How Do Brands Survive AI Slop?
Nick Richtsmeier argues that many teenagers use social media in a healthier way than their parents do. 17 year olds don't think it's real. It's a game to be played.
In this episode · 18 chapters
- How do we survive the AI internet?
- Trusting things you have never spoken with
- Building trust with a community
- Why media does a bad job of it
- Was the internet ever good?
- Everyone exists on a distortion gap
- The Michael Jordan problem
- An example, walked through
- A thousand true fans
- Deciding where you want to live
- Are young people asking this?
- The human soul remains undefeated
- Is marketing a con?
- The quote about efficiency
- The load bearing side
- A musical example of inefficiency
- Resilience
- Kevin Kelly, and what Nick wants
There’s this period of time where we were lulled into the belief that this thing can be free and non-extractive forever. When really it was just an addiction play. It was just handing out cigarettes to teenagers coming out of high schools.
Nick Richtsmeier describes trust as a feeling the brain builds from constant small tests of whether something is safe. He explains why conversation matters so much for trust, and why the internet, with no real conversational space, is so bad at it.
He argues Silicon Valley sells a religion that produces a feeling, why brands under $100 million should move from funnels to networks, and why inefficiencies hold up what matters, from conversation to a good groove.
Nick Richtsmeier, founder of the consultancy CultureCraft, argues on the Thinking On Paper podcast that brands survive an internet filling with AI slop by cutting their dependence on platforms and earning trust through networks of people they know. He calls the digital marketing funnel a fiction: “Funnels don't actually exist, they never existed.”
How do brands survive AI slop?
Nick Richtsmeier argues brands survive by cutting their dependence on platforms and earning trust through networks of people they know.
Why can't words win trust, according to Nick Richtsmeier?
Trust is a fast survival judgement made deep in the brain, not something words can win, Richtsmeier argues: “There's almost nothing I can do to convince you to trust me.” He describes a brand as the averaged-out credibility people pass to each other, “a mass average of something much more fundamental and much more human”.
How does Richtsmeier link Silicon Valley to cults?
Silicon Valley has moved beyond selling a feeling to “selling a religion that consistently produces a feeling”, Richtsmeier says, and he links the method to how cults are built. He cites Sam Altman as an example of recalibrating danger so that not trusting him feels too risky.
What is the Silicon Valley tax on businesses?
Platforms that control distribution also hide who the customer is, and selling through AI models adds another black box: “your customer is OpenAI.” Richtsmeier estimates that the “Silicon Valley tax” of maintaining a digital presence costs some businesses three to 15 per cent of top-line revenue.
What is network methodology in marketing?
Network methodology, his alternative to the funnel, means every business decision runs through someone you know or someone who knows someone you know. In one client case, a professional services firm phones each new newsletter subscriber without a sales pitch, because email automation carries “way more downside trust risk than upside trust potential”.
Why do teenagers use social media more healthily than adults?
Teenagers often use social media more healthily than their parents, Richtsmeier says, because they treat it as manipulation they knowingly take part in: “17 year olds don't think it's real. It's a game to be played.” He pairs this with his line that “the inefficiencies are load-bearing”: slow things such as conversation and qualitative user research hold up what matters.
Where Jeremy and Richtsmeier disagree
Jeremy challenges the idea that trust is settled instantly, arguing it grows through back-and-forth conversation. Richtsmeier agrees conversation builds trust but says the threat check comes first: “you can't start dancing until you've put down your weapons.”
Links from this episode
- Nick Richtsmeier: CultureCraft, Trust-Made Growth Guild and writing (nickrichtsmeier.com, accessed October 2026)
- About Damns Given with Nick Richtsmeier, newsletter (Substack, accessed October 2026)
- Enshittification: Why Everything Suddenly Went Wrong and What To Do About It, by Cory Doctorow (craphound.com)
Questions
How do brands survive AI slop?
Nick Richtsmeier argues brands survive by cutting their dependence on platforms and earning trust through networks of people they know.
Who is Nick Richtsmeier?
Nick Richtsmeier, founder of the consultancy CultureCraft, argues on the Thinking On Paper podcast that brands survive an internet filling with AI slop by cutting their dependence on platforms and earning trust through networks of people they know.
Does the digital marketing funnel really exist?
He calls the digital marketing funnel a fiction: “Funnels don't actually exist, they never existed.”
How does Nick Richtsmeier define trust?
Nick Richtsmeier describes trust as a feeling the brain builds from constant small tests of whether something is safe.
Transcript
Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds welcome to another episode of thinking on paper where we unpack the future with the people building it
So Mark, you said you had a pretty fun question to kick us off. Where, where's your head going?
Mark Fielding after you joined us last week on an exploration of space and how you can play your guitar on the moon, this week we're back down on Terra Firma, speaking about the en-shitification of the internet, the en-shitification of internet culture and how, by the end of it, your brand, your personal brand, your business will have a better idea of how to connect, hopefully, with your customers, with your audience as...
the whole internet tumbles and crumbles into a big pile of AI impersonal slop. Our guest is Nick Richtsmeier He's the founder of GrowStrategy, consultancy, CultureCraft. He writes at Damned Given. Nick, thank you for thinking on paper with us. Welcome to thinking on paper. And I have to admit, I have a bit of a trust issue myself, you know.
How do we survive the AI internet?
Mark Fielding So to alleviate my fear, how can I and the Thinking on Paper audience trust anything that you're about to say?
Nick Richtsmeier that's interesting. ⁓ I don't know that you should. To kind of go off the beaten path here. So this may be a subsequent question, but we'll start with, what do we mean when we talk about trust? So trust is something that actually doesn't work very well as ⁓ the headline of a conversation, because we all sort of feel like we get it. And people go, ⁓ it gets yada yada'd really easily. But what fundamentally trust is doing is it's a way back in the brain neurological function.
to keep us alive. So it's this little test of like, are you gonna kill me? Is this thing gonna fundamentally end my existence? And so our brain just does these little tests way back in the reptilian brain of like, is this safe? Is this safe? Is this safe? Is this safe? Is this safe? And it aggregates into this feeling called trust. So, you know, we're gonna talk a lot about brand and marketing today, I suspect. And what's interesting about that is there's not a lot that we can do to to produce like an upside to trust. Trust gets us to like a playing field where I'm even willing to be in the room with you. And then good things have to happen from that. So to your question of, I trust you, your brain already made that decision. There's almost nothing I can say, because the prefrontal cortex has very little to do with trust. There's almost nothing I can do to convince you to trust me. In fact, me trying to convince you to trust me is probably going to make it worse. Right?
Mark Fielding That'll make it worse.
Jeremy Gilbertson you go on, me, so we had a conversation with a great guest last week about the dance of communicating with somebody and you know, this little back and forth and I would argue, I want to push back on that a little bit because I think trust,
Jeremy Gilbertson gets a little bit better as you lob something over to someone else and they kind of grab it and lob it back and there's this little bit of back and forth. How do you balance that with the first case like, holy cow, this guy's not gonna throw an ax at me, but I may not wanna jump into bed and build a business with him, right?
Nick Richtsmeier comes later, doesn't it? First, you can't start dancing until you've put down your weapons. The dance part.
of violence is a function of every person to person engagement. So even if I don't see you holding an axe and think you're going to come at me with it, how you look at me, like right now I'm getting a side eye from Mark, right? So there's a threat there in the side eye, right?
Mark Fielding That's my listening intent. I have
Mark Fielding No, that's shows. No, that's my focused and concentration face telling you trust me.
Nick Richtsmeier And if we're in a conversation, how you listen, whether you give me space to finish my thought, all of those have little twinges of violence or lack thereof. so, yeah, absolutely. Conversation goes an enormous way in our ability to trust each other, but it has very little to do with the words. The words are in the mix, right? That classic sort of, 90 % of communication is nonverbal, et cetera, et cetera.
Part of why people say that is because that back of the brain amygdala work is so much faster than our prefrontal cortex, right? So the back of the brain is already making all these decisions and our prefrontal cortex will go, gosh, well Mark said that really smart thing, so I should trust him. But that's really just a validation of a decision I already made, So conversation is incredibly important for trust building. That's why the internet's so bad at it.
One of the many reasons why the internet's so bad at it is because there's no conversational space really functionally on the internet. There's asynchronous commenting, but it's not really conversational space.
Trusting things you have never spoken with
Mark Fielding I trust things I haven't spoken with. People trust brands that they haven't spoken with. I would trust... I've never had a conversation with Jeremy's wife, but I would trust her immediately.
Nick Richtsmeier we borrow all the time, communities and networks are really powerful for trust making because we borrow trust from each other, right? We ship credibility across lines of relationship. That happens all the time. Brand is in some ways a really kind of silly mass tool that we use to say if we just averaged out all of that shipped credibility, what do we call it? We call it a brand.
You know, so we're, we're, you know, we're, again, we're shipping credibility through all these little channels, through communication, through conversation, through following through on what we said we were going to do through color, through sound, through meeting expectations. All of these things are little nodes of trust. And then to the extent that we fire on those nodes consistently or how we fire on those nodes consistently creates this funky thing that has been called brand. ⁓ but
Brand is really a mass average of something much more fundamental and much more human.
Building trust with a community
Jeremy Gilbertson how do you build trust with with a potential audience or community when the technology you're building is difficult for the average person to understand?
Nick Richtsmeier in the case that you're like selling technology or the medium through which we're transferring information?
Nick Richtsmeier So you're building quantum computers or you're building some kind of significant AI, you're building space technology, you're seeing, we're seeing in real time a lot of different strategies for this, right? So we can take the Sam Altman strategy, which a lot of people distrust Sam Altman. Some of that's because of media and book writing and things like that, but a lot of people do trust him, right? Right. They use his software, they pay him money. Part of how Sam Altman has done that is he, is he recalibrates danger.
So the danger of not trusting him is enormous.
Right. So then we don't actually have to think about him at all. We don't think about what's happening in that chat bot at all. We are just being trained by his media apparatus to believe that the risk, the danger of not listening to him is so enormous. Put our everything we can in this little chat bot so that Sam Altman can save the world.
and he's co-opted the media, I mean, quite effectively. And I mean that broadly, social media influencers, you know, he's co-opted the system. And that co-opting is another way of building trust is we insert intermediaries. That's why the influencer thing became as big as it did, is it was just a simple way of co-opting trust in a very trustless space. So social media...
Mark Fielding Yeah, and the media.
Why media does a bad job of it
Nick Richtsmeier does a really bad job of building trust over time because it does so many trust breaking things. But if you can insert people who I feel like I can trust, influencers, right, it allows me to use this mass media tool in a way to circumvent the trust issue, right. So influencers is a big piece of how we've used the internet to bypass kind of the trust issues. ⁓ Kind of getting back to sort of the technology question, difficult technology.
Not everybody's got the Sam Altman technique, although Musk is very similar. uses that sort of, if you don't listen to me, the world ends kind of logic. ⁓ one of the main ways they do it is they don't, they don't talk about technology, there's very little converse and this is an old Steve jobs trick, right? It's not a phone. It's 10,000 songs in your pocket. and that, that methodology of, we're not selling you technology. We're selling you a feeling.
And that's classic marketing 101. And I think the way that Silicon Valley has amped that up quite effectively, now I'm not endorsing this because it's had toxic effects, but the way Silicon Valley has amped that up is we're not just selling you a feeling, we're selling a religion that consistently produces a feeling. And if you buy into our religion, if you buy into our view of the world, you are going to have the good feelings. And that is incredibly powerful. That's how cults get made. Right. And so you, have what is arguably the groundswell of a global cult being built using the tools that cults have been using for 10,000 years.
Mark Fielding I'm always scared by the word cult.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, no, this it's, it's, it's the same. It's similar playbook. It's similar playbook, right? Scaled and scaled in different ways.
Was the internet ever good?
Mark Fielding enshitification of the internet. First question, was the internet ever good? Was the internet ever not shit?
Nick Richtsmeier I think there's gradations, right? You know, like, I think for those of us who were there in the early stages of it, and I don't want to preach Corey's book for him, Corey Doctorow's book, who wrote Enshitification it's a phenomenal book if you haven't read it. You know, Corey's point is that the first part of any of these mass tech build-ups is that the tech is really good to the users as a way of creating addiction.
And so if you look at a certain era of the internet like 08 to 2012, something like that, you had a lot of really big, incredibly funded companies that were burning money, making it good for users.
the very brief period of ad-free Google, when it was just a search line and an email client and a few other components, right? There's this period of time where we were lulled into the belief that this thing can be free and non-extractive forever. When really it was just an addiction play. It was just handing out cigarettes to teenagers coming out of high schools.
in the sense of the cynical question, was it always shitty? Well, yeah, that was really shitty. You know, to to addict an entire generation of people using, you know, freemium solutions. But it didn't feel shitty. mean, we were we were. Right, you know, like there was this level of autonomy and control and you could find any piece of information and, know, there it's hard.
Mark Fielding My space was awesome.
Nick Richtsmeier I think I would be hard pressed to say that the internet in 06, 07, 08 wasn't a really freaking good time. For those of us who were making use of it, early Twitter, I mean, God, early Twitter was a blast. And then to the point of Corey's book is then the extraction begins because investors have to get paid.
And I don't blame investors for wanting to get paid, it's just the entire game in which it's happened is built on addiction methodology. And that probably is bad.
Jeremy Gilbertson users, MAUs, right? Daily active users, DAUs, how many people cannot leave the thing that you've built?
⁓ And how much attention are you are you extracting from them? It's it's really funky when you sit back and think about it because normally you're like wow, this is a cool little thing. I can find some stuff I can do some things but when you really think about it the fundamental level of it is manipulative ⁓ and extractive
Nick Richtsmeier Yeah. Well, I think the, interestingly, I think the AI thing is going to really mess this whole thing up because people have already started doing the math of like, okay, fine. Let's say you entrap all these people on chat GPT. How much would you actually have to charge them to reasonably pay back the investors? It's an ungodly amount. I mean, it's, it's like double or triple what you're paying for Netflix and you know, other, other things combined right now.
the month and the end of perpetuity every per every user would have to stay on forever. So the math already says that this is not that model that AI is not that model, which means it's a different financial model. And who has the money to pay back these firms for the investment that have been made, not users, not even corporations, right? There's a reason why Palo, Palalantir is what it is, right? There's only certain a handful of entities in the world that have the level of capital possible to pay back these investors.
Nick Richtsmeier How many clients have you lost because of AI, don't sell anything that AI does. that doesn't mean you couldn't build an ⁓ LLM to pretend to do what I do and then maybe we would lose somebody to that. yeah, not something I lose sleep over.
Everyone exists on a distortion gap
Mark Fielding I want to read a quote from you. I love this quote. Everyone exists in a mirrored cage of algorithmic distortion. Given all of the above, it's not exaggerated to say there is no central source of truth. 21st century humans are quite comfortable in our house of mirrors, letting algos tell us what they think we want to hear. For sellers who want customers, this means rethinking neutrality. You can't please everyone because they don't even live in the same world as each other.
Building a community of customers requires accepting and engaging their preferred distortions. Pick your facts, pick your perspective, pick your customer.
Jeremy Gilbertson Wow, question for you there. the distortion gap is real. The distortion gap is real. Yeah, go ahead.
Mark Fielding Yeah, what do mean by that?
The Michael Jordan problem
Nick Richtsmeier What I mean is, it's, you know, like that classic Michael Jordan quote of ⁓ people from both parties buy shoes, right? The reason why he was politically neutral is he was like, well, people of all political persuasions buy shoes. The applicability of that thought is shrinking at a dramatic rate. There are some brands that are large enough that that is to some degree true for, and the way they've handled it is their POV shifts based on whose box they sit in at.
at the swearing in. But for most brands that are sub $100 million.
You just simply don't have the scale, the resources, the tools, the financial structure to serve a broad swath of people. You've got to get specific of who you're going to serve and how you're going to serve them. And one of the ways you have to get specific is what is the information ecosystem that they are consuming? Because that information ecosystem isn't just online. This idea that there's, there's the online and there's the real world and go touch grass. No, our brains are being formatted by these interactions.
how we think, I mean, there's already initial research that some of the word choice narrowing that the LLMs are producing is actually changing the structure of language, how we think about the structure of language. Like your customer is choosing a cage of information, limitation and distortion. You've got to walk into that cage and be comfortable there.
Jeremy Gilbertson ran across a quote last night from Blake Muskogee, the Tom Shoes guy that I thought that was really interesting. And I think I'd love to hear how, hear what you think about this. So ⁓ he was talking about a new idea that he had tried and massively failed and kind of put him into a bit of a funk. His quote was, even if you're, even if your idea works, you still have to understand the system.
that delivers it to the world. And I think that we're swirling around that same thing. So how do you, what's the best way to connect ideas to these cages, right? And that you're talking about and doing it in an authentic way, because the distortions in and of themselves are not authentic of the people that they emanate from, right? So if you're, if you're pitching to people, you're not really, if you pitch to them, they may not listen, but if you pitch to their distortions,
Nick Richtsmeier Yes, absolutely.
Jeremy Gilbertson You might like that's mind boggling, man.
Nick Richtsmeier yeah, it's messy. So ⁓ the short answer is use as few of them as possible. So that doesn't mean that you go become an analog business and you send out a printed newsletter and you put flyers under people's windshield wipers on their cars, although maybe that would work. But brands need to drastically reduce their dependency on distortion platforms because the distortion platforms have figured out the game.
And the game is, we're not even gonna tell you who we're giving your information to. So not only are you dependent on it for distribution, you're dependent on us for customer recognition. You don't even know who your customer is anymore. We're gonna black box that too. As soon as they start selling through LLMs, it's just one more layer of black box around who the customer is. So now you're running an enterprise where you don't even know who your customer is. So who is your customer? Well, your customer is OpenAI.
That's a terrible proposition. So you absolutely do not want to get in a situation. You want to de-risk by being less and less dependent on these, which means you move from a funnel methodology of building a client base, which is lots of people get as much tension as possible, trickle that into a little bit more focused attention, trickle that board into a little bit more focused attention, and eventually sucker people into a point of sale. Funnels don't actually exist. The internet may just think they did.
But lots of people are still doing it and 90 % of marketers are trained on funnel methodology and don't know how to break from it. So you move from funnel methodology to where we started this conversation, which is network methodology, which is everything you need to do, every decision you need to make as a business sub a hundred million, we'll say, is probably something that needs to happen with someone you know or someone who knows someone you know. And I don't need a platform to do that.
If I believe and start to build a business model where every decision I need to make is somewhere between someone I know and someone who knows someone I know, then I can start to make decisions on a network methodology way. Now that doesn't mean I don't have a discord group or it doesn't mean I don't have, I might put some stuff on LinkedIn or whatever. And we're not going to, this isn't an argument for full analog. It's different discussion, but reducing your digital dependency.
is one, a huge de-risking strategy for businesses that they need to think about. And it's also a way of recapturing your financial control. Because almost every business in America is paying the Silicon Valley tax of spending enormous amounts of money to create digital presence that they've been lulled into believing that they have to have that they don't have to have. And it's costing them sometimes three, four, five, 12, 15 % of their top line revenue.
and they're burning money keeping Silicon Valley Well Fund.
An example, walked through
Jeremy Gilbertson Give me an example of a company, talk me through an example of a company that is wrestling with that methodology right now.
Nick Richtsmeier So we were just, I run a community group and we were doing some coaching with that group this morning. And so we were used to, we use the same case study. So this is an organization that does professional services. It's like a network of professional service providers under a central brand. And the owner of that professional services company, much like many of them is obsessed with the idea that they could go build some branded digital funnel to click, click, click, click, click, click. We'll get some customers and then we'll link them to one of our consultants and magical things will happen. Well, that hasn't happened on the internet since like 2018, but sure, let's do it.
Nick Richtsmeier what we're working with that firm to do is what first we have to reeducate the CEO and then we have to reeducate the board. And then we can start to build the processes is we always start with where is there an existing relationship? So in this case, it's a really simple. The founder has been really successful on podcasts. The podcasts have produced an uptick in newsletters.
So we're just doing a basic BDR motion of having somebody pick up the phone and every time somebody signs up for a newsletter, they don't do a sales pitch. just say, hey, I'm assuming you saw owner, Joe on, on this podcast. We care about you. want to be valuable to you. And if you want to talk to us, here's the number to call. And that is based on the belief that their best thing, the thing they need to do next is based on someone they know or someone who knows someone they know. Right. So they shift. So instead of, taking that newsletter person and forcing them into some painstakingly terrible email automation, they bring them into a relationship note. And that relationship note has some potential to bring down defensiveness and bring up trust in tiny little ways. So ⁓ in every little decision we bias, can we earn trust here?
What's our upside trust potential versus our downside trust risk? And email automation, for example, has often way more downside trust risk than upside trust potential. So we don't do them very often. we'd never do them.
Jeremy Gilbertson community node. I think you said community node. Talk to me about that. Where does that live?
A thousand true fans
Mark Fielding It sounds a little bit like a thousand true fans in a way that you have to narrow down your field to actually people who care about you and people who care about you are not at the end of a digital funnel that doesn't exist.
Nick Richtsmeier Yeah, it's a little bit difficult to talk about because it's hard to make it sound innovative and interesting because it's not.
Mark Fielding Well it is now because we've all been blindsided by this. Like when you were speaking to yourself, yep, that sounds right, that sounds right. I felt
At I'm not the only fool in the world because I believe I bought into it as well and you've just made me realise that perhaps, especially for a lot of companies, that it's the wrong way to go increasingly.
Nick Richtsmeier the reality is there's a thousand people have written books about or just described how to do this because this is how humans do things. Networks exist, funnels don't exist. Funnels don't actually exist, they never existed. It was a way to market marketing. It was a way to get CEOs to buy digital marketing was to invent this idea of digital funnel. Thank you HubSpot, we appreciate you. ⁓
Networks actually exist. So there's endless material on how to create a great powerful and successful network Because we've been doing it since we had prefrontal cortexes. So let's keep let's let's do what's actually exists in the real world Right one of your previous guests said I think everything that matters is everything that's real is analog, right? This is another application of that everything that's real is analog and that's true for businesses to everything that's real is analog
Jeremy Gilbertson It's funny that the one thing I think people are missing with this and I think this is where you're talking about the the Silicon Valley ⁓ Influence tax right is that Requires patience it requires patient investors. It requires intention. It is not the easy button so ⁓ And it's in it's in it's well, it's it's more it's more
Mark Fielding It's not immediate.
Jeremy Gilbertson Dunbar's number than something logarithmic, right, or exponential. So how do you convince someone to be patient?
Deciding where you want to live
Nick Richtsmeier I think they have to decide where they want to live. when we're talking to investors or CEOs or helping CEOs talk to investors, we just try to we suss out first. If your capital, if your source of capital, their comfort zone of risk is we would rather tank 20 companies and have one go 100 X. Then you got to play. You got to play. They want to play. And what that means is you got to burn money.
begging attention on the internet as fast as humanly possible to get to a certain level of scale and cross your fingers that someone buys you. That's it. That system is what it is and for whatever percent, 5, 10 % of companies, if that's what your capital demands of you and they have no flexibility, it is what it is. Now there's a big messy middle of sources of capital that are kind of buying into that idea because
That's what seems normal, but they don't, they're not, they don't really have any real conviction. And if you can present to them to say, okay, we have option A is we destroy 25 companies and the, and the money that built them in the hopes that one goes a hundred X and get sold that strategy, a, which makes a lot of money for people. It's made some of the biggest puzzle money in the history of the world. Strategy B is we go slow to go fast. We build fundamentals. We think strategically. We.
We don't make big bets. We don't use your money to just burn through failure. And we go slow to go fast so that by the time we're ready to scale, we're scaling with real relationships and not bought attention. Are you willing to go on the go slow to go fast journey with us? And of course, that's a much longer than a three minute spiel. I find that a lot of people are really open to that because everybody else is as tired of this as we are. It's just no one's giving people permission to do it a different way.
Jeremy Gilbertson there's going to be more people that are going to want to dig into that. There's going be more people that...
are gonna listen to records, there's gonna be more people that write in really cool notebooks, there's gonna be more people sitting around a table like a salon in Vienna in the 1600s to unpack ideas for the shit of it, right? So I think it's an interesting thing to be talking about right now.
Nick Richtsmeier Yeah, sociologically, I agree. think, I think we will a hundred years from now, there will be the, the, the web primacy era. The web will always be here as a function of society, just like many other archaic technologies, but there will be a brief period of time in the early two thousands where the web was the central feature. And people actually believe that we were going to sort of digitally replace analog existence. And then eventually it's going to become the phone company.
And it's this thing that we use and as a part of our life and connects things and it's in the background and has probably all kinds of regulatory problems with it. And we're going to realize like, actually the human shit matters, right? Listening to records, writing by hand. you're seeing, you know, some of this people thought it was sort of a trend in COVID. And I think COVID did trigger some things, but this is, this has long lasted the COVID trend. People are really asking fundamental questions of what makes a good life.
Are young people asking this?
Mark Fielding Are young people asking this question because we do, we get around to this and what about the TikTok generation? What about the 18 year olds now?
Nick Richtsmeier I find they're not coming around to it, I think they're leading it in some cases.
It's yeah. Yep. It's not something to be unlocked. It's present. It's there. It's yeah.
Nick Richtsmeier you watch how these guys actually use the technology. And I would argue that in many cases, it is much healthier than how their parents are using the technology. Right? You have a bunch of late Gen Xers or et cetera, who are like, still think Instagram is real. I mean, which is insane.
Jeremy Gilbertson That's a very good point.
Nick Richtsmeier that someone in their 40s or 50s thinks that what they're seeing on Instagram is anything replicating reality. 17 year olds don't think it's real. It's a game to be played. TikTok is a game to be played. They know it's a game. They know they're being manipulated. They know they're participating in the manipulation. It's a gamified and that doesn't mean it's not toxic, but there's just a whole different level of consciousness that's in play.
I think even in the so-called TikTok generation.
Jeremy Gilbertson So I've got kids that are, my oldest is in college, my youngest is a sixth grader. Mark has kids that are a little bit younger than mine. And we always talk about, you know, when they should dive into technology and that sort of thing. So I'd, see different uses and my son that's a freshman, like throws all these really interesting ideas out to me and his understanding of space technology and all this weird stuff that I get involved in. And he's like, I found it on TikTok.
Jeremy Gilbertson it's a very interesting balance. And I think the older people struggle with it more. They're sitting there just peppering Instagram, feeling bad about themselves because they don't have the abs this guy has and they don't have a coaching business that throws $5 million a month, you know.
There's an artificiality of what you see, like you said, yeah.
Mark Fielding saw that when we read the Alan Turing report on AI, generative AI use in schools in the UK and they interviewed the kids, eight, nine, 10, 11 year old kids about what they thought about AI. And the responses were much more thoughtful and much more profound and much more poetic than literally 95 % of the posts I read on Twitter or LinkedIn about generative AI. So is this because
Mark Fielding As Jamie alluded to, it's innate. We are analog creatures. Is there a rebellion to what the generation before is doing? Like this is a punk rock movement and we're to not do this because our parents do this. What do you think culturally is happening?
The human soul remains undefeated
Nick Richtsmeier the human soul remains undefeated. Like that is a core tenet of mine. I think there is a punk rock thing. I also think consciously in terms of how our consciousness works, we consciously engage something that is our soup.
differently than something that we discover, right? So for Gen Z, the web-based technology is the soup. It's always been, they were born into it. And so they have a different relationship to it. They're not impressed by it, right? None of us are impressed by a telephone. We were never impressed by a telephone, because we were born into it. Gen X and a little bit Millennial saw these things come up out of the ether, and particularly come up out of the ether in the hands of some demigod level marketers. And so we still think it's cool. Like, I mean, you talk to Gen X and millennial, mostly Gen X people about technology, they still think Steve Jobs is in the room. I'm like, is he still here? Like, because it was just, this technology was delivered to us. It isn't all about Steve Jobs, but just by some legendary.
once in a generation, even once in multiple generations level marketers. And we just under, we grossly underestimate the impacts of that.
We just got sold so hard. mean, people still talk about that stupid 1984 commercial. It's really not that good.
Jeremy Gilbertson I think the more people talk about it in like ad schools and agencies and all of that, circling back to that point, it just gives it more power, I think. ⁓ So Mark and I have had this, had a very interesting debate, dare I call it potentially heated debate. I think in one of our last shows related to curiosity and.
Mark Fielding my behalf. Don't know about you, but I was very heated.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, no, it was good. So we talk a lot about curiosity. It's another theme. I believe it's the fuel source that powers all the things we want to do. And if we can access it in the right way, you know, we're lighting ourselves up. And Mark has a different opinion that curiosity can be co-opted. I think attention can be co-opted, can be hijacked. think attention can be hijacked. Mark believes curiosity can be hijacked. My question for you.
Is marketing a con?
Jeremy Gilbertson There you go. My question for you is why could marketing be considered manipulated curiosity?
Nick Richtsmeier I think in some cases it is. I mean, I, there.
I don't, this is probably bite me in the butt to say this on a public forum, but like, just think marketing as a discipline is not great. most of our clients, we try to help them do as little marketing as possible to get to where they want to go. ⁓ Particularly since it's become primarily digital marketing, it's really not great. I don't think it treats companies well. I don't think it treats consumers well. I think it drags us to least common denominators. I think we've all just sort of accepted a level of it's all, it's just marketing that, that dehumanizes us in a way that's just not necessary. think we can grow businesses, earn clients, add revenue. can do all those sort of fundamental business development things, build brands and just not succumb to these sort of really sad lowest common denominators. I think to the question of, it manipulated curiosity? Sure. It's manipulated a lot of things.
I don't know where this lands in you all's great debate. I missed that episode. But ⁓ I think anything truly generative about the human spirit is manipulative.
because it's the soft tissue of who we are. And soft tissue gets wounded and can be damaged and turned into something dark. only way to make it unmanipulatable is to not have it. And that would be really sad.
The quote about efficiency
Jeremy Gilbertson I like that. I like that. there's one quote that I saw that I found really interesting. I want to try and find it here. Related to efficiencies.
Do you know what quote I'm referring to so I don't have to dig it up?
Nick Richtsmeier we spent a generation obsessing about efficiency only to find that the inefficiencies are load-bearing.
The load bearing side
Jeremy Gilbertson Talk to me about the load-bearing side of that. What do you mean by load-bearing?
Nick Richtsmeier that sometimes things that take a really long time are the things that hold the roof up.
conversation is inefficient, democracy is inefficient, sex is inefficient, Good sex is inefficient. the things that matter are not easily optimized and if you try to optimize you ruin them.
And so when optimization is in our top tier of priorities, we are absolutely on the risk train to destroy what matters. can't, I'm not saying ignore optimization, but we've built a culture and an economy where optimization is in spot one or two at almost any given time. And so no wonder we burn the whole freaking thing to the ground. Because inefficiencies, our load bearing of what matters of everything that we do in our social relationships, in our communities, in our businesses,
Mark Fielding What might be an example in business?
Nick Richtsmeier almost everything. I mean, I think in a business, I think in a business environment, user research is inefficient. If you're talking about technology, like really understanding what your users want and why they want it. Yeah. Qualitative user research, not just like gaming it so that you can justify the spend, but like actually engaging.
Jeremy Gilbertson qualitative side of that, right? Yeah.
Nick Richtsmeier It's a really inefficient process because people's opinions aren't easily categorized. ⁓ In the iSpace, ⁓ risk management is grossly inefficient. actually getting under the hood, it's really hard to get under the hood of an LLM and figure out where the risk is because the data is not even there.
Jeremy Gilbertson And even if the data was there, the mapping of the data is totally uncut.
Nick Richtsmeier Right, so you actually have to invent categories and invent questions to even start mapping data to, to even go, well, what, we don't even know what risks were exposed to, much less how to measure those. Like the process by which we would actually think about risk management for LLMs is so complex and end grossly inefficient because we've never done it before. But I don't know, maybe we should do it anyway.
Mark Fielding Well, that's the beauty of it for them is that it's so unbelievably complex and no one's going to attempt to do it because they can't.
Nick Richtsmeier Right, so they get some headlines and go, we've got a thousand people working on risk mitigation and people go, okay, check. And talk to people who actually worked in those risk mitigation arenas. Ask them what it was like. I mean, it's fascinating.
A musical example of inefficiency
Jeremy Gilbertson Let's talk, so let me give you a musical example of inefficiency versus efficiency, right? So the things that matter, you said we're in danger of losing the things that matter. And I think you're absolutely right. Our economy is built on ⁓ companies that are optimizing efficiency and scale for us in various ways through platforms, tools, things that they are producing, right? And this is really an interesting thread. ⁓ So you think about music.
Okay. You think about the reason why when you listen to a song where you start going like this and start doing this and you make that little bass face because the groove is so good. Right. And then you listen to a groove. When I say groove, it's bass and drums, right? A groove that is done in a computer that is quantized, very efficient. don't, just, you just half play it on a keyboard. You quantize it, it locks in and it's boring as shit. But the, the, the misses.
Jeremy Gilbertson The fact that that drummer's kick drum is hitting just, ⁓ maybe just a little late or just a little early, like J Dilla was early, Levan Helm was late, like all of this, that's why it matters, right? So that's where I go to in thinking about efficiencies and inefficiencies.
Nick Richtsmeier Yeah, I mean, and we could even stay in music and take it up to the technology level, right? again, times when the internet was good, right? Back when we would like make playlists based on other people's playlists and you would like go to somebody's place, go, oh, you like this song? Oh, I never heard of that song. And I'd grab it. I put it in a playlist. Of course, we first did that illegally. And then eventually we did it on iTunes. But that was a really inefficient process. You'd spend hours meticulously scrolling through people's playlists and grabbing them. And Spotify says, well, don't worry. We'll just do that for you.
We'll just grab all the songs that people like you like. And of course, now the research makes really clear that the same 500 songs end up on all the playlists because they're the ones that validate Spotify's metric, which Spotify hates it when you skip out on a song in the middle of the song. Well, you know what songs get skipped out on? Ones that are interesting that you've never heard before. Right. But landslide never gets skipped out on. People always listen to landslide till the end.
So they put landslide in every freaking playlist. Well, I love landslide, but I don't want it in every playlist, right? So it's inefficient to build thoughtful, creative, inspiring, evocative playlists. It's incredibly inefficient. Doing it in an efficient way, you're going to listen to the same thousand songs for the rest of
Mark Fielding I'm sure Jamie did the same, but I used to record my tapes off the radio with a tape waiting to press record. And that takes a whole another another level of inefficiency. you speak a lot about resilience.
Jeremy Gilbertson yeah, hit the timing.
Resilience
Mark Fielding and to accept a lot of these inefficiencies, you have to be resilient because it takes time, it takes failure, it takes more time and more failure. How do you think about resilience and
Mark Fielding How do we get more of it?
Nick Richtsmeier Yeah, I use ⁓ an anatomical sort of metaphor for this is, know, like the reason why lifting heavy things is good for your body is because it doesn't create big injuries, it creates little micro tears in the muscle, right? So everybody's obsessed about weight lifting because those little micro tears then get healed and the muscle gets stronger and gets healed, the muscle gets stronger, right? So that when you eventually have to do something that's really uncomfortable, your body's built for it.
And there's no way to shortcut that. It's incredibly, that's another thing that's inefficient. Weightlifting's inefficient. ⁓ Resilience is a function of a thousand small, a billion small inefficiencies building up to strength. That's what resilience is. Is we take little tiny efficiencies and we add them up and we add them up and we add them up and we get strength in the end. And that's a really important thing because bad news for everybody, everything's moving to entropy.
everything's moving to falling apart. So what do we need when everything falls apart? Resilience. So the end game for everybody is a resilience game. The end game for every business is a resilience game. The end game from every small town and city and like the United States of America and its definition of democracy is in the middle of a resilience game. Are we resilient enough to live through this thing and maintain some semblance of who we are?
everything ends in a resilience game. So it's like, it's super important, I guess, to simplify the point.
Kevin Kelly, and what Nick wants
Mark Fielding So Kevin Kelly, a thousand true fans, I think he's a relevant name for this conversation. He left us a question, he asked us a question, I guess, on thinking and paper at the end. What do we want humans to be? And how does technology help us get there? If indeed it does.
Nick Richtsmeier ironic to our previous conversation, I think we want, I want humans to be curious. I think I want us to be driven to wonder and imagination and what else could we know that's worth knowing? And can that be weaponized? Sure. But I still want it. I think to balance that out, I want us to be humble. I want us to realize that what we think is big is so small in the grand sense of almost everything, right? Our lives are short. Our planet's a little tiny speck. Like humility allows us to have a more resilient curiosity. And the other thing I thought of is just as relates because we're on a sort of a technology ish podcast is I want us to be agentic.
I want humans to have agency. I want our decisions to have effect. I want the nihilism of our time that says, it doesn't matter. It is what it is. I want to stamp that out like a thousand fires. Because humans who believe that their choices have meaning and have efficacy are better humans. They just are. And they have the capacity to be better humans. So those are my three. That's what I would want.
Jeremy Gilbertson Wonderful, man. Wonderful. I do have a lot of other threads we could go down, but in the interest of time, maybe we could do a round two at some point. But Nick, thanks so much for joining us and being so willing to bounce all over the place with a lot of these things. But I think all of these are foundational elements to being a human, participating in the world with meaning, with purpose, all of that. So thank you very much for sharing your ideas.
Nick Richtsmeier Thank you guys for the time. I really enjoyed it.
Mark Fielding And I'm also going to borrow Steele, that new Thinking on Paper logline, a technology-ish podcast, which is actually, that is what we do. Because I've been looking for everything because we're not a 100 % technology podcast. And I think as we go into the future, we want to speak to writers and authors and more. A technology-ish podcast.
Jeremy Gilbertson It's great. It's perfect.
Mark Fielding I will borrow, we will steal it. Thank you.
Nick Richtsmeier I mean, it's part of what I love about you guys is like, you know, as one episode it's like, here's how we're going to go to the moon. You know, and the next episode is this really sort of humanist, deep, know, soulful thing. It's why I find what you do fascinating.
Mark Fielding It's like that mixtape, isn't it? Because we're creating a mixtape that we make ourselves rather than this Spotify version. We're going back to recording off the radio,
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, this has been amazing. ⁓ Thanks for listening, everybody. You know where to find us, thinkingonpaper.xyz. Be curious, stay disruptive.
Mark Fielding Keep thinking on paper.




