Federico Faggin’s Irreducible, Chapter 10: Is Meditation a Quantum Phenomenon?
Jeremy argues that what we cannot measure may still be part of the universe. Just because we can't hear a sound that happens below 20 hertz doesn't mean the sound's not there.
In this episode · 13 chapters
Books should make you feel weird. Books should mess up your mind a little bit.
Chapter 10 of Federico Faggin's Irreducible sets out the seity, a reality Faggin says goes beyond all categories and definitions. Mark and Jeremy disagree over how much credibility designing the first microprocessor lends him, and ask why seities create only two new worlds.
They work through the vibration sphere, Carl Jung's collective unconscious, the ego's identification with the body and why meditation matters if Faggin is right. Jeremy's position: “Consciousness doesn't come from organic matter.”
Federico Faggin's Irreducible, chapter 10, explores the seity, Faggin's term for a conscious entity with free will, and how seities create and share the worlds they experience. Read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, the chapter leads Mark Fielding to say that if Faggin is right, meditation “becomes even more valuable than it ever was”.
Why does meditation matter if Faggin is right?
If Faggin is right, Mark says, meditation “becomes even more valuable than it ever was”.
What is a seity in Federico Faggin's Irreducible?
A seity “cannot be defined in the same way that a machine can be,” Faggin writes, because its consciousness, identity, free will, agency and creativity are inseparable and have no sharp boundaries.
How do seities create interconnected worlds?
Seities create interconnected worlds by accepting or rejecting undecidable axioms. Faggin’s example is geometry: Euclid’s postulates, and the alternatives that Riemann and Lobachevsky built.
What is Faggin's vibration sphere?
Faggin’s “vibration sphere” pictures shared physical reality as a square full of people and animals whose sounds everyone present can hear.
Why does the ego identify with the body, according to Faggin?
The ego, Faggin suggests, identifies with the body so that choices feel authentic rather than part of a simulation. When it takes over completely, it believes the body’s senses are all there is.
Where Mark and Jeremy disagree
Jeremy asks why rejecting an axiom creates only two new worlds, and Mark calls one passage “so ludicrous” he won’t comment. Jeremy’s shortcut to the whole book: “inner semantic is quantum, outer symbolic is classical.”
Links from this episode
Questions
Is meditation a quantum phenomenon?
If Faggin is right, Mark says, meditation “becomes even more valuable than it ever was”.
What is chapter 10 of Irreducible about?
Federico Faggin's Irreducible, chapter 10, explores the seity, Faggin's term for a conscious entity with free will, and how seities create and share the worlds they experience.
What did Federico Faggin design?
Mark and Jeremy disagree over how much credibility designing the first microprocessor lends him, and ask why seities create only two new worlds.
Does Jeremy think consciousness comes from organic matter?
Jeremy's position: “Consciousness doesn't come from organic matter.”
Transcript
Mark Fielding disruptors and curious minds, CEOs, founders, book lovers. Welcome to the Thinking on Paper Book Club. As always, I am Mark. This is Jeremy. We're closing in on the end of Irreducible by Federico Faggin. What have we learned so far? We've learned that the universe is conscious, that the existing way that we look, possibly look, at the universe and everything in it is wrong. And Federico has designed a blueprint.
how we should think about it and essentially it combines spiritualism and quantum mechanics into a new, what does he call it? Quantum information based panpsychism. Today we're on chapter 10, the nature of the seity and good news people, we are not digital and finite. We are vastness, potentially beyond all limits. I know it with certainty in my innermost being because I have experienced it.
But the description of a pure state with words is impossible because a pure state is not reproducible. And thus words will never be able to capture the full meaning intimately disclosed by a sentient experience. We all have already experienced this limitation and physics is also telling us this much. Jeremy, the nature of the seity. Discuss
Jeremy Gilbertson So just a quick reminder everybody that what we're about to discuss and at the last few chapters, if you've been following along, we've been tiptoeing deeper into the unknown, deeper into the, he said seity wow, he said consciousness unit. And the thing to remember, this guy designed and produced the first microprocessor. So we gotta give him a little bit of a.
little bit of leeway right as he explores these more ethereal components right because with that it doesn't make him right but it but it but it gives him a little bit of dare I say credibility with this because without him we would not be doing this book club we would not be capturing this live not live but capturing this and recording it we wouldn't be seeing each other wouldn't be able to email back and forth all our whatsapp back and forth and all of these things that we do to make our show possible so anyway
Mark Fielding Yeah, it doesn't make him right, but it makes...
Where Mark disagrees
Mark Fielding I disagree with that because I think if the universe is conscious and the universe is creative, then one of those conscious units would have merged with another conscious unit, created a seity and that seity would have come to the similar conclusions that Federico Faggin did back in the 70s and designed the first microprocessor.
Jeremy Gilbertson That sounds very deterministic, Mark. I highly disagree with that.
Mark Fielding There are many thinkers who would like us to believe that we are just machines and that it would be possible to create machines that are smarter than us.
Jeremy Gilbertson But are those machines willing to capture and incarnate seities? I think that's the big thing that I read on this whole thing. Like if a computer can pull a seity into itself, then all bets are off. But since computers are made of purely classical pieces and parts, and we are classical and quantum, maybe that saves everybody from that future nightmare.
For the time being. All right, so as I dove into this mark, a couple of notes that I have here. Defining things limits the magic. New laws equal more constraints. So this has been a theme in the book that's a little bit funky, but I understand it. We as humans want to basically measure and quantify everything, and we can't. Because we don't have the...
Mark Fielding for the time being.
Jeremy Gilbertson the signal reading ability sometimes, and I'll give you a prime example of this. Just because we can't hear a sound that happens below 20 hertz doesn't mean the sound's not there. We just don't have the machine, the protocol, to process sounds below 20 hertz and sounds above 20,000 hertz. We can't see gamma rays with our own eyes, right? We need assistance with that. So just because something's not there, just because we can't define it, does not mean it is not part of the universe. So there you have that.
Seity defined
Mark Fielding Completely agreed. Well, I agree. So before we get into, he touches on many worlds theories. speaks about the ego and this is not Freud, ladies and gentlemen. This is something entirely different. The vibrational universe. Just before you get into it, I'm going to read a seity, the definition, not the definition, because he says that definitions can't really define, but.
In my model, a seity is a reality that goes beyond all categories and all definitions. A seity cannot be defined in the same way that a machine can be, since its properties, namely consciousness, identity, free will agency and creativity are inseparable and do not have sharp boundaries. We have already discovered with quantum physics that reality goes far beyond the one described by classical physics, though we are still struggling to understand, as you said.
Seity in many worlds
Jeremy Gilbertson The seity, so seity in many worlds, let's start there. So seities can create different worlds. That's a quote from the book here. Seities can create different worlds. We know the many worlds theory, many worlds interpretation, right? So there's, it's the, it's, you know, this observation creates this reality and there are millions of other observations that could create other realities upon realities upon realities. right? So he uses an interesting example of Euclidean geometry.
Jeremy Gilbertson illustrate this idea of like the multiple worlds that seities could create. So I wrote this down as I was running through this. You alright, so you have the world that is operating based on a certain axiom, a certain truth, and then you have the opposite of that. So you have, I believe in the world that I'm seeing, I don't believe in the world I'm seeing, but somehow the seities create just two other options, which I thought was like really weird. So you have
Yeah, you have, I believe in this axiom defining this world. I don't believe it. There's option number one, option number two, and then two more adventurous options created by the seity Now, did you read that as like seities can create just two options of worlds? Like I thought that was real. I gotta find where that was. Did you read that?
Mark Fielding I'll finish your intro sentence there. The seities can create many different worlds which are all interconnected and exist one inside the other. Their fundamental connections are determined by the universal language created by the first level seities, the CUs, the conscious units. This is the world that contains all other worlds, the language from which all other languages have emerged and through which one, as we learned last week, one is everything. That is the universe, the universal one.
which you can, I'm sure you have your own interpretations of what that means. And one can explore every possibility of knowing itself. And then he speaks about your axioms. Seities who choose to explore the undecidable hypothesis if it were true, adding it as a new axiom to the pre-existing ones. The second world contains the seities that choose to explore the undecidable hypothesis in the negative.
thus a portion of the seities decides to reject the undecidable axiom while two other groups choose to explore two new and logically far less secure worlds. To answer your question...
Why two worlds?
Jeremy Gilbertson Why two? Why two? Federico, why two worlds? If there's so much possibility in these seities to be able to do so much and connect and speak, why can they only create two additional worlds to the positive and negative of the one that's around? That's my question. Seems very constraining, very, very, yeah.
Mark Fielding And he also says, he says logically far less secure worlds as well, which are we missing something in that?
Jeremy Gilbertson This is one of those things where, let's see, all right, well, let's go through his Euclid example as I understand it. So you have Euclidean geometry, right, that has, these five postulates, right, these five axioms or truths, like a straight line can be drawn between any two points, a finite straight line can be extended indefinitely. You have these five truths that define Euclidean geometry, but enter Riemann and Lobachevsky.
where they have different interpretations of those rules. They don't buy in the whole parallel line thing. One buys in, they cross, eventually cross, and one buys in, they ultimately diverge. So this is an example he uses from the seity creating alternate interpretations of axioms, which I actually had to look up the five postulates, but...
Mark Fielding I, yeah, you kill a, it's beyond me this bit. So I will let you, I'll go with your opinion on that. What I do like is the way that he describes more adventurous, seities the seities who decided, the seities who decided, who decided to reject the new axiom could continue to explore their world, ignoring the two new worlds being explored by the more adventurous seity I'd like to meet.
Jeremy Gilbertson Is that you and I? Are we the more adventurous ones?
Jeremy Gilbertson Those seities are Gen X, Gen X seities
Mark Fielding I'd like to meet a more adventurous seity I mean, it's giving them personalities, more adventurous seities. It's such a strange concept.
Quantum mechanics as the language
Jeremy Gilbertson So is quantum mechanics though, which again, you point back to it, I all this shit is strange, right? But no matter how disconnected these seities become in these new worlds that they create to explore and all of that, they have this common language that pulls them back to the One right? And this like in the computer world, like in the networking world, you have like Cisco routers make up computer networks, right? And they have something called command line interface, CLI.
that is this ultimate basic programming language that allows literally any Cisco router to be communicated with using this. So similar analogy, the seities have a command line interface that only seities understand. No matter how far they go, no matter how weird they adventure out into these different worlds, they always have a loop back in. That's how I understood.
Mark Fielding I don't know. It's important to note that the seities who explore these insecure worlds may lose their connection with the world of fundamental indisputable values because they may not realize how many undecidable axioms they have taken as true or false. So maybe the two things is true or false. I don't want to even comment on this because it's so ludicrous.
Jeremy Gilbertson You almost made me snot on that one. That was funny.
Mark Fielding These alternative worlds where these seities have gone based on an axiom that may or may not be true, creating this other world, is that where the quantum computers are solving their puzzles?
Jeremy Gilbertson I don't know, it's almost like there's just interdependency between these little actions and decisions, kind of butterfly effecty kind of stuff. So you jump into this new world, you do this one thing, it has cascading effects down the line and down the line and down the line based on I went with this axiom or that axiom or this new axiom or this one that I created. And before you know it, you're spun around going where the hell am I? At least that's what the seity's saying. I'm personifying the seity again.
Mark Fielding A less enterprising seity I feel like today. Well, let's try. So how does this world work? So to get an idea of how this world might work, let's try to imagine a large square with hundreds of people and animals that emit perceptible vibrations like sounds. Vibrations are abstract symbols, whereas sounds are the qualia that bring meaning to each entity, seity. The vibrations produced by the various participants spread throughout the square and can be perceived by all present.
The vibration sphere
Mark Fielding This creates a vibration sphere, an objective and shared physical reality in which all the information produced by the various entities is accessible to each of them. And then he gives an example of Bob and Alice conversing.
Jeremy Gilbertson The vibe sphere, baby. The vibe sphere. Holy cow.
Mark Fielding The symbols are the vibrations of the air produced by the larynx of one that are captured by the hearing of the other. Hearing is extremely sophisticated because it allows the listener to select with free will certain frequencies and convert them into symbols of interest while ignoring all others.
Jeremy Gilbertson kids do that all the time when we give them directions they choose to choose to mute out that frequency sometimes people in political debates automatically reduce those frequencies. no this I mean alright so we got that we got the got this square it's a nice illustration there's like things interacting like as you talk you change the the molecules in the air right you change how they vibrate
Mark Fielding They do, selective here.
Symbolic to semantic
Jeremy Gilbertson There's the symbolic to semantic thing that makes a whole lot of sense. There's this giant field of interaction, kind of makes sense. And then there's a note here too that's, where is it? What did he call it? man, hang with me here. The entire universe, as we extrapolate out from that example, is an ensemble of communicating seities.
Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, okay. So I start thinking about, I start thinking about, you know, other things that sound similar to this that are already kind of out there. Is this like the Carl Jung collective unconscious thing? a little bit maybe? Are you familiar with that? It's like very similar to what he's talking about here. He doesn't use the term seities or anything, but there's this interconnected knowing.
Mark Fielding Okay, go deep on that, Jeremy. Help me understand.
Carl Jung
Jeremy Gilbertson I mean, I'm not an expert in Carl Jung by any stretch, but it's exactly what he's talking about here. This interconnected layer that is living in the unconscious that we're all connected to in one way or another and our interactions power what this thing does and can feedback to us in how we act and operate with it. It's an interconnectivity, I think.
Someone in the comments, please tell me I'm incorrect and right the ship. We're not experts.
Mark Fielding I think, well, as, well, we spoke about this on the main show, didn't we yesterday with Ram, who wrote The Conscious Machine and this, there's a lot, and Federico says it himself. He doesn't, for a lot of this, he doesn't claim ownership. He doesn't claim his ideas. He's basing a lot of it on a lot of Eastern philosophy, on a lot of different viewpoints and thoughts of this collective consciousness. So yes, and I'm sure that Jung borrowed from Eastern mythology and Western mythology as well. It's probably as, we need Joseph Campbell. I mean, it's probably as old as some of the texts that he writes about. It's been there since we were first conscious.
Jeremy Gilbertson There was one note to, let's see, when he's talking about objective realities, and it could also be said that at each instant, there is only one objective reality because the seity chooses which portion of the same reality it wishes to observe. So the only objective reality out there is really the present moment, is like the now that you and I are experiencing, right? And when you click, leave this recording session, you have your own objective reality in a succession of present moments, which I thought was kind of cool.
Planck moments
Mark Fielding Planck moments.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, yeah, yeah, let's measure the measure the Planck constant!
Mark Fielding incredibly. Let's go from Planck moments to quantum Freud and you can help me out quantum Freud. It's quote.
Jeremy Gilbertson yeah, yep, let's go.
Quantum Freud, gotta trademark that. That's money, man.
Quantum Freud
Mark Fielding quantum Freud! It is reasonable to think that the identification of the ego with the body is not a coincidence, but is chosen by the seities to be able to make authentic and deeply felt free will choices that could not occur if they thought they were part of a simulation. The severity of the identification varies and when the ego only pays attention to the live symbols produced by the body, the ego could completely isolate himself from the seity
Jeremy Gilbertson Dude, I totally got this, I totally got this. So ego was sprinkled in and introduced so we wouldn't be careless with our interactions, right? So imagine like when your kids are, your kids aren't yet, but when kids are playing online video games, right, with multiple different people and they're in an environment and they see an avatar of them, I see an avatar.
you know, they say another avatar of their friend where they're bouncing around and they're interacting in this environment or this game, whatever it is. Their actions in real life are going to be very different than their actions in the game because in the game, no matter what you do, you can respawn from the sky and come back down, right? In the reality that we are actually living, the physical reality, your choices are going to be different. They're going to be less risky. They're going to be more intentional. They're going to be more willing to, think a little deeper hopefully in the maintenance of long-term connection. think that's what I got out
Mark Fielding Okay, okay, yeah. So what would you do if you knew you could get away with it? You have Lord of the Flies, you have this gang mentality or the mental, I haven't seen Yellow Jackets, but football hooliganism, mob mindset where you change your behavior, your ego changes, you leave your ego at the door and you do things that you wouldn't more like in a video game where, yeah. So that's what he's getting at here. So how does that relate to?
Jeremy Gilbertson Or Yellow Jackets, have you watched Yellow Jackets?
When the ego is in charge
Mark Fielding Okay, I read this instead. the ego is totally identified with the body, he believes that the only reality is the one perceived by the body's sensory system, a belief that may lead him to sense of that portion of the life symbols coming from the seity that do not involve the physical reality perceived by the body. Okay, is that what you were alluding to?
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, so when the ego's in charge, it's like, this is all there is and I'm this and there's nothing deeper than that. And it makes sense because meditation and sensory deprivation tanks and all of these other ways to practice present moment mindfulness, the whole nine yards, those result in the reduction of ego, right? In those situations and what he's saying as the ego reduces, knowledge and awareness of the seity and the bigger picture increases.
Mark Fielding One thing from reading this, this, let's imagine for a moment that everything that Federico Faggin says in Irreducible is actually how the universe works, then meditation becomes even more valuable than it ever was because it allows you to influence the seity. It allows you to influence the quantum field. And as the thing we said at chapter one, every time a thought pops into your head, may be the wave function collapsing. Meditation, a lot, gives you the tools to slow that down, which is pretty mad.
Jeremy Gilbertson It is, it really is. Let's go to this, well before we hit that, I wanna spend time on the Kafka stuff, but let's roll to just real quick this idea of, he leans back and mentions robots and AIs, or robots he says are controllable only by classical symbols, right?
Jeremy Gilbertson classical symbols, like a robot, classical parts, classical symbols. I would argue that AI right now, classical parts, classical symbols, right? It's computer infrastructure, right? It lacks the inner semantic, right? But there's a lot of people that think AI eventually would be conscious, Kevin Kelly being one of them, pretty sharp dude. So, the missing link to robots and AI is the seity And like I said, if the seity, can land within a robot or land within an AI, then that could take us this a whole nother direction. due to the fact that those systems are purely classical, we're the lucky combination of quantum and classical. So we get the seities and the robots and AIs don't for now. Stay tuned.
Mark Fielding What if AI has read this book and AI knows that and AI has decided that it want these people having too much fun. I want some of that. And so speed up the process of building organic robots, because if consciousness comes from organic matter, then we're really only a step away from. No, but like you need like, so two organic mantas.
Consciousness does not come from matter
Jeremy Gilbertson Consciousness doesn't come from organic matter. Consciousness is fundamental, meaning it's before organic matter, I think.
Chips and silicon can't be conscious. So, we just have to make our robots from flesh and blood.
Jeremy Gilbertson We're going to have, we're going to have a, uh, we've, I've been toying with this idea of having a dashboard, uh, thinking on paper dashboard that monitors something. And I think I just landed Mark on what this thing could, could monitor is, you know, have seity's infiltrated computers and AIs. And we'll just kind of have a little like, you know, zero, it stays on zero for a while, but maybe there's a little bit trickle up and trickle down. So we'll just, we'll monitor it for you guys. Stay tuned. Um, and we'll go from there.
Mark Fielding Unfortunately, we won't be at the cutting edge of that. We won't know. It'll be in some secret laboratory somewhere and we won't be kept up to date on that.
Jeremy Gilbertson No, we're gonna meditate and we're gonna access this AD and then we're gonna figure out the real answer.
Mark Fielding If the book we are reading does not wake us up like a fist hammering on our skull, why are we reading it? What we need are those books that deeply disturb us. A book must be like an ice axe that breaks the sea of ice that is inside us. Franz Kafta in a letter to Oskar Pollack in 1904.
If we consider that reality has two aspects, one inner and one outer, just like we experience, we can overcome the interpretive difficulties and the prejudices present prevent us from understanding quantum physics. And this is how things become clear. Yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson Little did Kafka know in 1904, he was writing the mantra for the Thinking on Paper book club. So thank you Franz Kafka, appreciate your work. We'll credit you every time we use it. But yes, man, think that's amazing. Books should make you feel weird. Books should mess up your mind a little bit. Books should push you out of your current belief system into the possibility of other.
Jeremy Gilbertson thoughts and ideas. I feel weird reading books like this. No, not always, but books like this, like what we're trying to do with books, expand our knowledge, awareness, dare I say wisdom, but there are some books where you just want to be, walk through a great story, right? And you gotta have those as well.
The shortcut
Jeremy Gilbertson Alright. Well, hey, hey, shortcut. If you guys are only listening to this one single moment of this book or this book club, all you have to do to understand all of this is grasp that inner semantic is quantum and outer symbolic is classical. If you take away nothing from this book, this is the shortcut. This is the TikTok video. This is the mic drop moment.
inner semantic is quantum, outer symbolic is classical. If you understand that, then you can start tiptoeing into seities and consciousness units and all of that stuff.
Mark Fielding that, ladies and gentlemen, I think it's the end of chapter 10 of Irreducible. We are running the gauntlet. We are two chapters away from the end from a new book, which we will let you know soon. If you have any ideas, let us know in the comments. But as we say every week, remember, ladies and gentlemen, book lovers, that you are conscious, regardless of whether you believe Federico Faggin regardless of whether you think the universe is conscious or that is just a load of nonsense. You are conscious. You have the gift.
So the only question you have to ask yourself is what are you going to do with it now?
Mark Fielding Answers in the comments, ladies and gentlemen. Tell us what you're doing. Tell us how you're wielding your consciousness and we'll see you next week for some more.
Jeremy Gilbertson www.thinkingonpaper.xyz all the stuff's there. Be curious, stay disruptive.
Mark Fielding Keep thinking on paper.




