What Is AI Doing Inside Schools?

In a three day workshop at two state funded schools in Scotland, children aged nine to 11 described what making art with AI felt like. I like to feel the droplets of paint on my artwork.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 15 chapters

  1. Coming at it as parents
  2. The upside, and the framework
  3. The Turing survey
  4. The main use cases
  5. Private schools and state schools
  6. What teachers report
  7. Great for me, but not for them
  8. The framework
  9. What the children said
  10. Physical materials
  11. The awareness of the children
  12. The biggest surprise
  13. The recommendations
  14. The shortcut button
  15. Equitable access

We read the Alan Turing Institute's study of generative AI and children as parents of kids in its target age range. The survey found 58% of private school children aged eight to 12 had used AI, against 18% in state schools.

The children worried about stereotyped images and the water AI uses, and some preferred paint and paper. Jeremy raises a concern about children with learning difficulties leaning on AI as a confidant, and we test the report's recommendations, including equitable access.

The Alan Turing Institute's study of generative AI and children surveyed 780 UK children aged 8 to 12, their parents and 1,001 teachers, and ran workshops with 40 children aged 9 to 11 in two Scottish state schools. Reading it on the Thinking On Paper podcast, Mark Fielding and Jeremy Gilbertson, both parents, look at how children use ChatGPT and the gap between private and state schools.

Which AI tool do children use most, and what for?

ChatGPT is the generative AI tool children use most, and their main uses are “creating fun pictures, finding information and entertainment”, the hosts report. Mark singles out the gap between private and state schools, where only 18 per cent of eight to 12 year olds say they have used AI, and puts it down to parents: “10 year olds aren't using AI unless their parents are”.

How do teachers feel about using AI?

Teachers use AI while worrying about what it does to their pupils. Mark reads that two thirds of teachers use AI themselves and 72 per cent worry about it, including its effect on pupils' critical thinking, and the hosts note that 85 per cent of teachers say it increases their productivity. Jeremy sums up the attitude as “this is great for me, but I don't want you to mess with it”.

Do children prefer making art by hand or with AI?

Many children in the Scottish workshops preferred making art by hand, Mark says, enjoying “physically creating artworks and using more tactile means”, though one said they were jealous of AI because it was better than them at art. Jeremy picks out the finding that children chatted with classmates while using traditional materials, but locked into the device when using AI.

What did children say about AI bias and water use?

The children raised bias and environmental cost themselves. One complained that the image tool “only came up with an image of a white person and it would not change”, and Mark says some children did not want to use AI once they learned of its environmental impact; one wrote “it is ridiculous that it uses so much water”.

What framework does the Alan Turing Institute study use to judge AI?

The study judges AI against the Responsible Innovation in Technology for Children framework, whose eight factors include safety and security, autonomy, creativity, and relationships. Of the report's recommendations, Mark calls involving children in designing child-friendly AI an inspired one, and he warns that without equitable access, the fifth recommendation, the gap between haves and have-nots is “a snowball and it's gathering speed”.

Where Mark and Jeremy disagree

Mark questions whether the children's sharpest lines are their own: “Did a 10 year old really say that or they just parroting what their parents have said?” Jeremy replies that copying is how people learn, like learning other people's songs on guitar. Jeremy also worries that children with learning difficulties, who used AI more, lean on it as a friend when they need more human time.

Questions

Who did the Alan Turing Institute study of AI and children survey?

The Alan Turing Institute's study of generative AI and children surveyed 780 UK children aged 8 to 12, their parents and 1,001 teachers, and ran workshops with 40 children aged 9 to 11 in two Scottish state schools.

How many private and state school children have used AI?

The survey found 58% of private school children aged eight to 12 had used AI, against 18% in state schools.

Do children with learning difficulties use AI more?

Jeremy also worries that children with learning difficulties, who used AI more, lean on it as a friend when they need more human time.

Transcript

Mark Fielding Disruptors and curious minds, I'm talking to you. If you have children between the ages of one and 18, if you're thinking of having children, if you know somebody with children, listen up. This is for you. We're talking about the impact AI on kids how they've been used in schools.

the teachers are using AI, how the teachers and the students together are using AI. We're reading the Alan Turing Institute on the impacts of generative AI on children. There was the biggest...

Questionnaire, I think that's ever been done on children's use of AI, There was a three day workshop where kids were exposed to AI. They used AI in conjunction with their teachers to get to the root of their feelings, their opinions. there's some very insightful recommendations for parents, for teachers, for policymakers. and some very interesting insights into how children are using AI today, Jeremy.

where do you stand on all this? What do you feel about the use of AI by kids in schools before we get into the paper?

Coming at it as parents

Jeremy Gilbertson I've got four kids, Mark, you have two kids, mine go all the way up from in college down to, down to sixth Mark, yours are how old?

Mark Fielding My kids are nine and six, so they fall right into the bullseye of this paper that we're gonna break down.

Jeremy Gilbertson Totally, yeah, so we're coming from the parent side as well on this. I started thinking about this study that the closest platform or the closest technological comparison to AI, not saying it's the same thing, but it's a similar thing that came out that affects a generation a certain way. I think about social media, and...

what that's doing or what that has done to kids, AI, generative AI in particular can be more, potentially be more helpful.

than social media, but also can, on the flip side, be, man, maybe even more

The upside, and the framework

Mark Fielding upside is astronomical. There just has to be a framework. There has to be a structure of how kids and adults, but today we're talking about to use it and are exposed to it and behave with it. Before you get going, I just want to leave a couple of questions for our listeners as we're talking through this paper, as you're thinking about what we're speaking and thinking about. What is...

a healthy AI relationship between children and AI. My daughter is nine. What should she be doing with AI in her school, if anything? And with that in mind, let's get going. So the paper is based into two different reports. One a survey of 780 children between the ages of eight and 12 and their parents and 1001, who was that lucky one, 1001 teachers with kids in primary school or secondary school. And I point out that this survey was in the UK. and...

Jeremy Gilbertson kids in primary or secondary, but teachers teaching kids in primary or secondary. Yeah, yeah.

Mark Fielding Teachers, teachers, yes, good, good, important to notice that difference. And the second report was with 40 children between the ages of nine and 11 in two state funded schools in Scotland. And that was it, which we'll get into that after the first one. And that was a three day workshop with less kids, but that was more about the feelings, the emotions, the children's opinions on AI and there's some very insightful, very interesting, very powerful quotes from some of the kids, which we'll read later. But yeah, first the survey.

The Turing survey

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, the survey. again, this was study through the Alan Turing Institute was funded or partially funded by Lego, which pretty interesting, OGs of analog play, the OGs of IRL play and creativity. thought that was cool that they're supporting this.

Jeremy Gilbertson I don't know if this is unfortunate news or not, but just given what we're learning about chat GPT and open AI, the number one tool being used by kids is actually chat GPT. How do you feel about that one?

Mark Fielding I'm not surprised. was surprised, which is because of my age, that one of the second, I think it Snapchat AI was up there as well. Snapchat AI. So yeah, I wasn't surprised by chat GPT.

Jeremy Gilbertson Snapchat, think, yeah, yeah.

Snapchat's pretty big, I've resisted it, but my my wife actually got it and has this nice communication channel with our kids. Not saying it's only through Snapchat, we do. We go out of our way to generate or try to orchestrate real life moments and.

and stuff, but she now snaps them. I mean, it's a big part of their world. so we know chat GPT is the most popular tool, How are they using it? What did the study find? How are they using it?

The main use cases

Mark Fielding main use cases were quote, creating fun pictures, finding information and entertainment in that order. I've got a few key results from the paper. I'm just gonna fire bomb them out there just so we can know. 55 % of households in the UK use AI.

25 % of eight to 12 year olds have used AI. 58 % of eight to 12 year olds in private school have said that they've used.

AI, only 18 % in state schools. So obviously there's a lot to read into that, which we'll get to. 76 % of parents are positive. 72 % of teachers worry about AI. 50 % of teachers report students submitting work done by AI. And two thirds of teachers use AI themselves. So there's a lot going on. It's there. It's very prevalent.

Private schools and state schools

Jeremy Gilbertson I don't know much about the the gap between private schools and in public schools in the uk is it Is it different than in the states

Mark Fielding that statistic 58 % of private school kids between the ages of eight and 12 have said they've used generative AI, but only 18 % at state school. I think that statistic gives you a very good window in the difference between state and private schools in the big.

Mark Fielding And if 58 % of them are using AI already and only 18 % aren't the haves and the have not, which we speak about a lot on thinking on paper, not just in AI, but all technologies about this balance of power is already So some of the recommendations that they get will get into later involve trying to close that gap.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah. mean, it's.

Yeah, it just accelerates like technology does it accelerates the what's what's already happening happening from an analog perspective.

Mark Fielding got question for you then as an American, I'm sure it's probably the same in other countries. kids in private schools three times more likely at the age of 12 to have used AI?

Jeremy Gilbertson I don't know. I don't know what to think about that.

Mark Fielding come on. It's the parents, it's socioeconomic backgrounds and the parents. 10 year olds aren't using AI unless their parents are A, using it and B, allowing them to use it. So the parents at these schools are using AI more and that they're letting their kids use it.

Jeremy Gilbertson yeah, it's familiarity, I guess. If talk about XYZ, you're gonna be more familiar with XYZ. If they have a good opinion about XYZ, you're likely gonna have a good opinion about XYZ until you can form your own opinion through experiences, I guess.

Mark Fielding That's interesting.

Do you think wealthy people care more about speaking about artificial intelligence and technology in general than people from less wealthy economic backgrounds? Just to put you on the spot, Jeremy.

Jeremy Gilbertson Don't know. wouldn't say I'm in the upper 1 % of wealth The wealth echelon by any stretch of the imagination

Mark Fielding Yeah, because if you were, there's something you're not telling me, but yeah.

Jeremy Gilbertson No, I'm definitely not, but like I'm very deep into my awareness of technology and as you are as well. So I mean, there are people like us, there are curious individuals, are maybe, I don't know, people with better access to understanding what the hell these things are. Maybe they work for companies that are already implementing some of those things.

Mark Fielding if your company pays for your chat GPT subscription, or you're using your personal account, let us know. We would like to know what people are using.

What teachers report

Jeremy Gilbertson and why? Yeah. all right. let's talk a bit more about some of the other things we think about with, AI. are kids using it to cheat on their homework?

Mark Fielding % of teachers have reported that, that they've seen a homework submitted by AI. 50 over exaggerated or under exaggerated? Is there some slipping through the net? I think there's some slipping through the net. I think it's.

Jeremy Gilbertson Probably so, but 85

85% of teachers are showing that it increases their productivity on what they're doing. it's about becoming more efficient at what you're doing. And the whole discussion.

Mark Fielding teachers were also worried about some of the impacts that it could have on the children in their classes' critical thinking.

on the one hand, they're using it themselves and they say that it's going to increase their productivity. On the other hand, they've seen kids cheating. They're worried about it taking their critical thinking. There's this imbalance between their opinions.

Great for me, but not for them

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, it's like, it's, is, this is great for me, but I don't want you to mess with it I would love to see being taught in schools and I don't know if it is or it isn't, but the, the, productive approach to using AI instead of it being this easy button, this way to offload critical thinking. How about the way to, exponentially catalyze rabbit holes.

of curiosity, And really help you get to the things that you want to find quicker. But you're still synthesizing, you're still generating the questions,

Mark Fielding That would be great. That implies that AI has already been taught in school. And as we learned last week, okay, in China it is, in India it soon will be. As far as I'm aware, well, my kids don't learn about it at school. I don't know if yours actually learn about it in school at all.

Jeremy Gilbertson is it, is it the what, the why, or the how? Like is it what AI is? Is it how do you use AI? is it, what does it say, what, why or how? Yeah, the why piece of it.

Mark Fielding when you're eight, it's all three of those things, isn't it?

The framework

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, you're probably right. this RITEC framework? This is the first I've ever heard of that. It's basically the responsible innovation in technology for children framework that is... Is that part of UNICEF or is that... Where did that framework come out of? That's been used before to evaluate technologies,

Mark Fielding So there's eight factors in that framework, safety and security, autonomy, diversity, equity and inclusion, competence, identities, creativity, relationships and emotions. Ticks a lot of boxes. that framework exists. So for other technologies in this report, they're using that framework for AI, generative AI technologies,

Without thinking too deeply, I don't think anything's missing from that. Can you? What's missing off that list, if anything?

What the children said

Jeremy Gilbertson I'd like to spend a little time kind of talking through some of these that stood out to me as it relates to AI use, AI concerns, one that really, really stood out to me is So quote in this chart here, when children work with traditional art materials, they generally did so while chatting with their classmates.

more engaged in what's around them physically. If they're doing something that's outside a computer and if they're, if they're locked into doing something on a computer, they're locked into the computer or the device or whatever it is versus engaging with their peers. And that, that gave me a little pause. What did you think about that piece of it?

Mark Fielding The kids were divided, weren't they? was some of them really enjoyed how it helped them with their creativity in their art. Some of them resented it. One of them said they were jealous of AI because it was better than them at art.

Let just bring up some of the quotes on the art section from the kids.

Jeremy Gilbertson that's kind of tough to hear right off the bat,

Physical materials

Mark Fielding children often stated that they enjoy the experience of physically creating artworks and using more tactile means, which is what you said. I like to feel the droplets of paint on my art brush. I like coloring and sticking things on myself. I did not like using AI. I liked making crafts without generative AI. I like doing art a bit more. I prefer doing things physically. I don't want to use a laptop. The experience feels a lot better when you're physically doing it.

I felt art materials were better, slower, but it ended up what you want it to be. And then some very powerful quotes and insights from the kids, which you would expect to come from adults. And you've probably heard adults saying a lot of these. AI can create an image that gets quite close to your imagination, but it never really gets there. No, AI is too easy. AI is like cheating.

Then another one I do not like drawing so much, so I'm quite happy about the output the generative AI created of me.

it can make a lot of stereotypes around people. So it is generating all men, all white. They all look exactly the same. It only came up with an image of a white person and it would not change. made, it made me feel annoyed and sad. The images need to be more diverse. Generative AI needs to be less bias.

if you don't have kids, they're very smart. They're much, much more tuned in than we often give them credit for. kids in this survey were very concerned about the environmental impact of AI straight away as soon as they became aware of that to the point where some of them didn't want to use it. Quote, it is ridiculous that it uses so much water.

Quote, I think people should use it less if it has the impact that it has on the environment. Quote, guilty because it is so bad for the environment. They're aware of that. They speak about the trust layer. They say, the AI made it, it's not me. Sometimes it works okay. Sometimes it doesn't do what I asked it for.

This could affect you because you wouldn't know the real thing. So nods to conscious AI, seemingly conscious AI.

The awareness of the children

Jeremy Gilbertson Definitely encouraged by the awareness of these children of the bigger picture. And I think it's largely because they're unencumbered by the bullshit that...

Jeremy Gilbertson turns our thinking into path A or path B, you get hardened in your beliefs. You get less open-minded by relying on shortcuts over time. You just, you find yourself in this, in this one group versus this other group, no matter if you share some characteristics of the other group, the easy button is to go into one group and that stuff.

solidifies it calcifies and and it's very hard to change when you get old and they don't have that they're not they're not encumbered by that they're they're free from it and like Pablo Pablo Picasso said every kid's an artist until it you know gets pushed out of us I'm loosely loosely framing that but man can AI help kids stay kids?

Mark Fielding all of these are real quotes from nine and 11 year olds in the survey. And they wrote them all down on pieces of paper so you can see them in the documents. on chat bots. They were saying, quote, computers don't have any feelings. Why would you talk to them? No privacy in AI chat. Anyone could look at that.

Mark Fielding I think that people who make generative AI should do something to protect it somehow. They speak about misinformation, disinformation, fake news on fake news. A nine year old said misinformation could be fake news. When people start using AI, they could use it for their own purposes by making fake information and putting it online to make money. And I want to stop on that one. And before we move on to the recommendations from the Institute on what we should be doing.

Did a 10 year old really say that or they just parroting what their parents have said? That sounds like me. That sounds like my kids have gone to school and said exactly what the parents are saying and

That's very important. And I think that goes back to the private school and the public school usage. I think it goes to how confident children are, how confident teachers are, how worried parents are mirrors how worried the kids are.

Jeremy Gilbertson part of learning, Here we go, Jeremy, with his musical reference again, but how do we learn how to play guitar? We learn other people's songs, And we learn to perform those songs and play those songs, but then we get our own ideas from that. So I think whether it's a parroting, I think it's a parroting of important messages, so good job, parents.

of those kids to get them thinking in such a way. OpenAI is always talking about needing a refresh of their board. Maybe they get some damn kids on it and get them on the right track.

The biggest surprise

Mark Fielding so recommendations from the survey the biggest surprise for me was exactly that to get the kids involved in the development, the ideation, the if kids are going to be using these tools to augment their thinking, they have to be child friendly. should, there should be child versions of chat GPT, there should be chat GPT 456 and junior or whatever it is and the kids should be involved in developing and designing those and I thought that was inspired recommendation because a lot of the other recommendations were very obvious and wrote and I didn't really see anything new there.

Jeremy Gilbertson The one thing I wanted to touch on was, let me see if I can find it. There was a stat in here about...

use of AI related to those with, I don't know how they phrase it, not learning disabilities, but learning difficulties.

Mark Fielding learning difficulties, yeah, they were using it a lot more than the kids who didn't have learning difficulties, makes sense.

Jeremy Gilbertson the thing that I thought about with that is survey pointed to those particular individuals leaning on that more as a friend, as someone that can be a confidant for them as they're trying to figure things out. I got a little scared with that. I got a little sad about that because those with difficulties, learning, making friends and that sort of thing. Those are the people that need more human time to help them figure it out. But.

I think people will lean on an easy button of like, we'll just let the kid use this thing to solve that harder part of life. And then they get into this loop of, oh man, is this thing conscious? Is this thing my friend? and you get down that whole rabbit hole. So I think it's important to call that out and make that not be an easy button.

for the path of some of these kids that actually need more attention. I understand that certain cases, and maybe there's a supervision thing that can happen with that, but I don't know, that freaked me out a little bit.

Mark Fielding I you're right to be a little bit worried and concerned about that. Again, as seems to be the case with all of the AI talk, room for good, room for bad.

The recommendations

Mark Fielding So recommendations, the project outlines about eight recommendations for parents, teachers, policymakers. Number one, promote child-centered AI and children's participation, which is what we just alluded to. not sure what that would look like.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah. And it's also with these recommendations, who's going to do it? Like who's going to take the hard job of doing it? You know, because remember open AI gonna get a load of kids into their boardroom like you said and beat out a humane chat bot for the kids.

Jeremy Gilbertson This is all out. This is all outside in approach, Rather than, rather than inside out. Cause inside out the race is more GPUs get to AGI, the fastest,

Mark Fielding so what is easier is develop age appropriate generative AI tools. That would be something that the big AI firms could do and they could do it pretty easily. much more limited data, data sets, are child content, I mean, there wouldn't be a lot of money in it, would there?

wouldn't be, or there could be, they could monetise it if it went into the schools so that it could be a money spinner.

Jeremy Gilbertson But not a big one, so it's not a profit-driven thing. It's a humanity-driven thing, So it's the equations. The equations need different symbols, support offline and online, you like this one? I like this one. So when advancing AI develop approaches with support, which support wider infrastructure simultaneously ensuring generative AI adds value alongside, not instead of more tactile materials and approaches.

Jeremy Gilbertson I love that and what that could look like is if you're engaged on a chat bot platform after a while, maybe it's go outside, touch grass, get out in the sunshine. It'd be nice if social media stuff would have that as well and just be like, close the curtain, whew, and you have to go outside now. I diverting our...

Jeremy Gilbertson tangible takeaways.

one of the kids they quoted this and I've written here, shape AI by environment and context, not everything can be improved and made better with an AI hammer. and I think there is a, I've got to stop saying I think, there is a.

The shortcut button

Mark Fielding You call it the shortcut button. People just want to solve all their problems with AI. AI is the solution to all of these challenges and all of these creative endeavors. And it's not, but there is this knee-jerk reaction to make it so. And I like this idea of building alongside that. But again, might that look like at home or at school?

Jeremy Gilbertson I think we could improve, let's improve literacy in general. would, would help, would help that cause.

Mark Fielding You asked this question earlier, how do we improve literacy in general and AI literacy? And how do you push that out to all of the millions of schools in the world?

Jeremy Gilbertson Man, schools are systems that are very tough to integrate new stuff into.

if we just look at it from our particular local perspective, it's really difficult to get new information into old structures like that. trying to figure out how to do that would be step one.

just in general and then figure out the message of how do you improve AI literacy into that model? it's a step one before step two,

Mark Fielding one of the big statistics in this was 80 % of teachers are using AI, but 70 % of those use their personal accounts because the schools don't have, the schools aren't giving them access to AI yet. And so.

Jeremy Gilbertson I think that's a risk

Equitable access

Mark Fielding number five on the list of recommendations is equitable access. And so perhaps equitable access doesn't just mean for schools, it means for business and society at large. Are all of the smaller, less financially viable corporations not having their subscriptions? Are charities not having subscriptions? Schools aren't having subscriptions and the only people having subscriptions are the big tech companies or the big commerce platforms, big banks.

the haves and have nots everywhere, everywhere,

It's a snowball and it's gathering speed and a lot of these recommendations and lot of these statistics are, I don't want to say set in stone, but I fear that if we came back, when we come back in a few years, that the numbers will have grown, but the disparances will remain.

Jeremy Gilbertson The gaps are the gaps.

Mark Fielding the gaps are the gaps, then the gaps will remain the gaps.

policymakers and maybe some people in UK government in the Education Department of the UK government have read this and are acting on this and are doing something with this with the boards of teacher boards and hopefully acting on it and making AI more equitable, fairer, more distributed and a nicer experience for the kids who are going to be using it in school because they are going to be using it.

Jeremy Gilbertson What other papers, guys?

Yes, what other papers do we need to read and research and unpack? What do you not wanna read that you wanna hear us talk about? We'd love you to read it because that's how you make it happen and you can even write about it. It's called Thinking on Paper, but if you wanna listen to us do it. We're gonna do it anyway because we like to understand this stuff. So put something in the comments, let us know what to tackle next. Empire of AI, we're still unpacking it. We got one more part to do in that series. Stay tuned there.

Got some great guests coming up. Closing thoughts, Mark, before we get out of here.

Mark Fielding We are tech agnostic. We speak about AI. We talk about space. We talk about quantum computing, robotics, human or bioengineering. Doesn't matter what it is. If you've got a paper, if you've got an idea, if you've got a conversation, put it in the chat and we'll spend some time thinking on paper about it. Thank you for joining us. Check out thinkingonpaper.xyz and we'll see you next time. Be curious, stay disruptive.

Jeremy Gilbertson Keep thinking on paper.