Yuval Noah Harari’s Nexus, Chapter 5: What Separates Democracy From Dictatorship?
In 1830 there were only 78,000 newspaper subscriptions in the United States, one of the figures the hosts pull from Harari to show who could take part in early democracy.
In this episode · 17 chapters
- Totalitarianism has no self-correcting mechanism
- What citizens trust in a working democracy
- Where information flows, and where it stops
- Democracy in small groups
- Scale, and the limits of the city state
- Empathy and intimate knowledge
- Bureaucracy, and the urge to do it yourself
- The pamphlet as technology
- Two early experiments in democracy
- Who counted as a voter
- Mass media made democracy possible, and totalitarianism too
- The secret police and the surveillance network
- Stalin and the Kulaks
- Democracies and totalitarian regimes in the AI era
- Does AI favour one system over the other?
- Who writes your shortcuts?
- North Korea as the laboratory
People talk about the democratization of knowledge and they use these nonsense terms like AI makes everybody knowledgeable, it democratizes knowledge and skills. Does it?
Mark and Jeremy read chapter five of Nexus by Yuval Noah Harari, which places democracy and dictatorship on a continuum set by information flow. They follow the idea from hunter-gatherer groups and ancient Rome through the pamphlet, the newspaper and Stalin's campaign against the Kulaks.
Then they turn to AI. Does it favour democracies or dictatorships? One host worries that AI shortcuts will harden into beliefs. They also ask whether AI democratises knowledge or only access to information, and why North Korea may be the laboratory to watch.
Chapter 5 of Yuval Noah Harari's Nexus, read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, treats democracy and totalitarianism as two ways of moving information: a conversation between many nodes, or a broadcast from one centre. Mark Fielding and Jeremy Gilbertson follow Harari from ancient city-states to Stalin's Soviet Union, and argue over whether AI favours either system.
What separates democracy from dictatorship in Harari's Nexus?
The key difference is self-correction. Democracies rely on courts, the media and education to correct mistakes; a totalitarian centre claims to be infallible.
Are elections a way to discover truth, according to Harari?
Elections, in the line Jeremy quotes, are “not a method for discovering truth” but “a method to maintain order”. Dictatorships hold them too.
How does Harari say a democracy can be flipped?
Harari’s account of how to flip a democracy starts with taking over its self-correcting mechanisms. Populism opens the way by telling people to trust no institution except the strongman.
What made mass democracy possible, according to Harari?
All the ancient democracies were city-states. Harari notes that Rome had 75 million people spread over 5 million square kilometres, and only 10 to 20% could read. In his line, “mass media made democracy possible, not inevitable.”
How did Stalin's regime control information on citizens?
Stalin’s regime shows the other end of the spectrum: a secret police filing system on citizens, and on 27 December 1929 Stalin’s call for “the liquidation of the Kulaks as a class”.
Where Mark and Jeremy disagree
Mark doubts AI is a decentralising technology, since it puts “all the information in one point”. Jeremy will not say AI favours either system, and worries instead that shortcuts will harden into beliefs.
Links from this episode
Questions
What separates democracy from dictatorship?
The key difference is self-correction. Democracies rely on courts, the media and education to correct mistakes; a totalitarian centre claims to be infallible.
What is chapter 5 of Harari's Nexus about?
Chapter 5 of Yuval Noah Harari's Nexus, read on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, treats democracy and totalitarianism as two ways of moving information: a conversation between many nodes, or a broadcast from one centre.
Do Mark and Jeremy think AI favours democracy or dictatorship?
Where they push back: Mark doubts AI is a decentralising technology, since it puts “all the information in one point”. Jeremy will not say AI favours either system, and worries instead that shortcuts will harden into beliefs.
How does Nexus chapter 5 trace democracy through history?
They follow the idea from hunter-gatherer groups and ancient Rome through the pamphlet, the newspaper and Stalin's campaign against the Kulaks.
Transcript
Mark Fielding Disruptors and curious minds, CEOs, founders, book lovers, welcome to the Thinking on Paper book club. I'm Mark, this is Jeremy and we read books that have stood the test of time, books that will change your mind. You've heard of slow food, this is slow reading, one book, one chapter, one week. If you're new to this book club is the second pillar in the Thinking on Paper framework, a better more holistic understanding of the impact of emerging technologies on business and culture, thinkingonpaper.xyz or more. So we're reading chapter five of Nexus this week and we're going to be talking about the difference between democracy and totalitarianism, how they are formed by information networks, how the flow of information changes the regime and how they can flourish.
Jeremy Gilbertson We'll be examining the whole spectrum and we're meeting some very nefarious, horrible characters along the way, won't we Jeremy? Nero, Sparta, the Soviet Union, the strongmen, Putin, Orban, Erdogan, all of them. It's going to be brilliant. First impressions, Jeremy, before we get to that. First impression is just a commitment to my no jacket required engagement with books. First impressions on this, man. Well, it starts out, we're basically bouncing between democracy and totalitarianism, right? So you have these two, if we break it down to how information is sent, you could send information in multiple ways, just like we're doing right now, this is a broadcast, right? This is a broadcast. It's going from us to one person.
It's not a bidirectional yet, but if you guys send us a link and you're listening and you want to participate, we can turn this broadcast into a bidirectional thing. So democracy is a conversation, right? And totalitarianism is more broadcast. So maybe we can do it a different way. Mark, me talking to you and you talking to me, that's democracy. You telling me something and me having no choice over it is totalitarianism. Yeah. So that's the main difference is he outlies the differences. Yeah. Centralized totalitarianism is a centralized flow of data. Democracy is decentralized. It uses the word nodes. It's kind of spread out.
Totalitarianism has no self-correcting mechanism
Mark Fielding I think the big key is that totalitarianism has no self-correcting mechanisms, whereas democracy is based heavily on self-correcting mechanisms, which we've spoken about self- correcting mechanisms in the past, haven't we? The law, the court, the media, education, those kinds of things where we're all fallible, aren't we? And these correct that fallibleness, but in you have the totalitarian systems, there is no, the center is infallible. They're the main differences between those two. And then he kind of lays out how you get there, doesn't he? So yeah, what's your favorite totalitarianist? Well, geez, I mean, like, well, first of all, that one of the quotes that popped out that I thought was really interesting is about elections, right? And, you know, dictatorships have elections and you're like, how the hell is this dictatorship having? What does an election mean in there? So elections are not a method for discovering truth.
Jeremy Gilbertson They are a method to maintain order. So less truth, more order, more truth, less order. We got to remember that like little seesaw thing there. And, you know, it's really interesting. We're a week away from the inauguration here in the States, right? And not a week away. We're like a couple of days away. It's Monday. We're recording this on the 17th of January. I try not to think about it, Mark. Tell you the truth. But what's really interesting is he talks about, Harari talks about in the book, about how to flip democracy. And, you know, like almost like this playbook on how to flip democracy. And he says flipping democracy starts with taking over its self-correcting mechanisms. Okay.
And as you mentioned before, self-correcting mechanisms are the courts, are the media. And this particular individual that's reassuming office in a few days has pretty good control over the courts. And I don't know about the media, but I think he created his own media. So it's really interesting to read this and kind of go, wait, is he dusting off an old playbook? Like what is, what's happening here? You know? Well, so in the book, in chapter five, he speaks about populism, doesn't he? And I think that's the kind of the middle ground between democracy and dictatorship.
What citizens trust in a working democracy
Jeremy Gilbertson And once, you know, in a well functioning democracy, citizens trust the results of elections, the decisions of courts, the reports of media outlets and the findings of scientific disciplines, because citizens believe these institutions are committed to the truth. Once people think that power is the only reality, they lose trust in all these institutions, democracy collapses, and the strong man can seize total power. Exactly. And here's the irony of all of this, Mark. Populism, according to the book, according to the author and his examples, starts with this telling of, hey, you know, we shouldn't trust all these elites and all of these institutions and all of that. Don't trust any of these things, Mark, but I know who you should trust.
Mark Fielding You should trust me and don't trust them. You know, you shouldn't trust any one thing, but trust the one thing that is me, which is, which is really an interesting, because I know better. I know what's best for you. Yeah. Above the power structure lies with the will of the people, isn't it? And it doesn't matter how many people take up arms and try and defend that. It always comes out as the will of the people. I think it's very important to mention the spectrum. So there is, it's not a binary sum game, is it? Democracy and dictatorship aren't binary opposites, but rather are on a continuum to decide whether a network is closer to the democratic or the dictatorial end of the continuum.
We need to understand how information flows in the network and what shapes the political conversation. I thought that, I mean, I think we all know what democracy is in general. I think we all know what totalitarianism in general, this chapter. It's playing a difficult balancing game, isn't it?
Because on the one hand, he's trying to explain the very basics of democracy, but on the other hand, he's trying to expand on how it comes about. And I think that as a writer, you've got to know your audience because you've got to know your readership, don't you? Because sometimes I felt like he was saying very obvious things. And then other times when he goes into the historical details, it was a bit more eyeopening. And I quite enjoyed that aspect of the chapter. That's the tricky part. It's like, you know, coaching a group of players. Some players are highly skilled, some players are new, some players are in the middle. As a writer, you got to kind of give something to pull all of those different skill sets along the journey.
Where information flows, and where it stops
Jeremy Gilbertson So you talked about this continuum, this spectrum, and it's all based on how information flows within these systems, which is really interesting, right? So the dictatorship is kind of flows from this central point and out as a broadcast, and it's all processed centrally, right? But here's an interesting piece about democracy. They talk about democracy as a conversation, between two nodes in the network. Let's talk about, these are information networks, right? These are two nodes in a network talking. But even when you have the ability to talk in a democracy, what happens when you don't have the will to listen? Well, democracy fails. That was the other point of it. That's the other way that democracy can fail.
Mark Fielding It's when the conversation becomes one way, nobody's listening. Not because of the inability of the network and the system to function as like an infrastructure, but the ability for the human side to use the infrastructure as designed. It's an important thing to think about, I think. It is. And a lot of this is important to think about, like you say, three days away from Inauguration Day. And I forgot to mention at the beginning what me and Jeremy are going to try to do at the end of this is assimilate Chapter 5 into what it means in the age of artificial intelligence, because the whole book is about that. Artificial intelligence is about the flow of information.
So in some way, we're going to try and connect democracy and totalitarianism to what happens next with artificial intelligence. So stay tuned for that. So let's jump in a time machine. Let's jump in the time machine and let's go back and look at Athens and Rome. Let's go look at how those organizations dealt with scale, because I think infrastructure is designed based on how things scale and things like- Okay, then. So get back in your time machine and go a little bit further and we'll go to the hunter gatherers first. Okay, let's start there. Let's start at the beginning where democracy in the very early hunter-gatherer period of humanity, that democracy flourished, kind of. And why did it flourish?
Democracy in small groups
Mark Fielding Because small manageable groups of people where any kind of dictatorial delusions of grandeur would be quickly put out, wouldn't they? There's a communication amongst the small group. The group would decide what to eat, who to hunt, whether to go rampaging around and kill everybody in the next community. It was all a group decision, wasn't it? Maybe, maybe. Or it's one person holding this group hostage per se by manipulating their desire for security and their fear of not having it. Do you think that happened though in those hunter-gatherer times? Well, imagine you're in a group and you have 20 or 30 people. You're well fed. You're maybe, dare I say, cultured. You have nice houses that protect you from the cold.
Jeremy Gilbertson And I'm this dude just walking around in the perimeter doing my own thing. I'm fending off threats. I'm maybe eating once or twice a week. And from my perch high on the mountain, I'm looking down at your little organization. You have fires and you're dancing. And I'm like, man, that would be kind of awesome. It kind of sucks out here by myself. I should probably run down and see what they're up to. And I get down there and you welcome me in. You're like, hey, this is great. Come on in. But you're also like, yo, you have to shave your mustache. You can't call me by anything other than your highness. You're not allowed to wear shoes on Wednesday. But I'm like, you know what?
Mark Fielding Food, shelter, all that stuff is worth me making those sacrifices under your control. That's later though, isn't it? That's like well, Mesopotamia and ancient Greece. I think right back in the hunter-gatherers, that wasn't a possibility. But yeah, once the agricultural revolution came about and writing became a thing, then yes, exactly what you described became possible, didn't it? They controlled, you could control the crops. You could control to a certain degree the financial systems of those places and times. So with a technology, meaning with a means to exert your will or control over something, that's valuable. And that becomes valuable, makes you valuable. You're the guy that figured it out.
Scale, and the limits of the city state
Jeremy Gilbertson People kind of trust you and kind of get pulled into your ecosystem. I want to talk about scale though. Let's talk about scale. So Rome had two elected consuls checked by the Senate, checked by something else called tribunes. So how the heck did they end up with an unelected emperor? It's really interesting, but it's, he argues or he presents the point that they had 75 million people distributed over 5 million kilometers squared, and only 10 to 20% of them could read. So it's hard to have a conversation when you're that far apart, right? And when people aren't even able to converse necessarily. So it had to become something different, didn't it? Democracy in that case couldn't officially scale, right? It was like an autocratic center. What did he say? As the size of polities continued to increase and city-states were superseded by large kingdoms, even partial democracy disappeared.
Mark Fielding All the examples of ancient democracies are city-state. We don't know of any large scale kingdom or empire that operated along democratic lines for the reasons that you say. We just, and that was to do with the technology. It wasn't possible. I mean, Nero would have loved to manipulate and know and control and corral everyone, wouldn't he? But the technology wasn't there. And so I guess they knew that they couldn't do that. So they were happy to kind of have the power and the money and the taxes that they had, rather than seeking this totalitarianism, which came later. The E word came up again. I'm not talking about the one that melted our faces during Carlo Rovelli's book about entropy.
Empathy and intimate knowledge
Jeremy Gilbertson I'm talking about empathy, which ironically, we talked about a lot in the debrief of our last show with the technical prize director for quantum computing for XPRIZE. Awesome show. Awesome show. That was so much fun. But the idea of empathy being a required ingredient for large scale political conversations is really interesting because right now there's a lack of empathy in large scale political conversations, but he defines meaningful discourse in here, which is something I've always wanted to think about. How do you define meaningful interaction? How do you define meaningful discourse between two people? And he says, you have to have proximity. So right now we have proximity, Mark. You and I were connected on a largely unlaggy stream here. What are you trying to say?
But yeah, it's a little jabbery. And intimate knowledge. So intimate knowledge of I know you, you know me, don't sing the Barney song. But we also have intimate knowledge of the topics, right? Of the topics of discussion, right? So we can have meaningful intercourse, discourse. Let's not have meaningful intercourse. Let's have meaningful discourse. I know it's Friday, but come on. Because we have proximity and intimate knowledge. I think that was an equation for something undefinable. That's really interesting to me. I agree. Do you think, just before we get back onto kind of mass media and what happened after ancient Rome. They gave up, didn't they, in ancient Rome? They kind of wanted democracy.
Mark Fielding They understood what it was about, but they just thought, we can't do it. It's too big. We've invaded too many lands. What are the Brits doing? What are the Gauls doing? Who cares? We can't do it. Let's just go down. Let's get Caesar in control and go down the other path. How do you think people feel about being governed? I mean, do you think that people in ancient times had a different view of being governed? Do you think we've learned kind of like Pavlov's dog to like or not like being governed? Man, whenever I'm asked a question like this, and I don't know if you do this as well, we've talked about our Thrasher magazine and skate culture and punk rock music and just the idea of someone telling you, you have to do something.
Bureaucracy, and the urge to do it yourself
Jeremy Gilbertson And immediately, there's a resistance to be like, hey, I want to do this thing myself. But like he references in previous chapters, there's a place for this bureaucracy. There's a place for these rules and this organization and this standard to kind of live and work by. So it's a balance, right? Like where is the balance of giving people like it's almost like we're sitting in a jazz jam, right? And if we're getting ready to play together, we've never played together. I'm going to say, hey, we're going to play. We're going to play and see, Mark. And you're going to be like, OK, well, I know that there's a rule that helps us instead of just like clamoring around. We got to have a little bit of organization, don't you think?
Mark Fielding Like, do you struggle with that, too? How do you think about that? In a very similar way, yeah. And on a personal level, we're all different, aren't we? So some people like to be told what to do. Some people like to have other people putting all the structure in it. Some people like a much more hands off approach. I guess it depends. And I was just kind of thinking aloud about how that's changed over the thousands of years. And. Pompeii, I've got Pompeii written down here, I was just thinking about the Pompeii. So you talk about scale, you talk about the Romans, ancient Rome, Greece. And then. I was reminded again how in the grand scheme of things, how everything's really happened in the last hundred, two hundred years, hasn't it? Before that, before the invention.
The pamphlet as technology
Mark Fielding I mean, at one point he talks about pamphlets like this great technological marvel, a pamphlet, and actually the pamphlet kind of because of its ease before the book became kind of universal, it was this changed the flow of information in a pamphlet. I think he was talking about Poland and Lithuania or the Dutch experiments like the Netherlands that we know now that was found on pamphlets. And obviously that quickly comes to newspapers. And he talks about America and the civil war and how, you know, your American history better than I do. But they're talking about what was it? Oh, gosh, I'm writing it down. I was going to ask you a question about American history, Jeremy. While you're looking for that. Yeah, let's move to the US. Right.
Two early experiments in democracy
Jeremy Gilbertson So he talked about the two first experiments in democracy, this Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth that, you know, to some extent work, but was missing that vehicle to communicate over long distance. Then you talked about the pamphlet newspaper. The Dutch Republic was really the one experiment that that kind of said, hey, here's a newspaper. Here's we're going to we're going to distribute the news. It's it's the WhatsApp of like the early days.
Right. Yeah. And then the U.S. is kind of peeking around like, how do we what do we do? What kind of system do we put in place? Hey, hey, these Dutch guys have something going on. Like, let's talk about that and how how how we can base our systems around that. But here's something I thought was really interesting, just like any technology when it first comes out, like the Apple Vision Pro when it first came out was like thirty five hundred bucks or four thousand bucks. Like who the hell is going to, you know, just rip off four grand and, you know, go do that. Right. But newspapers back in the day, subscriptions were actually pretty expensive. It was like more than one week's wages for most skilled workers, according to what Harari says in here.
Who counted as a voter
Mark Fielding Yeah, that's the spectrum of democracy again, isn't it? So America back in the time of the Gettysburg Address, I mean, it was only rich white men who were allowed to vote. So today, compared to today's democracy, it wasn't very democratic, but compared to everybody else and everywhere else in the world, it was very democratic. So on that spectrum, you get more freedoms in your democracy back then, thanks to the newspaper. It was the Gettysburg Address, by the way. Could you explain what the Gettysburg Address was, Jeremy? Four score in seven years. Was that that? I think. I think. I don't know. I could be wrong. No, here's an interesting fact that I pulled out of here, too. In 1830, there were only 78,000 newspaper subscriptions in the U.S. in 1830.
Jeremy Gilbertson And largely, like you said, that's the domain of wealthy white men who could afford that, right? So you have this available technology, but then accessibility to that technology is super limited, right? So it's it's only for the participation in democracy is limited by your ability to access the available technology. To tie into that a little bit more, you referenced the elections in 1824 elections. Seven percent of the total population made use of their right to vote. Seven percent. And Adams won the vote with two percent. Two percent of that seven percent. That's like it's like, is that is that a democracy? And then he also says, yes, at the time. Yes. One variation of democracy. Yes. But but at the time, there were more slaves in the United States than voters.
Mark Fielding 1.5 million slaves to three hundred and fifty two thousand seven hundred and eighty voters. I don't know that count. Don't forget that he says and he says it quite a few times that democracy isn't voting. It isn't just true. It's the self-correcting mechanisms and the way to question the fallibility of the center. So it's not just the elections. And as North Korea demonstrate with their democratic elections every five years, we're going to put it in the box. When again, 99 percent of the vote.
Well, what a guy. But yes, compared to today, that's a very tiny fraction. OK, should we can are you are you OK to flip to Stalin? Is that too far to jump ahead or where do you want? OK, so on that Stalin bit, I'm going to say the telegraph, the telephone, the television, the radio, the train, the plane. These were the the way the information flowed very quickly. Technology expanded from the pamphlet. Yeah. The telegraph, telephone, later television before that radio train plane and a quote, mass media made democracy possible, not inevitable. Mass media made democracy possible, not inevitable. And I think that that when we talk about I later is a very we should hold on to that. But yeah. And then so that lays the way for a very dark time.
Mass media made democracy possible, and totalitarianism too
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, so so say that quote again about democracy that doesn't guarantee mass media doesn't guarantee democracy is basically what you're saying. Yeah. Mass media made democracy possible, not inevitable. Yeah. So, yeah. Does it is mass media a broadcast or is it a conversation? Right. And I think you go back to that little rule, that little heuristic, if you will, that that maybe can lead us to believe it's one way or the other. Stalin must have been freaking exhausted, dude. I'm telling you, like, listen, listen to this quote here. Attempt to control totalitarianism, an attempt to quote an attempt to control what every person throughout the country is doing and saying at every moment of the day and potentially what every person is thinking and feeling.
Mark Fielding I can't imagine. I can't imagine like trying to do that and stressing about whether I was doing that. I guess he just killed people. That's what he did. But I don't know, man, that seems seems crazy. Yeah. Well, OK, I quite like a bit of Russian history. I like it. You know, so the the Bolsheviks seized power in the 17 revolution, buoyed by Marx. They kind of started to dismantle the self-correcting mechanisms, didn't they? And then Stalin comes to power in the 30s. It's like, oh, what they've done a good job. Let's take it to its most nefarious, evil conclusion. And. Kind of that crescendos into the collectivism, Soviet farmers and kulaks, which was. Hard reading, what was the most dangerous job in Russia in 1941?
Oh, yeah, that was like, yeah, KGB or not KGB, but whatever it was, the precursor to that spy was it? Well, you know, even more descriptive than that, being one of Stalin's generals. Yeah. Can you read that thing about how did they all die? The shot he killed 90 percent of his generals by 1941. 90 percent of his inner circle was killed by 1941.
The secret police and the surveillance network
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, let's OK, so let's let's slide this down into secret police in this surveillance network. Again, not being a conversation. This is not a conversation. It's just a capturing of data, right? To power, to power control. Right. In this, how do you say it? Kartecki? Kartecki is is basically like the the Dewey decimal system for what everyone else is doing. And they put it in a giant filing system to figure out who is doing what and when and how and why. Yeah. And then and then that eventually leads to a dip back into interest, intersubjective realities created to control populations, right, to control large, large groups of of people. And the super unfortunate story of the Kulaks, right?
Mark Fielding These these entrepreneurial they called them capitalist farmers, but like they kind of had their own farm. They had their own, you know, animals and that sort of thing. And what what this surveillance and what this intersubjective reality created by Stalin as this information network, the largest and fastest enslavement campaign in history. This is like the darkest of the dark, dude. And wasn't that built on the collection, collection, collectionist, where they put the farms together and then, oh, big surprise, people don't actually work as hard when it's not for them and their family and their closest. And so the crops didn't give the the bounty that they expected, did they? And so that led on to this. OK, we're going to have to do something about this.
Stalin and the Kulaks
Jeremy Gilbertson On December 27th, 1929, Stalin declared that the Soviet state should seek the liquidation of the Kulaks as a class and immediately galvanized the party and secret police to realize that ambitious and murderous aim. And what follows is a very, very short period of. Genocide. And insert in certain certain areas, certain villages where actually there was a there was a directive sent down that you had to identify people as Kulaks. You had to identify them even if you didn't have people that fit the definition. So what happened like would be a situation where like, oh, we don't have any in our village, but we got to pick someone or else something's going to happen.
So they just picked old people or just like, hey, sorry, Mark, there's no one that there's no one that fits that definition in the village. Sorry, dude, I got to put you up. You know, good luck in the you know, good luck either not being alive anymore or being in some kind of encampment like. Wow, yeah, I mean, learning about this, learning about this and in history, the thing that gets my wheels spinning is that it's not just history and dates and this happened and that happened, but it's the the how these information networks spin up and affect large groups of people, you know, and what type of information network it is. If you look at it as a network, if you look at it as an information network, it's really.
Well, and this is what you said earlier, it's really applicable to like where technology is going right now. And technology being literally ones and zeros, moving from points to point on networks and looking at history that way has been, man, pretty eye-opening and a little bit scary. Agreed.
Democracies and totalitarian regimes in the AI era
Mark Fielding So let's move on to the final part then. As humankind enters the second quarter of the 21st century, a central question is how well democracies and totalitarian regimes will handle both the threats and the opportunities resulting from the current information revolution, aka AI. Will the new technologies favour one type of regime over the other, or will we see the world divided once again, this time by a silicon curtain? How would you corral all of that information from chapter five into how you view AI? Just everyone listening, by the way, we haven't read the rest of the book, so Yuval might give the answers or his opinions on what happens next. We're doing this in real time, so we're just doing it on chapters one, two, three, four.
Jeremy Gilbertson Step- by-step across each information node. Because we've got, this is our own self-correcting mechanism, we'll self-correct in chapter six. In real time. In real time, that's a great point. The book club is a self-correcting mechanism for our own nutty lack of understanding on some of this stuff. Back to dictatorships and democracies. Dictatorships being infallible and broadcasting one way from the inside out and nothing's coming back here. Well, the stuff that comes back is like the surveillance network. All of these things that come back into the, what do you call it? The carotechy? What a bureaucratic nightmare to deal with Dewey decimal cards with all that information on people in a manual way and processing all the interconnectivity between that.
Mark Fielding What does AI profess to do? What does quantum computing profess to be able to do eventually? We talked about this with our wonderful guests from XPRIZE the other day, how technology can be used for great things that help people in the world and can also use it for nefarious reasons, as we say. If you had to choose now, just on the spot, do you think that AI lends itself more to North Korea or to little old blighty England? Is it a totalitarian thing or is it a democratic technology? Do you think it lends itself more to one or the other? I mean, imagine if Stalin had had AI. Yeah, game over, game over. Like game over.
Does AI favour one system over the other?
Jeremy Gilbertson All right, I'm going to answer that question a little bit differently because I don't think I can say that AI is more inherently a great fit for democracies or a great fit for terrible dictatorships. The challenge being, democracy is these independent nodes that collect and process information. We talked about this. Again, I keep pointing back to this last show, guys. If you haven't listened to the XPRIZE show yet, please check it out because we talk about empathy. We talk about the human piece involved in technology's use in a good way or a bad way, and also the problems that we create for ourselves. Will AI limit the human element by creating so many shortcuts that we can't think for ourselves anymore?
Then democracy becomes in danger because I have so many shortcuts. My shortcuts have turned into beliefs. I'm not going to listen to you anymore, Mark, because I already have those and I'm not going to spend my energy on listening. That's what scares me.
Who writes your shortcuts?
Mark Fielding Who's creating those shortcuts for you? Who's writing those shortcuts? Who's harvesting them from the internet without due diligence, without critical thinking? Thinking on paper is learning your own shortcut by critically thinking and processing and writing and all of that stuff. The centralization, the center is infallible. The information all flows from one point, the opposite of decentralization. AI is essentially putting all the information in one point. All the information will come through one AI. Who has control of that? It doesn't feel like a decentralizing technology necessarily. People talk about the democratization of knowledge and they use these nonsense terms like AI makes everybody knowledgeable, it democratizes knowledge and skills. Does it?
Jeremy Gilbertson It democratizes access to information. I don't think it becomes knowledge. Information isn't truth, is it? Yeah. I'm starting to envision if we use our Star Wars analogy, you have could it be that AI is Darth Vader in the dark side and blockchain is the rebel force on the outside. One wants to get their arms around all of the things and tweak and manipulate. The other side is like, hey, we want to create a decentralized approach to this, ownership of all of the little pieces and parts and remuneration of those pieces and parts once they get used and applied in different ways. It's an early riff, but I'm going to sprinkle it out there for now. Well, I'd like to see what's happening in North Korea.
North Korea as the laboratory
Mark Fielding I think North Korea, that will be the experimental, that's the lab, isn't it? Let's see whatever's happening right now with AI, whatever they're doing is probably a nice experiment to see where we end up. Because they are, aren't they? I'm sure they are, but it's so secretive. Nobody knows anything. That's the piece, that's the piece. Guys, how can we end on a high note? How can we turn this thing around, Mark? I felt good after the XPRIZE episode and I'm feeling a little... Okay, I'll turn around. So everything we said in the last five minutes is somewhat, not in jest, but it's very easy to go, the world's a bright place and everything's fine. Maybe it is, but you have to think about the flip side.
Chapter five of the Nexus has just made it blindingly obvious that you have to think about the flip side. You have to. It's not being negative and doom. I love artificial intelligence. I think it's great. Like you said last week, the benefits are unquestionable.




