Federico Faggin’s Irreducible, Chapter 3: Can a Computer Experience Anything?
Jeremy reads Faggin's line that meaning, understanding and free will do not exist within a computer, and asks whether that will change in 20 years. It will not change because consciousness is a quantum experience.
In this episode · 18 chapters
- Thoughts, and consciousness
- Do we create the universe?
- Wim Hof
- Questions over answers
- What matters is in the organisation
- Boolean
- Computers compared to brains
- The operation is extremely fragile
- Can a computer experience anything?
- Randomness, and ignorance
- What reductionism means
- True reductionism cannot exist
- Computers are completely deterministic
- Comprehension
- We are not built to do a specific thing
- The logical progression of biotech
- Never complete
- Living organisms, and coordination
I haven’t been sitting in a calm, zen-like enlightened state. When I meditate, my brain is just a firework display of thoughts crashing around completely out of control.
Chapter three of Irreducible follows the machine from relays and triodes to the MOS transistor and chips with up to a trillion transistors. We read Federico Faggin's case that computers are deterministic, and that one wrong bit can turn one into a useless box.
Then the argument turns to life. Faggin writes that no one has ever built a cell starting from atoms, and that living organisms use every phenomenon available, quantum and classical. Mark brings in his meditation practice, and Jeremy asks whether AI already creates understanding.
Chapter 3 of Federico Faggin's Irreducible: Consciousness, Life, Computers, and Human Nature, read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, traces machines from relays to microchips and argues that a computer, however powerful, processes symbols it does not understand. Jeremy Gilbertson asks whether AI already builds understanding the way people do.
Can a computer experience anything?
Faggin says no. Chapter 3 of Irreducible argues that a computer, however powerful, processes symbols it does not understand.
What Einstein line opens chapter 3 of Irreducible?
The chapter opens with a line the book attributes to Einstein: “One day the machines will be able to solve all the problems, but none of them will ever be able to pose one.”
How does Federico Faggin define a computer?
Faggin defines a computer as “a physical structure in which an energy pattern created by the human mind has been organized in such a form that the matter is forced to act in accordance with this pattern.”
Why are computers deterministic, according to Faggin?
Computers are deterministic: they process ones and zeros according to their instructions, and the meaning comes from the programmer. In the book’s words, “meaning understanding and free will decisions do not exist within a computer.”
How does quantum randomness differ from classical randomness?
Quantum randomness is different in kind from classical randomness, Faggin argues. Classical randomness is ignorance of something knowable; quantum randomness reflects “a reality that has not yet been created and therefore is unknowable in principle.”
What separates artificial intelligence from human intelligence?
The gap between artificial and human intelligence, the book says, is comprehension, “a non-algorithmic property of consciousness”. And while we can build a computer from its parts, “no one has ever been able to build a cell starting from atoms.”
Where Mark and Jeremy disagree
Jeremy asks whether AI already builds understanding the way his own experience does: “Isn't that us though?” Mark asks what happens when lab-grown brains are put inside a machine.
Links from this episode
Questions
Can a computer experience anything?
Faggin says no. Chapter 3 of Irreducible argues that a computer, however powerful, processes symbols it does not understand.
What is chapter 3 of Irreducible about?
Chapter 3 of Federico Faggin's Irreducible: Consciousness, Life, Computers, and Human Nature, read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, traces machines from relays to microchips and argues that a computer, however powerful, processes symbols it does not understand.
Has anyone ever built a living cell from atoms?
Faggin writes that no one has ever built a cell starting from atoms, and that living organisms use every phenomenon available, quantum and classical.
How has the computer evolved, according to chapter 3?
Chapter three of Irreducible follows the machine from relays and triodes to the MOS transistor and chips with up to a trillion transistors.
Transcript
Mark Fielding Disruptors and Curious Minds book lovers, you're tuned into the Thinking on Paper book club where we read books that have stood the test of time, books that will change your mind and none of the books we've read so far will probably change your mind as much as Irreducible by Federico Faggin and it's book number seven in the book club. Today we're reading chapter three, Consciousness, Life, Computers and Human Natures. We'll be talking about transistors, the history of computers, robots, robots versus computers, computers versus robots, robots versus humans, humans versus robots, what does it all mean?
Consciousness, quantum mechanics, relays, diodes, triodes, not triads for you guitar nuts out there. But, Jeremy, I wanna begin with a question for you. consciousness, I've been inspired, I've been meditating more this week just to get deeper into my own consciousness. Sam Harris, Waking Up App, I've been using that a lot.
And I've come to this realization based on this book. I want to know what you think about it.
I haven't been sitting in a calm, zen-like enlightened state. When I meditate, my brain is just a firework display of thoughts crashing around completely out of control. There's not much zen going in. But I was thinking from this, every time a new thought flashes into my head when I'm meditating, is that the wave function collapsing?
Jeremy Gilbertson Very interesting. I was thinking about this. was listening to Sam Harris' wife's, I think it's his wife, Ana. She has a new audio documentary out there that got me thinking about that. And I actually wrote a note and wrote a note about this because consciousness, so there are so many different ways things can happen, right? In your brain, in your mind.
my consciousness versus your consciousness and wave collapsing. There is something to that. I don't know if the thoughts or the waves collapsing or not, but there's something there. There's something.
Thoughts, and consciousness
Mark Fielding How do separate thoughts from consciousness? Is consciousness not thought? Is thought not consciousness? And if we're talking about quantum consciousness.
Jeremy Gilbertson So consciousness, the way I think about it is like the awareness of your own experience, right? Like I'm aware of my surroundings. consciousness is also based on memories. This is where the, on her audio documentary, this is the idea that I was trying to bring up. The idea that memories are tied to consciousness, meaning memories are these perceptions of a conscious state.
And that, I think, is a wave collapse. Is a memory.
Mark Fielding interpreted as thought. I think we're saying the same thing.
Jeremy Gilbertson Maybe so thoughts could be random thoughts could be just weird random stuff that like fires in your brain
Mark Fielding But that's still consciousness. You still need to be conscious to have that. the animals aren't having weird mad thoughts about
Jeremy Gilbertson How do you know?
Mark Fielding how do you know? I don't know. Anyway, I've got a follow on question. So, well, I've been meditating for years. Can you not tell? Yeah, you don't get this beautiful without meditating a lot. So let's say that our conscious, every time a new thought comes in, that's the collapsing of the wave function, the quantum realm speaking to us.
Jeremy Gilbertson I love that you're meditating by the way. It's one of the most... Yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson I don't know.
Do we create the universe?
Mark Fielding I'm going with it. So if that is the case, does that mean that via meditation, via critical thinking, via thinking on paper, I can control?
collapse of the wave function, by becoming more Zen, by becoming more aware of my thoughts, by being able to not follow those thoughts, am I controlling the quantum realm there? By preventing those thoughts just flashing in, even if it's just for a second, a moment of calm, is that me pushing back on the collapse of the wave function?
Jeremy Gilbertson That's really interesting to think about. That's really interesting to think about. Everyone gets all caught up on meditating the right way and they get all stressed out and when thoughts come in their head, they think they're failing at meditation and that sort of thing where the real root, even if you have these hyper minuscule moments of complete nothingness happening in your head and training those to be longer and longer and longer, actually the best
Mark Fielding I don't think we like that word, do we? Here's your thinking on paper, titbit.
Wim Hof
Jeremy Gilbertson There you go. To the T-O-P tidbit. No. Have you ever done any Wim Hof breathing?
Mark Fielding Yeah, I'm doing it right now. Yeah, I did four minutes.
Jeremy Gilbertson Have you done it with the pushups?
Mark Fielding I've held my breath and done pushups. I've held my breath running and stuff, yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, okay. So I found after like four rounds of that with doing the push-ups, it was almost like it was the quickest way to a very cool meditative state as opposed to just trying to sit there for 20 minutes to get somewhere, 30 minutes, whatever it is. I got there quicker by doing that, which was really interesting.
Mark Fielding Well, we need to get an expert on, but that's to do with carbon dioxide and oxygen, isn't it? I think that's a different process that's happening where your brain is almost being starved of oxygen. It's the carbon dioxide that's doing that.
Jeremy Gilbertson I think you're over oxygenating when you do those big breaths and those quick, yeah, yeah, yeah, Anyway, let's get focused on the nature of machines.
Mark Fielding Five minutes in and we haven't even spoken about the book. Irreducible. But these thoughts are stemmed from reading the book. Listener. But Jeremy, so go. Chapter three, the nature of machines, the evolution of machines. What are your first thoughts?
Questions over answers
Jeremy Gilbertson So I've always been a big fan of questions over answers. Just the idea of questions over answers in the Einstein quote that starts this whole chapter. One day the machines will be able to solve all the problems, but none of them will ever be able to pose one.
Mark Fielding After our last book, Nexus, that's such a hopeful, optimistic quote. I love it.
Jeremy Gilbertson It really is. But I always teach my kids, know, that our superpower is our curiosity, our creativity, our ability to ask really good questions, right? So starting off, I thought that was really cool. It goes through a nice stepping through of how computers became computers and some of the amazing inventions our host and author put together. I mean, it's really interesting.
Mark Fielding Let's call him Federico. Work the algorithms.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, that's right. I like, yeah, there you go. I still like calling the authors hosts for this conversation. Um, but yeah, I did get a little cross-eyed with, with some of the technical stuff, um, in here, but, uh, we, goes through kind of these, this evolution of machines with, with relays, you know, from relays to triodes from triodes to the, you know, MOS transistor, um,
Pretty interesting, like kind of difficult to follow because I'm not in the nitty gritty of those mechanical things, those electrical things. How did you, did your mind melt a little bit with that or no?
Mark Fielding Well, I had to look at what MOS stood for, which is like how much now, metal oxide semiconductor created in 1959. I really liked the way he describes the history of computers. Obviously, a lot of people have wrote a lot of histories of the computer. I think he describes it in a very nice way. We go very quickly from the coal-fired industrial revolution via electromagnetism.
Jeremy Gilbertson What does it stand for?
Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, okay.
Mark Fielding via the abacus to the reelo like you said, the triode.
What matters is in the organisation
Mark Fielding We are discovering that the large portion of what matters in our life has to do with information. Creating, transforming, moving and consuming information represent a growing portion of what interests us. OK, what I liked about that quote was what came next. But if we think about it, much of the physical movement in the past was also connected with information. For example, 200 years ago, what we accomplished with a phone call by downloading some data to our computer would have required a trip of several days on horseback.
40 years ago we physically went to the library, to a record store, to a movie theatre. 40 years, I went to a movie theatre the other day. To do what we now do at home or on the go. So yeah, nothing's changed and he kind of relates the evolution of technology in computers to the evolution of information flow. Thought that was very interesting. For the reader, yeah, if they want to go deep into the tech, they're welcome.
Jeremy Gilbertson It all comes down to the organization of electrons, right? We talked about like, I don't remember if this was the first chapter or second chapter or whatever it was, but just that we're all organizations, unique organizations of electrons, right? And it goes from Steam Engine to where you would have, if I wanted to tell you something back in the day, I'd have to jump on a damn train powered by Steam Engine to go see you and be like, hey Mark, what's up?
But now, there's soon a dense network of cables covered the cities to distribute energy and information without moving anything but electrical signals. So a taste of what's to come, right?
Mark Fielding You like a big number, I like a big number. I did like when he moved on to modern chips and when he's describing a modern microchip it may contain up to one trillion transistors and can speed up human calculations nearly a quadrillion times with nothing moving. Moreover a chip is monolithic, so I learnt this, in the sense that all its parts are made and assembled simultaneously. What moves in a chip are electric signals but that motion is more like the propagation of light than the motion of objects.
in a chip though the electromagnetic energy that carries the information flows through the labyrinths of streets and doors at close to the speed of light. And what was interesting on the chip was that how the connectors take up much more space than the actual transistors on a chip. Like way more space, which is quite mind boggling because whenever I think of a chip, how do they fit billions and trillions of transistors onto a chip the size of a thumbnail?
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, I think a lot of us think about all of this stuff is just pure magic Like you turn on like I turned on this computer to start this, you know This this recording and it's just like you just take for granted that there's like a tiny little box sitting on my desk That has all these things in it that are sending Ones and zeros through these tiny little compartments these tiny little pathways that are getting a to B And we all are just like wow, it's just amazing that it works
Boolean
Mark Fielding Boolean, did you know it was called Boolean?
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, Boolean math. Yeah.
Mark Fielding So what you've just described is a nice segue of, yeah, okay, we all have these computers on our tables. We don't really know what they do. It's like a magic box. You open it up and suddenly we're talking across the Atlantic Ocean at the speed of light, reading books, which we don't understand to an audience of tens, thousands of people listening to us.
Computers compared to brains
Mark Fielding He gets into it, doesn't he? Where the comparison between computers and humans and the difference between a computer system and a human system, he starts talking about computers are reductionists, computers are deterministic, and we're not, doesn't he?
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, really interesting. So pointing back to what he said in the preface, I think, and then teased it in chapter one is these two paths of semantic and symbolic, right? So the ones and zeros, know, the computer's not concerned with what the ones and zeros mean. They're just concerned with processing the ones and zeros according to the algorithms and the instructions and that sort of thing.
the semantic side, the meaning is assigned to those by the programmer, right? And, you know, we are the beneficiaries of the output, which is really interesting to think about it in that way.
The operation is extremely fragile
Mark Fielding And yet the operation of the computer, however, is extremely fragile because it would take just one wrong bit to turn a machine that seems intelligent and deliberate into a completely useless box of metal, plastic and silicon, which I think my laptop is currently going through that process, trying its hardest to become a useless box of plastic and silicon.
Jeremy Gilbertson my gosh, your port.
Your poor laptop. Your poor laptop. What about computers? So, computer... this is a really cool sentence. A computer is a physical structure in which an energy pattern created by the human mind has been organized in such a form that the matter is forced to act in accordance with this pattern. I love the idea that it references an energy pattern because that's what we're talking about.
Jeremy Gilbertson is energy harnessed and pointed in a way and directed to do something very deterministic. Right? The computer, like you said, is deterministic. It can't decide. It just processes what it's told based on the rules.
Mark Fielding Yeah, however complex they are, that's all they're doing is obeying set commands by us, by the human, isn't it?
Can a computer experience anything?
Jeremy Gilbertson So today's date, is March 28th, 2025. Just to set some context, there's another quote here, meaning understanding and free will decisions do not exist within a computer. What is that gonna look, is that gonna change in 20 years, right?
Mark Fielding Well, that's the whole point of the book. No, no is the answer to that, Jeremy. No is the answer to that. It will not change because consciousness is a quantum experience.
Jeremy Gilbertson Fair enough.
Mark Fielding Could have computer experience. But that's not my idea. So then we get back into quantum, don't we?
Jeremy Gilbertson Fair enough.
Randomness, and ignorance
Mark Fielding Following on from what you said, says, moreover, the randomness of quantum physics is fundamentally different from what we call random in classical systems. Classical randomness corresponds to the lack of knowledge of what could be known by solving the deterministic equations of classical physics. Quantum randomness is instead non-algorithmic because it is indetermined prior to the measurement that literally creates it and then further along. In other words, the randomness of quantum physics does not...
correspond to the ignorance of a reality that is knowable, but to a reality that has not yet been created and therefore is unknowable in principle. That's like my mad thoughts when I'm meditating.
Jeremy Gilbertson Definitely, definitely a mad thought.
Mark Fielding Doesn't it fill you with hope and optimism though after reading the last book where we get this is the opposite side of the coin, isn't it? This is the opposite side of the AGI super intelligence argument.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, and it's one of those things like how, so you have the machines, you have the pieces and parts and this idea of separate in principle, SIP, right? It's, you you have these machines that are made of all these different parts, but if you remove the parts, the machine really doesn't work. So they call it kind of separate in principle, just to theoretically describe what.
Mark Fielding Yeah, because you could take a chip to pieces, but I mean, you're not going to because we can't, but you could theoretically.
Jeremy Gilbertson So computers are... let's let's... Julio Oatino, what's up dude? First Book Club Nexus Thinking. He talks about these two ideas of a complicated and complex. So as I start to thread the books together, I would say... I would say computers are complicated and consciousness is complex or quantum is complex, right?
Mark Fielding Yeah, which you should be doing listener.
Jeremy Gilbertson Alright, so to perform a useful function, so each of these parts, separate in principle, requires an exchange of energy between the parts in the environment. So this is... Let's see.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, what we're doing, what we're doing in this is there's like the idealization, he calls it, of this holistic system, right? Which I thought was really cool and the idea of reductionist versus holistic. What did you think about that?
What reductionism means
Mark Fielding I was just going to ask you what that meant when he says a reductionist system is therefore a holistic system in which the inevitable dissipative interactions with the environment have been minimised to avoid jeopardising their intended function. Such a system is a simplified mental model of reality. What does he mean when he's talking about reductionist idealisation of a holistic system?
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, reductionists, when I always think about it, is like us as humans, want to take something and put it in its pieces and parts and explain it, what it does and how it does it. Holistic is something working together, not just hierarchical, but also emerging at the same time, I think. And, you know, I think there's kind of this disconnect between the computer as a system, I guess.
and you know the the capability of what it what it can do maybe i don't know i'm talking in circles this chapter has kind of bonkered my head a little bit
Mark Fielding There's another one here. When we consider that the elementary parts of which everything is made are quantum states that behave like probability waves that can also be influenced by the random fluctuations of the quantum vacuum, true reductionism cannot exist.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, there you have it, Classical Physics.
Jeremy Gilbertson Alright, well-
True reductionism cannot exist
Mark Fielding That kind of makes sense because true reductionism cannot exist. So everything is quantum interactions on the atomic scale and even everything in those the trillions of transistors on the microchip all the way down. It's probability waves. It can't be.
It's not reduction because it doesn't exist until you interact with it and it becomes created. You can't take it apart. You can't go back. You can't study it because it didn't exist before you study it. And when you study it, it changes what it was or is or could be.
I don't know what that means though. Does that mean that...
Is that the argument for why consciousness will never be in a machine? Why a machine will never be conscious?
Jeremy Gilbertson we're yet to find. I think it's being revealed in real time as we read here.
Mark Fielding If reductionism complete isn't possible then...
Computers are completely deterministic
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, the major takeaway here is computers are completely deterministic and predictable, is what he says in here. they...
Mark Fielding Jane hasn't used mine, but yes.
Jeremy Gilbertson They do what they're told, right? Through the software, the hardware, the pieces and the parts, interacting with each other, exchanging energy, but not knowing the meaning of the ones and zeros that they are vigorously processing. They don't care about that. They're workhorses, right? So that's kind of the takeaway, kind of landed it in there.
Comprehension
Jeremy Gilbertson Comprehension. I thought that was an interesting piece of the puzzle.
Jeremy Gilbertson The gap between artificial intelligence and human intelligence, he is saying, is characterized by comprehension.
Jeremy Gilbertson And as he says, a non-algorithmic property of consciousness that is often underestimated and inaccessible to computers, as we will see in the course of this book, which is a little like, hey, teaser to come, comprehension. Like the meaning of comprehension is understanding something or making sense of something that's existing in front of you or within your consciousness, right? And it could be pulling, it's a synthesis of things, right? But doesn't AI today create understanding in a way?
Mark Fielding from preset conditions. It's creating a view, it's an interpretation of understanding from all the data that it's consumed.
Jeremy Gilbertson Isn't that us though? Isn't that, I'm gonna push on the other side of that. Isn't that us? Like I have, you know, nearly 49 years of experience, you know, things have been fed into my model. My model is used, my memory is used, what I see every day is used to sense make. How is that different?
Mark Fielding You're a quantum machine,
Jeremy Gilbertson Keep at that. Keep at that.
Mark Fielding You are alive, you are organic, you are creating that existence as part of the conscious universe, lest we forget. Jeremy, that is the difference. This remote control, which essentially is no different in theory to a computer, is not.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, so we organized and built those parts, not you and I, but humans, built those parts to do a specific thing.
We are not built to do a specific thing
Jeremy Gilbertson We're not built to do a specific thing. We can be conditioned to do specific things through experiences, through what we learn from things.
Jeremy Gilbertson But then again, we have the ability to make our own decisions unless we're otherwise compromised by propaganda, by coercion, right? But the ability for control is there.
We, I think, when I say the word spirituality, being spiritual, I'm not referring to a religious concept. I'm talking about the way that you view and internalize the self, humanity, the universe, and...
these kind of deep questions of what are we, what is there, is answered by different ways. And I think that this is one way to wrestle with those bigger questions that are beyond us. And I think that...
Mark Fielding Sometimes you have to leave certain preconceptions at the door and think about it on a different level, which isn't always easy to do. Here's a question for you after what I just said. If we make organic matter in a lab, if we create brains in a Petri dish and we put them in a machine, is that machine in a robot? Is that robot?
At what point does it no longer become a robot? At what point can it access the quantum realm of humanity?
Jeremy Gilbertson So we're talking about Frankenstein meets Robocop meets human machine things.
The logical progression of biotech
Mark Fielding I think we're talking about the logical progression of what biotech and technologies is doing right now. don't, it's a logical progression of what will happen. People are already doing it on a very small scale. It will. I think it's a logical regression of where we go. So what happens when that happens to this book, when consciousness is an organic quantum process ingrained in the reality of the universe, like he says,
Machines cannot be conscious. So you create a machine that's not a machine.
Jeremy Gilbertson This is really interesting stuff, like super interesting stuff, and I love the idea, just the theory that he has that consciousness can be explained by quantum mechanics because quantum mechanics is one of the most provable theorems, theories in science. I think we ran into that in a couple of our other books.
Jeremy Gilbertson which is super interesting, right? But yet it's so difficult to understand because it's not in our immediate proximity to understand it, right? It's like putting faith in something that maybe we know someone who we trust has told us that it exists, but we have never seen it or witnessed it. Let's talk a little bit about...
So we can build, here's a quote, we can build a computer starting from its elementary components, but no one has ever been able to build a cell starting from atoms. So again, I don't necessarily subscribe to this belief, but what if we just don't know that something like that can happen because it's beyond our capability to understand.
It's something we've never seen or experienced, but it has happened in some way or form.
Mark Fielding It is, isn't it? It is beyond our understanding. It is.
Mark Fielding totally beyond our understanding. Would it always remain this?
Never complete
Jeremy Gilbertson All right, so let's get a little bit more tangible here. One of the things that I really like and apply in a lot of ways to stuff that I do outside of what you and I are doing, this idea that humans are in a constant state of becoming, which is super cool. We're evolving minute by minute. Our cells aren't even the same year over year. There's a change out of our actual cells.
but just the idea that we can grow and evolve if we allow ourselves to is really cool. And the idea that a machine, you like this MacBook that's sitting over here was built and shipped out of a facility, shipped complete, right? So this idea of something being complete, that is a computer and something that is in a constant state of evolution. that's the difference between silicon and carbon.
Right? I thought that was pretty cool. How do you feel about the whole becoming versus completion?
Mark Fielding Buddhist, it's stoic, We are never complete. The only time we are complete is when we die. It's just a road of adding bits, adding everything, yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson But are we complete when we die? I disagree with that.
Mark Fielding That's the end of the game, isn't it?
Jeremy Gilbertson As we know, no one's ever come back and said, Hey, you know, here's where we go next.
Mark Fielding Well, the energy is gone somewhere else, isn't it? Just the laws of thermodynamics.
Mark Fielding It has gone somewhere else away from you out of your quantum experience into somewhere else, something else's quantum experience.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, years ago, like not years ago, like five years ago, but like back in, you know, Greek philosopher days and, even, even subsequently after that, this idea of anima, you know, is, the soul of this thing, right? And then there was this concept that we're in ether. So like anima living in ether, both of which have, well, the ether theory, you know, basically created what was it general relative? No, special relativity. I can't remember one of the two. one of the reasons he talked about in this book, Einstein, Einstein's curiosity was led by trying to disprove the ether that ether exists existed, right? So yeah, there's there's energy and the organization here it is. Here it is. Bam. Mic drop. Get ready. Everything's the organization of energy for instances.
Mark Fielding And there you go. And exactly it's when you die, it's all over. And have you seen that film? It is your particular quantum experience. 21 grams is it about the film? And when you die, your body loses 21 grams and that's your soul floating away.
Jeremy Gilbertson It's not all over though. It's not all over.
Jeremy Gilbertson wow, no, I never knew that.
Mark Fielding 21 grams is it called? It's not true Jeremy, it's a film. 21 grams or 27 grams. This is a question for the listener, a question for you and I think we've just covered it in the last 10 minutes of our quantum exploration. What's the difference between a robot and a living organism? The fundamental differences between robots and living organisms are surprising and poorly understood.
Living organisms, and coordination
Mark Fielding While computers and robots are classical machines, living organisms are not because they process information using all the phenomena available in the physical world. Quantum, classical, discrete and continuous. Inside a living cell, individual atoms are used to process information and this makes it extremely difficult to understand how the cell works. The quantum behaviour of single atomic and molecular events within a living cell gives rise to an incredibly complex dynamic order.
which cannot be described by the quantum statistical laws that regulate the behaviour of objects made up of millions of atoms.
There you go. That's the answer to that question that we posed about 10 minutes ago.
Jeremy Gilbertson Coordination, so it's coordination for instances, coordination for moments in time, whether it's an electron or an atom, it's kind of what it is.
Jeremy Gilbertson How's our coordination right now? I feel like we're becoming decoupled.
Mark Fielding Yeah, I think that's a good way to land the quantum ship. We are all separable in principle. Don't forget that. That you're very, very, very, very lucky. You won the lottery to be alive and conscious and thinking now. And you might be dis-separated at any moment. So enjoy your consciousness. Wield your consciousness. Call a friend. Listen to some music. Watch a movie. Eat some ice cream. Just do something with your consciousness.
Jeremy Gilbertson I love that, Mark. I love the little trickles at the end. These are perfect.
Jeremy Gilbertson Outstanding. Well, what do we...
Mark Fielding The side of the night for your computer, is it? It's just another zero or another one.
Jeremy Gilbertson There's no semantic understanding of what it means to be Friday night. take that as our difference between machines as we fight the, what did you call it? The spectrum, the doom utopia spectrum as we watch AI do what it's heading to do and you know.
Mark Fielding We're keeping humanity in the hunt, Jeremy. Let's keep our humanity in the hunt. That's what I'm thinking about now. We've moved on from the spectrum of doom and gloom. Nexus was very much on the doom spectrum. Now we're back on the optimistic human side of technology, which is good because we've got Kevin Kelly, is perhaps the ultimate technological optimist on the show in two weeks. That's good. Good news.
Jeremy Gilbertson Super exciting. Well, stay tuned. There's a lot of great teasers in chapter three. We got a ton more to unpack. Help us do it. If you're reading this thing, you you watch me stumble through my own interpretation and understanding. Help me land the plane. Help me understand. And I thank you, Mark, for being my buddy on these journeys. It's been a pleasure.
Mark Fielding It has and I think we're using our consciousness to good effect this Friday afternoon. So yeah, stay disruptive, be curious, keep thinking on things.
Jeremy Gilbertson Be curious. Keep thinking on paper. Hey, let's do that one more time so it doesn't juggle. can audit, you can edit that out. Be curious.
Jeremy Gilbertson Keep thinking on paper.




