What Does Commerce Become in Digital Worlds?

Diego Borgo spent four years bringing some of the largest brands in the world into Web3. We are just inside of the jar, shouting at each other and trying to sell to each other.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 20 chapters

  1. The pillars, piece by piece
  2. Why brands charged for their NFTs
  3. Four years inside Adidas
  4. When the NFT became the product
  5. Why should a Coca-Cola customer care?
  6. The thought experiment
  7. What is your anchor with customers?
  8. The challenge underneath the brief
  9. Finding the undeniable truth
  10. A five year old already knows Nike
  11. Built by technologists, for technologists
  12. How people actually arrived at ChatGPT
  13. Why onboarding is patronising
  14. Hot buttons
  15. What Diego changed his mind about
  16. Scalability, and where the industry is going
  17. The hack, and the trust problem
  18. The carryover question
  19. Backstage
  20. The Kevin Kelly question, in two parts
And that’s the problem, NFTs became the product. You sold NFTs, you bought NFTs, you minted NFTs, you traded NFTs.
Diego Borgo

Diego Borgo worked with Adidas, Porsche, Salesforce, Unilever and MasterCard to bring them into Web3. He argues that brands sold NFTs as the product, instead of the experience and utility on top, and that the industry was built for technologists, by technologists.

Borgo sees the technology as nothing more than an evolution, and he calls onboarding patronising. “People don't care. People don't want to be onboarded.” He also explains how he changed his mind about AI and where he thinks it hits a bottleneck.

Diego Borgo, who says he spent four years bringing brands such as Adidas, Porsche, Salesforce, Unilever and MasterCard into Web3, argues on the Thinking On Paper podcast that most brand NFT launches failed because they sold NFTs as the product instead of using them to get closer to customers. He describes Web3 marketing as an industry “inside of the jar, shouting at each other”.

Why did most Fortune 500 brands come to Web3?

Most Fortune 500 brands came to Web3 for quick revenue, Borgo says: of the 300 plus that entered, he puts 95 % in that camp. An NFT (non-fungible token) is a unique blockchain token that records ownership of a digital item, and in his view “NFT became the product and not the enablement layer”.

How does blockchain change direct-to-consumer marketing?

Borgo frames blockchain marketing as direct-to-consumer selling “on steroids”. Direct-to-consumer, or DTC, means a brand cuts out the middleman and talks to customers itself; he says blockchain adds the ability to prove where customers have been and what they have done.

What is Diego Borgo's five-step brand framework?

Borgo's brand framework has five steps, as Jeremy summarises it from Borgo's talk: present the undeniable change, name who you are against and what you are for, show the promised land, present the counter movement, then build the movement. Borgo argues brand is the defence because “Technology is an equalizer” and nobody can steal what a brand has built.

Should Web3 stop trying to onboard people?

Web3 should stop trying to onboard people, Borgo argues, because “People don't want to be onboarded” and nobody was onboarded to ChatGPT. His new thesis is to take Web3 companies that already have product-market fit, meaning working applications people value, and meet mainstream users where they are.

Why did Diego Borgo change his mind about centralised AI?

Borgo says he changed his mind about centralised AI after seeing Google's Gemini and DeepSeek handle sensitive prompts, and now believes “whoever controls the AI controls the truth”. He names Microsoft and Google as holders of that control and sees decentralised AI, models trained across many independent computers, as early but promising.

Where Mark, Jeremy and Borgo disagree

Mark rejects Jeremy's suggestion that early brand NFTs should have been free, and pushes back on Borgo's 95 % verdict. He cites Tiffany's CryptoPunk NFT as one of the most successful brand activations in Web3, says some Louis Vuitton drops were as expensive and did worse, and warns against painting the whole space “with the same brush”.

Questions

Who is Diego Borgo?

Diego Borgo worked with Adidas, Porsche, Salesforce, Unilever and MasterCard to bring them into Web3.

Why did most brand NFT launches fail?

Diego Borgo, who says he spent four years bringing brands such as Adidas, Porsche, Salesforce, Unilever and MasterCard into Web3, argues on the Thinking On Paper podcast that most brand NFT launches failed because they sold NFTs as the product instead of using them to get closer to customers.

How does Diego Borgo describe Web3 marketing?

He describes Web3 marketing as an industry “inside of the jar, shouting at each other”.

Transcript

Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds welcome to another episode of thinking on paper where we take you the curious minded individual of the disruptor Building the new future of the world behind the scenes of the latest and greatest new technologies that are out there Not just tech for tech sake but tech to figure out what it means for you what it means for your work what it means for your family what it means for the world and news flash today we listen to the perspectives of everybody we do not curate viewpoints. We bring the truth to you every day and we unpack it together in real time. Guess what? It won't always be easy to listen to. It might be a little overloading from a technical perspective, but it will always be interesting and it'll always get you thinking up here. My name is Jeremy. This is Mark. Mark, what are we learning about today?

Mark Fielding We're learning about AI and blockchain. Jeremy, our listeners are going to be learning how perhaps one technology can help the other, how AI could solve some of the challenges of blockchain, how blockchain, perhaps more importantly, can solve some of the challenges of AI. We're to be talking about Web3 marketing, one of my own personal professional hobbies close to my heart. On this show,

Check out thinkingonpaper.xyz. We've spoken to a lot of people in blockchain. We've spoken to people about personal fitness, logistics, art, music, IP, authenticity, provenance, all these really good, great benefits of blockchain technology. But unfortunately, it's all hidden beneath a veil of inept marketing. It's all barricaded behind tech jargon that six people in the world understand. And today's

Guest Diego Borgo is going to give us his blueprint for a new type of web theme marketing that's going to change how brands think about it. So it's going to be good, Jeremy.

Jeremy Gilbertson Outstanding well, that's a thread. We've been talking about a while is you know, we've been exploring web 3 the early iteration the phases the failures the reboots the the the Technical jargon the disconnects that sort of thing. So now we're we're looking into the future. We're looking still at a collection of technologies that has a An interesting potential to me, but you know, it still hasn't all come together. So without further ado Diego Borgo, welcome to thinking on paper. Thanks for thinking with us today coming to you from Portugal. Diego, how are you feeling today?

Diego Borgo I'm good brother, thanks for having me man. I'm stoked to be here and I love the jazz you guys are already playing in the back there, so let's go.

Mark Fielding It's almost like Diego knows the hot buttons before I've even asked them speaking of jazz.

Jeremy Gilbertson There you have it. So Diego, we like to start with a question that is relatable to a lot of people when you're talking about something complex. So you have like an older relative and a few friends at the table that are non-technical. You guys are getting ready to break some bread, have a great meal. And they ask you, what is this Web3 stuff all about? Like what is blockchain? What is all this? How do you explain it to them simply and succinctly to kind of get them a little bit ahead of the curve.

Diego Borgo Yeah, would say don't even bother about it. Just think about something else. I'm joking. No, I'm joking. I'm joking. I love this space and this industry. So the thing I keep going back to is you should be seeing those type of technologies as nothing else than an evolution, right? It's just a little evolution.

Jeremy Gilbertson Wow. Yeah, I love that. Hey, that's kind of a fun answer, man. But here, well, I'm going to push you on the challenge.

The pillars, piece by piece

Diego Borgo Piss by piss, part by part, it keeps going forward, forward, forward, like everything else, like your car, things that you use at home, cell phones, things just keep evolving, a little bit, a little bit, a little bit, a little bit, and everything is focused on giving people better experience saving time or any other type of utility that humans are designed for to go after. that's kind of like the ground.

to keep things very simple, right? We don't need to be, we're building like the rock science. No, fuck that, right? It's as simple as that, which is just a little evolution. And that's a layer of an evolution on top of the internet, right? The internet is gonna keep evolving forever in different parts. I break that through in three specific areas. The first one being the interface, right? We've been, the interface of the internet, the way we connect with the internet has been evolving throughout the time.

We started with chat rooms, we started with like ICQ, SMS, SMSsengers, and now we're here. We have audio, we have video, we have all different types of engagement, how we connect, right? We're all in three different countries right now and feels that we are very close connected right now. So that's one part of it, which keeps evolving. Immersive experience is a good example of that. Augmented reality and so on, right? So I put that under the Web3 bucket.

The second pillar there is the database, right? How information is transmitted, how it goes from A to B, and that can be data, that can be money, that can be any type of information. So you're talking databases, right? And the big evolution here where blockchain is nothing else more than that database is that this database is now is decentralized, right? This database is now running to millions of computers all over the world, and it's much more secure by doing so.

because nobody can take it down, right? It doesn't belong to one entity. Plus you have transparency so everybody can look on what is being transferred left and right. So that's another part of that slight evolution on how the internet is built, right? And then the third part of that is the logic, right? Is the language, the way that things react, if this, then that, the input you give gives another output, which then, you know, I play a lot under the AI element right now, of course, which AI is evolving the logic.

Diego Borgo of the internet, the logic of how we interact with content, how we interact with services within the web. So this isn't your traditional Web3, Maxi, Twitter, Degen, description of everything is blockchain, crypto. But again, if you think about your phone, the way your phone works is because there is a stack of technology that is put together in it that makes your phone be what your phone is. And the internet is the same. And if we claim that Web3 is the next evolution of the internet,

Jeremy Gilbertson think that makes a whole lot of sense and it's relatable too because everyone knows what the internet is. Even the oldest of folks have the familiarity with that. And you mentioned infrastructure a few times and I want to go into this pretty quickly because you were involved in some pretty cool projects on the early onset of Web3 doing some really interesting things. I've always thought of the most compelling aspect of Web3 to be this idea of audience infrastructure, right? To have these purpose-built highways directly to members of your audience to enable not just one way communication, but Mark and I call it bi-directional value exchange, right? I can send stuff to the brand, the brand can send stuff to me, and we can contribute together. We all want to contribute. That's meaningful, that's human stuff. Question for you related to this first wave of Web3, and I'm wondering if the brands could have done it a little bit better.

Why brands charged for their NFTs

Jeremy Gilbertson in the fact that most brands charged for their NFTs early on, and that was their moment of engagement with Web3. Given the fact that it's audience infrastructure, digital products aside, should that have been kind of a free thing or a highway for audiences to jump on without a heavy investment?

Four years inside Adidas

Diego Borgo 100%, yeah, so for the sake of the audience, I spent the last four years working with the largest brands in the world, right, from Adidas to Porsche to Salesforce to Unilever to MasterCard, all of them, bringing that into this industry. So I know exactly what you're talking about. I couldn't agree more with you guys' thesis. I would add to that, you know, all those major brands from a retail perspective, they're all going to see now, right? Direct-to-Consumer has been like the biggest movement that all those brands have done.

I spent 40 years within Adidas helping them shape that infrastructure aside of blockchain and all of that. So DTC is nothing more than cutting the middle man. It's nothing more than getting the brand to talk directly with the customer and getting them closer than ever so you get to learn everything the customer wants and you shape your offerings to that. I think that within your guys' thesis, blockchain, Web3, NFTs, the angle we're looking here, is that on steroids. Because you're literally going direct to them. You can get input.

You can prove where they've been. can prove what they've done. And a lot of those brands that came to the space, you know, within the realm of the Fortune 500, there was 300 plus brands that entered this industry, which is quite mind-boggling if you think about it, right? Majority of them, 95 % of them came with one thing in mind. We want to make money. We want to drive revenue. We want to extract money as quick as possible because it's a product. That's what we do. We sell shoes. We want to sell NFTs.

When the NFT became the product

Diego Borgo We sell cars, we wanna sell NFTs. So NFT became the product and not the enablement layer on how brands can get closer to customers. And that's the most, the biggest problem why most of them fail.

Mark Fielding Sorry, someone's phone's going. I'm going to push back on a bit of that. I'm going to push back first on what Jeremy said about should they have been free? No, I don't think they should have been free. I think like everything, it depends. So a lot of my early work in WebVee was working and writing for LVMH. So was involved in explaining a lot of the luxury NFT activations that happened. So NFT by Tiffany, for example, and the Louis Vuitton case.

Tiff by Tiffany, was $60,000. I think it was definitely one of the most successful brand activations in Web3. But on the other hand, so some of the Louis Vuitton's, were equally as expensive and they didn't do as well. So there's something happening with the culture of the brand and how they chose to activate it that affects the success and I think influences the cost, whether it was a success or not. And I don't think all the brands were in it.

the money again I think it depends on the industry and the vertical and how they were approaching it and some of them seem to have a good heart for it many didn't and I think that there's definitely a lot of people who did it very wrong but I don't think I don't think we should necessarily paint the whole space with the same brush would you agree or not both of you

Jeremy Gilbertson I don't think we're painting the whole space with the same brush. I think we're just calling it like we saw it, I think, where, know, Diego, you hit this spot on. I thought it was really interesting. Like you can't, you can't sell the marketing enablement or the enablement of your audience as a product. Like that to me seems very disingenuous. And I think that's when people ran into some stuff. I don't know. What do you think about that?

Diego Borgo Yeah, mean, that's exactly the point, Like you're selling the technology, you're selling what makes it happen, right? You're selling the microchip, you're selling the bandwidth, right? You're not selling the experience on top of it, you're not selling the utility on top of it, you're not selling the enablement on top of it. And that's the problem, NFTs became the product. You sold NFTs, you bought NFTs, you minted NFTs, you traded NFTs. That's all we talked about, right?

To Mark's point, mean, a lot of them came, yeah, with like good intentions, quote unquote, but we can't forget those are not NGOs, right? Like they are in the business of making money. So there's nothing wrong with making money. There is ways on which you can make money that can be thinking on the long term. And there is ways of making money that you can think on the short term. Majority of them fought on the short term. And that's the classical case of innovation led by marketeers.

Right, I am a marketeer by heart. I've been a marketeer since I was 15 years old. I'm 36 right now. So I'm putting myself as part of the problem. I'm not pointing fingers. Innovation led by marketeers drives short-term growth or drives short-term thinking, you know, because it's the next high. What is cool right now? How can we get PR? How can we get big numbers so the board is excited? Budgets are short, so they need to go those bursts of things. And now you start seeing like AI-generated commercial.

Why should a Coca-Cola customer care?

Diego Borgo Why should a customer of Coca-Cola give a fuck about AI generated commercial? They shouldn't care, but that's the marketing mindset, right? we need to talk, this is an AI generated commercial. It shouldn't be the point. The point of a commercial is to convey a message and to talk close to someone's heart to create cultural relevance so they take decisions on buying the product, right? If that's AI generated made or not, it doesn't matter. So we just start seeing the repetition of that, right?

was NFTs, was metaverse, now he's AI and whatever else is gonna come next.

Jeremy Gilbertson It's an interesting piece too. Another way I look at this too is, you know, to Mark's point, you know, when these, when these things are products, when they're building digital products, right? I think we're building the products before the use of that products, those products are fully defined yet. So it's like, you know, we're not living in space yet, but you know, someone's selling me an astronaut helmet that hopefully I can use at some point, right? But you know, you got to push the boundaries, right? You got to start leaning into stuff or things, things wouldn't really get done.

The thought experiment

Jeremy Gilbertson Question for you, I would like to dive in to if you're okay with a quick, like just jumping right in, we're famous for these weird thought experiments. So I watched one of your talks where you basically put together these five steps to see the unseen, which is really cool. It's very aligned with this, know, Shane Parrish, we just did his book in book club, Clear Thinking. He talks about that a lot, but there are five steps, right? So let's use that framework.

this thought experiment so mark and I are part of a company right the company that we have has designed a shoe that limits That that limits non-contact knee injuries right and it came right out had a product That's what we got and it's working right so people don't get ACLs by twisting their knees on turf It's it we've since started launching a great brand with products akin to lululemon Like we're kind of that famous now. It's nearly a billion dollar brand but the old systems have worked really, really well for us. And I'm the CMO, Mark's the CTO, right? So he's on the tech side, I'm on the marketing side. Can you walk us through, like we've had success, we have reach, we have audience, but why should we lean into this new technology? How should we do it? And more importantly, how do we set up some KPIs to know that we've done something right?

Diego Borgo That's a hell of a mission. But let's go. mean, the first thing I would love to look into is sort of like the brand strategy. Like, where are you guys heading? What is happening five, 10 years from now? What are you guys looking to achieve? And what is sort of like that one lighthouse that you have North Star that you get to go towards that no matter what? What is that?

Jeremy Gilbertson So Mark, this is a brand question. the CMO. Let me, I'll address it. So we've largely partnered with professional athletes to start. We've really scaled. They've pushed their messaging out. We've got sponsorship partnerships with them and that is kind of trickled down to the, to the, amateurs, to the youth, to the people who are just closely affiliated with sports. So that's really been our channel. We've got a really strong community. they're pretty tech savvy. Mark can probably speak to that, but, but that's kind of, that's kind of how we, and we're big direct to consumer.

We had a, we used to go distribution. Now we built this direct to consumer strategy. have the technology infrastructure to sell that way. So that's kind of where we are today.

What is your anchor with customers?

Diego Borgo Right, what is the main anchor that you're having with your customers when you're talking to them about the problem you're solving? What is that one thing that you can do that nobody else can?

Jeremy Gilbertson The main anchor right now is that they trust our product to really prevent these knee injuries. Knee injuries can be catastrophic, right? But that's turned into like, we've got a bit of a cool factor to our product now. People are buying it because they want to be affiliated with the look and the feel and that sort of thing. That's why I reference like a Lululemon kind of thing.

Diego Borgo Right, gotcha. So if you look from that angle, are you painting a picture to them, not to the ones that have been sold, to the ones that are not part of it yet, of undeniable change that has happened? Something that our injuries happen more often because people were practicing more sports, there is any increase into certain level of injuries because, I don't know, there's less quality products out there.

What are you guys putting your hat on by saying that we can help you prevent injury and it's important because it's increasing or something like that?

Jeremy Gilbertson So the biggest trend we saw was the increase in non-contact knee injuries that are, be even career ending, right? And does that have to do with the turf? Well, maybe it has to do with the turf, but it really has to do with the shoes and how the shoes are used. So we came up with that strategy and that's really our, our differentiator from, from that perspective. And it, you know, and again, like I said, it scales and translates with this ancillary product offering that, know, sweatshirts, active wear, that sort of thing that people are really liking and getting pulled into.

The challenge underneath the brief

Mark Fielding think you've like you've just in unintentionally fallen on a big challenge that Diego probably faces every day at work is that as I'm the CTO, I kind of disagree with what you're talking about. So as a as a technology officer, you're the marketing officer, I'm more interested in the tech side. So okay, we use it a lot of fitness trackers, we want to just embrace the digital more. to do that, as all the kids are now using TikTok using fitness trackings tracking their thing, we want to take what I feel as a tech, as a CTO is an outdated.

base and I want to take it more digital. That's why you want to do web three. So that's a big disagreement. You would probably face every day between CTOs and CMOs. They want different things. Let's take it.

Finding the undeniable truth

Diego Borgo Yeah, it's an interesting play because if you look from that, that undeniable change in the world, one thing that Jeremy is looking at is that more people are getting more injured, right? Because they're practicing more sport. And what you're looking at is the digitalization element of that, right? People wanna be more connected. People wanna track their stats. The increasing movement of how you can know more about your body and you can know more about the sport you're going. I don't think that two things are different.

I think that they can convey under one umbrella, is essentially how you are building that group of people around your brand that wanted to achieve both things. People don't want to get injured and they want to track better their stats, so they improve their performance on that sense. So if you would look into that for me, that would be probably the most important element from a brand perspective that we should look from that lighthouse element.

And once we identify those two, the next thing I would move in is, know, like who, what is bigger than this that can bring people together? What is a cause? What is an enemy? What is something that we can talk emotionally to people? If you think about Patagonia, Patagonia want to save the world. Who doesn't want to save the world? Environment. Adidas did a really cool play with Parley, with, you know, recycled products.

out of plastic bottles that is in name of saving the oceans, right? Like, what is an equivalent to you guys?

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, I probably should have mentioned this at the start, Diego. I'm sorry I didn't, uh, starting to tell you about this, but all of our shoes are made from, uh, recycled water bottle components. We basically recycle them, create a polymer that makes these shoes. It's actually 97.9 % from recycled materials.

Diego Borgo Right, but is that a differentiator factor that people are buying your product because of that, or it's just that nice to have that, you know, it's interesting for people to see it? Because if this isn't sitting at the core of getting the tech connected with people that don't want to get injured, it's just nice to have, right?

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, so we lean into the messaging. The messaging resonates with the people. I think from what we've learned, and Mark can speak to more of the data side, but what we've learned is that that is partially one of the reasons why people lean on us. And we're working on more campaigns to really tie those two things together. So great point on that.

Diego Borgo Right, because that's why we need to be leaning in from a brand perspective, right? We need to go into the element of will people buy this because they want to save a planet or because they want to get together or because they want to celebrate sport or because they want to win, right? Why do people buy Nike? Because Nike is for winners. If you want to win, you buy Nike, right? That's the biggest element a brand can give you as a superhero power, right? I love to do that.

A five year old already knows Nike

Mark Fielding My son is five and he already knows that specifically about Nike. He's five years old and he knows. Somebody's told him, the culture has told him that Nike is for winners and that's what he wants. Five, that's the power of their brand but I don't think we quite have that power yet, Jeremy.

Diego Borgo Yeah, and that's what I'm seeing a little bit of dilution already, right? Because one element is the tech element of that. The other element is, you know, not wanting to get injured. And the third element, there's a sort of like sustainable play to it, right? We need to find that one message that cuts through because that brings me to the third point, which is once we identify what that cut through element, whether it's a cause or it's an enemy, whatever is bigger than us that bring people together under one umbrella.

We need to show them what the promised land looks like, right? You never get injured anymore. We are saving the ocean. This is the best way for you to track everything in one place, right? Like you're gonna revolutionize the way you work out or the way you get fit, right? That's kind of like that promised land that we need to start painting in their minds on how we can deliver something that nobody else can. That's just us. So that's the power of brand, right?

Technology is an equalizer, right? Tech is for the sake of tech as you just started a podcast with, it's just an equalizer. Everybody can start from here. If tech is here, it's here. If tech is here, everybody is an equal playground, right? But that's where we build brand on top of it. Because if you put brand on top of it, your brand is your brand. Nobody can steal that from you. People can try to replicate or emulate, but nobody can see what you've built, right? So we need to drill into that promised land that we are delivering against the stuff we said before.

so we can be so unique to you that regardless of how the market evolves, you're the owner of it.

Jeremy Gilbertson I think the biggest and we'll pop out of character in our in our thought experiment here. I think that was it. That was a fun little ride for a minute. Thanks for entertaining it. I want to highlight the framework and you guys can watch this talk that Diego has. We'll post a link in the show notes, but his framework present the undeniable change. Number two, who are we against? What are we for? Three, show the promised land. Four, present the counter movement. And then five actually build.

the movement. So he talks more about these in his talk, but I think it's really interesting. You got to find that through line, right? And you find the through line and then figure out how you build from there. I would love to dive more into this thought experiment, but I want to kind of land the plane on that because I know we're limited on time. Yeah.

Mark Fielding Can I just ask a question on it's an awesome program. Why do you think having been in a space and experience it so much that crypto and blockchain is so reluctant to embrace that way of brand building and brand culture? Why is it seemed quite almost reticent to approach that and focus on the features and focus on the tech and focus on these incomprehensible

Built by technologists, for technologists

Diego Borgo It's very simple. This industry was built for technologists, by technologists. It happened to start getting in the hands of people by mistake or just, you know, just happen. And the more it goes towards the direction, the deeper we go. We are just inside of the jar, shouting at each other and trying to sell to each other. And money is just going around in circles, right? And essentially it's all coming down to that.

It's just technology is trying to do tech for the sake of tech and whoever has the most complex and the most hype ecosystem wins. That's the race to the bottom that we currently have.

Jeremy Gilbertson And and thankful for for us writers and those who think on paper stories are harder to come up with and We're still gonna need stories. So one other thought on that Diego That I think is is interesting. We love to get your ideas on is that traditional marketers and crypto natives I think couldn't be further apart traditional marketers speaking like net promoter score. They they speak a brand strategy audience engagement and then you have on this other side, not to diminish too much, but what some of those folks are seeing, they're probably closer to my age, at least from a management perspective. You know, they see the memes that are like, when Lambo TLDR, you know, and all these little jargons. It's not just tech jargon. It's also like this crypto native jargon. How do you bring those two audiences together? Are those two groups together? And do they even need to be brought together?

How people actually arrived at ChatGPT

Diego Borgo Yeah, that's a really good point. I spent the last four years with the thesis that the way we will bring mainstream adoption to this industry is gonna be by bringing the biggest brands in the world, which as a byproduct will be bringing their audience to Web3. And as we already touched upon, it wasn't very successful at scale. And I think that one of the core elements of why it wasn't successful is because one, we are not building applications for a daily user or applications that the average Joe can see value on. Very few of them exist today. And two, we are not meeting people where they're at. We are trying to onboard. We are trying to bring the masses. We're trying to show them what we have seen. People don't care. People don't want to be onboarded.

Nobody got on boarded to chat GPT. People downloaded, saw one simple bar, typed a couple things, an entire word opened up in front of them. It changed their life and their perception. And they're like, oh yeah, I'm to pay 20 bucks for it. It's a very different approach, right? Now my new thesis, which I've been spending the last year on, is going the other way around. It's how do we get web tree companies that already have found product market fit, that have already working applications that do solve real world problems?

and how we go the other direction, how we go mainstream, how we meet people where they are, how we show them how that can improve their life, how that can give them a better experience, right? So a lot of what we've been talking about is exactly that, is this industry is so inside the jar, is so focused on the tech jargon, is so focused on the hype, is so focused on cycles, right? We're still talking cycles all the time, bear market, bull market, bear market, bull market, bear market, bull market, right? Which is not long-term thinking, which is not let's build something sustainable.

A brand is long-term thinking. You don't build a brand overnight. We've been talking about Nike and your five years old, Marc. Nike has been doing what Nike is doing now for 40, 50 years, right? It's the same thing, just cutting through, cutting through, every day, every day. We're not thinking that way. So of course, when you talk, you know, like with Web2 legacy brands, and they come into this space, like there is that mentality of like,

Diego Borgo Where do we fit? Do we bring our existing customer here or do we tap into a new audience? Do we want to just talk to the Web3 native or do we want to bring them together? There is a layer of technology which is complex by itself, but there's also a culture layer which is not a problem because people and especially brands love underground culture. That's exactly what happens in Web3. That is the sneaker hat culture back in the day.

the hip hop culture back in the day, skateboard went through the same process, and look at all those things, they're all mainstream, they're everywhere. Surfing is going through exactly that right now, right? It was always underground and now surfing is like at the forefront of a lot of mainstream places. And Web3 is still there and I don't think that is a problem. I think that's an opportunity for brands to know how to tap in an underground culture that is extremely unique and very rich. The problem is, do we bring our audience here or do we...

build a separate branch of our brand to tap into this BRD and to build something sustainable for the long term. That's a lot of times the question that I'm getting asked.

Mark Fielding Jeremy, I'm getting a call, Jeremy. It's time for hot buttons. So I'm going to stop your thought there.

Jeremy Gilbertson just let me hit one real quick. This is important. This one's important. And let's go. So I just want to make sure we highlight this onboarding word, right? And I think that was one of the biggest mistakes that that industry did. Because when you think about onboarding, what do you think about? You think about, I picture like a subway line in New York City where everyone's like kind of corralled and smushed in and they're forced to go into this line. And there's someone in the end that's going to onboard them, right?

Why onboarding is patronising

Jeremy Gilbertson Did anyone like stand with a big sign and say, we're going to onboard people to vacuum tubes. Hey, did anyone stand with a sign and say, we're going to onboard you to TCP IP? Right. So I always was like, it's bonkers, right?

Diego Borgo Yeah, yeah. And it's even worse than that because it's patronizing. Onboarding, I come here. I'm gonna tell you how this works. You don't know, Jeremy, come here. I'll tell you how this works. I'll show you my word. Okay, you're gonna catch up. You're smart enough. You're gonna figure it out. That's what we're doing.

Jeremy Gilbertson Absolutely.

Diego Borgo Cause you don't know what to do. You don't.

Mark Fielding Do you think anybody has ever succeeded in actually onboarding someone into Web3? If you think about all of the time that people have spent writing posts on LinkedIn, writing tweets on Twitter about education and onboarding, I just wonder how many have actually been onboarded, if it's like five or six people. Right.

Aware of Diego's time, I'm going to hit the hot buttons after I've got one question that I want to take a little bit deeper after the hot buttons. I've got a good question about what you've been doing for the last six months, Diego, because I think people want to know that. So let's do the hot buttons. This is five, one word answers, yes or no, thinking fast, thinking slow. You have 30 seconds. Don't think about it, very easy. Have you got a clock, Jeremy? Skateboarding or surfing?

Hot buttons

Mark Fielding Solana in one word. What's your favorite meme coin?

Mark Fielding Decentralization, security or scalability.

Mark Fielding And again, we need more questions. Well done. Thank you, Diego. Although you can't have skating and surfing, you have to choose.

Diego Borgo Both. You're never going to make that choice, sir. I'm either a both, not a either or kind of guy. It's just abundance after abundance after abundance.

Jeremy Gilbertson quick, three seconds. Two, one.

Mark Fielding You could frame that question. If you were stuck on a desert island and you had to choose one. I wonder. Yeah. So for the last year, I believe you've been working with brands at that famous intersection of AI and blockchain. And my first question really is in the last six months, having been exposed to all these brands and doing all these cool things, what have you changed your mind about?

What Diego changed his mind about

Mark Fielding regarding AI in the past six months that you didn't think you would change your mind about.

Diego Borgo What I changed my mind, I would say that I changed my mind because it got exposed to more facts. So my initial hypothesis with AI when I first got in touch with it and I started playing around was like, this is exciting and I think it's centralized, but it might not be a big deal. And the more I start playing with it and the more I start going deeper into the rabbit holes of decentralized AI.

the more they realize the size of the beast, right? Simple example, look at Gemini, right? When we started seeing all that woke content coming out of it, you go and prompt, you know, create an image of Viking and then they would have like, you know, an African looking Viking or an Asian looking Viking and people are just like, what the fuck you guys doing, right? And then DeepSeek lately came out and everybody was playing around, everybody's so excited, almost crashed the stock market, crypto went down.

because it's gonna replace Chai GPT and NVIDIA's debt and all that drama that happens in the macro economy nowadays and everything that happens. And as soon as you went on and start questioning about the Chinese government or some cultural movements that have happened within China, it would just go left or go right. let's talk about chess. No, I wouldn't really know what is your opinion about the current politics in China. Do you want me to solve mathematical problems for you?

The thing which is ringing huge alarm bells inside of me right now that has accelerated the way I've changed my mind more and more is that whoever controls the AI controls the truth. Right? Whoever controls AI controls the truth. And we are going more and more towards a world where AI is going to be extremely centralized. Right? It's in the hands of Microsoft. It's in the hands of Google. It's in the hands of the big tech players that we all know. And there is a very big risk on those models that are being trained, be trained in a biased manner that is going to shape the future of knowledge, the future of truth, where our kids are going to learn from, and they're going to be learning from a biased source, which, you know, it's going to be increasingly more difficult to differentiate what is true and what is not.

Diego Borgo That has been something that I changed my mind a lot. When I first seen it, I it wasn't a big deal. And the more I learn and the more I go deeper, the more I realize the size of the trouble.

Mark Fielding Sounds like an advert for our book club, Jeremy, a Nexus. That's exactly what we've been talking about.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, even a call, even a call back to, you know, conversations we've had with a Reed Hoffman, was it Reed? What's his last name? Reed Hoffman. so philosopher, AI ethicists, but we talked to him a really long time ago and like, so yes, you have these things that are out there. These, these, these AI's, these models, right? I always thought like a great way to do this with blockchain. So you can't change it. You can't change it at all. Whenever an AI model is built, whenever an AI is built,

Jeremy Gilbertson you actually have to basically point whatever you're pointing to the data sets and say, hey, this is trained by this data set, this data set, this data set, locked in stamped in blockchain. So you can always see it can't be amended. And the people can actually go critically think for themselves and look in the data set. Yes, cumbersome. Yes, the AIs won't develop as fast, but that could be a really interesting way to handle the whole whoever has it has a truth or some transparency.

Diego Borgo Well, is a lot happening. Sorry, Mark, you go.

Mark Fielding If it's a public blockchain.

Scalability, and where the industry is going

Diego Borgo Yeah, there is a lot going on already within that side of the industry, right? Decentralized AI, it's been around already and it's very early infancy and who knows whether it's gonna scale, whether it's gonna work or not. there is, if you keep the same fundamentals of Bitcoin when it comes to a tech standard, right? Like the peer-to-peer element of that, the nodes, the stability of the network. Of course, speed is one of the biggest...

troubles you're gonna be looking into here when it comes to scalability for sure. But an immutability which you already touched upon. The fundamentals are similar there, right? Like you can do peer to peer LLM training where if 300 people come up and say that that information is true, then it goes forward. If it doesn't, then it's of like, almost like mining, right? If you were able to solve that equation, then it goes forward. If not, it doesn't. There is a way to obviously tap into that.

The element of being decentralized, which means nobody can take it down, which of course is the beauty of Bitcoin itself because nobody can shut it down. And if someone would be able to, they would have done already because it's worth a lot of money right now to do it and nobody has done. And also there is this element of the transparency of seeing where the information is coming from. Who...

who is interested to be, that information is being transmitted forward or it's seen as true, right? So you're able to sort of like to track back to that. So I'm excited about it. I definitely think that there's a lot of elements in it that are, that make sense. But my concern within our industry is that a lot of things that make sense don't fly, right? It's just the pump and dump and it's just the memes and it's just the bullshit that goes and get lags and go forward. So, you know, like I'm...

I'm not sure how far it's gonna go, but I'm really, really fascinated by learning as much as I can about it, because I think it's a big deal.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, it's super interesting that also the scary part to me is I always like to find that thread that you can kind of pull on and tug on and the biggest thread that's gonna have the biggest impact and it's so simple. Humans love shortcuts, easy buttons, right? They love when something lands on their plate, including me, all of us, we're in this group. Something lands on your plate.

you what's the quickest way I can get it off my plate? And we don't hold space to critically think and that sort of thing. That's the biggest danger because people start relying on these models because they're, it's Google. I put all my stuff on Google Drive. I'm good. My email's with them. I search them every day. And not to pick on Google, there's plenty of others, But how do we manage that as a society? That's the hard, that's the big thing for me.

Diego Borgo Well, we need catalysts, right? We need global wide catalysts that display that certain systems are broken. I think we are coming, everything that's happening in the world right now, not to get political, is exactly that, right? It's a reaction to what has happened within the last eight years. And then a lot of people are just like, wait a minute, wait a minute, wait minute. We need to figure out something out of this, right? I don't think this direction is the direction it should be going. Maybe we need to go that way.

Those catalysts are needed. That's how humans are, right? If you're not getting at the edge of extinction, you're not really bothered about it, but once you get close to it, then you're like, okay, we need to figure out something else or we keep existing, right? And I think we're gonna need to get to that point with AI too, to be able to find what the line on the sand is. We're gonna need to cross it.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, disruptors and curious minds, something to keep in mind too, the broken system, we talk about broken systems, we talk about calcified systems, just systems that have been in place for so long. You know, we don't know why, but the systems don't appear broken to the people running the systems. So that's the catalyst that you mentioned, Diego, and I love. Guess what it's time for? Let's get into the news.

Mark Fielding Look at those graphics. They didn't work.

The hack, and the trust problem

Jeremy Gilbertson Thinking on paper news. We have one topic that that has been spinning around this week that everyone I'm sure has heard about that's adjacent to blockchain. That's adjacent to crypto The biggest hack in crypto history happened this week or was it last week? 1.4 billion by bit right biggest heist ever pointing to a certain group a specific group What what does that mean for people kind of tiptoeing in?

And what is the impact of that in your mind? I mean, I there's financial impact, but what is the impact to this, to growing this piece of the industry?

Diego Borgo Yeah, mean, people said that Kim Jong-un wanted to have some ETH OTC at zero dollar and that's why that happened. mean, it's just this year has just been like so difficult, right? Like Trump coin came out and then, you know, a bunch of other catalysts just being so, so difficult. And I say, you know,

Diego Borgo A lot of people are like, I'm not a fan of any musician or artist or anything, but a lot of people say that being Web3 is like being a Kanye West fan or a Ye fan, it's just so hard. Because every week there is something that happens and he's just like, here we go again, right? And this is another one. And of course, it's part of the industry, right? But it just makes it very difficult.

to be taken serious, it just makes it very difficult to build trust. The fundamental thing that sits at core of finance is trust, right? Like nobody wants money, that's why you trust in the bank and you leave your money with that and God knows what to do with it, but it's been safe since the 1700s, so it's gonna be fine. And we're going just through that process too, you know? So I think that the biggest point apart from of course the financial damage that it does for people that had money within the exchange is the brand, is the image, is the perception damage that it caused, right?

Jeremy Gilbertson And that was cold wallet hack too, wasn't it? I think.

Mark Fielding They tricked, it wasn't the transaction between the multisigs. They were tricked into believing there was something else. So the transaction was programmed elsewhere, but on their multisigs, they believed that it was like one eth.

Diego Borgo As far as I understood was a safe issue on the UI where they tricked the UI to show you something different, but behind it, what you sign is not what you're signing. Well, I don't know. I'm not tax-happy enough to understand any of it. I just saw headlines.

Mark Fielding Yeah. Do you think I wouldn't?

Mark Fielding Here's a question for you both on since we were on the intersection of AI and blockchain. I wonder how much AI played in that particular hack and how in the very near future, people's ability to use AI to start to hack to steal to corrupt web three as a whole, what kind of impact it might have.

Jeremy Gilbertson Don't make me trigger the dark and nefarious music again, Mark.

Mark Fielding Well, we've got Nexus tomorrow, Jeremy, so might well get into it because I think it's a valid question. mean, AI is making coding available to everybody and blockchain is coding essentially at the base. So, I mean, it goes both ways, doesn't it? Good and bad.

Diego Borgo Well, mean, out of speculation, I think that it's going to create good and bad things as always does. And the bad things is, of course, it's going to empower scammers to scam better and faster. As it empowers creators, as it empowers writers, as it empowers designers, artists to do stuff faster and better, it's going to do the same on the other side.

The carryover question

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, two pass. Choose the darker the light. Well, let's get to our carryover question. We had a great guest on last week that described quantum computing so succinctly. And we look forward to having Coleman back on from IonQ. But let me give you his question for you. And then at the end of your answer, if you could give a question for our next guest. And we'll tell you who that's going to be. very excited about. So your question, where do our current approaches break?

Can we just keep scaling forever or are we going to have to do something different at some point? So in the context of these emerging technologies.

Diego Borgo Yeah, I'll stick to AI and blockchain as we spoke majority of the show around that. I think that where AI hits a bottleneck is data integrity, right? So we've been talking about it, like how much can you trust in that data and how good that data actually is. Decentralization, right? Like who is behind it and is it biased, is it not biased? And then computation limit, right? We've seen of course,

You know Nvidia stock exploding because everybody's betting that it's gonna need a ton of chips Therefore, you know computation limits is gonna be a big a big bottleneck and then on the blockchain side It's it's it's what we already seeing anyway, right? One is speed is always about speed how much transactions per second can you actually? achieve cost You know everybody has this race to the bottom and I was joking around Solana before it's just because how how

How sustainable is something that is close to free, right? And how decentralized can that be, right? So, cost is gonna be an element. And in blockchain specifically, scalability itself is a problem, right? Like we see, you know, back on the good and old days of NFTs, you would be paying $1,500 for gas, so you could get a transaction through a chain, right? Like, how are we gonna be able to scale that as both technologies marry?

and people are prompting every second across the globe millions and millions of people doing it. And I think that we cannot just scale forever. At some point, we're going to need new architecture. We're going to need evolution on those architectures. We're going to need more modular chains that interact with each other. We're going to need zero-knowledge-proof base that will give people the privacy and ensure privacy behind the scenes as well, which I think is extremely important within every on-chain activity.

And also we're going to need more, you know, less biased AI models, but also that can, you know, sustain and process more data. So I think that one thing comes hand on hand. And as always, as long as there's money behind it, it's going to keep evolving.

Jeremy Gilbertson Good stuff. our next guest, you'll like this Diego. Our next guest is Ajay Patel, head of product at WorldCoinID. So question for Ajay, what would you ask him?

Diego Borgo Yeah, I mean, you might have heard already a lot of what I have to say throughout the show and the way I think about some things. So the thing I'll be the most excited to know is that, you know, I really see this concept of UBI, universal basic income, coming out of like different vertance, right? It became, do you know that meme that the guy has a sticker on his hand and there is like a tube that is leaking water and he's just like...

putting this sticker on it, it's a very famous meme, which essentially is like a quick fix for it, right? And UBI has been posed as the quick fix for AI going, that's okay, right? AI is gonna replace everybody, so solution for that, boom, is universal basic income, right? So if UBI will become the norm, and then a biometric identity like, you know, the one we're talking about is what's going to be differentiating whether you are a machine or a person. What are the risks that come with it, right? Because it's going to be a centralized control where governments and corporations could impose conditions for people to be qualified to be able to get that UBI, to get that money from it, right? And how does WordCoin ensure that participation becomes voluntary?

and doesn't become a tool for excluding or coercing people out of the system. So I'm going very far with that, but I'm quite excited about it.

Jeremy Gilbertson You might've just, you might've just put together a whole episode outline right there. That is a super intriguing question and I can't wait to hear what, what Ajay says about it.

Mark Fielding I definitely need to tell you, Jeremy, that for our show with WorldCoinID next week, you actually have to go find an orb and have your eyeball scanned.

Jeremy Gilbertson I'll go see where one is. I'll go see where one is.

Mark Fielding I think there's one near you. Unfortunately, there's none near me.

Jeremy Gilbertson All right, all right as long as I don't it As long as I don't end up like Tom Cruise's character in Minority Report get my eyeballs replaced and all that stuff All right. Well before we dive too deep into the darker side of things Diego Borgo. Thank you so much for joining us today I think we had a fantastic discussion on where web 3 came from maybe some things that we could do as Participants in the industry to help communicate the next version of it that is that is helpful that is accessible that is doing things that will make transactions better, experiences better, so all of that. Thank you so much for joining us today. will hit everyone with links. Come see us again and thanks for joining.

Diego Borgo Thanks for having me guys, really appreciate it.

Backstage

Jeremy Gilbertson Alright, backstage, just me and Mr. Fielding.

Mark Fielding stage, VIP access all areas. Just if you're here, thinking on paper, for you that are still here for the good ones, thinking on paper.xyz to learn more about our guest next week's WorldCoin. You'll also find information on the guest after that. We've got David Bianchi, Hollywood actor, Film 3, Web 3. We have the mighty famous Kevin Kelly coming on. So we've got some great guests thinking on paper.xyz. You can catch up on all the shows you've missed, all the shows that are coming up.

Jeremy Gilbertson Not if you're still here, they're still here. They're still here.

Mark Fielding and join the book club and come read books with us. So, Web3, marketing, AI, brands, where your thought experiment, mad, wish you'd have told me about that. What are you thinking? First thoughts, go me.

Jeremy Gilbertson can't tell you about the thought experiment for it to work the right way.

Jeremy Gilbertson Good. love it. it's called divergent thinking Mark. so yeah, I, I wanted to, I, I wanted to stay the course on that a little bit longer, but we didn't have, we didn't have the time and I wanted to maybe make sure we hit some other topics. But the, the idea of the strategy, the framework, everyone loves a strategy, especially like, you know, C level folks that are in business that need a justification as to why to listen to somebody or something, that sort of thing. So the strategy framework is really interesting to me.

Jeremy Gilbertson the tangible steps to execute the strategy. I'd be curious to learn a little bit more about, I know a lot of our listeners leading brand initiatives, leading technology initiatives for these big companies. So maybe we do a follow-up workshop or something where we say, you know, hey, brand X, Y, or put it out to everybody and say, hey, look, you can get a free workshop to figure out how to do all of this stuff or if it makes sense.

we bring Diego or someone in to lead that one hour workshop and the idea of not staying in strategy land, but to give them some tangible takeaways. I don't know. I started thinking about that as we were digging in. Yeah. What did you, what did you come away with? What were any, any aha moments besides getting slapped in the face with my thought experiment?

Mark Fielding It's funny, my knees hurting. It's like I need some kind of app to fix my ACL. I think I've hurt my ACL. If only there was a brand for that.

Mark Fielding I liked his answer on what he'd changed his mind about, about AI and the impact and the importance. I think he called it a beast at one time and I that's a acute, astute analogy. And I think we can extrapolate out if he's thinking like that and he's working with all these...

Fortune 500 brands like Shell, Adidas, Prada, Mastercard, VW, Porsche, some of the brands he's working with or has worked with. That thought is percolating very quickly around the world of business.

Jeremy Gilbertson It was a, it was a great question, Mark. And I think it's super important. You know, the reference back to our Packy McCormick, review of his, his paper, more human wins. I think the big thing to think about is like, it's changing your mind is a good thing. Adapting your thinking space is a good thing. And to be, even if you're an expert in a field, things change and things move and more so than more so now than ever, this is going to be an almost like a,

I don't know, a quarterly evolution of our place and our position in this technology as we move forward as individuals. So I thought that was a really cool question. Yeah.

The Kevin Kelly question, in two parts

Mark Fielding Well, thank you. was actually, I'm kind of, I want to ask Kevin Kelly that question because I think that...

I'd like to ask him that question in two parts. In the last six months, what's he changed his mind about AI? 20 years ago, 25 years ago when he was just starting out at Wired, he's probably got some impactful, powerful ideas there. But how can you not change your mind about AI at the moment? If you've got your eyes open, if you've got your ears open, if you're listening to the whispers of the universe, then surely you have to be.

Jeremy Gilbertson Here's why people don't change their mind because remember what we talked about, humans love shortcuts, right? And when we find a trusted source for our information, that information becomes our information. If you say something counter to information that I pulled into that is now stamped with Jeremy's information, it becomes an ego thing. I defend it no matter what. I'm not open to listen to you. I'm trying to win the battle. And that's literally half the challenge of the world today just all encompassing is if we could do better about that. So it's not as easy to change your mind. have to be curious. People have to be open to new ideas and recognize when shortcuts like Shane Parrish, our book club, Thinking Clearly, we outline all of this stuff. I think we would all be better off.

Mark Fielding So going back to what Diego was saying about that, do you think that plays a part in this broken web theme marketing in culture that's afflicting the industry that people are just, don't want, by changing how you approach brand building and culture building in blockchain, you have to change your view of the world and your view of how things work. And that's very hard, like you say, for people to do.

Jeremy Gilbertson If I were running a large company, large global brand, I would challenge my internal leadership of different groups like technology, like marketing, like product, and to have them build a working group that meets to discuss the impact of things like blockchain, AI, immersive experiences.

Spatial computing all of those things and I think that the larger ones have done it because we used to do this in music where my buddy Joe Belli and I had this music company where we advise brands on how to use music we would say hey, let's set up what we call a CoE or center of excellence around music in your organization tied into multiple stakeholders and then use that to think big and and look silly and push ideas around and try to Figure out what this stuff means to them not just grabbing what someone else is doing

So that's where my head went on that one.

Mark Fielding we had him on the show? Didn't we have him on the show? Yeah, I was thinking on payment.xyz, it will be there on Spotify. As a nice sound bite from Diego, I liked his, why is Web3 not learning really from the information that's available to it, that it has to shift this marketing viewpoint. And he said that because blockchain was a technology created and built by technologists for

Jeremy Gilbertson We had Joe on the show. Yep, we sure did.

Mark Fielding technologists, buy technology for technology. And I don't think much has changed in the 10, 15, 20 years since it was first.

Jeremy Gilbertson So was the internet? Internet was the same thing? Like, yeah.

Mark Fielding Well, that was my question to you. Was the internet, but you're bit older than me, so you probably remember the If you would probably remember the shift from Netscape to a useful, entertaining internet. It didn't take as long as blockchain is taking now, did it? Or what were those time spans like?

Jeremy Gilbertson Whoa, easy, easy.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, think the internet provided unique access to things that you weren't able to access before. So there are a couple of moments that I recall. I think it was in college and I was sitting at my big clunky computer at my apartment and I had the ability to send a message to somebody near instantaneous and get a near instantaneous response. you know, I think text texting was still early in, that as well, but that was really interesting. And then also you know, as I moved forward when jobs I had allowed me to work from wherever, that was a big moment where I was like, well, I don't have to sit at my desk in the office. I can now be somewhere else, you know, just accessing email and ordering systems and that sort of thing. So it was a series of inflection points probably over, you know, five to 10 years. yeah, I think it was, but the internet didn't come out with, you know, TCP IP hats and, you know, OSI model hats and, know, hey, I'm a,

Mark, I'm gonna onboard you to the internet. Stand in this line, go through this stuff, because you're dumb and you don't know what you're talking about. We're gonna onboard you, because we know better than you. That is a, that's a difference. We are rabbit-holing, man. We need to wrap this up.

Mark Fielding Note to future Jeremy as well. Going again to Kevin Kelly, we should have this conversation. And can we get some virtual backgrounds in here? So like we start the conversation in 1991, in like in his living room or in your living room and we have, you know, the big old clunky massive dorky computers. And as we progress through the show, the backgrounds.

update in real time to match the time that we're in and then we end the show in the far future on the rings of Saturn.

Jeremy Gilbertson That's that's a grand idea. But as you see, I can't even push the right buttons for the news segments. So, sponsors out there, drop us a line at hello at thinking on paper, right? Send us a note and that way you can sponsor Mark's grand visions of the production of the show. Thanks for listening. Thinking on paper. X Y Z for all the information. Jeremy, this is Mark. Be curious, stay disruptive.

Mark Fielding Keep thinking on paper. and reading books.

Jeremy Gilbertson No, for real, really keep thinking on paper. You'll need it.

Mark Fielding Do it now with a pen, paper, put them together, magic happens.

Jeremy Gilbertson There you have it.