answers all but one of the big questions: it cannot explain creation itself.

Where Mark and Jeremy disagree

Mark declines to follow the seity into life after death, and Jeremy proposes a quantum computer controlling an AI from the outside. Mark, a materialist before reading the book, says he likes the theory.

Questions

What is panpsychism?

Quantum information panpsychism joins panpsychism, the idea that consciousness is a fundamental element of the universe, to the operational probabilistic theory of D’Ariano and his collaborators, which derives quantum physics from quantum information. Faggin’s addition is conscious experience.

What is chapter 8 of Irreducible about?

In chapter eight of Irreducible, Federico Faggin sets out quantum information based panpsychism and uses it to take on the problems of order, life, consciousness and free will.

What is the one miracle Faggin says must be accepted?

Creation is the one miracle he says must be accepted.

Does Faggin think consciousness comes from the brain?

Irreducible by Federico Faggin, chapter 8, sets out quantum information panpsychism (QIP): the theory that consciousness is a fundamental property of the universe, present even in elementary particles, not something the brain produces.

Transcript

Mark Fielding Disruptors and curious minds, welcome to the Thinking on Paper book club where we read books that will change your mind, books that will change your consciousness. And I had a whole script planned out for what I was going to say today and I've thrown it out the window because I don't know where to start. We're reading chapter eight of Irreducible by Federico Faggin and it is...

Like I said, I don't know where to start. In short, he's redefining what it means to be conscious and by that, he's redefining how we understand the world, the universe and everything in it. In chapter eight, we're answering the big questions. So, Federico's new way to understand consciousness will help us answer all but one of perhaps the biggest questions that any human has ever asked.

The problem of creation, why does something exist? The problem of order, why is there order instead of chaos in the universe? The problem of life, how did life emerge and why? The problem of consciousness, how did consciousness appear in living beings and what is its purpose? And the problem of free will. And he's going to answer all but one of those with his new theory on consciousness. Existential questions today. So if you listen to this, go, Mark, I moan my law and I don't have time to think about this, come back to it later.

Bookmark the podcast, listen at your own leisure. So Jeremy, chapter eight, irreducible. Where do you begin?

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, let me let's step into this. Let's step into this. So chapters one through seven. It was kind of like you're reading through the chapter. Yeah. Okay. Yep. Yep. Hurry. Yep. Can connect the dot. Yep. Okay. Great. Yep. And like chapter eight, our host and author literally grabs us by by the collar and and shakes loose something new. It's like this. This was like, wow. Okay. Like this was this was a pretty interesting step in. I was I was kind of tracking with everything else, some of the things we'd heard before, but this is like, this is where he's dropping the bomb of like, Hey, I've got a, we've got a new theory on how all of this stuff rolls out. It's based on an existing theory. That's that's tweaked a little bit. So, all right, let's, let's start into it. So, so consciousness, as we set the tone for this, he says is really the only, only thing that differentiates reality from imitation of it. Right? So in this age of AI, in this age of, of, of computers creating things, creating versions of experiences and realities, pointing back to consciousness being the one thing that can differentiate what is real and what is not. And it's an interplay between interactions, right? We have an inner semantic, right? Inner semantic. And you can't see my semantic, you know, you can't experience my inner semantic. But when

I translate my inner semantic into an outer symbolic, you begin to understand, but guess what happens when I do that? I go from quantum to classical. My inner semantic, my inner perception of things is quantum. When I go to explain what I'm feeling to you, it comes out and that is classical. That's what I got to start off with this.

Mark Fielding Yeah, that's a good explanation. Yeah, we are the hard problem of consciousness. And as you say, yeah, our, when we speak, when we describe something that's a classical and exactly what did I say in episode two, that every time you have a thought, any time a thought pops into your mind, that is the wave function collapsing. And that is a quantum process that's allowing you to do that.

The postulate

Mark Fielding I'm going to quote from Federico Faggin for our audience just to give an idea of what his actual...

would you describe it? A postulate he calls it, a thesis, an idea, his way to describe the universe. So quote, find it hard to believe that consciousness could emerge from organisms that are devoid of it. Hence, for consciousness to emerge from inanimate matter, a minimum quantum of consciousness should also exist in at least one of the elementary particles of which the atoms are made. TLDR.

Consciousness is fundamental

Mark Fielding Consciousness is fundamental to the universe. is... And what I got out from that is that in fact...

It's not coming from our brain. It's not an odd...

Mark Fielding side project of our brain. It's actually, if it's in the fabric of the universe, our body, don't need our bodies. We don't need our brains.

Jeremy Gilbertson Wait, wait, hold on, hold on, hold on, hold on. You just said consciousness is a side hustle of our brain. I love that. Like it's not right. It's not just this side hustle, right? Well, let's, we can, we can go into this a little bit, with, with his, his idea of basically human beings are fields, right? And let's, let's get into that here in a little bit, but you talk about, what you, what you were saying a second ago is, consciousness being fundamental. All right. So that is a theory.

Mark Fielding Well it's not is it? That's the thing. It's not a side hustle. It's not.

Panpsychism

Jeremy Gilbertson called panpsychism, right? Which has been around for a long, time. It's that consciousness is a fundamental element of the universe, even before particles. Because some people think the other theories are like, okay, consciousness emerges from material things. Consciousness emerges from molecules and particles and all of these things. They emerge out of it as a secondary experience. But panpsychism says that it's part of the, of the foundational elements of things, meaning, you know, again, irreducible, like you can't, you can't go below these foundational elements. They are what they are. And that's what panpsychism is. But you say the word panpsychism, people are like, what is that? a little frou-frou, like more, more spiritual, less science kind of thing. Right. But as we see, our host and author runs us through this stuff, it's actually like a very very interwoven thing between spirituality, between science. And one thing I wanted to point out, was part in this book, but part in our like, so Mark and I are digging into supplemental material from Federico Faggin to help us connect the dots in some of this stuff because we have to go deeper. Our curiosity has driven us to go deeper, but talking.

Mark Fielding What Joby really means is to help us understand just some of what the hell he's saying some of the time, at least for me.

Jeremy Gilbertson That too, that too, no, no, it's both. But the idea that this theory, this postulate that he has a quantum information based panpsychism, QIP, which is basically talking about what I just said before, reality is both semantic and symbolic, right? It's internal, it's inner and it's outer. And it's all based on quantum information, right? So we do a lot of, we do a lot of talk about quantum computing, right? So qubits and that sort of thing, qubits and bits together. So quantum information as a quantum bit is how quantum physics is explained by quantum information. And what was that gentleman's name? D D Amelio? No, not D. What is his name? D Ariano, D Ariano.

Where Faggin came across it

Mark Fielding Okay, let's go back then. it's, yeah, so Federico Faggin, came across something called operational probabilistic theory that this GM, Dariano and his collaborators has developed. And that showed that quote quantum physics can logically derive from quantum information. However, quantum information is completely abstract, i.e. devoid of any meaning. If consciousness is fundamental, information without meaning makes no sense at all. I'm not sure that makes much sense to most people.

And that was the essential aspect was missing from this QIP. So Federico Faggin spent some time speaking to GM D'Ariano about this and...

Federico's like, okay, yeah, conscious experience.

is an irreducible aspect of quantum information, mix that into this original QIP and you get this quantum information based panpsychism. So essentially it's added ingredient into panpsychism, which is this conscious experience, the qualia that we all have this innate unique internal experience, put that in there and you get your QIP.

Jeremy Gilbertson So P.S., Anika Harris, I'm calling out to you again. I read Lights, or I listened to Lights on. This book, you should read it if you haven't read it. If you don't wanna read it, jump on and talk about it with us. all right, so let's go back to what you said a second ago, Mark. You said something about quantum information is an abstraction, and what did you say? It's incoherent.

Mark Fielding It's a quantum is in quantum information is completely abstract. I devoid of any meaning if consciousness is fundamental information without meaning makes no sense at all.

What travels between two particles

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay. Okay. Let's, let's, let's keep on that first part of that is, is devoid of quantum information is devoid of meaning. So do you remember, I can't remember if it was the Michio Kaku book or, or Carlo Rovelli or one of the other books, but like, I remember thinking, um, that, know, when in two entangled particles, it was an example when two particles are entangled quantum entanglement, uh, information.

can travel between those two particles faster than the speed of light. I don't know if you remember that, right? So, but the problem is that information that's moving at the speed of light is noise, it's static. It's not signal, it's noise. it's that, I just remember it being, even though the information can travel, it's kind of nonsense. It doesn't make sense. But what it actually is, is the probability of all of the situations

Jeremy Gilbertson that can happen between those two particles. That's the information that's happening that's processing.

Mark Fielding Yes. Well, I remember that I think we have to like clarify that speed of light thing because someone's just tuning into this again. Things are moving faster than the speed of light. Then I think that we're complete idiots. It's not exactly what, well, we are complete idiots. That's why we're doing this, but it's not exactly what we're saying. So it's that entanglement of quantum physics whereby.

Jeremy Gilbertson Do you remember that though?

Jeremy Gilbertson We are complete idiots though.

Mark Fielding one bit can be a negative, the other can be positive, but they can be billions of light years apart and then they change in accordance with each other. And so that's the information and that's the beauty and the weirdness and the strangeness of quantum mechanics is that that happens. And for that to happen, if it was a one bit sending a signal to the other one, obviously it'd be going faster than the speed of light because it couldn't be this instantaneous change on the other side of the galaxy. But that is happening in entanglement.

So whatever that is, nobody knows that probability of blah, I don't know. Yeah. Yes, I remember.

Jeremy Gilbertson All right, so let's continue. Let's continue. So remember in the beginning of this, everyone we talked about.

Mark Fielding It was Carlo Rovelli, by the way, that was the order of time.

Jeremy Gilbertson Ooh, well played. And by the way, you can listen to that whole book unpacked by Mark and I chapter by chapter in book club. So we have this, I mentioned in the beginning, have inner semantic, right? Which is like, say an example, this is what I'm feeling. Inner semantic. You don't know what I'm feeling, Mark. And I, once I explained to you how I'm feeling, that's when quantum information, as this theory predicts, internal and semantic is quantum.

Consciousness is quantum

Jeremy Gilbertson Right? Consciousness is quantum. And when I explain consciousness or I explain my feeling to you, that's when it becomes classical. That's when there's a wave collapse, right? with, within all of that. that's, that's what I want to bring up too is this whole Levo's theorem, whole Levo's theorem, which there's always a one-to-one that, yeah, I don't know if that's the, I just know it as whole Levo's. might be no.

Mark Fielding Is that the no cloning theorem? Or is that something different?

Jeremy Gilbertson might be no cloning, but there's always a one to one relationship between a classical bit and a quantum bit because you have, you have this whole of things, basically the probability of all things happening and there's a collapse into one thing happening. So there's that, there's that quantum to classical conversion there as described by Hulevos. all right.

Mark Fielding Maybe that's too...

Jeremy Gilbertson talking through this, let's get out of, let's get out of, let's talk about qualia. Let's talk about qualia as described by our host and author. So I'm going to read this. Yes, our host and author.

Mark Fielding You mean Federico Faggin? Yeah, go on then. Shoot.

Qualia as the experience of a quantum system

Jeremy Gilbertson That's right. So qualia is the experience of a quantum system in a pure quantum state. So what is a pure quantum state? And you referenced this a second ago. Pure quantum state is not clonable and it's private and it's definite. So that would explain, that's how I'm like, okay, my feelings are that quantum state, right? Because my feelings are definite. My feelings are private and they can't be copied and cloned.

thrown in your brain. Right? Am I seeing that? Am I hearing that correct? Am I...

Mark Fielding Yeah, yeah, yeah, yes, that's how I interpreted it as well,

Conscious experience is private

Jeremy Gilbertson So conscious experience is private then.

Mark Fielding Well, that, he's well, quote, a pure quantum state is the mathematical entity most suitable to represent an experience because it has the extraordinary property of being irreproducible yet knowable by the system feeling it. Yeah, which is what you said.

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, good, that makes sense. Feel like I'm connecting the dots. Conscious experience in private. So we've talked about comprehension in the last few chapters, right? And comprehension as a difference between computers and us, a difference between silicon and carbon, right? So comprehension is the transformation from live to quantum information within a conscious entity.

So is that a wave collapse? Is that a free will working in a wave collapse? Is that comprehension?

Mark Fielding I don't want to get ahead of ourselves, but I think like everything is every thought, every idea is a quantum process. So the wave collapse. So yes.

Jeremy Gilbertson Not everything is a quantum process, because once it's turned into classical, it is no longer quantum.

Mark Fielding whatever thing that you experience inside you. Yeah. The feelings, the emotions, the thoughts. Yes.

Mark Fielding I'm gonna read just to give some optimism because to our audience, what does this mean for technology and artificial intelligence? Because everyone's listening to this, they wanna know what about the machines? So.

Jeremy Gilbertson I'm optimistic, man. I feel good right now. I'm just melted a little bit.

A pure state cannot be reproduced

Mark Fielding Quote, the fact that a pure state cannot be reproduced makes it homomorphic to the qualia I feel, for I too cannot fully describe my love without violating the no-cloning theorem. I can only partially express my love with words or with other classical symbols, but that partial description cannot be confused with the love I feel within myself. Moreover, for the symbols to be understood, the receiver must comprehend my words. It should not be surprising then that comprehension requires a transformation from live to quantum information with a conscious entity.

Therefore, a pure quantum state is the mathematical entity, this is what I said earlier, most suitable to represent an experience because it has the extraordinary property of being irreproducible, yet knowable by the system feeling it. Thus, quantum physics, which supervenes on quantum information, indicates that the ultimate ontology resides in the private experience, representable by quantum information. This is as far as mathematics can go to describe reality. True knowing.

is non-algorithmic and only partially shareable with classic symbols, i.e. with algorithms. Said differently, so if you don't know what I just said, because I don't really know what I just said, said differently, conscious experience is non-algorithmic because it cannot be known through algorithms, but only by experiencing what is known. That's why machines cannot be conscious.

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, inner semantic, outer symbolic. Inner semantic, outer symbolic.

Seity, what the F

Mark Fielding SEITY Jeremy. So I've written down, Seity what the F.

Jeremy Gilbertson I learned a whole new word, yeah, Seity Seity.

Mark Fielding some weird stuff going on with the part on seity

The definition

Jeremy Gilbertson So the definition, a self-conscious entity that can act with free will is a seity, S-E-I-T-Y. So as soon as I started reading this, if you guys have read any Buckminster Fuller, specifically, Nine Chains to the Moon, which I've suggested multiple times to Mark, but he's slightly frightened of it, which he should be, which he should be, it's a gnarly read. But Buckminster Fuller calls,

The Seity, I think he refers to it as the phantom captain, the phantom captain. That's like you picture, you know, in, in, in those movies where you have a mech and you drop into the mech and you're controlling the body and the, the, the phantom captain is, making the decisions. And the Seity is the decision maker for the body and the body is the body is how the Seity experiences and organizes what's happening in the world.

The body allows, here's what wrote, the body allows the Seity to perceive and operate in the physical world.

Mark Fielding a seity exists even without a physical body and this is a crucial statement because it means that our existence does not depend on the body's existence. The body simply allows the seity to perceive and operate in the physical world, which is only a small portion of the vast reality in which she exists. Now, yes, he's referring to it as a she. I don't want to go into what that means. That opens a conversation about life after death and I'm just not going there today. So maybe we can save that for...

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, suffice it to say, and neighbors, that there's more to everything than meets the eye. Boom. Next.

Mark Fielding In principle, a seity could be described with a set of quantum equations, which, however, could not represent. This part of the chapter is where it goes beyond my... This is where we need a proper scientist to come on to explain it, or a mathematician. I don't know. He's talking about Heisenberg's indeterminism and how using his new theory of consciousness, somehow you could use mathematics to describe kindness. And it was like, what?

Jeremy Gilbertson That was bonkers. Yeah, I wanna jump into that. I kinda love it though. Yeah. Well, let's, all right, let's look at, let's look at page 172 here for a second. 172. And this is a bit confusing. I think it was 172.

Mark Fielding Yeah, I loved it, it was like, what?

Conscious, but not self conscious

Jeremy Gilbertson So just the idea of like, what's the difference between conscious and self-conscious? that's 171. 171, I wrote here, because being self-conscious is much more than being conscious without identity.

What in the world? Here, let me read this. A seity is endowed with a unique and permanent identity because she knows that the conscious experience she is having is her own and thus she can direct her experience, i.e. Bucky Fuller's Phantom Captain, right? So being conscious is much more, or being self-conscious is much more than being conscious without identity.

Mark Fielding quantum entities that are conscious but not self conscious, I call thought forms. Thought forms do not know what that their experience is their own. And this could not direct their own actions and experience with free will. Okay, does that is he talking there about so this idea that he has that okay, consciousness is fundamental to the universe is if the universe is a field, it's in the field, it's part of everything, which means that

Consciousness has levels

Mark Fielding Consciousness has levels. So our consciousness, my consciousness, your consciousness is not the same as your cat's consciousness and your cat's consciousness is not the same as...

a mouse and it goes down, down, down, down, down to these like fundamental particles that they have. They have no free will because they're particles, but they do have what he calls thought forms. They do not know that their experience is their own and thus they can't direct it. But they are still conscious, not like we are, but in this theory of consciousness being fundamental to the fabric of the universe.

Jeremy Gilbertson So it's like a self-awareness level, right? So there's something experiencing some sort of qualia, but they don't know that that qualia is being experienced by them. That's the difference.

Mark Fielding Yeah, and they're qualia wouldn't be like hours asking existential questions about what is nothing that they would just be doing whatever the cell does or whatever that protein does or whatever that particle does. It wouldn't be going, I'm a light particle. I'm going to do something different. then I might go a bit slower today. Chill out. Just relax. Kick back and.

Jeremy Gilbertson I'm going to spin around this way today.

You actually can't. We learned that electrons actually have a granular.

force or, or, it electrons spin at the same force, no matter what. It's not like, Hey, I'm an electron today and I'm going to spin a little bit lighter. They're all spinning at the same force, which I, which I kind of didn't know.

Kicking back against Kevin Kelly

Mark Fielding Let's kick back against Kevin Kelly here because is AI conscious? Everyone says AI AI creative. Everyone says AI is creative.

Jeremy Gilbertson Wait, Kevin Kelly, you mean the guy that was on our show a while back, the founder of Wired Magazine? Wow, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

Mark Fielding Yeah, yeah. Thinking on paper at xyz, you can listen to that. And you can listen to us have other conversations with other people about whether AI is creative or not. free will implies creative choices from within that cannot be determined by any algorithm or mathematics, but only represented a posterior experience is not a mathematical formula, simulation, or whatever. Does that mean that the algorithm isn't creative because it doesn't have free will? So.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, so he talks about it at the very end of this. There's no real creativity in a computer because creativity requires non-algorithmic choices that can only be made by a quantum entity controlling the computer from the outside. Let me read that one more time because I've got a funky idea on this. There is no real creativity in a computer because creativity requires non-algorithmic choices that can only be made by a quantum entity phantom captain.

Jeremy Gilbertson controlling the computer from the outside. All right, here's what I wrote in the book. What about quantum AI controllers? What if there was a quantum computer that could control an AI, a computer that actually lives as the quantum conscious side of the fence that controls the classical side of the fence?

Mark Fielding Then yes, this goes back to what we were raging about the other day where everyone makes robots out of metal and silicon and chips. But if you start making your robots in a Petri dish, then yes. Or if you use a quantum computer, then yes, because then it's been built from the inside out. It has the building blocks of life. It's organic, it's conscious, then yes.

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, so we're now seeking funding for our Quantum AI Controller, patented by Thinking on Paper. A16C, feel free to give us a shout and we'll talk about it.

Mark Fielding Podcasts are great. You can just literally say anything you want. Just redefine physics, redefine, we're changing physics. Well, he's, he's, what this book is doing is redefining physics. It's redefining what science means. Well, that's like his theory does.

Jeremy Gilbertson Redefining our understanding of science, I think.

Mark Fielding Or unifying, what do you say? think that to be able to unify physics, we must abandon the current approach and open ourselves to a new vision. New concepts are needed. Quantum physics. Yeah.

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, so what did you think?

Mark Fielding It's pretty big, isn't it? not like, he's not, he's not messing about.

Jeremy Gilbertson No, he's not messing about. all right, mic drop moment in this chapter. If we were to turn this chapter into short editable TikTok videos, this would be the mic drop moment. It would be.

Free will proven by entanglement

Jeremy Gilbertson Free will is proven by quantum entanglement.

Jeremy Gilbertson He believes free will, the proof for free will exists in quantum entanglement. And the wave collapse of the field of a particle is actually free will in action as described by science. Whew, Sam Harris would be mad at that one.

Mark Fielding You gotta go on, take...

Jeremy Gilbertson Maybe Sam and Annika could both come on and talk about this with us. Maybe, I don't know.

Mark Fielding You've got to go on TikTok and do that. And I want to see what the, what TikTok says.

Jeremy Gilbertson Dude, I don't even know how to like, I think I've maybe tried to make one TikTok piece of content.

Mark Fielding The entanglement stuff, I'm just trying to find where there's another sentence about entanglement, which I read it and then I just kind of tried to forget that it existed because...

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, here we go. I got it. I got it right here. All right. Since entangled quantum systems exhibit non-local correlations, quantum entanglement provides the conclusive proof that classical states cannot exist prior to the quantum transformations that manifest them wave collapse, right? This is exactly the necessary conditions for the existence of free will. Mic drop by our host and author.

Mark Fielding coming soon to a TikTok channel near you. Right, let's just for the sake of...

Mark Fielding The sake of posterity. Answer some of these questions. The unsolved problems, the problem of creation, the problem of order, the problem of life, the problem of consciousness, the problem of free will. Now, these five problems, he does say that his theory will not answer the first problem, the problem of creation. Why does something exist instead of nothing? Where does the universe come from? Has it always existed? What is its purpose? He says it's a miracle and you can't, our brains can't answer that question. He thinks that that question goes unanswered.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, we do know how our life got to be in a way with cyanobacteria burping. We've talked about this a lot, created our atmosphere, created life on earth scientifically. Yeah, tell me, tell us about Luca.

Mark Fielding But the others...

LUCA, and one miracle

Mark Fielding No, no, Luca, forget Luca. Well, Luca, last universal common ancestor. No scientist has ever been able to explain how it was created by natural processes. So evolution Darwinism works from that point. Survival of the fittest evolution works from that point, but it doesn't work before that point. At what point does non-conscious become conscious?

Is that a miracle? Do we have to say that? With this theory.

Jeremy Gilbertson He's, he's, he's accepting one miracle and the rest of it he's got. Right.

Mark Fielding Yeah, it's not that one. Yeah, he's accepting one miracle like because our brains can't handle the problem of creation, but his theory answers that problem because if there is consciousness in the fundamental building blocks of the universe, then Luca that last universal common answer that first one that first point that first glimmer of consciousness came from something that was already conscious. So that answers that one.

Jeremy Gilbertson So yeah, so on these nested, he talks about these nested levels, right? So you have the emergence of the inanimate, which then all living organisms are nested in the first level there in this second level. And then the third level, all conscious organisms are kind of nested in that level. And then the fourth level finally nested within all of those levels is all conscious organisms plus free will. And he has this like little

Jeremy Gilbertson Almost the, what are those like the Russian doll things? Yeah.

Mark Fielding Yeah, the Russian dollar things. other words, living organisms must emerge from inanimate matter, conscious organisms emerge from unconscious organisms and free will emerges from conscious organism and a similar structure also applies to the laws that govern each level. And that is the bit I think the only problem of the five that can never be solved is the problem of creation. The beginning of the universe, assuming there was a beginning, is something that is beyond the reach of our feeble.

I added that, mines. And yet we need to start with reasonable postures to explain the other problems as logical consequences of the only miracle of creation that must be accepted.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yes, yes, there was another piece that I'm gonna pull out.

Yeah, there's just stuff we don't understand is what it really boils down to. There's just stuff that is beyond our current comprehension to understand and we have this stubbornness, not just you and I, Mark, but all of the human species has this need to organize, label, define, into blocks. It's like when you learned about cells in, you know, elementary school or when you were younger and you learned that, okay, a cell is a thing and then it has a mitochondria and that's like a thing and all there are all these little objects and then a molecule is a thing. It's a round ball. Not really. It's this interaction between fields and what you're seeing is kind of the result of that interaction. But that's pretty complex, man. Like that's, that's super complex. Like to even think about like, I don't know.

So the reason I say that is like, that should in and of itself put people's minds in a situation where we have to be open to the possibilities of which we don't understand.

Mark Fielding Are you buying into the theory? Because we've spoken a lot about emergent systems in the past. And even though I didn't know how to describe myself, but before this book, and not before this book, before it's maybe like, this goes back to the order of time by Carla Rovelli, the idea that time is a quantum concept and time, and maybe it goes, maybe in me somewhere I knew this, but I think I was probably, I was a materialist and saying that consciousness came as an offshoot.

of these processes in the brain and that's where consciousness came from. And now reading this book, I like this theory. Do you believe it? Are you buying into it? Are you going to change your mental models of how and how you think about consciousness?

A constant state of becoming

Jeremy Gilbertson I've always thought we're in this constant state of becoming. I've, I've, I've that's permeated all of the things that, that I've been learning and teaching and in being involved with is, you know, we're, we're, different than we were five seconds ago, you know, like, and even compounded over time, right? Are the cells in our body change every year, right? You know, 98 % of ourselves and our body are different every year, right? Or, or recycle or change and become new.

Mark Fielding Well, yeah, is no present Carlo Rovelli.

Jeremy Gilbertson And we're just in, there is no, we're just an organized collection of particles that is assembling in a certain way in a certain moment in time. Well, time doesn't even exist, right? But we're gonna leave that for the whole order of time book. like we're just organizations and approximations is kind of what it it boils down to. So I definitely am super, I've always been interested in quantum because quantum is this, is the explanation or the possible explanation for the magic that we don't understand, right? And classical is our way, is our means to get our head around and organize stuff sometimes to our detriment, right? Sometimes things don't need to be organized and they're not hierarchical, they're emergent and there's this flow of top to bottom. I'm feeling it, man.

The biggest thing I guess for me, and I said this right at the beginning of the episode is inner semantic, quantum, outer symbolic, classical. And we are machines that are both quantum and classical at the same time. And in this supplemental video that you sent to help us understand what was like, Federico Faggin was like running through a lot of this stuff. There is no hard line between, where's the quantum in Mark and where's the classical in Mark? It's like,

The true and false analogy

Jeremy Gilbertson Beautiful analogy he used was a true and false, right? Something is true only or false only in a moment in time, right? And we are organizations and approximations in a moment in time, right? So the boundary between what is classical with us and what is quantum with us is pretty fluid.

Jeremy Gilbertson How you feeling, Mark?

Mark Fielding I'm feeling conscious, Jeremy. I'm feeling aware. I'm feeling like I'm connected somehow to existence and the universe and creation. I'm feeling as if maybe our consciousness is not a byproduct of events in the brain. But maybe my consciousness is here and here and here here here and here and in the trees and in the leaves and in the bees.

and everywhere else. that's how I'm feeling. I'm feeling conscious. So the question is, think, listener, how are you going to use your consciousness? Because regardless of whether consciousness is fundamental to the very fabric of the universe, regardless of whether consciousness can explain, imagine that the Big Bang consciousness somehow developed.

and exploded out with all those other things at the beginning of time. Imagine that. Consciousness was in there. It doesn't matter if that's true or false or the primordial quark glue on conscious soup that exploded out into the universe. You're conscious. What you going to do with it? What are you going do with it, Jeremy? What are you going to do next?

Jeremy Gilbertson It was in the primordial.

Jeremy Gilbertson What am I going to do next? I'm going to, I'm going to stay down the rabbit hole, man. This is, this is some fascinating stuff and almost like dare I say quasi tangible stuff that I've always been kind of thinking about that there was an interconnectedness. but, the idea that these starting to kind of break it down a little bit. by the way, PS quantum theory in general is one of the most proven theories in science. think it was proven the most times out of out of any other theory. So when we look at it, it was like, well, that's just magic and weird stuff. No, it's actually one of the most proven theories in science. I can't remember where I read that, but it was, it was somewhere. And hopefully someone can push us around if I'm incorrect, but there we have it guys. That's the new vision. Jump on board the Federico Faggin consciousness train, fundamental quantum information based panpsychism. Stay on the journey.

Mark Fielding That's something I never thought I'd say.

Jeremy Gilbertson Oh my gosh, well hey, a couple more chapters to go guys. Tell us what you're thinking about this. Drop us a line, give us a book. Do you want to jump in to this book club? Do you want to be on one of these screens to talk through a particular book with us? If you do, drop us a line, hello at thinkingonpaper.xyz. Hit us on social media, all the fun stuff. Mark, any other closing thoughts?

Mark Fielding Can you hear that? That's the sound of the wave function.

Jeremy Gilbertson in our decision to end the show. Stay curious, be disruptive.

Mark Fielding Keep thinking on paper.