Who Owns the Data That Moves the Supply Chain?
Todd Haselhorst's company, Heale, rewards freight carriers with a token for sharing the shipment data they usually keep to themselves.
In this episode · 9 chapters
And currently the data is available to be able to provide that level of transparency, but carriers don’t want to share it because then there’s a likelihood of a shipper calling them every 30 minutes saying, hey, I saw the truck turn towards Mexico. What’s going on?
Todd Haselhorst grew up around warehouses and freight brokers, then studied economics and game theory. His company targets the middle mile, the city-to-city freight that he says is still fragmented because most of it runs on small fleets.
He explains how Heale unifies shipment data into one record, rewards carriers with a token for sharing it, and uses zero-knowledge proofs so competitors never see each other's data. He also sets out the network plan, borrowed from the L1s and L2s.
Todd Haselhorst, CEO and founder of Heale, tells the Thinking On Paper podcast that the middle mile of logistics is “still a complete mess” because freight carriers keep shipment data in separate systems and have no reason to share it. Heale uses blockchain to tokenise that supply chain data into one master record per shipment, and rewards carriers with a token for sharing it.
Who owns the data that moves the supply chain?
Todd Haselhorst says freight carriers keep shipment data in separate systems and have no reason to share it. Heale tokenises that data into one master record per shipment and rewards carriers for sharing it.
Why is the middle mile of logistics so fragmented?
The middle mile, moving goods from city to city by truckload, less-than-truckload or ocean freight, is highly fragmented because 80% of the industry is small owner-operators running one to five trucks, Haselhorst says. FedEx, UPS and DHL all rely on networks of these independent contractors, he says, and Heale's own calculation puts errors, theft, fraud and waste in the industry at 268 billion.
Why do freight carriers avoid sharing their data?
Logistics has “a bit of a perverse incentive”, Haselhorst says: the market rewards obfuscation rather than transparency. Shippers want to see their freight, but carriers treat their data as a competitive moat, an advantage rivals cannot copy, because competitors could use their pricing to undercut them. Carriers often switch off live tracking feeds that already exist.
What shipment data matters before, during and after transit?
Haselhorst splits a shipment's data into pre-transit, in-transit and post-transit. Pricing matters before transit, when carriers compete for the load. Location data in transit lets the receiving shipper prepare its docks, which also helps carriers, who otherwise burn drivable hours waiting to unload.
Why not use Web2 for a single source of shipment data?
A single source of truth for shipment data, one shared record every party trusts, could be built with Web2 technology, Haselhorst says, but that creates a trusted third party holding “a lot of data and that's a lot of power”. Heale's pitch to the industry is that each firm keeps ownership and control of its data, which is encrypted end to end.
Does Heale ask carriers to change how they work?
Heale does not ask carriers to change how they work, Haselhorst says. It partners with technology providers and plugs into the transportation management systems (TMS) that freight companies already use, adding a common data layer between them. He argues that firms that solve coordination this way will be more efficient than those that do not.
Where Jeremy and Haselhorst disagree
Jeremy plays a carrier with about five trucks who is nervous that a competitor on the network, Mark, could see his costs and routes. Haselhorst replies that “your data is your data”: it stays obfuscated until its owner grants permission, and Heale uses zero-knowledge proofs, a way to prove a fact without revealing the data behind it, so a rival sees nothing unless the two firms do business together.
Links from this episode
Questions
Who owns the data that moves the supply chain?
Todd Haselhorst says freight carriers keep shipment data in separate systems and have no reason to share it. Heale tokenises that data into one master record per shipment and rewards carriers for sharing it.
Who is Todd Haselhorst?
Todd Haselhorst, CEO and founder of Heale, tells the Thinking On Paper podcast that the middle mile of logistics is “still a complete mess” because freight carriers keep shipment data in separate systems and have no reason to share it.
What does Heale do?
Heale uses blockchain to tokenise that supply chain data into one master record per shipment, and rewards carriers with a token for sharing it.
How much do errors, theft and fraud cost the freight industry?
FedEx, UPS and DHL all rely on networks of these independent contractors, he says, and Heale's own calculation puts errors, theft, fraud and waste in the industry at 268 billion.
Transcript
Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds. Welcome to another amazing episode of Thinking on Paper. My name's Jeremy, this is Mark. It's the best day of the week. It's Thursday, it's 1030 Eastern. We get to unpack the intersection between culture and emerging tech with the founders. These guys are actually defining new ways we're gonna be doing things in the future. I'm super excited to be here.
Mark Fielding Mark is fresh off of quantum computing panels at Vivatech. Mark, tell me about your experience there real quick before we jump in. Before that though, I'm gonna stick on this one because the global logistics business is worth trillions. I think eight or nine, 10 trillion, who knows? I think that if, unless you live off the grid in North Wales or you're one of the few communities in the world that's not connected, it impacts your life.
Everything gets delivered, freight, shipping. It touches everything that we experience in our lives. And to speak to Todd today about how technology is gonna change that, I'm very excited about it. And as for a question on Paris, it was awesome. And I got some very good quantum guests lined up for our quantum season, but let's not get ahead of ourselves. I love it, I love it. Well, glad you're back.
Jeremy Gilbertson And yeah, this is a really interesting topic. Just basically that this is how things are coordinated, right? How things are coordinated and organized and there are better ways to do things by getting people within the ecosystem that you're trying to organize to add value to that ecosystem. And you can actually reward them for adding value to that ecosystem. So I think that's the conversation that we're gonna have today.
First of all, thanks to our amazing friends at Ripple, W-R-I-P-P-L-E. Ripple is Marketing's on-demand talent platform. So Ray Samuels and the crew over there have been amazing supporters of our show for a really long time. They do great things in organizing interdisciplinary talent and point them to your projects, whether it's a year long, whether it's two years, whether it's three weeks, whether it's four disciplines or one discipline, they're amazing.
Please check them out. And yeah, W-R-I-P-P-L-E. Without further ado, Mark, let's bring on our guests to give you a little intro and we'll pop them on the screen. Yeah, welcome to the show. Todd Halehurst is the CEO and founder of HEAL, the Unified API for
Mark Fielding Logistics platform. Welcome to the show, Todd. It's great to have you here. And we're gonna get into you and HEAL and we're gonna unpack all of that great stuff. But I'm thinking on paper, we like to thread our episodes together, don't we, Jeremy? So we're gonna start with the last question from the last show, which was posed to you by the CEO of Stepin. So that's what we do.
Todd Haselhorst So everyone leaves a question for the next guest. And her question for you, before we get into Todd and HEAL, is how do we bring more people into Web3? What's the secret magic ingredient that we're missing to get more people to look at the space? Yeah, great question. So thank you guys for having me. Pleasure to be here. Really, I think the best way to get more users into the space is ultimately to create usable applications and usable technology.
Jeremy Gilbertson And we gotta meet them where they're at, right? So we gotta create applications that are easy for them to use, that looks and feels a lot like what they're used to today. Indeed. Case in point, Todd and I just shared an analogy that both of us tend to use that is email. People don't care about the behind the scenes stuff, how the tech works, how it all works. We can type in a message and press send and it goes from Atlanta to Iceland.
It's amazing. So we need to get in that mindset, I think. One other thing I want to add too, we were talking about for my friends listening from Simsbury, Connecticut. Todd is Todd's first name and his company's name is HEALY. And Simsbury friends, if you remember Todd HEALY was the leader of a band called Uncle Gabe in Connecticut that were studs. So off we go in serendipity land. Todd, how did you get into this world of logistics and try to reinvent it?
Todd Haselhorst Like where did all this, where did these paths cross and how'd you get started? Yeah, so actually my whole life has been in and around logistics. My dad worked at a warehouse on a dock, loading and unloading trucks, receiving shipments. My best friend's dad growing up was a freight broker. So I've always been in and around the space. And then when I got to college, my first job was with the moving company and ended up getting a degree in economics and game theory.
Where it started
Todd Haselhorst Left college, helped the friends start a freight brokerage, got back into the moving space on the brokerage side and then got into the technology space in 2011. And at that same time, I was looking at Bitcoin. At the time it was Bitcoin, Litecoin and Purecoin were number one, two and three. So those paths kind of diverged at the same time with my interest in technology. Purecoin, wow. Purecoin, that way back in the day, this was before Ethereum. Amazing. You had me at game theory, Todd.
Yes. Talk to me about how that sparked your curiosity and how that folds into what you're doing. Is that going to be carryover or was that just an interest that you landed on? Well, could we even maybe have a brief explanation of game theory for our non-game theorists? Sure. I would say game theory is kind of a broad category, but I would say it's the science of decision- making and creating games that optimize for the best outcome.
Jeremy Gilbertson In the context of this, that's how I see the world. I see the world through the lens of how do we optimize for the best outcome? And how do we solve against the worst outcome? So it's, yeah, games are experiences, right? These experiences turn into how people interface with products and systems and all of that kind of stuff. So that probably fed into how you're building this or how you built this wonderful product.
So let's root in, since your history is deep in logistics and that sort of thing, what's the current state of the industry right now? I mean, we're in a situation where I can pull up my iPhone and order something and it basically gets to me before I ordered it, right? So what are we seeing? What's the current state right now? What's important to the people that are doing the shipping?
Todd Haselhorst What's important to the people that are doing the buying? Yeah, so when people think of shipping, they mostly think of parcel and they think of, hey, I go to Amazon and I click a button and within a couple hours, my thing is delivered to my doorstep. And that's the last mile piece. So in the last 10 years, the industry has done two things. Primarily, it's undergone a technology revolution from one perspective.
The middle mile
Todd Haselhorst And then from another perspective, that last mile piece has really gotten solidified and optimized to where now you can get a package in a couple hours. So Amazon has really done a great job of really optimizing that last mile pickup and delivery piece. There's been a lot of work that's been done on the fulfillment side, last mile pickup and delivery, but really the middle mile is still a complete mess.
And when I say a middle mile, what I'm referring to is that if you think about, you have last mile, so you have all these distribution centers in these cities, goods will move into these distribution centers and they'll pick and pack from these centers to be able to have them delivered to your house within a couple hours. So middle mile is going from city to city, it could be a truckload, it could be less than truckload, it could be ocean, it could be maritime.
So that component is still highly fragmented and part of the reason for that fragmentation is because 80% of the industry is small fleet owner operators, one to five trucks. So behind the scenes, FedEx, UPS, DHL, they all use a network of independent contractors and owner operators to do all the middle mile shipping. So what we're primarily focused on at Healey is creating a data management platform that connects all those different systems together that those companies use to unify that into a single format and then tokenize that data to create a master record.
So no matter how many parties or who is interacting with a particular shipment, everybody's using the same information and on the same page and therefore solving the coordination issue that exists. Again, primarily at that middle mile layer.
Is there a consensus?
Todd Haselhorst Is there a general consensus on this is the root issue and this is the root problem? So you mentioned this kind of hierarchy of companies where you need the big global companies to work with the smaller fleets of five trucks. Is everyone on the same page? Is everyone open to this particular solution? Yeah, so there's a general consensus in logistics that data is a big problem and the data is siloed in all these different systems.
And there's a bit of a perverse incentive where currently the market rewards obfuscation or at the very least, it doesn't reward transparency. So on one side, you have the shippers that are trying to push for transparency and they're saying, hey, we want transparency into what's going on with our shipments. And on the other end, there's no clear incentive for carriers to provide the transparency that they want.
In addition to that, without the use of decentralized technology, carriers are losing control of their data, they're losing ownership of their data. And for them, that's a big competitive moat because that's how they operate. That's the lifeblood of their business. And so they don't wanna disclose this information for no reason. So with Healey, we're rewarding them for providing that data, for being transparent and doing so in a way where they don't lose ownership and control of that data.
And in addition to that, the network will provide them with additional means of monetizing that data, which I think the hope and promise of Web3. Could we unpack a little bit more about why someone wouldn't wanna provide that data? Yeah, so it's a very competitive industry and they don't want their competitors knowing how they're pricing because then people can undercut and undercut and undercut.
Mark Fielding So, I mean, that's the primary reason that they don't wanna, they're reluctant to share that data. So is it the data? Sorry, Mark, go ahead. Sorry, no, like the data is valuable. So in order to remove that friction, you need to make something that's more valuable than the value of the data. They're a nice game theory, right? So you have to make the- I'm a poker player, that's where my game theory stops.
Changing the economics
Todd Haselhorst You have to change the economics to make it more rewarding or incentivize them to share the data because if they're making more money by sharing the data and being transparent, they're going to do so. And also be able to maintain their competitive advantage within a broader network without exposing that data to their competitors or others who could use it against them. So I understand the data in like, so if Mark ships something and I'm the guy- It's like pineapples, I'm shipping pineapples.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, yeah, we'll unpack that choice in a minute. That's very interesting. But all right, so Mark ships, I buy pineapples from Mark and Todd is the guy in the middle that's going to somehow get the pineapples from Mark to me. The valuable information for me and Mark is where are the pineapples after they leave Mark's warehouse and before they get to my spot? The pricing information necessarily isn't important to me.
Todd Haselhorst Well, when I buy it, but like to the network, it doesn't seem to be as important. How does the cost of shipping, how does that data come into play? Yeah, so there's three primary components. You have pre-transit, in-transit, and post-transit. So in pre-transit, pricing is a key component because carriers are competing to try to get that business, right? So that happens at the front end. And then in transit, then you want to know where your shipment's at.
And currently the data is available to be able to provide that level of transparency, but carriers don't want to share it because then there's a likelihood of a shipper calling them every 30 minutes saying, hey, I saw the truck turn towards Mexico. What's going on? Is my shipment being stolen? Is it going out of the country? It opens up things like that. A lot of times, it's non-linear in how a shipment is actually moved from one place to another.
And if you're not experienced with it, you may not know. But that data is valuable to the shipper because on the other side, they're looking at that saying, I have to prepare my docks in order to receive this shipment in a timely fashion, which also helps the carrier, right? Because they're not sitting there, if the dock is poorly managed, they're not sitting there waiting, or sorry, if it's poorly managed, they're sitting there waiting, spending drivable hours to try to get that shipment unloaded from their truck.
What the data does
Todd Haselhorst And so that data is available. For us, we want to incentivize that with the use of our reward token to be able to generate that data and share that data to provide them with an additional stream of revenue, ultimately, make it more valuable to share that data, despite additional headaches it may create from a certain perspective. So a lot of times what will happen right now is that the feed is available, but the driver or the carrier will shut it down and not expose access to it.
Mark Fielding And then they'll manage everything through phone calls, emails, and texts. That makes sense. So like, yeah, so they think of it as giving away their secret sauce a little bit, where by giving away a little bit of that sauce, the whole system becomes better. Yeah, exactly. And that's, I mentioned, I actually shipping pineapples, Jeremy, because I was actually, I was in the supermarket just a couple of days ago and I bought a pineapple.
And my wife says, you probably shouldn't be in pineapples up a mountain in the beginning of spring. But I was like, it was amazing. And I always think, how did this get here so quickly? Like how many steps were involved? And then before the show, I mean, I don't know anything about logistics and this is fascinating for me to hear this, but how much waste, how many wasted hours, how many wasted trips, how many wasted man hours will this save?
The waste
Todd Haselhorst I mean, I can't imagine how much waste there is in the global shipping and freight industry. It's almost as mind boggling as eating a pineapple in the mountains in winter. Yeah. Yeah, so when we ran our calculations, we looked at all the different components. We calculated 268 billion of errors, theft, fraud and waste, which are the primary, those are the four primary things that our network solves for.
But there's other calculations out there that's as high as 600 billion. So it's a huge problem that everybody has all around the world. And that's not even accounting for waste from the perspective of this shipment, these apples went bad, or that's not even accounting for situations like that where food goes bad or spoils in transit. On that, I was speaking to someone who runs a company in France who was trying to solve or trying to help with the food waste.
And just in France, it was like 14 billion euros per year is wasted on restaurant food waste alone. And like anything that can make that system run smoother, it is literally cultural defining. It changes everything. Yeah. Yeah, fundamentally, we don't have a resource problem. We have a resource allocation problem and it's very inefficient to get the resources into the hands of the right people when they need it.
Jeremy Gilbertson And so I would say that most of our problems could be solved by better systems for resource management and allocation. So a lot of decisions to participate in a network or an ecosystem are based on trust, right? It's a human factor and that extends through business and all of that, obviously. So I think of it, I love the idea of this unified API. It makes a ton of sense, rewarding and incentivizing people as well.
Building trust with big entities
Todd Haselhorst How do you build trust with these big entities and these small entities to kind of say, hey, I'm going to do all of this stuff right. Here's how we do it. Yeah, we shift the narrative from I to we, right? Because this is an open ecosystem and it's something that we collectively are doing together. So if you look at the problem, the problem of data and creating a single source of truth, you could do that with web two technology.
The problem that you run into is now you create a third party that is a trusted entity. And number one, that's a lot of data and that's a lot of power. And so people are reluctant to share and put their data into technology where they'll lose control or they'll lose ownership of their data because then it can be used, sold, monetized, used against them. There's all sorts of things that can happen with that data.
So when we talk to the people in the industry, we talk about community, we talk about open, we talk about decentralized, we talk about these things that there's a lot of education involved in because it's outside the scope of what they're currently used to. But boiling it down to say, look, you maintain control of your data, you maintain ownership of your data.
It's actually more secure because it's encrypted end to end and it accomplishes, it solves a lot of your coordination issues and provides you with rewards for, you and the counterparty in the transaction rewards for things that are ultimately beneficial to streamlining that shipment and also streamlining the settlement process that happens in that post-transit phase, which is good for everyone, right? Totally agree, so super interesting. So here's my, I always go to like, my brain always tries to get to practical examples.
Mark is not the shipper
Jeremy Gilbertson So let's go back. Mark is not the shipper of pineapples. Mark and Jeremy both have two businesses. We're kind of middle to last mile kind of coordinators. I've got a fleet of about five trucks. Mark's got six wagons that he pedals behind mountain bikes. And we're part of this network and I'm intrigued. I ran across you, Todd, and I'm like, man, if I give my data into this network, it'll help me become more efficient.
And I also get some reward for that. But I'm a little nervous because Mark's my competitor. And like, what if he sees what my costs are, what my routes are, what my, Todd, how do you help me get my head around that? Yeah, so your data is your data and the data is obfuscated until you provide someone permission to access your data. So there's no scenario in which Mark can see your data or he could see your data or vice versa.
Todd Haselhorst You could see his data, right? Unless you were going to do business together, then you could share your data with him and you could share specific data with him relating to the transactions. So we use zero-knowledge proofs to make sure. Mark is a ZK dude. Oh, no, I'm not a ZK. We had the founder of ZK Link on a couple of weeks ago and he was, we're kind of fascinated by what ZK knowledge can, zero-knowledge can do.
Jeremy Gilbertson Sorry, I interrupted you. I'm very excited. Sorry, go ahead. That's a perfect scenario, right? That's the scenario that this technology can really solve. I think it's a key use case for that. It's actually pretty amazing. So I'm thinking with my, I'm just a shipper. I'm a guy that just puts stuff on trucks and gets it from one point to another, giving back to our practical example.
Todd Haselhorst And so what you're saying, Todd, my data is used to make the overall system better, fed into creating knowledge in the overall system, but Mark doesn't necessarily see the granularity of how I do my business. Yeah, exactly. Unless Mark gets your private keys or you share the data with him, then, or you share the data with him directly, then he doesn't get access to your data. It's in the messaging, it's in the storytelling because I think, and perhaps shipping and freight is old school.
Mark Fielding I don't know if that's the right description for it, but the people who run these companies are, they're a bit thinking on paper. They're old school. They use ledgers, they use pens, they use pencils, they use paper, they share notes. And maybe the storytelling narrative part of that to encourage them that they don't, that they can leave these things behind and try a new system, which will eventually make them more profitable is the way to really change opinions on.
Todd Haselhorst Are they fearful of tech then? Is there fear in, are you meeting fear? So we're partnering with technology providers in this space primarily and plugging into the transportation management systems that these companies use already. So for them, they're not, they don't really have to overhaul or change any of their operations or their business. They're just, we're just plugging into their existing technology and creating a common layer between, common data layer between their technology and who they use and all the other technologies that are out there.
Jeremy Gilbertson Pretty tight. I think it's super compelling. So, all right. So let's say we get, this system gets rocking and rolling. The middle layer folks are figuring stuff out. What's the grand goal? I mean, are we knocking on like FedEx and UPS and kind of saying, hey guys, I got this. It's more than a risk. Is it, are we knocking on that door? Yeah, right. Like where are we pointing? Like a few years down the road, if all goes well.
The same playbook
Todd Haselhorst Yeah, so really we're running the same playbook that all the L1s and L2s are running, which is that we're building out this network, that we're building out this ecosystem. We're setting aside funds for application development, for integrations, for mergers and acquisitions and things that will ultimately, will ultimately increase transaction volume on the network and attract new shippers, freight brokers and forwarders and carriers to the network.
So our end game is really just to provide this network, this open ecosystem for people to integrate their existing applications or build new applications on top of this common data infrastructure for logistics. And so that's our main focus. And whoever wants to plug in and play and build applications and integrate, then happy to have them on the network. And what you're delivering with this open AI is great because it's demonstrating, you know, hey, we're a community.
We're not trying to be this new walled off siloed solution that requires paid access. And you can only jump in if you give us a hundred dollars a month kind of thing. It's more of a, you know, hey, let's open this thing up. What are you hearing from the market? What are you hearing from people when they get some value back in return for helping out with some information? Yeah, so it's primarily an education process for us because it's very new and it's very novel and something that, you know, you're explaining things that have never been possible in logistics.
And so there's a bit of an education process involved, but pretty much everybody we've talked to, they want to be a part of it. It's just a matter of figuring out how they can be a part of figuring out timing. But to a large extent, it's an education process and podcasts like this help us create the content, provide the material that we can then share with other people and help bring them up to speed and get their minds thinking about, okay, what can I do with this technology?
Mark Fielding How can I improve my business? How can I be a better community member? How can I contribute? And how can we build this deep-end logistics network? Okay, now it's my turn, Jeremy. So I'm not getting involved in this. You and Todd, you are both using Healey. You've incorporated this system into your existing tech stack. I've refused for whatever reason. I'm a family-run business.
Todd Haselhorst I don't know, I've got 20 trucks, but what would I see happening between you two that I wouldn't have access to? And can the system get better with just a few points using this tech? Like what happens to the surrounding logistics ecosystem that's not using the API? Yeah, so if you think about it, we're solving the coordination issue. So the coordination issue, those who solve the coordination issue will be more efficient than those who have not solved the coordination issue.
So there's an incentive there for them to solve the coordination issue by joining the network. In addition to that, you're also getting rewards from the network for being on the network. So now you're more profitable, which means that you can either lower your prices and be more competitive if you want, or you're just making more money being more profitable and you can grow and expand your business and take up more and more of the market share. So just like any technology, those who adopt efficiencies are going to be more competitive and therefore will get a larger piece of the market. Yeah, so I think within the network.




