Can Blockchain Bring Trust Back to Journalism?

Ciaran Murray says about 90% of what his publishing platform uses is other people's inventions, just as Satoshi built Bitcoin from parts that already existed.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 10 chapters

  1. Spam folders
  2. Decentralised identity
  3. The more money you have
  4. Say Mark and I
  5. The fact checking bounty
  6. Native review protocols
  7. Wikipedia
  8. A societal need
  9. Segmentation of identity
  10. The biggest challenges
You always have to challenge yourself and check yourself before you press publish on this protocol because otherwise you won’t get paid.
Ciaran Murray

Ciaran Murray founded Olas, a long-form publishing platform where the crowd funds writers and checks their work. He explains quadratic funding, and how a writer who stakes money on an article funds a bounty for fact checkers who find errors.

Murray also covers why users must regularly prove they are a unique human, how a pseudonym could let a writer publish an unpopular insight, and why he calls the revenue model the big unknown. His bet is tipping as easy as a like.

Ciaran Murray, founder and CEO of Olas, describes on the Thinking On Paper podcast a blockchain-based publishing platform for trustworthy long-form journalism and research. Olas replaces editorial and peer review with open, decentralised fact-checking, and funds writers through quadratic funding and reader tips, in a bid to bring trust back to journalism.

Can blockchain bring trust back to journalism?

Ciaran Murray is betting that it can. Olas is a blockchain-based publishing platform that replaces editorial and peer review with open, decentralised fact-checking, and funds writers through quadratic funding and reader tips.

Which existing inventions does Olas combine?

Murray says “90% of the stuff we're using is other people's inventions”, combined in the way Satoshi built Bitcoin from existing parts such as proof of work, which he says was invented as an anti-spam email mechanism. The parts Olas uses include decentralised identity, blockchains, quadratic funding, prediction markets and oracles.

What is quadratic funding?

Quadratic funding, Murray says, is “a halfway point between markets and democracy”: each extra dollar spent to sway the outcome costs more, so a writer backed by 10 donors draws far more from Olas's institution-funded matching pool than one backed by a single donor giving the same total.

How does decentralised fact-checking work on Olas?

Olas replaces editorial and peer review with “native decentralized review protocols”. In Murray's example a writer stakes $50 on an article and 20% goes to a bounty for fact checkers; if they find errors, a judging panel drawn half from writers in that specialty and half open rules, and a bad article costs the writer the stake and reputation score.

How do writers earn money on Olas?

Murray says writers keep about 90% of reader tips, with “no Rupert Murdoch or Bloomberg” taking a cut. He names the revenue model as Olas's biggest risk: token issuance subsidises journalism and academic research for three years, after which Olas bets readers will tip, for example 50 cents for a good article.

How does Olas treat AI-assisted articles and Sybil attacks?

Olas judges content on accuracy alone, so AI-assisted articles are paid if correct; Murray says “we're just concerned with accuracy and truth”. To stop Sybil attacks, which he describes as someone setting up multiple accounts or bot accounts, Olas plans a proof of unique human check roughly every two weeks.

Where Mark and Murray disagree

Mark asks whether quadratic funding becomes a popularity contest, since well-known writers can find 10 funders and unknown ones cannot. Murray concedes “there isn't an initial protection, but there should be one ongoing”, as reputation scores from fact-checking feed into later funding rounds.

Questions

Can blockchain bring trust back to journalism?

Ciaran Murray is betting that it can. Olas is a blockchain-based publishing platform that replaces editorial and peer review with open, decentralised fact-checking, and funds writers through quadratic funding and reader tips.

Who is Ciaran Murray?

Ciaran Murray founded Olas, a long-form publishing platform where the crowd funds writers and checks their work.

What is Olas?

Ciaran Murray, founder and CEO of Olas, describes on the Thinking On Paper podcast a blockchain-based publishing platform for trustworthy long-form journalism and research.

How does Olas try to rebuild trust in journalism?

Olas replaces editorial and peer review with open, decentralised fact-checking, and funds writers through quadratic funding and reader tips, in a bid to bring trust back to journalism.

Transcript

Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds. Welcome to another episode of Thinking on Paper. My name is Jeremy. This is Mark. We get to talk with the founders and thinkers and strategists that are building the new version of the world that we will eventually participate in. We're super excited to talk to this guest today about kind of something called decentralized knowledge, which just to me sounds super fascinating.

Mark Fielding Mark, how are things in your world, man? Very often, my knowledge feels like it's a bit decentralized from my brain. I'm doing great. Had some great feedback on Thinking on Paper this week. So Robin Bennett, if you're listening, thank you for your awesome feedback saying that Thinking on Paper was helping her to acclimatize to Web 3.0. So that's kind of what we're trying to do.

So awesome news. And yeah, very looking forward to kind of building on that with today's show. And I think this is one of those conversations, decentralized news, fake news, deep fakes, where it's important. This is world-changing potentially, isn't it? So looking forward to getting into it. Well, the whole thing, there's a common thread between all of these discussions that we have is trust, right?

Jeremy Gilbertson And how do you trust the sources that you lean on for information, right? And the human brain loves shortcuts, right? And we like to build those trust paths quickly. And sometimes they're right, sometimes they're wrong, and it's hard to change them once we pick them, right? So let's jump right in. Definitely want to thank our amazing sponsors, Ripple, W-R-I-P-P-L-E. They are marketing's on-demand talent platform.

So if you've got a project that needs some creative energy, some building energy to point towards, whether it's a week long or a year long, they are great at building interdisciplinary teams, managing those teams through the process, over 3,000 vetted solopreneurs with different specialties that they're able to coordinate in real time. So they're amazing. Check them out. If you need help, we all need help.

Mark Fielding W-R-I-P-P-L-E.com. Mark, let's intro our guest and dive headfirst into this topic. I will just add to the sponsor. We're looking for a sponsor for season three, by the way, if you want to get involved, if you're thinking on paper, contact us, yeah, without further ado. Our guest today is Ciaran Murray, founder and CEO of Olas Protocol. He's a seasoned veteran of the blockchain space, been in web three for a long time and looking forward to seeing how he is going to instill trust back into our media landscape, our increasingly fractured media landscape as well.

Jeremy Gilbertson So welcome to the show, Ciaran. Hi guys. Thanks a lot. Thanks for having me. Wonderful, man. We appreciate you being here. Look forward to diving in. Let's start with our carryover question. We always like to thread the discussion, the conversation between these episodes. And from our last episode, Marcina left us a question of what is your take on how emerging technologies work or don't work together and what could they achieve when they do, so like the intersection, the confluence of all of these technologies.

Ciaran Murray What are the most interesting to you and what do you think are the ones that are most promising? Okay. I guess like a lot of these things are built or invented for one reason, but when you stitch them together, they can actually create something new. And that's one of the interesting things about Bitcoin. Satoshi didn't actually invent anything new. Proof of work was invented as an anti-spam email mechanism.

Spam folders

Ciaran Murray Now we ended up settling on spam folders instead and people filtering those messages into where we didn't want them. But that was built for one thing. There was all other aspects of Bitcoin that were built for various things. It was nothing to do with money. And Satoshi just happened to be abreast all of these technologies and put them together to create something new without actually inventing something himself, which is very interesting.

And weirdly enough at Olas, we're pretty much doing the same thing. I'd say 90% of the stuff we're using is other people's inventions. We've come up with a few novel things ourselves. But most of our work was actually just having the vision to put these things together to solve a huge problem we saw. I didn't know that about which of those technologies that, well, yeah, I didn't know about the email thing, but which of the technologies that you're using, which already exists?

Decentralised identity

Jeremy Gilbertson Decentralized identity for one, blockchains for two, quadratic funding for three, prediction markets for four, except we've kind of tweaked them there to kind of novel parts of our system. Oracles would be another. Pretty much everything we're using is other people's inventions. We know what's wonderful about this is I've always had this kind of ringing theme in my head that, you know, creativity is the rearrangement of found elements in a unique way, right? You know, and we can't always just poof, have something net new. It's gotta be this brilliant combination of things that were used for other things. So I think that's awesome.

Ciaran Murray Can we, can we break down some of these components that you had talked about for our audience? Quadratic funding. Walk us through that really quick. Okay. Uh, quadratic funding is a really interesting, I always find this hard to explain this one, uh, is a really interesting, is a really interesting. It's the name. It's a scary name. I know. It's just like, everyone's like, what in the hell is that?

It's actually a site called what the fuck is quadratic funding. Which visit that website. Maybe people, yeah, it's WTF, but, um, it's actually the best explanation of quadratic funding. Much better than I'm about to give. Um, it's, um, it's best summed up, I think, as a crossroads between, or a halfway point between markets and democracy. So markets are essentially $1, one vote.

The more money you have

Ciaran Murray The more money you have, the more you can sway an outcome in your favorite markets. Um, which tends to work really well for us. Markets are amazing, but the downside of that is they can be bought. They can be controlled with people with lots of money. Um, democracy is the other extreme. Uh, it's one person, one vote, no matter what resources or information they have, which also is great for, you know, preventing tyranny, et cetera.

But the downsides of that is you have people who know a lot about a certain topic who only have the same voice as a bunch of people who know very little, which is a bit shit. So quadratic funding tries to find a middle ground between these two, where it's one, it's, it's a, you have to buy to get into the system, but every time you spend another dollar, it, it scales and quadratically and not linearly.

So every dollar you spend to influence that market actually gets more expensive to a point where you're, you're probably going to reach where I'm not, I can't buy this market anymore. Um, so for funding purposes for us, um, we, um, we will have these competitions where let's say a writer wants to write on climate change and we'll have a quarterly funding competition. Um, they will canvas for funding from communities and then their funding will be matched from a big funding pool that would have been funded by institutions because we don't want the institutions, uh, influencing the outcome.

Um, and let's say person A gets a thousand and person B also gets a thousand, but person A gets it from 10 donors and person B only gets it from one, person A will get way, way more funds from the matching pool because their funds will be much more community based, more democratic. So that's essentially how the explanation behind quadratic funding and how we're going to use it. So, okay.

Say Mark and I

Jeremy Gilbertson So just to, just to clear it. So say Mark and I are two writers on this platform. We want to write for climate change. The donors that I've locked in are 10 individuals and Mark has one donor specifically. My, my donor pool, my, my, I guess my donor pool is more valuable because it's diversified and rather than coming from one person, one person. Okay. Well, I don't know if this is an example or real life, cause I would like to write about climate change and I'd like to be paid to do it.

Mark Fielding So maybe I could apply for this pool. Um, listening to that, I was thinking it could become a popularity contest because if you, if you're very popular and well-known, you can get 10 funders. And if you're not, you can't. Is that, is that, is there something in the system which prevents that? Or is that part of the system? There is, that's an excellent observation and there is. Um, so that's just the funding side of things.

Ciaran Murray Um, once you get your funds, you can't just use them to write and take them home with you. Uh, another very kind of novel part of OLS is that we have native decentralized review protocols built in. So these are essentially a replacement for editorial and peer review, uh, open ones, market-based. So to take you through the flow further, this, uh, person A would have a thousand dollars or more. They would've got matched, but they have money to write an OLS and they stake $50 on an article.

The fact checking bounty

Ciaran Murray 20% of that tenor goes to a bounty to fact checkers to find something wrong with that article. And if they find something wrong with it, a judging panel is formed. Um, of half the seats are formed by other writers who put down climate change as a topic of specialty and the other half are open. And the rationale is here is to get expertise in, but also to guard against collusion and groupthink. So you have both disruptors and curious minds as fact checkers, right?

There you go. Yeah. Um, and, um, let's say the article is found to be bunk, found to be factually incorrect and just very bad. The, the writer will lose a stake first and foremost, and second of all, a reputation score will be docked. So when they go to the next quarterly funding round, I'd like to think, I know some people can be loyal, um, to a fault and, and just back people, even though they're bad.

I'd like to think that would greatly affect their performance in the funding markets next time, next time round. So to answer your question, it should, there isn't an initial protection, but there should be one ongoing. On, um, so as a writer's perspective, okay, I'm doing, I'm writing an article. I have done a pretty good job of researching my, my facts, but there's like one or two.

Mark Fielding Is it, I mean, we probably should get into how all this works, but is there, do I have the opportunity then to take advice and change and update facts? Will the article stay long alive? Kind of how long might this process take? Yeah, it's, it stays live and you'll only get your, you can update and say, yeah, the fact committee or the judging panel found against me. And you know what? I held my hands up.

Ciaran Murray I actually got to change this, but that won't change your payout. Um, because there will be that initial two week period. I'm thinking about two weeks for this or the review process to play out where people could have been misinformed. So there has to be accountability. But if, if the overall article was good and it was just a few hiccups, shall we say, particularly if they weren't huge facts that weren't consequential to the whole gist of the piece, um, you would still get 90% or something.

And you have to remember at 90% of that stake, it all goes to you. There's no Rupert Murdoch or Bloomberg, uh, taking their cut. And then if people liked it and they add tips on top of that, which is going to be the main revenue source in my view, um, you'll still get 90% of those tips. So there's room for error, but still accountability. I love, I love, I love the, I love the concept of this.

Jeremy Gilbertson I love the idea of this. Um, the technology, how, how much of this process through technology is, is automated because certain writers who are not very tech aware would look at this and be like, Whoa, this is like massively complex as opposed to, Hey, you hire me to write something, I bang out some words, you send me a hundred bucks and we, we call it good. Yeah. Um, I'm expecting the kind of interaction with this protocol to be very different to my explanation of it.

Ciaran Murray I work an app, uh, we're at the app layer of web three, which is, you know, pretty much the last 10 years, everyone's been building infrastructure, infrastructure, infrastructure. And I think we're at a point now where we can at least start planning apps and start tentatively building them because scaling is getting there and all the other tooling and plugging into the financial system and people just getting used to web three is getting to a point where we can do that.

Um, but obviously we need to make these web three apps as intuitive and as user friendly as web two. So even though there's going to be complex blockchains underneath them and complex prediction markets, uh, underneath, uh, some of the markets, the user will literally just go, I raise money. I stake money. I have to get my facts right. Uh, the reader will go. I like that piece. I tipped it. And the tipping will be as easy as like liking on Twitter or Facebook.

Now, you know, it's that would be that frictionless. Um, so yeah, I'm, I'm, I'm hoping and expecting it to be very user friendly. So I think we've, we've kind of hinted to the picture of what Olas is without kind of actually defining what it is. Um, essentially are we talking about the distribution of news and goals and essentially getting that truth in, in the news? Uh, the higher level pitch for Olas is it's a long form media publishing platform, um, for a trustworthy information.

So it's competitor in the legacy system would be any type of media that is reviewed. So that would be news media that has editorial review. Um, some might think it doesn't, the amount of misinformation we see, but it does and, uh, academic media that has peer review. So we're directly challenging that type of media. Um, and we are reintroducing or introducing a completely different funding model based on subsidies that is made possible by advancements in payment technologies.

Native review protocols

Ciaran Murray And we are introducing native review protocols that are open and market based. Um, so the crowd rather than committees that are quite opaque and possibly prone to backscratching and corruption, um, reviews information on the internet. The idea is that these review protocols will actually become native to the internet itself and part of its fabric. Um, and that's kind of the three main elements of Olas.

Jeremy Gilbertson I kind of think about, this might be a, this might be a silly comparison, but is I started thinking about like with the peer review, with the review process, if I write something and then other community reviews it, Wikipedia is kind of, uh, at least not, not the financial transaction piece of it, but the, the community review piece, is that a relatable concept? Yeah. So I think Wikipedia would be an initial stepping stone to where we want to get to.

Wikipedia

Ciaran Murray Um, Wikipedia is still relatively closed in the sense that yes, you can propose edits, but I think it's quite hierarchical from what I remember. There's not many people who actually do it. Oh, there is. Yeah. Very small. You've kind of super editors that have kind of closed the market basically. Um, and also I think culturally it's very much, you know, Western and are these people getting the information right about all the other parts of the world that they're not necessarily affiliated or have connected to?

Jeremy Gilbertson And that's a big question. Um, where this protocol, um, should, um, solve those problems. I think there's a market of people for that love the fact-checking element of stuff or love, like reviewing something and be like, yo, this isn't right. And here's why. And you know, whatever, whatever their incentive in, in their mind is to do that. There are people, are you finding like, as you kind of built this, are you finding that as well, that there's a large group of people that are interested in that?

Ciaran Murray Um, I, yeah, I'm one of those people, by the way, I'm a commenter on newspaper sections, but like, as soon as you comment, it gets buried and thousands of comments. Um, it might be upvoted and get to the top, but it might not. Or if you want to critique an article, you can post it on your own Twitter, but the long and the short of it is most of the people who read that article will not see your criticism or your insight or your, you know, fact-checking.

Um, so we want to bring that ability to comment or to note something into the actual review process itself and then affect the content because most journalists, they're not, I'm sure they read the comment sections they do, and they'll take things on board, particularly if it's an intelligent comment, but most of them aren't going to care too much about what's said. They care about what, uh, their editorial review board says.

And most importantly, what their owner who tends to have economic interests and ideologies himself and has set an editorial direction. Um, and that's the main thing they have to concern themselves with. On this system, you have to concern yourself with what the informed people, and that's crucial. It's not just them to members of the crowd. What are they going to pull you up on? You always have to challenge yourself and check yourself before you press publish on this protocol because otherwise you won't get paid.

Mark Fielding Okay. Kind of makes sense. Um, I really like the idea as someone who personally is getting to the stage where they don't trust anything they read or see that maybe just because you're paranoid doesn't mean they're not after you. Maybe this is something which I would, I would really enjoy personally, just because trying to create, as Jeremy said at the beginning, things that you trust is, and it's, it's not getting any easier, is it?

Ciaran Murray So this would be a way. Well, no, that's the thing. Like, so if the internet democratized publishing, which it did, and you know, we're all journalists. If we want to be now citizens, citizen journalists or bloggers or social media posters, we can say anything we want on the internet now. But if that was bad enough for misinformation, because there's no controls, more voices is good by the way.

I'm not, you know, giving out about that. I like the fact that more people can say stuff, but we lost in that transition. We lost the review part. This is what we're trying to bring back. But if that was bad enough, like AI is now like, I don't know, supercharging that by like, it's just because so trivially easy to create content with AI. And we're going to be awash with information with the tools, you know, devoid of the tools to judge if it's accurate or not.

A societal need

Mark Fielding Um, so I think there's a huge societal need for something we're doing. Um, and, and I think in your protocol about, about AI created content, do you have any kind of, is there any philosophy behind, um, you can't use AI or if you use AI and our readers can obviously tell that it's been created with AI, then it, you, you are penalized or is there anything that's built into the system or do, or in two years, it won't matter because you won't be able to tell the difference for thinking about that.

Ciaran Murray No, it's just accuracy. So if you write a piece using cloud or chat GPT or whatever, and it's factually accurate, you're going to get paid. Um, we're just concerned with accuracy and truth. Um, how you get there is your business. Um, what I will say is you won't be able to set up multiple accounts and then just churn out thousands of articles a week to get paid, um, because that's, you know, I, you, even, even if using AI, I want a lot of thoughts. I've gone into it.

I want to, um, make sure the market doesn't get too bulged and everyone can have a, have a slice of the pie. So we, that's where the decentralized identity technologies come in. Um, anti- sybil attacks to explain to your users, basically someone setting up multiple accounts or setting up accounts with bots, um, that will all be prevented by these protocols. So you learn how, uh, how. And as a seasoned airdrop farmer, I'm quite, it's kind of the Sibyl farming is quite a, um, uh, relevant topic for me and for crypto in general at the moment.

And I'm like, what are you doing? It's a huge thing. In fact, I think airdrops are just not viable anymore because of it. Um, but, uh, what we're using is, um, proof of unique human protocol. So every period of time, probably something like every two weeks, you will have to jump on either a people party or a scanner biometric, um, world coins, the biometric approach, bright ideas, a people party.

You basically hop on a call. Like we're on now wave to everyone go, Hey, I'm a human. And, uh, they, yeah, that's pretty cool. Yeah. And then they also have, um, a way, uh, of knowing if you set up multiple accounts. So there's a, it's a, you can't be a bot and you can only have one account and you're using world calling for that. The, the eye orb. Well, we'll probably use multiple, um, because it just makes it easier for the users.

Jeremy Gilbertson Um, but I'm sure we'll probably be one of them. Yeah. The digital identity thing is such a big part of this. And, you know, I, I got on the digital identity train like years ago when the idea of open mustard seed came out of MIT and it was all database driven. Mark's like, he's talking about open mustard seed again, like stop. But no, I remember waiting for a guest to go. Yes. Open mustard seed.

And then I am totally lost. So I'm not, I'm not that guest. It was, it, it, it just, it just got my brain churning even before I knew about blockchain. And then now blockchain is a way to decentralize this, what they used to call personal data stores, right. And, and verifiable identities and different identities, right? So I can have, I can have me, but then I have worked me and I have lacrosse coach me and I have writer me and I have, uh, is, is that, is that allowed on your, on your platform?

Segmentation of identity

Ciaran Murray Cause that would be a segmentation of identity, right? Yeah, no, you've, you've touched on something that, um, I think is another powerful use of OLS. And that is people who have an insight and want to write about it, but they know this insight might be unpopular. Right now, the cost to one's career from the mob are just too great to risk that, where an OLS, you can go, you know what, I'm just going to write this under a pseudonym, but I get to carry over all my performance under my other identity.

I won't call it my real identity, but my, my given name identity. But I write this under a pseudonym, anonymous, essentially. Um, and yes, a lot of people might kick off, but my payout and reputation score is dependent on the market, not the mob. Um, and so it frees up people to write, you know, say something they feel is valuable, but I would otherwise be too scared to say it. So that's, um, cancel culture and whistleblowers.

Jeremy Gilbertson Exactly. No more. Yeah. Yeah. There are a lot of, yeah, there are a lot of things that need to be said about certain, I, we talked about this in the, in the pregame, but like, you know, Mark and I've used this nomenclature a lot, the calcified systems, right? So if you speak up against these systems and these processes and these waves of doing things, you can severely limit your, your participation in those, because those are the systems, right?

Ciaran Murray Those are the systems that are happening, but to be able to exit the system and, uh, talk about it in a meaningful way without, you know, without negative financial rep, uh, repercussion, that's super interesting. Yeah, it's, I think it's, you know, people, one of the downsides of the internet is people are, are go with their gut initial angry reaction. And that's the thing that often like, you know, someone angrily retweets something and somebody else just does it.

And in seconds, this anger has just gone around the world, exploded. And eventually people probably calm down and get to the truth, but not, not before someone's career is in the gutter. Um, so, you know, if we can build systems that can guard against our worst instincts, like that, our initial emotional reactions, I think we'll be all the better for it. Yeah. I think the whole awareness of, of our default mode.

Jeremy Gilbertson So, you know, uh, Ciaran, we've got a book club. Um, this is a shameless plug for a book club, but we read, uh, Shane Parrish's book, um, that, that was really amazing. That talked about these default mechanics that, um, you know, everybody has, they're biologically ingrained in who we are as, as humans, but to be aware of those, uh, is, is super, super important and critical. Um, yeah.

Cause that bad energy reverberates big time. Um, so, so let's talk about, let's shift gears a little bit. Um, let's, let's talk about, um, okay. So we get, we get this, we get this put together, right? Olas is a, is a platform, right? Where, where this news resides. Right. So I love the idea of pushing up against these systems that are out there. Right. But what are some of the barriers?

The biggest challenges

Ciaran Murray What are some of the biggest challenges that you see in, in letting this wonderfully brilliant plane take off and start flying? Um, I, I think the, the big unknown, um, is the revenue model. Um, if subsidies were viable for media now, they'd probably use it. I know Wikimedia does, they take in about $200 million a year, I think at the moment, but Wikimedia is really cornered or Wikipedia.

It's, you know, child has cornered that market. So they have such traffic, even of a tiny, tiny proportion of that traffic just gives $15 a year or whatever. They're taking in huge amounts in news media. The Guardian does okay, but it also needs, um, rich philanthropists to prop it up. So there's no example in history where a media industry has sustained itself by people's voluntary donations.

And our big bet is that because without a paywall, um, so lots of eyes on every article and also by reducing friction. So if I want to tip the, or sorry, if I want to donate to the Guardian now, they'll recommend 10, 15, 20, $30 because it's, they know you're not going to do it every time you read the paper. So they want you to do it like annually or monthly or something. Um, you have to whip out your credit cards, do lots of things that would stop people from actually, even though they might go, I'd actually like to pay them.

They won't. Our big hope is that when people get to the end of an individual article, instead of having been asked to pay for a bundle of articles, many of them they don't want, they will just go, you know what, that was actually a good read. I'll tip that 50 cents and they don't have to take out a credit card. It's just, as I said, it's as easy as liking a post on Facebook because that's the way payments are going in web three.

Um, and so that's, that's our big unknown. I'd say that's the big risk to our success. We'll have three years where, uh, tokenize, token issuance will subsidize, uh, journalism and academic research. After that, the training wheels will be taken off and we're hoping that people will donate and tip. It's really good because I'm sure everyone has their favorite journalists or their favorite articles.

Mark Fielding They go to different websites, different news outlets. And there might be, you know, my, like a sports journalist or somebody who's writing about culture and you don't, you don't want to pay 30, but okay, you read a good article. He's like, okay, yeah, I'll tip that. And if it's easy and simple and the click of a button, then you would, you would do it. A lot of people would do it anyway.

Ciaran Murray What, what's, um, what can I tip with? Well, the, the, the, the bet again, the bet is on web-free technology. So you will, you will put appers in your crypto wallet. Anything I want. Okay. Yeah. Like, well, whatever. Sorry. Whatever the journalists.