Yuval Noah Harari’s Nexus, Chapter 11: What Is Data Colonialism?

Harari asks why rice farmers in Burma's Irrawaddy Basin or China's Yangtze Basin should have cared about the Liverpool to Manchester railway. Because by the end of the 19th century, they were all conquered or indirectly exploited by the Great British Empire.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 21 chapters

  1. Chapter 11: the silicon curtain
  2. AI is not the problem
  3. What the industrial revolution cost
  4. Cooperation needs exchange, not similarity
  5. How many bad actors does it take?
  6. Digital empires, and the race to build trains
  7. Why should a rice farmer care?
  8. ImageNet, 2012
  9. Second order effects of a cat detector
  10. Life online, and the physical world we stop noticing
  11. Could an AI be a legal person?
  12. Synthetic voices
  13. Realism and the veneer theory
  14. The jungle code, and cooperation in nature
  15. You no longer need gunboats to take a colony
  16. The data colony
  17. Technology is rarely deterministic
  18. The epilogue
  19. What we would tell someone about this book
  20. Living in a post-AI world
  21. The next book: Irreducible
I accept you with your strange avatar that bears no resemblance to you in real life. And I accept this thing over here, which I’ve given up asking whether it’s AI or not.
Mark Fielding

The final chapter of Nexus compares today's AI developers to the private companies that raced to build railways, and warns of digital empires that take colonies with data instead of gunboats. We also cover ImageNet, the cat detector and the veneer theory of human nature.

Mark puts Harari's data colony question to Jeremy: “Would you still be living in an independent country or would you now be living in a data colony?” We close on the epilogue's case for self-correcting institutions, and name our next book, Irreducible.

The Silicon Curtain, the final chapter of Yuval Noah Harari's Nexus, warns that AI could split the world into rival digital empires and asks whether countries could become data colonies. Reading it with the epilogue on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, Mark Fielding sums up the whole book: “AI is not the problem. The problem is us.”

What does Harari mean by a data colony?

To take a colony you no longer need gunboats, only data. Harari asks whether a country whose leaders’ personal histories are held in Beijing or San Francisco is still independent, or “a data colony”.

Can humans still control AI, according to Harari?

Harari writes that computers “are not yet powerful enough to completely escape our control”, and that as long as humanity stands united, “we can build institutions that will control AI and identify and correct algorithmic errors.”

What is the precondition for cooperation?

“The precondition for cooperation isn't similarity. It's the ability to exchange information.” Jeremy reads it as an argument against the echo chamber.

How does Harari compare the AI race to the railways?

Harari compares the AI race to the railways. The Liverpool to Manchester line put Britain at the front of industrialisation, and by the end of the 19th century rice farmers in Burma and China were “conquered or indirectly exploited” by the British Empire.

What does the epilogue of Nexus conclude?

The epilogue’s conclusion: to build wiser networks we must “abandon both the naive and the populist views of information” and commit to “the hard and rather mundane work of building institutions with strong correcting mechanisms.”

Where Mark, Jeremy and Harari disagree

Jeremy notes that Harari calls technology rarely deterministic, then describes a path that sounds deterministic. Mark adds that Harari compares AI to past technologies while insisting it is unlike them: “you can't have both arguments.” He calls the book one side of the story.

Questions

What is data colonialism?

To take a colony you no longer need gunboats, only data. Harari asks whether a country whose leaders’ personal histories are held in Beijing or San Francisco is still independent, or “a data colony”.

What is the Silicon Curtain chapter of Nexus about?

The Silicon Curtain, the final chapter of Yuval Noah Harari's Nexus, warns that AI could split the world into rival digital empires and asks whether countries could become data colonies.

How does Mark Fielding sum up Nexus?

Reading it with the epilogue on the Thinking On Paper podcast book club, Mark Fielding sums up the whole book: “AI is not the problem. The problem is us.”

Which book follows Nexus on the book club?

We close on the epilogue's case for self-correcting institutions, and name our next book, Irreducible.

Transcript

Mark Fielding Disruptors and Curious Minds, CEOs, founders, book lovers. We have reached the end of Nexus by Yuval Noah Harari. We have a new book, we'll tell you at the end. But before we get into that...

I've always thought that maybe this book would end with a big Hollywood twist, that it would go into a last chapter of happiness and optimism and hope, but instead Yuval notches it up and notches it up and notches it up and he ramps it up. Digital empires, turning points, the end of civilization, nuclear war, cats! I blame cats, it's all the cat's fault.

Chapter 11: the silicon curtain

Mark Fielding Chapter 11, the Silicon Curtain is closing.

Jeremy Gilbertson Could it have been Schrodinger's cat responsible for this at some point?

Mark Fielding Yes, whenever we're connecting dots between technologies, there's always a bloody cat involved.

Jeremy Gilbertson Seriously, so all right. Yeah, so friends we're turning my god. You have a cat Okay So we're about to turn this up to 11 as they say in spinal tap the final chapter Mark alluded to this a little bit before like the interdependencies between all of these different things Being being really interesting but not also being exacerbated by AI right? So societal interdependencies one of the first sentences in this last chapter I thought was really interesting. So you have all of these interactions between all of these different entities, right? And doing the interactions manually takes a really long time. Doing the interactions by connecting these information networks, AI does that very, very well, right? Not to mention the quantum aspect of things as we move forward. That's not the focus of this book, but

This will create more interdependencies. It will also create more walls. Like we're already walled off. Society's already walled off. He talks about, the silicon curtain's gonna wall us off. We're already walled off, I think. And it's gonna make those walls harder to navigate, easier to manipulate, and able to spin that stuff up in a worse way, I think. It's gas on the fire, right?

AI is not the problem

Mark Fielding Gas on the fire. And just when you were speaking, I had my epiphany. I've had my AI epiphany. And he mentions it on the first page of chapter 11. Computers are not yet powerful enough to completely escape our control or destroy human civilization by themselves. As long as humanity stands united, lol, we can build institutions that will control AI and identify and correct algorithmic errors.

I don't need to read the rest, do I? Of that sentence.

Jeremy Gilbertson Because we proven to be so good at that universal coordination global coordination

Mark Fielding AI is not the problem. AI is not the problem. That's what this book should be renamed. AI is not the problem. The problem is us.

Jeremy Gilbertson That's a fact.

What the industrial revolution cost

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, he references how we handled the industrial revolution and that that led to, you know, imperialism in a very, bad way, but also led to some awesome stuff, right? Eventually. And he talks about, Hey, we muddled through, I think was the term he used. We muddled through the, industrial revolution. What's going to happen if we muddle through AI, but let's, let's talk about, let's look at the, let's look at the bright side. Okay. I'm going to bring a bright side into this, Mark. I really love this. This was a little bit later in the chapter. Sorry if I'm jumping, but.

Jeremy Gilbertson This quote was really cool, the precondition.

Mark Fielding You've earned the right to jump now, Jeremy. After 11 chapters, jump away!

Cooperation needs exchange, not similarity

Jeremy Gilbertson I'm jumping. I'm jumping. The precondition, this is a quote, the precondition for cooperation isn't similarity. It's the ability to exchange information. Okay? So let that settle in there for a minute, right? We think we have to cooperate with those who are similar to us. Doesn't that just perpetuate the echo chamber is what I think about. And we have to get up another level of abstraction reference to Paci McCormack.

most human wins, tying that in. If we get up to a higher level of abstraction with this, cooperating on a global level, thinking bigger than the idea of nation-states, because guess what? Nation-states are intersubjective realities. Let's point back to chapter one, two, three, right? know, so...

Mark Fielding I would have loved if Zelensky would have gone to JD Vatt. The nation states an intersubjective reality.

Jeremy Gilbertson That would have been fantastic. That would have been fantastic. But I think about that. That's the that's the that's the true. That's the root of all of this. That's the root of it's not about AI. It's not about quantum. It's not about all these. It's about us and our inability to cooperate in a way that serves the greater good of all of the people of all of us. Right. And I know we have to protect ourselves. I know we need to secure, you know, find secure ways to move about our day and that sort of thing. But we gotta start thinking higher levels because AI's gonna change the game, like very, very quickly. And yeah.

How many bad actors does it take?

Mark Fielding I'm gonna pour a big dollop of pessimism on your hope there with a simple question. And I think that super intelligence by Nick Bostrom, obviously Nick Bostrom is mentioned quite a few times in this book. We've mentioned his book quite a lot. And how many bad actors do you need?

How many nefarious bad actors do you need, Jeremy?

Jeremy Gilbertson Not many. You just need one. Yeah.

Mark Fielding Yeah, so if we're to get humanity onto this singing from the same hymn sheet...

Mark Fielding It's going to be quite difficult when borders don't matter, when there is no... It's either the all... It's all of us or it's none of us.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, think about the nefarious bad actors. Like he mentions this kind of another thought, thought experiment, like imagine in 20 years, right? So imagine in 20 years when there's a new group of leaders coming out that, you know, maybe today are eight and you know, when they start becoming, when they become a leader, they're, they're 28 and maybe they haven't been so careful about what they post on social media or what is, what gets captured of all the 8 billion cameras in the world capturing you doing things that you don't want captured, right? And now someone has control over all of those things. If they have control over all of those things, I would say they have control over you as well. So another point of manipulation that again, wow, as if we couldn't like dive deeper and darker into the rough side of this, but.

Digital empires, and the race to build trains

Mark Fielding Well, that's a nice segue into digital empire. So he speaks about digital empires, the train, he talks about tipping points, turning points. There's the Liverpool to Manchester train, which nobody thought trains were going to do much. then the private sector built this train between Manchester and Liverpool and that kind of catapulted Britain to the forefront of everything. then, you know, a few decades later, we own half the world and we have all these dominions everywhere.

He likens AI and the race to develop AI to the race to trains, the private industry, the private sector versus the government public sector and who was the most successful that and he likens the private AI developers of open AI, et cetera, of today versus government and how it's mirroring that development of infrastructure. And we're at this point where we're just waiting for this turning point to this Liverpool to Manchester.

train equivalent in AI. And then I'm sure you noticed the Kevin Kelly quote.

Jeremy Gilbertson did see the Kevin Kelly quote. That was interesting. We'll have to ask him about that the next time we're on the show. But he was, I think the idea behind it was he was talking to Larry Page, right? And was kind of like, hey, you know, free search, like free web search. What's the what's in 2002, your web search for free? Where does that get you and page response? We're actually making an AI.

Mark Fielding of ahead of the game aren't they? They're like those train builders. They're like the bloody train builders and they know they're gonna build this train.

Why should a rice farmer care?

Jeremy Gilbertson So the, all right, so the train builders, but then you have like the rest of the people, right? And I think there was a reference to like, why should a rice paddy farmer care about a new network of trains going through their area? And what does that mean from a bigger picture perspective? Here's where you start to worry about that a little bit because here's the question, are smaller cogs in the wheel capable of bigger picture thinking? And when I say small cogs in the wheel, I don't mean to diminish.

who they are or their potential or their intelligence, but the idea that these smaller cogs in the wheel haven't achieved the levels of Maslow's hierarchy of needs, that they're focusing on, yo, I gotta have food right now, food today, where these other people are like, hey, let's draw these train maps all over and here's what's gonna happen and here's what we're gonna be able to do and before you know it, you blink and something new has spun up that is yet again controlling a large group.

Mark Fielding Yeah, well, to answer your question, why should the rice farmers of the Irrawaddy Basin in Burma or the Yangtze Basin in China concern themselves about the Liverpool Manchester Railway? Because by the end of the 19th century, they were all conquered or indirectly exploited by the Great British Empire. And could the same thing happen with AI? Could it that way he poses that question, Jeremy? Could it? Yes, I think you just answered it.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yep, for sure. Let's talk about cats. You showed me your nice cup, your tea cup with a cat on it.

Mark Fielding Can I just ask you a question on consciousness? Because I didn't actually think about this cup. I just chose it at random to make my cup of tea before the show. I've obviously done my notes, so there was some kind of thinking cats must have been there simmering away under something. So I chose this cup. I have a lot of cups.

Jeremy Gilbertson Milk in your tea or no milk.

Jeremy Gilbertson I'm gonna say milk. Okay, all right.

Mark Fielding Of course, milk in my tea. Except if it's green tea or herbal tea, must let you know, for the Europeans, English tea we're talking about.

ImageNet, 2012

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah. All right. So a fateful day, September 30th, 2012, ImageNet Large Scale Visual Recognition Challenge. So we started kind of putting together a bunch of cat images to teach computers how to recognize a cat. this challenge and this experiment, turns out now cats can recognize, humans, or on, pause, meh, bell.

Jeremy Gilbertson computers can recognize cats better than humans. We're like, okay, well that sounds pretty cool, you know? cool, meow cat generator, that seems kind of cool. We get like cute cats and all of that stuff. You look at the surface level of this seems very innocent. Not that the cat recognition immediately had the idea to be turned into something nefarious, but that technology, these little fun little experiments that we're having today, could be turned into not so great things down the road because this cat generator, the output, part of the tech of Meow Generator, we look at Red Wolf, Blue Wolf, Wolf Pack, right? Which are these technologies that are perpetuating the terribleness between Israel and Palestine?

Mark Fielding I'm just going to back up there before we get to Israel and Palestine and actually explain... Can an algorithm identify a cat? The competition was about identifying pictures of cats and algorithms were notoriously bad at identifying cats until Alex Net, who was incredibly good at identifying cats because we...

I assume it's because we actually flooded the internet with cat pictures for billions and billions and billions of cat pictures. And it just became really good at identifying a cat. And it demonstrated to experts the potential for rapid progress in certain AI domains, essentially image recognition.

Second order effects of a cat detector

Jeremy Gilbertson And let me back up a hair, because I jumped quite a bit ahead there. I'm not saying the Meow Generator developers knew that similar technology would be used to do other things. What hit me was the experiments that we're making today could have effects beyond the result of the immediate experiment. That was where I was headed.

Mark Fielding Yeah, secondary down river, second order effects. What it doesn't say here is, because obviously on my first read, it was like, can only identify 96 out of every 100 cats. These cat images must be very hazy or blurry or manipulated, or the cat must look like something else to actually fail.

Jeremy Gilbertson Very good point. How's your cat recognition capability? Pretty good?

Mark Fielding Well, if it was just a hundred cats on cats, by the way, I know would talk on cats. There's something about cats and maybe there's something in cats that because we've got a show coming up with world ID and we're talking about proving you're a human in the age of AI. Thinking on paper XYZ for that to check that out. But cats know cat ain't falling for no bot.

Jeremy Gilbertson That could be really interesting. So not just cat identifier, but how do we organize cats behavior, cats tendencies, cats superpowers.

Mark Fielding How do we think like a cat?

Life online, and the physical world we stop noticing

Jeremy Gilbertson I don't know that I want to do that. All right, here's another question. As we move down, as we move through this chapter, we have this idea of supercharging the mind-body problem, which again, walks us back through the history of certain religions and the Old Testament referring to humans as merely physical bodies only. The kingdom of God is of flesh and blood until...

Jeremy Gilbertson you know, right around 1274 where the approach became a little bit more dualistic to where the resurrection and that sort of thing. Not to go, I don't want to go too deep in the Christianity side, but the reference is rooted in an interesting question. What is the relationship between our physical bodies and our online identities? When we start doing more things online and we start doing things online through avatars or online personas,

Will we care less about the problems that affect the physical world. So if we're online all the time, Mark, are we gonna become less concerned with things like global warming, less concerned with things like communities they get taken advantage of, co-opted, know, that sort of thing? Really interesting, right? So lastly on that, before I let you riff, is so if we move...

If society moves from identifying humans as physical bodies, if we spend so much time online that we start thinking of online personas as human people without physical representation, could we then start beginning to think of AI more as a human? And prime example of this, in games today, they have NPCs, non-player characters, that are AIs and they're...

they're shitty and dumpy like today, but as that gets better, those are gonna get better and what influence does that start to have? And that was a really interesting thread in the latter part of this chapter. How did you land? Did you get?

Mark Fielding I agree with you. because he takes a couple of pages to get to that question. And while was reading the two pages to get there, I almost stopped reading because I thought this isn't really going anywhere. But then he poses the really interesting question at the end, quote, this debate could shape attitudes not only towards organisms, but also towards digital entities, as long as society defines identity by focusing on physical bodies.

it is unlikely to view AIs as persons, but if society gives less importance to physical bodies then even AIs like any corporal manifestations may be accepted as legal persons enjoying various rights, which is what you said and yeah, it makes you wonder.

Mark Fielding how quickly we get to that point because people use avatars now. think most of world probably don't, apart from the Twitter avatar, whatever, there's not, most of the world don't use avatars, but more and more are. And as gaming proliferates, as the next generations come through, they will. And you have your online persona, you have your real world persona and they merge and they diverge and they merge and they diverge. And yeah, and that, it raises the question.

At what point are you, are AIs having some avatars online? They're just accepted as one of us. I accept you with your strange avatar that bears no resemblance to you in real life. And I accept this thing over here, which I've given up asking whether it's AI or not. So I'll just accept it for one of us.

Synthetic voices

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, have you heard the latest news on Sesame AI who's working on voice creation from AI, human voice replication and creation? I didn't get a chance to dig in too much, but they've created these voice identities as an interface to these AI systems, right? So instead of typing into a chat, you're actually talking through it.

Jeremy Gilbertson and they've been very successful in testing the the relatability of these of these like AI human voice recreations, right? That, you know, you have that human voice that could eventually be manipulated. And then you think about phishing scams today that are bad with the Prince of Nigeria asking you to let his son out of jail or whatever the heck it is. What if you have like your grandmother's voice call you and be like, Mark?

I need some help. Like that gets a little funky. Let's see. What did

Mark Fielding Fortunately most people don't answer their phones anymore, or least I don't.

Realism and the veneer theory

Jeremy Gilbertson That's a fact, yeah. What did you think about the veneer theory?

Mark Fielding realism, the veneer theory. I studied international relations at university, Jeremy, and I was a 21 year old realist. Oh, yes, I'm a realist. Yeah, we suck.

Jeremy Gilbertson So let's talk, so you you had, when you were going through school, so realism as I understand, realist thinkers, it's all about power, right? It's about the attainment of power in order to achieve control. Is that a core theory that I picked out of this?

Mark Fielding Well, I think that he explains it with Hans Morgenthau and John Meersheimer have argued that an all-out competition for power is the inescapable condition of the international system. Yeah, realism is that's the basis. The veneer theory takes it to the next step. It argues that at heart humans are Stone Age hunters who cannot but see the world as a jungle where the strong prey upon the weak and where might makes right.

On my bad days, on my cynical bad days, like Friday, for example, about 7pm GMT, yeah, I think that that, I think that, but on my brighter, more optimistic days, I like his quote as for Stone Age hunters, they were gatherers as well. I mean, they're only gathering to feed their killing sprees, but you know, I think on my brighter days, I'm not, I don't subscribe to the veneer theory, no.

The jungle code, and cooperation in nature

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, dot, dot, dot, the jungle code, right? So the strong over the weak, right? The strong controlling the weak to manipulate, control jungle theory. But guess what? This was really cool and bright at the end of this. Real jungles are full of cooperation. Let's point back, hey, just a little ding ding, mycelium networks, Mycelium networks, right? You got these little strands between the fungi that connect the dots and the trees and the...

enable all gets a fiber optic network or the forest right so when you really think about it scientifically based there's tons of cooperation in that where I would debunk from principle from theory the jungle code but unfortunately some people decide to live by the jungle code

Mark Fielding Yeah. So after the jungle code, he gets into populism again. I'll let you if you want to take that, can take that. Could I just ask you a question just before that about your thoughts on data colonialism and the cocoon?

You no longer need gunboats to take a colony

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, so, so, you know, there was a quote, I think that he referenced, you know, to take over a colony, you don't need gunboats anymore. You just need to extract data, right? So if you can extract data, you can control things. Um, and he talks about these cocoons being these little digital empires where instead of having two, three, four superpowers in the world, we could have 12, 14 superpowers in the world that activate their, their wishes.

Upon the others in a digital way instead of a physical way like it's you know, the Cold War analogy was great Cold War he referenced as a Hyper rational game of chess if I push this button everybody dies. It's really kind of easy and straightforward but when we have these these multiple digital empires that are able to interact and cause chaos digitally, it's harder to track that it's harder to see what's gonna happen down the road because number one, you can't spot all the interactions. Number two, you can't see where they're gonna go because a lot of them are emergent and it's hard to predict the end outcome. that, again, damn it, we're like in scary land again.

Mark Fielding Yeah, because if the big red nuclear button, you press it, you know what's going to happen. And so mutually assured destruction permeates and nobody presses it because they know what is going to happen. But if you have next to it a little green button, because it's AI and it's painted green, you blue, so you trust it. So you press it and it sends a some kind of AI virus somewhere.

you're more likely to press it. A government is more likely to press it. A leader is more likely to press it because they don't know the outcome exactly.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, within these cocoons that he calls, you're gonna have the people, right? And you're gonna have AI in the form of bots or personas or whatever the heck it is, right? And just millions upon millions upon millions that are, once they're unleashed in their ability to interact, the possibility of doing things is kind of endless, right? But here we go, it goes back to this, as humans.

Hey, let's just all get in a room together. Let's work it out and make sure, make sure we protect everybody. you know, the likelihood of that doesn't seem.

The data colony

Mark Fielding Question for you, Jeremy, going back to nation state is just an inter... An inter what? An intersubjective. An intersubjective. So, question for you. Imagine a situation in 20 years, when somebody in Beijing or San Francisco possesses the entire personal history of every politician, journalist, colonel and CEO in your country.

Jeremy Gilbertson Subjective reality, my favorite term coming out of this book.

Mark Fielding every text they ever sent, every web search they ever made, every illness they suffered, every sexual encounter they enjoyed, every joke they told, every bribe they took. Would you still be living in an independent country or would you now be living in a data colony?

Jeremy Gilbertson So all right, let's extend that a little bit. think data colony. So let's extend that. You and the 12 people who lead a particular country are going to a global meeting to figure out AI. And you're like, you have these grand ideas about, we're gonna do X, Y, and Z. We really need to lead the charge in this and blah, blah. And then the dude that has all that information is gonna go to you and be like, Mark.

Remember this? Remember this? Are you sure you wanna lead the charge in that way? Because you know, if you can, we're getting very black mirror again on a lot of this.

Mark Fielding The way you say it, and if we follow on from the question quote that I just asked you, it doesn't seem like a very difficult conclusion to come to, though. It seems straightforward. The way he paints the picture, all of our deepest, darkest fears about AI suddenly come into the light very, very easily. It's almost like a script where this A follows B follows C follows D and the big

Technology is rarely deterministic

Jeremy Gilbertson But he says multiple times in this book, technology is rarely deterministic.

Jeremy Gilbertson but that sounds very deterministic.

Jeremy Gilbertson pregnant pause.

Mark Fielding He also, numerous times, kind of says that AI isn't a technology like we're used to as well. He always, like he makes, he goes to pains to point out that you can't compare it to the printing press, you can't compare it to the industrial revolution, you can't compare it to those, it's not like for like, it's more like everyone says, oh, the printing press was amazing, AI will be amazing. Yes, you pointed out that, like the printing press gave us the witch trials.

and mass murder. The Industrial Revolution gave us huge, huge shifts to our political, social, economic, millions of people died. There's a downside to all of it. And he says AI is not a normal technology as we're used to it. So you can't have both arguments.

The epilogue

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, well played. let's tiptoe into the epilogue here. Spoiler alert, guys. Spoiler alert, if you didn't read this entire book, all we have to do, all we have to do is create wiser networks. That's my takeaway. We just gotta create wiser information networks. Bam, done, I'm out, bye.

Mark Fielding Yeah, rather to create wise networks we must abandon both the naive and the populist views of information, put aside our fantasies of infallibility and commit ourselves to the hard and rather mundane work of building institutions with strong correcting mechanisms. That is perhaps the most important takeaway this book has to offer. Hashtag wishful thinking.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, hang on to your self-correcting mechanisms. Make sure important things aren't excluded from your AI models. Like the exclusion of the acts of Paul and Thecla that led to the giant growth of misogynistic views over time. That's pretty important. Something gets left out of a universal book because some guy doesn't believe in it. Look at the repercussions. Be careful what goes into your models, friends and neighbors.

Mark Fielding Be careful what you wish for.

What we would tell someone about this book

Mark Fielding When's the next holiday? I don't know. Jeremy, last question for you. So you're going to go, you're going to meet some family you haven't seen for a long time, meet some friends for a beer. They're going go, what you reading at the moment, Jeremy? And you can say, I've just read Nexus. And they're going to say, could you summarize it for me in like a bit of a sentence? Because I can't be bothered to read 400 pages of AI doom and gloom. What are you going to say?

Jeremy Gilbertson Wow, put me on the spot. I would say it was the study of information networks, how they were used over time, how we can point back to historical outcomes based on information networks and what different technologies created deeper, faster, quicker information networks, and how the patterns we've seen in the past are shaping what we see in the future, which is not any grand

You know grand aha moment, but now you look at the ability for all of these things to hold together It comes back to me the idea of controlling something like this or getting our hands around it You got to have the self-correcting mechanisms, right? You got to have these things that will auto correct instead of You know lock down or block down all the blockades that keep you in the center of the lane as you're driving, right?

I that was the biggest thing and I love the idea. I said it in jest earlier, but creating wiser information networks. What does it mean to be wise? I think to be wise is to seek true understanding no matter your current position, right? And that requires a little bit of empathy for other people as you hear their view. And it also requires a little bit of vulnerability, knowing that, what I know today about this subject may not be all there is to hear.

It might just be a small piece of it and I need to kind of decouple from this belief that I'm just driven to defend it. It's basic. It's not even about tech. It's about that. That's what it's all about to me.

I think it is an important book. think that...

Living in a post-AI world

Mark Fielding We, and I said this in last show and I say a lot of things in jest, but that's just my way of interpreting it. We live in a, we're going to live in a post AI world. I think the world before AI and the world after AI. And regardless where you are, what you think, where you are on the spectrum, whether you're an optimist, whether you're a doom monger, whether you're somewhere in between, you cannot deny that the...

that the horse has bolted, the horse is out of the shed, the AI horse is rampaging across the earth and it's going to change entertainment, it's going to change work, it's going to change our relationships, it's going to change the internet, it's going to change finance, it's going to change how we inter-operate with each other, it's going to change relationships, it's going to change culture. How it changes, what changes and to what degree?

we're gonna find out. And I think that you asked about what it's like to be wise and I don't know the answer to that, but I do know that you gotta read both sides of the story to get anywhere near being wise. And I think that this book paints a very good picture of one side of that. And hopefully we'll read a book about tech optimism next.

Jeremy Gilbertson the big exhale from the book. And I enjoyed it as much as we were like, man, this thing was so dark. What we saw, the case he laid out from history and stair step in all of these different regimes and talking through it as information networks, I thought it was great. I definitely enjoyed it. I'm glad I read it. It was dark. I feel like I can exhale a little bit, but now I'm moving forward with a little bit of,

Mark Fielding But you're moving forward, like you're thinking about it. You're engaging with the material. You're not, this is the whole point of thinking on paper. And if you're listening to this, that's the whole point of what we're doing. Some of this is, it's kind of not scripted. We take notes and then it emerges as we talk. And that's why we do it because it helps us to understand and it helps, it will help you to understand. So that's why we do it and come and join us. I forgot what I to say. I don't even know. Yeah.

The next book: Irreducible

Jeremy Gilbertson What are we reading next? Let's tease the new book.

Mark Fielding Right, so what are we reading next? So out of the frying pan into the fire. I'm really excited about this book. It's by Federico. Right, he's Italian, so we're to say fagin, I think that G is like a G, a fagin, I don't know. Can you pronounce the title,

Jeremy Gilbertson He's definitely not coming on the show because he, you can't pronounce his name yet. We need to work on that.

Mark Fielding I'm going to edit that bit out. He is going on the show.

Jeremy Gilbertson wonderful. Let's do it. So this talks about consciousness, life, computers and human nature. Mark, when you shared this with me via text the other day, it was like such an immediate yes. Hot. I was just like, yes, immediately. So I'm not sure where the adventure will take us. Come on it with us. Read this with us. Buy the book. Jump in. Pop into one of these squares. We've been asking you guys for quite a while. We've had a few guests come on. We'd love to unpack this with you in real time.

Help sharpen our minds. We can help sharpen yours maybe. Yeah.

Mark Fielding Do know where I got this book idea from? You'll like this.

Jeremy Gilbertson Talk to me.

Mark Fielding So it was from a tweet from a man who writes the newsletter about being human.

So Paki McCormack, he posted a picture of this book and I clicked on the book and like you, was an immediate, hell yeah, we've got to read this book. And just read the back of it just to give people, like we can turn this bit into, we'll edit out and make it into an ad. Federico Faggin is one of the greatest luminaries of high technology alive today.

Jeremy Gilbertson Back to Paki back to Paki Paki you got to come on the show

Mark Fielding A physicist by education, he is the inventor of the microprocessor and the MOS silicon gate technology, both of which underlie the modern world's entire information technology. See, we're always tying books together. It's just magic. It's thinking on paper magic. Federico now turns his attention to consciousness and the nature of reality, sharing with us his profound insights on the classical and quantum worlds, artificial intelligence, life.

Jeremy Gilbertson Buckle up kids, buckle up.

Mark Fielding When are gonna start that? Two weeks? I'm gonna... We'll figure that out.

Jeremy Gilbertson We'll figure it out. haven't gotten the book yet. It should be here soon. anyway, uh, thinking on paper.xyz we have, uh, two ways we push stuff out to you guys. One is this book club where we actively read, critically think, think on paper together. This is participatory. This is not designed to be a broadcast. This is designed to be a book club. Come in and read it with us. Hello at thinking on paper.xyz drop us a note if you want to join in. Secondly, we interview some of the some of the most interesting technological leaders, cultural leaders in the world that are painting a new picture of the way the world's gonna look. We bring you backstage to ask the questions that you care about to try and understand what it all means. So two ways to engage with us. If we can get better at something, send us a note, drop us a comment. This is for you, this is not for us. Off we go.

Mark Fielding Yeah, and people, I'm going to add to that because people talk about connecting the dots. We really are connecting the dots of emerging technology. In the last two weeks, we've spoken to people putting data centers in space, building ion trap quantum computers, using AI on satellites to get real time analysis of natural disasters. A blockchain 500 brand advisor advising biggest bands in the world, what to do about AI and blockchain and robot pills in your stomach. We've got world ID coming to speak about proof of humanity. We've got it's there and all you have to do connect the dots thinking on paper at xyz.

Jeremy Gilbertson Robot pills in your stomach?

Jeremy Gilbertson That's it for today guys. Be curious, stay disruptive.

Mark Fielding Keep thinking on paper and we'll see you next time.