Can Music Tech Create Real Connection?

Nicholas Ponari built his guitar skills in his parents' basement, putting in tens of hours a week. So to go back to your point, AI is not gonna make anybody David Gilmour.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 16 chapters

  1. What Overtune is
  2. The David Gilmour question
  3. A strong personal position
  4. Taking a stance against Suno
  5. Language converted into maths
  6. How accurate is it?
  7. The thought experiment
  8. The split sheet
  9. The final automation of attribution
  10. Can you backdate it?
  11. The numbers
  12. Hyper personalised music
  13. A hellscape
  14. In 2040
  15. DJ Dave
  16. The Kevin Kelly question
There’s no words, but I know the pain that this person was feeling because I can feel it in the guitar, the way it was played, the musicality of how that comes through, even in the recording.
Nicholas Ponari

Nicholas Ponari was one of the first investors in Overtune and later joined full time. He explains why Overtune took a hard stance against Suno and how it trained its model: “Yes, we have around 20,000 loops all created by our in-house producers.”

Ponari sets out how vector maths could trace a generated track back to the producers whose stems shaped it. He argues attribution cannot be fixed in existing models without rebuilding them, and that live music will matter more as personalised content grows.

Nicholas Ponari, an early investor in Overtune who later joined the company full time, tells the Thinking On Paper podcast how the AI music app credits and pays producers. Overtune took “a hard stance against Suno”, trained its AI on loops from its own producers, and uses vector maths to work out which producers shaped each new track so royalties can follow the music.

Who are the most valuable users of Overtune?

Overtune's most valuable users are singers who do not play an instrument. Ponari calls this group “non-musical vocalists” and says Overtune builds their backing track, mixes and masters it, and exports it to Spotify, SoundOn and SoundCloud. He puts the app at 300,000 downloads, with between 7,000 and 15,000 recurring users depending on the month.

Why did Overtune take a stance against Suno?

Overtune took “a hard stance against Suno” and built its model on licensed material instead. Ponari says the model uses around 20,000 loops made by in-house producers, and that outside producers can submit stems (the separate parts of a track, such as drums or bass) to it. He says models already trained on scraped music cannot be fixed after the fact and would need rebuilding “from the ground up using new stems”.

How does Overtune trace which artists shaped a song?

Overtune traces influence by measuring distance between vectors. Ponari explains that each stem is converted into “audio latent vectors”, lists of numbers that place a sound in a mathematical space, and that measuring the distance from a new song back to those origin vectors shows which artists contributed most.

How would Overtune split royalties between contributors?

Ponari describes the royalty model as “realistically a volume play”. In a thought experiment with a $100 payout, he says the song's creator would probably get $50 and the stem contributors would share the rest, while stressing the split is still being worked out. Contributors with only a faint influence are cut off from commercial attribution, which he compares to the tiny pull Pluto exerts on Earth.

Will AI make anyone a great musician?

Ponari argues that human effort will become the mark of real talent. “AI is not gonna make anybody David Gilmour,” he says; that takes hours of practice and failure. He positions Overtune as “the entry level, using AI to build the interest”, and says users who outgrow it and hire real producers have graduated.

Where Mark and Ponari disagree

Ponari predicts that AI will become “the largest curator of content” and feed everyone music suited to their tastes. Mark calls a world of hyper-personalised music a hellscape in which there “would be no shared culture”. Ponari replies that both can exist, and that personalised listening will make live music more valuable.

Questions

Who is Nicholas Ponari?

Nicholas Ponari was one of the first investors in Overtune and later joined full time.

What is Overtune?

Nicholas Ponari, an early investor in Overtune who later joined the company full time, tells the Thinking On Paper podcast how the AI music app credits and pays producers.

How does Overtune pay producers?

Overtune took “a hard stance against Suno”, trained its AI on loops from its own producers, and uses vector maths to work out which producers shaped each new track so royalties can follow the music.

Transcript

Nicholas Ponari I was one of the first investors into Overtune. This happened at the very beginning of the pandemic. And what I had felt that was missing was connection. People were really desperate to connect. And for myself throughout my entire life, music was always a method of not just connecting with other people at a concert. The euphoria and the feeling of being in a live music event with other people is magic.

You feel so connected to your fellow humans, also connecting with yourself. I discovered at a young age and for me it was through Pink Floyd's Comfortably Numb, where you you hear that ending the outro solo and I just felt this deep, deep sadness. And that's when it clicked in my brain where it was like music is the language of emotion. There's no words, but I know the pain that this person was feeling because I can feel it in the guitar, the way it was played, the musicality of how that comes through, even in the recording. It's it's it's so different.

So Overtune had come out with a way to help people create and share music. And I made this investment based on nothing, but this is what the world needs more of. Needs more people being in touch with themselves, sharing themselves, getting themselves out there. And that's what put me on the same path as Overtune. As the company grew, ⁓ they started going through their seed round, through their Series A and so on. They needed somebody with more business experience to help them achieve their next levels of growth.

And that's when I joined in full time and I took some of the experience I had from my previous jobs into building something really unique for Overtune.

What Overtune is

Jeremy Gilbertson Overtune is a beat I know you're doing more things with it, which I want to unpack, but I got on it, I tried the demo of the beat maker, the shading of the dots are really interesting as a mechanism instead of dragging and dropping if you don't have experience in a DAW or you haven't ever programmed beat yourself out in analog world. It's a very accessible...

means to jump in. are a few other people doing things like that, right? Splice and, you know, even GarageBand to a certain extent, with those things already being out there, what did you want to take this core functionality of making and sharing music and making that accessible? are you headed with it?

Mark Fielding He wants to turn you into Dave Gilmour

Nicholas Ponari I would love to do that, by the way. I want to turn myself into Dave Gilmour. Like that's what I'm going for. ⁓ It's a very interesting question. And I think the answer really falls onto all of the customer interviews that we've been doing and really figuring out who's been resonating the most with our product. In our case, it's non-musical vocalists. Like we found out this is the cohort of people that resonates most with our product who wants more features, who stays the longest, pays the most.

And it's really about giving that platform to, know, how does like, so we've conducted, you know, dozens of customer interviews and like, what does that process look like for somebody who wants to get something from their heart into the world? And usually it starts with an idea while you're driving. And what happens is like those lyrics hit, you pull out your phone, you do a voice recording, you sing into your phone. Then you go home, you write the rest of your lyrics. Maybe you have a, you know, a semi-professional microphone, you sing into it. And then the problem comes with, you know,

Well, now I need a backing track that I need to have music to accompany this. And it's like, well, I can reach out to my artist friends, ⁓ you know, who can I afford? Who can't I? Who wants to collaborate? And then once you get that done, mixing and mastering and then how do you publish a Spotify? How do you publish to SoundLon or whatever it is? So to answer your question in terms of, you know, this cohort specifically, we help those vocalists create that backing track very easily.

We help them mix and master the entire thing. We have tools in the backend that handle all of that. And we have the tools for exporting directly to Spotify, SoundOn, SoundCloud, et cetera, et right? Now, what is the next step to It's great that we can work with beats. And this is where we're going to go into AI attribution and how we're handling it. And I don't mind giving away that secret sauce.

think about what was said earlier on, right? Where somebody with a musical background can get better results from an a difference between having the system generate a stem with, I want ⁓ an Afrobeats backing track or give me melancholic jazz piano. And then there's a difference between putting in like, give me a pentatonic minor piano jazz and whatever, right?

we wanted to create an AI that really sort of responded to that need. A response to the need of somebody who understands the music that they're singing and wants to create the adequate backing track for it. And then the question on top of that, which we can get into afterwards is how do we do that ethically? How do you do that without scraping all of Spotify or Apple Music, stealing all of this information and then creating a model that kind of like generates this

The David Gilmour question

Jeremy Gilbertson Let me go back to your David Gilmour comment, because I want to, it's been stewing in the back of my brain a little the idea of making someone a David Gilmour,

Jeremy Gilbertson If we keep easy buttoning, our music theory people are just gonna kind of wean away how do you ease my mind with that?

A strong personal position

Nicholas Ponari So I'm going to take a very strong personal position on this podcast right now where I think human in the loop and human effort are paramount to all. And I think in the future, that easy button is going to be the big differentiator between someone who's legitimately impressive and someone who is not. you know, given that, so I'm almost 40. So I grew up in a world before all of this stuff, right? My, my guitar playing skills were built in the basement of my parents home with, you know, tens of hours a week building up the calluses and just going at it, right?

Jeremy Gilbertson TikTok, no YouTube to find the short circuit. It's like you really had to get to listen.

Nicholas Ponari Nothing, right? It was ultimate guitar and learning the guitar tabs. Like you start with that, right? there is a human satisfaction in actually picking up a I think a big fan, sorry, a person that I'm a big fan of actually is Lindsey Stirling. You know, she does the dancing, violin stuff. Like that's absurdly difficult. Like you don't just pick that, there's no easy button to learning how to do that.

Nicholas Ponari So to go back to your point, AI is not gonna make anybody David Gilmour. It's gonna be hours and hours and hours of practice with the guitar, fumbling, figuring out why your pinky is muting your sixth string and just getting frustrated over and over and then figuring out your hand positioning. It's going to be the hours of the mistakes and failures until you get to a point where you're actually good. Now, overtune is not that, okay?

We are a platform to help people unlock their creativity. And the way I've always seen it and the way I've always pitched it to investors is that one day somebody might outgrow Overtune. In which case, you know what? You wanna start hiring real producers, you wanna start getting real musicians. We congratulate you, we applaud you, you have graduated from us. Go on and do amazing, great things. We're proud of you, we love Go make your way. We see ourselves as the entry level, using AI to build the interest.

Jeremy Gilbertson that's awesome. Well, listen, I know a lot of people listening right now are probably going with that all sounds, that sounds great. I love that, that idea, but they're hearing about how AI and music, how things are being built and you referenced, you know, scraping and stealing and all of that stuff.

Jeremy Gilbertson I understand that your product, like your core product was actually trained on licensed music to start off with. Is that accurate? Can you talk us through it?

Taking a stance against Suno

Nicholas Ponari That's accurate, Yeah, so we took a hard stance against Suno and Yurio, especially as we were learning what they were I don't believe music is a one-shot creation process with a prompt. I downloaded it over last Christmas.

It was fun with my cousins and my sister where, know, hey, create a song about our grandfather who escaped Italy, came to Montreal and married somebody, whatever. And like, yeah, we're laughing, but the fun is over after a I thought it got boring fairly quickly. And it's because of that lack of human in the loop, right? Okay, so our model, our training model. Yes, we have around 20,000 loops all created by our in-house producers.

But we figured out a way that, you we think we wanna try to disrupt the industry in another way, where any producer who creates beats can submit their stems or their loop pack to our model. And it goes back to the mathematics of how these LMs work. And I'm gonna get a little bit technical here, but it's cause I want people to understand like, you know, that this stuff is not impossible, that we have the mechanics to do it.

Language converted into maths

Nicholas Ponari Language can be converted into math, which we call vectors using deep embedding once there's an output, you can match the output to the distance from the original vectors to figure out which vectors had the biggest impact on the output. The amazing thing is that with audio generating systems, the process is kind of very similar where all of the musical stems get converted into what we call audio latent vectors.

Now, when you ask it with a prompt and it converts everything into a waveform ultimately, and I can go into the details of that if you're interested, but I'll avoid it for now. But ultimately what can happen is that we can measure the distance between all of the origin vectors to the new song creation, figure out which artists contributed the most to it. Now I want you to imagine what that world looks like, right? Where let's say you really enjoy making Afrobeat soundtracks, right? And you're a producer who thinks, hey, in the future, Afrobeat is going to be really, really hot. So you can kind of get ahead of the curve and start submitting stuff to our model. And as more people are jumping on the trend, well, you have a new revenue stream for you, right? Where people are going to be using your stems and your chords for new generations. But here's where it gets even cooler. If we can match all of those artists to any songs that you're producing, imagine if we can say, hey, you've used many stems that were primarily influenced by this artist. Why don't you get in touch with them and do a collab? Since like your styles are so similar. Why don't you guys do a live event? And then we have like a live event platform that can get that set up. How do we, you know, take things from the music platform to the rest of the world? How do we really encourage what music is really meant to do? Bring people together, shared experiences and all that. So bring it into the live space, connecting artists together, creating new creations together.

How accurate is it?

Mark Fielding how accurate is that? So it.

Nicholas Ponari I would say there's no more accurate system in the entire world. We're talking about vector mathematics. We're able to ultra precisely to infinite flotation points know how close the origin is to a new generation. ⁓ the new Amen Break I don't have to worry about my work being ripped, stolen or used without my permission. And I can collect all the royalties from those number one hits which come. the beat maker.

Nicholas Ponari That's exactly right.

So if a generation is made up of primarily four artists, then if that song goes commercial, that slice of that stem in terms of the royalties, it's going to get divided by those four artists for that stem across all the stems that are used for the song in terms of like their time length and all that. So everything is measured again mathematically to ensure that proportionally everything is fairly distributed. But the answer is yes, everybody would get their fair, their fair remuneration for their work. Yes.

The thought experiment

Jeremy Gilbertson All right, so we're famous for silly thought experiments. So let's try to break this down a little bit. So the three of us are on your platform. I've got a bass line that I put out there. You've got a drum line that you put out there and Mark has this nice little vocal stem, so these things are kind of out there for people to use and come together. All right, so say there's a ⁓ fourth person.

that is out there kind of looking, right, I want to create this beat. So they grab my baseline, they grab your drum beat, they grab Mark's vocal stem, and they add a few other things to it they put out a song.

thing goes to distribution and it goes to Spotify and gets a million plays on Spotify. What does it look like for all four of us?

Nicholas Ponari So ultimately, okay, wait, let's just talk about like in the real world as well, right? I it's a funny thought experiment, but we all know Spotify pays very little. Okay.

Nicholas Ponari Yeah, okay, so I mean, because I want to make sure that the expectation is set correctly here, that from our perspective, The musician, let's say, you know, the total payout is 100 bucks, they'd probably get $50 and then the rest of the $50 would be divided between us three, right? So it's, you know, 10$, $12, $13, $14 dollars, whatever it may

The split sheet

Jeremy Gilbertson that split sheet automatically on the back end locked into that arrangement of pieces and parts?

Nicholas Ponari To be frank with you, it's something that we're still toying with. So even like I have numbers now, it's not going to be probably what it ends up being at the end. Right. But for this thought experiment, we're just going to go with easy numbers. But ultimately, for us three, it's a volume

Nicholas Ponari Just a million people using our music for their stuff. Suddenly we have ten dollars per, commercially available song. And suddenly it just starts trickling and then suddenly it's like a giant wave, depending on how good or how trending or whatever factors. The more people are using your stems, the more it's going to make you some money.

But ultimately that's what it's gonna come down to, So it's realistically a volume play.

The final automation of attribution

Jeremy Gilbertson what is the final automation of attribution?

Nicholas Ponari the prompt itself is going to dictate from which vectors it draws on. And typically it's going to find the middle of several that are similar. So in that respect, it's not going to just be my good, like in a world where, you know, this AI model just has our tracks, yes, but in the real world, it's actually closer to like, you know, dozens of contributing factors, But I also want you to imagine all of the infinite points in between all those vectors and the infinite arrangements of sounds you can get. So in one aspect, no one is going to get the same sound, which is kind of magical about it, right? But when we're talking about, the simplicity and distilling it to its vectors, it's because we're imagining sometimes a vector in 2D space, but the reality is that these vectors exist in like almost 8,000 So it's tracked across every type of property you can possibly imagine.

that being said, every generation is going to be different. The proportionality of it is going to change. There's always going to be one vector that's closest because you're going to say like, give me melancholic Afro beats with whatever it is. And there's going to be somebody out there And it's going to land closer to someone than someone else.

And then we sort of have to like cut it down where it's like, Hey, well, everybody between, you know, 70 and 90%, those are the secondaries in from 10 to a hundred. Like the, it's like gravity, right? Where Pluto exerts a gravitational force on the earth, but it's so small, you wouldn't really count it. Right. So like the last 10 % are influencing it a little bit, but not so much to the point where it makes a big impact. like in our model right now, those are cut off from the commercial attribution.

So it's really about crediting the primaries and secondaries first and then, cause you know, even like ⁓ a soulful jazz drum beat is going to have an impact on somebody asking for like a hardcore gangster rap song, right? So it's like, where do you make that cutoff? What's the thresholds? How do you make these decisions? And these are questions we tackle every day.

Jeremy Gilbertson you chop up the pie so much that it becomes really, so like you say, maybe it's going back to the volume play, like you said.

Nicholas Ponari Correct, yeah, and that's the only way like mathematically again, and I'm a math guy at origin, so that's why I talk about it a lot. It's the only way it can make sense. However, however, if you lower the barrier for entry downstream, the volume play can make sense. It just, have to have a tool that works so well and it's so easy to use that everybody just jumps on board. It really requires like you to catch lightning in a bottle twice, but no one said this was gonna be easy. So we're gonna go for

Can you backdate it?

Mark Fielding Is it possible to backdate this vector technology? Is it possible to solve the current problem of music being ripped and stolen to create

Do you see a way to solve for what's already happened

Nicholas Ponari I think that's more of a culture question in the United States than it is anything else. This culture in the States where, you know, let's break it first and then ask for permission later. ⁓ Uber did it. Airbnb did it. And, you know, these companies eventually go on to become like these mega unicorns, public companies and all that. Right. So I think like

I'm trying to figure out what to say because I don't want to throw any companies under the bus in a way that can put me in a weird position. ⁓ think that does the technology exist? Will it ever exist to solve for that problem?

No, what I honestly what I think has to happen is that they're going to have to rebuild their model from the ground up using new stems. and craft everything at the stem level. instead of like this one shot large generative model where you crunch all this data in one place and then, you know, hope for the best. My answer to that is no, I don't think there is an easy or elegant way to do it. I really think it requires a complete reconstruction of the technology to consider.

attribution to consider at the stem level to consider like all of the instruments that individually make up an entire song and then having that, you know, fit into like a four bar loop. ⁓ It's pretty complex and technical and these models are just not there yet.

Jeremy Gilbertson I use the analogy a couple of weeks ago is like trying to pull the drops of tea out or drops of cream after you put it in your tea and stirred up. It's really hard to unmix that stuff.

Nicholas Ponari Yeah, I would say it's impossible. Well, not impossible. Nothing's impossible. But yeah, it's exactly akin to that.

Jeremy Gilbertson What a research project that would be to get like a group of the, some of the smartest engineers, your music-based, focused engineers to see if that's possible to put the genie back in the bottle. Like that to me, that's a killer problem to try and solve. But it's like, like you said, man, it's like, holy smokes.

The numbers

Mark Fielding you give us any numbers? How many people are using it? What are your projections?

Nicholas Ponari Right now we have 300,000 downloads ⁓ between our web app and our Apple App Users recurring, it can fluctuate anywhere between, some months we're at 7K users, somewhere at 15. It often changes. We're trying to track where people are taking our music. Oftentimes people are going to output a song that they make in Overture and they're going to bring it to Audacity.

We have a pretty strong partnership with Audacity as well. But ultimately the projection is that, you know, we're working on building a more robust set of voice recording features. ⁓ We wanted to include some auto tune in there. The idea here is that, so by the way, quick addendum, before this, I had a video game studio where I was also the first video game programmer and the first game designer at that company. And I learned a lot about.

Mark Fielding You've been around Nicholas, it's an interesting backstory you've got there, medical, computer games, music.

Nicholas Ponari Yeah, yeah, and that could be an episode on its own actually, because that was a fascinating story. We were doing ⁓ athletic virtual reality. So games that, you know, force people to get up and move because I wanted people to stop being so lazy. ⁓ But the takeaway from the takeaway from that is that every time I design a product, I wanted to impart a feeling, which is what you get in game design. In game design, you always want somebody to come away with a feeling.

Mark Fielding That's another show.

Nicholas Ponari And the feeling that I want to impart to our Overtune product is that I want people to walk away saying, I can make music. So part of that is, know, our voice recording software having an auto tune feature where you can like auto tune your voice a little bit. But we want people to walk away saying, hey, that thing I made sounded really good and I'm really impressed with myself and I want to keep doing it.

Hyper personalised music

Jeremy Gilbertson All right. Let me throw this out there. I'm just going to, I'm just going to riff a little bit and I want you guys to react Imagine it's, let's just say it's like 2045. we're, moving in a direction where, all music is an interactive experience, right?

in part of that world, is there eventually gonna be something that is like our composer in a pocket that lets us, that basically scores our experience in the world?

Nicholas Ponari that already exists, by the way. I don't know if you've ever used Endel. Endel is like this procedurally generated music app and I was using it for my anxiety at some point and actually it worked very well. But on the paid tier of that, they have like this workout mode where the music was adjusting to the beat of my footsteps. So as I took a step, as I was walking to work,

Nicholas Ponari like from the metro to my office, ⁓ it would play the song in tune with my steps. And it felt like my life was being scored and like the music was being generated as I was walking. And I think I ran across the street to like catch it to not miss a yellow or red light. And like the pace picked up as I started running. It was really interesting. ⁓ To answer your question, no, I don't think that's gonna happen at all. I saw the future very, very differently.

And I'm going to iterate my vision through the story of my son. So my son right now is six years old. And I imagine when he's 17, right? Maybe one day he's gonna say, I wanna make a movie. And he's gonna go to a specialized LLM that's gonna generate a script. He's gonna, I want a script about a war in the afterlife with something or whatever, okay? And then he's gonna be able to input that script into a video generator.

It's like generate me a one hour and a half film in the style of Stanley Kubrick mixed with Quentin Tarantino and hit these plot points and here's the script and yada. And then he's going to have a movie, right? And then there's gonna be a button like publish this to Netflix, I'm trying to get across by this is that anybody and everybody will be able to be a content creator in any medium they want, whether it be music, video, ⁓ writing, literature, poetry, whatever it may be. What does that mean? It means that...

we are going to see a sur like this resurgence of content that we've never experienced before. It's going to be literally impossible for anybody to consume all the content that's going to be being produced by other humans. What does that mean? It means that nobody wants to consume all the content. People just want to watch and listen to stuff they like. So I imagine actually AI in the future being the largest curator of content that you can ever imagine, where, hey, you liked

A, B and C titles in Netflix, so you like A, B and C in music, well, here's the next 10 songs you should be listening to. And I think it's just going to be like everybody's just going to be continually fed content that is like really suited to their unique tastes. That's kind of how I saw it. I don't know, maybe you guys see it differently. I'd like to hear your takes.

A hellscape

Mark Fielding has painted a hellscape for me. the hyper personalisation of music, wherever you go, there's an AI in your pocket that is soundtracking your life for you, which means that everybody is walking around in their own hyper personalised musical bubble.

Hey, did you hear that new song? no, sorry you didn't because I'm nobody else in the universe has heard it except me. did you see that new movie? But no, sorry. I made it in my head. Nobody else has seen it except me. would be no shared culture. No music, no movies, no art, because everything is hyper-personalized. And in that world, like some people, kids, on the whole have terrible music taste, right?

But there's too many adults in the world who hold on to that.

bad taste into their adult life. So there are people who have no taste in music and they will listen to whatever the hell they're told to listen to. But thankfully that's a small minority what you describe is not happening, not on my watch, no way.

Jeremy Gilbertson Your parents thought Nirvana sucked.

Nicholas Ponari think both can exist. I think both can exist. And the reason for that is because it's going to actually solidify the importance of shared experiences. everybody can have their own hyper personal bubble of music while you're walking with your headphones, fair. In the world that I show that you can still share music because it's not being generated on the fly. However, is still a magic to the human experience of going to live music concerts.

Like you don't need hyper personalization to enjoy that experience. Actually, it's gonna make that experience much more valuable. And the artists who can do interesting things in that venue are gonna be the ones who are gonna be the superstars of the future. That applies to everything from film to retail. It's not gonna be good enough to just have a retail front. Yeah, here's my plant store. No, no, no, no, no. At this plant store, there's also classes where we teach you how to properly fertilize or repot a plant and...

You know, then we have like the plant meeting greets where you can like, hey, find, you know, your partner who's also interested in plants or it could be that for video games or it's not just a video game store where you buy video games. You also compete and there's contests and prizes so on and so forth. Everything is going to be based on experiences like the days of a brick and mortar store just being a place where you go and buy something and pay for it and leave. That's going to be gone at least in like at 2045.

In 2040

Jeremy Gilbertson What if, all right, so Mark, Nicholas and I say in 2040, Hey Mark, come see a show. There's this, this, uh, creator. We're to call them a creator. We're not going to call them a musician for, for reasons while I'll say in a minute. So it's a creators on stage picture minority report, you know, Tom Cruise throwing things around like this and there's audio output of

What is your reaction seeing someone up there doing this, moving things around that's an AI, that's basically directing an AI model versus what we know as playing music right now? How do you feel about that?

Mark Fielding You just described an AI, Jean-Michel Jarre. I don't totally understand the question. would I be hearing the same thing as everybody else in the venue?

Mark Fielding would I go and listen to AI generated music? I think that's really the heart of your question. And my answer to that is the same as would I read an AI generated book? Would I watch an AI generated movie? Would I go to a museum and look at AI generated art on the wall?

My initial answer is no, I need to see the struggle. I need to have seen the pain. I need to have seen the joy and the love that went into that.

Jeremy Gilbertson There's a human doing it though. There's a human.

Mark Fielding no, I wouldn't come with you. I'd stay at home and I'd listen to Dark Side of the Moon.

Nicholas Ponari Always a good choice. ⁓

Jeremy Gilbertson You have some thoughts,

DJ Dave

Nicholas Ponari I do. Okay, before I start this, to properly contextualize this, have any of you ever heard of DJ Dave?

Nicholas Ponari DJ Dave is an American based DJ who produces her beats live on set while live coding them. Like she vibe codes the beats live. Check her out. It's called, actually it's creating a new genre of show called an algo rave. So live, as you're there, as everybody is dancing to the music, she's programming beats.

Nicholas Ponari And she's using mathematics to generate like an algorithmic EDM rave type beat. And it's awesome. So people like her shows are already selling out. She is going to have two shows in LA. I wanted to go. That's why I'm following her. I I won't be in LA during that time, but I would absolutely go to experience a live because like there's no set. She doesn't know what she's going to do. It's going to be based on the feeling of the room.

And I imagine like of the two shows, both are going to be entirely unique based on what the crowd is like, how the crowd is vibing. So that's the first step to your question, because maybe one day it's going to be AI generated and they're going to just be prompting it as it goes. it's like, this is an indication that there is an appetite for that kind of thing.

Mark Fielding What Nicholas has described isn't too different from house music and the rave movement of the 90s and every DJ now who will change what they play based on the feeling of the room.

Nicholas Ponari She's mathematically coding it.

mathematically coding it. Yeah, she's vibe coding the music.

Nicholas Ponari to see you have to watch your videos is she's ridiculous.

Mark Fielding the wrong town, Nicholas. I need to move to a place where these things happen because where I live, there was nobody vibe coding the music scene where I live.

Jeremy Gilbertson DJ Dave? All right, she needs to come on the show. Awesome, well let's land the plane. This has been fun, but Mark, I know you gotta roll.

Nicholas Ponari DJ Dave, check her out. It's gonna blow your mind.

The Kevin Kelly question

Mark Fielding end every show, Nicholas, with the same question from the Wired founder, Kevin Kelly. What do we want humans to be and how does technology help us get there?

Nicholas Ponari We want everybody to experience the totality of this very beautiful human experience. And I mean the totality of it. It means everything from love to heartbreak, creation, failure and success, ⁓ relationships, solitude, and everything, you know, we have to offer each other everything, like I said, from dance to music to film to literature to poetry. ⁓

The world is an incredibly large and beautiful place. And the amazing thing about it all is that this life gives us enough time to actually experience it all. ⁓ Not of course, all the content, but we get to experience all those aspects of it. And if technology can serve to connect us to these experiences and help us get through experiencing them and documenting them and, you know, allowing us to look back on all of that. And then at the end of your life, you can look back on a life well lived, you know.

And I think ultimately that's the real objective of technology to help us just get more out of everything. That's how I see it and that's how I live my life. And that's how I kind of want everybody to live their own life. That this life is a beautiful thing and we have one shot at it and to just get the most out of it.

Jeremy Gilbertson Wise words, friends and neighbors. I ⁓ would agree with everything you just said. That's amazing. the work you're doing is actually doing that as well, which is super cool. So thanks for joining us. Keep us posted on how you guys are evolving. Keep us posted on this Roblox experience you guys got coming up. And maybe we'll have you back on down the road.

Nicholas Ponari Pleasure was all mine. Thank you for the time.

Mark Fielding Brilliant. Turn it up to 11, Jeremy. Turn it up to 11. World needs a soundtrack that we can share.

Jeremy Gilbertson Sounds like a plan.

Mark Fielding keep thinking on paper.