Who Provides Access to Blockchain Data?

Yair Cleper met Vitalik in 2013, when Vitalik came to eToro as an intern. We had a great chat. Obviously, I didn't understand half of what he said.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 12 chapters

  1. Where the idea came from
  2. In a nutshell
  3. Interacting with the blockchain
  4. Building something scalable
  5. Some silly questions
  6. Interoperability
  7. What you can do with the data
  8. Making infrastructure scalable
  9. Quantum
  10. AI and data
  11. Vitalik at eToro
  12. A question for the next guest

Yair Cleper entered Web3 building MEV bots and found the infrastructure lacking. Lava is his answer: an access layer that lets an app reach many blockchains with a single line of code, without running a node or dealing with each chain's own RPC specification.

He explains incentive pools, which pay node runners for quality of service, and why he wants the industry to move from infrastructure to utility. He also argues that crypto incentives are misaligned, and that this year's airdrops failed to bring in new users.

Yair Cleper, CEO of MagmaDevs and a contributor to Lava Network, explains on the Thinking On Paper podcast how Lava gives apps RPC access to more than 40 blockchains with “a single line of code”, without running their own nodes or signing up with a data provider for each chain. He describes Lava as “the access layer to all web3”.

Who provides access to blockchain data?

Lava Network gives apps access to more than 40 blockchains without running their own nodes or signing up with a data provider for each chain, Yair Cleper explains.

What is RPC in blockchain?

RPC, short for remote procedure call, is “the language of the blockchain”, Cleper says: the set of queries apps use to read data from a chain and send transactions to it. Ethereum, Celestia and Solana each publish their own RPC specifications, so developers must either run nodes themselves or pay providers such as Alchemy and Blockdaemon.

How widely is Lava Network used?

Cleper says Lava is available on more than 40 chains, has handled 80 billion on-chain interactions, and served 2.6 million users in the previous month, mostly people opening wallets, DEXs and exchanges that use Lava behind the scenes. He adds that the 80 billion figure, as an industry metric, “doesn't really matter”.

How do Lava's incentive pools pay node providers?

Lava's incentive pools, launched about six months before the recording, let a blockchain put up rewards that Lava pays to node providers at the end of each month based on their quality of service, Cleper says. He calls Lava “a Uber for nodes”, because many developers already run nodes but do not earn from them.

What do Lava champions do?

Lava champions keep the network current as chains upgrade, Cleper says. A champion watches one chain's RPC specification, publishes new versions, and makes sure that once a version is live every provider on Lava supports it.

Why does Yair Cleper say crypto incentives are misaligned?

Cleper says crypto incentives today are “deeply misaligned in crypto” and that the year's airdrops, free token giveaways meant to attract users, “were a big fail”. He questions protocols that hide weak utility behind token inflation of 2%, 8% or 10% a year, and says “The crypto protocols must shift from speculation to fundamentals”.

Where Mark and Cleper disagree

Mark describes a Web3 gaming meme in which a MetaMask pop-up asks the player to confirm a transaction every time a character moves a pixel, and asks whether Lava will carry that information between chains. Cleper corrects the premise: “lava is not a bridge”, meaning it does not move assets or data across chains. It connects an app to whichever chain it chooses and saves it repeating the set-up when it moves to another.

Questions

Who provides access to blockchain data?

Lava Network gives apps access to more than 40 blockchains without running their own nodes or signing up with a data provider for each chain, Yair Cleper explains.

Who is Yair Cleper?

Yair Cleper, CEO of MagmaDevs and a contributor to Lava Network, explains on the Thinking On Paper podcast how Lava gives apps RPC access to more than 40 blockchains with “a single line of code”, without running their own nodes or signing up with a data provider for each chain.

What is Lava Network?

Lava is his answer: an access layer that lets an app reach many blockchains with a single line of code, without running a node or dealing with each chain's own RPC specification.

How did Yair Cleper get into Web3?

Yair Cleper entered Web3 building MEV bots and found the infrastructure lacking.

Transcript

Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds, welcome to another episode of Thinking on Paper. My name's Jeremy. This is Mark. We get to talk to the people building the future. They're taking old systems and reinventing them. They're creating systems that we will eventually interact with on a daily basis. We're here to help unpack that and understand it and see what it means to our lives, to our culture, to society, all that fun stuff.

Mark Fielding Mark, how are you doing today, sir? I'm good. Just a quick shout out to Ian who made our new intro trailer. Very impressed with that. Thank you, Ian. Today's show, blockchain interoperability, a lot of technical knowledge that we've been learning about. I'm very interested in today's because I've been, like a lot of people, moving tokens between chains, a wormhole from Celestia to Optimism to Arbitra, moving coins around.

Jeremy Gilbertson In the research for this show, I've stopped and wondered, hold on, what's actually happening behind the transaction? What's going on behind the scenes? How is it possible that I can move assets between chains so smoothly, so easily? I think today's guest is going to help us understand how that works. Yeah. I've always wondered too, when blockchain first started gaining some popularity a few, three or four years, it's been around forever, but three, four years ago when the Web3 thing started spinning up, I was like, man, this is a great concept, a great idea to have these trustless platforms and that sort of thing.

But then I was like, man, if all these different chains build up, are we just moving the gatekeeper? We have platforms now that are gatekeepers. And then if we have all these different chains, we have gatekeepers, but this is a way to make all these independent things work together, I think. Let's get there. Why don't you introduce our guest, Mark? Yeah. So today's guest is Yair Cleper.

Mark Fielding He's a serial founder and entrepreneur, CEO of MagmaDevs and contributor to the Lava Network, which is what we're going to be speaking about mostly today. So welcome to the show. Hey, guys. Great to be here. Thank you. Thank you for being here. And you've got a big task ahead of you today to help us understand interoperability, the modular blockchain network. Yeah, yeah. It sounds like there's a lot of my shoulders.

No, no pressure. I mean, if we jump in, so I've read the website, it's I'm from Web3, so I understand what's happening. Maybe you could just talk us through what Lava Network is, but maybe speak through the benefits. What's it doing? What's it giving me a Web3 user and what's it giving developers? Because that's two very different audiences, and I think they're going to approach this from very different spaces and places. Yeah, of course.

Where the idea came from

Yair Cleper So, you know, me and my co-founder, when we jumped right in Web3 three and a half years ago, we started to do MEV bots. He started to do that and then he dragged me in and we communicated a lot with the different blockchain. Three and a half years ago, you didn't have thousands of blockchains coming up like today, but we had the same problem. The infrastructure was shit. And it's very interesting because the way you interact with the blockchain is the same over each and every blockchain.

Read, write transaction at the end of the day, read data, fetch data, write transactions, and it's all going to the same thing. If a chain is able to bring developers, that's what they want, right? It's all about the usage, the utilities. And we realized that this piece of infrastructure is missing, right? We see that there are a few different layers in the blockchain. We have the data availability and consensus.

We have settlement execution, but nobody really specialized and give you an access layer that you can interact with it and reach every blockchain. So our first vision was that we can create, give the apps the ability to write a single line of code and get access to all the different blockchain without the need to run a node, to speak to a provider and to make it smooth that it can bring scalability, interoperability, obviously, and security while doing so.

In a nutshell

Jeremy Gilbertson This is in a nutshell. If I could expand on that, just kind of poke and prod a little bit. So I'm going to try and compare it to an existing or an older technology, right? So I come from the data center world, hardware infrastructure, that sort of thing. And you have these facilities that are interconnected, right? And within these data centers, you have something called a meet me room, which is where all of the network providers kind of bring their fiber into this one room, right?

And there is a team that usually manages like, hey, this fiber needs to connect to that fiber. And it's almost like this patch bay living in the middle to make sure that network can connect to other networks. The more it can connect to other networks, the more valuable it is, network effects, that whole thing. Am I on the right track? Is this kind of what Lava is aiming to do in the blockchain space?

Yair Cleper Have you just described an operator, Jeremy? Exactly, yeah. So I think, you know, let me start with a question. What language, guys, do you speak? What languages, if more than one? English and Spanish, English and French. Oh, OK, so Ashante and mucho gusto. I speak Hebrew, English and a bit of other languages. And if you think about the term RPC, remote procedure call, this is the language of the blockchain, right?

Interacting with the blockchain

Yair Cleper So in order to interact with the blockchain itself, you need to speak those languages and you need to understand what the RPC specification for each and every chain. And so, you know, in order to do that today, you have different options. You can run the nodes as the original, you know, the original idea behind blockchains, or you can use a great set of companies like Alchemy, Blockdaemon and ask them the question that you want to query the blockchain.

For example, what is the Ethereum price? What's the Gatsby price? If you want to mint the token, right? If you want to claim an airdrop, all of these kind of different functions are requiring a node runner to go and query the blockchain and give you back the result. Does that make sense? And that's what RCP essentially does. RPC, yeah. Who comes up with the specs of that language, right? So you have like someone who wants to create the universe.

Jeremy Gilbertson I don't know if you remember like Esperanto, right? Like create it. Hey, we're going to make a language that everyone's going to speak. You know, you create the language, but no one adopts it, then it doesn't do anything. So is this particular language universally adopted just in blockchain technology in general? This is an amazing analogy, I think. In general, RPC is the language of each and every blockchain, right?

Yair Cleper So Ethereum coming up with hundreds of different RPC APIs and they say this is how you interact. You're running a node and this is how you interact with the blockchain itself. Celestia is doing the same, Solana. Everyone has a unique, so a unique point of different APIs that you can interact with the chain with them. And today, the developers, the dApps, the wallets, they need to know this set of queries.

And I'm going to ask you something. When you're surfing the web, right? When you're surfing the web and you type in www.google, do you know what is HTTPS? Do you know what is TCPIP? What version it uses? Do you ever wonder this website is stored in North America? Is it GCP? AWS? And when we came first time to blockchain, we realized that you need to know these things. And we asked ourselves, how come is it possible?

Building something scalable

Mark Fielding How come you build a scalable, you know, a scalable domain with millions and even billions of different dApps, when every dApp needs to answer those questions? And this is exactly why we decided to found Lava. So every blockchain, just on, I just want to be clear on the RPC, so every blockchain has it, but then they're all, they have their own versions of it. So the RPC on Solana is different to Ethereum and Lava is the universal duolingo of those, connecting them, translating them.

Yair Cleper You can look at that exactly as that. You are a dApp, right? And you want to build something on Near, okay? But so what do you do? You need to get access to the data. So you can use Lava, okay? The last six months, 50% almost of the volume of Near goes through Lava, of the data requests. But then, you know, every successful dApp is going multi-chain, right? So then I need to replicate what I do with Near, I need to go now to Solana, I need to go now to Ethereum.

So how do I do that? Today, until Lava was in the picture, you need to go and find the providers, the data providers, in order to continue and expand to different chains. With Lava, with a single line of code, you have the access and you don't need to worry about, is it scalable? What is the uptime? Is it reliable? And so forth. So, and just for those that are kind of still rooted in, you know, non-blockchain, this would be like developers building, you know, you talked about multi-chain, right?

Jeremy Gilbertson It's kind of where the dApps are going, they want to be multi-chain. This is like building for iOS and building for Android and like building for these environments where, you know, those communities can interact with your application, correct? Exactly, yeah. So at the end of the day, let's say you are a wallet user, you're opening the wallet, what's happening right away? You see the account balance, right?

Yair Cleper You can make a transaction. But behind the scenes, it's exactly what you mentioned in the intro to this podcast, what happened behind the scenes? So Lava is kind of the underlying protocol that gives you the data. And the end user don't need to think, oh, do we have privacy? If next time we're going to make a, you know, claim an airdrop, do we get an error? This is exactly the problem that we came here to solve.

Some silly questions

Mark Fielding Can I ask some potentially silly questions? There's no silly questions, there's only silly answers. Reassuring to know. So your daily user, it was 160,000 daily users. To answer my, ask my silly question, I need to ask what are those 160,000 users doing? So what is the majority? Is that DeFi transactions? Is this moving coins between chains? What's the main purpose of those 160,000? What is 160,000?

Yair Cleper I'm not sure. Is that unique users on average daily? Yeah, in the last month, we have 2.6 million users that using us. And also a few millions in the last one week. So there is like, obviously, it's scaling up. But who are those users? Those are wallet users that opening the wallets, and the wallet using lava in order to get access to the chain. The users can be DEXs, right, that they need to query the data, and goes back to the chain to make the transaction, right?

Those are the users, the dApps, the wallets, the sexes, the exchanges, the DEXs. Those are the users that are actually implementing lava to be the underlying protocol. Does it make more sense? That makes sense. And which particular chains are the majority of these happening at the moment? Oh, yeah. So today, lava is, you know, is available on more than 40 chains. And you see like an enormous number of 80 billion on-chain interactions.

Those are, you know, what we mentioned before, the RPC request, the minting, staking, all of that. And that's already happening on lava. Yeah, the second part of that is what is the newest product of lava that was launched six months ago, which called the incentive pools. This is a tool for the chains themselves, that I can elaborate, obviously, if you would like a bit later. I need to ask my silly question before that.

Mark Fielding I don't know, a while ago, and I was speaking to this to Jeremy just before the show, there was a meme, and it was about Web3 gaming. And it was a picture of a player playing a game, and the character on the screen would move a pixel, and then MetaMask wallet would pop up, and it's confirmed transaction, confirm the transaction, and then the player would move another pixel, and then MetaMask would come back up, and it was confirmed transaction.

Interoperability

Mark Fielding And we talk a lot about interoperability. And if we move away from finance, and we move perhaps this layer of gaming that we often speak about, can lava do the same things? Because I assume when you're playing games between chains in the future, the same information will have to move. Is this something that lava can, will, or does already accommodate? Is that something which I should even be thinking about and asking that question?

Yair Cleper That's my silly question. It's not, obviously, it's not silly, it's a matter of definition, right? And lava is not a bridge, okay? It's not a cross-chain. Lava helps the apps to interact with a specific blockchain that they can choose every time, okay? So it's built as the access layer to all web3. And when you want to interact with a certain chain, you can implement lava. And if you move, if the dApps move for a different chain, it doesn't need to do the same process all over again.

Jeremy Gilbertson Does it answer your question? Your smart question. Thank you. Over to you, Jeremy. Yeah. So what does this mean as we look to the future where blockchain finds these great little moments to solve big problems? Like from a worldwide perspective, I mean, blockchain is doing great things today, but it's the adoption of it in new, widely adopted scenarios, we're still not quite there yet. What does lava do to help this down the road?

Yair Cleper What are you seeing? Imagine that you are a dApp developer and you know that as part of the fundamentals of web3, you have a lot of things to do. But part of that, part of the resources, part of developers, you need to contribute in implementing a cloud, a private cloud at your back garage. Is it scalable? Is it something that makes you, oh, I want to develop those applications? Not, right? So if you think about how we encourage a billion dApps coming to web3, how we encourage usability, how we encourage users that don't open a wallet and see errors, I think that this is exactly the part that lava is helping.

If you want to see a scalable industry going to more and more utility cases, I think at the end of the day, you need to solve this infrastructure problem. We call it bootstrapping your own infrastructure. You see that with the modular thesis, with the monolithic, with the chain obstruction, it doesn't matter how you call it, but there's a proliferation of different chains. Everyone wants to create his own chain to get his own sovereignty.

So all of these chains answering the same questions. How do we bootstrap the infra? It started with RPC, bring dApps to build on top of that, but then they have the same problems. Indexing, subgraphs, Oracle, all of that. And we believe that lava can be this new day primitive that everyone going to use in order to easier the building, right? It allows them to make sure that dApps are coming and they have scalable usage.

Jeremy Gilbertson We talk a lot about hierarchical systems versus emergent systems and the phenomenon of emergence, right? If you're connected or if you're connecting all of these different chains and you're witnessing these things happen over these chains, it's almost like you're looking at it. You ever witnessed like a group of starling, these birds move and one moves and they all kind of move together.

It's this beautiful like dance. It would seem interesting to me knowing that you're connected to 40 plus blockchains. You have 80 plus billion of these calls between them. You could start to like have a real interesting perch on the trends of this emergent phenomenon. Do you think about that at all? And if so, what sort of applications? This is one of the application that can build in the lava community and I see some initiatives starting to form.

What you can do with the data

Yair Cleper What you can do with this data, right? If you think that lava is designed to be invisible to the users but still you have a lot of way to contribute, you think that there's a lot of dApps that going to use this information to eventually even build this multi-chain dApps and stuff like that. You mentioned analytics. We can think about different transactions and see like for internally in a community, you say for example Near, right?

But where are the users from Near coming from, right? This is information that you can see on the blockchain. We just came up with a dashboard that shows the regions that every user is interacting with. I can maybe leave a link at the end but it shows like every country in the world from Hawaii to Japan, there are users that using lava constantly and yeah that's one of the ideas to have better insights into the community to see where they might be bottlenecks and stuff like that.

Mark Fielding On picking up on what you said, Jeremy, I think there are some big trends in the blockchain space. These new use cases, this real world utility that people are talking about, they're mostly acronyms RWA, dPIN, privacy enhancing technologies. I suppose lava can play a role in all of those moving forward. I think another one that's particularly interesting is the resurgence of Bitcoin as a programmable blockchain.

Is this, again, is this something that lava will be able to fit in? Like how, if on that note, if a new or when a new blockchain is created, a new layer one, how quickly the RPC can be incorporated into lava? First of all, thank you for the question. It's one of the great features I think we thought of at the beginning of lava, flexibility. New chains are emerging and they have all the time upgrades, they have new versioning.

Making infrastructure scalable

Yair Cleper How do we make the infrastructure scalable and flexible at the same time? So this question we addressed from the early on, right? Lava can customize each and every infrastructure for each chain. And this helps the developers to adapt to specific needs, right? So there is a concept we call lava champions. Those are the guards that are watching the specific RPC for a chain. They can come up with new versions and they make sure that once this version is live, all the providers has to support that.

All the provider has to make sure that they also develop the support needed for this chain. So I'm going to give a quick example. For example, a new chain is coming up and they're creating what I described before the incentive pool, right? They say, okay, this is the spec, this is what providers, node runners has to develop, has to support when joining this incentive pool. And then they're putting incentives, right?

They can put from 50K, 100K, it doesn't matter. But at the end of the day, the providers are joining the chain, giving the support, giving the service to the dApps. And at the end of every month, they receive the rewards based on the quality of service. So this is how we bring flexibility to new upgrades and support. So when a new chain comes on board, you have, say Mark and I are developers on that chain, where we know it top to bottom. And there's an incentive pool that's created in coming onto Lava.

And we are able to apply our skill sets and receive rewards to make that relationship between Lava and the chain that we're developing on grow and become more valuable. That's kind of the model, right? Exactly. Think about, we started Lava, as we said, it's a Uber for nodes, right? We find out that a lot of developers already running the nodes, but they don't monetize them. So if I'm a super user in one of the blockchains, and I see this incentive pool, I can join, list my nodes, at the end of the month, receive rewards for that.

Mark Fielding This concept was not even applicable before. Until now, you have a reputable node runners that you don't know if they do really the best job, right? So now chains have the tool to incentivize and give community back using this incentive. I love this little, these threads, these common threads that we have, Jeremy. But I remember last week with Coinbase, and we had Coinbase on last week, and they were talking about their desire to bring a million new developers into blockchain, because there's a shortage of developers.

And yeah, we had the same problem with our quantum guests in IBM, that this shortage of developers, and incentives, it all comes back to the power of incentives to bring more people into it. And I just, I like that little thread between last week's show and this week's show of the incentivizing developers. I don't want to go too far down the quantum hole, but I'm a quantum nerd for sure.

Quantum

Mark Fielding Do you think about quantum at all, related to like seeing the next 10 years, just from a technological landscape, and how do you think about it? Well, Jeremy, that's last week's question for, yeah, the invisible segue, you've done it. Oh my gosh, I did. Yeah, we do like to tie these shows together, Jair, and we had- That's my idea, yeah. Yeah. So what do you think about quantum, like when, post quantum cryptography?

Yair Cleper Yeah, I'm really excited about that. I will not say I'm a nerd, quantum nerd, but I definitely trying to keep up on the latest trends. And I think already governments are trying to develop kind of counter cryptography or post quantum cryptography, because it's crucial for the blockchain security, right? It can eventually break the traditional cryptographic method that we know. And if governments are already saying, oh, that's a threat, which usually they're lagging behind, I think that- Well, yeah, we want the private industry to be coming up with solutions, don't we?

Not the government for this. Yeah, no, I'm just saying if the government there, so this is a real threat, how long it takes them to keep up. So I think in general, blockchain protocols and also Lava itself, all of us, we will need to evolve to this kind of quantum resistance mechanism. And I think one of the good things of that is that the decentralization nature of the blockchain, it makes it super adaptable.

Jeremy Gilbertson And obviously, the mutual efforts are going to create this collaboration that we're going to be prepared for post quantum era. I love that. I think there's two pieces of the puzzle. Like when I think about quantum and blockchain, or quantum and Lava, just as much as I've understood lately about what Lava is doing, there's a lot of data coming out, right? Between all of your transactions and nodes and 80 billion

Mark Fielding RCPs. I think that's a lot, right? And traditional computing will get to a point where it can't handle that. And that'd be interesting to see what quantum can do to help with the data analytics side of that. But yeah, I think, what did they say last week, Mark, on the post quantum? IBM said it, we don't have to worry for at least another decade. Although, I guess next week, we have D- Wave quantum on next week, and they've just been in the news about a Chinese from Shanghai research department who have broken, but very limited, it's like 28 digit cryptography or something.

Yair Cleper So IBM said a decade, we'll ask D-Wave next week what they think. But yeah, I forgot what I was going to say. I had something in my head then, Jeremy. It's all for you, go for it. Yeah. What are you most excited about right now that you're working on related to Lava or related to something else you're developing? So I think you touched this number, 80 billion requests. And I think that this number, what was used as a metric in the industry, doesn't really matter, right?

This number can say that we are in the early beginning, or it can say that we are already advanced. But I'm super excited about the fact that you see more and more chains adopting Lava as the go-to access layer. It starts with the RPC, goes to API indexing. And I'm super excited about the opportunity that developer has today when they build it. When we started three years ago, we really needed to run a node in each and every chain.

We needed to implement from load balancers to disaster recovery, backup, all of these things that we thought, how come every data building that has to do the same? And this is a problem. This is something that we want to focus on. And one of the most exciting thing is to, in general, blockchain today, and you see how volatile it is, is that the conversation about the infrastructure has to stop, right?

We need to focus on the utility. We need to focus on bringing millions of Telegram users to use it. We need to focus on bringing millions of social apps users to use it. And I think that with Lava, you paved the way to really make it a game changer for the industry. Yeah, that conversation needs to change. I think that with so much going on in terms of these verticals, I fear that it might not come straight away, this moving from the infrastructure to the consumer utility.

AI and data

Mark Fielding My question was on about AI and data, by the way, Jeremy, if you have quantum that can help sift through all this data, and then if you incorporate AI into it as well, then maybe we can use the quantum to sift the data and AI to look for patterns. So yeah, one of the things, it's a new segment on Thinking on Paper, it's called being a founder, being an entrepreneur in blockchain, and you have quite a history.

And we have quite a few CEOs, most of our guests are CEOs and founders, entrepreneurs in different technologies. And what I did is think about, if you were starting tomorrow, a blockchain venture, where would you prioritize the majority of your time and efforts? If you were starting a new protocol, whatever it was, what would you, yeah, where would you focus the 20% that makes the 8% of the difference?

Yair Cleper I think you mentioned that in the question, we have over too much activity around infrastructure, and it's time to bring it to utility. So I will look for examples in web2tech that can be easiest implemented into blockchains. I would look for real use cases of a web2 enterprise, even government that can be much more efficient if implemented with blockchain. I heard like, California government implementing the driving plates on Avalanche.

I hear like there is a very interesting startup on Solana that taking kind of cutting the middleman of Western Bank or, you know, giving checks in third world countries like that. Those are real use cases that if implemented, nice, right, not even perfect, they can bring a lot of adoption to web3. So if you are a founder that coming from web2 with an expertise in derivatives, right, in finance, look for utilities that tomorrow can be brought into blockchain.

If you see that, the same goes to gaming. There is a lot of hype around the real world assets and so forth. That would be my two cents as a founder to founder. And yeah, that's what I personally want to see in web3. I always like to ask this question, what do you say to, because there are a lot of people who think the world still operates perfectly using databases. We're good. Yeah, databases are good.

Jeremy Gilbertson We're going to keep rocking and rolling. How do you talk to someone who is deeply entrenched in database world that says, you know, databases can do everything that blockchain does, which I know they can't, but do you ever run into that? And how does that discussion go? I can go back 10 years ago. Well, 10 years ago when I was speaking to a good friend, one of the founders of eToro, who actually introduced to me Vitalik himself.

Vitalik at eToro

Yair Cleper Vitalik came as an intern to eToro 2013. We had a great chat. Obviously, I didn't understand half of what he said. And I was ignorant enough to not follow him even. So I jumped into web3 only three, three and a half years ago. But he was talking to me about, yeah, it's not efficient, right? At the end of the day, Bitcoin is not efficient. So it grew up to serve as kind of the gold for web3, right?

Now it's trying, people are trying with Lightning and, you know, to create also smart contracts with Bitcoin. Ethereum started to come and it says like, you know, they're going to create this kind of a world computer that everyone can just write a code. That's, by the way, why my co-founder joined. He was in top intelligence force in Israel and he was like super excited about being able to write code that's going to be executed on different computers.

If you think about the beginning of Solana, they said, oh, we're going to replace the NASDAQ, right? It's inefficient. I don't see them replacing the NASDAQ yet, but they have other use cases that's going there. So I think when the world is developing today, the pace is never before. So it's very hard to say like what's going to happen to database, but you still have banks, right?

You still have a very traditional enterprises that using centralized database, and sometimes it's better. And one thought about Lava with databases, it's about caching, right? We developed at the beginning caching and we thought, oh, it's a very strong competitive advantage that we have towards other protocols. But then is what in general we did with Lava is open source stuff. So put the caching models to the providing the self that they can use it and improve their services and eventually get more rewards.

So in general, the industries go towards open source. And if I'm going to tell you now, what do you think about GPS? And I have this crazy idea like 20 years ago to create this GPS concept and stuff like that. Do you want to buy tokens or do you want to help contribute? I think you would do that, right? So this is what blockchain allows and enables, right? Everyone can be an early contributor and maybe one day meet with a big upside.

Jeremy Gilbertson Makes sense. I like it. Well, I think in your line of work, Jeremy, you meet that resistance to blockchain more regularly than perhaps Yeah, and I do. Do you come up against the friction when you mention it? Yeah, it boils down to like, to me, it seems like there's like, we're still in like laboratory mode with a lot of things from a massive scale. There's a lot of very definitive solutions that are happening in kind of a micro level, but from a macro level, like adoption across the world and the traditional way the world operates.

I think there's a resistance because it's not efficient, right? Because humans love to like grab hold of stuff and organize it and make it more efficient. That's what we do. That's like the job of the brain. How do we organize and make this more efficient? And when it's not efficient, you go find a more efficient way to do it. So yeah, I think, I don't know, just in the circles that I run in, I definitely see a, not an aversion to it, but they're watching.

They're like, okay, let's just see what these guys do for a bit. And then hopefully something unique will pop out that they can apply. I think that holds for a lot of things, that kind of waiting on the outside, culturally looking in and waiting for the big moves. But then again, so if your world is more creative and artistic, where the finance industry just has jumped into it with gusto, but the creative, the musicians and the artists, obviously much less so.

Yeah. It'll be interesting to see how it all shakes out. Yair, like we said, we like to string these shows together and this conversation has been awesome. I think I feel comfortable understanding on what LAVA is doing, the intention of this infrastructure and connecting the dots and all of that kind of stuff. It's very cool. What question would you leave for our next guest? And there's really, it could be something random that was on your brain this morning when you were having your coffee or whatever.

A question for the next guest

Yair Cleper Just what would you leave for the next guest to get them thinking and operating in a new thinking space? We spoke about open source. We spoke about the current phase of crypto and I think incentives are, today are deeply misaligned in crypto, right? You see the latest airdrops were a big fail.

You see that the airdrops all of this year was a really fail and they were not helping, I think, more adopters jumping into the ecosystem. So I think if there is one thing that should change, like how should incentive change or what is needed to change for those incentives to be better? We see many protocols today using inflation or hiding their utility with inflation, right? Inflate 2%, 8%, 10% per year.

Jeremy Gilbertson Is it the right direction or yeah, well, how do you change incentive for being better? It's a big, deep question. It's a great one. That's a great one. Well, this has been a fantastic conversation, Yair. We'll put a bunch of show notes together. Please send Mark any links to where we could point people to learn more about what you're doing. Mark, closing thoughts? And closing thoughts.

Mark Fielding If I just want, if I could have one kind of soundbite from you, since you mentioned airdrops and maybe the bigger picture from someone who's entrenched in blockchain really and who sees it, are you optimistic about the culture of blockchain and Web3? And if so, what is it that powers your optimism? I'm super bullish and optimistic. This is how I was born. That's what my mom says all the time.

Yair Cleper You took it from your dad, not from me. But I really see great signals all over. I see more entrepreneurs coming, for example, from Israel and want to solve problems. I see more utility that is being adopted now. And I think this is the time to shine, right? The crypto protocols must shift from speculation to fundamentals, right? And I think this is something that we're excited that we in Lava, we are focused on the fundamentals.

We focus on the utility. We focus how the six million unique users that use Lava in the last one month, they have great service. They don't need to worry about accessing the data. And yeah, that's what I'm really curious about to see what the future holds. Web3 in general has an amazing feature, which is decentralization. It's not one person decides what's going to change of the culture, but it's a lot of small groups that create the trend.

Jeremy Gilbertson And that's what we need to see in 2025. Excellent. Thank you. I love that. And just I want to put a point on the shift from speculation to fundamentals. I think that's a great way to describe the nonsense that we've seen over the last few years to kind of where we're headed to make the impact that this technology could. Great way to state that, Yair. I love it. Thank you. Thank you for hosting me here.

Mark Fielding And hopefully it was a nice time also for you. It was a very nice time. I hope that our listeners got something out of that. I would just like to finish with books, as we always do at Thinking on Paper. Join our book club where we read books that have stood the test of time, books that will change your mind. Thinkingonpaper.xyz we're reading Nexus by Yuval Noah Harari next.

Jeremy Gilbertson If you want to come and read it with us, we'll be doing it live. Yeah. Thinkingonpaper.xyz to join the fun. And if you don't want to read it, if you don't want to read it, come listen to us, break it down. We read chapter by chapter. We make it fun. Yeah. So let's give it a rip. Be curious. Stay disruptive. Keep thinking on paper. Bye-bye.