Where Is the Smart Money Going in Space?

Mark Boggett names ground terminals, the kit that brings satellite data down to Earth, as one of the most under-invested parts of the space market. Investors have just not been able to get themselves excited about investing into ground terminals.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 18 chapters

  1. The size of the space economy
  2. Space Race 2.0
  3. IPOs, and the public markets
  4. Trump and Musk
  5. The venture backed companies
  6. Launch costs
  7. Why the unglamorous parts are underinvested
  8. Latency
  9. Planet Watchers
  10. Is space getting too crowded?
  11. Getting an old satellite out of orbit
  12. Who pays for the cleanup?
  13. How the investment strategy changed
  14. Defence driving the speed
  15. The Cold War precedent
  16. One word questions
  17. The best reason to go to the moon
  18. The Kevin Kelly question
We could actually fill that with so much junk that we can’t actually get off the planet anymore. So it’s about us being a steward for next generations who might need to escape the planet.
Mark Boggett

Seraphim invests other people's money, and its investors expect a return within about ten years. Mark Boggett explains why that keeps him close to Earth, then walks through Seraphim's map of the market, from launch bottlenecks to satellite data sold to insurers.

He tracks the shift to defence, which he says sets the pace while commercial markets reap the benefit. Debris, deorbiting and Cold War cooperation follow. On the Moon, his view is plain: “I think it should be treated as a training ground.”

Mark Boggett, CEO and co-founder of space technology investor Seraphim, tells the Thinking On Paper podcast where space investment is going. He says defence now dominates, ground terminals that bring satellite data down to Earth are among the most under-invested parts of the market, and his prediction that direct to device satellite connectivity would hit the mainstream has held up.

Where is the smart money going in space?

Mark Boggett says defence now dominates space investment. He names ground terminals, which bring satellite data down to Earth, as among the most under-invested parts of the market.

Why does Seraphim avoid Moon and Mars ventures?

Seraphim avoids Moon, Mars and asteroid ventures because its investors expect their money back within about ten years. Boggett asks of those ventures, “can you make money in a 10 year period in those? Well, the answer is probably no.”

Why are satellite ground terminals under-invested?

Downlink, the business of getting satellite data from orbit to the ground, has taken only about 2 to 3% of total space spending for the last ten years, Boggett says. “Investors have just not been able to get themselves excited about investing into ground terminals”, yet he expects it to become a growth area because satellite operators need data down fast and in a cyber-secure way.

How is defence money shaping the space industry?

Defence money is speeding up the build-out of space data infrastructure, and Boggett says the commercial markets will be the real beneficiaries. He says revenues in Seraphim's London-listed public fund are now nearly 80% defence, and expects defence's share of revenue to fall from 70 or 80% to about 20% within five years.

Has direct to device satellite connectivity gone mainstream?

Boggett says his prediction that direct to device, satellites connecting straight to ordinary mobile phones, would hit the mainstream in 2025 has held up. He says SpaceX spent $17 billion buying spectrum from EchoStar, and that AST SpaceMobile, which builds “cell towers in space”, hit an $18 billion valuation earlier in the summer.

Is space debris a problem, according to Mark Boggett?

Space debris “isn't a problem today”, Boggett argues, but only 18,000 satellites have ever been launched, half of them since 2020, so regulators are now focused on making operators remove satellites at the end of their economic life. He says licences are moving towards requiring independent propulsion to deorbit, a removal contract with a company such as Astroscale, a Seraphim portfolio company, or an insurance policy.

Where Mark, Jeremy and Boggett disagree

Mark puts it to Boggett that launch costs are still the industry's biggest obstacle; Boggett disagrees, saying SpaceX's Starship will cut prices by a further order of magnitude and the constraint is launch availability. Jeremy presses on who pays to clear old debris, and Boggett concedes that looking backwards is hard because the regulation did not exist.

Questions

Where is the smart money going in space?

Mark Boggett says defence now dominates space investment. He names ground terminals, which bring satellite data down to Earth, as among the most under-invested parts of the market.

Who is Mark Boggett?

Mark Boggett, CEO and co-founder of space technology investor Seraphim, tells the Thinking On Paper podcast where space investment is going.

What does Mark Boggett think about the Moon?

On the Moon, his view is plain: “I think it should be treated as a training ground.”

What kind of investor is Seraphim?

Seraphim invests other people's money, and its investors expect a return within about ten years.

Transcript

Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds. Welcome to another episode of thinking on paper where we unpack the future with the people building it in real time.

The size of the space economy

Mark Fielding The global space economy reached $546 billion in 2023 and the World Economic Forum predicts $1.8 trillion of investment by 2035. So my question for listeners as we go through today's show is: where is the smart money being invested? Space is no longer the final frontier. It's maturing, capital is spreading to a broader set of companies, a broader set of technologies. We've spoken about a lot of them on thinking on paper. Public demand is rising and today's guest is Mark Boggert, the CEO and co-founder of Seraphim, an international investment firm focused on space technology. And he is going to help us understand who's investing, where they're investing and what we can expect over the next few years.

in the advancements of space technology. I'm excited, Jeremy. welcome to the show, Mark.

Mark Boggett Yeah, well I'm excited as well. We're going to be talking about space. It's great to be on the show, speak about space every day. It must be an amazing position to be in.

Mark Boggett I'm pinched myself. The stuff that's going on, the real stuff that's going on, but the stuff that's on the near-term horizon that we're going to talk about today, I think is going to get everybody excited.

Mark Fielding That's a very interesting point that you made because when I was looking at the Seraphim investment portfolio, it is very much the term. It's very actionable. It's very of the moment. It's not this grandiose Star Trek vision of space technology.

Mark Boggett Correct. We are investing other people's money and they typically expect to see it back within a 10 year period. So that really sort of narrows our focus about what we're going to invest into. And whilst there's all these amazing, exciting things that are going on on the moon and Mars and asteroids, they're fantastic. But can you make money in a 10 year period in those? Well, the answer is probably no. So this is the reason why we stay a little closer to home.

when it comes to where we're deploying our money within the space market.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, let's yeah, let's let's dive right in. So the reason we reached out to was related to some predictions you had in the space economy at the beginning of the year. And it's always fun to kind of noodle back and see those are doing, what what's happening. Let's let's jump in and see, see those and and see.

out here. I haven't looked at those predictions since I think I wrote them in December. So I

Mark Fielding Mark, the advantage here is that you can analyze and critique your own score because you know much more than we do. So you could just say, that's exactly what happened. So prediction number one.

Space Race 2.0

Mark Fielding Space Race 2.0 hots between the US and China will continue to drive both governmental and commercial markets. 2024 has seen a surge in large funding rounds in Chinese space tech companies. That is set to continue. Do you stand by that prediction?

The US in the first half of last year really fell behind China.

in terms of the volume and value of investment that was going into space. That was rectified in the second half of the year. But in the first half of this year, China has not been investing as much as we saw last year. relatively speaking, there's been a huge boost to the US there. So, yes, I think I'm safe in saying that that's correct.

Mark Fielding Why do you think that is?

Why do you think that is? are China spending less?

Mark Boggett they just had an exceptional period in 2024. And the other thing with the Chinese numbers is that you can't really rely on them. they paint a picture, but you know, I think they do little more than that. But we have enough evidence to see that it's a really hot race.

and you know these are two horses running neck and neck and you've got Europe which is sort of squeezing in between the two with very significant capital that's been allocated this year so we're expecting this to become a three horse race.

Mark Fielding prediction number two, direct to device ready for prime time. Following on from Apple's recent 1.5 billion investment in GlobalStar to improve space-based communications for iPhones, we expect 2025 will be the year that direct to device satellite connectivity hits the mainstream with SpaceX, AST, Space Mobile and Skylo all launching direct to device offerings.

well another one that's I'm pleased that I said that one. So yeah, we've just seen in the last week or so that SpaceX has spent 17 billion on buying spectrum from EchoStar so that they can have the spectrum that's required to be able to from satellites communicate directly to mobile phones.

And then the other company that we referenced there, AST. So that company, if you pull up the stock price ticker on that and look at the chart, they've had an incredible year. They hit $18 billion valuation.

earlier in the summer. They're about $15 billion now. So the rest of the market are really expecting them to start coming through. So what these guys do, they do cell towers in space. And they provide the ability to be able to connect to any mobile phone without any hardware or software adjustment to that phone. Just any old phone can roam onto cell towers in space that are provided by AST.

Jeremy Gilbertson just a quick thing on that, the cell towers in space, any technology that can bridge an old technology and make it easy to connect and use and all of that has great success, right? And we're seeing that with these guys, yeah.

Mark Boggett Yeah, you know, it's really clever. What it basically does is it tricks the ground-based infrastructure to believe that the space-based infrastructure is actually on the ground. So they can't distinguish the fact that the satellite is in space. And these things are absolutely massive. There's 700 square meters in space. These things are huge.

Mark Fielding Well, thank you. I'm thinking that mainly from my mom who needs better phone reception. So anything which helps there, I'm all for. Prediction number three, public markets learn to love space tech again. 2024 has seen a significant recovery in the share prices of many space tech companies that went public during this SPAC boom of 2021. Several of these companies

IPOs, and the public markets

Mark Fielding most notably Rocket Lab and AST Space Mobile, have now been propelled into the ranks of most valuable space tech companies in the world.

Mark Boggett Yeah, you know, so that is the case. So several space related IPOs have happened in 2024, including one of our portfolio companies, Voyager. So that's one of the space station companies they IPO'd about two months ago. So there's been three space related IPOs this year. The most recent one was Firefly, which is absolutely flown. This is a rocket launch American company. So yeah, you know, that is true. There has been the market.

has been very receptive to these space companies as they've come to the market. So I think that that one is true. We should definitely stop there now because I'm probably going to get all the rest of them wrong.

good with that. can run with three for three. Didn't Voyager have a particularly interesting technical achievement moment this year or recently?

Mark Boggett These guys are the Space Station Company. They're effectively science parks in space. So what we're now invested into

Mark Fielding I like the sounds of that.

Mark Boggett are the tenants of those science parks. So we're investing into the companies that are doing things like new materials or doing things like biofarmers, inventing drugs that will effectively be the customers on those space stations.

Mark Fielding number four, private markets reaching for the stratosphere, but exits to remain rare. We expect 2025 will be another year of record breaking investment activity in the private markets. More space tech companies will raise VC funding than ever before. Although the heights of 2021 may not be quite surpassed, we do suspect investment to grow substantially year on year.

so it is growing, but not as fast as I was thinking back then. So we're still up on 2024, but I think it's like 10%, 12%, 13%. I was expecting it to be more like 50%, 60%, 70%. I think this is probably going to be one of my predictions for this year. I think that we're going to see a very significant influx of cash from investors who've just discovered space.

realized about all these amazing things that happening. And I really see that lifting up. So graded my own homework here, so I'll probably give myself a C on that one.

Trump and Musk

Mark Fielding Okay, and the last one, Trump and Musk to dominate the space agenda.

Mark Boggett that is definitely happening, but not really in the way that I would have liked to have predicted at the time. we've sort of moved into reverse gear when it comes to sort of space exploration. we've had some big NASA. So, yeah, that's definitely one that I think they've had an impact.

But I'm not so sure that it's the positive impact that we were all really hoping for. But time will tell.

Jeremy Gilbertson Sounds good. Sounds good. Thanks for, thanks for entertaining us through those, through the revisit of your predictions. That's, that was, it's always fun to do. I want to talk about this map So it's a 2025 map of, of essentially the the economy, that sort of thing. And the categories are really interesting to me and the tangible nature of what you're putting together on one page.

The venture backed companies

Mark Boggett so these companies are the venture backed companies that are really the new space leaders. We've created this map to help investors understand who the competitors are, the leading competitors within different parts of the market. So we've broken it down between upstream and downstream. So put simply, upstream is about the building and launching and creation of the satellite platforms, whereas downstream is about taking the data.

back down from space, down to earth, and for it then to be used within software and as an input to different businesses.

So let me just talk you through each of these to help you understand. on the upstream side, you've got build. So this is the building of satellites, the building everything that goes in relation to building that. So you've got the hardware side, and then you've got the software side.

the two different types of companies that relate to that. So you've got things like propulsion within the hardware side, and then within the software side, you've got AI elements, and then you've got the operational elements. Next of all, we've then got launch. And you'll see that there's a whole range of companies there in the launches. Now, this is a really interesting sector because this is really considered to have a big bottleneck at the moment.

You've got SpaceX out in the lead that have effectively got almost a monopoly on the global launch market. You've got some newer companies there that are now operational, such as Rocket Labs and Firefly. But what we've got in the market is about 100 or 200 other financed rocket companies all around the world that are now vying to become operational to address this big bottleneck that we've got in the space environment.

Launch costs

Mark Fielding launch costs are still the biggest obstacle that the industry faces.

Mark Boggett well, launch costs have come down considerably. So I wouldn't categorise the launch costs as the issue for the industry. You know, they've continued to fall and ever keeping ahead, SpaceX have got their next rocket that they're just about to bring to the market, which is called Starship, which is this rocket that takes 100 metric tonnes to space in a single launch. So that's going to take the price down by...

an order of magnitude further. So price is not really something that's the sort of main focus at the moment. It's the availability.

So next of all we've got platforms. So this is our word for satellite constellations. So this is where you've got a satellite operator that's got many different satellites And the reason why a constellation would grow is that these satellites are all gathering data about Earth.

And the more satellites that you add to the constellation, the closer to real time the data gets that is being gathered by those satellites. So you can see that the value increases as the frequency that you collect that data goes closer to real time. the other one that's in there is called HAPS, High Altitude Platforms. So these are pseudo satellites.

that sit in the stratosphere. And these are sort of balloons or planes that effectively hover above a certain area. They have all of the sort of same payloads as a satellite, but they're inside of the orbit just.

Mark Fielding the Chinese balloons that were in the news a few years ago would that be a hap?

Mark Boggett Yeah, that would be a good example. balloons and think about the Goodyear Blimp. This is what many of them look this is a market that is still very embryonic, but we're expecting to grow quite significantly because it has a whole range of benefits over the satellite industry. If your high altitude platform isn't working properly, you just bring it back down to earth, fix the problem and send it back up again. Of course you can't do that with satellites. So this is one of the real values that HAPS has to offer. So then we're then talking about downstream. So this is about how you get this data that's been collected by all of these satellites that are looking down at earth and monitoring everything that's going on. How do you get that down to the ground?

There's the communication element, there's the ground terminal element, and then there's the cyber security and the storage of all of that. So this is one of the areas that is the most under-invested within the space market. Everyone's been focused on launchers and on satellite constellations. So building out the infrastructure, building this critical infrastructure, this effectively this network in space.

We consider it's like a new internet that's being developed in the space environment. Now we've got to start getting this data down. And speed is everything. So the quicker you can get the data down, the more value that it has.

Why the unglamorous parts are underinvested

Mark Fielding Is that because it's more difficult or less exciting? Why is there a lack of investment there?

Mark Boggett I think you put your finger on it there. Investors have just not been able to get themselves excited about investing into ground terminals. They'd much rather invest into rocket launches or satellite constellations. But what these companies are now finding is that actually this is a really important element of their offering and they really need to get data down as quickly as possible in a cyber secure way. we believe that this is one of the growth areas of the future.

just because it's been so under invested in the past. Typically out of all of the market, Downlink only gets about two or 3 % of total spend and it's been pretty consistent at that sort of level, you for the last 10 years. it's just never been in fashion and I think it will be coming into fashion because many of the new investors that coming into this market.

are not really looking for the most exciting part of the space market. They're looking for the picks and shovels and the more mundane businesses that relate to space can really get on the space bandwagon for the growth of space, but they're more traditional type businesses.

Latency

Jeremy Gilbertson How's the technology doing to reduce latency in getting the data from space to Earth?

Mark Boggett the thing that is exciting that's expected to happen during the course of the next few years, and in fact, Amazon have been talking about doing this for a long time, and they're now just putting up the first satellites in their constellation. It's about creating a mesh network of satellites in orbit that communicate directly with each other via lasers, and then effectively have one central unit to actually send all of the data down. what's really compelling about that is one, particularly if it's Amazon that do that, it's all immediately connected into the cloud and it actually changes the design of satellites because if this mesh network is available and open for everyone to use, you just need to effectively have a laser and a receiver that on the right sort of frequency.

for you to be able to then use that for your downlink. So it should really increase capability, reduce latency and significantly reduce cost when this network is up and running. And there are a few other private companies and actually some really big government companies or not rather than government companies, large sort of conglomerate type companies.

but are also looking to focus on this area. So this is another area of growth. So next of all, you've got analyze. So these are companies that are focused exclusively on satellite data. So their entire business is about the data set that is being drawn from space. know, for example, they don't use any other data sets to provide their service to their customers.

Mark Boggett It's all about leveraging this data capability. The next level down.

Mark Fielding Can you give a couple

Planet Watchers

Mark Boggett let me give you the example of Planet Watchers. they access space data in order to be able help companies use this data. So they may well have a customer who's in the insurance market that wants to understand, what's happened in a particular field of that's growing crops.

as to whether those crops have been grown or whether those crops were damaged by a flood or a hurricane. So they would be a customer of a company like this that all of the input that they're using to sell to those customers is this data from space. The customer itself has no knowledge about how to access this data, how to analyze the data. They just want to know the answer to their question.

did that field grow that corn or was it, did it not grow anything because of a flood or other kind of climate related issue? So when you.

that data into intelligence for that business to use one way the other. Yeah. Yep. Yep.

Mark Boggett That's exactly what they do. And we call the sector analyze. It's the analysis of space data. Whereas the next one down is around product. So this is where space data is part of a range of different inputs that provide a product. there are companies in there, for example, that are like B0 that are effectively focused around climate.

credits. So they would be sort of evaluating a climate credit as to whether it's good value or not. So they'll take some space data, but they'll also take a whole range of data from other sources in order to be able to provide their client with the outcome of their service. so a product is where space data is just one element of the data that's important to that product.

Mark Fielding For anyone who's not watching, just listening, the five product verticals there are climate, insurance, location and mapping, logistics and other. On climate, mean, if we just pick Earth AI stands out as a catchy name there.

Are we seeing any success stories in these climate companies and where is that being realised?

Mark Boggett it's still relatively early days on these companies. The leading ones have got revenues of less than 100 million. So these businesses are scaling, but they're not reaching levels where the companies are growing to unicorns on the back of that growth they're focused around a market that is still embryonic, but is almost certain set to grow. Many of these companies are enabling this market to grow because what it's bringing is transparency to the data.

if you're Google and you've got all your data centers, you need to offset all the carbon that you're producing by buying carbon credits. When you go and buy a carbon credit, do you know that you are actually getting $1,000 of carbon offset for the $1,000 that you've just spent on that carbon credit or not?

So what some of these companies, Rhinoster is a good example of a company that's doing exactly that. What they're saying is this carbon credit, they look down at the forest that the carbon credit is written on and they analyse how many trees, what type of trees are there, what is the density of those trees, what's the health of those trees. And then what they're able to do then is accurately build up an understanding.

of what the carbon sequestration capability of that forest actually is. So you can then say, well, this carbon credit that's costing you $1,000, you actually get $4,000 of carbon sequestration for that $1,000. So that's great value. But you might say you only get $500 for that $1,000, and obviously it's bad value. So what this is doing is it's bringing confidence and transparency to a market that has largely been troubled by exactly that. whilst these companies are sort of new embryonic and you know, are in the early stages of growth, the market in which they're playing into is potentially, you know, ginormous and will be ginormous in the future.

Jeremy Gilbertson Makes sense. Yeah. So as we go through this, this map, we have, we have kind of the infrastructure piece component, the things that are used to collect data. And then we have the ability of getting that data from space to earth. And then we have the ability of making that data usable to businesses and companies and entities in a translation of that. get to the this map into the in-space economy.

we're all thinking about, in the future, the big, things that we could do in space. is that were this categories landing?

Mark Boggett It is, yeah. So this is, as the name suggests, it's all of the new markets in the space environment. Everything above the line here is really about space serving Earth. And now we're now moving into the in-space economy, it's kind of space to space. So we break that down into four parts, space services, space infrastructure, in-space R &D and manufacturing, and then space exploration.

the space services are companies largely around the debris management in space. many of the listeners have seen the film Gravity, where small fragments of a broken space station cause absolute havoc

Is space getting too crowded?

Mark Fielding that's the number one question that our audience ask is about space debris and how hazardous it is and what can we do about it.

Mark Boggett to answer that question, it isn't a problem today. Space is big. If you think about the Earth, 70 % of the Earth is covered with sea, and on that sea we've got millions upon millions of boats all operating and not colliding with each other too often. Each time you move another sort 10 metres out, that's a whole new plane.

that effectively covers all of the Earth. as you go out in these planes, you know, the environment is absolutely huge. So what we really need to make sure that we do is now respectful of the space environment and not unnecessarily create more debris as we're building out this network in the sky. You know, there's only ever been 18,000 satellites ever launched.

in the history of space. Half of those were launched since 2020. So we're going through this very rapid growth of the number of active satellites in the space environment. So the regulators are quite rightly now focused on making sure that regulations are in place so that when a satellite reaches the end of its economic life, that it's down to the operator of that satellite to remove that satellite. So there's a whole industry that has now grown.

in order to be able to provide the services that the regulators are saying are required so that these satellite operators abide by these rules and remove their satellites. So companies like Astroscale, which is one of our portfolio companies, is the market leader. They can not only remove satellites from space, they can go to a satellite that's run out of battery and they can then extend its battery life so that that satellite that could have cost 500 million dollars to a billion dollars that they can extend the life of that rather than the owner having to buy a new

Getting an old satellite out of orbit

Jeremy Gilbertson how do you get an old rickety satellite out of orbit and out of the ecosystem?

Mark Boggett what you effectively do is you go and you grab hold of it with a sort of robotic arm. You then push it towards the Earth's atmosphere where it burns up and

The other alternative is to effectively tow that satellite to a graveyard and leave all of the satellites that are not operational in one place.

Mark Fielding satellite graveyard and tow trucks pulling satellites, old rickety satellites into satellite graveyards is a fantastic idea. I love that analogy. Well, you're happening.

Yeah, well it's not an idea. know, this is what's happening right now.

Mark Boggett know, Astroscale IPO'd a year ago now. You know, this is a sort multi-billion dollar market already. it's something that's essential if we're going to make sure that space continues to be a habitable commercial environment.

Jeremy Gilbertson so out of those 18,000-ish satellites that have been launched and are up there, what percentage of them have fallen into the rickety category and been kind of either pushed in the atmosphere or dragged to the graveyard-ish?

about 10,000 operational satellites now, so it's about 8,000 that are not working and are effectively just debris.

Who pays for the cleanup?

Jeremy Gilbertson who funds the cleaning up of that stuff? Would the owner of the satellite go to this company you're talking about? And it's like you said, it's their responsibility, they have to fund it. What happens if they

Mark Boggett looking backwards is quite hard to, because the regulation didn't exist and, you know, it's hard to hold anyone to account. at some point we need to find a way to just go and clear up, you know, everything that's there already. What the regulation is really focused on now is stopping adding to that problem. the regulation is moved and is moving in the direction of that you won't get a license to launch unless you can prove one, that you've got independent propulsion that in the event that your satellite is not working, that can independently provide the propulsion necessary to send it back towards the earth where it burns up in the atmosphere. the other alternative is to have a contract with a company like Astroscale or deorbit where you've already paid to have this satellite removed.

when it either breaks down or reaches the end of its economic life. Or the third option is to have an insurance policy. And that insurance policy would then have a contract with a company like Starfish or Astroscale to remove the satellite when it reaches the end of its economic life. But it might be a cheaper way of doing that. So the obligation of needing to do that is then pushed on the operator. then, effectively, they then have to account for that.

They have to provide the budget for it as part of their strategy. And the whole thing is done in a sustainable way. So this is really how regulation is really helping making all of the players be sort of good actors in the space environment. And then there are companies like Leo Labs, which is another one of our portfolio companies that uses ground-based radars that look up into space. And they can see an object the size of a penny.

from a thousand kilometres away. And that penny is going around our planet at 17,500 miles an hour. And what they're able to do is identify all of that debris so that you can then use that data in real time for satellite operators to avoid the collision with debris. It's used by the regulators to make sure that the satellite operators are removing their satellites.

as they're supposed to under the regulatory requirements. So in this year, we've seen the first year ever where a regulator fined a space company for not removing its satellite when it said it was supposed to. So it gives the regulators teeth. It also gives information and data to the insurance companies so that they can better work out the risks around collision and...

and the risks within the space environment.

Mark Fielding Was the fine more than it would have cost to get the satellite out of the sky? Well, is it substantial fines? Do you know?

it wasn't. No, not in today's dollars. like any new industry, the cost of you know, the first movers is very high. And then, once that becomes routine, it really comes right down. So no, no, it wasn't.

How the investment strategy changed

Mark Fielding Okay, thank you. I think you've constructed a very good picture of what the investment of the space industry looks like. If we move the conversation on a little bit, geopolitically the world is in a, at best, a state of transition, let's call it. How much of investment is defence based? is it already the dominant investment? Do you see a way of having a more humane, less defence orientated?

investment strategy happening? what's the geopolitical situation versus investing in space looking like?

Mark Boggett it's changed very significantly this year. This year, this year. you know, that space investment, it's safe to say is now dominated by defense. but this isn't necessarily a bad Defense has got significant budget.

Mark Boggett that it wants to deploy in building capability in the space environment, arguably to make our world a safer place. And what that defence dollars are doing is that they're accelerating the technology roadmap of these companies faster than they would have gone naturally. And they're growing the constellations in size to get them towards being big enough to provide a real-time data set faster.

than the otherwise would have done. Now the reason why that is good news and you know in my, so we've got currently two funds operational, one of them's a public fund listed on the London stock market. That fund, the revenues of that fund are nearly 80 % defence now and it was nothing like that you know three or four years ago. But what I've just described is that,

Defence driving the speed

Defence is really driving the speed of the build out of this digital infrastructure. But the real beneficiary of that is going to be the commercial markets. It's going to be the insurance, the real estate, the oil and gas. Because they are effectively going to be using this data in a myriad of different ways. And they're going to be able to access that data sooner at a lower cost.

than the otherwise would have done if it wasn't for the increasing defence spend. So right now, well, defence is sort of 70 or 80 % of the revenue. During the course of the next five years, it will go back to being more like 20 % with 80 % of this coming from commercial.

Jeremy Gilbertson I think there's a history too of things spinning out of, you know, defense funded stuff. mean, the internet is obviously the simplest example of things there. ⁓ GPS.

Mark Boggett you can list all of the technologies as well from the ballpoint pen, you know, through to Velcro and you know, yeah, I mean the list just goes on and on and on.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, Mark, you've done a tremendous service to the listeners in creating just a tangible explanation of really what's happening today that investors can generate returns on within 10 years. Because if you don't have that, you're not going to have progress. You're not going to get to the moonshots that we're all super excited about. I've got a couple of like more ethereal questions to kind of think about that are always on my mind.

So space is the exponentially more complex version of the wild west, should create the rules of the road for space for it to work for humanity.

The Cold War precedent

Mark Boggett So during the heights of the Cold War, the US and Russia were cooperating in space. During the course of this year, American astronauts have gone to the International Space Station on a Russian rocket with Russian satellites, with Russian astronauts. So space diplomacy is something that has sort of risen above earth-based geopolitics.

And I believe that that is going to continue into the future. So I think that this is a really good message for your listeners to telecommunication, SAPCOM industry is governed by something called ITU, where effectively when it was originally created, all of the countries got their spectrum directly above their country.

as their spectrum and it was very fairly organised and to this day, know, it continues with everybody largely agreeing and operating to this set of rules where they are not putting up satellites that interfere with the spectrum of their neighbours so that they are sort of causing problems with their neighbours. So again, that's another great example of a commercial activity.

that's continued to work and I believe that that sets some standards for what's going to happen as we go into the future. Another area that pretty much everyone's agreed on is around debris management and space traffic control and all of these things because everyone recognises if you get that wrong, we're all going to suffer from it. So I think that there are some really, it's still hard to do all of these things.

and we could talk about this subject for the rest of the day. But I'm really positive about the history of where we're coming from. And despite the horrible world that we live in at the moment, the very fact that astronauts are going to the International Space Station together, living together, and there's this level of cooperation going on, I think that that stands us in good stead for the future.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, I think the simplicity of the maybe three astronauts working with three other astronauts brings everyone back to, Hey, we're all made of this same stuff. We're all humans. Like this is a bigger picture.

One word questions

Mark Fielding I ask you a couple of one word questions first, and then we'll get into our follow-over questions. yes or no, should we be having any conversations about terraforming Mars?

Mark Fielding Who's your favourite science fiction writer?

Mark Fielding Best science fiction movie out there that best captures the essence of space exploration.

Mark Fielding Do kids today still look up with the same awe and wonder that you did and we did?

Mark Boggett more than ever. You know, it's more accessible. They watch SpaceX launches. Space has become more accessible to everybody and children are so excited about it. was supposed to be a yes or no. Apologies.

Mark Fielding That's brilliant. That's exactly what I wanted to hear. We had a guest on Sanjay Vijendran He was the lead of Solaris for the European Space Agency. He left a question which we've been keeping for the right person. And I think that right person is you. His question was, what's the best reason to go to the moon?

The best reason to go to the moon

Mark Boggett the best reason to go to the moon is to enable us to use it as a stepping stone for going somewhere else. So you've got to, on the create a habitat and an environment that we can live in, create all of the features that are required for us to successfully live off planet. So we can effectively use the moon.

as a training ground to get it all right much closer to home. And then when we've got that working, then it's time to move on to somewhere else.

Jeremy Gilbertson So there's been a lot of debate whether the moon has the resources, the assets that we need to build the things we need to on the moon to make it a stepping stone. Do you believe that the moon has resources, the things that we need to build and make it successful up there?

Mark Boggett Yeah, I do. Provided that we're not expecting too much from it. It would be horrible to see the moon with huge chunks taken out of it. But no, I believe that it has. But it's also just, it changes the game for being able to launch because of the lack of gravity. You don't require the same amount of thrust. So moving elsewhere from the moon...

I think is of a different order. And we've got to find ways of being able to produce all of the material and all of the equipment that we need in space by using materials that we can lay our hands on. So the moon is going to sort of help us work out how to use regolith, which is soil on the moon, how we can sort of put that into a 3D printer and out of the other end pops know, or any other type of material that we might need. So this is why it's a training ground. I think it should be treated as a training ground. I'd hate to see the moon effectively being terraformed and really, really, know, looking like Earth. I don't think that's the name of the game. I think it's a training ground for us to do something, go somewhere a little bit further.

Jeremy Gilbertson a lab, a sandbox, I love that idea.

The Kevin Kelly question

Mark Fielding the final question from the famous Kevin Kelly, he left a question that we now ask all our guests at the end of the show. What should humans be and how does technology help us get there?

Mark Boggett humans should be a steward of the earth.

And from a space perspective, this is about effectively using space to help us be a good steward of the Earth by safeguarding Earth's ecosystems. It's biodiversity. It's climate. So using technology to help us repair and regenerate the stuff that we've harmed. So things like carbon capture.

environmental monitoring from space. You these type of things I think are going to help us, you know, address the big problems like deforestation, melting ice, wildfires, you know, the heating of the ocean, all of these things I believe we are going to be able to be better stewards of by using the technology that develops from space. But that's only part one of my answer. I've got three parts. The second part is about using their stewardship beyond Earth into space. So we've already talked about it in our discussion earlier. It's about preventing the pollution in space. we've made a terrible job of our own planet, particularly, you know, the oceans. You know, we've just treated them like a dumping ground, and we can't do that in space.

particularly the small part of space that surrounds our earth, which is very, very fragile and precious. We could actually fill that with so much junk that we can't actually get off the planet anymore. So it's about us being a steward for next generations who might need to escape the planet. And we need to make sure that we are preserving that. And then this third one is a little bit more contentious, but I believe in it.

which is about being a steward of the earth around defense and using technology for security and restraint, rather than it being about domination and control. I think we can use the technology from space and the monitoring to ensure that we've got equity and justice and we've got a record of what's going on.

We've got a record of who the bad actors are and we can use that to hold them to account. you I really believe that space is a force for good and it enables us as stewards of the earth to do good things. think technology is going to be a real enabler there.

Jeremy Gilbertson Wonderful, wonderful, very thoughtful answer that I will continue to unpack as it settles into my brain. That's great. What about a question for our next guest on any topic you desire?

Mark Boggett Yeah. So this thing always puzzles me and I'd like to work out how to sort of put it into a question. But one of the things around technology that never ceases to amaze me was that we had Concord. We could fly from New York to London in a couple of hours and everybody did regularly. And then we pulled them.

the technology out of everyday use. And 20 or 30 years later, we still haven't replaced it. So my question is, are there any other examples of technologies where we have actually developed a technology that's been practically used, where we've then actually gone backwards and gone back to the situation before?

Jeremy Gilbertson We could turn that into a little thinking on paper study. That could be fun.

Mark Fielding Yeah, it's a brilliant question. Thank you. Thank you very much.

Mark Boggett Yeah, yeah. I want to be able to

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, excellent.

Mark Boggett get to New York in two hours is the reason for my