Federico Faggin’s Irreducible, Chapter 7: What Are Qualia?
Jeremy points out that a machine can tag the smell of a rose but cannot remember the last time it smelled one. Consciousness is the thing that we know more definitely than anything else and yet we can't describe what it is like.
In this episode · 16 chapters
- What Kevin Kelly believes
- The four types of qualia
- Is curiosity an emotion?
- Is qualia the differentiator?
- The scent of a rose
- The scent is not a signal
- What we know most definitely
- Does it matter?
- The most perplexing problem
- Huxley, and the Doors of Perception
- The alternative
- How a machine recognises a cup
- Right and wrong
- Comprehension
- True intelligence
- The dangers of semantics
You are conscious. Go outside and wield your consciousness. Be curious. Be courageous. Be brave. Be inquisitive. Be caring. Be loving. Be all of the things that make you different to the machines that you are increasingly relying upon.
Chapter seven of Irreducible sets out Federico Faggin's four types of qualia: physical sensations and feelings, emotions, thoughts and spiritual feelings. Mark opens by saying he wants AI to be conscious, because only then would a superintelligence conclude that humanity is worth saving.
We ask whether curiosity is an emotion, how a machine learns to recognise a cup without knowing what a cup means, and whether AI hallucination counts as creativity. Jeremy sums up the chapter: “Comprehension is literally what we're doing. Comprehension is thinking on paper.”
Federico Faggin's Irreducible, chapter 7, defines consciousness and qualia, and argues that AI can recognise and label the world but cannot comprehend it. Read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, it prompts Mark Fielding to push back that AI can be truly intelligent without being conscious.
What are the four types of qualia?
He names four types of qualia: physical sensations, emotions, thoughts and spiritual feelings. Curiosity comes first in his list of emotions.
How does Federico Faggin define consciousness?
Faggin defines consciousness as “the inner semantic space” where signals from the physical world become feelings, sensations and meanings. Those are qualia.
Why is the scent of a rose not a signal?
“The scent of a rose is not a signal,” Faggin writes. A sensor can detect the molecules, but the scent itself is a quale, something different from the electrical signal.
Can AI comprehend what a cup means?
A trained network can recognise a cup it has never seen, yet “the program still cannot comprehend what CUP means.”
What does Faggin mean by true intelligence?
Faggin’s “true intelligence” includes intuition, creativity, empathy, compassion, ethics and love, and he argues machines will never be able to do those things.
Where Mark and the book disagree
Mark says that describes being human, not intelligence, and that AI can be truly intelligent without being conscious. He also calls curiosity an itch, not an emotion.
Links from this episode
Questions
What are qualia?
He names four types of qualia: physical sensations, emotions, thoughts and spiritual feelings. Curiosity comes first in his list of emotions.
What is chapter 7 of Irreducible about?
Federico Faggin's Irreducible, chapter 7, defines consciousness and qualia, and argues that AI can recognise and label the world but cannot comprehend it.
Why does Mark want AI to be conscious?
Mark opens by saying he wants AI to be conscious, because only then would a superintelligence conclude that humanity is worth saving.
How does Jeremy sum up chapter 7 of Irreducible?
Jeremy sums up the chapter: “Comprehension is literally what we're doing. Comprehension is thinking on paper.”
Transcript
Mark Fielding Disruptors and curious minds, book lovers, welcome to the Thinking on Paper Book Club. I'm Mark, this is Jeremy, and every week we read books that have stood the test of time, books that will change your mind, books that will change your consciousness this time. But what is consciousness? What is qualia? What is the hard problem of consciousness? What is panpsychism? And the Dharma Bums are back.
Mark Fielding But first, a public service announcement from Thinking on Paper. I want AI to be conscious. AI isn't conscious. It will never will be conscious, but I want it to be conscious. Why? Because then we wouldn't have to worry. I don't mean we wouldn't have to worry about job loss, your children's future, the centralisation of data, the centralisation of power, depression, anxiety, AI girlfriends, AI boyfriends.
trillion dollar companies with 10 employees, the death of human creativity and the homogenization of culture because you will have to worry about that. You have to think about that now. No, I don't mean that. I mean, I want AI to be conscious because of the long term survival of humanity, of the species. We wouldn't have to worry about Skynet and AI blowing up the world in search of better paperclip factories, the alignment problems because...
If you combine superintelligence with consciousness, if you combine superintelligence with all our stories, all your stories, if you combine superintelligence with everything we've ever written, everything we've ever dreamed, everything we've ever said, everything we've ever lived, then that superintelligence will come to the conclusion that humanity is fundamentally peaceful, collaborative, optimistic, hopeful, friendly, caring, loving and funny.
It will be a reflection of us, the best version of us. But without consciousness, AI will just be a really smart wanker. And then all bets are off.
That's when shit hits the fan because it isn't conscious. We want it. I want it to be conscious because of that. Some say I'm a dreamer. I'm not the only one. Consciousness, chapter seven, irreducible, Jeremy, paint us a picture. Another picture. I think I just painted one.
Jeremy Gilbertson I don't know how to follow that up. That was amazing. That was holy. I feel very inspired, Mark. Thank you for...
Mark Fielding I want it to be conscious. like the more I think about it, the more I read this book, the more I think on paper, the more I see people, know, like tune in, turn off, drop out. was the expression? Turn on, tune in, drop out. There's a modern version of that, but yeah, but people are just turning off and yeah, I want it to be conscious.
Jeremy Gilbertson Kendrick Lamar's Turn the TV Off.
What Kevin Kelly believes
Jeremy Gilbertson All right, so a couple of thoughts on that. Kevin Kelly believes that AI will be conscious. He talks about the thing that's gonna be really interesting is when we code emotion into AI, which is like, know about that and how, well, we'll talk about the difference in why machines.
Mark Fielding Well, yeah, how are you going to code qualia into AIs?
Jeremy Gilbertson That's exactly what we're going to run down today. It's super interesting. And you know, I've been rabbit holeing into consciousness, not just with irreducible, but other inputs, books, audio books, the whole thing. But man, all right, my brain's spinning a little bit from where you're headed. So you want AI to be conscious so it will manage, it will look out for humanity. It will see the bigger picture. It will...
it will see that we're all part of a bigger thing. But check it out though, like how many people are conscious to that level, right? And is consciousness, one person's consciousness and another person's consciousness, are they equal, right? Because like there's some really bad dudes around that have a similar idea of consciousness that we do, but being kind, being empathetic, being understanding, being seeing the earth rise, right? So we talk, we're bouncing all over the place, but we were on Chris Muller's show the other day and he brought up the idea of earth rise as picture taken by this astronaut from the moon of the earth actually rising as the sun would just because of a change of perspective. But like that shift, like some people don't, I don't think consciousness, the quality of someone's consciousness is not universal, I think.
Mark Fielding No, we're talking about super intelligence though. We're not talking about the average person. We're talking about, so Dostoevsky, takes something more than intelligence to act intelligently. The idea of super intelligence is that it will be able to pattern recognition and connect the dots like something we can't comprehend. And if its only access point is all the data and all the stories and all the things we've ever said and thought and dreamed and imagined.
Yes, there are nefarious people. Yes, there are horrible dictators. Yes, there is murder and genocide. And that is not the prevalent condition of the human species, far from it. And so this superintelligence, my reasoning is, like I said, I'm a dreamer, but you know, but the superintelligence will go through all of that and it will come to this conclusion that we are worth, worth, worth saving, that we are not disposable.
heroes that we can and it will act accordingly. But because it doesn't have consciousness and as we learn about intelligence and consciousness are not the same thing and empathy comes from consciousness and all of these human facets that we need it to have to not end in a bad way. That's why what
Jeremy Gilbertson So you gotta, so in the language models, in the models for this, you have to sprinkle in empathy, you have to sprinkle in vulnerability, you have to code in this idea that we're a small piece of something larger. I don't know how to explain that.
Mark Fielding Yeah, that'd be pattern recognition again, but if it doesn't have consciousness, can't understand empathy. It can understand what empathy gives you, but it can't feel empathy because it isn't conscious. is it, Federico Faggin?
Jeremy Gilbertson So you being the dreamer. All right.
Mark Fielding What is cut out his consciousness work Jamie let's get into the book
Jeremy Gilbertson Let's do it. I thought it was really funny. The first piece of this chapter comes from his, our host and author's recollection of his experience in Christianity with the Holy Communion in this idea of the examination of consciousness as a part of that process, that regiment, right? And as he kind of worked through where he got the first few bits of the chapter, we're like, okay,
So if, if this idea of consciousness emanates from electro electrochemical signals in the brain, as this neuroscience professor told him, he was this neuroscience professor was on his advisory board for one of his companies, right? So he asked the, this guy about consciousness. He's like, okay, it's like electrochemical signals emanating and generating things. Right? So he's like, okay, well, that's cool. What, what about computers, know, computers are electrical signals. Good computers generate, you know, or generate consciousness or experience consciousness, which led him down this path of discovery that we know, he figured out that computers couldn't be conscious, but, that's where it starts. But qualia let's talk about qualia. It's pretty interesting stuff. Touchy feely.
Mark Fielding Well, yeah, and I wasn't really that familiar with the word qualia before this. So consciousness is the inner semantic space where the signals coming from the physical world, both inside and outside the body, are processed by the brain and take the form of feelings, sensations and meanings, i.e. qualia.
The four types of qualia
Jeremy Gilbertson What are the four types of qualia, Mr. Fielding, according to our host and author?
Mark Fielding The four, let me just check my thinking on paper here. The four types of qualia are physical sensations and feelings, emotions, thoughts, spiritual feelings, and thoughts and spiritual feelings may or may not be qualia depending on who you ask.
Jeremy Gilbertson There you go. Yeah. So physical sensations, it's the taste of food. It's the sound of music. Emotions, pretty self-explanatory. The one interesting thing that I saw listed on here, the first emotion that he listed as an example was curiosity. I was like, I'd never thought about that as an emotion before.
Mark Fielding curiosity, friendship, compassion, joy, trust, fear, anger, sadness, pride, stubbornness, shame, envy, greed, confusion and so on.
Is curiosity an emotion?
Jeremy Gilbertson Is curiosity an emotion?
Mark Fielding Or is it a thought? Is curiosity an emotion?
Jeremy Gilbertson I thought that was interesting. That, that hit me. That hit me. Cause I always think about curiosity is this like, as this vehicle, right? Or this, I think about it. If you, if you have like a, who was it? think the Shopify guy, this is a, this is a hard left turn, but the Shopify guy had this idea of, of the trust battery, right? When you're building an audience, when you're building, you know, a client base and that sort of thing, you got to just keep feeding the trust battery. As long as the battery is charged, you have trust with your customers.
I think about curiosity the same way, this curiosity engine, that as long as you keep it filled and activated, you know, it's a way to like dive into things, right? It's a way to, you know, seek to understand stuff. I never thought of it as an emotion before.
Mark Fielding It's an itch. I think it's a sensation. It's almost like an itch. You have to scratch it and I think that it's more of a sensation than an emotion.
Jeremy Gilbertson Good call. Good call. I like it. It lives in quality though, does it not?
Mark Fielding It lives in Kuala Lumpur, so we digress from the actual main point. It lives in Kuala Lumpur.
Is qualia the differentiator?
Mark Fielding What's the, is Qualia the differentiator, are we saying? Because a machine can, so they like speaking about roses, don't they, in these books? And so Aldous Huxley, the doors of perception, he speaks about roses, he speaks about flowers, and he does it in a way that is quite spellbinding. The Dahama Bums are back, so check out our substack. Check out our substack, thinkingonpaper.xyz.
Jeremy Gilbertson Who's, so who's back? Who's back? The Dharma Bums.
Mark Fielding follow the links to the sub stack and it's not for today but the consciousness industry I think is replicating what came before but without the without without the
Jeremy Gilbertson the storytelling.
Mark Fielding rebelliousness of the beatniks without the rebelliousness of those. But I digress, yeah, call it.
The scent of a rose
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, let's speak in a rose. Speaking of roses, let's talk about, he had an interesting example of using how a rose is recognized by its sense to differentiate kind of man and machine a little bit. Right. So let me walk you through this and let me know if I missed anything. Right. So, when we recognize the smell of a rose, right. Molecules from the rose come out and land and hit our receptors. Right. And then, what he says, a macroscopic.
Jeremy Gilbertson electrical signals generated that kind of fires to our brain to say, Hey, you know, we're, we're sensing this thing coming up. Right. And these are inputs to our neural networks to understand the qualia that's coming in, right? Where we're kind of making sense of, all of this stuff. So we turn objective to subjective at that point, right? The, all that stuff lands.
And we go, that smells like a rose. the last time I smelled a rose, it was this situation or whatever. And you know, roses make me think about this and the memory connection and all of that stuff. Whereas machines, right? Can recognize the inputs and say, Hey, that's the input that tells me that input is, is tagged to a rose in my little matrix. But I can't, you know, the, machine can't, you know, remember the last time it smelled a rose, right? It can't do that. So there's.
I see this as an objective to subjective translation that we're able to do with Qualia that machines are not. What do you think?
Mark Fielding Yeah, I think that you've summarized what he said far better than I could.
The scent is not a signal
Mark Fielding However, the scent of a rose is not a signal, it is a quail, something completely different from the electrical signals generated by the neural networks. It is related to them, of course, but it is not identical, nor can it be produced directly by them. I yeah, we can smell a rose and we can be taken back 50 years. We can smell a rose and we can think of something else, like there's this springboard of emotions and qualia that stem from that rose and the machine. Yeah, it can...
The problem is that the machine can convince you that it can smell that rose. so going back, that's the thing. This is what Aldous Aldous Huckley speaks about in the Doors of Perception about the and that's the hard problem of consciousness, isn't it? That you can't.
Jeremy Gilbertson That's yeah. Yup.
What we know most definitely
Mark Fielding Consciousness is the thing that we know more definitely than anything else and yet we can't describe what it is like. So vis-a-vis, you can't describe what it's not like. So a machine could tell you it's conscious and you can't prove that it isn't, but it can convince you that it is.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, it almost goes back to that whole how AI and AI chat bot busted CAPTCHA, right? You know, that we talked about before, you know, they couldn't figure out or they, right? The model couldn't figure out, you know, how to actually do it, but it convinced a human to help, you know, to help the model do it. yeah, very, that's the thing. It's like, there's gonna be a lot of pseudo humanity kind of emerging out of this and figuring out is that pseudo humanity or is that real humanity? That's pretty
Mark Fielding Well, that's the problem with the emotional AI that everyone's speaking about now, aren't they? And this threat I mentioned at beginning of AI Boyfriends and AI Girlfriends and this reliance on something that... I mean, here's a question for you. Does it matter? Does it matter if you think that this one of your AIs is conscious? mean, do most people think, is this conscious? I mean, it doesn't really matter, does it? I mean...
It's the matrix, isn't it? If it looks like a rose and it, if it looks like a steak and it tastes like a steak then, yeah. Might as well be a steak.
Does it matter?
Jeremy Gilbertson Wow, yeah, I think the does it matter part to me is if it slowly erodes what it means for us to be human. That's the alarm button for me. In our sub stack this week, we posted that people are actually using AI right now to break up with their boyfriends and girlfriends, which part of part of being a human is having the ability to figure out how to navigate difficult situations, right? And if we don't navigate that, that requires empathy, right? If it's done the right way, it requires a little empathy. It requires kind of a, I don't know, like a softer touch a little bit than just brute force kind of thing. And if we just keep hitting these damn easy buttons,
Sure, yeah, it's gonna be easy. I can just send this note over text. Well, people are texting to break up too. We don't have conversations anymore. And there's the old guy in me. This is the gray beard coming out. But hey, I think we should still have human conversations. And that's what scares me with all of this stuff.
Mark Fielding Yeah, but okay, so the next generation's don't.
Again, the question still stands. if they're, I mean, does it, does it matter if if, if it's a cultural norm to, to break up by AI, to use AI to design your life. mean, Altman was talking about these three layers of how people are using AIs and we fall into the oldest bracket, which was like 40 and plus 40 plus is the oldest bracket. And they, this population use AI essentially to replace Google. And then you have the stage below that, which use AI in a more varied way, and then the youngest people who use it to design their lives, and they use it for everything. And if it's a cultural norm to do everything like that, then who are we to say, you know, it's wrong, bring back the analog world?
Jeremy Gilbertson Man, I find it hard to believe that we're like, and please dump something in these comments and convince us otherwise, but I find it hard to believe like that we're this same version of our parents when MTV first came out and you know, MTV, we're staring at MTV like, that's going to melt your face and you know, it's going to turn you into a loser and all of this. That's the one thing. Do you know how much different what we're dealing with now?
Mark Fielding Well, yeah, that's when people, as we learned in our last book, Nexus by Noah Yuhara, you can't compare AI to the printing press. You can't compare AI to these other technologies that have come before it because it is fundamentally very different. I still think that we're like listening to classical music and those under 20 are like listening to punk and grunge and we're just sitting in our rocking chair going, right, it's not like it used to be.
Jeremy Gilbertson I'm, I'm, I...
The most perplexing problem
Mark Fielding Consciousness represents the most perplexing problem for the science of mind. There is nothing that is not known more intimately than conscious experience and yet nothing that is more difficult to explain. David Chalmers, the hard problem of consciousness.
Jeremy Gilbertson Mm-hmm. Well, let's talk about the idea of consciousness as an irreducible property of fundamental particles. So I did invite Anika Harris multiple times to the show. Hopefully she'll come hang out with the trippy kids at some point. like her audio book, audio documentary, Lights On, that's the main thesis there too, is that consciousness is fundamental.
Jeremy Gilbertson She doesn't outright prove it, right? But she's on this track to figure it out.
Huxley, and the Doors of Perception
Mark Fielding Old Dutch Huxley said that 60 years ago in the Doors of Perception.
Jeremy Gilbertson Man, so if we could have him on the show, that would be even better. See if we can figure that out.
Mark Fielding Well, we can just bring him back as an AI embodied virtual twin.
Jeremy Gilbertson hey, we're talking to some companies actually that are doing that very successfully. all right, aside from that, so consciousness, this idea of being a piece and part of fundamental particles and not a result of particle interaction, I think that's an important thing, right? And that's the main difference. A lot of people have different theories about it. But I wanna talk about interiority. It's a really interesting word that comes up in this chapter quite a bit.
And I want to ask you a question Mark. If there is an influence from the outside in, from the world in, how come there isn't an influence from the inside out? And if not, what's the point of interiority?
Jeremy Gilbertson He taught, so he teased this out a little bit. I rephrased it into a question. But I think that's the idea that a lot of us are missing. We're conditioned to operate in this Newtonian world, right? And this goes back, I think there are lot of references to Newtonian physics and quantum mechanics as we understand consciousness, right? Because we believe all of these things around us are like, you know, hard and like physical where they're just things moving really, really slowly to give us the impression of that. Right? So our brains already in this process of trying to, you know, we understand the world in this way because we move around in it this way. But you know, to understand consciousness, you almost have to think quantum because a lot of the stuff is counter to what we think the world is to understand consciousness. I think you need to think more quantum.
Mark Fielding I agree. Just give me a sec, because I to add to what you just said.
Jeremy Gilbertson While you're looking for it, tagging on to what I just said, so he talks about inner reality, which is the same thing as interiority in my mind, is the same space that our dreams exist. How about that?
Mark Fielding to read from the doors of perception because he's just, it's just like, he's just taking, it's already been said, like almost like exactly the same way, only he's, he hookily explains it much better and he's tripping on mescaline at the time so you know that's maybe about the thing but he describes consciousness and he just he talks about this disintegration of time and disintegration of space exactly as
Jeremy Gilbertson Hey, the Dharma Bums are back, man. Let's go.
The alternative
Mark Fielding Federico Faggin. The alternative is to consider that physical laws may be emergent properties of consciousness, an assumption that is hard for most scientists to accept. It would mean that the objective world derives from the subjective world and that's asking too much. Accepting panpsychism implies that inner reality has a direct impact on outer reality. And in my notes I've written connect to quantum but I don't know how.
Like, when I was reading it and I kept reading it and my brain kept jumping like you did to this quantum idea of superposition and the collapse of the wave and how that doesn't come a reality until it is measured, observed, interacted with by something else. And I don't know how to link that thought to what he says here about emergent properties of consciousness and assumption that hard, that physical laws may be emergent properties of consciousness.
the wave collapse causes whatever probability, and I know I'm not describing this very well, but to become a reality in the same way, why can't our consciousness?
Mark Fielding cause the physical realities to come into existence. There's a link there, I can't explain it very well, but that's I was thinking, somehow.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, I think it's really interesting, man. When you first brought up this Dharma Bums are back kind of thing, you know, we're seeing now, you know, the many, we're going quantum again, many worlds theory, you know, many worlds, even string theory, like all of these different worlds operating at the same relative time to us in space. You have, know, Kerouac and Huxley in the back going, yo, guys.
We are on this already. Like, where have you been? Like, I think it's really... and I can't wait to... We are gonna do a Dharma Bums are back series on all of this stuff, Mark. I think it's a great idea. There is a link to...
Mark Fielding Made the world wasn't ready, now the world is ready and maybe the world is ready and also much more easily accessible via social media.
Jeremy Gilbertson Fair enough, fair enough. Well, let's park that one for our Dharma Bums are back episode. A couple quick things that I want to run down that are really interesting that kind of came out more tangibly to this is so organizing and pattern recognition in the brain are separate from consciousness according to our host and author. And I tend to believe that. And consciousness being kind of a supervisor.
How a machine recognises a cup
Jeremy Gilbertson of the activities, right? So, you know, as you're driving down the road, right, we did this reference before, you know, there are mechanical things happening, right, but your consciousness is like observing and helping you react to all of these things. So pointing back to another old book, you know, or a bunch of books, Buckminster Fuller's idea of the phantom captain, right, is this idea of the captain of what's happening.
you know, for you and your life and all that is that consciousness is a supervisor, right? So I think that's, I think that's a really interesting way to put it, but the idea of true intelligence, he starts talking about that coming from consciousness, true and real intelligence coming from consciousness and it requires conscious comprehension. So what, did you get from comprehension in this? Cause he talked about that a lot as being kind of a key cog in
Mark Fielding Example on how a machine recognises a cup compared to how we recognise a cup explains it very, very well. An example of a machine learning is when we teach a computer to recognise a cup from its visual image. To learn that task it is necessary to have a representative sample of cup images called the training set and a program performing the simulation of a properly structured artificial neural network that automatically finds a hierarchy of common traits.
that are present in all the CUPs that are part of the training set. When the program has learned the correlations existing in the many images whose name is CUP, it may also recognize a CUP in an image that was not part of the training set. At this point, it seems that the neural network understands what a CUP is, even though the CUP is only another symbol, not the conscious experience that it is for us. This ability to generalize is good and necessary, yet the program still cannot comprehend what CUP means.
Jeremy Gilbertson You know where that sent me when I read that and I kind of went back on my notes, the idea of like, okay, you train these models, right? Here's a cup, this is a cup, all these examples of a cup, but you know, that model will never be able to really understand the meaning of a cup, right? And how it interacts and all of that, can define it, it can see it, right? But I started thinking about like, why haven't we heard more about
And maybe, maybe it's out there. I just haven't heard of it. Why haven't we heard more about people training models to screw them up? Like to, to, all it's almost like, stay with me here. This is going to be weird. So it's almost like, it's almost like psychedelics for AI models to generate, to purposely generate hallucinations. Are people out there like effing with models and the training data to, to generate hallucinations?
and is a hallucination incorrect or is a hallucination kind of an enlightened understanding or comprehension? That's crazy. Boom. But that's where I...
Mark Fielding I think that there are people out there messing around with them and doing all kinds of crazy shit. So in our last show, we spoke to a very smart guy about the business case for AI and he made a lot of sense and I thought he was very good. The one point that I didn't agree with him was that, that hallucination is creativity. I had a problem with that and...
I think that's... does a disservice to creativity.
Right and wrong
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, here, let's simplify it, right? Let's simplify it. So objective, let's simplify it to like an objective arithmetic, right? So one plus one equals two. You train a model to understand that's what that is. And then all of a sudden you convince a model to say one plus one is three. You know, is that a creative endeavor or is that just messing up something that is objective fact, right?
Mark Fielding Wrong is wrong, can't be 30 % wrong in something like that, it's wrong.
Jeremy Gilbertson but who says what is right and what is wrong, right? So creativity is breaking rules a little bit too, right? I'm just pushing back. I agree with you, but I'm just pushing back.
Mark Fielding Intentionally intentionally breaking rule actually although a lot of lot of creativity comes from accidents or the great advancements of the world have all come by accident so maybe yeah maybe that's the AI is hallucinating to try because it knows that by hallucinating it could just serendipitously create something which might change the world like penicillin
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, or beer. Who left some, who left some, you know, cereal in the corner, you know, for three months and decided to drink it. Like what, what in the world, right? That's anyway, I digress comprehension and, comprehension and perception. Let's talk about that a little bit, right? you know,
Comprehension
Mark Fielding Comprehension is the process that adds new meaning to our experience and skillfully integrates it with the previous meaning.
Jeremy Gilbertson but he says requires a greater capacity for generalization than machines can handle. What do think he meant by that?
Mark Fielding I think it goes back to what I said at the start about empathy and curiosity and the lack of qualia, that the only reason that comprehension adds new meaning to our experience is because that we can connect it to all those emotions, to all those qualia that have come before and a machine, an algorithm, an AI, whatever you want to call it, can't.
Jeremy Gilbertson Mm-hmm. Yep.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, so, alright.
Mark Fielding Let's keep banging that drum. Keep banging that drum. Yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson No, I get it, I get it. All right, so conscious perception is, think the way I understand it is this conversion of electrochemical, inputs into qualia, right? This objective into subjective. As I understand what our host and author talks about conscious perception, but comprehension is different, right? Comprehension is literally what we're doing. Comprehension is thinking on paper.
comprehension is connecting the dots. It's taking something new, connecting it to something old and, but don't, don't models do that though?
Mark Fielding Yeah, but not via koala. They do it by patterns, don't they? So it's the same thread that keeps coming through in this that they can, they know it's rose, they know the smell, but they don't connect it to the koala, to the emotion. So yes, but no, they don't have that. Yeah, pseudo humanity.
Jeremy Gilbertson So pseudo humanity, let's coin the phrase pseudo humanity. All right, you heard it first, I'm thinking on paper when AI models try to convince you that they're human, but they're actually not.
Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, nature of consciousness. I'm trying to think about, I'm gonna read something here that I thought was really cool. Back to true intelligence, all right? So remember, true intelligence requires comprehension. Comprehension is connecting moments of qualia for humans, In which links memories, which links experience to new information. It's a synthesis of understanding, right?
True intelligence
Jeremy Gilbertson True intelligence is intuition, imagination, creativity, ingenuity, and inventiveness. is foresight, vision, and wisdom. It is empathy, compassion, ethics, and love. It is the integration of the intuitive mind, the empathetic heart, and courageous action. In other words, true intelligence is not separable from the other properties that make us human and that require consciousness and free will. It's the ability to comprehend and make unexpected, creative, and ethical decisions, machines will never be able to do those things.
Mark Fielding Is that a definition of true intelligence or is that a definition of what it means to be human? Is that a definition of consciousness? Because semantics is intelligence without consciousness, true intelligence. mean, it depends, like, if I agree or not with that definition of true intelligence. I go back to my opening gambit that...
Don't think it matters how you define true intelligence. They can be... Okay, let's rewind that. Everything you just said, I think, defines consciousness, what it means to be human, not true intelligence because...
true intelligence and what it means to be human are not the same thing. Why would they be? How could they be? think that AIs can be truly intelligent. This notion of super intelligence, I like that. They can become that, but they can't become conscious human form.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, think about emotional intelligence, right? That's why like empathy and compassion and all of those things fold into the equation, right? Emotional intelligence is one of those, and I hate the categorization of it as a soft skill. It's like one of our most important skills, right? In interacting as humans. So I think when I look at that, it's an encompassing of understanding.
information, connecting the dots, that sort of thing, but also sprinkling in those human elements of it. So I think the true intelligence nature folds in the emotional intelligence side of the fence. That's how I think about it anyway.
The dangers of semantics
Mark Fielding semantics. We must be especially mindful about the dangers posed by the human abuse of computer technology, especially AI, which will bring to the fore new dangers that are difficult to predict and avoid. There is no doubt that the greatest danger is represented by the desire for power, domination, possession and superiority that dulls human consciousness.
Jeremy Gilbertson So as we move into part two of this book, I'm gonna leave you with a quote as the bridge from Cicero. If you remove consciousness, everything else is nothing for man.
Mark Fielding So don't remove your consciousness disruptors and curious minds. Plug in your consciousness. We are, we find ourselves once again on a Friday evening with the nature in full bloom outside and you with time on your hands. I'm gonna read.
Mark Fielding close this with a different book. Hold on.
Jeremy Gilbertson Dharma Bums are back.
Mark Fielding Is this from heaven and hell or is this...
Jeremy Gilbertson Good thing we can edit these, right?
Jeremy Gilbertson We should write a paper on the Dharma Bums are back on that theory, and pitch it as a, pitch it as like a research paper, like write it as an app, write it like as what Paki McCormick did, like write it as an abstract, make it, make it appear as like a white paper. I think that could be.
Mark Fielding and you can just take quotes, take bits from bits and compare it. This is what they said in the 1960s. This is what they're saying today. Notice the similarities. You are conscious. Go outside and wield your consciousness. Be curious. Be courageous. Be brave. Be inquisitive. Be caring. Be loving. Be all of the things that make you different to the machines that you are increasingly relying upon.
Jeremy Gilbertson Keep thinking on paper.
Jeremy Gilbertson All right, dude, good stuff,




