What Can the Martens Clause Teach AI Warfare?
Jeremy proposes the Martens Clause as a baseline for AI, and Mark tests it against an AI-first military. If there are no humans in the loop, how can you have a humanity clause?
In this episode · 18 chapters
- An unknown Russian legal scholar
- Fyodor Martens, and the conference that nearly collapsed
- The preamble, read out
- What it means when the rules run out
- Nuremberg
- Corfu Channel, and Nicaragua
- Why Jeremy is raising this now
- The Outer Space Treaty, and what it leaves open
- Seatbelts, airbags, a minimum viable architecture
- Does it just mean don't be an asshole?
- The guests we want to put this to
- Safety mechanisms, and why AI ethics glazes people over
- Who would actually be accountable
- Technology moves faster than the law
- A Martens tribunal
- What about the black box?
- A meteorite, or aliens on the lawn
- Unless the AI shoots first
I think maybe two things would do it. One, a giant meteorite impact. The other, aliens landing on the lawns of Buckingham Palace. I think you need something on that level to reset the human condition.
In 1899, a peace conference nearly fell apart until Fyodor Martens offered wording vague enough for every country to accept. Jeremy traces how the Martens Clause was later cited at Nuremberg, in the Corfu Channel case and over the mining of Nicaragua's harbours.
He then proposes it as a minimum viable architecture for AI and space, with accountable tech leaders, governments and a third-party tribunal. Mark asks who could judge the black box of AI, and whether any court would understand what it was ruling on.
The Martens Clause, written into the 1899 peace conference by Russian legal scholar Fyodor Martens, protects people in cases the written rules of war do not cover. On the Thinking On Paper podcast, Jeremy Gilbertson proposes it as a baseline for AI warfare and space law. Mark Fielding tests it against an AI-first US military: “If there are no humans in the loop, how can you have a humanity clause?”
What is the Martens Clause?
The Martens Clause is a line in the preamble of the 1899 peace conference document that keeps populations and belligerents protected in cases the written rules of war do not cover. Jeremy reads it aloud and explains it as a fallback on the laws of humanity and public opinion; Mark sums it up as “something not explicitly prohibited is not automatically permitted”.
Who was Fyodor Martens and how did he save the 1899 conference?
Jeremy says Fyodor Martens, a Russian legal scholar he describes as runner-up for the Nobel Peace Prize in 1902, rescued the 1899 conference. A smaller country, which Jeremy believes was Belgium, objected to the big powers calling people who defend their own country belligerents, and Martens offered a concept vague enough for every delegation to accept.
Where has the Martens Clause been cited in international law?
Jeremy says the clause has been cited in international cases: at the Nuremberg trials of 1945 and 1946, citing a Pepperdine law study; in the 1949 Corfu Channel dispute over mines that destroyed British ships, citing an American Journal of International Law case study; and over US mining of Nicaraguan harbours in 1986.
What is a minimum viable architecture for technology?
Jeremy proposes the clause as a “minimum viable architecture”, his term for the baseline safety rules any technology must meet, in the way every car needs a seatbelt, airbags and a crumple zone. He applies it first to space, where he says the Outer Space Treaty is the only rule in force.
How would the Martens Clause hold AI companies accountable?
For AI, Jeremy sketches an accountability chain: companies explain how a system works before deployment, a named leader such as the CEO answers for the decision to deploy, governments answer for missing laws, and a third party, perhaps a “Marten's tribunal”, polices the principle. His case rests on the claim that “tech moves faster than our ability to understand it and write laws around it”.
Where they disagree
Mark argues the clause works for obvious atrocities such as Nazi Germany but says nothing about questions like “who does this asteroid belong to?”. He adds that the AI black box means companies cannot fully explain how their systems work, and that an international tribunal could not judge technology it does not understand.
Links from this episode
- Martens Clause: text and background (ICRC Casebook, How does law protect in war?)
- Corfu Channel (United Kingdom v. Albania) case page (International Court of Justice)
- Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua (Nicaragua v. United States) case page (International Court of Justice)
Questions
What is the Martens Clause?
The Martens Clause is a line in the preamble of the 1899 peace conference document that keeps populations and belligerents protected in cases the written rules of war do not cover. Jeremy reads it aloud and explains it as a fallback on the laws of humanity and public opinion; Mark sums it up as “something not explicitly prohibited is not automatically permitted”.
Who wrote the Martens Clause and when?
The Martens Clause, written into the 1899 peace conference by Russian legal scholar Fyodor Martens, protects people in cases the written rules of war do not cover.
How does Jeremy Gilbertson want to use the Martens Clause?
On the Thinking On Paper podcast, Jeremy Gilbertson proposes it as a baseline for AI warfare and space law. He then proposes it as a minimum viable architecture for AI and space, with accountable tech leaders, governments and a third-party tribunal.
What is Mark Fielding's objection to a humanity clause for AI?
Mark Fielding tests it against an AI-first US military: “If there are no humans in the loop, how can you have a humanity clause?”
Transcript
Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds. I want to tell you a story. It's 18, it's 1899. The world's first conference on peace comes together.
Mark Fielding I like the story.
An unknown Russian legal scholar
Jeremy Gilbertson largely put together by a very unknown man, Russian man, legal scholar, who actually was awarded honorary degrees from Cambridge, from Oxford, from Harvard. He was actually runner up for the Nobel Peace Prize in 1902. So I think it's probably okay to consider his opinion fairly valid. He actually negotiated
the peace terms of the peace treaty in the Russo-Japanese war. So he's done some stuff. So anyway, I'm not gonna tell you his name yet. I'll tell you his name in a minute. All right, yeah.
Mark Fielding He's doing some stuff. That's a good CV.
⁓ Jeremy, could I just ask you a question? What
year was that? Did you say at the beginning? So it took us until it took humanity until 1899 to have a conference on peace. What were we doing for the other 400,000 years?
Jeremy Gilbertson 1899. 1899.
us versus them. We were racing to beat each other at whatever the cost, unfortunately.
Mark Fielding I wonder
when the word peace first appeared and emerged because having the first peace conference in 1899 seems like it should have been much sooner than that. Anyway.
Jeremy Gilbertson Mm-mm.
Fyodor Martens, and the conference that nearly collapsed
Jeremy Gilbertson Okay. So, so the, gentleman's name Fyodor Martens all right. Fyodor Martens. And you know, imagine it's 1899, everyone's together, all the countries in the world in this room for two weeks or more, trying to figure out what's permittable in the rules of war. You know, what is allowable from an international perspective on war after weeks of debate, they're close. have 54 articles.
And everything's kind of working out. We're getting to a spot where everyone's agreeing. And then at one point, one of the smaller countries, I believe it was Belgium, stands up and goes, Hey guys, listen, you big powers are calling the smaller countries or the smaller groups within countries you invade, belligerence. We're not belligerence. We're actually defending our own country when you invade us. So we need to change the language in there a little bit. And then the big powers were like, yeah, no, I don't think we're going to
Mark Fielding ⁓
Jeremy Gilbertson get on board with that and the whole conference almost is a waste of time and everyone else grabs their ball and go home and then Mr. Martens stands up, has an idea and shares a concept that aligns everybody and the uniqueness of this concept is that it was vague enough to get everyone to buy in but also open enough
Mark Fielding descends into chaos.
Hahaha
Jeremy Gilbertson to be universally applicable as we move through the various stages of the world beyond 1899.
The preamble, read out
Jeremy Gilbertson Let me read kind of, this was the preamble that ended up being in the document that came out of that conference in 1899.
Until a more complex code of laws of war is issued, the high contracting parties think it right to declare that in cases not included in the regulations adopted by them, populations and belligerence, there's that word.
the Belgians came up and got their word in there, remain under protection and empire of the principles of international law as they result from the usages established between civilized nations from the laws of humanity and the requirements of public consciousness.
The last bit of that is the important piece, because that's the carryover. from the laws of humanity and the requirements of public consciousness. So how does that all shake out? Basically,
If it's not spelled out in the rules, we should still consider laws of humanity, meaning what's right for humans and the requirements of public consciousness. What is the, what is the international community? What do people think about what you did? Okay, great. This sounds like a nice little floaty requirement. Hey, they're not a requirement, but this idea, right? So I did some research.
And it's actually been cited in multiple cases in international court, international justice. number one, the first case.
What it means when the rules run out
Mark Fielding Hold on. So just
so I get my head around this. So basically, if what you're doing isn't written out in legal terminology, word for word in whatever treaty document or memorandum you're using or going by, just because it's not written in their word word doesn't mean you can do it just because it's not just because
It isn't explicitly illegal, you can't do it because of the rules of humanity, whatever they might be.
Nuremberg
Jeremy Gilbertson Exactly right. Exactly right. So how does it, how is it first applied? Not necessarily first applied, but what are the most famous cases in which it was applied? Nuremberg 45, 46, pretty big, pretty big conversation.
Mark Fielding pretty big conversation is I just described the Nuremberg trials. Wow.
Jeremy Gilbertson Pretty big conversation.
Yeah,
it was like, so Germany was brought to trial or the Germans were brought to trial to be held accountable for their actions. basically what happened was the Germans were saying there wasn't a law specifically
against their approach to killing millions of people, putting them in concentration camps, all the terrible things that were done in that war. And there's a reference ⁓ in Pepperdine law, there's a study that I found the development of international law related to crimes against humanity. It references that the Nuremberg trials referenced the Martens Clause to hold the Germans accountable.
It wasn't the end all be all, I don't think, that drove the decision of those trials, but it definitely was cited as something super important and something to kind of lean on as a precedent, which was pretty powerful. Another example, little lesser known example in 1949 in a place called the Corfu Channel, ⁓
Corfu Channel, and Nicaragua
Jeremy Gilbertson clear minds out of their waters post-war to clear shipping angles and all of that. British ships were destroyed. Albania was like, yeah, there's nothing in law that says I have to clean the minds out and warn the people after the war. It turns out actually that new minds were placed in this area. But the American Journal of International Law case study, the Martens Clause principles of humanity and dictates of public consciousness references
this and the decision to hold Albania accountable, even though there wasn't legal.
reasoning or legal precedent for them to clear the mines that reference the Martens Clause. this is something that's been referenced a lot in 1986. Last one, I'll tell you about 1986, US, Nicaragua, the whole Contras thing. Reagan was in office, and the US actually was mining the Nicaraguan harbors, putting mines in the water. They stood back on the fact, well, we didn't really sign any treaty precluding us from doing that. The Martens Clause was again, referenced.
Why Jeremy is raising this now
Jeremy Gilbertson So why do I bring up the Martens Clause? Why are we talking about it? I'm thinking on paper. My thought is what if we dusted this damn thing off and applied it across the board to all the challenges we're having in AI, all the challenges we're having in spacefaring and space tech, and potentially even nefarious uses of other technologies like quantum and some of the other things. So that's why I wanted to...
have a dialogue about it. And I wanted to share, because I didn't know about it before I started researching it. Did you know about Martens Clause?
Mark Fielding didn't know about Martens Clause. Is it is the answer to that? My first in my first answer to that is twofold. Firstly, the Nuremberg trials and to a much lesser extent, the Albania situation in the Corfu canal.
doesn't take a genius to work out that they were nefarious, evil acts on the first one and perhaps incompetence on the second one. doesn't, don't need a 300 year old law to say that that's, that's bollocks. They're guilty. off with their heads. If you apply that same thought process to much more
less obvious situations. It becomes much more difficult to execute on. And also what are the laws of humanity? Again, the same thing. I mean, the laws of humanity for, you shouldn't freaking gas millions of people.
But the same laws of humanity don't apply to can I build a hotel on the moon or not? or who does this asteroid belong to?
That was my thoughts.
Jeremy Gilbertson Good thoughts. Good thoughts. Well,
so yes, I mean, you, you and I individuals, people can think about the atrocities that, have happened in war and, and point back to them and go, man, that that's terrible. Like that's terrible. And those people should be held accountable. But when you have international organizations and you thought like,
just states and cities are bureaucratic. You think about the levels of bureaucracy when you have multiple companies or multiple countries organizing together and trying to figure out how to put something out. You do have to have stuff to point to and you do have to have reference points in this case. So I think it'd be interesting to consider and lean on it. The space tech piece, I think we can jump around a little bit like between space tech and well, let's start with space tech.
The Outer Space Treaty, and what it leaves open
Jeremy Gilbertson The only thing out there governing space is the outer space treaty, which was done in what the sixties or the seventies. And just, just this, this idea of like space for all mankind was this just ethos, this idea. and it could be an, the Martens clause to me is a potential architecture. It's potential infrastructure to jump off of and call it kind of the minimum viable requirements.
Seatbelts, airbags, a minimum viable architecture
Jeremy Gilbertson for anything, think about a car, Think about a car, you have a car, it could be anything, man. It could be a flying car, it be a submarine car, whatever you want, But the minimum viable requirements that are out there is like whoever's driving and operating the car, there needs to be a seatbelt in there, it needs to be some airbags, there needs to be a crumple zone, there needs to be safety mechanisms that are in place for that.
Mark Fielding Right? Is that a flying car?
Jeremy Gilbertson Could this be kind of this minimum viable architecture when applied to space to really point back to and say, hey, Mark, I know you're doing all these great things, and I know there's investment that's required to support those things and you're accountable to your investors, but could we have that Martens Clause woven in to your operational procedures?
Would you be willing to?
Does it just mean don't be an asshole?
Mark Fielding What's the alternative? The four stoic virtues? Or you put it in human language, don't be an asshole. Doesn't the Martens clause essentially mean don't be an asshole? You can wrap it up in all of the bureaucratic, legal language you want. and you can have as many footnotes as you like.
Jeremy Gilbertson Pretty much. You could, you.
Mark Fielding But it boils down to don't be an asshole. And we can all generally agree on what that is and don't be that. But it's still, even that seems, that's easy to do in certain situations, but not in others. So yeah, to give it a legal framework, yeah, a minimum viable, what did you call it? An MVP, an MVA.
Jeremy Gilbertson What's
Minimum Viable Architecture, yeah.
So, all right, so define what's an asshole as applied to a human moving through the.
Mark Fielding Well, that's the problem
with the Martens clause, isn't it? So it's on the one end of the spectrum. Yeah, you have Nazi Germany and then lower down that scale, you have what happened in the Corfu Straits. then, yeah, what point is they just being a bit idiotic and not being an asshole? I don't know the answer to that.
The guests we want to put this to
Jeremy Gilbertson You know what we need to do? Here's my ask, all right? If anyone knows Tyler Cowen, I want to have him on the show and I want to ask him about the possibility, what does society look like if we use the Martens Clause as a minimum viable architecture for human flourishing and survival? Boom.
Mark Fielding Well, I think that we should ask Yuval Noah Harari that same question, since we're on a social media rampage to get Yuval. Yuval, what do you know about the Martens Clause? And how could that be incorporated into the AI, the US, particularly AI military machine? I'm sure you've read the memorandum from the Department of War putting America on a war footing in an AI first military ambition.
It's a race against China, as you know.
If there are no humans in the loop, how can you have a humanity clause?
Jeremy Gilbertson Really good question.
Mark Fielding Moving from space
to AI, jumping around. So yeah, okay. So we spoke about the AI military machine. Yeah. Could you just read the Martens Clause again, just so I have it at top of mind?
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, let me pull up a kind of a paraphrase of it, because the language in 1899 is written for people in 1899. Over the years,
Mark Fielding Let's not shy
away from the language, this is Shakespeare, this is the land of Shakespeare.
Jeremy Gilbertson Fair enough, would you like me to reread the version? It's kind of long though.
Basically, in a nutshell, if it's not covered by law, populations and belligerents remain under the protection of the principles of international law, number one, the laws of humanity and the dictates of public all of those things, international law is like consensus, right? It's everyone agreeing that this is right or this is wrong. You have people on...
Mark Fielding Give it a whirl.
Safety mechanisms, and why AI ethics glazes people over
Jeremy Gilbertson polar opposites of that, that believe something is 100 % right, where another person will believe it's 100 % wrong. You've got some people in the middle of that, then the laws of humanity and laws of public consciousness are a little bit As it relates to AI, the safety mechanism for the car thing is probably more applicable to the AI case than it is to the space case. But we talk about Dario Amodei leaving OpenAI because of not agreeing with the safety
programs, even though he was in charge of the safety programs, I guess what he was trying to put in over there wasn't accepted. It was speed first and he left and is doing his own thing. Now stepping up and stepping out against the US government a little bit, although I think he's walking some of that stuff back just to touch. The safety mechanism, we all have to agree on like what the safety mechanisms are for AI.
And it's not AI ethics, AI ethics gets blown. AI ethics is a topic that people glaze over because it's talked about a lot, but there's not really anything, I think at the meat of it. It's like, what are we building? How is it built? How is it gonna serve humanity? How does it have the potential to hurt humanity? And what can we do as a society to make sure the second piece of that doesn't outweigh the first piece of that?
Mark Fielding just
As an aside, so I just very quickly I typed into Claude, is there a modern day equivalent of the Marten's law in international relations? And then it goes through a few examples exactly as you did. This is the AI thinking like a human. But then there's a bit it says applied to new technologies.
One of the most relevant modern applications is to emerging warfare technologies. In the absence of clear international treaty norms governing the use of new technologies in military operations and information warfare, the question arises as to whether it is necessary to apply the Martens Clause to unregulated situations of modern armed conflict. This is actively debated in discussions about autonomous weapons, cyber warfare, and AI guided systems.
You're ahead of the game, Jeremy. You are. You should be leading the conversation out there. You should be on the BBC or the NBC or ABC telling the world about this.
Who would actually be accountable
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, let's talk through it. Let's talk through it a little bit. All right. So if we were to take the Martens clause as minimum viable architecture in the case of making sure AI doesn't do the wrong shit, right? So let's think about like the accountability chain of that, because there's no...
Mark Fielding or as ⁓ something that something
that something not explicitly prohibited is not automatically permitted. Sorry.
Jeremy Gilbertson Okay,
there you go. Little little Martens Clause simplification. like that. So accountability, there's no Martens Clause police. There's no there's no police station that that has Martens Clause badges on it, right? But let's let's talk about who would be accountable in this.
Mark Fielding Well, it isn't
protect and serve a little bit. That's the wording of the Martens Clause in a roundabout way. mean, protect and serve, can be No? OK, sorry, go on.
Jeremy Gilbertson Maybe, I don't know.
Technology moves faster than the law
Jeremy Gilbertson It's another vague, vague line, rally cry kind of thing. But no, let's think about it. All right, so you have the technology companies that are making the technology. in order for technology to be deployed, I think you have to explain the technology enough to write laws around it. Here's the problem, and here's where the Martens Clause, I think, could be interestingly applicable. Tech moves faster, especially now.
tech moves faster than our ability to understand it and write laws around it to protect ourselves from it. not even a fair race how far off tech is from our ability to govern it. So what if we put in a situation where all new technologies has to be explained well enough, we have to understand it well enough, and this is where the tech companies are gonna push back, because it's like, hey, I spent
10 or 15 years developing this technology, if I tell you how it works and everyone else will be able to do it. Okay. I agree with that for smaller things, but this is AI. This is a different technology, I think, that is important enough to really understand. Now, Mark, hang with me here, man, because I know the reality of this coming together is highly unlikely, but I'm going to push this anyway,
Mark Fielding I'm hanging, I'm hanging.
Jeremy Gilbertson You have this requirement that before technology is deployed, has to be presented related to AI, has to be presented well enough to understand how it was put together, why it was put together, and how it actually works top to bottom. Number two, who eventually chose in that company to deploy that technology? Here's interesting accountability piece. Tagging those deployments with a lead,
Maybe it's the CEO, Similar to bank statements, similar to all kinds of verifications that CEOs have to make. Someone had to push the button to say, let's run with this. And whoever that person is, is ultimately accountable to any, negligible effects of it. Number three, the government. Okay. So you have the tech companies, you have the people leading the tech companies, you have the government.
So.
Mark Fielding tech CEOs and the government all being held accountable since time immemorial I know I know I know
Jeremy Gilbertson Totally, and like I know this is highly unrealistic,
A Martens tribunal
Jeremy Gilbertson government, okay, are there laws in place to defend, to uphold the laws of humanity, to uphold the, what was it? Public conscious, God, I can't think of it now. Yeah, public consciousness dictates a public consciousness and laws of humanity. So were there laws put in place to protect humanity?
to account for the dictates of public consciousness where there were those turned into laws that apply to this technology? If not, why not? And who didn't allow that law to come to bear? If they didn't, they're accountable. The last piece of this mark is there's got to be this third party, got to be this third party to basically be guided just by the principles of the Martens clause. And that third party,
Maybe it's a Marten's tribunal or something. I don't know what the hell, but they actually view these instances and police that maybe the international criminal court, think ICC has used this stuff before, but anyway, that's what I'm thinking. Highly unlikely, but it could be an interesting anchor for people who really wanted to fix shit instead of perpetuate and accelerate the wrong stuff.
What about the black box?
Mark Fielding This is good a framing as I've heard of something has to be done. What about the black box of AI though? So you said, okay, you have to explain how it's done. Everyone knows that the black box of AI that they don't actually know how it does a lot of the things that it does. How do you account for that?
Jeremy Gilbertson think part of the accountability is like, how was it trained? What was it trained on? What did those interactions look like? I think there's a, God, I wish I had this.
Mark Fielding It's like A
plus something equals C and they don't know what that something is, but they know that it gets to C and they know what A is. It's the input data, but that little magic that happens, they can't explain that. Here's another pushback for you. Say that they're talking about fusion, which as we know from one of our former guests, it's just an engineering problem. So when fusion eventually comes to market,
And the CEO of Helion is explaining to the court, to the international tribunal in Hague, how it works. They've got no idea what he's talking about. How can they make any kind of informed decisions about the inherent goodness or badness of any tech? So you'd have to get the CEOs, you have to get their friend CEOs into the thing. They'd all be self-ticking themselves off, wouldn't they?
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, and it-
Yeah, either that or it's got to be incentive to get wicked smart people on the other side. You know, unfortunately people on the other side are probably not going to get those, you know, billion dollar payouts. But
Mark Fielding Yeah.
How do you
get wicked smart people out of big tech and into more humanitarian first projects?
Jeremy Gilbertson Jeez, man. I think it's, I think it's, this is tricky. This is tricky. I'm gonna ramble through this a little bit and see what happens, but.
Mark Fielding You
Hold on before that, Yuval, how do we get the... What did I say? I can't even remember. Yuval, how do you answer that question? Sorry.
Jeremy Gilbertson No,
there's conditioning in us, Mark. There's conditioning of, and a competitiveness that is, it's a me versus you versus an us connected thing. you know, if there's a, it all probably started when, you know, my tribe was running through the woods and your tribe was running through the woods and there was a deer in the middle of us and my people.
We're starving. Your people were starving. I needed the deer. You needed the deer. You know, instead of us working together and feeding both of our tribes, I wanted to get it. You wanted to get it. Right. And that conditioning is pervasive in through our upbringing versus the collaborative nature. And it's so interesting. This is the Yuval thing too. success over time as humans is a result of our communication and our collaboration. That's how we, how we
how we moved up the food chain over the years, but now that equally could be our, instead of being collaborative, we're competitive. And competitive is not bad necessarily, but competitive for an us versus them. It's ingrained in us, Mark, is what I'm trying to say. to release that connection, that ingrained thing in our brain is difficult because guess what? If it's in our brain,
It's our thought, it becomes part of us. If it's part of us, it's hard to change because us can't be wrong. Ego comes in and on and on and on.
A meteorite, or aliens on the lawn
Mark Fielding Do know what I think would do it?
I think maybe two things would do it. One, a giant meteorite impact. The other, aliens landing on the lawns of Buckingham Palace. I think you need something on that level to reset the human condition. I don't think any amount of bottom-up education, cultural conditioning,
has the power to change it.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, that's the thing like humans are humans are good at coming together when something epically catastrophic happens. But there's there's a there's a there's a there's what is that an apex? There's a there's a top of that.
Mark Fielding Yeah. Epic.
Are they the same when
it's epic, epically awesome? Like people are good at coming together when it's epically catastrophic. And we're good at coming together when it's epically awesome. you remember the best parties of your life, the best celebrations of your life, everyone's together and because it's freaking awesome. So maybe we need to create more.
incredible moments. The aliens could do that one, then beyond that. So I take back my cynical response.
Jeremy Gilbertson Or we figure out how to, how to cascade and connect the energy of those moments, right? Because we come up and come down, the moments over the aliens, we, we work out the whole alien thing. get off Buckingham Palace's lawn. Everyone's back and safe again. And now it's time to get into races of, of, of me beating you at stuff. It's, it's hard stuff, dude. We're, we're thinking on paper live. We're, learning on.
Mark Fielding you
Yep.
Unless the AI shoots first
Mark Fielding Maybe we were always safe, because
we handed over control of the military machine to an AI that makes that snap judgment call that in fact, then they're bad aliens. have bad intent. Let's shoot first because this is an AI first. We're in a race to China. We've got to shoot them before the Chinese shoot them. that...
Jeremy Gilbertson Geez, nothing, hey, hey, nothing simple in these discussion forums, but ⁓ there you have it. That's the Martens Clause. Look it up, check it out on your own. Consider it as a minimum viable architecture for human flourishing.
Mark Fielding And we can all flourish together. We can all flourish on next week's show. Until then, be disruptive. Stay curious.
Jeremy Gilbertson Keep thinking on paper.




