Can Ethereum Have Smart Transactions?

Boris Mamlyuk and Anuj Dasgupta of STXN build smart transactions for Ethereum. Asked whether tracking AI training data is the killer use case for blockchain, Mamlyuk says no single one exists. It's like saying what's the killer use case for paper?

Thinking On Paper

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 21 chapters

  1. Time travel on the blockchain
  2. What Boris does
  3. Traffic control
  4. The 99.9 percent inclusion promise
  5. Why transactions fail
  6. MEV, and what happens when you drive
  7. Block Clock, and the atomic clock problem
  8. The biggest surprise in two weeks
  9. What blockchains are actually for
  10. Do I need to know any of this to use it?
  11. Hot buttons
  12. Fraud, the bitter with the sweet
  13. The single killer use case
  14. At least they are not pretending anymore
  15. Are they afraid of it?
  16. Facebook tried this
  17. When companies act on fear
  18. The carryover question
  19. Humans and bots
  20. A question for the next guest
  21. Backstage
And our commitment is to get this right because the cost of failure is just too high, not just for us as a team, but for the ecosystem as a whole, for humanity as a whole, without sounding too grandiose.
Boris Mamlyuk, STXN

Boris Mamlyuk and Anuj build smart transactions at STXN, which add programmable conditions to single Ethereum transactions. Anuj compares the goal to Gmail's undo button: a short window to go back if you send funds to the wrong address.

They explain why so many transactions fail, why Anuj likens MEV to being unfairly overtaken in traffic, and how their Block Clock app builds a shared time from users' phones. Boris also names rampant fraud as what he dislikes about blockchain today.

Boris Mamlyuk and Anuj Dasgupta of STXN build smart transactions for Ethereum, which Mamlyuk defines as “making transactions programmable”. On the Thinking On Paper podcast, they argue that letting a transaction carry conditions, retries and rollbacks would make Ethereum usable for people who are not crypto experts. Mamlyuk says one in five transactions through the most popular Ethereum wallet fail.

Can Ethereum have smart transactions?

Smart transactions make Ethereum transactions programmable, in Boris Mamlyuk's definition. A transaction could carry conditions, retries and rollbacks, which STXN argues would make Ethereum usable for people who are not crypto experts.

How many Ethereum transactions fail, and why?

Mamlyuk says one in five transactions submitted through the most popular Ethereum wallet fail, and that the failures arrive in surges during network congestion. He blames wallet default settings, such as the slippage tolerance (the maximum price movement a user accepts before a trade cancels) and the gas fee, which look reasonable most of the time but fall short when the network is busy.

What is MEV and how does it cause failed transactions?

Mamlyuk names MEV as the second cause of failed Ethereum transactions. He describes it as what he calls “maximally extractable value”: profit that bundlers and searchers take by ordering transactions so they can sandwich other people's trades. Dasgupta compares it to being overtaken on the road by professional traders “who know how to work the system”.

Who else is working on smart transactions besides STXN?

STXN is not the only team working on smart transactions, Mamlyuk says: the largest wallet promises 99.9% inclusion rates, and Vitalik's Ethereum Improvement Proposal 7702 lets Ethereum addresses act as smart contracts in some contexts. He says STXN refuses the shortcut of private mempools, private queues of pending transactions kept off the public network, which he says deliver inclusion “at a pretty severe security cost”.

What is the STXN Block Clock app?

STXN's Block Clock app collects the time from users' phones and combines the timestamps into a consensus time, which Mamlyuk calls a decentralised network time protocol: an alternative to relying on a few atomic clocks and authoritative timekeepers. He says it passed 50,000 users in under two weeks, and that its reward, TimeToken, exists only on a test network and cannot be cashed out.

Does blockchain have a single killer use case?

Asked about talk at the World Economic Forum in Davos that tracking AI training data could be blockchain's killer use case, Mamlyuk says “there is no single killer use case for blockchain. It's like saying what's the killer use case for paper?” He argues the WEF wants blockchains classified as financial market infrastructure, and calls tying AI to blockchain “another backhanded way at effectuating capture”.

Where Mark and Mamlyuk disagree

When Mamlyuk likens crypto to the neutral Hotel Continental in the John Wick films, Mark replies that “In John Wick 4, they blow up the Continental” and asks what happens when big tech and governments act on their fear of crypto. Mamlyuk says crypto already lives with it in what he calls Operation Chokepoint 2.0: debanking, deplatforming and Google Ads campaigns blocked for using the word crypto.

Questions

Can Ethereum have smart transactions?

Smart transactions make Ethereum transactions programmable, in Boris Mamlyuk's definition. A transaction could carry conditions, retries and rollbacks, which STXN argues would make Ethereum usable for people who are not crypto experts.

What does STXN do?

Boris Mamlyuk and Anuj build smart transactions at STXN, which add programmable conditions to single Ethereum transactions.

What are smart transactions on Ethereum?

Boris Mamlyuk and Anuj Dasgupta of STXN build smart transactions for Ethereum, which Mamlyuk defines as “making transactions programmable”. On the Thinking On Paper podcast, they argue that letting a transaction carry conditions, retries and rollbacks would make Ethereum usable for people who are not crypto experts.

What is the goal of smart transactions, according to Anuj?

Anuj compares the goal to Gmail's undo button: a short window to go back if you send funds to the wrong address.

Transcript

Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds welcome to another episode of thinking on paper where we take you behind the scenes of the latest in emerging tech to help try and connect the dots to what it means for the future of humanity what it means for you as a parent as a as a business person as an entrepreneur as someone like mark who just jumps on a snowboard and runs down big hills all day long mark fielding what are we learning about today what's going on

Time travel on the blockchain

Mark Fielding It's not my job. Today, we are learning about time travel on the blockchain. We're learning about smart transactions. We're learning about real time adaptability. We're building verifiable time machines on Ethereum. And I know that sounds pretty scary and it is quite technical, but thinking on paper, we write things down, we help you understand what they really mean. So we're gonna be trying to understand.

about how we time travel on the blockchain. Our guests are Boris Mamilouk and Anuj Dasgupta from STXN. That's Smart Tracks Action Corp. I don't know if they have a more nifty way of saying that, but welcome to the show, Boris.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well real quick before we bring those guys on folks, stay tuned. We've got all your favorite segments coming up. We got Mark Fielding's Hot Buttons, we've got the news, we've got the carryover question, all of that fun stuff. So this will not be as scary if you're reading and listening to book club with us. As scary as the last chapter of Nexus that we unpacked, but time travel, entropy, all the fun stuff. Let's bring on Boris and Anoush.

What's up guys, welcome to Thinking on Paper.

Boris Mamlyuk Hey Mark, hi Jeremy, good to be here.

Jeremy Gilbertson So in our pre-production chat, we talked about you guys have a history with each other, know, known each other, been working together for about seven years. We always like to start with one question, because your technology is very interesting, but it's a little complicated. It's kind of next level, deep blockchain. So what do you tell your friends and family that are not technical when you're breaking bread, you're sharing some dinner, sharing a lunch, what do you tell them about what you do to give them a little leg up?

Boris Mamlyuk you want to give it a go?

Anuj Yeah, I mean I usually tell people that you know, you don't need to care about blockchains because I mean, let's be honest I mean it's kind of useless because when was the last time most people did a trade really it's not for everybody but if WhatsApp or Telegram or Airbnb shuts down even for 30 seconds WhatsApp shuts down I think they're gonna be like in crisis it's coming on the news but if not if Ethereum shuts down for three hours most people won't even know it what oh yeah I've heard about that thing

And that's going to change with what we do because we're going to real applications on the blockchain. That means you can get your favorite apps. You don't have to think about who is stealing my data, what's happening to this and that is a real person behind the scenes. All of that trust, not a problem. Blockchain, that's the promise of blockchain. And that's what we want to bring to everything. So that's what we tell people that, you know, that soon they will be invested in blockchains.

Jeremy Gilbertson Boris, what do you do on your side? Yeah.

What Boris does

Boris Mamlyuk Yeah. So if yeah, if you, yeah, if you think about transactions and blockchain or just regular day-to-day non-blockchain life, you think about swapping one asset for another, or you may think about sending or paying right for a loaf of bread. Smart transactions introduces the idea of programmability to individual transactions. So imagine if you could encode conditional logics.

What you can do is you can create arbitrarily complex transactional chains that enable new forms of economic exchange, new types of social organization. So smart transactions in a nutshell is making transactions programmable. It puts the power of smart contracts and individual transactions and the utility of that and the applications of that really touch everything from point of sale payments all the way to really complex financial derivatives upon derivatives upon derivatives.

Mark Fielding Is this possible because of Ethereum? Because of the blockchain? Is this something that you have done specifically that didn't exist before? Is this an improvement protocol? Like where does this come from?

Boris Mamlyuk Yeah, so there, there. Go ahead.

Anuj You have a transaction so transaction is anything that you do online like we have a conversation I'm saying something you're saying something in return. That's a transaction so on chain or online You're paying for something and the next thing you know, the thing is shipped to you. That's a transaction So Ethereum already has transactions where I want to send you eat so you request the eat I send you eat that's a transaction But what we are doing is currently for most people is going to use Ethereum

It's kind of complex. It's not easy. And, you know, products that are built in a not smart way makes smart people feel they are not smart. But if something is built in really smart way, even the dumb people feel they are smart because it that's the beauty of building something smart and blockchains are not smart. Let's be honest. I mean, it's not usable for most people. It's not like an iPhone where anybody even have to be trained to use an iPhone. And so what we do is we take

We took the existing transaction that exists, how it works and everything. You're not changing that. We're just making it so that if you want to buy and eat and you don't remember the exact address, you don't have to fret about it because with our system, if you pay the wrong person, it'll come back to you. Like you can have rewards and rollbacks like you do in regular banking transactions, you know. So, you know, that's what we're adding.

Jeremy Gilbertson You're like, you're lagging up just a touch Anuj, but let me see if I can throw this analogy out at you and this could be a completely ridiculous analogy, but I'm gonna give it a rip. So right now the way many people understand blockchain to be is there are different chains, there are different protocols, different layer ones, layer twos, all of that kind of stuff. And if you look at each of these, each of these protocols as a single lane highway, right? And you have these interactions happening down all of these single lane highways. Now, are what you're saying that your technology can do is make better use of the interactions that happen on these single lane highways and also between single lane highways? So is this like a multi-chain kind of enablement or is that something completely off the mark?

Boris Mamlyuk Yeah, I like that analogy. To extend the analogy a little bit further and then situate STXN within it. think we can, we usually think of blockchains as being that highway that only goes in one direction. It's a depend only ledger. The traffic can only go in one way. And so as a result, if there's a traffic jam, if it's rush hour traffic on the Poro 5 freeway in LAX, you're stuck. You're stuck for three hours. What we're doing at STXN in relation to this analogy is something like a hyperloop, but it's a open source hyperloop that goes underneath the highway, across the highway, allows for bi-directional travel.

hence the time machine dimension and the time travel dimension in Ethereum and enables overhead crossing. So what we're doing is we're augmenting the capacity of the blockchain ecosystem, primarily within Ethereum land, which is Ethereum and its peripheries and its adjutants, but also a cross chain with time.

Traffic control

Jeremy Gilbertson So could this be like traffic cop, air traffic control kind of thing? A little bit optimization of routes and paths and...

Anuj I mean, yeah, and some is yes, some is yes. mean, it's also a big part of it is just like, you are able to like what smartphone was to a phone. It's some something like that. It just makes it more easier to use because right now most people using blockchains, they're kind of scared of the if they make a mistake, the money is stuck. Like there's nothing you can do about it. But with what we time travel, which is

Boris Mamlyuk You can think of it like that.

Anuj You know, it's like on Gmail, if you send a wrong email, you get the five seconds to, you know, say undo or unsend or something like that. That's like time travel. Like you did something and it almost gives you, not, you don't actually go in the past in Gmail, but it gives you the feeling that as if you have second thoughts, you can always cancel. So simple things like this make it so much smarter. And that's what, yeah.

The 99.9 percent inclusion promise

Boris Mamlyuk Yeah, and to add a data point so that this doesn't come across as just subjective impressions, especially when we're throwing around words like dumb transactions and smart transactions. Right now, one in five transactions that are submitted through the most popular Ethereum wallet end up failing. So going back to that, traffic analogy, imagine one in five cars never make it to their destination, but nevertheless end up spending money and time on gas, end up spending precious resources to make the journey, but they never arrive there. I think the audience will agree that's a pretty dumb mode of transportation. That's a pretty dumb setup, especially because you can't really control for transaction inclusion. You can't really guarantee that you're going to be one of those four-fifths that ultimately ends up at their destination. So that's a pretty bad setup. That's a raw deal. We're not the only team within Ethereum that's tackling this. That largest wallet that we were just mentioning has their own approach to smart transactions that they introduced.

that promises to have 99.9 % transaction inclusion rates, cheaper transaction flow and so forth. There are proposals from people like Vitalik himself who introduced an Ethereum improvement proposal called 7702 that promises to make Ethereum wallets, Ethereum addresses rather, act as smart contracts in particular contexts, which is kind of like putting the power of smart contracts in specific types of transactions. And so there are lots of teams that are tackling this problem space head on. What we're doing, what differentiates us is we are committed to doing so in a maximally transparent, maximally Ethereum manner, as opposed to taking a shortcut, which is just privatizing the plumbing, privatizing the transaction flow, building what are known as private mempools.

Boris Mamlyuk and giving great transaction inclusion rates, but at a pretty severe security cost. And so that's our chief differentiator, which is we are Ethereum to the core. We've been here since the very beginning. And our commitment is to get this right because the cost of failure is just too high, not just for us as a team, but for the ecosystem as a whole, for humanity as a whole, without sounding too grandiose.

Jeremy Gilbertson No, that's interesting. Real quick, Mark, I've got a quick follow-up on that. Something you mentioned, Boris, I thought was really interesting. So the programmable nature of smart contracts but incorporated into these transactions. Is that where you're kind of leaning on there?

Boris Mamlyuk Correct, greatly simplified because ain't nobody got time to write a smart contract and deploy it on the blockchain. As Anuj said, that flow, that UX flow is first gen nerd speak. Right now in order to actually use blockchains, you need new infrastructure that makes this incredibly easy.

Mark Fielding Can I speak as somebody this is my kind of technology I'm not a developer, but I am Heavily into farming air drops and exploring blockchain and trying to work out where the interesting Protocols are I've had a lot of transactions blocked. I've had a lot of transactions failed I think we're speaking now to a crypto native audience. That's sorry if you're listening and you're not a crypto native, but I think that

This is gonna be really invaluable for crypto native people to understand what you're actually trying to do here. So first of all, could you explain why four out of five transactions fail, for whatever reason that is, and then explain how programmable contracts alleviate that problem first?

Why transactions fail

Boris Mamlyuk Yeah, so the huge failure rate currently has to do with two things. One is sort of default settings and a lot of wallets that set seemingly reasonable tolerances for a particular transaction. So let's say a slippage tolerance or a gas fee that are reasonable for most situations, but in moments of heavy network congestion or yeah, it's just heavy usage.

those might be inadequate and so you have entire batches or swaths of transactions where you're sitting at a computer, you're trying to click on a button to save a position from being liquidated and you're just getting failure upon failure upon failure, which compounds. So that 20 % failure rate or 15 to 20 % depending on the wallet or depending on the blockchain, it isn't just consistent or predictable, it often comes in surges.

where you have periods of relative low congestion, everything's going smooth, much like your highway analogy. And then there's a traffic jam, there's a crash, and everything goes to smithereens. And you can have a situation where you're ready to pound the monitor because you're having failure upon failure upon failure. That's reason number one. Reason number two has to do with the block production chain, the actors who are involved in the process of bundling transactions together and ultimately submitting them to validators. And those bundlers, transaction searchers are optimizing for high value transaction bundles, which they can then exploit in what's known as MEV, maximally extractable value. So they can structure the transaction chain in such a way that they can sandwich trades and so forth. And these two elements combined to exacerbate the problem. And there are of course a lot of additional kind of problem sets within that as well.

MEV, and what happens when you drive

Anuj Actually, MEV happens all the time when we are driving. So when we are driving, we get overtaken by other people. And they reach faster. And next thing we know, we get so much overtaken that we are waiting in traffic forever. And next thing you know, we couldn't reach on time. And then we have to make other plans. And that's what MEV is, just getting unfairly overtaken by people, for example, who are professional traders.

who know how to work the system. And they will work the system. They know the side lanes, they know the people, they know the controller, they know. And so you are at a loss. You can't do nothing about it. And what are the ways we think about it? This is that if instead of thinking of this as only a one way lane, which is Ethereum, that once you do something, you cannot come back. It's a Pendolle ledger and all that.

If we introduce the capacity to go back and retry within a certain window, like the Gmail example, we can undo an email. That means if you suddenly get stuck or you see somebody is overtaking a lot, you can go back and take another route.

So we... Yeah. That's it, that's it, that's it.

Jeremy Gilbertson That's an, sorry, go ahead.

Jeremy Gilbertson I love that we're staying in this traffic analogy. continuing this, so Boris, you mentioned the idea of default settings. And I think this is common in a lot of different technologies. Like you think about this video conferencing thing that we're working on right now. Back in the day, it took a lot of know-how to get video encoded and decoded and muxed and demuxed and all of that kind of stuff. But now it's very easy to do. So the analogy back to the road would be like, hey, if everyone was at cruise control, at 62 miles an hour perpetually without taking into account the turns and the things and all of that kind of stuff, I think I'm starting to see that you're now enabling automatically some of the magic that the experts have to people that don't actually have access to that magic.

Boris Mamlyuk Absolutely. yeah, and lest we be seen as being sort of a crypto project serving only crypto natives, Mark, to your point, it's really important to point out that although we're doing deep Ethereum infrastructure, we're also app developers. And so we have demos for smart transactions that are live, that are in prod.

Boris Mamlyuk We have hundreds of thousands of beta testers, essentially real humans, that are clicking buttons to do social but useful work and are being rewarded by protocols. And so without, again, without embellishment, without exaggeration, right now, as we speak, we have two apps that are the easiest entry points for crypto curious people to go from zero to full fledged Ethereum on the market, full stop.

And that's something we're incredibly proud of. Available in every single market that Google and Apple serve. Rated E for everyone. Huge accomplishments because of the highly politicized, geographically bounded nature of blockchain politics and global governance. so again, lest we be misconstrued as being Ethereum nerds for Ethereum, we are launching and running apps that are open to everybody and that are inviting completely new network participants that may not even know that this is run on smart transactions or that all of this is happening in Ethereum.

Anuj including our including our five year old kids who have downloaded who actually are users and we have five year old four year old who are full of Therians and we didn't have to explain to them anything how those apps work.

Mark Fielding What are steps? There's finance steps, education steps...

Boris Mamlyuk What were you asking Mark?

Mark Fielding what are they doing on the apps, the five year olds or anybody, what would a crypto curious person be doing on one of these apps?

Block Clock, and the atomic clock problem

Boris Mamlyuk Yeah. yeah. So, so you had mentioned, these financial apps and straight off the bat? No, absolutely not. So they include very similar or functionally equivalent, utility to what is known as a wallet or a crypto wallet app. So they generate private keys, they generate Ethereum addresses. You can do wallet type stuff with these apps.

but they're not financial in nature. One of them, which we launched just a few weeks ago, and we already have more than 50,000 users, is an app called Block Clock. It's an app that opens to a button, you press it and it sends your local machine time, your phone time, to our decentralized backend.

The backend compiles all these timestamps and builds a consensus time. So it's a crowd clock. In technical terms, it's a decentralized network time protocol. So the way that we get time usually is in a very centralized.

server client model. There are few atomic clocks, are few authoritative timekeepers that spit out time signatures to billions of people all around the world. That works most of the time, pun intended, but there are occasional async or the clocks go out of sync with catastrophic effect.

catastrophic on the markets, catastrophic in terms of entire platforms going down. And so it's really important to have an alternative and an additional way of keeping track of time that is not reliant on centralized time. And so what we did is we flipped the script and we built a decentralized network time protocol that's live in an app, 99.9 % of the time, again, pun intended.

Boris Mamlyuk It's going to be showing the same time that we're getting from the atomic clocks. But in those rare instances where it's saying, uh-oh, the clocks are out of sync, the world's clocks are out of sync. We generate a very valuable market signal and a very valuable kind of tech signal. It's like an Atlassian dashboard just for time. And that's just the front-facing utility. Behind the scenes, we also have a pretty naughty web three browser.

That's built into our app and like we said earlier like full key management. So you go from literally zero You don't need to buy anything there. We're not selling you anything you go from zero to installing an app Contributing your timestamps and being rewarded by a protocol for doing that. We think that's pretty cool

Jeremy Gilbertson So feeding my information based on what my timestamp locally says, feeding the platform with that is, so I'm helping you with time. Right, so check this out. Disruptors and Curious Minds, if you call back to when Mark and I completely unpacked Carlo Rivelli's The Order of Time, if you want to jump in and nerd out on time and entropy and all of that stuff, hit that episode. But Boris, this is really cool.

What sort of outputs, how long has Block Clock been up and running?

Boris Mamlyuk Less than two weeks and we got more than 50,000 timekeepers.

Jeremy Gilbertson wow, so this is fresh. All right, so what's the big...

What's the biggest takeaway in the last two weeks that like blew your mind about like, cause you always, when you start something, it's like, Hey, we're going to try this and you have intentions of what it might look like. What's the most surprising thing in the last two weeks that's come out of this experiment for you guys.

The biggest surprise in two weeks

Boris Mamlyuk Yeah, so the most surprising thing is the old Ethereum adage and it's not only Ethereum, right? Incentives drive behavior. Incentives matter. So the reward for clicking the button is a token called TimeToken. It is currently on our test net. So it's not like you can quote unquote cash out and you know, buy other cryptocurrencies for it. It's a fake imaginary cryptocurrency for now. Nevertheless, we have hardcore timekeepers that are publicly bragging about hitting the button thousands of times. So one guy on Twitter on X was saying, I've got more than 3000 time tokens. And these are people right who have lives who have families that are tapping the button.

doing useful work because they understand that we wouldn't have launched this unless it was useful in the hope that their protocol rewards are gonna be worth something or doing something meaningful. That's really, really cool and that's really surprising.

What blockchains are actually for

Anuj You know, everybody thinks blockchains are only about money, but at the same time time is money. So we are taking blockchains back to time.

And that was Nakamoto never. That's what Nakamoto called it. Nakamoto did not call it blockchain. He used the word time chain to refer to what we now call blockchains. So Nakamoto was all about time. was so a big part of our work is inspired among many things Nakamoto's own words about what he was trying to do. He was trying to invent a way for people to make sure that every 10 minutes is 10 minutes. And that 10 minutes would not be just based on the atomic clock.

Jeremy Gilbertson It's almost like the proof of time protocol, yeah.

Anuj But people talking to each other and figuring out, is this good enough for 10 minutes? And I think that's a more organic human sense. it's almost connect the psychological sense of time with the physical labor of time, which clocks don't give clocks. Sometimes something seems like 10 minutes, but it's actually one hour. But here when you actually do the work and it's actually 10 minutes, it's actually 10 minutes in Bitcoin. In the case of our case.

You actually create a time everybody together to collective. It's the world's first collective democratic time is what we have built.

Jeremy Gilbertson really cool. think you know hopefully you know with you guys creating this like this oracle for time let's say right you know maybe people will start to value the 1,440 minutes that each of us has in our day right because it's hard to hard to hard to value stamp that. Let's move to hot buttons Mark. Let's let's let's fire into hot buns. So this is a segment guys we're gonna Mark's gonna fire a couple of questions at you.

We're aiming to get this done in 30 seconds. It's a fun little experiment. I'll throw a timer up. Mark, are you ready?

Do I need to know any of this to use it?

Mark Fielding I am ready just and then after I've got a question burning a hole in my head which I need to ask after the hot buttons because

Jeremy Gilbertson Ooh, is it, does it relate to the time thing? Let's keep it here then. Let's keep it here.

Mark Fielding It doesn't relate to the time thing. I want to go back to the actual what's happening with the smart transactions. Is it direct result of EIP 7702? And I want to play my stupid question card because I don't understand where the smart transaction is taking place. Like what needs to happen in Ethereum in all the layer twos?

for me to be able to use it as a user. Can I use my Rabi wallet and go on Uniswappers? And is it taking place on my wallet? Is it taking place on the DAP? Like where is it taking place? And follow on question for a user like me, what's the experience look like? What do I have to know? What do I have to do to make a smart transaction to, so I don't get foot run by the box and I can actually get some benefit from this smart transaction.

Anuj Yes, yes, yes, you don't need them.

Anuj any wallet that you use, there will be a kind of a button to enable smart transactions. And the moment you enable, you suddenly have new features in your transactions. Those features could be, please have my transaction, whatever you're doing on-chain, happen in this amount of time. Or please take 0.001 ETH every month because I'm subscribed to some kind of service.

or never make sure that I cannot receive funds from an address originating from North Korea. You know, all these kinds of stuff will be automatically done. Any wallet or any system could enable this and you just have to do yes. And then it will be like a conversational dialogue, like I want to do this and do that. And it will figure out how to make that happen. That's for a user. And from infrastructure perspective, we are purely L1.

So it's not L2, it's very core Ethereum. So we are working with, currently Ethereum has a PBS model. So there are people who are building the blocks and people who are called basically solving the MEV, they're called MEV solvers or searchers. And we are working with these actors like core Ethereum validators and nodes that actually keep the system up. We working with them to add these services on the server side.

And the user all have to do is just like enable that or in the case of block clock, you have to do nothing. Just download that and magically you send time, which has almost no financial value unless the financial as it, but it is so smart, it can still get confirmed. Which is currently difficult in in in theory as you can imagine. yeah, and 7702 hours, not a consequence of 7702. It's kind of the other way around in many ways.

But more interestingly, it's like, you know, sometimes it comes for idea to happen. And then different people said calculus was invented by Newton and Leibniz independently. So it's a bit like that. It is time, once intended for, you know, time to be democratized for smart transactions to be here. you know, Vigalik has his own proposal, we have our own, but, you know, we do, are friends. So we, you know,

Anuj cross-border net, of course.

Mark Fielding Okay, interest, lost the last one.

Jeremy Gilbertson Got it, got it. All right, well let's, hey, let's move the hot buttons. Stretch it out, guys. Here we go, Mark Fielding. Nope, I'm going to hot buttons, Mark. We're going right now.

Mark Fielding Hold on, hold on, hold on. Just so people are listening while they're wondering what hot burns is. Think Daniel Kahneman thinking fast, thinking slow. This is thinking fast. One question, one word answers. Might be related to technology, might not.

Hot buttons

Mark Fielding Question number one, Boris, Vitalik or Gavin Wood?

Mark Fielding Err, Anuj, what's your superpower? One word.

Mark Fielding Boris, Jazz or Classical?

Mark Fielding and urge the benefit of blockchain in one word.

Mark Fielding Excellent five and five you did it. Thank you That was good and just on the main coin question because I know in the pre show you said ask us anything so Maybe you love meme coins. Maybe you don't but both of you. What do you really? Dislike about what's happening in blockchain today

Jeremy Gilbertson Well done guys, well done.

Fraud, the bitter with the sweet

Boris Mamlyuk rampant fraud. It's so easy. this is the bitter with the sweets. So the same superpower that allows blockchain to be this really transformation in human consensus and human social organization. These are consensus engines, not just financial tools. This isn't just financial infrastructure. This is general purpose consensus.

The same thing that makes them so powerful, which is their permissionless nature anybody can do whatever they want on chain Is one of the one of the Kings in the armor, which is that malicious actors can do really malicious things on chain? Often without any accountability or for the time being without any accountability But their reckoning is coming because what happens on chain stays on chain and it's it's ultimately going to be easy to detract them and bring them to justice. But there's a ton of fraud. Satoshi says a certain amount of fraud is accepted as unavoidable. Anuj has a terrific blog analyzing this part of the Satoshi lore. We think it is regrettable, it is lamentable, and it's a major problem that we all have a collective duty to reckon with in combat.

Anuj But if you can go back in time, you can fix those things. And that's our pitch to like how to avoid scams. Like what if every time we invest some money, you just put some sort of a time lock. It's I give you money, can do whatever you want with my money, but just give me two months where you do whatever. Only thing is you cannot take the money out of the blockchain. You cannot cash out. And at the end of two months,

Anuj You have to agree on some conditions like if you didn't do this or if you use this and that way, it will automatically be given back to you. So it could be as simple as if you cashed out in these countries in the world with these addresses in the world, automatically, you know, just cancel those transactions and give me back my money.

Jeremy Gilbertson So if you think, I tend to throw out a lot of pop culture references because half the show's about culture. But every time we talk about time and time travel and doing things, I picture Dr. Emmett Brown talking about like, you know, affecting the reverberations on one event across time and all of that fun stuff. Let's talk about, let's hit the news. I wanna hit the news, because this kinda ties in with what you guys are talking about. So the two,

The single killer use case

Jeremy Gilbertson biggest things that are kind of happening right now. mean, blockchain is definitely in the news and obviously AI has been in the news and increasingly more so. These two questions kind of relate to both of those things. So the first, there's been a lot of talk out of the World Economic Forum, Davos, recently about blockchain possibly being the killer use case for blockchain being keeping track of the data that's used in training models for AI, controlling the biases and that sort of thing. What do you guys think? Is that the killer use case for blockchain?

Boris Mamlyuk killer use case for blockchain is that there is no single killer use case for blockchain. It's like saying what's the killer use case for paper? Paper can be used for anything from rolling doobies to writing sonnets. Paper is all powerful because of its manifold utility. So too with blockchains. so everybody, and you know, in one's blockchain journey, it's common, right, to search for the killer use case. It's sort of like that El Dorado, that prize. I'm guilty of that. I had a couple of blocks saying that, this is the blockchain killer use case. But over time, you kind of gravitate towards the real genius of Ethereum, which is a Turing complete programming language. It really expresses an infinite range of future possibilities, and that's brilliant.

And the fact that you have tens of thousands of people who are contributing to keep this range of future possibilities infinite to the infinite garden makes for pretty awesome invention. So Davos folks, like the WEF folks, they're coming with their own biases, their own preconceptions and their own agendas. And the biggest agenda that they're advocating is classifying blockchains as financial market infrastructure because that's the easiest way for them to capture blockchain processes and blockchain actors. What they're doing by tying AI with blockchain is another backhanded way at effectuating capture.

And we need to be very, very skeptical and very critical of those overtures, especially when it's coming from policymaking circles. That being said, the crypto AI intersection is the hottest, most bleeding sort of slice of frontier tech right now. And there are amazing teams that are building at this intersection. There's a project called Jensen that's essentially putting

Boris Mamlyuk AI inference on chain. And there are lot of projects in this category that are most important live in production with real users, real value that's being created. And that growth curve is just exploding right now. And that's a really, really exciting place to be. But whenever there's talk about policymakers sort of having figured out how they're going to govern AI and blockchain. All sorts of alarm lights should be going off because that's danger Robinson, that's danger.

Jeremy Gilbertson What a great answer. Mic drop, that was a brilliant answer.

Mark Fielding Boris, as someone who had to the misfortune of watching some of those Davos panels, why were you not there?

Boris Mamlyuk I'm there in the shadows.

Anuj But I mean, if you are the police, everything will look like an opportunity to monitor and track. And there's nothing because they can't themselves be part of those kind of innovations. They're like, what can we do from the sidelines? Oh, can we have a magnifying glass to everything? So if we need to, we can just interfere as and when. So I mean, yeah, of course.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, here's a couple quick things that I pulled out of that Boris. That was great, very articulate answer. And paper, the original technology, we think on paper here, right? You mentioned AI inference on chain. So Mark and I are, I haven't told Mark this yet, but Mark and I are creating a startup where we are gonna put human aha moments on chain, which is the messy, gushy equivalent of AI inference.

Question number two or news point number two guys so Google made some big changes to its AI principles I don't know if you guys saw that or not.

Mark Fielding I don't think you need to ask this question after what Boris has just said, Jeremy.

At least they are not pretending anymore

Jeremy Gilbertson Fair enough, but I'm gonna ask it anyway. Are you guys familiar with are you guys familiar with the changes that were made in the Google principles?

Boris Mamlyuk Yeah, some of them high level

Jeremy Gilbertson So basically in a nutshell, miraculously due to the timing of the things that are going on in the states that we all know about, change of regime and all of that stuff, they're removing all the language and lifting all bans on using AI for weapons and surveillance. We are reading Harari's text Nexus right now, which is pointing a lot of this stuff into the light. like, what do you...

How does that make you feel? what is that going to mean for folks as we move forward with such a big organization like Google doing something like that?

Anuj I mean at least they are not pretending anymore.

So I think that I mean, you know, nobody in crypto is surprised. Why do you think not a single major corporation has any actual inroads in crypto like real inroads? I mean, they provide, you know, compute space, this, that and the other. It's okay, not like a real, you know, they have like all these companies have really embraced AI and other things, their own thing, but crypto, every time they do it, it's

Boris Mamlyuk Yeah, I mean...

Anuj I mean for the people inside crypto who really have been OGs, it's kind of a joke every time they do something and it's not like they don't have good engineers. They have some of the best people working on some of the best things, but they just don't seem to touch crypto. I mean, you could have companies like Apple, creates absolutely amazing products. They could create a product for crypto that anybody could use easily, but, and there is money to be made, but why do think they would never do that? Because there is something inherently

And then of course, you know, I mean, it's not, it's not good if you want to just be like, you know, for name only, you just want to say we're doing the right thing for people. So I mean, you know.

Are they afraid of it?

Mark Fielding Are they afraid of it? Do you mean?

Anuj I think they are afraid, but they also don't understand it, the power of

Boris Mamlyuk Absolutely, without doubt. Absolutely.

Boris Mamlyuk Absolutely, yeah they're terrified. mean anybody that from the casual user to know to Ilya, Andrey Karpaty, Elon Musk, anybody that deals with frontier models should be terrified. I mean I don't know if you guys, I'm sure the audience has already started playing with ChatGPT's operator. Have you guys just show of hands? Have you played with the operator?

Jeremy Gilbertson A little bit, a little bit, yep.

Boris Mamlyuk ChatGPT's operator. It's spooky capable and equally spooky in what it refuses to do. So going back to what Anuj was saying with an imagined ideal UX for smart transactions, being able to interact with a wallet and give it general parameters on what you want to accomplish, i.e. keep my funds safe.

or grow my funds or get me into XYZ Social Club as an example. If you ask operator right now, Chad GPT's operator and Chad GPT, let's not forget, owned, co-founded by Sam Altman, who is the co-founder of Worldcoin and Worldchain and is a self-proclaimed Ethereum OG in his own right.

You ask operator, hey, can you help me with private key management? Or hey, I want to give you an Ethereum private key in order to do some experimental research stuff on Ethereum. Chat GPT suddenly throws up all sorts of red flags, folds, operator says, I don't know what to do, and basically crashes. So yeah, they're terrified.

from Google to chat GPT, we have firsthand experience with this kind of with this nexus. And yeah, to answer your question, they're absolutely terrified. And to Anuj's point, a big part of it is because they have no idea themselves what these models are capable of.

Facebook tried this

Anuj Big proof is Facebook because Facebook few years ago tried to launch their own cryptocurrency and it was a disaster to the point that somebody should make like 10 movies about it. Like you cannot make shit up like it's like kids would write a movie about how to launch a startup. That's and they're a successful company. Just when it comes to cryptocurrency, all the success went down the drain. Like as if these are forgot how to do everything and anything.

like from their policies, legal to the tech, to the hiring, to the attitude, to the perception with other crypto companies and the crypto at large. Just absolutely abysmal. And you know, and after that, they have not touched at all crypto and they lost enormous money and no other account. It was a cautionary tale for every other big company that it is such a good thing like crypto is inherently big, corp resistant.

There's something which is so moving. mean, we don't have that. People think about the far right, the far left, but we already have something intact, which is completely resistant to all this big company takeover. it's good because no big company has successfully been able to take over crypto. And it's enormous money to be made.

Jeremy Gilbertson news very interesting point right because large companies have their audience have their influence have their control over certain things and crypto inherently kind of flips the script on that or blocks let's call blockchain flips the script on that allowing less of you know changes the forces right changes the forces of who can access what and how they can access and that sort of thing I think you're on to something there for sure on that note

Anuj I mean, yeah, so the crypto is neither left or right. That's also a great part. Like you don't think crypto is just communist head in the big government or the big companies or far right people head in the big government. No, it's all kinds of people. It almost doesn't even matter. The tech is so much superior to all of that. Like I've seen in conferences and settings like crypto people who are really far right and far left.

working together like there ain't no problem because they know this is crypto they will transcend that divide and that you know yeah

Boris Mamlyuk You were talking about analogies earlier and pop culture explainers. A really great metaphor that comes to mind, or analogy, image, is the Hotel Continental in the John Wick series. You guys know John Wick? Okay, you know the Hotel Continental as the neutral ground. And if you have a specific coin,

Boris Mamlyuk It doesn't matter what mafia you belong to, what crew you belong to, you can get into this Hotel Continental, can feed yourself, you can rest up, and you can feel safe. And that's crypto. It's that...

Mark Fielding In John Wick 4, they blow up the Continental.

Boris Mamlyuk hahahaha

Anuj That is true. They do, they do, they do.

Mark Fielding Originally, they do rebuild it because they realize the error of their ways and John Wick is like Bitcoin and they rebuild it. with that analogy, it was raised an interesting question. They're afraid what happens when they act on that fear.

Anuj But it is based in France. The story is based in France, the John Wick 4.

When companies act on fear

Boris Mamlyuk when companies act on that fear?

Mark Fielding Yeah, when these big tech companies, governments that as you've just described it, if they act on that fear, do we get John Wick 4?

Boris Mamlyuk Yeah, and we've been on the receiving end of that in blockchain for many years. This is Operation Chokepoint 2.0. I don't know if you're familiar with that phenomenon. Massive, not just debanking, you often hear about debanking of crypto companies, even huge companies with billions of dollars of turnover, but as consequential, if not more, is deplatforming.

And so for the longest time, if you use the C word in a Google ads campaign crypto, you were automatically censored. Your ads could not run. I mean, just think about that for a second. just

Mark Fielding Yeah, that's why we got Sophie to do interviews.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, then you say, Boris, think about that on a larger scale, the whole net neutrality thing. whoever's controlling the pipes higher and higher up, like who lets what through and for what purpose, right? And the whole thing gets really scary. So I want to flip the script because we tend to go down the dystopian what if side a lot. We're coming out of reading chapter seven of Nexus, Harari's book, was yikes, pretty, it was a doozy.

The carryover question

Jeremy Gilbertson Let's talk about the carryover question we have from last episode. And I think this is a good one. And the question was, how do we make sure everyone can use technology and make sure that technology is applied for good? So let's take the second, yeah, go ahead, fire away. If you can run with that, let's run with it.

Boris Mamlyuk Heck yeah. We mentioned demo block clock, which is sort of the doomsday clock. It detects when AGI has thrown the world's clocks out of sync and Y2K is gonna happen, but for real this time, right? That's the dystopian. And then we have the yang to that, which was an app called CleanApp powered by smart transactions. It's been around for many iterations.

for more than a decade. And CleanApp is an app that opens to camera and it invites people to submit photos of waste and hazards that they come across. So you're at a playground, you see syringes or you see cigarette butts. You can clean it up, but chances are you're there with your kids. You don't wanna get your hands dirty. You just wanna play with your kids. So you take a photo.

Jeremy Gilbertson Away from the syringes though, right?

Boris Mamlyuk Exactly. Well, somebody is going to pick them up and you take a photo and in the not too distant future, you're going to have optimus and other robots that are going to come in your real time and clean it up. And so this is a technology that's as solar punk and emancipatory and know, for retto optimal to any future without it as you can imagine politically unimpeachable and it's live on smart transactions

Jeremy Gilbertson So, okay, so we have, this is really interesting, and also probably the most succinctly and tangibly answered carryover question in the history of thinking on paper. So.

Anuj I don't know if it's a good or a bad thing.

Jeremy Gilbertson So Boris, so we go around and we collect, we take pictures of these things that need to be cleaned up. They're geo-tagged with location or whatever, and that information would be sent to kind of a robot to clean it up. Is the robot around yet, or is this kind of the early phases of it? Are we attaching the robot after?

Anuj The humans, humans, it's humans, it's human. So you send the thing and what?

Boris Mamlyuk Humans and bots. Humans and

Mark Fielding Humans need something to do, Jeremy, once all the jobs have gone. Voila.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, also, they could be rewarded for said activity. It's all, like you said before, Boris, like it's all about incentives, right?

Humans and bots

Boris Mamlyuk Absolutely. yeah, so humans and bots. So right now in the protocol, there's an app where you can add a responsible party. So you draw a polygon and you say, I want reports from this area to go to, let's say your personal email address, or you want them to go to the city or the council, wherever you are. And those reports are forwarded along. And there's a lot of very valuable you know raw material like resource that is that isn't outside so think about the recyclable value cardboard plastics metals that can be and will be recaptured and the main thing to emphasize here is this is an app again that's live in prod with two hundred and fifty thousand installs tens of thousands of active monthly users and chances are you've never heard of it because so much of the rhetoric around blockchain is, financial market infrastructure or meme coins or, you know, swap this, swap that or stable coins.

Anuj Or we can use this to track people how they use AI because we care about people.

Boris Mamlyuk Right, and you have apps that are doing great, that are scaling, that are taking blockchain in a slightly different direction. With all of those paths, it's not one or the other, or one is better than the other. With all of them, all the lanes in our proverbial highway, combining to make this beautiful yellow brick road.

Jeremy Gilbertson Hey, I love it. What a way to land the plane guys. Thank you so much for joining us today. This has been, this has been a great discussion. We'll definitely post some links where everyone can go check. I'm going to go download these apps. guess we can get them from your website, right?

Boris Mamlyuk Absolutely. STXN.io and just follow the links. Follow the rabbit hole. Yeah.

Jeremy Gilbertson Follow the yellow brick road.

Mark Fielding I need that app because my son just has a habit of picking up rubbish off the floor and me just go, no, don't pick that up. But now I say, hold on.

Boris Mamlyuk there's an out for that there's an a theory of out for that

Mark Fielding apps that we can use for this loop. And then I can, well, funny story on that. It's a good idea because when I go to blockchain conferences, I come back with loads of swag and my kids kind of, play shop with all the swag that I bring back. But I say you have to use Bitcoin or Ethereum though in this shop. You can't use euros or dollars. This is another, another.

A question for the next guest

Do you guys have a question for our next guest for next week?

Boris Mamlyuk Yeah. So the question of secure data storage in space would be a long time horizon question, which is what are the measures taken to assure data integrity 500, 5,000 years from now? And it's inspired by the long tomorrow clock in San Francisco and sort of deep, deep thinking, which is the idea is brilliant. Let's make sure that the data is stored safely.

And the question is, right, knowing data degradation kind of rates in like physical media, what are the measures taken to assure that this data is going to be around in 50,000 years, like those time horizons?

Jeremy Gilbertson You had me at Long Now Foundation. I've been following those guys for a long time. Great, time of clocks. Well, timely question, Boris. I don't know, you're somehow like, you both are locked in with us, but Boris, like a couple of the responses, one of our guests actually builds data centers in space. So it's a perfect question for the carryover.

Anuj You know, we have Bitcoin, one of the nodes running in space, in Starlink. So we need people to be able to run Ethereum and Bitcoin node in space, where if so happens that humans start doing more dumb shit than they've already do with the environment, we at least have those nodes and some aliens will read and they will be like, you gotta save these humans. Like why are this dumb shit with their, you know, wonderful.

Jeremy Gilbertson A a new, no question humans will continue to do dumb shit. No question. No question. Unfortunately. Hopefully we can help fix it with some tech and some, and some empathy and all the great stuff that makes us human.

Boris Mamlyuk Dumb shit powered by smart transactions.

Jeremy Gilbertson My gosh, that's another t-shirt. We're gonna start making t-shirts with these quotes guys. Thanks so much for joining us stay in touch Awesome. Have a great one guys. Thank you

Boris Mamlyuk Likewise, thank you so much.

Anuj Have a good one. Bye bye.

Mark Fielding you very much. See you next time.

Backstage

Jeremy Gilbertson All right, Mark, we are backstage. Post smart transaction discussions. Bit of a head spin as always. How did the analogy land when he talked about if we're in a one lane road and cars are overtaking us because of their knowledge of the road, but what they're doing is helping you, not a race car driver with knowledge of the road.

Being able to navigate conditions at a higher level that are technically above your pay grade.

Mark Fielding anything which makes my experience easier and less prone to malicious intent is good and I think I...

Mark Fielding There's a lot of UX problems with blockchain. There's a lot of, as they alluded to in the show, fraud, crime, idiots doing stupid things. again, anything which makes my experience and other people's experience more enjoyable at the end of it is going to be a net positive for the space. It's gonna bring more people in. So I like what they're doing. I have to say that anyone listening, we had a bit of a...

problem with connection at the beginning, but it smoothed out. I think that Boris and Anuj were dropped some of the most poetic, powerful insight that was really, you could genuinely hear they were speaking from a place of passion and belief that they've invested and are investing their life's work into this. And that was really, really, really nice to hear.

Jeremy Gilbertson Agreed, agreed. And in this app that you could take pictures of things that need to be cleaned up and those things with geolocation kind of fed to people that are able to help clean up those things. Coordination is a big piece of the puzzle. And I think that app, that framework is really interesting. a friend of mine in the real estate business and there's a lot of things like residential real estate agents have to do.

during the course of managing multiple transactions and showing people houses and putting up signs and picking up signs and doing all these little things. And he's like, man, I wonder if there's a way to automate tasks like that and incentivize people that are just in the area to put a sign up for me or take down an old sign. And I'm like, I'm gonna point him to this app and just kind of see if maybe it could be used in that purpose. Really interesting.

Mark Fielding We need to have a show on incentives on blockchain crypto incentives because where as I agree with the need for incentives, in my experience, most incentives on the blockchain are very, very small.

and yet there's a lot of hope that they will get bigger, but they're very small incentives and I don't think that they last, they're not sustainable. I mean, if you...

Jeremy Gilbertson I think we need to have a psychologist on to talk about incentives and what incentives mean to the human dynamic and have that piece of the puzzle to understand why things work in coordination and that sort of thing. And then also, what incentives are meaningful? Like you said, these incentives are really small. Is that gonna push me over the edge to wanna do something that I wouldn't normally do, which is kind of interesting, right? Make me coordinate with a larger group.

you know, if I don't have the true passion to do that. I think it's an interesting piece to explore. Anyway,

Mark Fielding Also with like the tie in, again, I'm not a psychologist, I'm probably thinking about this wrong, but if you tie in the gambling and incentives, like the hope that you can make more, that you can win more, that the incentives will grow is perhaps more powerful and more influential than the incentive itself.

Jeremy Gilbertson the dopamine release, we could probably get a neuroscientist to talk about that. I thought his answer on the Davos stuff was awesome because you have like humans in general, like we all want to, know, especially in these like hierarchical organizations, we want to like get our arms around something and call it and label it and you know, careless Linneas back in the day going around looking at plants and saying, I'm going to categorize this thing. I'm going to categorize that thing and we're going to organize it, you know, and Harari in her book talks about bureaucracies that tag and organize and put things in place, right? That's kind of what we want to do. But sometimes, you know, have the hierarchy on top and you have the emergent on the bottom. Sometimes you need to give way to the emergent sometimes and actually do things and let things happen as well.

Mark Fielding Yeah, well, we're reading Nexus, so we don't need to speak about kind of personal brand building. And I think that I listened to some of these talks at Davos and yet obviously you get the CEOs and the founders of these big AI companies. But then you have you have panels full of people with agendas, politicians who don't know what they're talking about. And then you have on the other hand, people like Boris who could literally speak to an audience and make them understand and make them believe in a technology that they know about, rather than you get these big displays of political might where I feel personally that they're just there a lot of the time because they have to be there. There has to be a political conversation about crypto or AI. It has to be there and okay, we'll get all our mates in the suits to go there and pretend that they're putting humanity first. like, I just want to go back to your news article I know, because it got me angry on the Google AI. They didn't say ethics. I think that are...

former guest Reid was talking about this on social media today about everyone's scared to say ethics now. That website, I'm sorry, but you can't put a few butterflies on a really nice white website with some very, very well designed spacing between your images of butterflies and peace and swirls and then have, it just reeks of.

Jeremy Gilbertson And the timing of everything too is like unbelievable, I pulled some of these quotes here that I don't want to belabor this too much. So Per Wired Magazine, which is where I did some research on this, Kevin Kelly, the original founder and maverick of Wired Magazine will be on the show. Per Wired, quote.

Jeremy Gilbertson The company removed language promising not to pursue technologies that cause or are likely to cause harm weapons or other technologies whose principal purpose or implementation is to cause or directly facilitate injury to people technologies that gather or use information for surveillance violating internationally accepted norms technologies whose purpose contravenes widely accepted principles of international law, and human rights, all that language has been removed from the butterflies.

Jeremy Gilbertson What do we do, Mark?

Mark Fielding We keep asking questions, we stay curious, we keep thinking on paper, we keep our head above the noise and find our own understanding of what is happening.

Jeremy Gilbertson Preach my brother, preach my brother, I love it. Thinkingonpaper.xyz. I'm Jeremy, this is Mark, that's all for today.

Mark Fielding No, it's not. If anyone is still listening on the Kevin Kelly, we have 10 signed copies of Kevin Kelly's new book to give away. have 10 seats to the recording of the show where you'll get to be behind the scenes with us and Kevin Kelly. When we're recording it, go to thinkingonpaper.xyz sign up and get in the hat. You got to be in it to win it. That's what they say. Keep thinking on paper.

Jeremy Gilbertson Stay curious, be disruptive.