Why Did Space SPACs Crash? Space to Grow Book Club
Virgin Orbit, the satellite-launching cousin of Virgin Galactic, is the book's example of what redemptions can do to a SPAC. PS, Virgin Orbit, whose 2021 SPAC valued it at $3.7 billion, went bankrupt less than two years later.
In this episode · 18 chapters
- How a SPAC works
- The crypto parallel
- What happened to space stocks
- Virgin Orbit and redemptions
- Astra: public without a rocket in orbit
- Why this matters to serious founders
- The stag hunt
- What the space stags are
- Artemis, the new model
- What Artemis 1 to 5 are
- Why the South Pole
- What each launch costs
- Why NASA leaned on SLS
- Only one rocket is ready
- Betting on SpaceX and Blue Origin
- How do you reinvent an agency?
- The race, and who gets there first
- Will NASA exist in 25 years?
We need, I believe, infrastructure in space. We need these companies. We need these visionaries, these engineers, these crazy minds to go up there and build these incredible things.
Space to Grow follows the SPAC boom in space, and Mark sees crypto's 2021 in it. They explain how redemptions work, why forward-looking revenue projections pushed CEOs to forecast exponential growth, and how Astra was valued at $2.1 billion before any rocket reached orbit.
The second half turns to Artemis. They run through the missions, why the lunar South Pole matters, the quoted $4.2 billion cost of each SLS launch, NASA's lander deals with SpaceX and Blue Origin, the stag hunt, and whether NASA will exist in 25 years.
Space to Grow by Matthew Weinzierl and Brendan Rosseau, read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, explains why space SPACs crashed: special purpose acquisition companies took space startups such as Virgin Orbit and Astra public, and Virgin Orbit went bankrupt less than two years later. The episode also covers the stag hunt game and Artemis, NASA's new model for returning to the Moon.
What happened to Virgin Orbit and Astra after their SPACs?
Redemptions left Virgin Orbit with $68 million of the $228 million it expected. Valued at $3.7 billion by its 2021 SPAC, it went bankrupt less than two years later. Astra went public at a $2.1 billion valuation before any of its test rockets had reached orbit.
What is a SPAC and how does it take a company public?
A SPAC, or blank cheque company, raises money before it has picked a target, then merges with a private company to take it public while “bypassing the normal scrutiny an IPO receives.”
How did space startup stocks perform after their IPOs?
Jeremy cites SpaceWorks figures: $100 put into space startup stocks at IPO was worth about $10 by early 2024.
What does the stag hunt game say about big space projects?
The stag hunt game explains why big space projects are rare: they need coordination and trust, so companies keep hunting hares. The authors’ space stags include research and manufacturing in orbit, lunar development, in situ resource use, Mars exploration and space-based solar power.
How much is NASA paying for SLS launches and Artemis landers?
Each launch of NASA’s SLS rocket and Orion capsule is expected to cost $4.2 billion. For the landers, NASA is paying fixed sums: $4 billion to SpaceX for Artemis 3 and 4, and $3.4 billion to Blue Origin for Artemis 5.
Where Mark and Jeremy disagree
Mark compares the SPAC cycle to the crypto boom and says it makes him angry for the serious engineers in the sector. Jeremy asks whether NASA could become the coordinator that lets the industry hunt stags.
Links from this episode
Questions
Why did space SPACs crash?
Redemptions left Virgin Orbit with $68 million of the $228 million it expected. Valued at $3.7 billion by its 2021 SPAC, it went bankrupt less than two years later.
What is the book Space to Grow about?
Space to Grow by Matthew Weinzierl and Brendan Rosseau, read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, explains why space SPACs crashed: special purpose acquisition companies took space startups such as Virgin Orbit and Astra public, and Virgin Orbit went bankrupt less than two years later. The episode also covers the stag hunt game and Artemis, NASA's new model for returning to the Moon.
How does Mark compare the space SPAC boom to crypto?
Space to Grow follows the SPAC boom in space, and Mark sees crypto's 2021 in it.
What does the episode cover about NASA's Artemis programme?
The second half turns to Artemis. They run through the missions, why the lunar South Pole matters, the quoted $4.2 billion cost of each SLS launch, NASA's lander deals with SpaceX and Blue Origin, the stag hunt, and whether NASA will exist in 25 years.
Transcript
Jeremy Gilbertson so, all right, enter the SPAC special purpose acquisition company, according to Jeff Faust, veteran journalists question, can you still spell space without SPAC? So let's talk about what a SPAC is and what it did to space investment in that short term. And then over the long run, what's a SPAC mark?
Mark Fielding a SPAC. It's well, it's the hottest thing in finance is according to the Wall Street Journal. It's called a SPAC and increasingly it is the favorite source of financing for private companies looking to go public. Their purpose is to find a private company, buy it and take it public quickly. Some on Wall Street call them blank check companies because investors backing the SPAC put up their money months before an acquisition target is identified, trusting the people running the show to find a good deal.
These deals are generating a lot of interest because they produce big paydays for their creators, make it easier for startups in hot industries, such as electric vehicles, to capitalize on frothy run up in the stock market and offer everyday investors a new path to a hot stock. When a SPAC buys a firm, it merges with it in a sort of accelerated IPO process, a so-called reverse merger, while bypassing the normal scrutiny an IPO receives.
How a SPAC works
Jeremy Gilbertson Oh my gosh. So a couple of interesting things to point out. So the SPAC, the SPAC actually has between 18 to 24 months to identify a get a pile of money together. You get people agreeing to believe in your bet, So you're running the SPAC mark. put...
You put it out to a lot of people, they believe in you because you can find a good deal on a company. You can find a diamond in a rough, something that's missing scale, maybe two pieces, maybe two or three companies that would fit together in a beautiful Lego block to create something altogether amazing. Here's the interesting thing though. SPACs have something called Redemptions, allows people who invest in SPAC to decide after you put your Lego blocks together, ⁓ I don't really like this, Mark. I'm going to take my money and bolt. So you can actually get redemption. So here's what happens. You get this influx of money coming in, you get these targets identified. And a year or so later, they don't even have a product. They barely have like some research and a concept. And a lot of the people are going, man, what's going on here? What's happening? What's happening with this company? Yeah, I think I think I want my think I want my bread back.
The crypto parallel
Mark Fielding Do you know what this reminded me of? So for the listener, the SPAC starts in 2019, lasts a couple of years, maybe till 2023, it fizzles And because SPACs, at least the space focused ones in this period, seem to determine the value of a company largely based on forward looking revenue projections, startup CEOs were incentivised to forecast exponential growth, even though that meant setting their firms up for painful and public blowback if they underperform but it doesn't matter if all the investors get out and you are left holding the can. What does this remind you of?
and I'll give you a clue. Crypto baby, yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson ⁓ Web3, like just crypto Web3. There was some SPAC
Mark Fielding it's 2021 NFT. Summer. there's so much correlation and all of the big investment firms come in, the big investors come in. And I don't know if it was as bad as in crypto where the little, where the retail investor is left holding the can, it's basically gone to zero. And a lot of these space companies followed the crypto.
Mark Fielding trajectory and they went, they just crashed back into the ocean, didn't they?
What happened to space stocks
Jeremy Gilbertson let's share a couple of numbers here real quick. there's, Spaceworks. So Spaceworks tracks public startup stocks, public space startup stocks, calculated that $100 in space startup stocks purchased at IPO was worth about 10 bucks by early 2024.
Virgin Orbit and redemptions
Jeremy Gilbertson So big drop, a perfect example as illustrated in the book is Virgin Orbit. It's the satellite launching cousin of Virgin Galactic. So this is where Redemption's come in. So they only received 68 million of the $228 million they expected. When they put out ⁓ for the money, you have to subtract all the Redemptions. So instead of getting $228, which they expected to do whatever they wanted to do with, they only got
$68 million. So that's a really interesting example of what these redemptions can do. And then also think about like a typical IPO according to space capitalist, Chad Anderson is a general rule of thumb. takes about six to eight years for a company to go from initial seed funding to IPO. Assuming in that, in that course, they actually develop a product.
They have product market fit. They have revenue. They're scaling revenue. Some of these were pre-product, like even beyond.
Mark Fielding Astra, let's talk about Astra, shall we? I mean, just going back to your point on the Virgin, I mean, if Virgin's space spin-offs can't make it, then a lot of people are in for a tough ride if they can't make it. But so we spoke about Planet last on public markets. Planet was valued at 2.8 billion.
Astra: public without a rocket in orbit
Mark Fielding On the other end of the spectrum was Astra, a company hoping to mass produce small rockets. Now get this Astra went public despite the fact that none of its test rockets, much less ones with satellites from paying customers. repeat, none of its rockets had successfully made it to orbit. Astra was valued at $2.1 billion. Now, if that doesn't get you a little bit angry.
and doesn't remind you of crypto, then ⁓ maybe work for a VC fund.
Jeremy Gilbertson that's a very interesting parallel that you're tying together with some of these SPAC deals in space tech and crypto because I think it's pretty appropriate. ⁓ The idea that, yeah, the rockets never work. Hey guys, guess what? We're...
have one in, but it's a rocket company with no rockets valued at $2 billion.
Jeremy Gilbertson Guys, we're launching Thinking on Paper Launch Services. ⁓ We're be able to put stuff up into lower Earth orbit. If you need a ride, let us know, but we need about $200 million. Everything's in the works. know, that's the medicine show, Mark. It's the medicine show.
Why this matters to serious founders
Mark Fielding and it makes me angry personally, because as we've learned at Thinking on Paper, there are some incredible people, incredibly smart people doing some fantastic things. We need, I believe, infrastructure in space. We need these companies. We need these visionaries, these engineers, these crazy minds to go up there and build these incredible things. What we don't need is chances and nefarious investment machines taking advantage of essentially humanity's challenges. That's what we don't need. So that makes me angry. But what is to come?
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, I think it's an unfortunate piece of code in human nature that it would be great to have written a little differently and just the idea of being opportunistic and taking advantage of something at a certain point in time just to make a pile of money. I that always will be out there, unfortunately. Let's transition.
Mark Fielding New listeners, thinking on paper, we do always tie these technologies back to what it means to be human. And it's not always pretty. We're not to celebrate all of the investment opportunities We're here to work out what connects these companies to you and me and what happens on a regular basis. PS, Virgin Orbit, whose 2021 SPAC valued it at $3.7 billion, went bankrupt less than two years later.
Jeremy Gilbertson $3.7 billion to zero.
Jeremy Gilbertson dude thinking on paper could do so much more with like a hundred and fifty K. Let's prove it in the study. We'll do more in two years
Mark Fielding I love Claude Rousseau, the French I think it is Claude Rousseau who said, we see too many Econ 101 principles discounted and with only lip service paid to solid market analysis, as if making the technology work guarantees big bucks, but a great technology does not a market make.
The stag hunt
Jeremy Gilbertson Blockchain getting hammered again. Let's finish this chapter on the stag hunt game.
Jeremy Gilbertson Big things require two things, coordination and trust. Okay, Mark and I have to be able to coordinate and collaborate and I have to trust Mark, he has to trust me. That's a big gamble, I think, and that's why we're not seeing so many people in the space tech industry pair up to go hunt stags. They're still hunting hares. What do you think?
Mark Fielding the easy way versus the hard way, my way or the highway. So we can all make small little satellites that orbit the earth and take nice photos and take nice video and give us some nice data about the weather forecast in Mongolia. And we'll all make a little bit of money. We can all do that. Or we can group together and build Gerald O'Neill.
orbitals up there, or we can really around Jupiter out into the Kuiper Belt and build stuff out there. Like these grandiose visions. But to do that, we've got to stop building these little tiny satellites, taking pictures and selling data and focus on something huge and big and immense, a stag. either we all do that or none of us do it.
Jeremy Gilbertson We're not ready for it. Like we're not ready for it. You're in investors in your cookie factory. Don't give eight shits what my investors in my cookie factory want. And that's the breakdown and it requires a coordination. requires, we talked about this with the CEO of Iona this week about drones. talked about, this is another Paki McCormack, most human wins reference, moving up one level of abstraction. And that requires humanity to move up a level of abstraction in order to hunt stags.
What the space stags are
Mark Fielding I like it. last question before we move on to NASA and what would be an incredible stag in space? I said, slinging around Jupiter and building hotels out in the Kuiper Belt. Not very realistic. Our authors, Matthew Weinzierl and Brendan Rosseau who?
We hope we'll be thinking on paper with us one day, not too soon. And we'll ask them this very question to see if they have changed their minds since they wrote this.
beyond the expanded use of data from and through space, our space stags include research and manufacturing in Earth's orbit, lunar development, in situ resource utilization, Mars exploration, and space-based solar power. Any that you would add to that, Jeremy?
Would you add data centers in space? I wonder if they would add data centers in space now. I think they probably would.
Jeremy Gilbertson I think the solar power slash data centers in space, space-based solar power data centers in space are kind of the same tech, different outcomes, I think. So I think you could maybe bet on both at the same time. All right, Artemis.
Artemis, the new model
Mark Fielding Artemis, the new model goes to the moon. We're going back to NASA. They like to spend some money at NASA, don't they?
Jeremy Gilbertson The new model, did you say? Yeah. Well, this is
Mark Fielding Well, that's what it says here chapter 7 Artemis the new model
Jeremy Gilbertson some of the questions that before we get into this, Mark, that I thought were really interesting, you know, what this is a question written by the authors, what is NASA's place as the space economy continues to emerge, right? They're this agency in transition, and they've evolved when they've needed to. And it's interesting, we talk about coordination, we talk about trust, we talk about the stag hare game, the stag hunt game, requiring someone or something in the middle to coordinate and trust and all of that, could NASA be that thing as it evolves?
Mark Fielding what place does NASA play? Historically, they play a very, very important role. Going into the future, a lot probably hinges on what Artemis 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 achieve and what SpaceX and
Blue Origin achieve in a very shorter probably timeline and at what cost.
What Artemis 1 to 5 are
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, let's talk about let's talk about what Artemis is right. So Artemis one twenty twenty two uncrewed mission around the moon came back successful. Artemis two in a few weeks is going to largely repeat a similar thing, except it's going to be a crewed mission. Ten days looping around and coming back Artemis three.
Why the South Pole
Jeremy Gilbertson 2026 ish, think, will involve a South Pole landing. Why the South Pole mark? The South Pole has enough frozen water equivalent to 100,000 Olympic swimming pools. What can you do with water? You can live, but you can also make rocket fuel. Way station of the future, right? A lot of cool things going on there.
Mark Fielding also some helium 3, isn't there, down there and some other resources and minerals, not just the water. I'm sure the water gets the investment or gets the newspapers happy.
Jeremy Gilbertson 100%. And I'll just run down these others and we can dive back into it. So then Artemis 4 and is this gateway way station. So a lot of people, some people are calling it just another ISS in lunar orbit. And then Artemis 6 is the ability to dock with that way station and then carry people down to the lunar.
What each launch costs
Mark Fielding go on then. much is it all cost so far, Jeremy? What are the projections for NASA and the Artemis so far?
Jeremy Gilbertson ⁓ Each, quote, each launch of the rocket and its space capsule, Orion is expected to cost $4.2 billion.
$4.2 billion. So NASA, or let's see, by the time the SLS launched, that's another creative name, Space Launch System. Guys, we can help you with some better names.
Mark Fielding What's the SLS, Jeremy?
Jeremy Gilbertson mean the rocket that blasts up. The big rocket they're calling the Space Launch me, NASA was $4.2...
billion for each launch of the non reusable space launch system rocket. that Starship launches could cost as little as $10 million by the late 2020s, though it's important to note that these are estimates for SpaceX's internal costs and not the price it would charge to customers like NASA. But these cost estimates may be optimistic. Boasts, not like Elon to boast, but
Even if Starship costs are much higher, say $100 million per launch, that would still be 40 times cheaper on a per launch basis than what NASA is spending. Even if Starship launches cost 100 times that, what SpaceX says, around a billion per launch, that would still be one quarter the cost of an SLS Orion flight. I think we've seen with SpaceX that even if their 10 million by the late 20s is an oversell, it won't be
Mark Fielding that much of an oversell.
Why NASA leaned on SLS
Jeremy Gilbertson Totally agree. So one of the reasons I think they were leaning on this SLS model, I think there were old components from the space shuttle program that they were trying to reuse. going, hey, maybe we could dust these off. I don't mean to be trivial there. There's a lot of effort that goes into making pieces and parts put into a rocket.
And using stuff you have is always good to think about. But sometimes when you use stuff you have, ends up costing more than you think. So why the heck aren't we using Starship? Mark, why is SLS in place instead of Starship?
Only one rocket is ready
Mark Fielding Artemis is scheduled for launch. There is no Starship as NASA Administrator Bill Nelson quote,
There's only one rocket that's ready to launch at SLS and the Orion space capsule at its tip is also the only vehicle in which the crew can survive the return to Earth. At some point, Elon Musk would like to be able to do the same with his Starship, but we have a deal with the practical here and now.
Jeremy Gilbertson Look at you with your American bravado, man. So let me bounce that to a quote from another NASA associate administrator, Kathy Lueders towards the end of the chapter. Quote, NASA has a very hard time going from saying, I'm the one doing it, to we are doing it. I would argue, maybe it was in your delivery of that quote, but there's something, I think there's something to that. NASA was born out of this.
this we're getting to the damn moon and we got to the damn moon and there's this you have to have a little swagger about it but like this chapter points to some of the evolution of where that's headed and I think the really interesting thing the thread of that that I thought was really cool is instead of funding NASA completely funding this public good and making and delivering this public good and public good being, Hey, getting us to space, opening up opportunities for humanity, all of that stuff. Now it's more of a pivot to according to the authors anyway, which I thought was really interesting and pivot to enabling private companies, funding private companies to develop the actual tech and manufacturing and the service and all of that stuff. I think there's the evolution that they're talking about.
Mark Fielding We love NASA. We're not poo-pooing on anyone's parade and we're speaking about Artemis 1 and 2 really. It's not like NASA is ignoring the promise of Starship and other commercial launch vehicles for Artemis 3 and 4. Is it, Jeremy?
Betting on SpaceX and Blue Origin
Jeremy Gilbertson yep. So they're leaning on a couple of well-known players
Mark Fielding Can I guess, can I guess, can I guess? Is it SpaceX and Blue Origin?
Jeremy Gilbertson You're 100 % correct. 100 % correct. So, so they're, they're, it's, think, I think they're seeing what's happening, but there's another bet. There's another thing too about just, got to do it, right? We got to do it. And part of maybe NASA was thinking,
You know, we gotta get going. And this is a way to get going. I don't wanna continue to wait for this first step. Let's push this first step out. And then we can save in the long run by these, you know, these partnerships are in parallel to this first step, which is really cool. They're talking about the value of decentralization that they refer to on NASA's plans for lunar surface stuff. ⁓
How do you reinvent an agency?
Jeremy Gilbertson Imagine how difficult it is to reinvent an agency like NASA. Imagine like the amount of open-mindedness, the amount of objectivity, the amount of, I don't know, I think those two things to pivot something that large to do something different. I think it's really cool.
Mark Fielding Yeah. And a lot of people possibly having to check egos in at the door. And yes, we did this and that was just incredible. But now we have to do that. I just want to quote to ferry astronauts down to the lunar surface for Artemis three and four NASA ran a competition and opted to have SpaceX develop the lunar lander. When astronauts land on the moon for the first time in over half a century, it will be from a modified version of Starship.
For Artemis 5, NASA selected a lunar landing craft designed by Blue Origin. Under these agreements, the agency is paying a fixed sum for lunar landing services, $4 billion to SpaceX, $3.4 billion to Blue Origin. So it's a mixture of old and new. We've given NASA a bit of a hard time because they're spending ⁓ just incredible amounts of money. But there are, as you said, some foresight, a new model incorporating the private with the public. And yeah, they want to get to the moon. They want to start building. And so they've...
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, I think what's interesting too, there's a couple of nods in here of like what this Artemis mission is going to enable with other companies and thinking about just infrastructure on the moon. How do we build roads? How do we get power across it? How do we harvest the water and use the water to do what we need to do? So there's going to be an entire new economy that is infrastructure oriented, just in a new spot.
The race, and who gets there first
Mark Fielding There's one other reason that we haven't mentioned, which is perhaps why NASA are building their own rockets and focusing very much in-house for Artemis 1 and 2. And that might be that we're not the only ones trying to get to the moon, are we, Jeremy?
Jeremy Gilbertson It's a race, Mark, it's a race. We gotta beat them. We gotta beat them. Yeah, 100%. That's exactly what got us to the moon last the Russians beat the US. The US was like, man, we gotta chase them and we gotta make sure we get up there before anyone else. And it's a signal. It's a signal to the world, I think, in a lot of ways.
Mark Fielding Yeah, I think that might be the first person commercial activity on the moon. You get there, you start building, you're first in, you're first there. You have a lot stems from that.
Jeremy Gilbertson How do we want to wrap this one up?
Mark Fielding What's your astronaut called behind you, Jeremy? What did we name our astronaut? It's astronaut.
Jeremy Gilbertson Astronaut Alice.
Will NASA exist in 25 years?
Mark Fielding In 25 years when Alice and her peers are old enough, big enough and wise enough to be astronauts, do you think they will be?
flying on NASA space. Do you think NASA will still exist in 25 years? Do you think that the name will have become a monument to history or do you think they will be heavily involved in the space industry? Because one of the interesting things I learned in this chapter was that NASA isn't set in stone.
Jeremy Gilbertson That's correct. I think the agency has a tremendous opportunity to fill this gap of coordinator and trust enabler for the space economy. this quasi, you say independent, but it's a US organization with international affiliates or connections and that sort of thing.
if it evolves the right way, and the end of this is talking about how an old agency can evolve to enable the space economy, I think if it evolves the right way, I think it could fill that gap that is keeping people from hunting stags.
Stay tuned for more thinking on paper at XYZ. This is a book club. Book club turns reading into a team sport. I don't have to do it by myself. I get to bounce my ideas off Mark. Eventually, we're going to do this live with everybody who's reading the book with us. We're going to time it, and we're going to invite some key people to jump into these books. But until then, listen to the episodes. Drop some comments. We'd love to hear what you're thinking if you're reading this book too. And in the meantime, stay curious.
Jeremy Gilbertson Keep thinking on paper.




