Federico Faggin’s Irreducible, Chapters 4 and 5: Can Computers Understand Meaning?
Jeremy looked up the 1983 Stanislav Petrov story after reading it in Faggin's book. If they were really doing this, would they send just five missiles?
In this episode · 20 chapters
- The man who saved the planet
- Chapter four, and the history of computers
- What is information?
- Claude Shannon
- Capacity greater than entropy
- Words are not identical to things
- Qualia and meaning
- Knowing the sensation is not feeling it
- Into chapter five, and DNA
- DNA as a quantum construction
- Comprehension and curiosity are non-algorithmic
- Can a machine be curious?
- Mimicking creativity, mimicking curiosity
- Live information
- Is there meaning without consciousness?
- Annika Harris, and Lights On
- The question for Joe Fitzsimons
- Language, and prosody
- Alphabets, elements and simplicity
- Chapter six, and Marcus Aurelius
But the difference is we do that innately, whereas we have to script it. We’re jazz, computers are classical.
Mark and Jeremy read chapters four and five of Irreducible by Federico Faggin. They start with Stanislav Petrov, then move through a short history of computing up to the Intel 4004, Claude Shannon's theory of information, and what a one and a zero physically are.
The second half turns to qualia, DNA, live information and whether a machine can be curious. Jeremy puts it this way: “But the difference is we do that innately, whereas we have to script it. We're jazz, computers are classical.”
Federico Faggin's Irreducible, chapters 4 and 5, asks what information is. Read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, the chapters argue that meaning, which computers cannot reach, separates living things from machines. They open with Stanislav Petrov, the Soviet officer who in 1983 judged a satellite warning of a US missile attack to be a false alarm, and Mark Fielding argues a machine would not have had that intuition.
Can computers grasp qualia and meaning?
“Qualia and meaning are properties of consciousness not available to computers,” Faggin writes. A computer can be told that yellow means warmth, Mark says, but it would still only work within what it was told.
Who was Stanislav Petrov?
The chapters open with Stanislav Petrov, the Soviet officer who in September 1983 judged a satellite warning of a US missile attack to be a false alarm. Mark argues a machine would not have had that intuition.
How does Federico Faggin define information?
Faggin defines information as a relationship between an observer and an event: an event carries information only if it adds new knowledge.
What is live information?
Live information is Faggin’s term for what happens inside living cells, where matter, energy, information and meaning are inseparable. His example: glucose can be information, energy or building material.
Which properties does Faggin call non-algorithmic?
Faggin calls comprehension and curiosity “non-algorithmic properties”, and asks where quantum computing takes place, if quantum information processing “cannot be openly performed in space time with classical matter”.
Where Mark and the book disagree
Mark argues that a song you have heard a thousand times still changes you, so information is more than new knowledge.
Links from this episode
Questions
Can computers understand meaning?
“Qualia and meaning are properties of consciousness not available to computers,” Faggin writes.
What do chapters 4 and 5 of Irreducible cover?
They start with Stanislav Petrov, then move through a short history of computing up to the Intel 4004, Claude Shannon's theory of information, and what a one and a zero physically are. The second half turns to qualia, DNA, live information and whether a machine can be curious.
What separates living things from machines, according to Irreducible?
Read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, the chapters argue that meaning, which computers cannot reach, separates living things from machines.
How does Jeremy compare humans with computers?
Jeremy puts it this way: “But the difference is we do that innately, whereas we have to script it. We're jazz, computers are classical.”
Transcript
Mark Fielding disruptors and curious minds, book lovers, you're tuned into the Thinking on Paper Book Club. I'm Mark, this is Jeremy, and this is your weekly check-in with your humanity. You're in a war, ladies and gentlemen. There is a battle for your attention, for your choice, for your thinking. But you've joined us. For 30 minutes, the algorithm can't touch you. There will be no short form content. There will be no social posts. There will be no emojis.
Just you and a book. Like the good old days, we're on chapter four and five of Irreducible by Federico Faggin And on the 26th of September, 1983, in the midst of the Cold War, the world was saved from nuclear disaster thanks to Lieutenant Colonel Stanislav Petrov. Thank you, Stanislav, who did not trust the data sent by the satellites announcing the imminent attack of atomic missiles launched by the USA against the Soviet Union. I was an analyst, he said.
The man who saved the planet
Mark Fielding I was sure it was a mistake. My intuition told me, convinced it was some error, Petrov did not communicate to his superiors that an attack was imminent, and he saved the planet. Maybe I decided this way because I was the only one who had a civilian education, while all the other employees were soldiers used to giving and following orders. Information makes consciousness, Jeremy.
Jeremy Gilbertson How do we not know this guy?
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, I read that and I'm like, how in the world have I not heard of this guy? Like we would not, literally not be here if it weren't for him looking at data presented to him and being someone in a very mechanical environment, right? The military soldiers, order comes in, you execute the order, you don't think, you do. And like you said, his background coming from outside in is pretty interesting. And also think about like, in Russia back in the Cold War, USSR back in the Cold War, right? It wasn't the most friendly environment to just be thinking on your own, right? So holy crap, we need to celebrate this guy, because he was thinking on paper for sure.
Mark Fielding I have done something very unthinking of paper. I didn't actually check that story was true I assumed it was true because Federico has gained my trust
Jeremy Gilbertson I looked it up and ironically, and this is just what got fed to me in my searches, but apparently he was like, all right, so there's only five missiles coming from the US. If they were really doing this, would they send just five missiles? So again, the gall and pomp of the...
Mark Fielding That was what kind of triggered his, I smell a rat. There's a mistake, it? Because there wasn't enough.
Jeremy Gilbertson Wasn't enough missiles. Yeah, wow.
Mark Fielding Wow, okay. What was the problem? What was actually the mistake? A computer system had just picked up something that was in a...
Jeremy Gilbertson Early warning system allegedly misfired and sent this warning out without missiles being in the air. So was a little glitch in the ones and zeros in the symbols that were being processed without semantic meaning until our friend jumps in, right?
Mark Fielding Oh, Oh, yes. Well, he saved the planet. Yeah, it's a good place to start consciousness because of a machine, a robot, an AI wouldn't have had that intuition.
Jeremy Gilbertson And it's interesting, the more I read this book, the more I think that people are already projecting AI to be this conscious entity when at the core of things, he says this a couple of times, at the core of things, all computers are doing is differentiating between a one and a zero. That's all they're doing. Which when you think about it like that, you're like, damn, okay. So anyway, let's jump right in. So chapter.
Mark Fielding Well you're right though sentient AI people talk about it as if it's just it's gonna happen next year and there's no comprehension of what consciousness is what being sentient is what being aware is yeah as he said
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, in this week's brand new newsletter, Thinking On, we will be thinking on consciousness because I'm melting my brain with Federico's information, but also Annika Harris's book, Audiobook Lights On, and my face is like straight melting on this. I have, I'm in like chapter four of that, and we're gonna weave some of that in, so stay tuned, newsletter junkies, it's coming your way.
Mark Fielding Have you been listening to it?
Jeremy Gilbertson Alright, so again...
Mark Fielding I did just promise no short form content at the beginning of the show so it better be a long newsletter.
Jeremy Gilbertson I think newsletter doesn't qualify as short form content. Short form content is a TikTok video.
Mark Fielding Okay. Okay, no emojis though. You should have a guarantee no AI was used in the making of this newsletter.
Jeremy Gilbertson No emojis, facts. All right.
Chapter four, and the history of computers
Jeremy Gilbertson Hmm, fair enough. All right, so chapter four, let's root this in at the start. We get a little bit of information processing history, right? We talk about these vacuum tubes, right, that were invented to amplify weak radio signals that thankfully ended up in my 69 Vibrolux amplifier that makes it sound really amazing.
Then we move into the idea of diffusion bipolar transistors, germanium transistors, which are all these different, this evolution of technology, until we get to Federico's Intel 4004, which essentially changed the game. Quote, with Silicon Gates, the part becomes the whole. Everything kind of changed from.
Mark Fielding Mustn't it be nice to write about the history of computers when you invented that? The Intel 404, the first 4-bit CPU, which I designed in 1970. Yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson my gosh, right? Yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson And then the 8080, the Intel 8080, right, is the next one. So again, it's cool to root this stuff in, but a couple cool things I pulled out, know, in forma, the Latin root of information, meaning to give shape to something, and we think about bits, right, these ones and zeros, encapsulating something, encapsulating some form of early information, you know, that, that, what that is. So this idea of like giving shape to something is really interesting. but information to a computer is different from information to you and I, right? So a computer sees a one or a zero. It's very this or that you and I witness an event, which is a collection of information. The semantic meaning is going to be different for me than it is to you. And again, as we run through this book, it's the difference between computers and people. How did you read that?
What is information?
Mark Fielding Well, maybe just recap is that what is information? So the chapters called the nature of information. I've got a question for you on information. So just I want to read a little bit first. The fact is the term information has many meanings which vary according to the context in which it is used. It can indicate data facts, news instructions, knowledge, intelligence, relevance, meaning what is represented by a particular arrangement of signs or symbols, the amount of information carried by a particular symbol and so on. Rene Tom from.
morphogenesis to structure, the French, he's a French mathematician so it's René Dom. The term information too full of all its intentional and anthropocentric connotations should be banned from science. Okay and then Federica goes on. The central concept of information has to do with a particular relationship between an observer and an event that transmits information to the observer.
The event is a sign that brings with it information, that is new knowledge for the observer. Note that if the observer knew in advance which event would occur, the event would bring no new information, but only confirmation of what he already knew. If, on the other hand, the event increased his knowledge, it would have transmitted information. Okay, what about music, which you've heard before?
Mark Fielding Well, as soon as I read that, about it only being information when the knowledge is new...
Mark Fielding I immediately thought of information which wasn't new knowledge, the replication of what's come before, like when you listen to a song which you might have listened to a thousand times before.
It still has an impact on you. still changes something. I still think that is information.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, that's difference between the symbolic nature of information, I think, and the semantic nature of information. So once that song comes through, how it was captured, let's say, I don't know, this might be a stretch, but let's say all the little pieces of the song are symbolic. The notes are symbols, right? The notes are symbols of information representing, like A, the note A.
is a representation of a frequency at 440 Hertz, right? That's what A is. And those are symbols, right? But when I listen to them all together and I've listened to them multiple times, it generates meaning and maybe even attachment, maybe even, maybe even like, that's why songs are so meaningful. Like when you hear them multiple times, you hear them tied into moments in your life.
They're part of that moment. They're part of that piece of information. And when you said before, when the universal wave collapses to create that memory, that song is linked to that memory. That's part of that information.
Mark Fielding In simpler terms, it's subjective versus objective and I have consciousness so I can have a subjective entanglement with that information whereas a machine that is only interested in objective information can't.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, what we, yeah, this is interesting. So as we read on what we call information is always based on a prior agreement, which is kind of interesting, which questions the universality of what is meant by objective.
Yeah, this is a little mind melting, but.
Claude Shannon
Mark Fielding Well, then he gets into Shannon, the Claude Shannon theorization of information. And he kind of, if I understood what he speaks about correctly, Claude Shannon created this objective view of information using a lot of maths, which I won't go into here, to kind of create a blueprint for what information is and this objective information.
is what modern computers can understand, work on, look for, kind of built around his framework of what information is from a mathematical perspective-ish.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, so yeah, so he didn't define and our author and host references this in his book. said Shannon didn't define information, right? So I had to do a little research to get my head around this stuff. I've heard of Claude Shannon. I know he was critical to information theory and computer networks and communication. And basically the idea is like, everything is better when it's converted to bits first before you send it from one place to another.
Jeremy Gilbertson just like you take electricity and convert it into RF and beam it to the world. If you wanna listen to that episode, it's coming up. We talked to the guy that's doing it, Space-Based Solar Power. But back to Claude Shannon, I did some research and he did a couple of things according to this research. Number one, created this, came up with this formula for the minimum number of bits per second to represent the information he's trying to represent.
And he calls that, here's the E word again, Mark, be careful, entropy rate, which is represented by H. And then he also came up with this idea of capacity, right? So I'm actually flipping to my notes here just to make sure I get this right. So a formula for the maximum number of bits per second that can be reliably communicated in the face of noise, right?
Capacity greater than entropy
Jeremy Gilbertson So as long as capacity is greater than entropy, as long as C is greater than H, you have reliable communication. At least that's my understanding of things. So, hey, feel free to pop in the comments, call me a Yahoo. I'm always looking to get better here, but that's my understanding of things. What about value of bits, dude? There was a little part, I think it was...
Jeremy Gilbertson Might've been a little reference section in here, I think, but the value of bits, I didn't know this. So let's talk about what a one and a zero actually is. This was super fascinating. So a one actually is voltage in the node of a circuit between 0.6 and one volts. So we freaking quantify it. So you always talk about ones and zeros. I never knew what the heck it was. So that's what it is. And a zero,
Jeremy Gilbertson is voltage in a node of a circuit between 0 and 0.4. So that's how you distinguish these ones and zeros. And guess what 0.4 and 0.6, the area between those two are? It's the noise that Shannon was talking about.
Mark Fielding I did like that bit and as the naive observer, which he then references after that, I will take the role as the naive observer because he essentially writes what I thought and I think what most people thought. So quote, a naive observer who had the task of understanding how a microchip works by measuring what is physically accessible inside, but knew nothing about binary computer systems would think that the important information is represented by dynamic signals that change rapidly.
Yes, well I thought instead the information that matters is represented by stable but fleeting states during which by convention the signals have meaning. By observing only the dynamic voltages that are constantly changing at various points in the system, it would be difficult to understand what is going on because the logical description is anchored firmly but elusively on an agreement that is not evident to an ordinary observer.
I think the first part of that is the bit that everyone thinks that it's just the gates flicking around but it's not.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, go back. I think we did this a couple of episodes ago, or maybe it was in another book that we were reading, but this analogy of light switches on a wall. you have, if it's like a 10-bit system, right? There's 10 light switches and any combination of those light switches captured is the capacity of the system, I guess, is way... So you have like the first switch is on and the rest of the nine are off.
the first switch is on, the second switch is on, the rest of it. So all of the infinite combination of those little signals is kind of where we get to this. But I love pulling out like these little collections of words that are kind of inspiring. So bits are not physical objects, but must be robustly represented by a physical barrier, robustly represented. That's kind of some cool language, man.
Mark Fielding Robust, not anti-fagile. So I think after explaining what information is for a computer, a brief history of how computers came to be, then starts the rage against the machine, doesn't it? I think there's break in the prose in his choice of words and in the argument, and he suddenly churns against.
Mark Fielding machine and focuses on consciousness conscious entities life organic matter atoms cells dna he gets into all of it a lot yeah go for it
Jeremy Gilbertson question for you related to that. Why don't we fully grasp the difference between conscious and unconscious?
Mark Fielding Why don't we fully grasp the difference between conscious and unconscious?
Mark Fielding Well, because to be, to understand that difference, you'd have to be conscious when you were unconscious.
Jeremy Gilbertson there you go with the loop, the infinite loop. So I asked
Words are not identical to things
Mark Fielding Look Jeremy, words are not identical to things. Knowing words relating to facts is in no way equivalent to the direct and immediate understanding of the facts themselves. Meister, I don't know the answer to your question. What's the answer?
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, what I gathered from this, I asked the question, no, and the answer, which is kind of jerky. but, so as I understood it based on what he was working us through in this chapter is we do both as humans, we act both as machines and as conscious entities, right? When we're walking, you know, down the street, once we start walking, it's very mechanical, right? It's like, okay, we're just doing this thing. We're not.
constantly going, my right foot's touching the ground, my left foot's touching the ground, right? But there's what Buckminster Fuller in his book, Nine Chains to the Moon, which we're actually gonna read at some point, he refers to this as the phantom captain, basically our subconscious that allows us to go, shit, we're about to step in a hole, you need to move to the right. So we move between this mechanical existence and this conscious existence.
Jeremy Gilbertson do machine-like things, but we also have our phantom captain helping us navigate the in-betweens.
Mark Fielding He spoke about that in the last chapter with the driving example when you're driving on autopilot, you'll see the problem is when you said the difference between being conscious and non-conscious, just imagine to this is the transfer of information objective and subjective and I subjectively understood it as being like knocked out unconscious, not being a robot. So when you said what's the difference? I was thinking, how can I? Yeah. So my, so yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, when a robot hits me with a right cross and knocks me out, this is how I feel. Here's another quote that was pretty cool. Computers are physical structures to which we have transferred a portion of our mind in the form of programs, creating a bridge between mind and matter. So again, pointing back to you, hey, we're machine-like, but we're conscious. We now transfer a portion of that experience to a machine to help us.
do things by translating, by translating, by giving meaning to some of these symbols that we understand as programmers of the system. But the computer doesn't understand the meaning of the one or the zero or the, you know, the, the combination of those things. We direct it and all it does, this was really interesting. All it does is go one or zero. Is it a one or zero? Is it one or zero? And that's the basis of all of this stuff. But we assign meaning as programmers and we also assign meaning as you know, interpreters of the output of that as well.
Mark Fielding And that is essential to clarify that point because the ambiguity of the words used to describe robots and artificial intelligence system tends to eliminate the abyss that separates human beings from so-called intelligence machines, which you've described that I like the use of the word abyss, just really drive home the wedge of the difference. Okay. Okay.
Qualia and meaning
Jeremy Gilbertson Last bit in this chapter real quick. So I pulled this, I think it's relatively paraphrased here. I'm not sure if I wrote it down exactly, but conscious processing of meaning is very different from the automatic processing of symbols. It's something that I just kind of said in a different way, but said that way is a great reminder as we read these other chapters and dig further that that is the difference between man and machine.
Mark Fielding Well, I'll read the full quote from I think what you might have just paraphrased.
Qualia and meaning are properties of consciousness not available to computers.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, this is this, so I'm bouncing this, this book off of Lights On by Annika Harris, who I would love for you to come on the show and talk through this with us too, in relation to this book and in relation to just your work in general, but really, really interesting fact that as we, as we think about it, like, so you have a computer and you have a person, right? And a computer can, can take a camera can take a signal in.
and that signal can be the color yellow, right? But the color yellow is, I think it's light vibrating at like 1400 nanometers, just like the note A is a sound wave at 440 Hertz, right? But we don't look at the cycles, we don't look at the frequency of these things, we look at it as yellow, and I look at yellow, I think warm, I think sunshine, I think this, but that is different.
than what a computer just registers as that. could a computer be programmed to interpret that collection of that signal as what I am interpreting it as a human? Meaning, could I give the computer instructions to say, if you see light vibrating at 1400 nanometers, I want you to respond with understanding that it's warm.
It's sunshine, it's whatever else you might relate to the color yellow. So anyway, there's not a question there or I don't know, it's just something that I've been thinking about.
Mark Fielding Well, yeah, you could, but it still would only just be working in the paradigm of what you've told it. It wouldn't have access to the qualia to actually feel.
Jeremy Gilbertson Say that one more time, that's a brilliant distinction, I think.
Knowing the sensation is not feeling it
Mark Fielding it would still be operating within the framework of what you told it. doesn't have the qualia to to feel.
subjectively what that is. It's the quote by Eckhart, words are not identical to things, knowing words relating to facts is in no way equivalent to the direct immediate understanding of the facts themselves. You change the wording in that and you could just say...
Knowing the sensation is not the same as feeling the sensation or knowing what you're supposed to feel and feeling and not the same thing are they knowing what you're supposed to say saying is right thing I mean you can just say about anything really but they don't have the qualia they don't have the live information or the lived information
Into chapter five, and DNA
Jeremy Gilbertson Perfect bridge into chapter five. Perfect bridge into chapter five. So let's stay on that. I'm jumping ahead just a touch, but I think we can bring this all back, because this makes a lot of sense. So you said the computer is only reacting to the instructions that you've given it previously. And those instructions could have changed over time, right? The first time you put...
Jeremy Gilbertson instruction A and then maybe a couple weeks later you put instruction B instruction C instruction D and over time This computer now has a program of instructions that have evolved based on human input. So this idea of coding DNA is Really interesting to me. So coding DNA is about 1.5 percent of Human DNA and it specifies the structure of our 21,000 whatever proteins right so super important
But there are other pieces to the DNA that we don't really know what the potential is. He talks about that, but I wanna focus on the coding DNA. So consciousness versus intuition. So our DNA holds information, right? That allegedly has been changed over centuries based on experience, the evolution thing, the gene thing. So DNA is instructions, right?
Mark Fielding Yeah, it's the instrument, it's the blueprint for life. And why is it what? Why is it? Yeah, sorry.
Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, and again, I'm not debunking consciousness, but I just wanna think about the idea of like, when I react to something, how much of that is intuition going back to my code, this coding DNA, this 1.5 % instruction set to generate a response? That's crazy interesting to me.
DNA as a quantum construction
Mark Fielding No, but the DNA is a quantum. It's a quantum construction, not a classical physics construction that lives in the machine. That's the difference. I remember junk DNA. We studied the DNA at school and I remember them talking about junk DNA and I never once heard somebody suggesting that, in fact, maybe that junk DNA, the other 97%, is actually the meaning of life, the force, the qualia. It's all wrapped up in
Jeremy Gilbertson Dark matter, yeah.
Mark Fielding It's all wrapped up. It's the dark matter of your blueprint, of the construction of your life. Going back, okay, I wanna ask you, so following on what you just said, creativity and curiosity. If what you just assumed, okay, can you not just learn it by the code and then over time evolve to feel, do whatever that the human can do?
Comprehension and curiosity are non-algorithmic
Mark Fielding Note also that a truly creative event could not be part of the alphabet of events to which we could assign a probability since that event never existed before. And the quote on curiosity. When an event is novel, a conscious entity becomes curious about it and this curiosity. So again, when an event is novel, a conscious entity becomes curious about it and this curiosity motivates its exploration.
comprehension and curiosity are non-algorithmic properties that emerge within the entity's consciousness that can supervise the mechanical aspects of the body, which we spoke about earlier. Okay, curiosity and creativity evolve, emerge from the quantum realm, from the quantum qualia, which I will now call them the QQ. But the same thing applies to your question that you said all of these things that you can...
So curiosity and creativity can be... Well he says they can't be algorithmic but you question whether they perhaps can be.
Can a machine be curious?
Jeremy Gilbertson Yes, but let me clarify. I am probably the biggest proponent of curiosity as a, well, here's the thing. Here's the thing that the beauty of this stuff is to challenge our intuition, our perceptions, our beliefs of things in this environment because I think curiosity and creativity are some of the things that make us human, right?
Mark Fielding Yeah, that's exactly why I asked you.
Jeremy Gilbertson So, but when you get to the root of something, creativity is the unique arrangement of elements that are found already. So if a computer finds four blocks and they arrange them in a way that hasn't been done before, is that creative, right? So then thinking about curiosity, curiosity to me is like the fuel, the power, the drive to dig deeper, to understand something, right? So could there be algorithmic instructions to say,
Look at this book, look at this book again, look at this book again in order to find the connection between X, Y and Z. Look at this book again and talk to Mark about it. But the difference is we do that innately, whereas we have to script it. We're jazz, computers are classical.
Mark Fielding we're conscious they're not. I don't know about you but on the creativity curiosity thing in my head when I think about it I can more easily imagine creativity being...
I can imagine a robot and a computer and AI being creative more than I can genuinely curious because I think that
Of course it can fake curiosity. Of course it can and it does. in that, and you can see them thinking now. You program something into Gemini, you can see it thinking. You program something into Deep Sea, ask it a question, can see it thinking. And it gives this impression that it's curious, but it's not real conscious curiosity that we have.
Jeremy Gilbertson It's not sitting there chewing on glasses, of, right? No, you hit the nail on the head. This is a, it's mimicking the behavior that's innate within us, right?
Mimicking creativity, mimicking curiosity
Mark Fielding and it's easier to creativity than it is to mimic curiosity.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, requires, curiosity requires a lot of things. I've been writing a lot about empathy lately and know, empathy, lot of the most powerful leaders in the world right now, which is super unfortunate, they're diminishing the value of empathy, calling it the fall of our civilization. I'm not gonna mention any names, but think of the two biggest yahoos that are out there purporting this kind of stuff. Guess what? Our previous author and host,
Noah Yuval Harari has stated historically and by research in fact that humans thrive based on our ability to be empathetic because our ability to be empathetic allows us to communicate, it allows us to cooperate, and that's why we haven't gone extinct and other folks have. Rabbit hole, but I think empathy is important in curiosity as well.
Mark Fielding I have empathy for Yuval because he won't come on thinking on paper. He's too busy having interviews with Natalie Portman so I understand. Well she's got a book club.
Jeremy Gilbertson You will stay at it.
Jeremy Gilbertson my. She can come along too.
Mark Fielding course she does. think it's more well attended than ours?
this a little bit. So anyway let's go into the final straight because then he turns up the dial again going right into the what he calls live information and we what let me just read the his proposal where's the proposal he actually says what he wants to outline doesn't he?
Live information
Jeremy Gilbertson It's the idea of live information being a combination of energy, information and matter and these things interacting together. Uses glucose as an example of a molecule of something that can be multiple things, right? It's not just one thing or another.
Glucose can be information, glucose can be energy, glucose can be building material. I think that was a really good example of what live information is within a cell.
Mark Fielding Yeah, I just, I was just looking at the, it's not on the live information page, but he actually outlines his thesis on what live information is. And I thought I'd.
highlighted it but obviously I hadn't. He says like in this book I propose that live information, doesn't he say that junk DNA is live information or something?
Jeremy Gilbertson Good thing we can edit this, right?
Mark Fielding Maybe I imagined it but I'm pretty sure it said.
Jeremy Gilbertson think you might have imagined it. Web page?
Mark Fielding yeah, okay, I've got it. In this chap... page 91, right at the beginning in fact. In this chapter I will introduce the concept of live information, a new concept suitable for the types of transformations that occur within cells where matter, energy, information and meaning are inseparable. I am convinced that the study of this new type of information in which the semantic aspect cannot be separated from the symbolic aspect and from matter, energy...
will play a fundamental role in the understanding of life and will lead us to a deeper understanding of the nature of reality and consciousness. The essence of life is about experience and consciousness in what allows us, through the body, to have that first-person experience of ourselves and the world.
Jeremy Gilbertson So again, we're going back to this us versus them, machines versus humans. What makes computer parts versus what makes our parts, computer being very separate things, power supply, hardware, software, right? Working in a particular way, right? There's no piece of that that can affect or nothing can affect those three pieces and except the pieces themselves, I think.
Jeremy Gilbertson Actually, we'll zip that out, because that doesn't make any damn sense.
Is there meaning without consciousness?
Mark Fielding Question for you, Jeremy. Is there meaning in the universe?
Jeremy Gilbertson Man, so you gotta define meaning, right? So what is meaning? Is that a semantic understanding of interactions, right? Because the universe is a series of interactions, right? We're all part of these, we're all little pieces interacting in certain ways. If we subscribe to the understanding quantum events, there are certain instances as the wave collapses that are.
that things move from being quantum to classical, right? So the conversion of quantum to classical when the wave collapses. the meaning, meaning is, has to be.
Mark Fielding Okay, I'll rephrase it for you where you can think about that one. then he says here, conscious, conscious, I didn't do my warmups. He said here, consciousness must be brought into the domain of physics and can no longer be ignored. Do you agree with that? a non-consciousness must be brought into the domain of physics and can no longer be ignored. consciousness should be part of.
Jeremy Gilbertson Say that one more time.
Mark Fielding I mean, we should probably ask a real physicist what they think about that because it feels quite controversial.
Annika Harris, and Lights On
Jeremy Gilbertson So, all right, so let's bounce back to Light's on. Annika Harris, again, please come on the show and talk with us. But I think in chapter...
Mark Fielding She sounded a bit desperate then, Jeremy Be more...
Jeremy Gilbertson chapter two, chapter three, just a nice invite, just a nice invite, I'm not desperate. The idea of, man, you me lose my train of thought.
So she kind of proposes, and she did this through a paper a couple years ago, proposes that consciousness is fundamental to atoms, to quarks, to the components that make up the universe, right? So that is fundamental and not this outside force generated in our brains, generated.
Jeremy Gilbertson you by whatever is, it's innate to these little particles and you had a consciousness field proposal, just kind of like a gravitational field or electromagnetic field. So if you're talking about making it part of physics, you would have to look at what is physics, what makes physics and how does consciousness, how does consciousness emanate from that? And I think the field idea is really interesting.
Mark Fielding Wouldn't it be part of the quantum field? There's only one. How many fields are there? Surely there's just one field somewhere. The conscious field is part of the quantum
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, do you want to go to string theory?
Mark Fielding I want to go to, following on from what you just said, quantum because he kind of ends the chapter on quantum and I think that ties into what you said about Annaka Harris. So she's all free will exists, doesn't Sam Harris say that free will doesn't exist? So if they must have a right of ding-dong about free will.
Jeremy Gilbertson Absolutely. Absolutely.
The question for Joe Fitzsimons
Mark Fielding What did you think of this, was I wanted to email Joe Fitzsimmons and ask him or quote him this and just get his thoughts on this quote. Quantum computers, for example, cannot exist entirely in our physical world. Only the setting of the program, the initial conditions and the recording of the result of the calculation can be obtained in the classical world as classical information. Quantum information processing cannot be openly performed in space time with classical matter.
because qubits and their entanglement are non-local properties. So where does quantum computing take place? The question has puzzled physicists since the inception of this technology, but there is still no adequate answer.
Jeremy Gilbertson That's a great Joe Fitzsimon's question, for sure.
Mark Fielding We should ask that to all our quantum guests. We'd like just, what are your thoughts on this?
Jeremy Gilbertson Yes, what did you think of the...
Mark Fielding It's a mad question though, isn't it? the quantum.
computation doesn't, I mean there's probably some kind of quantum explanation where in fact they do take place in our reality, maybe it doesn't, but yeah where do they take place? Somewhere else? In that world, it's like the, when you, it doesn't exist until you interact with it, does it? So they don't exist, so the computation doesn't exist until it's created, so where does it take place? It doesn't take place anywhere because it doesn't exist.
Jeremy Gilbertson So think about like, let's just think about quantum events. Think about like quantum event number one. And let's say you have four perspectives, four observers of that quantum event. So according to many worlds, that quantum event would spin off the amount of worlds that we have observers, observers for that, right? So yeah, the idea of like, you just can't,
Jeremy Gilbertson It's bonkers because you can't explain it. You can't like, hold on, I'm just gonna pop in a quantum world real quick and just kind of see what's happening over there and I'll be right back. Like we don't have the, we haven't unlocked the ability to perceive the quantum world yet in here. Maybe that's in our junk DNA. Maybe we could, maybe we can unlock it through junk DNA.
Mark Fielding Maybe, yeah. Can it answer what's on the edge of the universe as well? What's on either side of the edge of the universe? Is that another question that lives in that same bit of junk DNA? Anyway.
Language, and prosody
Jeremy Gilbertson Couple other things too. I think it's Elias Canetti. There was a quote in here. Have you ever read the book On Crowds? my gosh, one of the most profound ways to understand the way societies control people. mean, it all comes out, there was a bunch of different ideas and stuff, but the main idea is you split them into two groups and make the two groups.
Jeremy Gilbertson hate each other while you do all the stuff behind the scenes. And when I read that book, was like, wait, so I saw that quote in there. The quote was kind of meh, but yeah, I just saw his name. Like, yeah, I read that book by him.
Language, let's talk about language for a minute. So, inner meaning converted to outer symbols, outer symbols converted to inner meaning. This idea of, I don't know how to pronounce this word, prosody, P-R-O-S-O-D-Y, prosody, prosody.
Mark Fielding Yeah, prosody, prosody, yeah. That's the way that you speak.
Jeremy Gilbertson wow, know you're gonna sing today. Yeah, so intonation.
Mark Fielding I wasn't speaking, I was like talking, but with prosody.
Jeremy Gilbertson intonation, rhythm, nuance, all of that stuff. All right, so page 105. If I read this correctly, given a longer text, all languages have equal letter probability. Did I read that right?
Mark Fielding Hold on, I've played Scrabble in French and I need more to that because...
Jeremy Gilbertson Scrabble's not long text though, that's just little words, right?
Mark Fielding In English every second letter is E and then in French every second letter is an E. They have different points on their scrabble board for different letters because the letters appear more often than others.
Jeremy Gilbertson No, but I think what he's saying is the idea of like not just E compared with the other languages version of E is of alphabet, alphabet one versus alphabet two, the probability distribution between the letters in the alphabet is similar given a longer text.
Mark Fielding Okay, like I said in the last episode, if it's a math question, I just accept it. Yes, I agree.
Jeremy Gilbertson So you, all right, so you accept, you accept the axioms as self-evident. Okay, heard.
Mark Fielding Statistics, that's maths. Yeah, I accept that probability.
Alphabets, elements and simplicity
Jeremy Gilbertson Can I go down this rabbit hole just a touch longer? So alphabets and translating symbols, right? So the difference between humans and machines, understanding symbols, making the one zero determination, not knowing the semantic understanding because they don't have comprehension, right? And you look on the cellular side, the human side, human life is 99 % made up of six elements. So let's say six letters, right? Six letters of the alphabet.
Jeremy Gilbertson to create humans, right? The Earth ecosystem has 40 elements or 40 letters, all right? Quantum mechanics has six postulates, according to this theory, this operational probabilistic theory that we're gonna get into later in the book has six letters. So are there symbols there to create? I thought that was really an interesting parallel saying that there are symbols, but these symbols are, I don't know, man. That was really interesting to me.
Mark Fielding If ever there was a lesson to simplify, then that must be it. So few things that create so much.
Jeremy Gilbertson John Wheeler at it again. It from bit. Good old John Wheeler.
Mark Fielding Yeah, I saw the John Wheeler
Mark Fielding Is he dead? Can we have him on?
Jeremy Gilbertson Couple of... I think he's dead. Couple of questions for you as we finish up this chapter. How can a physics... This is a quote from the book. How can a physics entirely based on objective information explain the existence of consciousness?
Jeremy Gilbertson This isn't hot buttons, Mark, I need more. Okay, and the other one you already asked, where does... It definitely can't. All right. Good stuff, well, hey.
Mark Fielding What's the other question you said there was two?
Jeremy Gilbertson You actually already answered that. Where does quantum computation take place? The end of the chapter teases an explanation of consciousness and free will by this OPT, operational probabilistic theory, which I'm assuming he's going to get into in the next chapter.
Chapter six, and Marcus Aurelius
Mark Fielding Chapter six, the nature of life in any chapter in a book that begins with a quote from Marcus Aurelius is something I want to read. chapter six.
Jeremy Gilbertson What's the Marcus Aurelius quote? Go ahead and tease it for us.
Mark Fielding When you wake up in the morning, remember what a precious privilege it is to be alive, to breathe, to think, to feel joy and to love, which is a bit like what I said at the end of last week's book club. Really, you are conscious people. We are reading a book about consciousness. is Friday evening. It is spring. You are conscious. What are you doing? Now you finish listening to this. Walk out the door of wherever you are. Look at the sky. Look at the birds. Listen to the birds. Find somebody, say hello, do something. Use your consciousness.
Jeremy Gilbertson find somebody, say hello. I love that. I love that. Well there you have it, chapters four and five, Irreducible. Again, our ability to reduce these chapters is also appropriately named the title of the book. But that was fun, man. I feel like I got my head around some of this stuff. Excited to dig in deeper. What do these guys and gals need to know about what's coming up next for us?
Mark Fielding think there's only really one thing that the disruptors and curious minds of thinking on paper need to know and that's next Friday we are speaking with Kevin Kelly, futurist, wired founder, optimist, wise man. He's been on Tim Ferriss. He's probably been on Joe Rogan and now he's coming on thinking on paper and that will be released as soon as I can work out how to edit it after the show. So maybe in about 10 days.
Next week I'm in Paris at blockchain week if you're there come and say hello and Anything else Jeremy
Jeremy Gilbertson That's it. Be curious, stay disruptive.




