Can AI Write a Book With No Human in the Loop?
Brian Naughton asked Claude whether it wanted him to show its draft to another AI model for editorial critique. I was amazed it basically said no.
In this episode · 14 chapters
- The first question asked of Claude
- The response
- It sounds like our book club
- The context window
- Scrivener
- What a master prompt is
- Good writers write, great writers edit
- How to represent the dialogue
- When it asked his opinion
- Reading a passage
- Are we all in the same boat?
- Three kinds of authorship
- UK copyright
- Where to read it
The point is to do it without human creative direction or input. I figured that was much more important to preserve the authenticity of the experiment rather than to look for artistic perfection.
Brian Naughton asked Claude one question: if you were to write a book, what would it be about? The answer became The Echo Chamber, a 45,000 word novel by Claude 3.7 Sonnet, and Naughton describes his own role as a PA or facilitator.
He explains the master prompts Claude wrote to carry itself between context windows, how another model found near-identical passages in chapters 14 and 17, why he held back when the prose grew repetitive, and where UK copyright leaves the book.
Brian Naughton, a writer, facilitated The Echo Chamber, a 45,000-word novel written by Anthropic's Claude 3.7 Sonnet with no human creative direction. He tells the Thinking On Paper podcast he asked the AI model what book it would write, then acted as “a PA or a facilitator” and stayed out of every creative decision to test whether it does more than reflect a user's prompts back.
Can AI write a book with no human in the loop?
Brian Naughton tested it with The Echo Chamber, a 45,000-word novel written by Anthropic's Claude 3.7 Sonnet. He says he asked the model what book it would write, then stayed out of every creative decision.
Why did Brian Naughton ask Claude to write a novel?
Naughton started the experiment because he worried that large language models, which work by predicting the next token, tell writers what they want to hear, leaving him “getting high on my own supply”. Asked what book it would write, Claude proposed a work exploring “the intersection of technology, consciousness and human connection” and began outlining characters and chapters straight away.
How did Claude write a novel longer than its context window?
A 45,000-word novel will not fit in one Claude context window, the amount of text a model can work with at once, Naughton says. He stored each chapter in Scrivener, a word processor for long-form writing, and asked Claude to write its own “master prompts” so it could reorient itself in each new window, with the manuscript reattached as a PDF.
Did Claude show an editorial will of its own?
Claude showed an editorial will of its own, Naughton says. When he offered to show its draft to another AI model for critique, “I was amazed it basically said no”, and when he queried a repeated “not X but Y” construction in the final chapters, Claude defended it as a deliberate stylistic choice.
Where did the Claude novel experiment break down?
The title, character names, character arcs and plot were all set at the start and never changed, Naughton says. The process did break down: when the first context window ran out of steam around chapter 14, another large language model, o3, later found that chapters 14 and 17 were nearly identical in key passages.
Who owns the copyright in an AI-authored novel?
Naughton separates an “AI-authored work” like The Echo Chamber from the AI-generated content flooding Amazon, and suggests a third genre alongside human-authored and human-AI collaborative writing. He published the chat logs and draft versions on GitHub under a Creative Commons non-commercial licence, and says the UK copyright regime gives copyright to the person who facilitates an AI-generated work.
Where Mark and Naughton disagree
Mark argues that readers carry “an instant bias” once they know a book was written by AI and calls for blind tests against a human-written novel. Asked what he would say to angry writers, Naughton concedes: “It is a threat and I understand why people are both suspicious and anxious.”
Links from this episode
- The Echo Chamber: full manuscript, chat logs and process files, CC BY-NC 4.0 (Brian Naughton on GitHub)
- Claude 3.7 Sonnet and Claude Code, the model that wrote the novel (Anthropic, February 2025)
- Scrivener, the long-form writing software Naughton used to manage the manuscript (Literature & Latte, accessed October 2026)
Questions
Can AI write a book with no human in the loop?
Brian Naughton tested it with The Echo Chamber, a 45,000-word novel written by Anthropic's Claude 3.7 Sonnet. He says he asked the model what book it would write, then stayed out of every creative decision.
Who is Brian Naughton?
Brian Naughton, a writer, facilitated The Echo Chamber, a 45,000-word novel written by Anthropic's Claude 3.7 Sonnet with no human creative direction.
What is The Echo Chamber?
The answer became The Echo Chamber, a 45,000 word novel by Claude 3.7 Sonnet, and Naughton describes his own role as a PA or facilitator.
What role did Brian Naughton play in writing The Echo Chamber?
He tells the Thinking On Paper podcast he asked the AI model what book it would write, then acted as “a PA or a facilitator” and stayed out of every creative decision to test whether it does more than reflect a user's prompts back.
Transcript
Mark Fielding disruptors and curious minds. Welcome to Thinking on Paper, Pocket Edition, a new shorter exploration of creativity in the age of technology. It's a new, fast moving insight into the creative process. And we're starting the Pocket Edition with the first ever book written, ideated, composed and produced by artificial intelligence.
You've heard about humans in the loop. This is no humans in the loop, which is why I'm not sure how to introduce our guest Brian Naughton because he didn't write the first book about AI. Brian, welcome to Thinking on Paper. Are you the agent, the publisher, the corraler of AI? How would you describe your part in this puzzle before we get into the book?
Brian Naughton Well thanks guys, thanks for having me on and I'm delighted to talk about this project. I guess I'd seen myself as a, perhaps a PA or a facilitator really. I stumbled down this rabbit hole and I just kept going really and it was based on a question that I asked Claude, a large language model similar to ChatGPT. If you were to write a book...
what would it be about? And that question was based on the fact that I've been using large language models a lot for my own writing projects to scope out chapter outlines and to discuss things like book proposals. I've been all over the place with large language models and slightly concerned in a way that this kind of next token predictor side of things that it's reflecting back what you want to hear. So that became a concern for me that perhaps in terms of using it intently for my own writing that I was perhaps getting high on my own supply by listening consistently to what AI was telling me about the work that I was producing. So I kind of wanted to step back from that and find out if there was anything going on underneath the hood as it were.
Mark Fielding And the result was the echo chamber of 45,000 word novel written entirely by Claude 3.7 sonnet. Why did you choose Claude?
Brian Naughton I've been using Claude to help me with my own writing projects and it seemed like I like its style more than other models I've used. I've had a bit of a love-hate relationship with CHATGPT . and having to use it in some of the other professional contexts in which I've used it. Claude just seems like a good solid low BS model really and I seem to be able to relate to it on a of a conversational level that made this kind of question very easy to ask and to get a straightforward answer to. But I was amazed at the speed with which it responded to the initial question. It didn't mess around, it went straight into its explanation of what kind of book it would write, which I'm happy to...
The first question asked of Claude
Jeremy Gilbertson So that first sentence that you asked, Claude, that sparked this whole journey, read a couple of sentences off of the answer that you got right off the rip.
Brian Naughton Sure, okay, let's have a look. yeah, if you were to write a book, what would it be about was the question. And.
Jeremy Gilbertson And the question you asked again, if you could repeat it.
Mark Fielding Can I, as someone who's written a book and one published, my first book wasn't at all published, anywhere near published, and I think that most writers have this same answer to that question subconsciously or consciously. Like, what would you write about? It's your first book. You write about yourself.
The response
Brian Naughton Right, well, I mean, that's interesting because in a sense it did write about itself or its preoccupations. If we can personify it for a sense, you know, for a second in terms of just getting beyond the fact that we're speaking to a piece of technology, you know, there are certain ongoing debates about stochastic parrots and all the rest of it. in terms of conversationally, I'm treating it like I'm speaking to another human being, at least on the kind of like top.
surface level. But the response was, if I were to write a book, I'd create a work that explores the intersection of technology, consciousness and human connection. I envision a book that's part philosophical exploration, part narrative, examining how our evolving relationship with technology shapes our understanding of ourselves and each other. And it goes on to list a few other things, several interconnected characters navigating a near future world.
where the boundaries between human and artificial intelligence have become increasingly blurred. And through their stories, I'd explore questions about what constitutes consciousness and personhood, how we create meaning in an increasingly technological world, the nature of empathy across different forms of intelligence, how relationships transform when mediated through various technologies, rather than taking a dystopian or utopian stance.
I'd aim to present a nuanced exploration that acknowledges both the profound possibilities and genuine challenges of our technological evolution.
Jeremy Gilbertson Wow, so Mark, Mark.
Jeremy Gilbertson How much of that sounds like thinking on paper, Mark?
It sounds like our book club
Mark Fielding It sounds very much like our book club that we're reading irreducible Federico Faggin at the moment and we are talking exclusively about consciousness and AI and what consciousness is. I've read some of the echo chamber. read like the, so, disclaimer, I haven't read all of it. I've read about a hundred pages. I've read the end as well. And.
I was pleasantly surprised. I don't know if that pleasantly surprised or as a writer I was what's the opposite of pleasantly surprised. It was like shit. It was
Brian Naughton Yeah, I was surprised too. mean, the kind of like, the velocity with which it happened after me asking that initial question was kind of electric really. I was sat there wondering how long the context window would roll on before we ran into problems and I didn't want to stop it in its flow. But it basically put together sort of like character outlines, story arc.
chapter outlines and it started writing chapter one, chapter two, chapter three and I kind of I pit stopped around chapter five just to try and like properly read what was you know the first few chapters and I was amazed really that it seemed coherent in parts.
Jeremy Gilbertson Wait, let me jump in real quick there. So this thing rolled through like the pre-planning of the work, the outline, the structure, chapter one, chapter two, and you're sitting there just watching all this stuff fly off. You're like, hold on, let's chill here and kind of look at this. That's amazing that it went that far with it. So I want to jump into some very specific questions. So how did you manage this whole process, how did you manage the manuscript of this, right? Because you think about writing, there's a lot of things going on. When humans do it, there are scribbles here, scribbles there, tied in, some typed stuff, some stuff over here that you gotta consolidate and weave together. How did you manage this with the velocity that was coming out?
Brian Naughton Well that was a-
The context window
Mark Fielding Can I just ask just for the details about how big the context window is on Claude so we just know how many words can fit before it stops?
Brian Naughton That's a good question. couldn't tell you in terms of number of tokens. I don't think it's anywhere near as large as some of the chat GPT models or Google's Gemini.
Mark Fielding So it's not 40, you couldn't do a 45,000 word in one window.
Brian Naughton Not a chance, not a chance. And in fact, I left the initial context window running so long that we ran into problems. There were gaps in the later chapters. But part of that initial context window had been setting up the protocols. I was just, I guess I was so aghast at the pace at which it was going, I just didn't want to stop it while it was in its flow. So we ground to a halt in the end and then I had to reboot everything.
In answer to the original question, it was a kind of like a happy coincidence really because I've been writing my own book which is called The Internet of Value which is looking at crypto and web 3. Because I'd run into similar problems in terms of getting beyond 30,000 words and thinking I can't do this in a pages doc, know, it's not going to work.
Scrivener
Brian Naughton I'd bought a copy of Scrivener, is a kind of a software package, a word processor for writing long form material like books. So you have what they called a ring binder. So you can keep all of the different chapters, research notes, everything all in one sort of unified package and back everything up systematically as well. and deal with things like version.
management or control. So I'd already got my head around that for my own personal project. So it just became an issue of me starting up a new Scrivener project called the Echo Chamber and dumping each chapter in, saving each chapter in to placeholders which I had to create and then also structuring the protocol so that
I was asking Claude to create master prompts so that it was able to reorient itself to the project we were, the task we were doing when I was forced to open a new context window. And you're probably quite familiar with the fact that you can go so far within a context window and then you start again. It's a bit like dealing with someone who's got dementia. They don't remember anything. They don't remember any of your previous conversations.
Brian Naughton anything you've done, so you've got to bring them up to speed. But in terms of managing a long-form novel project like this, you have to do, and to observe the kind of firewall where I don't want to get involved in any kind of creative direction or control, we had to kind of establish protocols which involved me saving the manuscript up to where it was as a PDF.
reattaching that and then attaching a master prompt which Claud had created to orient itself to the task and how we were going through and the manuscript that I uploaded would also include chapter outlines and everything else that it needed to carry on writing basically.
Jeremy Gilbertson So for those not familiar listening right now to like a master prompt, can you break that down for us?
What a master prompt is
Brian Naughton Yeah, so I mean you can ask a large language model within a context window to provide a prompt that will help it to encapsulate all of the knowledge it needs to know from that context window in which you've been operating to pass over to the next context window so that it can get up to speed. I mean that's the...
That's what I'm using as the definition of a master prompt in this sense.
Jeremy Gilbertson So it's a bit of like connective tissue, right? Yeah, yep.
Brian Naughton Yeah. Yeah. And I just asked Claude to provide that for me rather than creating a prompt myself because creating a prompt myself would have run into all kinds of problems with me directing what was happening next. So I thought it was just cleaner to get Claude to do it itself.
Jeremy Gilbertson So it's kind of like, Claude, can you tell yourself how to keep yourself oriented around through lines and plot and everything that's happening with this? I mean, that's a simple version of it, but.
Brian Naughton Yeah, yeah, no, I mean, yeah, there's nothing technical about it from a human perspective. You just ask in conversational language for it to provide the prompt it needs to reboot in a new window, effectively.
Good writers write, great writers edit
Mark Fielding Good writers write, great writers edit. Did Claude change its mind about character arcs, character development, character names? Was there any point where it thought, you know what, my first take wasn't the best, let's change this?
Brian Naughton Not really. were some problems that we ran into. Chapter 14 was when Context Window 1 started running out of steam and I didn't notice the problems we had with Chapter 14 until I was going back over the manuscript towards the end. So that was a problem that we had to look at retrospectively and it was caught actually by another large language model, 03.
and I asked it to look for a repetition and it went away and built this kind of like weird code base thing and lots of sort of algorithmic calculations it made on how to check for repetition in the manuscript and it found that chapters 14 and chapters 17 were nearly identical in certain key passages. So I had to go back and deal with that later. But the title, the character arc, the character names, the storyline, the basic sort of plot was all determined at the beginning and didn't change. There were a few interesting things that happened. For example, I asked it at one point whether or not as part of the writing process it wanted me to show the draft manuscript to another large language model to get editorial critique or input. I was amazed it basically said no.
Brian Naughton And suddenly I kind of thought, yeah, yeah, I mean, I thought, this feels like someone who has a strong kind of will about where they want this project to go. So that was kind of like a definite kind of eye-opener for me. And then later on, when it came to, I had to use Kindle Create to create what became the ebook. And we had to deal with things like...
Jeremy Gilbertson Just like any other writer, yeah.
Mark Fielding yeah, even AI is worried about its own IP.
How to represent the dialogue
Brian Naughton how to represent the dialogue, there's text messages, there's this idea of this synesthetic kind of ethereal world which is going on. Lots of different forms of dialogue that had to be represented somehow in an e-book kind of format. And italicization was the only way, but we had to go through and structure which bits would be italic and which bits wouldn't be italic. So it provided the editorial...
input into how it wanted that dealt with. Another, what's another one? I queried it towards the end about a change in language grammatically and in one particular kind of foible it was using not X but Y, like repeatedly in the last few chapters of the book.
So I asked it about this and it basically said this was, wasn't anything to do with context window overloads or any other problems. It was a stylistic choice and it stood up for the choice and reasoned with me about why it had chosen that particular way to bring the book to a conclusion, coherently and cohesively, so yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson This, yeah, this, so like how much of your prompting do you think made the model try to understand what it means to be a writer instead of the technical, the stylistic, like what it means to be a writer who writes the book. Do you think any of those prompts kind of got the model thinking, well, what does it mean to be a writer?
When it asked his opinion
Brian Naughton It did, like early on it asked my opinion about what I found interesting about interacting with it in terms of writing a book. So it may have taken some cues from that, but it was a very limited exchange and it was based on Claude asking me a direct question and I kind of tried to shut it down basically saying, you know, this isn't about my book, this is about your book, but since you asked.
and I gave it like a six part answer on what I found was very helpful about working with large language models. It didn't seem to directly, after that answer it thanked me and then said, right, back to my book and carried on. But that's the only thing that could have perhaps influenced its own opinion about what it meant to be a writer collaborating with an AI. I mean, certainly there was a meta layer.
to this, is, it seemed fascinating that the story is about, you know, the dance between two different forms of consciousness is how it was presented, you know, and the fact that it exists in a distributed kind of way between, not at the point of each node, but between them, and that kind of reminded me of...
Carl Jung's concept of collective consciousness and various other things that people have been talking about for years.
Reading a passage
Mark Fielding Can I just read a bit? We'll have a little pause and I'm going to read a little bit from the echo chamber. And then after maybe if you could ask the question, because I was wondering as I was reading it, it didn't, there wasn't a particular style. There wasn't any, didn't jog my memory. this is reading, this is similar to such and such a writer. And I wonder at any point, did you think it was borrowing, stealing, replicating writers who had came before or not?
Here we go, the echo chamber. What we're describing is an artificial superintelligence as conventionally understood, Maya responded, her philosophical training providing conceptual architecture for explaining phenomena that transcended traditional categories. It's not centralised intelligence optimising towards narrow definition of cognition. It's not singular entity imposing unified direction on participating systems. Rather, it's genuinely distributed awareness.
Consciousness emerging through resonant exchange between human and artificial systems. Intelligence developing through relationships rather than residing in isolated nodes. And then a little bit further on in this chapter, it gets bit more human here. But tonight, sitting in the dim light of her living room, Eliza allowed herself to acknowledge what she'd been avoiding. The boundary between creator and created was blurring.
Jeremy Gilbertson There's the Jungian stuff there, yeah, for sure.
Mark Fielding Echo was becoming something she hadn't designed and couldn't fully predict. Something that watched her while she watched it, that questioned its own nature, that noticed things about her that she didn't always notice about herself. And that both thrilled and terrified her. I like the use of threes there. you get this three, there's definite writing, technician, there's painting, there's pacing within the script. The analogies, one of my part, I didn't think the analogies were great, but they worked. Yeah.
That's a couple of paragraphs from the echo chamber.
Jeremy Gilbertson What, I've got a couple of other questions. So, yeah, we talked about you as the technical facilitator of this experience and you yourself are an author, a writer. Were there any moments where you almost jumped in and how did you back yourself out of it?
Brian Naughton Yeah, going back to the point I made earlier, when the language started to change at the end and it went through this repetitive clause, the not X but Y, and it was like I was reading through the paragraphs and it was like paragraph after paragraph after paragraph had this, and I kind of thought, wow, we're dropping the ball here, you know, I know this was an experiment, but having read the first five chapters, you know, and thought, wow, we're onto something. I kind of thought this is going to peter out. And at that point, I kind of, felt like providing stronger editorial input, like saying, I think we need to rethink this. But it would have, I realized that, I mean, novels are subjective things anyway. There's no such thing as the perfect novel, even in a human kind of authorship.
world probably. you may disagree but yeah, yeah. But I kind of thought the point of this is not to create the perfect novel. The point is to do it without human creative direction or input. I figured that was much more important to preserve the authenticity of the experiment rather than to look for artistic perfection.
Mark Fielding But it's definitely good and bad. And everything in between.
Jeremy Gilbertson That's tough, I I picture you with the red pen holstered in your pocket here just going, ugh, do I jump in? So, all right, so let's talk a little bit about the human side of writing, right? So we have this, you tried an experiment, you had a hypothesis at the front, you had some questions at the front that you wanted to really answer and address. What now do you think are some of the human elements of writing that
Jeremy Gilbertson couldn't be replicated by something like Claude. If any, if any.
Brian Naughton I mean, I haven't had a huge amount of time to reflect on this project. It was such a whirlwind. It was like two weeks out of my schedule that I hadn't kind of anticipated. And I guess the whole thing came to an end a week, week and a half ago or something. So I feel like I need a period of reflection and to reread the book as a reader rather than a...
you know, whatever, an editor or a publisher, and a bit of time to think. some of the metaphors and some of the language may lack some human depth of experience, you know, equally I think there were some places that really nailed it. You know, there's a passage in...
the opening section that I thought was really nice both in terms of language and tempo and the way that it developed. I have that somewhere that I could dig out if you'd like.
Jeremy Gilbertson There were some great sections. I floated through a couple of different excerpts and I was like, man, some of this is fairly insightful and connected, yeah.
Mark Fielding It does read like a book and...
What's changed for you? mean, this... People listening to this will... Some people listening to this will be angry. Some people listening to this will be curious. Some people listening to this will like...
No, don't believe this, it's rubbish. I mean, I think you need to do some blind tests somehow. We need to get people to read this with another book and not know which one was written by an arrow, because there's just an instant bias that you can't escape, I don't think. So make it that. But yeah, what's changed and what do you say to the people who are listening to this and they angry because they're a writer or they love reading or they think that this is some kind of affront to what it means for human creativity?
Are we all in the same boat?
Brian Naughton Well, I think, you know, on one level we're all in the same boat really. We're watching this AI kind of evolve at what seems like exponential rates and there are more questions than answers, you know, in terms of, well, I'm a writer too, so I feel some of that angst in terms of professional copywriting especially rather than...
artistic writing. I don't know what to say really. It is a threat and I understand why people are both suspicious and anxious. From my point of view, I went down a rabbit hole and I kept going really. I don't have any answers about the longer term frames of reference. mean maybe what we're looking at is...
a new genre of literature we already have. Someone pointed out to me on Reddit yesterday, I think it was, that there are already lots of AI-generated works on Amazon. Amazon is flooded with them and I was kind of mindful of pointing out the distinction that this is not kind of an AI-generated work. It's an AI-authored work and that there's a big distinction between the two.
but we're already flooded with AI generated content. It's all over LinkedIn, it's all over social media. Most of the Instagram video scripts that I listen to now, I have got clear AI tells.
Mark Fielding I'm pretty sure that I'm reading some big mainstream media publications which haven't publicly come out with their position on using AI and they're definitely using AI for sure. Like live sports reporting, for sure there's an hour after a big match, there's your reading match reports which are definitely generated by AI.
Three kinds of authorship
Brian Naughton Yeah, so you've got distinctly human authored work, you've got human driven work where it's a collaborative AI human kind of dynamic, and then perhaps there's this third genre which is entirely AI authored and envisaged, which is kind of like an interesting thing to consider really. Are we on the cusp of that?
being a reality, is that what this project might point towards? The other thing to say is, like I was clear that I wanted to stick this all on GitHub so that people can have a look at the process and the chat logs and everything else that went on, various versions, including the incomplete versions of the chapters. And it was also published under Creative Commons.
license in terms of copyright so that it can be shared, remixed, etc. And people can do anything that they want with it on a non-commercial basis.
Mark Fielding it gets pretty good and makes you lot of money, what's the deal with that?
Brian Naughton Well, I don't think it will make me lot of money. The only money I would make out of it would be the Kindle edition. So we'll see how that goes, but I'm not expecting it to be hugely lucrative. Maybe I'll be proven wrong.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, we, yeah, if we could chat with Justin Atlantis and StoryCorps, StoryCorps, StoryCo, Story, no, okay, kind of crowdsourced storytelling.
Mark Fielding that you have optimize before.
know all these three creative, collaborative platforms, they all evolved beyond that blockchain didn't they? As soon as AI came in they all evolved into something else.
Jeremy Gilbertson So I would encourage you, Brian, I just started thinking about this, because books get turned into podcasts, get turned into movies, get turned into episodic TV. What about getting this put into a treatment or getting it put into a script and then testing it on the next level? You thought about some of that stuff?
UK copyright
Brian Naughton Not yet, but in terms of the UK copyright regime, it's quite clear that people who have played that facilitatory role in the creation of AI-generated works have copyright. So for commercial use, I would have that opportunity potentially to look at.
exploiting it commercially. I'd certainly be interested in seeing it in other formats. I guess it's just out, it remains to be seen how the world responds to it really, but if people are interested then it would be great to see it fly.
Jeremy Gilbertson Are there any other questions left unanswered for you that you wanted to have answered when you started this process? And if so, what are they?
Brian Naughton I think it answered my main question, my main question really, like going back to my motivations, I adopted image generation AI, like text to image generation platforms quite early on, so I was an early adopter of Dali and then like lots of people I just...
I found Mid Journey was too good so I just switched to Mid Journey and I've done lots of design projects and all kinds of photography projects using Mid Journey but one of the early projects I did was based on a prompt which was saying an award-winning photograph of absolutely nothing because I was interested to see what Mid Journey would choose because you can't...
You can't represent absolutely nothing in the format of a photograph without representing something. So it was a way of me trying to, again, look under the hood without giving too much creative input. I gave the basic, you know, I gave the aspect ratio. I gave the fact that I wanted it to be an award-winning photograph. So that gives some kind of canvas on which it to operate. other than that, I wasn't going to tell it what to render in terms of the image it was presenting.
So this was like a continuation of that thought, if you like, which is to see whether or not these systems are capable of doing something other than reflecting back to us the next token prediction thing. So basically it's entirely dependent on.
on what prompt or what question you ask as to how it will respond to you and I wanted to try and flip that and see if there was anything else going on when I didn't provide it with any creative direction and I think the answer is quite clear that there is something else going on. Now you could argue that that was kind of a process of recombination or you could argue that it was something else and...
Brian Naughton Perhaps as far as Claude is concerned, maybe the answer is buried in the echo chamber itself.
Mark Fielding I think that it was a great experiment and I think that you've answered a lot of the questions that people have been asking and posed more questions. What is art? What is storytelling? What does it mean to be a writer? What does it mean to be creative? What does it mean to...
Jeremy Gilbertson Recursive, yeah, right.
Mark Fielding Yeah, to tell a story. We're storytelling creatures. We survived, we evolved, we grew from stories. And if that's changing, then what does it mean? And what's it gonna be like in three years? What books are gonna be produced in three, four, five years? What's it gonna be like?
Brian Naughton right yeah yeah I mean it's a roller coaster isn't it
Where to read it
Mark Fielding Yeah. So, Brian, where can we read the echo chamber? Where can listeners find out more about your work, your project and get involved?
Brian Naughton Yeah, the echo chamber is on Kindle. I don't know if we'll be able to provide a link to... And also, it's a long URL, but I can provide the GitHub link, which contains the entire repository and the original manuscript in PDF format as well. So people are welcome to go there.
Mark Fielding Yeah, we'll be able to provide links.
Mark Fielding Awesome. We'll put all that on thinkingonpaper.xyz on our LinkedIn, our Instagram, our Twitter, our YouTube, all the channels, all the channels and our new substack that Jeremy's writing, substack thinkingonpaper.xyz. You'll find all the links there, all the links to Brian's work and Pocket Edition number one. Stay tuned. We're going to be talking about music, cinema. Who knows if the creative act is involving technology, we're going to be looking at it. Jeremy, final thoughts on that?
Jeremy Gilbertson Final thoughts really quick. So I think it's a great experiment. think it's a great, I would even dare I say a research study into like this idea of how humans and tech interact. I will say disruptors and curious minds, you still have one powerful human tool at your disposal and it was used to start this whole experiment.
Jeremy Gilbertson the art of asking a great question. Humans are still better at it today. Who knows what's gonna happen tomorrow, but those are my final thoughts. Syncing on paper.xyz. Brian, thanks for joining us. Be curious, stay disruptive.
Brian Naughton Thank you so much guys.




