Federico Faggin’s Irreducible, Chapter 9: What Is the Purpose of the Universe?

Mark reads out a line from chapter nine of Irreducible that he disagrees with. We instead are alive, even when our body is dead.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 18 chapters

  1. The prejudice is in us, not in nature
  2. Life as a classical phenomenon
  3. Hilbert space
  4. Seities and conscious units
  5. Another prejudice
  6. Science, or spirituality
  7. The creative principle
  8. Higher conscious beings
  9. If the One is everything, is it deterministic?
  10. The genome analogy
  11. Technical difficulties
  12. If your soul is the accumulation of consciousness
  13. Mark picks bones
  14. Alive even when the body is dead
  15. Borrowed ingredients
  16. Bringing spirituality and science together
  17. No growth equals death
  18. Carol Dweck, and the growth mindset
The universe wants to understand itself and it uses seities, i.e. conscious units, us, everything to get there on this continuous, never-ending, infinite search for knowing.
Mark Fielding

Mark and Jeremy read chapter nine of Federico Faggin's Irreducible, which argues that consciousness, free will and life exist from the very beginning as properties of the whole he calls One. They test the idea against Hilbert space, seities and conscious units.

Jeremy asks whether a single One driving everything would make the universe deterministic anyway. Mark rejects the idea that we live on after the body dies, and the pair close on growth, with a nod to Carol Dweck.

Irreducible by Federico Faggin, chapter 9, argues that materialism is not enough: consciousness came first, and stars, planets and living organisms derive from a deeper quantum reality of conscious entities he calls seities. Read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, the chapter rejects the idea that computers will become conscious and proposes that “One desires to know itself”.

What purpose does Faggin propose for the universe?

The purpose Faggin proposes is that “One desires to know itself”, through seities and the elementary conscious units, or CUs, they are built from.

What assumptions lie behind claims that computers will be conscious?

Predictions that computers will become conscious rest, Faggin argues, on two assumptions: “That consciousness emerges from the brain and that life is a classical phenomenon that can be reproduced by a computer.”

Where do consciousness and free will come from in Faggin's model?

In his model, consciousness, free will and life exist from the beginning as properties of a whole he calls One. Stars, planets and living organisms derive from a deeper quantum reality of seities.

Is Hilbert space real, according to Faggin?

Faggin treats Hilbert space as a real, larger reality, arguing that without one “it would be impossible to explain how quantum computers work.”

What does Jeremy ask about semantic distance and curiosity?

Jeremy asks whether the “semantic distance” between what we feel and the full meaning of a symbol is what drives curiosity.

Where Mark and Jeremy disagree

Mark rejects the claim that “We as seities are eternal”: “When you're done is done.” Jeremy asks whether one thing driving everything would make the universe deterministic after all.

Questions

What is the purpose of the universe?

The purpose Faggin proposes is that “One desires to know itself”, through seities and the elementary conscious units, or CUs, they are built from.

Is materialism enough, according to Federico Faggin?

Irreducible by Federico Faggin, chapter 9, argues that materialism is not enough: consciousness came first, and stars, planets and living organisms derive from a deeper quantum reality of conscious entities he calls seities.

Does Mark believe we live on after the body dies?

Mark rejects the idea that we live on after the body dies, and the pair close on growth, with a nod to Carol Dweck.

Will computers become conscious, according to Irreducible chapter 9?

Read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, the chapter rejects the idea that computers will become conscious and proposes that “One desires to know itself”.

Transcript

Mark Fielding disruptors and curious minds, CEOs, founders, book lovers. Welcome to the Thinking on Paper Book Club. I'm Mark. This is Jeremy. We're reading chapter nine of Irreducible by Federico Faggin And to quote AI, buckle up, ladies and gentlemen, because here we go. Materialism is wrong. The universe needs a new sheriff. Science needs a rethink. Should spiritualism and science combine?

The quantum fields that have the extraordinary property of explaining chemistry are drastically different from the atoms of Democritus that inspired classical physics. Those are the ones that gave us the materialism and the determinism that still dominate our thought. It is precisely on the basis of these prejudices that many thinkers believe that computers will be conscious in the future. Their prediction is based on two fellatious? No.

Jeremy Gilbertson Whoa, wait a minute.

The prejudice is in us, not in nature

Mark Fielding It is precisely on the basis of these prejudice that many thinkers believe that computers will be conscious in the future. Their prediction is based on two assumptions. That consciousness emerges from the brain and that life is a classical phenomenon that can be reproduced by a computer. Therefore, according to their theories, we are simply the body, i.e. a deterministic machine because living cells are considered classical systems rather than quantum classical. And when the body dies, everything fatally ends.

If this were the case, our future would indeed be hopeless. And then he goes on to propose his new model. In the model I propose, as I have already anticipated, consciousness, free will and life exist from the very beginning as constitutive properties of the holistic whole, what he refers to as ONE from now on.

that also contains other properties that allowed the evolution of the inanimate universe. According to this model, the inanimate universe did not come first, but derives from a deeper quantum reality inhabited by seities with consciousness and free will that communicate meaning with each other. That process has gradually created a symbolic reality that contains live and classical information.

This symbolic reality is a physical correlate of the ever-increasing self-knowing of the seities that has given existence to stars, planets and living organisms when it is perceived through the quantum classical information system we call the human body. Jeremy, help me.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yes, sir. Yeah, man. That's yeah, this this is let's see Where do we even start with this? So that I think the first note that I wrote here like on the first page of the chapter was silly scientists You believe everything could be explained like that that write it off and and and in this idea he talks about the the back-and-forth between people scientists questioning the absurdity of things that they don't understand and the absurdity of how nature operates, but where he says basically the absurdity is within the fundamental laws that are, that have to be deterministic, right? So this, we have to explain it. has to have a reason. has to, oh boy, it has.

Mark Fielding Yeah, the absurdity isn't in nature, the absurdity is in our prejudice.

Jeremy Gilbertson 100%, well said, well said. Well, well read from the book. So, all right, so he talks early on in here about the idea of AI being conscious and how wrong that is. You talked about it through two false assumptions that people are operating under, that consciousness emerges from the brain, whereas we're kind of revamped panpsychism where it's a fundamental aspect.

Mark Fielding So he said, well, I didn't say that. Federico Faggin said that. Well read from the book.

Life as a classical phenomenon

Jeremy Gilbertson and the false assumption that life is a classical phenomenon, right? You know, we are quantum classical machines in both of these things. So let's get to the seities Let's get to the seities. Yeah.

Mark Fielding Hold on, did we not get to the Hilbert space before the seities no, the seities come first. No, Hilbert's a new perspective. Hilbert space.

Jeremy Gilbertson Ooh, Hilbert. Sure, sure.

I think it's a little bit of both, right? So here I thought it was really interesting that he talks about, know, quantum again doesn't describe any outer reality, quantum describes inner reality. He highlights this actually, like, guys, we would get on well and better if we just understood that One thing, that quantum doesn't explain anything outside of us, it explains.

the inside of us, the inner. I sat with that for a little bit. I thought that was pretty interesting.

Mark Fielding Well, as we get into later, the outer is actually a result of the inner.

Hilbert space

Jeremy Gilbertson it all flips together, right? So, Hilbert space, complex N dimensional Hilbert space. So you and I talked right before we started recording in this idea that, if a vaster reality is what he says, if a vaster reality, than what is measurable in space time didn't exist, we couldn't explain quantum computers. We couldn't explain how quantum computers work, right? And we've seen quantum computers work. There's gotta be this, this thing that explains the math of everything. And then you and I both landed on that same analogy, like, okay, dark matter is this thing that makes the math equations work where we can't really still explain what it is. So maybe Hilbert space is a similar situation. Did you land on that too?

Mark Fielding Yeah, we should note for the listener that Federico doesn't mention dark matter. We're just talking about connecting dots. Hilbert space, every time I've read the word Hilbert space in anything we've done quantum, I've just kind of ignored it and accepted it as being there on the page. I can get around entropy, but Hilbert space, but this little paragraph here I've written in the margins, where do quantum computers calculate question mark?

Jeremy Gilbertson like entropy like when entropy kept coming up

Mark Fielding According to the current conception of quantum physics, the physical universe is the result of the collapse of the wave function that describes the universe in a complex n-dimensional Hilbert space, where n can be infinite. Until now, Hilbert space has been considered an abstract space, a mathematical idealisation devoid of any physical reality. However, if there wasn't a vaster reality than the One manifested in space-time, it would be impossible to explain how quantum computers work.

Jeremy Gilbertson So I actually, I told you this, I had to do a little bit of investigation a little bit deeper into Hilbert space. I'm not a mathematician by any stretch of the equation, but One thing came up that in my kind of looking into this was Hilbert space is what they call a vector space. And by they mathematicians that are far more in tune with math than myself, but

Basically what it is is a collection of math things operating by a set of rules, right? In its very simplest form. And then Sean Carroll, who's a theoretical physicist that I ran across in my research, defined Hilbert space as the space of all possible quantum wave function. So wave functions. I thought that was pretty interesting. And it starts off with this, what they call a humble vector, where you just have like an X and a Y, right?

and just X and a Y here. And then you have this other line coming out of that humble vector that basically creates these three points, right? And you look at those and you go, okay, I understand that One thing and that small piece of this, but then you extend that out to infinity. Like infinity possibilities, infinite possibilities, the whole nine yards. So I'm not here to explain.

Hilbert space, I'm just talking through that I may kind of small percentage understand that it's a space of all possible quantum wave functions. Thank you, Sean Carroll.

Mark Fielding you sure? Somebody just googled or perplexed what is Hilbert space and they're going to get your answer now. In this new model, Hilbert space is the mathematical description of a vast reality in which seities and other conscious entities could exist and in which the physical reality perceived by our body emerges. We already know that what is measurable in space time is only a small portion of the greater reality in which quantum states and live symbols exist. Right.

Jeremy Gilbertson Sean Carroll's answer, yeah.

Seities and conscious units

Mark Fielding Jeremy, what is the difference before we get to seites? What's the difference between the concepts of field and what Federico Faggin calls One? Because I think that's important before we get into seites and life after death.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, way I, I got to cascade One down, right? So I might be going too far, but just let me talk through this, right? So he has this idea of One it's like this collection of all the things, right? All the things, all the possible things. And One wants to understand itself. If we were to personify it, One wants to understand itself. So what does One do? One dispatches these seities to,

Jeremy Gilbertson communicate using particular rules. This sounds like a Hilbert space. You know, participate in this space that has rules. Sounds like Hilbert space, right? So these seities are communicating semantic, symbolic, the whole thing. But in order to do that, they again distribute consciousness units or CUs, right? And the CUs are what help the seities know themselves, which helps

Mark Fielding Sounds like something.

Jeremy Gilbertson the One know itself, then this sounds like, guys, you're probably listening to this going, what the ever loving.

Mark Fielding Do you, does not, it's like a seity and a CU a Conscious Unit, not the same thing? for.

Jeremy Gilbertson I don't think, I think seities are collections of CUs. That's what I think. Kind like the brain's a collection of neurons in a way, maybe.

Mark Fielding Okay, I missed.

Another prejudice

Mark Fielding Okay. However, before proceeding any further, I must point out another fundamental difference between the concepts of field and One. In the universe described by physics, there can be no purpose and no meaning since its fields are inanimate. On the other hand, if we assume that consciousness and free will always existed as properties of One, they must also be present in the quantum fields that emerged from it. If we say that the field is also conscious and has free will, then the field is another name for One.

There must also be a reason that justifies the presumed existence of seities and the most sensible one I can imagine is that One desires to know itself, which is what you said.

Science, or spirituality

Jeremy Gilbertson This is such a blurred line between science and spirituality. I think it's like, and I think everything, when you really try to understand everything, I think you're always living in that pool with science and spirituality kind of combined. And he talks about...

Mark Fielding Why do you say spirituality, not religion?

Jeremy Gilbertson To me, religion has a narrative, a particular narrative, a particular set of rules, a particular Hilbert space, right? I think spirituality is thinking bigger than yourself, I think, is knowing that there is something beyond you that you're connected to in some way or some form. Not, hey, this is the way that everything's connected. That's religion.

I think spirituality is a knowing and a willingness to understand, try to understand, right? Without someone forcing you into a deterministic narrative.

Mark Fielding think it's hard to read this chapter without thinking of spiritualism, without thinking of religion, without thinking of God, without thinking of the One. The One being everything and the One wants to understand itself. The universe wants to understand itself and it uses seities, i.e. conscious units, us, everything to get there on this continuous, never-ending, infinite search for knowing. It's like, forget turtles and forget qubits

It's knowing all the way down. It's like this, Descartes to infinity. And it's,

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, the knowing too, the knowing and this communication between the seities is what he says is knowing. And it's a constant knowing, a constant evolution of knowing. That is a correlate to the physical world that we see. So the knowing from the seities is what projects what we see in the physical world. This is getting, I know guys, don't turn, hold on, on, hold on, to the listener, hang with us.

The creative principle

Mark Fielding Is it the creative principle?

Jeremy Gilbertson You know, we're not telling you this is what it is. We're talking through what Federico Faggin believes what it is. yeah, this is heavy shit, dude.

Mark Fielding Yeah, yeah, he's trying to bring together, connect the dots between spiritualism and science. And so the creative principle is this, the One being everything, search for knowing, he calls the creative principle saying that reality contains consciousness and free will from the beginning implies the existence of a creative principle that gives purpose, meaning and direction to the universe. think this principle could be the following One wants.

to know itself, to fulfil itself, and thus to enjoy and love its own existence. All creation exists for the pure joy of God. The work of creation was a work of joy, the purpose of which was to instil more joy into existence. For some reason, I've written in the margin here, aliens. And so consciousness, our consciousness, are, seities is, we have the meaning of the meaning of us is to know more.

and we help the One to know itself. And obviously we've spoken in the past about these layers of consciousness. My consciousness is not the same as a donkey's consciousness. A donkey's consciousness is not the same as a lion or a flea, or, and then it goes down, down, down. And then at One point, I think the building, shouldn't call them building blocks. It doesn't make sense. Like a protein, seity plus an electron, seity equals a hydrogen seity So they've all got consciousness. But yeah, where do...

Jeremy Gilbertson That may be close.

Higher conscious beings

Mark Fielding in the far reaches of space if these higher conscious beings exist, how are they feeding into the One, to the seity to the consciousness, to the knowing for this, what he calls the One?

If the One is everything, is it deterministic?

Jeremy Gilbertson So if there's the One, I had a question here. If the One is here and the One wants to know itself by dispatching seities and seities want to know themselves by dispatching consciousness units.

Isn't it? Wouldn't it all be deterministic anyway because there's One thing driving it all?

Mark Fielding Say that again, sorry.

Jeremy Gilbertson So if the One was the top of the show and everything interconnects to this One, and the One wants to know itself, there's a personification of the One a little bit, right? So that would mean it's One thing, it's an identity.

Mark Fielding But it's everything.

Jeremy Gilbertson It's everything collective.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah. All right. So here's a here's a reference that I actually

Mark Fielding I'm just going to just before you go on, I'm going to read this just to clarify for myself really. In the previous chapter, I called an elementary seity CU. CU is the simplest part whole, i.e. the simplest quantum system that can contain the essence of the whole and possesses an identity that once created can no longer be extinguished. A CU is like a living cell that reproduces and combines with other cells to create ever more complex organisms. The CUs are conscious fields with free will.

agency and identity that communicate with each other to deepen their own self-knowing. It is important to realise that since each CU is a part whole of One, she can only increase her self-knowing by interacting with the other CUs through symbolic communications.

Jeremy Gilbertson So what does that sound like to you? Like what, and I was just about to say this before you read it, but what is similar to that, the part whole?

Mark Fielding I don't know what is similar to that. What are you thinking?

The genome analogy

Jeremy Gilbertson So think about the genome cells and genome, right? So your cell basically has like each individual cell has a copy of all of the information to make another cell, right? So there's this part whole thing. He used an analogy of that, I think with, with CUs and seities to cells and genome. So I'm still here.

Technical difficulties

Mark Fielding Hold on, I've lost you, hold on. I can't hear you. Speak.

Jeremy Gilbertson Hello, hello. Yo, I'm seeing level on my side.

Jeremy Gilbertson Does your headphones come up?

Jeremy Gilbertson Yo check in check in.

Mark Fielding I've lost your voice. Hold on.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, that sounded like you just plugged something in. Checking again, checking again. Yellow. Yellow. Green. Red. Purple. Blue.

Mark Fielding Have you muted yourself?

Jeremy Gilbertson I have not, have not.

I still, hold on, I'll get in the chat function here.

Mark Fielding and can hear me.

Mark Fielding Just keep speaking, Jeremy.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yep, yep, yep, yep. Now I'm hearing an echo. You might be coming through your speakers.

Mark Fielding I've just turned it on to my speakers. can hear now it's not coming out of the headphones for some reason.

Jeremy Gilbertson Jiggle, twist the headphones in. No, no echo now.

Mark Fielding You still got an echo now.

Jeremy Gilbertson Sometimes the ring isn't sitting maybe. Yo, I'm gonna start saying colors again. Blue, magenta, red.

Mark Fielding Okay, I'm going to have to continue with.

Jeremy Gilbertson Burnt sienna. Yeah, I don't hear any echo.

Mark Fielding Can you speak now? I'm going to have to use the audio. I don't know if my headphones will just stop working.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yo, or forever hold your peace.

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay. now I got echo. Echo, echo.

Mark Fielding Sorry, do you remember where you were?

Jeremy Gilbertson Echo. Echo.

Mark Fielding I want an echo.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, echo on your side. Alright, not anymore. Can you hear me?

Mark Fielding Yeah, I can hear you.

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, yeah, no echo.

Mark Fielding Okay, sorry, don't know what happened then. Do you remember where you were?

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, no idea. I think we were talking genome. echo again.

Mark Fielding Do you know, oh, that was your, yeah, that was your idea. No, I don't know what, what are you thinking?

Jeremy Gilbertson Echo again.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, okay. All right, it's better now. We're good. I lost my flow, dude.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, I think we landed on the part whole. I think we landed that plane with the genome, insidies, and consciousness units.

Let's look at, let's look at, I got echo again my guy.

Jeremy Gilbertson All right, no, it's like kind of, we'll just have to deal with it. I'll just try to put it out.

Mark Fielding Just give me a second. I'm gonna check, see if I can make it work. Cause you've got 20 minutes, haven't you? Like what?

Mark Fielding stopped working.

Jeremy Gilbertson You still can't hear me?

Mark Fielding So we get echo if you speak there.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yo. Yeah, it's like an off and on. Can you hear me now?

Mark Fielding You get an echo now.

Jeremy Gilbertson Check, check, nope, can you hear me? Okay.

Mark Fielding I can hear you,

Jeremy Gilbertson Let's see, back into this.

All right, we talked, where do we wanna go? let's talk about this idea of semantic distance. Did you run across that?

Mark Fielding That's your specialty is semantics. So semantics.

Jeremy Gilbertson So yeah, so back to comprehension, right? So comprehension allows CUs not only to recognize the meaning carried by the qualia, remember qualia are just the signal of things happening in the environment that you internalize into semantic meaning, But also serve to sense the semantic distance between the meaning felt and the full meaning of the symbol. It's kind of interesting. So to me, as I read that, I'm thinking, you know, what I feel from qualia may not always be the full potential of what I could feel from that qualia. And this talks about the gap, the semantic distance between that. Maybe I'm not perceiving all that can be perceived internally from the qualia, which like to me is kind of crazy. And what does the math of that look like? But therefore here again, quote, therefore what is not yet comprehended produces the feeling that there is more to know than what has been recognized. So I put a note in here. I'm like,

Is curiosity a vehicle for consciousness? And like do CUs activate curiosity based on the gap between what was felt and the potential of all that could be felt?

Mark Fielding He says that kind of creativity is and this need for knowing, mean, creativity and a need for knowing, that's curiosity. Combine those two, isn't it? So I say yes. Before on a page on about page 200, it starts to get a little bit Monty Python for me. It's like, do you know One of those scenes where John Cleese and

Mark Fielding Michael Palin are just talking nonsense in a circle around and around and around and around and it just starts to feel a little bit like that. This knowing loop that he comes to, this type of knowing is linked to existence like the two sides of the same coin, because to exist is to know the meaning and to know the meaning is to exist. The pure quantum state is just an abstract state that is useful to represent the knowing of the seity that becomes what it knows.

The interesting aspect of quantum information is that it has the essential characteristics of what it represents since it is definite and cannot be reproduced, i.e. it is private just like the knowing of the seity is. In this sense, quantum information represents the interiority of the universe, what can only be known by being it.

Jeremy Gilbertson You're cracklin'. You're cracklin' a little bit. Like your audio's cracklin'.

Jeremy Gilbertson It's gotta be the headphones crackling maybe.

Sounds okay now, but it was like it caught ya.

Mark Fielding Let's go and see if we can get some of the headphones.

Mark Fielding Okay, new headphones.

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay. All right.

Mark Fielding New headphones. Still can't hear you. Why is there no sound coming out?

Jeremy Gilbertson still got level.

Mark Fielding Maybe it's this.

Jeremy Gilbertson Check, check, check, check, check, check. You can or you can't?

Mark Fielding hear that though.

Mark Fielding Literally, why has it just stopped working?

Jeremy Gilbertson Check, check, check, check, check.

Jeremy Gilbertson What does your speaker say?

Mark Fielding It's not gonna work, Jeremy, I don't know what's happened.

Jeremy Gilbertson What does your speaker say?

Jeremy Gilbertson Pop me out on the speakers again.

Jeremy Gilbertson Pull the headphones out.

Mark Fielding can't hear you. It's just not working.

Mark Fielding I've tried pulling headphones out.

Jeremy Gilbertson Are they out right now?

Mark Fielding That's the new recording track.

Jeremy Gilbertson So you can hear me now?

Mark Fielding Yeah, can't. I it works. can hear you.

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, so your microphone is out now, I think. I think your microphone is, check your

Jeremy Gilbertson Look at the mic button on the bottom.

Mark Fielding Yeah, it's not given the other options.

Jeremy Gilbertson Does it show your mic in there?

Jeremy Gilbertson where your headphones plugged into.

Mark Fielding Nothing's changed from where it's all been. If I refresh this browser, that's not going to do anything, it? If you're in here, that's okay. It'll just create a new track.

Jeremy Gilbertson Dun-dun-dun!

Mark Fielding Okay, that's everything in. Can you speak?

Jeremy Gilbertson Check in. Check, check, check.

Mark Fielding Okay, that's working now, everything's back on.

Jeremy Gilbertson Sounds like your mic's back too.

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, you have gremlins dude, you got gremlins.

Mark Fielding Get back into this stuff. stopped again. What is going on?

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah? No, you can't hear me?

Jeremy Gilbertson Hmm. Check. Checka, checka.

Mark Fielding It's hard to do this, hard to get back into it.

Jeremy Gilbertson The depth of these topics, yeah, the pausing is tough. You can hear me now though? All right, let's try to get our heads back around and see if we can land this plane here. Where was I going? Okay, I'm ready. Are you ready? Okay, I wrote this in the margin. seity equals soul. What's your take on that?

Mark Fielding Yeah, I can hear you now.

Mark Fielding Yeah, let's go.

If your soul is the accumulation of consciousness

Mark Fielding Well, yeah, if your soul is the accumulation of your consciousness, then that works.

Jeremy Gilbertson Here's the sentence that caused me to write that. A living organism is both quantum and classical and can host the consciousness and free will of a quantum seity because the seity can communicate directly with the body using live information. But guess what? It doesn't. This is where it gets funky. I mean, it's been funky for the whole chapter here, but not because we don't believe you, Federico Faggin. It's just very new information and we're trying to get our heads around it.

Mark Fielding I did read that, yeah, I didn't understand.

Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, okay. So they're irreversible and reversible atomic transformations, which what in the world? So irreversible means that you can't, can't try again. No do over. You don't respawn in the video game. Is that what it is?

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, so that's the One case where a wave collapse is not necessary. that's...

Mark picks bones

Mark Fielding Can I pick bones? Okay, I'm gonna, you said we don't believe Federico or we don't agree with Federico.

Jeremy Gilbertson I didn't say that. I didn't say that. It's not that we don't. Yeah. Okay.

Mark Fielding Well, I'm disagreeing here and I want to know what you think about this and we'll know what our listeners think about this. Quote, a robot automatically repeats what its human programmer makes it say because it has no life and no consciousness, even though it moves and appears to be alive. We instead are alive, even when our body is dead. We exist in a greater reality, which also contains what we call physical reality. And when our bodies die, we don't die. Death.

is the next rebirth that is given to us as a gift in the spiritual universe. We as seities are eternal. When the designer of a robot claims that the feeling is identical to the symbol for the feeling if he's not okay. We as seities are eternal. Discuss.

Jeremy Gilbertson So you don't agree with that?

Mark Fielding We instead are alive even when our body is dead,

Jeremy Gilbertson So once you're done, you're done?

Alive even when the body is dead

Mark Fielding Yeah. And this, this has always been my, well, One of them, One of my blocking points in this. I know. Yeah. When you're done is done.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, I mean, there's been ton of different interpretations of this, you know, within spirituality, within religion, which is kind of spirituality with a directed narrative, right?

Basically, say it's a bit of like the reincarnation side of the fence or the afterlife of Christianity. Yeah, but no One's ever been. Have you been or do you not remember? Yeah.

Mark Fielding I think maybe if you wanted to unpack that, sure if we had Federico Faggin on here, who'd probably or perhaps say that that's not what he means, like reincarnation, life after death is not what he's getting to. If we are, if we are seities, if we are conscious entities and that goes all the way down to the, to the classical model, and every One of those is a seity, we just belong to the...

to the One so all of our fundamental conscious units just.

break down because and they go off again somewhere else. So like our collective whole.

doesn't continue, but our, the quantum particles, the particles that makes up, they go on. It's that entropy, it? The energy goes somewhere else.

Borrowed ingredients

Jeremy Gilbertson Maybe we're just, maybe we're just, maybe our bodies are just borrowing pieces of the One. You know, we're, we're just, we're organized. If you think about it, like science has proven that things that we see are just organizations of collections of things moving at a certain speed for a particular timeframe. Right. And that's what we are. We're collections of things moving at a particular speed that's going to be organized.

Jeremy Gilbertson for a specific time period, unknown to us, maybe known to something else, but maybe they're just kind of borrowed ingredients, right? We spin up just like a quark. Yo, there's a quark, it's a up quark, and then it kind of interacts and turns into something else, Interactions of the field. is, wow, this is,

Mark Fielding Yeah. But that's the whole, this whole new thing, isn't it? Like we're not, it's not about my soul going off somewhere else and doing something else, is it? It's about kind of my, the trillion bits that make me going off somewhere else. Worm food. I'm worm, we're all worm food. We're all worm food. Yeah.

Jeremy Gilbertson Your borrowed ingredients, your borrowed ingredients are reorganized.

my gosh, dude. Yeah. Yeah, guys, this is, this is real time processing of, of very complex, and counter, counter narratives to how things are explained. Remember we talked to the beginning, you know, science tries to understand everything. If we could understand, if we understood everything, free will wouldn't exist. We'd be in a deterministic situation, which largely most of us believe that, that we do have free will. let's see.

Let's try and land this plane here, man. Here, how about this? So, theories of reality. So a theory of reality is only a mathematical model, a theory of reality is only a mathematical model of the measurable events occurring in space time. So just in space time, like that's kind of funky. So going back to Kevin Kelly episode.

and going back to your desire to have AI be conscious, thinking that AI is truly intelligent, meaning true intelligence would have, I think it would be consciousness. think let's be loose with that interpretation. Thinking that AI is truly intelligent when it can only imitate human behavior, devoid of meaning is a grave misunderstanding to what occurs when a theory of reality is confused with reality. But reality is only an inner, reality is a semantic knowing. Like my reality is different than your reality, right? And then me explaining my reality to you turns it from semantics to symbolic. And maybe I don't grasp, like they said, maybe I don't grasp, maybe there's a semantic divide, what did he call it? Semantic distance between my interpretation of qualia and

Jeremy Gilbertson the full potential interpretation of qualia. Wow, dude, this is like, this is a lot.

Bringing spirituality and science together

Mark Fielding Yeah, this is a lot. think that...

He is bringing together spirituality and science to create this new understanding of consciousness, the universe. I really want our listeners to comment on his, you know, we instead are alive even when our body is dead. I'd really like if anyone's read this book, if you've read it, drop your comments on how you think about that. And I'm going to leave you with this.

No growth equals death

Mark Fielding Life is growth. If we stop growing technically and spiritually, we are theoretically dead. So regardless of whether your consciousness is fundamental to the universe, regardless of whether when you pop your clogs, your consciousness will disintegrate down into an infinite number of pieces and go off into the One as individual conscious units and seities Who knows? You are conscious growth.

is everything. No growth equals death. Stasis. Stasis is death. Now get out there, wield your consciousness, do something with your consciousness. Whatever that is, grow, love, care, ask. Be curious, be creative. Jeremy, what are you going to do with your consciousness?

Carol Dweck, and the growth mindset

Jeremy Gilbertson First I'm gonna give shouts to Carol Dweck and the growth mindset We're connecting dots. Yeah. Yeah growth is where it's at push the boundaries just like we're pushing the boundaries man You saw us for the last 39 minutes fumble through What we try to figure out here and put yourself in situations where you're fumbling through stuff make your brain work make your consciousness work and Try to generate understanding and meaning it'll help the cause it'll help everything

Jeremy Gilbertson Thanks for listening guys www.Thinkingonpaper.xyz got a ton of great episodes coming up We're nearing the end of this book if you have a book recommendation pop it in the comments We will consider it for the next One mark closing thoughts

Mark Fielding Yeah. Join us next week for chapter possibly 10 and 11, the nature of the seity and the evolution of the seities. I think those two chapters go hand in hand. We've got Walt Whitman, we've got consciousness as quantum property fields and who knows all lots of other good stuff. So join us for that thing on our paper to XYZ. Be disruptive, stay curious.

Jeremy Gilbertson Keep thinking on paper.

Mark Fielding Keep reading books.