What Changes When Stories Become Spatial?

Michael Guerin's company tells augmented reality stories at Spike Island, which he calls Ireland's version of Alcatraz. It was a prison and a military fort for a couple of hundred years, right the way up to 2004.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 16 chapters

  1. What changed since Pokemon Go
  2. Where the uses actually are
  3. Why does the world need more AR?
  4. How people communicate outside work
  5. Walgreens
  6. Defining digital storytelling
  7. The word immersive
  8. Mark's summer experience
  9. A really good tour guide
  10. The guards room
  11. What else you need to get right
  12. The Holocaust Museum
  13. Zuckerberg, and the glasses
  14. The Wayfarers
  15. Ivan Sutherland
  16. Closing
You could stand in the middle of London or any city in the world and something happened here in 1502 and 1657 and 1727.
Michael Guerin

Michael Guerin builds augmented reality stories for tourist attractions and for tech companies, including new-starter onboarding at Salesforce. He says Snapchat alone sees 8 billion uses of augmented reality a day, though it is almost never called augmented reality.

At Spike Island, visitors hold up a phone in a punishment cell and find a prisoner chained to the wall. Guerin explains why his team plans the space first and writes the narrative last. “It's so incredibly powerful if it's done right.”

Michael Guerin, founder and CEO of Imvizar, argues on the Thinking On Paper podcast that augmented reality (AR) earns its place as spatial storytelling: experiences of 60 to 90 seconds tied to a real location, such as Imvizar's tour of Spike Island in Cork, designed around the space and the visitor's movement before any script is written.

Who is the biggest user of augmented reality?

Snapchat is the biggest user of augmented reality, Guerin says, with 8 billion AR uses a day against 14 billion Google searches. Augmented reality lays digital images over a live view of the real world, and he argues that wherever it has succeeded, “it's almost never called augmented reality”.

What is the Imvizar AR tour of Spike Island like?

At Spike Island, which Guerin calls “Ireland's version of Alcatraz”, Imvizar runs an AR tour with 15 points of interest, from the guards' room to a punishment cell where a prisoner appears chained to the wall. He says two visitors cried on launch day because they had walked the prison for two hours without considering its human toll.

Why does Imvizar write the story last in spatial storytelling?

In spatial storytelling, a story overlaid on a physical place, “The narrative is the last thing that you should think about”, Guerin says. Imvizar starts with a site survey, then plans user movement, visuals and interactivity, and writes the script last, because AR viewed from one spot is “basically just a less enjoyable video”.

How does Salesforce use augmented reality for onboarding?

Imvizar builds Salesforce's AR experiences, Guerin says, including onboarding where new staff scan a QR code and explore the building together instead of sitting through hours of presentations. He says the company has over 150 experiences in 12 countries.

Will AI glasses become one device that does everything?

AI glasses are coming, but not as one device that does everything, Guerin argues. He says Meta's Ray-Ban display glasses sold out in about six weeks and counts around 27 pairs of glasses released this year; in his usage, mixed reality now means the head-worn version of AR, while “augmented” means the mobile version.

Where Mark, Jeremy and Guerin disagree

Mark says “a really good tour guide would be better than any AR”, and Guerin replies that he would debate it if the AR is good. Jeremy says AI glasses send his head to “scary mode” over privacy; Guerin answers that phones have been listening for at least a decade and that consumers will decide which companies they trust on their heads.

Questions

Who is Michael Guerin?

Michael Guerin, founder and CEO of Imvizar, argues on the Thinking On Paper podcast that augmented reality (AR) earns its place as spatial storytelling: experiences of 60 to 90 seconds tied to a real location, such as Imvizar's tour of Spike Island in Cork, designed around the space and the visitor's movement before any script is written.

What kind of augmented reality work does Michael Guerin build?

Michael Guerin builds augmented reality stories for tourist attractions and for tech companies, including new-starter onboarding at Salesforce.

How many times a day is augmented reality used on Snapchat?

He says Snapchat alone sees 8 billion uses of augmented reality a day, though it is almost never called augmented reality.

Transcript

Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds welcome to another episode of thinking on paper where we unpack the future with the people building it We push it, product question it and figure out if it's actually gonna be what we as humans need. My name is Jeremy. This is Mark. Mark. You're gonna take us through a pretty fascinating step by step ⁓ in augmented Situations augmented reality. Do you have a little history lesson for us today?

Mark Fielding I want to take you back Harvard 1968. A mounted display suspended from the ceiling. You put it on your head. 3D wireframe objects are overlaid onto your view. Your real time perspective changes on how you move your head. This is

Ivan Sutherland's Sword of Damocles, the first system where computer graphics were placed into a view of the real world. It's primitive, but it's the first, perhaps, reality. But it's not called augmented reality, Jeremy. The term AR isn't coined until 1992. Two Boeing engineers, Tom Cordell and David Mizzell, coined the term when they're building a system to help workers assemble complex wiring.

harnesses, essentially Boeing employees experiment again with a head mounted display showing instructions over physical aircraft parts. It's quite useful, that's a good use of augmented reality, so go Boeing. But AR then goes into hibernation for a few years. People are tinkering, know, playing around and it re-emerges as a mobile concept in 1997.

So enter this time Ronald Azuma and in his paper, a survey of augmented reality, he defines AR in this format we still use today, three things. It combines real and virtual. It's interactive in real time. and it's registered in 3D. So in the same time as Ronald Azuma was doing that, early outdoor AR prototypes emerge. One is Steve Feiner, Mars.

And that's got nothing to do with Elon Musk and going to Mars and terraforming that planet. It stands for mobile augmented reality system. And it's at Columbia University and essentially it's like a ghost busters pack. You put on your back another head mounted display, GPS based outdoor AR. You use it or they used it to do tours of the campus. Okay. So that's the beginning of location based AR and the hunt.

for the mass market begins. In 2009, we get LAYR, L-A-Y-A-R, the first consumer AR browser on a smartphone. And this was used for Splinter Cell, for Splinter Cell Conviction, so a Splinter Cell game launch. And if you're feeling like you want to feel old, you can go on their YouTube channel and watch videos from 15 years ago of Splinter Cell augmented reality. They went to Amsterdam.

Mark Fielding players use the AR to do missions on their phone around Amsterdam, complete tasks in augmented reality to advance. Pretty cool. Makes you feel old watching that video. But from Splinter Cell and Leia, 2012, IKEA show you what flat pack furniture could look like, but they don't put it together for you. They show you what it looks like in AR. 2013, Google launch their Google glasses to widespread.

What's the opposite of fanfare? Widespread. And then 2016, yes, it really is that long ago. 2016, perhaps the high watermark for augmented reality, Pokemon Go. And that was a big one. think that everybody with a telephone knew what Pokemon Go was. And that brings us to our guest.

Mark Fielding In that very long intro into the history of augmented reality, our guest is working in augmented reality. It is Michael Guerin He is the founder and CEO of Imvizar, which is an augmented platform. And he joins us today to say where the journey has gone after Pokemon Go. Thank you for thinking on paper with us, Michael.

Michael Guerin Thanks for having me Mark and thanks for that very comprehensive introduction. ⁓ anything out of the story and history of AR there?

Michael Guerin I all the main bits are there. Plenty has happened since 2016 though, so maybe I can add some of that today.

What changed since Pokemon Go

Mark Fielding Okay, so What has changed since Pokemon Go?

Michael Guerin Yes, the three that I would give an example of whenever I ask people.

give different talks from time to time and I ask people have you ever used augmented reality and most people say no and then I show them Pokemon Go as you've touched on. I also show them the IKEA app which a lot of people have used which you touched on as well but the other probably the much much bigger one is if anybody has used a lens or a filter on Instagram or Snapchat and that's all augmented reality. Probably the interesting thing like it's been incredibly successful. I'm actually just back from an event in Brussels I was with the snap team ⁓

Where the uses actually are

Michael Guerin There's 8 billion uses of augmented reality on Snapchat every single day. For context, there's 14 billion searches, the Google searches per day, 8 billion uses of augmented reality on Snapchat, right? So nobody would associate, nobody in the general public would associate Snapchat with augmented reality, but they're actually the biggest users of it and the biggest company delivering it. like since 2016, I mean, there's a whole lot we can get into now in terms of like spatial experiences and immersive experiences, but in terms of day-to-day use.

there is literally billions of uses of it every day on Snapchat alone, that's not including filters on Instagram or any other platform. So it's definitely used much more prominently than people think it is, but probably most interestingly everywhere it's been really successful, it's almost never called augmented reality.

Mark Fielding is a big snapper. don't use Snapchat. Can you use Snapchat without using the augmented reality, the lens features? Does it work as a standalone app without that?

Jeremy Gilbertson yeah, messaging it's location based, like where are your buddies? You can flip open this dashboard and you can see that Mark is snowboarding and, um, you know, Michael and I are at work. You know, you could see all of that. You could see all of that stuff. Um, it's Michael really interesting that you, that's a very relatable reference to what augmented reality is. there's a piece of the world that's actually there and there's a layer over the top of the world that's changing.

Jeremy Gilbertson that through a digital experience. I think that's really cool way to say, hey guys, this stuff's been around and you guys are using it every single day, right?

Michael Guerin Yeah, I mean, is. mean, there's other ones people have.

seeing like the wine bottles thing was quite popular a years ago where Snoop Dogg jumped out of your wine bottle. Yeah, yeah. So it's been, and then it was used in marketing a little bit more. There's kind of the back of the cereal box style experience. There's a lot of kids experiences. then like Gorillaz, the band, which you are probably aware of, they launched an album three years ago now, maybe, where they took over Times Square in New York and Piccadilly in London.

Jeremy Gilbertson Mmm, 19 crimes.

Michael Guerin it was a location-based experience. was like a listening party for the new album, but it wasn't just listening. Whenever all the fans went there and they held up their phone, the Gorillaz characters were sitting on top of the buildings and they were able to virtually take over all the billboards and own the place and make it a whole Gorillaz experience. I think the evolution that's happening now, lots happened.

with augmented reality and there's always the wow factor initially but then making it sticky has been a challenge and then getting things beyond gimmicks so like you know that Snoop Dogg out of a wine bottle thing was like kind of cool at the start and then once you've seen it you've seen it and are you really going to keep you know if you're another wine company or whatever else you're going to keep investing in that type of thing? so I think where we're trying to get to is slightly like what we focus on a slightly longer form content so rather than like a 10 to 20 second experience where the focus is on you taking a video and sharing it with your friends. Our focus is like 60 to 90 seconds, slightly longer form where you're more engaged in the location and the content. And we've been doing that now for four or five years. And then what's definitely happening and happening at a much quicker rate than we expected, glasses are coming. Yeah.

Mark Fielding Hold on, hold on, I'm gonna stop you there. to glasses.

said a word, gimmicky. you described anything to do with Snoop Dogg jumping out of a wine bottle, I think that's a good adjective to use for that.

Why does the world need more AR?

Mark Fielding why does the world need more augmented reality?

Michael Guerin phrase it slightly differently. I'm not sure the world needs more augmented reality, but if I give you some context to why we're using it, I believe we're using it in a meaningful way. So for a bit of context, us as a company, we ⁓ have over 150 experiences in 12 countries, right? So we started building experiences in tourist attractions and now we do a lot of stuff in large tech companies. we, as an example, build most of the AR or all the AR experiences for Salesforce.

if you give you an example of one of their experiences, if you join them in some of their offices around the world on your first day, you used to sit through a couple of hours of onboarding. There'd be some presentations and they tell you about the culture and the values and whatever else. Instead of doing that, they put up a QR code, you scan it with your phone and then you go and explore the building with everybody else that's joined that day and you learn about Salesforce through this shared experience, right?

Mark Fielding Everyone at Salesforce

Michael Guerin everybody in East Coast and West Coast of America. So it is, yeah. So that's all just come, yeah, the last, I the last year or so. So like the reason, there's lots of different reasons behind it and why they want to do it. But ultimately, you know, I can give you another example in a second, but people...

Mark Fielding That's a lot of people.

How people communicate outside work

Michael Guerin Typically outside of work people are communicating on a very like visual and short form way, right? So people use TikTok, Snapchat, WhatsApp. It's real short and snappy and a lot of it is visual and some of it is interactive content. And then you come into the place of work and it's like, you know, two hour long presentations of the 127 slides of all this text. And you expect people who like deal this way outside of work.

Michael Guerin you're just not going to get the same engagement if, if, that's the way you're communicating with people. does go back to your question, why does the world need augmented reality? I think it's more like, can we use different forms of communication to capture people where they are and still engage them with the message? So, you know, whether we like it or not, like our brains are becoming increasingly tuned towards this really short form content and all the dopamine hits that come alongside it. If you're an employer or a tourist attraction or a brand or whatever it might be, if you want to engage with people, you've got to move the direction and the way people are communicating. I think augmented reality, if done right, can be a really effective way of communicating a message that still has meaning and that people will still register the message that you're trying to communicate with them.

Walgreens

Jeremy Gilbertson So I don't know if you guys know of like Walgreens. Have you heard of Walgreens? It's like a drug store, like a CVS, Walgreens, the drugs and like all that stuff.

Jeremy Gilbertson I worked at one when I was 15 and my onboarding, I distinctly remember this. This was like this little bullshit CRT TV, VCR combo. And I was like tucked into this. It was a break room, but it was literally like a five by five closet. And I'm literally watching VHS tapes on corporate culture at Walgreens.

Jeremy Gilbertson I was like, what is happening?

and then before that, it was like a 200 page manual, which you had to read, right? So like it went from like a really boring book, I'm sure at a point in time, those VHSs were incredibly innovative. And I'm sure whenever they transition to doing things on PowerPoint, they probably thought that was even better. And then whenever they started having video in it, I'm sure in the PowerPoints, they thought it was even better. Like this is

Michael Guerin It's just another evolution. It's a new form. It's a new medium of communication, but it is shorter form. Maybe, you know, is that being driven by that or is that being driven by other media sources? Probably a bit more. But, you know, I'm not massively concerned in the sense that this transition has happened over time. know, whenever radio came in, people had concerns and even electricity and video and the internet and whatever else is, it's just another form of communication.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, Michael, Mark and I are children of the eighties and early nineties and ⁓ MTV was supposed to have melted our brains. So the fact that we're still alive and functioning, I guess, is probably okay.

Mark Fielding I don't know, but if you get the thinking paper, it a lot of short form content these days, Jeremy, because people like to digest the ideas. Well, you've got a good word for it, nuggets. We've got a lot of nuggets, don't they, their short form. How did the Salesforce partnership come about? Did they come to you or did you go to them?

Michael Guerin Yeah, was actually inbound. a very innovative company, fairness, like lots of tech companies try to be, but they were striving ways to engage people digitally within their building, whether you're a visitor or a new member of staff. So they were looking for digital storytelling, whether that was in video format or like QR codes as you wander around the building or whatever else.

Defining digital storytelling

Jeremy Gilbertson Can I ask you to define digital storytelling for our listeners? Yeah.

Michael Guerin Yeah, I can. Yeah, like we actually use the term spatial storytelling, is ⁓ either better or worse, depending on how you... Yeah, so like...

Mark Fielding I think that's, I prefer that actually.

Michael Guerin augmented are very like, kinda quasi icky terms a little bit, yeah.

The word immersive

Michael Guerin I tell you what's worse, the word immersive. I said this on a panel in South by Southwest last year. Immersive in the world of immersive technology, it's used everywhere. But then you look outside and it's literally used everywhere as well. Like I saw a university advertising last year and they were the most immersive university. And then I saw somebody else describing a film and it was really immersive. And then I think it was ⁓ like a painting and decorating company were describing what they do as immersive. And I was like, this word means

Michael Guerin everything and nothing, know. digital storytelling is obviously very broad. Like it's really anything that mixes any kind of digital media and storytelling and that can be video format. That could even be an audio guide. That's all digital storytelling. The reason we use spatial storytelling is because it uses a physical space ⁓ and the story is overlaid on top of that. So what we mean by that is physical location. And there is a story. There's normally visuals and audio as part it so when you hold up your phone you might see or wear glasses you might see things around you you'll also hear the story and but it uses the physical space that you're in.

Jeremy Gilbertson So let's stay on the definitions ⁓ for a second here. So spatial reality is one I hear, spatial compute, spatial this, spatial that. ⁓ Isn't reality already kind of spatial? There's a technological overlay that I understand needs to be communicated, right? And all we're doing...

Jeremy Gilbertson really is kind of mimicking what normally happens in nature, but doing it with technology ⁓ in a way that hits the same beats of the story that we resonate with. The Joseph Campbell hero's journey thing is just applied

Michael Guerin the terminology and language thing is a problem across the board. like we've talked about like there's augmented reality, virtual reality and mixed reality and they're all kind of under the extended reality bracket. But then you also have the concept of a metaverse and then you have spatial computing and spatial experiences.

And then with Snapchat and Instagram, we have lenses and filters and it's ultimately like all a different flavor of the same thing. Probably the bigger challenge is it's different companies taking different terms. like Apple only accept things for their Apple vision for vision pro It's called spatial computing or a spatial experience. They won't accept a description that mentions augmented or virtual reality. Microsoft were definitely pushing the mixed reality terminology for for quite a while. And then obviously Meta went down the the metaverse route and you know, you know, they're, they're variations on the same thing and they mean different things. what we do, some people would call it augmented reality and a lot of people would call it called mixed reality. And I think the, the way that it's kind of gone in the last six or 12 months is augmented is becoming more of the mobile version and then mixed is more of the head worn version. But it's really like the world is there.

Mark Fielding Jeremy, I've got a question for you.

What do you see, this is to you, Jeremy, before I go back to Michael, is a good use case of augmented reality. Seeing as you're a little bit, you got your 90s head on today,

Jeremy Gilbertson Geez, like short answer, I don't know, like, yeah. Please.

Mark's summer experience

Mark Fielding I'll tell you mine if you want because during the summer, so my kids, my kids, Michael are nine and six. We went to a lot of tourist attractions across England and across France.

Mark Fielding reality that I saw wasn't particularly good for me. I mean, the kids loved it because it's like, it's augmented reality. I didn't think it was.

But I think that in tourism, in these big old historical tourist attractions, especially, there's an opportunity to use augmented reality to learn and to experience what life might have been like in a way that they

Michael Guerin So that's, I mean that's literally where it all started for us. That was my vision at the start, Mark, that there are so many places all around the world and so many incredible things happened. some, like, you know, if you go on a, if you go to a tourist attraction and you get a really good tour guide, they can really describe things in a way that you can almost picture it yourself. But the chance that, you know, the number of times you get that really good one and that you're really engaged and you can keep the kids engaged while you're engaged. ⁓

A really good tour guide

Mark Fielding That's a very interesting point because a really good tour guide would be better than any AR.

Michael Guerin Well, yeah, I'll debate that one maybe, I think if you get good AR. So the other thing you said was that the AR isn't good, right? So it's literally where we started. So as an example, we have an experience in a place called Spike Island, which is Ireland's version of Alcatraz. Basically, it's actually eight times the size of Alcatraz. It was a prison and a military fort for a couple of hundred years, right the way up to 2004. Really fascinating place. So we have 15 points of interest around the prison. So as an example, in the first stop,

The guards room

Michael Guerin It's called the guards room and you enter and the fireplace and the guards chairs there. But when you hold up your phone, the prison guard is warming his hands against the fire and then he turns around and he starts shaking his bat on that chair as if you're about to be brought into the prison. And he explains to you that you're about to be brought in. And then the second stop on the tour is in the punishment cell. And when you're in the punishment cell, like these cells even now in a tourist attraction are really grim conditions, right? It's really damp in there. It's cold.

this is off the coast of Ireland, like you're there in November, it's not a pretty place to be. And you hold up your phone and then the prisoner is there chained to the wall, blindfolded, and he doesn't know what time of day it is, and he's only let off the handcuffs for 30 minutes per day, right? The rest of the time he's blindfolded and chained to the wall. So the first day we launched this, I was there and I gave an iPad to two ladies who were walking past.

and they saw the guy in the punishment cell and then immediately after they started crying and I was like, this a good thing or not? But both of them said that they had walked around the prison for like two hours and they hadn't really considered the human toll or the human impact of the place. So if you're a really good tour guide, could you get to that? You possibly could. But having a visual of what really happened there, just on a device that you can just hold in front of you is like.

Michael Guerin It's so incredibly powerful if it's done right. And there's so many subtleties to what done right means, like the shadows need to be right and the chains that we have actually went right to where the hooks are in the wall where the chains actually went to. if you can get all of that right, although you know it's not real, the two terms we use internally a lot is plausible and believable. And if it's plausible that that happened and believable in this scenario, you can really, really connect to the story and to the place. And when that's done right, it's incredible, you know.

Jeremy Gilbertson no, I, he actually in talking through that kind of fired some neurons. and, so I think, I think this technology definitely has a empathy activation potential if it's done the right way. And I think that's what you're talking about, Michael. And there's a couple of examples that I'll share that, ⁓ in Atlanta has the center for civil and human rights and you know, amazing museum to, ⁓ to basically show, to tell some of the the world. And there's a lunch counter, in installation that basically, mimics if you were, if you were African-American person, back in the fifties or sixties at a lunch counter, you would basically hear people walking behind you. You headphones on, you would hear people walking behind you screaming, racial, racial slurs, like scaring you all of that. Like you would actually feel that. And I think

If you read about that in a book, you're like damn that sucks But if you like really feel it and there's one more example that I'll share I don't know if you've ever run across a woman named Melissa Zek She has an installation I worked with her a little bit a few years ago and she has an installation or a I guess it's a program or an experience called something about the tree and it's actually shows What it feels like to be a tree growing and then what it feels like to be a tree?

Jeremy Gilbertson chopped down and she highlighted the same experiences that people had when the tree got chopped down. People were like bawling their eyes out and I think if it's done right, I think it's a way to get humans to be more empathetic, I think.

Mark Fielding passionate about a subject and knowledgeable about a subject as well, if done right.

Michael Guerin Yeah. And looked on right. It's so important that ultimately that then comes down to the technology. You know, like whenever I started the company, there was a couple of key things that I wanted us to get right. And the mantra generally at the start was if we can nail the technology, the end user will notice it because I think in most other augmented reality experiences people get told that they have to find a tabletop or a ground and then they've got to detect the surface then they got a tap to make the thing appear then they got a pinch it to make it bigger and smaller so you're like five steps in you've just like I have to do all these things and now you're entirely focused on the technology and not the story so for ours you walk into that room you hold up your phone the thing appears and you hit play there's nothing that you don't you shouldn't really even it should feel so natural that you don't even notice the technology

What else you need to get right

Jeremy Gilbertson What are some other important things to do it right?

Michael Guerin think about it completely differently to every other story. So we have this guide to spatial storytelling which we've created internally. So whenever you're telling, even if you're doing an audio tour of a place, you'll pick this place, you'll do the 10 stops, you'll do the research and then you'll write a story. You might have a first person narrative, you might have a narrator, that's probably how it'll evolve. When you're doing a spatial story or an augmented reality experience,

⁓ The narrative is the last thing that you should think about. the most important thing is to do a site survey of the room, the building, whatever it might be. So really understand the space. And then the second thing is the user movement. if you want, so like in the two that I've just given you an example of with the guy at the fireplace, the prison guard at the fireplace warming his hands. And then the next one, like you can see the prisoner change the wall and you can walk around them, right? So if you think about the place, the user movement, then you want to think about the visuals, then the interactivity and the last thing is the narrative, then you make the narrative suit all the things. And the reason we do that for context is augmented reality, if you stand in one place and hold up your phone, it's basically just a less enjoyable video because you might as well just watch it on a video. Whereas if you move, it's the only thing that makes it different to any other medium. So

A really, really important thing when you're designing any experience is to not think about, you'll know roughly the story that you want to tell, but don't write a script. Look at the location, look at the user movement, think what visuals you want in there, think about the timing of the visuals and possibly any interactivity, and then you can write the script at the end.

Mark Fielding to what I first thought when Jeremy asked that question. I thought you'd lead with the story, but it makes perfect sense to lead with the space.

Jeremy Gilbertson there's triggers in the space, I think, that can generate different aspects of the story, this kind of choose your own adventure. I spent a lot of years doing sound design TV video, video games, digital experiences, augmented experiences, and there's this trigger of like, hey, what can that sound drive the user to do? really think about, do you ever think about like,

Jeremy Gilbertson emotional response when you're

Michael Guerin Now that's literally the basis to it all to be honest with you.

whenever we're writing. like we have a like a spatial script, which has all the different elements of what I've just discussed and a really important thing for every single bit of the story and every scene is what we expect the emotional response to be, you if you can create an emotional connection to a piece of content, then the people will remember that. whether that's like you enjoyed it, you were frustrated, you were angry, you were crying, laughing, whatever it might be as long as is an emotional response to the content you're engaging with, you're much more likely to remember it. So the next time you go home and tell people about the tourist attraction you went to in Ireland or to the best onboarding you've ever had in a company, you'll probably remember the ones that you had more fun with, you cried on. And that's what we're trying to, in an appropriate and sensitive way, I would say as well, it's not just let's get everybody to cry at every stop, you know, it's got to be appropriate to the content.

The Holocaust Museum

Mark Fielding I still remember going to the Holocaust Museum in Berlin and it was incredible. the Spike Island would be again, very easy to tell a story that makes people feel very emotive. And for your examples too, Jeremy My first writing website was actually called The Metaverse Writer, Michael, which dates me. unfortunately, Mark Zuckerberg destroyed my business when he

Zuckerberg, and the glasses

Mark Fielding And he rebranded Facebook as meta and the metaverse. I want to read a quote which I think links to what you're doing and a future where AR and AI combine and maybe you can paint that for us.

This is from Mark Zuckerberg July this year quote. I continue to think that glasses are basically going to be the ideal form factor for AI because you can let an AI see what you see throughout the day, hear what you hear and talk to you.

End quote. Now, as mad as a hatter that Mark Zuckerberg is.

When you hear that, first of all, what do you think about his his opinion?

Michael Guerin I think it's the next.

natural enough evolution of hardware devices. I do think, so you referred to the Google Glasses your intro, Mark, what happened between then and about a year ago was

Everybody was striving for one thing that you wore in your head that did everything. And what's happened in the last 12 months is people have realized that that's not the case. So literally only yesterday or the day before at United XR, which is the biggest AR and VR conference in Europe. One of the directors of engineering for Snapchat was on and he had a slide which talked about headsets for experiences, the everyday use AI glasses, and then were snap, were positioning themselves as the in-between.

So it's glasses that you will like, might wear multiple times throughout the day, but it's to do something and to take back off. So a bit like, you you use a laptop or a phone, you use it at a point in time and then you take it back off. don't have your phone out in front of you all the time, but you use it for things throughout the day. And they're kind of positioning themselves as a device that you'll use.

that you'll use four things and then put them down again, whether you'll carry all these glasses around entirely up to you, know, but I think the AI glasses in fairness, you know, what he's saying there and what I've seen with the meta RayBan AI glasses, like.

people really love them. They sold out in like six weeks when they launched the display ones earlier this year. I think there's been like 27 pairs of glasses released this year from different companies and there's about the same to be launched in the first half of next year. like the, it's funny, like the glasses Google launched, which was 11 years ago, I believe the head of Google XR got up at Augmented World Expo in Long Beach in June earlier this year and said, he showed the video from 11 years ago and he said, so everything that we talked about back then we can now actually do, right? So it's taken that long to get to where that marketing video went. So I think that form of glasses can happen now where you have like a bit of something you can talk to, you can listen to music, it can capture a photo and it's like a heads up display. It's not spatial, there's nothing in the world in front of you, but there's like information displayed in front of you. And I think that will, that's a form factor that people will get used to. And then in the next couple of years, you will get more spatial content in the world around you.

⁓ So I think it's somewhat inevitable. I just don't think it's going to be one pair of glasses or one pair of hardware that does it all.

The Wayfarers

Jeremy Gilbertson ⁓ It was a smart move to jump on the Wayfarers. mean, that's such an iconic pair of shades that it's like, wow. But ⁓ Mark, I'm going to share my thoughts even though you didn't ask me about so Michael, we've been engaging with some really interesting guests, Carissa Velez, ⁓ specifically most recently talking about privacy and effects of data sovereignty on the individual, on democracies, on all of that stuff.

Jeremy Gilbertson I start thinking about, okay, these, these glasses are great and they're cool and they're going to allow us to do really cool things. But we're, basically deploying like surveyors, see the world in a specific lens and, can really grab more. not trying to

Jeremy Gilbertson say what you're doing is bad, is gonna destroy humanity. I think there's some very awesome benefit. No, let me be clear though. There's some really cool benefit to what you're doing in these experiences, especially the Salesforce stuff, especially the museums,

Jeremy Gilbertson like having these great ways to trigger empathy, but like on the glasses side, my head goes to scary mode a little bit. How do you feel about that?

Michael Guerin Yeah, which I think is fair enough, know, but ⁓ unfortunately that's really not new either, Jeremy. know, like the little device we have in our pockets has been recording us for, well, seemingly not, but it's been listening for, you know, at least a decade, if not longer, you know.

the differences, it was always audio data and now it's visual. then that's, that's more of a challenge, you know, and then look, I think what it then comes down to, like, you know, Europe and America are taking very different approaches in this. love some regulation and, you know, public policy in, in Europe, and to try and clamp down on things. But ultimately, I think consumers will decide. And you've seen that with different technology companies over the last 10 years, some trust more.

more than others and who's right and who's wrong? think they're all, like Mett have their thing with Ray-Ban parent company and the Oakley parent company, but Google have just launched theirs with a competing glasses company and Snap will have theirs. And I think it'll probably come down to which companies do people trust to be wearing on their heads, seeing everything that they're seeing.

Jeremy Gilbertson Mark, I'm going to design an AI model that ⁓ basically runs through terms and conditions of technology, apps and devices and gives me the shortcut version of, Hey, is this going to be cool for me? Is this going to be scary for me? That's my, that's my next project.

Michael Guerin I think it's all super important for us to be very educated on where it's going as best we can. And I think that's where regulations can be good, where they can people to, force companies to make it clear where data is going. But I mean, you've seen with lots of big companies over the last five years, you have to put something in where you have to accept terms and conditions, or you can't see your friends anymore on that network. And then people just tick the box, hit confirm, and then keep going. But I do think it's really important for people to be...

as informed as possible and then hopefully as a society we choose the right direction.

Ivan Sutherland

Mark Fielding think Ivan Sutherland is still alive and I think it's not ironic that his first project was called The Sword of Democles, but quick thought experiment for you, Michael. So the King of England calls you tomorrow and he says, look, Buckingham Palace, numbers are down, the estates, feedback is they're How quickly could you

Mark Fielding go into the Royal Estate, change things up and what would you do?

Michael Guerin I think as an Irish man, he's probably not likely to ring me ⁓ But if he did, ⁓ if he did, would, yeah, like we can, we can get things up and running in three months, maybe up to six, you know, depending on how expansive the experiences and on what side of the story they want to tell. So yeah.

Mark Fielding Bad example. My apologies.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well no, and that could be really interesting.

then you could insert your own Easter egg nuggets ⁓ with the real story, right? No, that's okay.

Wow, we're getting off track, but cool things to think about.

Mark Fielding Closing question, Jeremy, as I hang my head in embarrassment from not researching my thought experiments properly.

Closing

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, so lastly, Michael, thanks so much for jumping in with us and you would definitely love to stay in the loop on what you're doing. Feel free to keep us up to speed and share what you're doing. Maybe we can do a round two at some point. But one question we like to leave our guests with is one from Kevin Kelly. What do we want humans to be and how can technology help us get there if it can?

Michael Guerin You've got flavors of this from the things that I've said, but ultimately we're doing this so that people can feel more connected to the places that you're in. So whether that's the Spike Island example or whether you've just joined a company or whatever it might be.

There are so many stories and places around the world and we want people to be connected to. You could stand in the middle of London or any city in the world and something happened here in 1502 and 1657 and 1727. All these different years, so many different things have happened. So we as a company definitely want people to be more connected and then connected to each other. And look, we've actually just launched a canva for augmented reality where people can build their own experiences. It's called Lureo.

And we're ultimately trying to make it possible for anybody without any design, animation, storytelling knowledge, any previous knowledge that they can build these experiences and share them with their family, friends, whoever it might be. yeah, look, to feel more connected to the world around them is our goal.

Mark Fielding I like that we speak often about connection to people. We don't often speak about connection to place, Jeremy. We should add that as node in the thinking on paper substack and label it for future exploration.

Jeremy Gilbertson I love it. I love it. Michael, thanks for joining us. Really appreciate it.

Michael Guerin thanks very much for having me today guys, really enjoyed the conversation.