The Economics of SpaceX, Blue Origin and the Space Industry
Brendan Rosseau, who wrote Space to Grow with Matt Weinzierl, says NASA took a leap of faith with the landers for Artemis, its flagship lunar programme. It chooses two commercial companies that have not built lunar landers before.
In this episode · 23 chapters
- How the book began
- Writing together
- Government or market
- Is space different from terrestrial economics?
- Space stations, and who pays
- What microgravity is good for
- Long horizons and short returns
- When public money gets burnt
- How NASA has changed
- Consistency, security and economics
- A global moment, and how fast it fades
- Taking our mistakes into space
- Why space accomplishments echo
- What space does for people every day
- GPS and the invisible backbone
- Why not spend the money on Earth?
- Space based data centers
- Cooling, and big radiators
- A forest full of stags
- The authors' favourite lines
- If you had to write the rules
- Who is in the room
- The Martens Clause
The way that I think about what space does for us today is that it is this invisible backbone that upholds the 21st century way of life.
Matt Weinzierl and Brendan Rosseau, authors of Space to Grow, join the book club they have been listening to. Weinzierl, an economist, thinks the laws of economics are universal, and that space policy should play to the strengths of both government and the market.
Rosseau, who works at Blue Origin, explains why microgravity research is still an open question and how GPS became an invisible backbone of daily life. We also cover big radiators for space data centres, the stag hunt, and who should write the rules.
Matthew Weinzierl and Brendan Rosseau, authors of Space to Grow, tell the Thinking On Paper podcast how government and markets should share the work of building a space economy, from SpaceX's partnership with NASA to microgravity, data centres in orbit and who should write the rules. Rosseau, who works at Blue Origin, thinks data centres in space are a 2030s idea at best.
How did the book Space to Grow begin?
The book began when Rosseau, as an undergraduate, emailed Weinzierl about his senior thesis. Years later he joined Weinzierl at Harvard Business School as a research associate, and they built a course together.
Does Matt Weinzierl think economics works the same in space?
Weinzierl: “I tend to think that the laws of economics are universal.” The question for space is less how much government there should be than how to play to the strengths of both government and the market.
Is there a business case for commercial space stations yet?
Rosseau says microgravity creates “physical conditions that we really cannot replicate here on Earth”, but a dedicated Falcon 9 launch still costs $75 million, and recent comments from NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman suggest the business case for stations is not there yet.
How does space policy survive election cycles?
How space policy survives election cycles: Weinzierl points to bipartisanship, national security, and his view that economics wins out over politics. Rosseau notes that Artemis and the Space Force both survived the change from the Trump to the Biden administration.
When could data centres in space happen, according to Rosseau?
Rosseau, who works on Blue Origin’s New Glenn rocket, thinks data centres in space are a 2030s idea at best. The problem is heat, and the current answer is very large radiators. Weinzierl calls it a stag the market found for itself.
Where Weinzierl and Rosseau disagree
Asked to write the rules for space, Weinzierl is sceptical of any room of experts settling them centrally and prefers emergent order. Rosseau warns that a grand top-down treaty could put a damper on activity, though he wants clear rules of the road like the laws of the sea.
Links from this episode
Questions
Who wrote Space to Grow?
Matt Weinzierl and Brendan Rosseau, authors of Space to Grow, join the book club they have been listening to.
What is Space to Grow about?
Matthew Weinzierl and Brendan Rosseau, authors of Space to Grow, tell the Thinking On Paper podcast how government and markets should share the work of building a space economy, from SpaceX's partnership with NASA to microgravity, data centres in orbit and who should write the rules.
Where does Brendan Rosseau work?
Rosseau, who works at Blue Origin, explains why microgravity research is still an open question and how GPS became an invisible backbone of daily life.
Transcript
Mark Fielding disruptors and curious minds. Welcome to Thinking on Paper, a very, very, very special book club episode. We've been reading Space to Grow for the last about two months, breaking down it chapter by chapter. And today we're very, very, very excited to say we have the authors of this book on Thinking on Paper. Matthew Vines-Earl and Brendan Rosu are here. Welcome to Thinking on Paper, Matthew and Brendan.
on Jerry. Thank you. Thank you for thinking on paper with us. Thank you for writing the book.
Matt Weinzierl Thank you guys for all you have done to talk about our book. It's been so awesome to listen to these episodes and be just along for the ride. We're so flattered by all the time and thought you put into it. And we're thrilled to be here today.
Mark Fielding It's important our future or maybe my kids, kids, kids, kids, kids future is up there somewhere. So it's important that their grandparents learn as much as they can about where we're going and how, how we might make some money up there. Cause this is really a book about unlocking the economic frontier of space.
Brendan Rosseau Yeah, real quick, you're absolutely right. That's one of the things I think that both of us love about ⁓ space and especially space today is that not only is there that really long term horizon that we know that this is going to be important for a long time. It feels almost inevitable. And that's part of what's so exciting is that there's this very exciting future that we can't quite discern yet somewhere out there. But also it's super important today. mean, it's in the headlines increasingly every day. It's fundamental to a lot of the the part of the next for the world so it's it's got a little bit of everything if you like history or economics or science or sci-fi or you know anything else spaces the place for you
How the book began
Jeremy Gilbertson Nice, nice. Well, let's, let's get started real quick. Just, I want to, I want to root the episode today and just a, just a brief history. Don't want to go too deep into it, but I definitely want to understand how you guys came together and decided let's write a book. Cause Mark and I have been doing this thing for a while. We've been, you know, this tag team for the last three years. We have various different projects we want to pull off, but you know, writing a book together is kind of a big initiative. So walk us through like how that started real quick and what gave you the drive to say, Hey, I want to do this.
Matt Weinzierl That's a really nice story. Brendan wrote to me when he was in undergrad, working on his senior thesis in college, because when you Google space economics, there aren't that many names that come up. And so I think I came up at the top of the results. And so he sent me email and I read his thesis and we talked a little bit and it was awesome. And then, you know, he went on with his life, got a job after college. And then a few years later, I was...
hiring a research associate to help me with the research on space that I was doing for case studies and eventually potentially to build a course. He saw the listing, got back in touch. We got reconnected and he joined me here at HBS and we then worked together for the next three years really co-building this course and writing a lot of materials and just being thought partners for trying to understand what was going on here. We both share an interest in economics and space. So we were natural partners there. ⁓
And then as we were teaching this course, at some point we thought, you know, actually, I think we have material here that would be, we could take it to a broader audience, right? We could spread this message and the learnings that we've gotten ⁓ beyond the 90 people we can fit into an HBS classroom. And so it was my great privilege and pleasure to get him to join up and write the book together. That's the story.
Writing together
Mark Fielding I've self-published a book and me and Jeremy have toyed with the idea of writing a thinking on paper book and we kind of fell out just in the idea phase. So how did you two over three years
Traverse those creative, inevitable creative blocks or barriers or disagreements between you. I know that's nothing to with space. It's more of a writing and a creative process, but still, question remains.
Brendan Rosseau It's a very important question. ⁓ I give Matt a ton of credit on this one because the work that went into what became the book started way before I ever even got there. Matt had been really ⁓ digging in and thinking critically about... ⁓ how to apply his economic toolkit and training and background that he's really one of the best in the world at to this domain that is space, which he just happened to be interested in going back to Star Trek days ⁓ when he was a kid. So Matt had been working on this for, by the time the book came out, maybe a decade. I had been thinking about it, but as Matt mentioned, in kind of like an undergrad capacity, more interested than... ⁓ than equipped. So Matt had been doing a lot of research and case studies and kind of doing a lot of the prep work that eventually became the class. I was lucky to be part of kind of the tail end of the prep work and shaping the last things of how do we tell the story of space through some really critical themes and through lines that we think are important, enduring, that really tell the story of what's going to happen in space, specifically through the lens of, you know.
economics, classical economics. ⁓ And ⁓ that gave us a lot of background material by the time we thought, you know what, this might be good to put into a book. We got a lot of great feedback. We bring a lot of guests in the class who are experts in space but through different lenses. Some are policy experts, some ⁓ are experts on the national security side. And a lot of them, when they came to the class, they said, you know what, I've never really thought about ⁓ space topics this way, but it really resonated with them. And I think after a dozen or so of those comments, Matt and I looked at each other and said, you know what, if this is useful for students and for even experts in the field, maybe this is useful for someone else. So it was a lot of just kind of what goes in the book and what doesn't. And thankfully, I think Matt and I have really complementary skill sets. ⁓ which made it really natural. mean, I won't speak for Matt, ⁓ it did not feel like the typical pulling my hair out, ⁓ know, frustration, everything. was really, really a joy from start to finish. ⁓ And I felt lucky to be part of it.
Matt Weinzierl Yeah, Brennan is being too not too modest, of course. I mean, I think the it was a great working relationship and friendship more generally. And I guess I would just pile on a little bit to the specialization. mean, I'm not a rocket scientist. I can't talk about the technical aspects of space in that sense and try to be super well aware of that from the beginning. Right. So just like we learned from every guest who comes into class and every student who has experienced in this sector.
I learned so much from Brendan. He has so much more experience on the national security side of space. He's actually been in the industry in ways that I have not. So it was just, you know, very much like we're throwing stuff into the pot. And in the end, the whole was created in the sum of the parts.
Jeremy Gilbertson It definitely worked. Yeah. So, so let's dive in. you, the book tackles a very complicated topic or a bunch of complicated topics that kind of are interwoven. And we talk about a theme that comes up a lot on thinking on paper is this beautiful tension between emergent things and hierarchical things, right? And, economies are just that, right? There are these, there's these interactions. There's the note, the centralization of all of these nodes coming together and this little thing pushes this thing and all these things happen. So
Government or market
Jeremy Gilbertson What's unique about space is the fact that we're getting a relatively fresh start when you think about it, like relatively clean slate. What is the appropriate amount of top down and then what is the appropriate amount of space? Bottom up.
Matt Weinzierl Yeah, that's such a great question. And can I just say, first of all, I love the fact that you guys go into this emergent nature of how we organize society. mean, as an economist, you're like speaking my language, man. This is beautiful. So I love that starting place. I was thinking, you know, obviously we thought about a lot this a lot really in the book, because the book is, as you guys have covered, a lot about the relationship between the government and markets and how it's evolving. in some, I one way I've always thought about it.
Matt Weinzierl since we started working on this is that we started off kind of at one end of the spectrum, right? Where it was like almost all government basically and then that's probably pretty natural when you're carving out the next big frontier or charting the next big frontier and the pendulum has started to swing toward a more balanced approach and it's it's possible I guess we might swing too far in some sense in the other direction and have to correct a little bit back. We'll see how it all plays out. But I think in the end the way I ended up thinking about it was that it's less about of the amount of government in some sort of, you know, or government intervention in some absolute number and more about playing to the strengths of the government and the market a little bit like we just talked about the book actually funny enough, right? We've learned that there are ways in which or parts in which you want a lot of government and then parts in which you want very little and that's really a sign of maturing of the second.
Brendan Rosseau Yeah, and something that I think is important is that it's going to evolve over time, especially with ⁓ so many of the critical areas in space need a lot of upfront capital and development and burning down technological risk. If you look at, for example, the launch revolution that really started with SpaceX in the early 20 teens, ⁓ it took so much ⁓ government support and intervention and everything. It was really kind of a beautiful partnership between SpaceX and NASA and the rest of... ⁓ the folks in that ecosystem to make that happen. So a lot of kind of push to get you started, but then after a while ⁓ you want to find that balance where you're.
not having too much intervention, you're allowing experimentation where appropriate, you're allowing people to innovate and in some cases to fail if that's kind of the natural ⁓ way of things. So I think if you look at different slices of, call it the space industry or space economy, it's a very mixed picture where in some areas I think Matt and I would say, my God, yes, this is still very much centrally. ⁓
Brendan Rosseau We need central command. need a focused push from the government. think the Artemis program and the related activities on the moon are a great example of that. We're all really supportive of those efforts to kind of kickstart efforts beyond low Earth orbit. But then in other areas, we say, like, let's take the reins off a little bit and see if we can have the private sector take on some of that risk taking.
Mark Fielding So you've reminded me connecting the dots and thinking on paper of a quantum computing episode we did recently about this hybrid supercomputing and the software and the algorithms you need to decide which part of a computational research is done by the QPU, the quantum computer, and which is done by the AI supercomputer. And they're trying to work that out because it's not easy to decide who does what. So what are some other examples of what might be?
Mark Fielding some of these space.
infrastructure products or companies where you really do have to take off the government break.
Matt Weinzierl Aha, well you really do have to. I mean, it's a great question. I'll just say, sorry, before we get into the space part of it, this is like such a, this is in some ways the central debate of economics. I was just teaching my other course at HBS yesterday. We were talking about measures of GDP versus other measures of economic performance and they're deeply intertwined with like, what is the role of government? What do you want the government to be doing? What's the responsibility you want to put on it? So anyways, this is such a great big question. Not really, I mean,
Is space different from terrestrial economics?
But is space any different to terrestrial economics
Matt Weinzierl Yeah, so I, it's a really, I love it. mean, I, of course, you know, I'm an economist. I tend to think that the laws of economics are universal. So it's, there's nothing in there that requires gravity, so to speak. That's not to say we can't try different things in space. Like, and maybe we can talk more about that. That's certainly one of the reasons I think I'm very excited about it is because we're going to get a chance to try new arrangements. But the fundamental forces and trade-offs I think will be very much the same.
in spaces on Earth. On your question on getting back to specific space domains, mean, stations I think are a great topic to lean into this, right? Because we all, I think most of us have a lot of hopes for stations. There was this push towards commercial stations which seems to have hit some obstacles. And so, is this the kind of place I think I would tend to think where some of that early push that Brendan was mentioning, where the public sector kind of...
gets the ball rolling downhill, and then you can eventually take the gloves or take the reins off. That seems like a good example to me.
Space stations, and who pays
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, the space space station thing is pretty, pretty interesting you and you you guys ran us through a nice history of that just to I mean, a lot of this stuff was tried and done like some some efforts were 20 years long and they didn't kind of come together and it's all about like, a can we do this from a scientific perspective but be is there value that can be created, captured and monetized because that's how we kind of move move forward with things.
10 that we did last week, then yeah, have Axiom, it was Axiom and Vast both building space stations and they were right at the top of the top 10 investments for the year. So the money is flowing into the space stations. So somebody must believe.
Jeremy Gilbertson Let's stay on the track a little bit. Related to space stations, then maybe we can kind of pop out a little bit. Let's dive down in this rabbit hole for a bit. ⁓ Microgravity has been a big topic in being able to use that for things like creation of drugs, fiber optic cables, all the stuff that you guys mentioned. How important is microgravity to the future of space stations? Proving that is useful or not?
What microgravity is good for
Brendan Rosseau So that is, think, the question. And as you highlight from the chapter, think Matt and I both, as we really look at this closely, depending on the day, some days we're super excited about it and other days we look at the history and say, you know, it's been decades that there's been this promise and still not as much to show for it as we'd like to for the investment. in fact, if...
Brendan Rosseau If the book was coming out today, one of the things that would include was recent comments from NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman who said, even just recently, it was kind of striking where he said, you know, it's not there. Like the business case isn't there. It doesn't really make sense. And to hear that from a very pro-business, commercially minded, let's take risks NASA Administrator is really striking. think it's kind of.
It shows how much work we still have left to do. To your question about ⁓ microgravity, I think ⁓ at its core, what is so exciting about it is that ⁓ it is ⁓ the absence of gravity creates physical conditions that we really cannot replicate here on Earth. That is something that is remarkable. It's just remarkable. I mean, how many things can you even think about? ⁓ in terms of natural labs for experiment and innovation where the laws of physics really kind of operate differently. They're not broken because obviously it's just, you know, different things happen, but ⁓ the way that heat gets transferred, the way that all these little things, way that, you know, the way that plants grow, it's just a fundamentally different environment. And myself and I think Matt as well ⁓ as optimists about...
human ingenuity and if you give ⁓ humans some the opportunity to experience something different then I think we're gonna find amazing things that they never thought of in the first place. It's the kind of the classic like, hey, you we started off with sticks and rocks and now we've got Bluetooth and Wi-Fi and spaceships going to the moon. Like, of course we'll find amazing remarkable things to do it. The challenge I think is that
Number one, getting to space in the first place is still very expensive. To get a dedicated launch on a Falcon 9 rocket is still $75 million. That's a high price tag.
Experiment and see how we can do this. So that's that makes it really hard and then also if you have ⁓ a Space station that is designed for humans on board which a lot of these commercial Leo destinations are that's a whole nother giant set of costs and also I really think it limits the amount of experimentation you're able to do there's really interesting stories of you know science that potentially people wanted to put on the International Space Station, but because it's you know, a giant tin can floating in orbit where people need to exercise to stay healthy and do all kinds of things you know it's it's kind of always shaking a little bit and there's always it's always rocking and rolling so it's
Mark Fielding Yeah, I'm a researcher in a lab. I don't want to go into space to do my job.
Matt Weinzierl Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Brendan Rosseau exactly. So ⁓ I think my conclusion would be it's an open question. It's one that I think in the fullness of time, it will look back and say, of course, this was valuable. Of course, this was immensely valuable. But I think the pathway that it will take to get there, think kind of low cost incremental experimentation where we chip away at this one step at a time is probably a path for success.
Long horizons and short returns
Mark Fielding the economic incentives work there Matthew? we're talking short time spans here on Earth for your ROI, you need to get your money back. But then we're talking about however many decades into the future where this is actually a realistic choice for many of the labs around the world. But how does the industry incentivize the duration of that gap?
Matt Weinzierl Mm-hmm. Yeah, it's a really big question. I mean, I you guys talked about the financing side of space. I tend to be, I'm an optimist by nature. Part of the reason Brendan and like working together on this, I suppose, because we both are. And I tend to be particularly optimistic actually about the financing side of this stuff in the sense that I think financial markets are very creative. Like if there's value to be found, a lot of smart people trying to figure out how to get that value funded so they can claim a piece of it.
And the long horizons thing, it's of course a big challenge in space. On the other hand, financial markets are pretty good at taking long horizons and cutting them into chunks where at each point you can evaluate progress and get your return and sell it to the next person down the line. So I kind of feel like we know how to do that. And then the real question is, is there actually value? So if the markets really believed there was, I think they would figure out ways to fund it. With the one caveat that it is nice to have a floor.
So if the government can provide a little bit of a guarantee that this is not just going to all go to zero, I think that can reassure financial markets in a big way. And that's why it's been such a big deal that the national security spending has gone up so much, why it's been so important to watch Administrator Isaac Minnan-Awi's thinking about commercial stations and other aspects of space, because I think the private capital markets do want to feel like there's some downside.
When public money gets burnt
Mark Fielding went to zero and what was that rocket company that went to, that was valued at two billion without any rocket? Like how does, how does that work?
Brendan Rosseau Unfortunately, you could be naming a couple at this point.
Mark Fielding The government's had its fingers burnt, is it going to get its fingers burnt again?
Matt Weinzierl Well, that's a really important, you know, it's always tricky when the government ⁓ invests in some sense, because there's a lot of scrutiny on government investment in a way that private capital markets, their investors understand that if you're in the VC space, you're going to fail a huge, like a huge share of your investments are not going to work out. And that's fine. That's the model. Government investment tends to be more risk averse because they think the political global act on those failures is really high. And historically that's been true. So I think helping broader public and certainly congresspeople understand that if NASA is going to be operating a little bit more as a venture, financier, there's going to be some failures along the way as an important part of progress.
How NASA has changed
Brendan Rosseau Yeah, I think it's important to note as we try to throughout the book that ⁓ NASA has come a really long way, not just NASA, but the entire US government in embracing this approach. ⁓ If you look at its flagship kind of cornerstone set of missions right now, it's the Artemis program. And ⁓ NASA is very protective of those kinds of flagship missions, especially with astronauts on board trying to do things that...
Brendan Rosseau have not been done in over half a century. And what does NASA do for its potentially the most critical component of that ⁓ program, its landers? It chooses two commercial companies that have not built lunar landers before. It is, in a sense, a leap of faith in the way that you would expect ⁓ an organization that is leaning into the promise of private markets to take. And sure, there's been hiccups along the way. There's been a lot of back and forth with SpaceX. then, you know, my...
I work at Blue Origin, so it's been interesting to that process on the inside as well. ⁓ But I think that's exactly what we want our government agencies to be doing is organizing the market in a way that only they can around these, pushing the envelope missions forward, helping companies develop technologies that they would never be able to pursue on their own. ⁓ burning down the risk and eventually I think these are the kinds of things that are really going to benefit all of us. So it's exciting.
Jeremy Gilbertson What a complicated map, what an orchestration of energy just around all of this stuff and knowing what to nudge and support, what to get out of the way and let the teenager be rebellious and ⁓ that sort of thing. So you mentioned the idea of the fundraising, the expectation and the timelines and how that has shifted from a fundraising perspective in a timeline approach. There's also the timeline.
Jeremy Gilbertson of election cycles and politics and man, we're trying to point and get our arms around some really big goals, some really moonshot pardon the pun endeavors. What do we need to do because there's a mismatch between these political cycles, these fundraising cycles. What's the secret to making it all work and is there a secret or are we just kind of having to learn as we go and adjust?
Matt Weinzierl secret to functional democracy, that's what you'd like us to address in the next 30 seconds. Yeah, that's a good question. ⁓ Okay, have three thoughts maybe. There's maybe more space specific, right? Because at least that's probably the point. Like how do we, how does space policy transcend election cycles, which is something we could maybe get a handle on. ⁓ One thought is space has been bipartisan for a very long time, and I think that's really important to try to preserve.
Jeremy Gilbertson Just, I'll give you 90. I'll give you 90 if you want to give it a rip, yeah.
Consistency, security and economics
Matt Weinzierl because that's part of the problem with political cycles is that they're driven by partisan shifts. And so if you can keep some consistency across time, and that's the responsibility of each generation, right, to not make it political or partisan in that sense. And I guess related to that is the second piece, which is the national security side of it. And this is always a little complicated because it's not like a free lunch to lean into the national security side of things to...
boost enthusiasm for space. are reasons you might be uncomfortable doing that. But it is also true that national security is probably the number one responsibility of a state. And so it can, I think, extend your horizons of thinking if you think that this is a national security priority. And so that's one way, I think, to get beyond a little bit of that. And then the last thing I'll just say briefly is we often talk at HBS about in the end, does economics trump politics or does politics trump economics? No pun intended with the president's name. ⁓
And as an economist, I tend to think that economics wins out. You can't defy the forces of economics in the long run. And if there is a lot of value out there in space, if we can really create a much bigger pie for everybody, that's a huge unifying force that I hope brings people together over time. So three thoughts.
Jeremy Gilbertson That's really interesting, just real quick, I wanted to nod on that a little bit. The politics or economics, so economics is the equation, politics is the interpretation and manipulation of the results of the equation. What do you think about that? Am I seeing that right?
Matt Weinzierl Yeah, that might, I've never heard that before. I like it. That's my, I have, I already have five quotes from you guys that I love. This will be my sixth. I think what I like about that, just a first blush, is that the equation is like, that's the truth, right? Like in some level, you can't deny the equation. You can play with the equation, you can manipulate it, but eventually there is the ground truth. economics has a bit of that element. Like you can't force people to pay really for something that doesn't have value in the long run. It's just not gonna happen.
Brendan Rosseau Yeah, no, was just, I was gonna add a footnote to what Matt was saying, which is there's, in terms of continuing the momentum for current projects from one administration to the next, there's the national security angle and there's also maybe the kind of softer edge of that, which is just national prestige. So something that we've seen over the past few administrations is ⁓ the Artemis program, our return to the moon and plans to stay on the moon, it was created during.
the Trump administration and it was notable that ⁓ when the Biden administration came in ⁓ almost everything else that the Trump administration had stood up for the first time was you kind of changed or scuttled, but two things that did endure were the Space Force stuck around and the Artemis program stuck around and largely in the same form. And part of the reason for that is because I think all the reasons that Matt listed, but also because we are in a competition or a race, whatever you want to call it, with China, which has very clear and very, you efficient lunar plants that they're exercising. nobody on either side of the aisle wants to be seen as responsible for slow rolling America's space program when there are geopolitical competitors out there that aren't. ⁓ And so I think to the extent that that can be a unifying factor that can keep us focused on the same goals and maybe not have us start looking side to side for distractions, I think that's a ⁓ healthy thing. And to the extent that it generates real ⁓ progress and real execution. think that builds momentum that can sustain itself. So I'm really encouraged by the direction that we've been going, and especially the reaction to Artemis 2 last week or two weeks ago. I don't know about you guys, but I was kind of blown away by how almost universal it seemed. I got notes from all kinds of friends who are not space people at all, saying that they had tears in their eyes at multiple times throughout the mission. So ⁓ it's a very, very good time, I think, to... ⁓
Brendan Rosseau be working on space stuff.
A global moment, and how fast it fades
Mark Fielding It was stunningly beautiful and all over, even in little old England, my kids, saw it. were talking about it at school. It really was a ⁓ global moment.
Mark Fielding But in this world of fleeting moments, my worry is that it's already ⁓ not tomorrow's fish paper to use a British, but it fades very quickly. You mentioned China, you mentioned transcending national borders. How do we transcend international borders and how do we fit China into that conversation? Let's continue on that because it's the
The story that a lot of people who aren't interested in space industry are aware of that.
Taking our mistakes into space
Matt Weinzierl Yeah, this is, ⁓ you guys have said in multiple episodes on the book, how do we not sort of bring our mistakes from Earth into space? And I think this is certainly related to that. Brendan, maybe I'll let you speak to this because you have, Brendan has often said this really lovely thing about how the U.S. Soviet rivalry worked out in space. And like in some ways, that's a model for how we might look towards the U.S. China one.
Brendan Rosseau Yeah, uh-oh, pressure's on now. ⁓
Brendan Rosseau I think that, I have two thoughts on this. The first is that I think that it's natural that as we go into further and further into the space domain, the same kinds of activities and behaviors that we have as humans towards one another individually, from one nation to another, whatever, we're gonna bring all that with us. ⁓
And I don't think that's necessarily ⁓ a bad thing. I think it is important that you have ⁓ some form of security or police force or military force in space the same way that we do here on Earth. I mean, it would be chaos if we said there should be no kind of national security devices here on Earth. That probably wouldn't work out well. We should do the same in space. ⁓ At the same time,
⁓ and we've all talked about this, I do think that going into a new domain where we don't have the scar tissue of ⁓ different interactions in the past and it really gives us the opportunity to do something new, I do think that it gives us the opportunity and the responsibility to behave in a way towards one another that...
that we want to chart the future that we want and that we can have and that maybe we only can have in space because it isn't fully contested and weighed down with the baggage ⁓ that a lot of our interactions here on Earth are. And I think that's a beautiful thing. There's something intrinsic about space that makes us want to have that kind of for all mankind. ⁓
⁓ attitude and I think we should really preserve that and to Matt's point ⁓ about the Cold War rivalry is that I think we've shown that even when here on earth we are you know very much pointing nuclear weapons at each other and calling each other our mortal enemies we can cooperate in space and that even when we're ready to pull the trigger down here on earth we're very hesitant to do any kind of combative things in space and I think that's something that we should cherish ⁓ at least it gives us a symbol that
Why space accomplishments echo
Jeremy Gilbertson I think there's a really cool power that space accomplishments echo throughout society. And it did this in the Apollo missions and just a sense of awe and sense of wonder that we're missing in the world when we get into this me versus you, it's a race. I'm running here, you're running there. I got to beat you. I'm going to step on your head to get there. The moments that I found so compelling with the Artemis mission is when these astronauts
Jeremy Gilbertson saw the earth setting behind the moon. I mean, what a perspective. This is the whole pale blue dot thing, but bigger and different. And you have these people saying, guys, trust me, from this perspective, we are all made of the same stuff. We are all here for the same purpose, yet we are pushing each other around in the wrong way. Those are the moments that need to be echoed, I think. But as Mark says, they're unfortunately like we humans come together in these beautiful points where we're here and there's a big moment and then it kind of fizzles away. How do we create the reverberation of moments like that to help create the economy that we want to see above our heads?
Matt Weinzierl well, okay. This is a really important conversation, I think, and I'll do a sort of deep cut. So footnote two in chapter 12 mentions an idea. Yeah, there you go. That I think is really important. It's a really old idea in economics is called due commerce, which is gentle commerce or sweet commerce. The idea that, you know, if we're building something valuable together, we're less likely to blow it up, basically.
⁓ And it's a very contested idea. mean throughout history people have said like, do nations who trade together go to war together? There's lots of different evidence on it. There's a new paper actually that just came out a couple weeks ago in economics that claims to have better evidence that actually this theory does kind of hold that nations that trade together tend not to go to war together. And whether it holds in history and on earth is maybe a different question anyways. Going out into space, you know, how do we keep the momentum? How do we keep this idea that we're not really, it's not a zero sum endeavor. This is like, if there's ever been a positive sum endeavor, this is one of them. This is it. And how do we keep that momentum? think leaning into the economics is not a bad way to do it, right? Cause the inspiration is wonderful. It's human, it's deep. It's important to have those narratives. But day to day, people want to see benefit in their lives. And so Brendan's always really good about bringing us back to like, what is the space sector doing for normal people every day? And I think the more it can do.
What space does for people every day
Mark Fielding So what's it doing for people every day, Brendan?
Brendan Rosseau man, how much time do you have?
Mark Fielding would you say are the top three things that it's doing for my uncle and my brother who are listening to this?
Brendan Rosseau I mean, it's a great question and I really do appreciate you asking it. The way that I think about what space does for us today is that it is this invisible backbone that upholds the 21st century way of life. And it's almost hard to...
point at one thing or another, although I will, in the same way that if someone asks you, does oxygen do for me every day? don't think about oxygen. It's not bringing me value. It's like, well, if it's gone, you would realize it real quick. There's actually a great quote from, I forget who it was, but there was an international group that did a study of what a space catastrophe or a day without space would look like. And the conclusion that they came to is that it would turn into
Brendan Rosseau like early 20th century kind of relationship very quickly ⁓ just because we rely on space so much so the the main ⁓
GPS and the invisible backbone
Brendan Rosseau The main way that people interface with space directly or the way that feels most tangible every day is through the GPS system or other global navigation systems. There's the obvious way where when you call an Uber, that's where it knows where the car is and where you are. But it's also baked into so many other systems, our financial transaction system, our energy grids, everything else. mean, if GPS goes out, ⁓ you lose a lot of things, ⁓ even just if you're sitting in your living room, you would notice very quickly. ⁓
And then of course, like on the national security side, ⁓ every ⁓ mission relies on countless pieces of both space connected hardware and assets and space and all kinds of things. So if you like your national security, that's important too. And there's a whole bunch of other smaller things. What I'm really excited about, not only about how we're using space today, ⁓ is that we're exploring, we're finding new and creative uses for space to do sometimes familiar things and sometimes completely new things. So the example that I love to cite is Starlink. Starlink is very much kind of a crazy idea that started less than a decade ago saying, hey, what if we could provide really good high speed globe spanning internet ⁓ from space ⁓ in a way that only space can. And in just a few short years, I mean, they just started deploying the system in like or 2020. There's already millions and millions of customers getting internet in places where they can't at really high speeds. And that's great to as a first step to
Get access to internet for people where they couldn't before but what's really exciting about that is that it creates entirely new ecosystems where you can have entirely think entirely new things be possible in places where you couldn't before because there is this Giant web of very high-speed internet truly everywhere on the earth That's where things start looking a little bit different and your self-driving car and your self-flying drone and all these kinds of things Become possible and then there's a million other things I'm gonna get off
Brendan Rosseau my soapbox because this is where I could go on and on. I really love it and I think the promise ⁓ of what we could see in the next few decades is just, it's so inspiring to me.
Jeremy Gilbertson We'd be remiss though if we.
Mark Fielding Jeremy, just to be clear, like, just can we just be sure, Matthew, have you got five minutes? Do you have to jump now? It's half past.
Matt Weinzierl I'm good and yeah, I'm good.
Jeremy Gilbertson No, you're good. think, and that's awesome. And having that perspective of, think you do a great job in the book of talking about the space to earth economy and the information you're able to capture and process and send back to the earth is huge. And that's where some of the monetary value is starting to get created. But you also have like, we talked about this before the show is like space is polarizing too. And like, seems half the comments that we get on our socials are,
Why not spend the money on Earth?
Jeremy Gilbertson wow, this is amazing, I can't wait, it's awesome, this is really cool thing we're doing, and you have the other people that are going, don't we have enough problems on Earth to solve, are we just running away from those? What do you say to those people about space?
Matt Weinzierl Yeah, I mean, it's a totally reasonable question. And it's a question honestly, it's been asked since the 1960s. People think about the Apollo era as this unifying moment where everyone was like, yes, let's spend four and a half percent of the federal budget on space. But in fact, there were a lot of people back then too, who thought, wait a minute, we've got serious problems here on earth. So it's a perpetual question for good reasons. And I guess I would just speak to where Brendan was already talking about some of the value that's been created and then the potential to create.
really exciting and transformational value to solve some of the very problems people are most worried about. I know you guys have done several episodes on space-based solar. And that's speculative. It's going to require a lot of technological development. The promise is also extraordinary for what that could do for us here. And AI data centers are a little bit trickier to necessarily draw the benefit to everybody, depending on your views of AI.
But I think they are a really important example of how the market finds ways to explore value creation that we can't foresee, ⁓ that can be transformational. So I don't know if AI didn't just work out in space. lot of smart people think they will. And when we were writing the book, they were like not even a figment. I think we maybe mentioned them once in the book. It was nowhere near the press they're getting now. And I don't expect that dynamic to stop. I think as costs keep coming down, know, launch costs for sure.
but station costs, operational costs in space, just in general infrastructure costs, we're gonna find new and creative ways to generate lots of benefits for people here on Earth, ⁓ even those who are skeptics.
Space based data centers
Mark Fielding Four words, space-based data centers.
Matt Weinzierl Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Mark Fielding Five words, star cloud.
you're not really mentioned in the book because it's such a short time that this has become a, at least on some social channels, massive conversation and in the wider media actually.
your both your views on space based data centers since the publishing of your book. Brendan, let's start with you.
Brendan Rosseau Sure, well, I should disclose that I'm part of a company, BlueLegion, where we have announced 51,000 satellite constellation of data centers. So obviously, in one respect, I am very much pro the opportunity ⁓ for data centers in space. ⁓ I think it's one of these ⁓ topics where, in some sense, the potential value is obvious, mean, especially with all the concerns about ⁓
Brendan Rosseau data centers here on earth where they use up resources, they spike energy bills, they're now very politically tricky. If you've been following the news around data centers, there's a lot, it's a very polarizing topic in whatever communities they're coming up in. So in some sense, the promise of, know, what if we put them in orbit where they don't affect anyone's ⁓ energy costs? They can connect to one another and ⁓ kind of be out of the way, but still immensely valuable to us. I think that the promise of that is something that will endure for a long time. I do think that there's a lot of ⁓ technological risk that needs to be burned down, particularly around how do you dissipate the heat that is generated in space. People think of space as very cold, ⁓ the challenge is that you can't really get rid of heat unless you ⁓ use radiators. And if you have a lot of heat and a lot of systems, you need very, very large radiators. then that...
causes all sorts of other problems. So there's a lot of smart people working on it. I do think it is not a 2020s ⁓ idea. I think it's maybe 2030s, ⁓ maybe at best. But we'll see. Hope springs eternal. And if it ends up working out, I'd be thrilled.
Mark Fielding Could you walk us through...
Cooling, and big radiators
Mark Fielding Could you just speak just for a little bit longer on potential cooling solutions? Because every time we speak about that, that's the question that gets asked and we get a lot of pushback on it. So if you go into a little bit more detail of what a solution might look like...
Brendan Rosseau Sure, three words for it. Big ass radiators, very, very large radiators ⁓ is really the best solution right now. Unless there's ⁓ kind of a novel or creative solution that comes out of it and a lot of people are working on it right now, that seems to be ⁓ the path forward. I know that's something, you mentioned Star Cloud, I know that's something Star Cloud is working on very closely as is everyone else. The good news is that.
That means bigger and bigger systems and we have bigger and bigger rockets that are being built. ⁓ That's what I work on all day every day is New Glenn. So there's some opportunity there. Matt, I love you.
Brendan Rosseau Is it the miniaturization physics limited. That's where the challenge gets in, is that you need, what's really key is the surface area, because that's how you dissipate the heat. And so you can only get that surface area in certain ways. And you kind of need it to be big. You can make it lighter.
Jeremy Gilbertson And it's inverse.
Yeah, it's inverse what the tech side of it's doing, right? Because the tech side is always getting smaller and smaller and more powerful, more powerful. It doesn't track and it's a tricky game. Terrestrially, it happens a lot. I come from the data center world a little bit too. like traditional cooling and what's happening on earth has been a challenge, but you're right. And up there, it's one of the biggest.
Brendan Rosseau Yeah, my takeaway, just because real quick, because you've mentioned kind of both sides of this, some people are so excited about it, exuberant about it, and then other people are really nacing. For me, my takeaway is I am glad that people are working on this problem. Will it work out on the timelines that people want? I really don't know. That's one of the exciting things. I don't think anyone really knows. ⁓ But I am so much happier to live in a world where...
Brendan Rosseau a broad swath of the community, especially the business community and tech community is thinking about this issue and investing money in it. Everyone from Google to the small players, that is positive. And we need that to be explored in all these other applications too. Sorry, Matt, go ahead.
A forest full of stags
Matt Weinzierl No, that's great. I don't have a lot of technical expertise to add to this. I will just mention that this is a stag, right? So you guys talk about the stag hunt and like, I'm so thrilled there's a stag that we have found to go after. And it wasn't like somebody from the center said, we got to do this, right? This is the market finding something big to raise huge amounts of money to go after. that's, that's great. No matter how it
Brendan Rosseau There's a full of stags out there. We are, we only know what we know and already it's incredibly exciting. mean, ⁓ in the long-term, ⁓ space resources, there's a entire solar system full of resources, including ones that are immensely valuable to us today. Not, ⁓ not, not only those, but also ones that we don't really know what we would do with them, but boy, I we would find some productive uses for them if we had, you know, continent size, ⁓ abundant materials. And that's, and you don't have to mine them in a way where you're
Brendan Rosseau know, strip mining next to a kindergarten or something like that. That seems like a universal win. And then the ability to generate huge amounts of power ⁓ through solar panels or other means where it's always solar noon. I mean, the list just goes on and on and on. They're incredibly hard to go after. I think that's part of the fun. But I...
I am really encouraged that it is a forest full of stags out there in space.
Jeremy Gilbertson Nice. No, the stag hunt. We had a lot of fun with the stag hunt game and pushing some ideas around. So in an effort to, would love to talk to you guys all day about this. Hope maybe we can do a round two or find something down the road, but I want to leave us with, we like to do a lot of thought experiments. ⁓ Yeah.
Mark Fielding just before that, I'm so curious about Matthew's quotes from us and I want to...
The authors' favourite lines
Matt Weinzierl Okay, all right. I'll run them. Thank you for the tee up. Okay, so first of all, I love that you call yourself the USS Enterprise of Technology podcasts. That was like, I think my hands went off the steering wheel because I was so excited about hearing that, given my Star Trek roots. So that was great. ⁓ My second one we've already talked about was how not to bring our earthly failures into space. I thought it was so great that you, that's not, people don't always talk about that in space discussions. I think that's such a useful.
Jeremy Gilbertson Great reminder.
Matt Weinzierl reminder. ⁓ Maybe a more narrow one in the property rights discussion. You had Exhum the Hume, which I love because I am a big fan of David Hume and ⁓ I thought that was pretty funny. I like the idea of a t-shirt. That sounds good. I also appreciated in the discussion of space debris that you offered your apologies to the Coase family for not believing in the Coase theorem. That was very funny. Not believing that it applied in this case. That was very thoughtful of you.
Matt Weinzierl And as a fan of the Coase theorem, I appreciate the apology of myself. And then the last one, you said, this was great. I felt like I was back in English class in high school. know, where you do like that close reading of the text, like maybe the authors didn't even know they were doing this, but were they doing this? You said, is chapter 12 the answer to chapter 11? Which is so great. It was like, were we subconsciously answering our own questions? So anyways, those were my top ones.
Mark Fielding We had a lot of fun. Thank you for highlighting some of our favorite parts too.
If you had to write the rules
Jeremy Gilbertson We really did. We really did. well, let's, let's, let's, I'm going to, I'm going to throw this out there. This, this last little bit, ⁓ don't feel like we need to go for hours on it. Like let's, can, we can use constraints as a powerful vehicle to help us, help us through this. All right. So imagine this. Okay. Matthew, you get a phone call. It's like, the authority of the world. Let's just call it the authority of the world. Matthew, I read you and Brendan's book.
You seem to have a really good handle on all this. We haven't done anything since 1967 in the outer space treaty. We have no idea how to govern all this stuff that's going to happen up there. I want to pull you both in. You agree to it. What are your first steps?
And this can be live riffing right here, boys.
Matt Weinzierl Wait, my first, okay. Okay, so honestly, are we the first two that are called? Brendan and I are the first two that get the call. Okay. Yeah. That's what I was gonna say. Exactly. No, no, no. Yeah. Hey, if that's on the table, for sure. A few of the greats. Let's zoom a few of the greats. It's funny. I just saw Project Hail Mary, like probably many of you and many listeners. And they have, that kind of happens, right? They assemble a team and.
Jeremy Gilbertson First two there are called, so you can maybe assemble the team. Who do you bring in? Do you exhume the Hume? Like, what do we?
Matt Weinzierl And I think that has to be in some ways the first step. I mean, I have to say, again, as an economist or whatever, I'm a little skeptical of like any room full of whatever, figuring out the big answers to these questions in any coordinated centralized way. Like I like emergent order. I think we're going to have to do that. But if this committee is being formed because we got to do something to get some rules down on paper, I think the first step is you've got to call in people with a wide range of expertise. I mean, we, and that again, back to what we do in our course.
We bring in people from all aspects of the space sector, not just startups, not just legacy primes, but also the government side of the table, the nonprofit side, because they each bring their own wisdom. And so that would be the first step for sure, is to get that list of whatever it is, 25, 30 leading thinkers together.
Well, okay, I'll give you one name. guess if we want to make the full list, but ⁓ and full disclosure, actually, I serve on the board of her nonprofit. So I guess it's a little bit self-dealing in that sense. But Ariel Equa is a local ⁓ scientist and entrepreneur here in Boston who is developing a technology to build large structures in space that self-assemble. And she has a startup that's doing that in a business sense, she has a nonprofit, has a venture arm, but she's one of these builders in the space sector who just thinks very long term, very benefit to all, motivated, and so she'd be in the room if I could start the lecture.
Mark Fielding Jeremy, write that down. We need to invite her to think on paper with us.
Matt Weinzierl She'd be a great guest you guys. Yeah
Who is in the room
Jeremy Gilbertson All right, so Brendan, he's handling, pulling the team together, getting the right folks in the room. Where does your head go with this?
Brendan Rosseau mean the thing I would want to start with ⁓ is what do we want the end state to look like? What is it that we really want to accomplish? And for me, I think there'd be a lot of different views on this, but for me personally, I would want ⁓ to encourage economic competition. I would want to encourage a flywheel of activities that pushes us forward. I think the risk with some of these kinds of ⁓ top-down, you know, broad treatise is that it can kind of put a damper on everything. ⁓ So I'd want to make sure that we're not doing that. But what I do think is truly ⁓ dangerous, if not destructive, is when it's overt military kinetic competition. I don't think anybody really wants that, but I think that everybody ⁓ is preparing for whatever the future might be out there. Thankfully, ⁓ the tip of the spear at this point ⁓ very much is, you know, science and exploration and things like that. The things that we're lucky to be at a point in history or space history where the things that we're worried about, ⁓ you know, are, ⁓ China sending another lunar rover to the far side of the moon. They're the first ones to get to the far side of the moon. I mean, from the, if you step back, that's a fantastic thing that have to be worried about that, that someone out there is doing ⁓ new and groundbreaking science and it just happens to be.
Brendan Rosseau you know, quote unquote, the other side. I think that's great. I want to encourage that as much as possible. And to the extent that you can bring national security leaders together and kind of chart out clear ⁓ rules of the road and ⁓ behaviors that are acceptable or not acceptable in the same way that we have, you know, laws of the sea and well understood traditions of what it means to operate in a professional manner ⁓ in those settings. I would love to see something like that too.
I'm not sure how optimistic I would be that one kind of grand treaty, to Matt's point, could solve all of this. think that maybe the path that on now, where there's a little bit of strategic ambiguity, ⁓ might fuel the forge in a way that's healthy. And I'm hoping that there is enough ⁓ real reluctance for any kind of major.
Brendan Rosseau conflict in space that we can try to avoid that, or at least prevent it. yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson Good start, gentlemen.
Mark Fielding What would you add, Jeremy? What's your third?
Brendan Rosseau I want hear your guys answers.
The Martens Clause
Jeremy Gilbertson So I'm a big proponent of the Martin's Clause. I'm not sure where I ran across it, but just this idea. It largely says don't be an asshole. Mark shortened it to that. But I think a lot about what could the minimum viable architecture for this governance be? And I don't know that anyone has the answer, but I know it's a really cool question to keep thinking about.
Mark Fielding ⁓ I'll save mine for the next episode of Thinking on Paper. Matthew Vines, Brendan Rosu, authors of the fabulous, awesome, important Space to Grow. Thank you for thinking on paper with us. It's been a pleasure. Until next time, be disruptive. Stay curious.
Jeremy Gilbertson Keep thinking on paper. Guys, thanks so much for joining us. If you could hang out for just a sec to make sure we get your local uploads.




