What Is World ID?
Ajay Patel sees websites asking everyone for a government ID as the fallback once AI can beat CAPTCHA. And so now imagine if every website did that, your personal data is just everywhere.
In this episode · 20 chapters
- What problem World ID solves
- Good users pay with friction
- Why a service cannot tell the difference
- Building blocks, like Lego
- Proving you are human without proving who you are
- Selective disclosure
- Zero knowledge proofs
- The orb
- Data minimisation
- Secure multi-party compute
- Mark's silly questions
- Hot buttons
- Use cases
- Oasis tickets, and exclusive shoe drops
- Gaming, and the Razer partnership
- Would you let your kids scan their irises?
- The Wolfman, and the Batman analogy
- The carryover question
- A question for the next guest
- Backstage
And over time, as some of this automation and bots and AI become more sophisticated and you can’t distinguish between humans and bots online, guess what? You just have to assume everyone’s a bot.
Ajay Patel works on World ID at Tools for Humanity. He explains why online services struggle to tell humans from bots, and why proving you are a unique human, without revealing who you are, is the first building block of identity online.
He walks through the Orb, which photographs your face and eyes and, he says, pushes that data to your phone, plus zero knowledge proofs, secure multi-party compute, and uses from ticket scalping to a partnership with Razer.
Ajay Patel, head of World ID at Tools for Humanity, explains on the Thinking On Paper podcast how World ID and the Orb let a person prove they are a unique human online without revealing who they are. With AI already able to beat CAPTCHA, he frames the problem as: “can I identify myself as a unique human online without exposing anything about myself?”
What is World ID designed to prove?
World ID is built as the bottom Lego block of identity: proof that you are a unique human, kept separate from proof of who you are. Patel says it must work for everyone equally, including the 800 million adults he says have no government legal identity.
Why does AI beating CAPTCHA make proof of humanity matter?
Proof of humanity matters because AI can already beat CAPTCHA, the distorted-text tests websites use to filter out bots, Patel says. The fallback is asking everyone for a passport or government ID, and “now imagine if every website did that, your personal data is just everywhere.”
How does the Orb register you as a unique human?
World ID relies on zero-knowledge proofs, cryptography that answers a question without revealing the data behind it: asked whether someone is human, “the only thing you get back is yes.” The Orb, Tools for Humanity's iris-imaging device, photographs your face and eyes and pushes the data to your phone, where you register as a unique human.
Why does World ID use iris data over face recognition?
Patel says the iris holds the most identifying data of the options they tested, and that face recognition starts producing false matches after about 20 million people. The stored iris data is split using what World calls anonymous multi-party compute, which spreads fragments across independent parties so no single one holds the whole; he says three nodes run live today and calls it the largest such implementation in production.
What is the World ID partnership with Razer?
Patel announced a partnership with Razer at the Game Developers Conference (GDC) in San Francisco, letting players verify a Razer account with World ID so games can confirm each account belongs to a unique human. Other uses he describes include stopping ticket scalping and bot purchases of limited shoe drops; World ID is open to adults only.
Where Mark and Patel disagree
Mark asks how World ID stays “decentralised, voluntary and resistant to misuse” by governments or corporations, and Patel answers that it is an opt-in open protocol: “WorldID itself does not restrict anything.” Asked if the system is quantum secure, he says the maths is, but phones and mobile operating systems are “probably not”.
Links from this episode
Questions
What is World ID?
World ID is built as the bottom Lego block of identity: proof that you are a unique human, kept separate from proof of who you are. Patel says it must work for everyone equally, including the 800 million adults he says have no government legal identity.
Who is Ajay Patel?
Ajay Patel, head of World ID at Tools for Humanity, explains on the Thinking On Paper podcast how World ID and the Orb let a person prove they are a unique human online without revealing who they are.
Can you prove you are human online without revealing who you are?
He explains why online services struggle to tell humans from bots, and why proving you are a unique human, without revealing who you are, is the first building block of identity online. With AI already able to beat CAPTCHA, he frames the problem as: “can I identify myself as a unique human online without exposing anything about myself?”
What are zero-knowledge proofs?
World ID relies on zero-knowledge proofs, cryptography that answers a question without revealing the data behind it: asked whether someone is human, “the only thing you get back is yes.”
Transcript
Jeremy Gilbertson I know. Hang tight.
Jeremy Gilbertson disruptors and curious minds. Welcome to another amazing episode of Thinking on Paper, where we bring you the curious thinker, the reader, the diver into new trends, behind the scenes, the latest technology trends, and we together figure out what it all means for future, for life, for work, for family, all that stuff. My name's Jeremy. This is Mark. We've got a very exciting show for you today. It involves, I'll let Mark T. into it a little bit more, but it involves
We talk about tech a lot, but this is about the H-word, human. The human piece of all this and how it works. We unpacked Paci McCormack's essay, Most Human Wins. We've been on a big thread about this. We're really excited for this guest. Mark, what are we learning about today? And let's tee this thing up.
Mark Fielding We are tackling a question that could define every listener's future, every single one of you. How do you prove you're human in a world of AI, humanoids, deep fakes and bots? And why does it matter? And there was a time not very long ago when I would have laughed at that question. And maybe some of our listeners are laughing now, but...
chat GPT Claude right now. Yeah. Okay. It's making everyone on LinkedIn sound like a robot facsimile emoji wielding robot, but very soon AI generated content and human generated content will be indistinguishable. Deepfakes are changing the world of politics of society. And it's all about trust. Isn't it Jeremy? And unless you want to be Fox Molder, that's an X-Files reference and trust no one.
Humanity needs a verifiable way to prove you're a human. And today's guest is going to give us the tools for humanity.
Jeremy Gilbertson Great tee up. So let's introduce, who do we have today, Mark?
Mark Fielding We have Ajay Patel, his head of world ID at Tools for Humanity. Welcome to Thinking on Paper. Thank you for Thinking on Paper with us, Ajay. Pleasure.
Ajay Patel Thank you for having me.
Mark Fielding Thank for being here and I think that Jeremy, I will let you paint us a picture.
What problem World ID solves
Jeremy Gilbertson So one of the questions we always like to start with Ajay, because tech can be pretty complicated, right? And relating tech to what it means for the general public as we move through our day. So imagine you've got a group of relatives sitting around a table and they ask, so Ajay, what do you ? and what is this all about and why should I care and how can I figure out what's going on?
Ajay Patel That's a question. And how do you do that without kind of using jargon that kind of makes everyone sort of, know, brains break, right?
Ajay Patel Yeah, I mean, if you look at like, AI is here. I think AI took everyone by surprise a couple of years ago when ChatGPT came out and it's advancing faster and faster, right? And I think every subsequent release of these new things kind of surprised the world and a lot of them are pretty amazing and eye-opening. And so there's a tremendous opportunity for us to be more productive and outsource things to AI.
and you know we're talking people are talking about robots and a lot of cool things and Things seem to be accelerating the things are happening faster than we expect although some things I think May not happen as fast as you know people expect but then other things are happening very fast and so When we look at like the internet and the systems the tools the processes how we access things The entire infrastructure and actually our daily lives are not built contemplating AI
And so when Tools for Humanity was created, was really with that premise, like hey, if we rethink how the internet and how our daily lives are going to work.
We really, there's an opportunity here to really think about the tools for humanity and kind of rethink them and then figure out what we should build in order to help humans usher in AI and then maximize benefit of it, right? So AI coming into the world is introducing a ton of challenges. And we actually see glimpses of that already, or, know, and as regular users, the way I would explain it to my parents, for example, is like, hey, when you go on a website, you you have to type in these fuzzy numbers and you can't find your glasses and it's super annoying. Why are they doing this?
that, right? Because they want to know you're a human and not a bot, right? Or you're going through some experience and suddenly this platform asks you for some information that you feel is kind of weird, right? Like, why are they asking for me for my driver's license to verify my age? Like, it just seems like complete overkill, right? And these sort of things are indications that there's this primitive on the internet that's kind of missing, right? And it's really about humanity. Like, we don't really have a good way
Ajay Patel with certainty that kind of can cover all of humanity in a way that's kind of a real baseline. So if we think about a primitive as like a baseline, right? Where everyone can get equal access to a primitive. Most of everything we do is based on something, there's like, it's financial or there's like government legal identity, but then 800 million adults don't have a government legal identity on the
And so when we're thinking about how you prove your humanity, it needs to be something that when I prove it versus when somebody in another country proves it, that proof should be trusted the same. So you mentioned trust. And so I think that's kind of our mission. And so when we assess the entire landscape of what we could do, we say, hey, you know what? The first thing that the cornerstone that needs to be there is actually, hey, I need to be able to prove with certainty that I'm a human and not a bot. And if I can do that and kind of in full control and also not expose who I am on the internet right because that there's like almost this requirement that you have to tell everyone who you are in order to do anything online these days and that would kind of data minimize the internet, but then also provide, could provide a lot of certainty in that interaction. And trust starts with certainty, right? Like the, if you think about money, it's there's counterparty risk and there's a lot of things and you see a lot of inefficiency and, and good, you know, like, kind of like from a user perspective online, it's a good users end up paying with friction, right? And so those are all the things that we think about when we're thinking about proof of humanity and building a tool for the, for users to kind of prove that they're human and not something else.
Good users pay with friction
Mark Fielding Good users pay with friction, Jeremy. Yeah, fist bump. I love the humanity, I'll rephrase that. Obviously humanity, we're on a different, I am on a different path to the 800,000 people in the world, the 800 million people in the world who don't even have access to a bank account. And that kind of proof of humanity for somebody living on a farmstead in Somalia has a very different need for.
proving their humanity than I do and I will in the next decade perhaps. So it goes from creating a bank account to verifying website access to voting in the future, to getting a mortgage in the future, to getting married, having a relationship. It's very, I don't know what the word is to describe what I'm trying to explain, but that difference in humanity for different people and how do you make the trust equal for everybody? Yeah.
Ajay Patel Yeah, and so when you think about what makes us human, it's something that's actually, it's physical, right? It's something about us. And so when we were looking at all the different ways that we could assess humanity, we realized that, it has to be something that's unique about that person, right? And then you think about, what are all...
you know, biological things that make you unique and then you can, and how much, and if you want to really build a system that can scale to billion, 10 billion people, let's say, I think we're at eight in the world. And so let's say 10, um, it has to be something that has a lot of data, right? And there's things that are like practical and impractical when you really kind of think about all those things. But if you kind of in a scientific way, go through all of them, um, there's certain, uh, what we call modalities. And, I won't say the jargon, but like there's certain ways that you can, you know, like fingerprints or palms or, or face or eyes or whatever there's certain things that you know if you think about face right there's doppelgangers and so actually technically after about you know 20 million people things start colliding right and so you you might you might be able to you know the system would mistake any technical system would mistake you for someone else right so that that's it.
Mark Fielding For example, Jeremy is a doppelganger of James Hetfield from Metallica.
Ajay Patel Yeah, exactly. And so if he got James' phone, he'd be able to totally get in. Yeah, go ahead.
Why a service cannot tell the difference
Jeremy Gilbertson So, Ajay, quick, wanted to, as we continue to kind of set the tone for this conversation, why is it so important to distinguish AI specifically from humans? What's the overarching need for that? And then let's dive into kind of what you guys are doing with it.
Ajay Patel Yeah, so one of the things to think about is if you're providing a service online, right, why do services online put Captcha in? It's because they can't tell the difference sometimes between two clicks. So very basic today, right? Today problem, we're not talking about agents or anything like that.
And so if a service can't tell the difference between two clicks, then a lot of things can go wrong. So number one, accounts are being created. Hey, someone's doing something on our system that we don't like, and there's lots of examples from social media or video or whatever.
And so you're open for abuse, right? That's one thing. And then that abuse can be automated. That's basically a bot, right? And then if you take that bot and make it, I don't know, smarter, it's AI, right? so bots are just kind of dumb AI, like today, right? But today is like the dumbest AI is ever gonna be, right? And so they're only gonna get smarter. And so now you can imagine a world where...
Hey, like Jeremy clicks and does access to the internet. Well, something can train on how you act online.
and then it's indistinguishable, right? So if I'm an online platform and the real Jeremy's clicking, but then an AI mimicking him is clicking, how do I know? Right? And it's too different. And then so there's a lot of kind of issues around trust where that certainty is important. And over time, as some of this automation and bots and AI become more sophisticated and you can't distinguish between humans and bots online, guess what? You just have to assume everyone's a bot.
Ajay Patel And so then guess what? Everyone has to go through things like CAPTCHA, right? But the funny thing about CAPTCHA, or not funny, but it's kind of, you know, the interesting thing about CAPTCHA today is that there's already videos on X of AI bypassing CAPTCHA. So then what? Well, you know what? Now we need to KYC everyone, right? You know, the only way can access this is by giving me your government ID or your passport, right? And so now imagine if every website did that, your personal data is just everywhere. And by the way, documents are easy to fake too, right?
that's not robust either. But from an individual, if all your data's out there, that's also even more data for AI to train on, or bad people to take and train. And so there has to be a better solution. so the problem is, hey, can I identify myself as a unique human online without exposing anything about myself?
providing that trusted signal that, this is a unique human, right? And so therefore, it's nothing else. It's a unique human. You don't know anything else about him. Yes, you can collect more information. But at least as a primitive, you can differentiate the two. And that's kind of like how I explain it.
Mark Fielding Is this, so just on that last bit, is this about, or is it both proving I am a unique human or proving that I am Mark Fielding or is it both?
Building blocks, like Lego
Ajay Patel No, if it's building blocks, right, so imagine Legos. The first Lego has to be that you're a unique human because your mark is another Lego block and not everyone needs to know that. Right? And so if you think about it in like blocks, then this bottom block doesn't exist. This is the only way to know that you're a unique human is by you telling somebody your mark.
And that's where the problem kind of starts. now, being able to tell, now there's digital identity things that are happening, like mobile drives license in the US or some of the stuff happening in the EU where they're focused also on this upper block, on being able to tell that you're, you're Mark, a different, using a digital credential, but you still need that building block.
Proving you are human without proving who you are
Jeremy Gilbertson I'm gonna try to not dive down too far into rabbit hole. ring the bell if I get there. you got me thinking on this Lego block thing. right, Lego block number one, I'm a human. Lego block number two, I'm Mark Fielding. What could other Lego blocks look like and could those Lego blocks automate the connectivity of community? So for example, layer on top of Mark Fielding, you I love a specific science fiction writer.
I like to snowboard, like different qualifiers of someone's identity to a community.
Ajay Patel Yeah, totally. So I think the way to think about it is that World ID, or the kind of tools for humanity and world, that network is solving that first block. And that's actually a really hard block to solve because you have to create something where 10 billion people have that unique block and you can guarantee that that is unique, right? And so then if you think about your online activity every day,
There's probably very few times a week. Let's say in the Western world we buy things online all the time, right? But like let's say like the average user like my parents they don't they don't what they do online is email You know, they go and watch some videos or whatever Nobody needs to know who they are So they can go days without ever anyone needing to know who they are online, right? And so that that block and so to the original to the previous comment about being something ubiquitous that's global is really our focus because if you're somebody in Africa or you're somebody in a village that doesn't have a, is not known to any official government system, right?
Eventually right now online you don't exist like it's like you don't even you know You're not even you're not even on the planet right, but if you have this digital this this this Lego block a digital credential that identifies you as a unique human You're known right like you you happen so now that that's like the most basic access Credential right now. There's obviously you need internet and all that other stuff which are other higher layer problems other blocks Let's say but this basic block is needed and that's really what we're focused on and scaling so now but you you can layer things on top, right? So what are we building? We're building a primitive that's actually a protocol, right, that anyone can build on top of, right? So you can have, so there's a lot of interesting projects out there already, right, where, you know, are there different ways that users can build their profile, but it's actually, like, it's self-custodied, but then they can share things in a controlled way. And there's a lot of, like, these sort of...
Selective disclosure
Ajay Patel The digital identity framework in general has concepts of selective disclosure where you share only the bits of information that is required for the job you want to do and the business on the other side or the product or the service on the other side will only ask for the things that they need and that's actually cool because it's a part of GDPR, right? But underneath that, the service still needs to know that...
there's a unique human behind it, right? And so that's kind of the way we think about it. We're kind of agnostic to those layers. Now, as we build this bottom Lego piece, we can create the hooks to kind of connect those things, and that's sort of something that we're exploring. But right now, our focus is to get this proof of unique humanity into everyone's hands, right? And there's enough use cases where, even if you just said, hey, you don't have to do fuzzy numbers anymore. Just present your world ID and you go right through.
Mark Fielding I think that's maybe you've just explained what most people get wrong about world ID. And I think that me and Jeremy probably misunderstood or didn't understand probably before we started researching this as well as that you're really about building that bottom Lego before things get built on top of it. Very important.
Jeremy Gilbertson So let's explore how you do that. obviously we want to kind of, like you said, you do a great job of this already, but kind of steer clear of the tech jargon and really figure out, like demonstrate how you take a person in and help them create this ID and how does that work?
Mark Fielding But you can talk about ZK proofs because then we can link to it.
Jeremy Gilbertson You love this. You love this. Zks
Zero knowledge proofs
Mark Fielding ZK proof, just seems like something which is one of those, if you want to talk about building blocks and Lego blocks and all of the shows that link our shows together, ZK proofs this and what they do in proving what you want or who you are without disclosing other information seems an integral building block in the future of technology. I love it. I love the idea of it. I don't understand it, but I love the idea of
Ajay Patel Yeah, it's actually really complicated. It's based on like super cryptographic math and I think there's like a point in math where things get really abstract. It's like physics, right? They get pretty abstract and there's special brains that understand that. But the end result of a ZK proof, CK proof is basically.
There's something that's real, there's something that sits in between, translates that and so you can ask, so basically you ask a question, right? Is this person a human? Right? And the only thing you get back is yes. Right? And something that identifies them as unique but you don't know anything else about them and that's basically how it works. So how do you get that proof of human?
So imagine like, I talked a little bit about modalities, right? There's faces, fingers, there's, and so we're always exploring how to build a proof of unique humanity in a way, using different modalities, but the one that we kind of settled on and we're really scaling right now is based on your iris. So it's not your eyeball, it's not your retina, it's your iris.
And again, if I'm explaining this to my dad, I'll say, think of Iris as like a really beautiful QR code, right? It just has a lot of data in it. And if you can take the picture of both eyes, there's actually a ton of data that you can extract, right? And build and identify someone as unique, right?
The orb
Ajay Patel And so what we built is a piece of hardware called the Orb. And can think of the Orb as a, you know, and there was a lot of engineering that went to get to that point. And so what we realized was, the fidelity cameras, the sensors that we need, all those things don't exist. So there's a lot of things that we built to get the Orb to where it is today. But it's really like a really high resolution camera, right? It has a regular camera and it has like an infrared camera and...
Ajay Patel You walk up to the orb, and it's actually, there's a lot of fraud risks this is built into, which we don't get easy into, but a user walks up.
has an anonymous interaction with the orb, so nobody knows you went there, right? It takes pictures of your face and your eyes, and it pushes that data to your phone, right? So it's basically like a camera. You go up there, takes a picture of you, pushes it to your phone. It doesn't go anywhere else, right? From your phone, you basically register, you register as unique human. And so if the network's never seen you before, you're given a new world ID, and if it's seen you before, then it's kind of like a re-authentication.
communication. So now you have this thing on your phone that's basically not tied to the pictures that were taken in the orb but it's kind of like this number, let's say. And from that, a zero-knowledge proof can be shared with anyone that you're a unique human, anyone online or anything online.
a unique human, it all sort cryptographically ties all together based on how that proof was generated originally, right? And so all of the pictures that you have are totally isolated from the proof of humanity, and then again, isolated by the proof that's generated for you online, right? So even if you wanted to, you'd have to take your own picture and send it to somebody, right? That's kind of the way the system works. And so that's like the most basic building block.
And then yes, there's gonna be scenarios where you have to share real information, so you're signing up for a bank account or whatever, but at that point, that's a different use case, and so you would then follow normal paths, but the beauty of this is that whoever you're connecting to has this sort of unique human signal that they can then build their account structure on. And on their side, when they authenticate you or when you're onboarding, they don't need to do CAPTCHA, they don't need to do a lot of different.
Ajay Patel things and it simplifies things and data minimizes things. That's kind of the vision of where we're trying to go.
Data minimisation
Jeremy Gilbertson I love data minimizing. You've used that a couple of times and you know that there's a lot of data out there and useful information is a little bucket within that data. So the more we can minimize the noise, the better the signal is. I want to nerd out just a touch. Mark, keep me honest here.
Mark Fielding No, nerd out. I think I know what you're gonna say
Secure multi-party compute
Jeremy Gilbertson We'll see if we're super positioned here. No, so that's a really good point, Ajay, because when people are like, man, I got to walk into this building and they're going to scan my eyeballs and like, where's that information going to go? And I love that you clarified that that information basically, it immediately goes to your phone, right? And then also cryptographically stored. So can we talk a little bit about secure multi-party computation just from a high level? And can I run my understanding by it?
by you and you keep me in level. So, SMPC, this is a way that the iris data is stored as I understand it. So you scan it, it's in there, it gets uploaded, but then it's broken apart into tiny little bits and pieces, right? Two little bits, or two little pieces that are then encoded, 12,800 bits, each bit is then encoded into a random integer and it just, there's a way that it keeps this.
separate it and the only way for it to come together is these multi-parties when it's needed and requested. So how does the multi-party thing work? If I get my eyeball, if I get my iris scanned and it's put in there and it's segmented and protected, who has the little pieces when I'm looking to push the button to use it?
Ajay Patel Yeah, so the secure multi-party compute implementation, so I'm not an expert in it, I'll explain kind how I explain it. So secure multi-party compute, our implementation, we call it anonymous multi-party compute, right? And the key there is anonymous. So what's stored is not, picture of your iris, right? There's this sort of, like you said, there's some data that comes out and it's distributed across multi-parties. And one of the things that we did, so on our roadmap what we did was our goal was to have multi-parties hold those different pieces. And so none of them are tools for humanity or world. It's actually four independent, non-profit universities, those types, and we're gonna expand that number. And so the idea there is that
In order to compromise a system like that you actually need to compromise all of those parties which and then becomes extremely you more and more difficult that's number one but then it's also cryptographically signed so you probably so even it's also cryptographically stored so even if you get some of the data it's going to be impossible for you to pull it back together.
And then, even if you have that code that came off your phone, let's just say that's what it is, right? Then you can't reverse it back to an image. I asked this question before I joined. was like, hey, and they're like, well, actually, if you reverse the code, you get this blob. It doesn't even look like anything.
And so the good thing is that you can never tie back. And so the user is in full control of the data. That's kind of the key. How that kind of storage and joining works is really through this super complex cryptographic system that's doing this math. And so the way that I think about it is that you ask it a question, and it gives you an answer. So it's really like you're just talking to this crystal ball.
Ajay Patel happens inside and how it gets all split up is kind of opaque to who's asking the question. It's all a part of that kind of...
And what we call that, what that's called is privacy enhancing technology. So you'll hear about PET and there's a whole research and innovation that happens in that space. And then you have these trusted execution environments which are where you can put data in, you can process it in there, and it'll give you answers out. But you don't know what data it used or none of that data ever leaves that environment. It's sort of like the technologies. so.
Ajay Patel So prior to joining, prior to taking on World ID, I was at Google and what's interesting is that PET and TEE is mostly happening in Google Labs, Google Research, right? But in production, there's not a lot of that, at the scale, that implementation at scale, actually World ID has it, as far as I know. We're doing all of those things at scale. have millions of users interacting with these systems, so it's pretty exciting.
Mark's silly questions
Mark Fielding I'm playing my silly question card. And I've got three quick questions before we hit the hot buttons, which is more short, quick questions. First question, my silly question. When I grew up, I believed that my fingerprints were unique and it turns out they're not. Are irises unique? And do they not need to be because of the technology that you're using?
Mark Fielding That's the first question. yes or no, feel free to expand on it if you like.
Ajay Patel They're the most unique. And so, you know, it's like any sort of modeling.
And there's always innovation in that modeling. we invest a lot in innovating and modeling. And so the modeling is actually what makes things more scalable. so, but from a physics perspective, iris is what is, know, DNA iris is where the most data is. The more data you have, the further it goes. Right. Now the problem with like fingerprints is also that like people that work with their hands, I didn't know this, but people that work with their hands, you can actually rub off your fingerprints. So don't even, you know, so, and reading. Yeah, exactly.
Jeremy Gilbertson Guitar players.
Ajay Patel like gut guitar players, like farmers, right? And then also interestingly enough, if you think about like, hey, we wanna get your fingerprints, yeah, nowadays when you cross a border, they'll do all these like pictures of your fingers, right? But if you have like a self-serve kind of setup, like you don't know what finger someone's putting on that thing. So it's really even harder. It's harder to assess.
uniqueness because the same human can come in and just put fingers in different orders and the system wouldn't know. So I think that this challenges when it comes to usability that also compound kind of the uniqueness aspect of things. So just things to think about when you're thinking about different methods of proving someone's human.
Mark Fielding Okay, the second one was you mentioned that four university nodes where it's distributed at the moment plans to expand that on the roadmap. How is there a number that you want to get to? I assume that's a decentralization key. So how many would you like to have? Or infinite, but.
Ajay Patel Yeah, mean, so right now we are, like four actually is like pretty awesome. And so any more than that is sort of just, it's kind of like.
doesn't add that much more decentralization. you know, because of that, because there's a lot of other things that happen, right? Because then you have like, speed and latency, right? So you guys were talking about this about blockchains, like we don't want to, we want to make sure that multi-party compute systems can still sort of handle billions of users, right? And so there's a lot of sort of layers of innovation that needs to happen. And so we're going to distribute things more this other way, you know, you know, whether you want geographic distribution, whether you want more parties, like, so I shouldn't have said like, more than four, but it's really about getting the right distribution so it's sort of global, right? And so if you like, know, something happens and one node goes down, that the whole thing doesn't go down, it's sort of like, it's kind of like data center redundancy, right? Those are the kind of concepts when we think about. But as far as like, ensuring the privacy of the user, you know, we're already at a multi-party compute solution, and so then it's just now it's about really optimizing that.
Mark Fielding That's one, Jamie, that's all yours. Linking shows, I'm linking technologies. Are you post quantum cryptography? Are you quantum secure?
Ajay Patel Yeah, we are. So the cryptography that we use is... But like, again, talk about something that's really far away.
I think there's been some really interesting quantum computing demos, but it's really like one bit that being demoed. so I think something like that, as far as like the math, it is quantum secure. But then there's other parts of the system that we're still dependent on phones and mobile OSes and all that other stuff. And that stuff is actually not, probably not.
Jeremy Gilbertson We all know that's a bit of a moving target too. So got a quick note from Lily to redo the node answer. How many nodes do you want to run through that again? Ask the question mark and then have Ajay.
Mark Fielding Sure. Okay. So you mentioned, I think you said there was four universities running the nodes. I think that's part of the decentralization key. A lot of the listeners listening to thinking on paper.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, there's three according to the note here.
Ajay Patel I it was four, but I think it's three. Sorry.
Jeremy Gilbertson yeah, however we want to do it. Go ahead.
Mark Fielding But hold on, is there four or three? What's the official line? What should I say? What's the...
Ajay Patel You can say three. Let's say three and then I'll...
Jeremy Gilbertson Okay, four partners, three, okay, there we go.
Mark Fielding three nodes. Okay, you mentioned that there was different universities controlling the nodes, you said three or four I think. People listening to thinking on paper, some of them decentralization maxis, they will pick up on that. What's the plan for that? Is that enough? What's on the roadmap? How many do you want to have? How does that affect the security of your data on world ID?
Ajay Patel Yeah, so basically we're already at a multi-party compute system, so the data is very secure. There's no magic number to the number of nodes. There's a lot of considerations there when you think about data centers. If you just think about the data centers as an analogy, there's a lot of things to consider there around speeds and redundancy and all that stuff. But yeah, so we have three nodes live today. We're planning on having more, but there isn't a magic number. But our multi-party compute system is already being used across the entire network. And from what I know, it's the largest implementation live in production today.
Jeremy Gilbertson Awesome. Guess what time it is, Mark?
Hot buttons
Mark Fielding is a hot-button time by chance.
Jeremy Gilbertson I it's, believe it is. Ajay, are you ready for this? Feel free to take a quick stretch. Mark's got five questions for you. We're gonna put a timer. 30 seconds, let's see if we can hit it. Timer.
Mark Fielding Hold on, just let's clear this for the new listeners, Jeremy. Don't forget the new listeners. The 30 seconds, five one word answers. Thinking fast, thinking slow. This is Daniel Kahneman's thinking fast. There are only right answers.
Ajay Patel Ooh, I'll say Android.
Mark Fielding AGI, humanity's greatest threat or greatest opportunity. 1984 or Blade Runner.
Mark Fielding What is one book everyone should read?
Ajay Patel Read, Write, Own by Chris Dickson.
Mark Fielding jazz or classical. And you've won a bonus question, what would you ask Elon Musk if you met him?
Ajay Patel How do you do it? When do sleep?
Mark Fielding You and you won hot buttons. Ajay, thank you for participating.
Use cases
Jeremy Gilbertson Amazing. Those were great. Let's dive into use case really quick and then we want to run into our news segment for new listeners. have a new segment. We look at what's happening in the news and tie it to the discussion. So, Ajay, talk to us about how it's being used today, where you see it going, what you're most excited about from a use case perspective.
Ajay Patel Yeah, I just realized we haven't really talked about the use cases. building a network of humans, where do they use their unique humanity? And so what's really interesting is there's actually a lot of segments and problems that we have today where proof of humanity is really, really resonating.
Um, and so for example, even like the simple things like, you know, we talked to certain creators or, um, you know, organizers of events and they're like, Hey, you know, Oh, cool. Maybe we can use this to prevent scalping, right? Like we can actually say, Hey, a unique human can only buy two tickets, right? Or are you the human that actually bought the ticket that's showing up the venue? Like, I don't know if you've been to a concert where they ask you to show the credit card you used to buy the ticket. It's like really weird, it's to ensure that.
Oasis tickets, and exclusive shoe drops
Mark Fielding It has such a great use case. England, Oasis recently they launched their new tour and the tickets were all scalped by bots Glastonbury. Every year the same thing happens. Every concert you want to go to, you have three seconds.
Ajay Patel Yeah, exclusive shoe drops, there's a problem, exclusive shoe drop or someone, one person buys all 500 shoes and then sells them, you know, at a markup, right? So there's those types of examples. There's also then like some of these interesting free trial examples where like, Hey, I just get another email address and I can get another free coupon or whatever.
And so that really kind of messes with like marketers ability to growth market and also incentivize users to convert, et cetera, et So there's like these business use cases that are interesting. And then there's like the basic, like I said, right? Good users pay with friction. So there's a lot of interest in kind of, can we use world ID for, you know.
authenticating or verifying accounts, right? And that kind of gives us a certainty of a signal. The one that I think that's really exciting is actually gaming. And so if you think about, know, my son's always complaining that a bot beat him. And so initially I'd be like, are you sure a bot beat you? Are you just not good at the game? But then the more you sort of look into it, right? I haven't played a multiplayer game in a long time, at least not as much as I did when I was younger, but like...
It's a real problem where you want to have a game tournament or you want to you want to play poker, know Or you want to do whatever online or sorry, not poker but chess, right? There's always examples of
AI or bots and chess and so here like gaming platforms can use the world ID to say hey this account is actually owned by a unique human They can ensure that that unique human only has one account right so you can't really Game that part of it and then they can have like real real human gaming and so one of the things that
Gaming, and the Razer partnership
Ajay Patel You know, we're announcing a GDC, the Game Developers Conference in San Francisco, is a really exciting partnership with Razer. So Razer is one of the largest gaming companies in the world.
They have, I think, 300 million users. they're super, I mean, this value prop definitely resonates with them, and we learned a lot about this problem from them. And so what you'll be able to do is verify your Razer account using WorldID, and then log in to the games that support their login, which there's a bunch of new titles and a bunch of titles already.
And then that game then knows that there's unique humans in that game. so if you think about like e-sports, online e-sports, I think we're going to start seeing like human only tournaments would be something that would be really awesome.
and just bring kind of certainty and trust into that entire ecosystem. And as you guys know, the gaming industry is just massive, right? And so there's a huge opportunity there. Other examples of things that we're working on or that's already live. So in World App, which is a consumer app that Tools for Humanity builds. So if you think about Tools for Humanity as the first developer on the world network, we have a consumer app and there's a mini app platform in the app. we already have 100 developers there.
So million users a day are going in and doing things with mini apps. You can play games, but then there's interesting things where users are, you can buy eSims, you can donate through that app.
Ajay Patel There's a polling app, so to your earlier point about surveys, for example, or simple voting mechanisms where I can ask a simple question and I know every answer is from a unique human, so it's not being shifted in any way by bots. There's a bunch of these, they're real use cases for real humans, but as a product person, they're kind toothbrush test, where you're putting stuff out there and seeing what people use, and that gives you an idea of where what other segments or markets that World ID could be relevant to today. And what's interesting is actually the more, when you talk to lot of business people,
A lot them don't know that they're really thinking about AI as a problem, right, or as a challenge they need to overcome, especially when it comes to how users are interacting with their platform. And so we also spend a lot of time educating the market on the value of proof of humanity based on use cases today, but then also why it's important, like kind of our earlier discussion, why it's important to be able to distinguish humans versus other things online, because it's going to become...
more more important. And it's not a problem, it's an opportunity, but if we can kind of think about that and build systems and tools based on that, then we can actually really maximize, put the human in middle and maximize the experience because ultimately that's how commerce is going to be done in the future, right?
Jeremy Gilbertson What? Yeah, brilliant. one quick thing I want to highlight too, you guys have a very cool ecosystem approach where you're not just focused on this. I mean, you're hyper focused on this one Lego block to get people proof of human kind of stuff going. But you're showing where this thing's going by little experiments and tests, like you said, and tests will become new products, will become other products. And it's really fascinating how you guys have it set up.
Mark Fielding Could we double click on Razer just for a minute because my kids aren't big gamers. Jeremy are you familiar with Razer? What kind of games do they have and is the world ID news mean that it's going to be incorporated in one game, lots of games, all the games? How's it going to work for a player?
Ajay Patel Yeah, that's a question. So Razer is like this, if you go to Razer.com, they sell a lot of different things to enable gamers. So it's actually really immersive. they sell keyboards and mice and headphones, and it's very cool brand and LEDs. And you can control everything about your gaming experience, like the entire environment.
And then they also have these interesting haptic products where the games that integrate the Razer ID can then, when you're playing a game, you'll feel things about the game. So their goal is to make this entire immersive experience. And so the games that...
integrate Razor ID, right? So think about like when you log in with Razor, underneath that account is verified by World ID, right? So that's the way to think about it, right? So it's that Lego block. So the Lego block one is I'm a unique human and I own a Razor account. And so their Razor account is then used to log into games. And so whatever games support Razor ID today, and there's a lot of them, would...
Razor would be able to share that this account is a verified human.
Mark Fielding That's a huge experiment then. This isn't a small experiment. This is across the whole Razer ecosystem. If you're using your Razer account to log into a game.
Ajay Patel Yeah, it'll take time, but that's what we're starting with. So we've just announced it. We're just getting started. There's user bootstrapping, and then we'll scale from there. And so we're excited to partner and learn together and make verified human gaming, I think.
Would you let your kids scan their irises?
Mark Fielding Okay, Jeremy, are you happy with your kids having their iris scanned to have a razor account? Sorry, should ask, I should confirm that. So to have it, you would have to have your iris scanned.
Ajay Patel You would, but to participate in the World Network, you have to be an adult. And so, sorry kids. We'll work on parent delegation at some point, but today it's, yeah, smaller level, exactly.
Jeremy Gilbertson It's a whole nother level, man. Good questions. That's awesome. And what an amazing, tangible, applicable, pertinent use case of what you guys are building. A lot of people are in idea phase. A lot of people are in test phase. A lot of people are in building something cool. People are jumping in. Not sure what to do with it yet. You're down the road, man. This is very exciting. Very exciting. It's time for the news, guys.
Mark Fielding Let's go Jeremy, hit me, yes.
Jeremy Gilbertson All right, so we talked about, we talk a lot about AI, right? And referenced AI, we said AGI a couple of times today. In the news, according to TechCrunch, Thomas Wolfe, the chief science officer of Hugging Faces, had an interesting quote about AI and kind of disappointed with the progress and basically saying, hey, AI right now is just yes men on servers, quote, right? So, as opposed to, when are we gonna create the next Einstein that's able to synthesize these amazing disparate things together to create something novel? What do you think about that when you hear that as, AI today is just yes men on servers.
Ajay Patel Yeah, I think that's true, probably, in a lot of ways, if your expectation is that you're gonna have this sort of sentient thing that's gonna be Einstein, right? Like thinking on its own type of thing. But I mean, today, AI is already doing a lot of amazing things, right? From productivity to, I think, I was reading about how scientists are using it to analyze a ton of data. There's just a lot of, it's kind of, right now, it's sort of like a,
I don't know what the right sci-fi thing is, but it's like augmenting humans, right? Which I think is really awesome and maybe eventually it'll be smart enough or sentient or whatever, the right word is, but...
Yeah, it's not that today, but I think we're on that path, which is what everyone's kind of curious about and probably afraid of if you've watched enough dystopian movies. like, yeah, my thing is it's still early. Like as long as much as like AI has progressed, it's still very early. Like it's only been two, two and a half years or something, right? Since ChatGPT
Jeremy Gilbertson You made a great statement earlier where you actually answered the question in an episode earlier. Today is the dumbest AI will be. Right? So it's like, that's, that's a really good way to think about it. Thanks. Thanks for.
The Wolfman, and the Batman analogy
Mark Fielding I'm going to push back against the Wolfman as well, because I think that the Wolfman, because A, if he's right, I don't think that matters when AI is being used so much in the West, that even if it is just a yes man on the internet, people are instilling a massive amount of trust and time in it, and it is percolating around the internet. So if it's true, we still need systems.
to protect ourselves and prove if we are human or not. And if he's true and in 10 years, 20 years, 30 years, it changes from a yes man to Einstein, what are we waiting for? Why is he standing on, why is he going on tech crunch and saying, it doesn't matter, it's just a yes man as you were almost. It seems very, I don't wanna say naive from one of them like.
companies that are at the forefront of AI, it seems almost like clickbait.
Ajay Patel It could be. The way I think about it is I think there's going to be people with different opinions all the time, right? So if you think back to the early days of the internet when I forget those people were out like, ah, this is going be nothing, right? Or when the iPhone came out, I think so many people were like, this is dumb. You can't live without a keyboard.
Nobody knows, right? But the thing is that the really interesting thing about AI today is that you don't need to be a super genius like Einstein to do amazing things because you have a super genius or at least like a sidekick. Like, know, if you're Batman and AI's Robin, that's cool, right? Like, wow, I don't need like a Superman, like AI be Superman for me. Like, if AI could make me Batman, I'm happy being Batman, right? And so, and I also think that, this idea of superintelligence is still like an idea right? I don't think we haven't proven it and so the other the Connor question is what if we never get there? Does that mean we don't even we don't do anything like that? So I think there's a lot of ways to think about it but the fact that AI augments us just like our smartphone augments us I think is really awesome and I think it should be accessible to everyone because like you don't know which kid out there that either has access or doesn't have access to internet and all these tools, which one's actually with AI maybe gonna be more accomplished than someone like Einstein or whoever else, right? We don't know that because raw intelligence is not really gonna be a thing because you have a sidekick that has that, right?
Jeremy Gilbertson Great, great thought. And listeners, if you wanna dig back into that more, we unpack Paki McCormack's Most Human Wins paper, which talks about humans getting to a higher level of abstraction and using AI to create, to build with new Lego blocks. We use the Lego block reference a lot. Listeners, especially.
Mark Fielding I just want to push on the Batman analogy for World ID. I think we're okay with people who are Batman with Robin. You're building these systems to protect us from the Joker and the Riddler.
Ajay Patel It doesn't matter what.
Ajay Patel Yeah, yeah, yeah, my comment was more general, that's my opinion, right? I mean, if I was thinking, I'm, yeah, I'll take my world ID off for that one. I wanna be Batman, okay?
The carryover question
Jeremy Gilbertson Fair enough. Well, hey listeners, every show we like to tie and thread to the other show because knowledge and wisdom is from connecting the dots between very different and disparate things. So we pull together the shows through our carryover question mark as we wrap up this wonderful conversation with Ajay. What was our carryover question from Diego from last week?
Mark Fielding Diego Borgo, Web3 marketing, big brand specialist. Are you ready for this one, Ajay?
Jeremy Gilbertson Probably the latter part of the question, Mark.
Mark Fielding Yeah, World ID is designed to prove personhood. Some people worry that biometric identity systems could be used by governments or corporations to restrict access to financial services or public benefits. How does WorldCoin ensure that World ID, I can rephrase that because it's not WorldCoin.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, reset that one, we'll edit.
Mark Fielding I'm really saying that one, How does WorldID ensure that the orb and all of your technology remains decentralised, voluntary and resistant to misuse?
Ajay Patel That's a question. if our aim is to build an identity network that is basically represented by every human, our goal is to open source and decentralize that. So that's very much a part of our mission. Our mission statement is accelerate every human, but decentralization is a core pillar of that. And so the
And World ID as an open protocol allows anyone to build on top of it. So if we think about Optin, you as a human have a choice to go get a World ID. I personally believe that it's a human right and you should have access to it, but you don't have to. Nothing's forcing you to do that. Then once you have a World ID, you have complete choice into which systems you access and no one knows anything about you unless you tell them. And so whether you're private or you're a private company, or a non-profit or a public government or something, you're building on top of these primitives. But WorldID itself does not restrict anything. It's an open protocol that is enabling access for real humans and the ability for humans to identify themselves versus other things online.
And that's kind of like, again, that building block, right? And so it can be used for benefits, it can be used for exclusive merch, it can be used for a lot of things where you want to provide a service to a unique human. And so those also can include government benefits, right? Like there's been, we've seen a lot of like in the US, like fraud when it comes to...
unemployment or whatever during COVID, all that stuff, right? Imagine if you had World ID, if American had a World ID, that could be a part of the solution to make sure that, hey, that this unique human got a payment this month and not two, right? And so those are the types of things that think World ID can be used for. But not to restrict access or not to do anything like that. At least from the protocol, that's not something that is possible.
Jeremy Gilbertson Wonderful. Got it. Ajay, thanks so much for joining us today. This has been a fascinating conversation. I love what you're doing. Would love to stay in touch as you guys kind of keep building because this is like, like you said, things are going to evolve out of this. They're going to turn into things we couldn't have even thought of. Where can people find more about you and your work in World ID?
Ajay Patel Yeah, so toolsforhumanity.com world.org, know, all of us, there's Twitter handles, there's a YouTube channel, which I actually recommend to all of my friends. There's a lot of great content there, especially if you really wanna go deep on some of the technologies. But at world.org, you can kinda see the stats of the network, it's all there on the homepage, and then there's just a lot of interesting documents and...
developer APIs if you're interested in playing with it. And then yeah, you can find me on social media as well.
Jeremy Gilbertson Sounds great. Sounds great. Thanks for joining us listeners. Stay tuned for Backstage with Mark and Jeremy. Mark, continue to, yeah, go ahead.
A question for the next guest
Jeremy Gilbertson good catch. A question for our next guest, Ajay.
Mark Fielding Who's our next guest, Jeremy?
Jeremy Gilbertson That's a great question.
Mark Fielding We're going to Hollywood next week. We are going to the foothills of Hollywood to speak to David Bianchi, NFT poet, Web3 movie producer and actor.
Ajay Patel Yes, I've seen him. He's a very intense actor. I actually really like him. Question I have for him, which is actually something that I've been thinking about, because I'm a huge fan of sci-fi growing up. And when I think about what my mindset was when I biked over to theater and watched Terminator 2 or saw Matrix or any of these things that really kind of blew my mind when most of my friends didn't understand what the hell was going on. When I watch his stuff,
What I realize is a lot of the fears or a kind of uncomfortableness that people feel about AI is really from storytelling. And so I'd love to understand, obviously the more exciting you can make it, the more people want to watch it. So the dystopian stuff is always awesome, interesting.
But guess for him, my question would be, what do you see as the intersection between humanness, art, and blockchain?
and like kind of, and how he thinks about storytelling around that, right? And is there a way to sort of, and then like, how do you balance sort of the, the positives of like, you know, storytelling can be like very positive and help people understand exactly what's, you know, what the value of all these things are and what the role of humanness and art is in the future. Or, you know, for entertainment value, there's always going to be sort of the action movie or the sci-fi movie aspect of things. And so I'd love to understand his view on the inner between human, know, humaneness or humanity, art and blockchain. Because he's kind of across all that stuff. I'm sure he has thoughts.
sure he does that'd be a very interesting question can't wait to ask him
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, Ajay, thanks so much for joining us today and stay in touch and keep up the good work over there. We're excited to see where it all goes.
Ajay Patel Will do. Thank you for having me.
Mark Fielding Thank very much. Thank you, Ajay.
Backstage
Jeremy Gilbertson All right, Mr. Fielding, we are backstage after talking with Ajay from World ID. What were your immediate takeaways, man? What did you come out of here unexpectedly learning from him today?
Mark Fielding Other than a new Hot Buttons question, which superhero are you? Which I'll now be asking you. Very...
Jeremy Gilbertson That's great.
Mark Fielding Very happy because I think a lot of people who are in blockchain know about World ID. A lot of people have heard about the orb and it's very difficult to write a news article or to report on a company who are using an orb to scan people's irises because
We're so programmed as a society to hear iScan orb, those kind of words, they're trigger words, aren't they? And they're just going to have a real powerful impact. And to hear the truth was very refreshing.
Jeremy Gilbertson Agreed, agreed. And Lily, see you're still on. You're happy to listen to this. We do a little quick unpack section at the end of it, kind of what we learned together. So if you hear anything that seems off, we're happy to edit it out again. Yeah, Mark, think where I go with this is I start thinking about stories.
Ajay mentioned his carryover question was, know, how do stories affect all of this stuff and generate fear and that sort of thing. When you hear, you know, the orb and you hear eyeball scan and it's not an eyeball scan, it's a retinal scan or it's an iris scan rather, it's an iris scan. The thing that kind of opened my mind up to it a little bit more is the fact that the scan goes directly to your phone and the scan doesn't go to some crazy database and live there with your name on it that can be taken and manipulated and used for other other purposes. It comes back to you and you automate the permissions for how it goes and that sort of thing. So after today, I'm actually more inclined to go get my iris scanned and try to figure out how to use this. And I also started thinking about how the adoption of this one Lego block. So we've got this Lego block. Someone's raised their hand and they've said, hey, I want to fix a problem that's in the world. Hopefully what I'm doing to fix the problem will be adopted by others because we're doing it authentically, we're doing it with trust, we're doing it with certainty. I love the use of his word certainty in it as well. But it's gonna be really interesting to see who adopts this as that layer of trust and identity across platforms, whether it's the old existing platforms that are out there right now, whether it's largely brand new platforms. What did you think about that? This is more a day two kind of conversation.
Mark Fielding Just you kind of cemented the word I was looking for when you first came, backstage VIP access. Relieved was a word, think that I felt like listening to what they're trying to build and how they're trying to build it. I felt a sense of relief that what I'd heard about World ID didn't reflect what they're actually trying to do. that was, the word was relief. And I agree with you.
But unfortunately I live up a mountain and I don't think that they're coming here, but you live in Atlanta, so maybe you can have yours scanned and you can let us know what you do with that data. To your question, I want to take it to step 20 because I'm still vibrating from reading Nexus. Yeah, book clubs, we read Nexus, still shaking off. Proof of humanity. At what point do we need?
Jeremy Gilbertson Still shaking that off too, holy.
Mark Fielding Proof of AI. when will you need to prove which AI is which if your, which of your AIs are yours? And if their AIs are interacting with AIs, how do the AIs prove that the AI that they're interacting with is the AI that they say that it says it is?
Jeremy Gilbertson So this would be the turtles all the way down discussion. So we talk about this a lot, Mark, and the idea of a chain of custody, right? And this is more agentic AI. So if we spin up, if I spin up an agent to handle things on my behalf, if you spin up an agent to handle things on your behalf, there's gotta be something in there that ties.
Jeremy Gilbertson me to the creator of the agent, especially if that agent is being released into the world to operate on my behalf. There has to be proof of humanity there, I would think, unless we want to have some more Harare moments where we move towards... What was the pendulum? was the Doom Utopia spectrum. I think it is a perfect application of having a little tag
Mark Fielding The doomed utopia spectrum.
Jeremy Gilbertson in those agents that can tell somebody not necessarily, hey, this agent is Jeremy's agent. It's this agent was spun up by a human. Here is some data that I'm releasing to you to understand who that human is or maybe up to me what aspects of my identity I reveal.
Mark Fielding You were listening, Jeremy. Wow, thank you.
Jeremy Gilbertson All right, well there you have it. Backstage with Mark and Jeremy post amazing discussion with Ajay from World ID. What do we have coming up? What are we excited about? Where can people go to see more about us, hear more about us?
Mark Fielding Thinking on paper.xyz, we've had a very eventful few weeks. We've been speaking to Ion Q and speaking to Star Cloud about data centers in space. We have, as mentioned in the show, Hollywood actor David Bianchi. We have, of course, Kevin Kelly in a couple of weeks, the famous Kevin Kelly. And in book club, we have a new book, which we haven't started reading. You have another two weeks. If you want to get a copy and come and read this book.
consciousness, life, computers and human natures with us, then wherever you're listening to this, write a comment. We'll send you all the info that you need.
Jeremy Gilbertson Tell you what, book club participants from the past, if you thought Carlo Rovelli's The Order of Time melted your face, this will be four or five steps deeper. Come join us, we'll unpack it together. Be curious, stay disruptive.
Mark Fielding Keep thinking on paper. See you next week.




