How Do You Build a Moon Base on a Budget?

The plan the hosts work through starts a lunar industry with 12 metric tons of hardware on the Moon. Interesting to note that by generation two, there are no human outposts. It's all tele-operated.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 18 chapters

  1. The phases
  2. It sounds like science fiction
  3. Metric tons as the measure
  4. Twelve metric tons, and what that costs
  5. The goal from that point
  6. We are going to print out the moon
  7. We will not start at the beginning
  8. Moravec, and the intelligence framework
  9. By generation two, no humans
  10. Lithography machines on the moon
  11. L4 and L5
  12. Power, diggers, chemical plants
  13. How do you coordinate with a delay?
  14. Digital twins, and the M word
  15. The jump off point is not the hard part
  16. Terraforming, or space manufacturing
  17. Landing the plane
  18. In praise of grandiose ambition
What kind of species do we want to be? Do we want to be here, chained to the earth forever? Or do we want to be out there colonising the solar system, taking our curious blend of culture to the stars?
Mark Fielding

Mark Fielding and Jeremy Gilbertson read a paper by Philip Metzger, Anthony Muscatello, Robert Mueller and James Mantovani on bootstrapping a space industry from the Moon. It climbs through generations of lunar industry, from teleoperated machines to robots that 3D print what they need.

The hosts cover Hans Moravec's scale of machine intelligence, lithography machines on the Moon and why a two and a half second delay makes teleoperation hard. Then they weigh the plan against terraforming Mars, and ask what human nature might do to it.

Affordable, Rapid Bootstrapping of the Space Industry and Solar System Civilization, a paper by Philip Metzger and three co-authors, plans to start a self-replicating lunar industry from about 12 metric tons of hardware landed on the Moon. On the Thinking On Paper podcast, Mark Fielding and Jeremy Gilbertson read how robots would expand it generation by generation through the solar system, and Mark doubts the timeline.

How do you build a Moon base on a budget?

Philip Metzger's paper proposes landing about 12 metric tons of hardware on the Moon and letting robots expand the industry generation by generation. Mark doubts the timeline.

Why does the Metzger plan start with 1700s era machines?

The paper deliberately starts with old technology. Jeremy reads that the first robotic colonists on the Moon would fabricate “1700s era machines” and advance them through the 1800s and 1900s back to the 2000s; Mark quotes the line “we will not start at the beginning and we will not begin at the end”. Each new generation of machines is at first less productive than the one shipped from Earth, then improves.

When do humans leave the Moon in the Metzger plan?

Humans leave the Moon early in the plan. In the hosts' reading, the first generation imports machines that produce gases, water, crude alloys, ceramics and solar cells, and by generation two there are no human outposts: everything is tele-operated, meaning controlled remotely from Earth. Later generations add chip-making lithography machines and move towards full autonomy.

How is robot intelligence measured on the Moravec scale?

The robots' intelligence is mapped to Hans Moravec's scale, which runs from insect-like through lizard, mouse and monkey to human-like AI. Jeremy reads the paper's citation of Moravec predicting lizard level by 2020, mouse level by 2030, monkey level by 2040 and human level by 2050.

Why does communication delay limit remote control on the Moon?

Communication delay limits remote control to the Moon. Mark puts the Earth to Moon delay at two and a half seconds and reads the paper's answer: resynchronising in a virtual world, as in telesurgery, which needs a “growing and expensive workforce of teleoperators on Earth” and “will not be extendable to the asteroid belt or beyond”. That is why the plan needs autonomous robots.

What is the payoff of a self-replicating space industry?

The payoff is industrial scale beyond Earth's limits. Jeremy says the paper claims that within a few decades this could reach millions of times the industrial capacity of the United States, and Mark reads its warning of “a significant national security risk”, because in a robotic industry occupying the solar system “the resources and real estate are a billion times greater”.

Where Mark and Jeremy disagree

Mark doubts the timeline, saying “I would be very surprised if I see humanoids on the moon doing even the most rudimentary tasks”, and warns that tele-operation jobs would vanish once autonomy arrives. Jeremy calls offloading that work to robots off the planet “a happy offload”. Both see human nature, not engineering, as the obstacle: the risk that one nation or corporation controls the industry.

Questions

How do you build a Moon base on a budget?

Philip Metzger's paper proposes landing about 12 metric tons of hardware on the Moon and letting robots expand the industry generation by generation. Mark doubts the timeline.

What is the Philip Metzger space industry paper about?

Affordable, Rapid Bootstrapping of the Space Industry and Solar System Civilization, a paper by Philip Metzger and three co-authors, plans to start a self-replicating lunar industry from about 12 metric tons of hardware landed on the Moon.

Who wrote the paper on bootstrapping a space industry?

Mark Fielding and Jeremy Gilbertson read a paper by Philip Metzger, Anthony Muscatello, Robert Mueller and James Mantovani on bootstrapping a space industry from the Moon.

How much hardware does the Metzger plan need on the Moon?

Affordable, Rapid Bootstrapping of the Space Industry and Solar System Civilization, a paper by Philip Metzger and three co-authors, plans to start a self-replicating lunar industry from about 12 metric tons of hardware landed on the Moon.

Transcript

Mark Fielding Disruptors and curious minds, welcome to Thinking on Paper, Pocket Edition. And I want to start with a question. What kind of species do we want to be? Do we want to be here, chained to the earth forever? Or do we want to be out there colonising the solar system, taking our curious blend of culture to the stars? Because if we want to do that, if we want to take humanity beyond the realms of planet Earth. We're gonna have to do some serious manufacturing in space. We're gonna have to humanoids, self-replicating humanoids on the moon. We're gonna have to diggers, diggers on asteroids. There's a lot going on and today we are speaking about rapid bootstrapping.

Mark Fielding of the space industry and solar system civilization. What can we achieve? How much will it cost? And what are the steps to get there? And Jeremy is going to explain more. And also, by the way, at the end, we're going to speak about Aliens, Total Recall, Blade Runner, all my favorite movies.

Jeremy Gilbertson Let's go, let's go. So this pocket edition has been really fun for me. We basically just every week we just find something that's interesting, a paper, an article. You we did Mustafa Suleyman's seemingly conscious AI. So we're just grabbing stuff that's interesting to us. Hopefully it's interesting to you and kind of unpacking it together. Cause that's the power of like you read something, but then you can riff on it with somebody. It's what we do in book club. It's what we do on our episode. So.

Off we go. Today's pocket edition is Affordable Rapid Bootstrapping of Space Industry and Solar System Civilization. Philip Metzger, Anthony Muscatello, Robert Mueller, and James Mantovani. So very smart guys, largely all NASA people, largely all physicists, chemists, that sort of thing. Those things we are not, but.

Mark Fielding It was very impressive CVs.

Jeremy Gilbertson very impressive. let's let's start from the top, right? So this is Mark's gonna laugh at me again. But hey, this this high frontier book is coming up again. This guy Gerard O'Neill back in the night.

Mark Fielding Well, he's mentioned, he's name checked in this.

Jeremy Gilbertson back in the 1980s figured out a way to create, you know, lower earth orbit civilizations. And with the technology they had in the 80s, which is pretty amazing, but guess what? Like all really good ideas that could benefit humanity, they get squashed in favor of capitalism and money making. So anyway, here we go. my gosh, hold me back.

Mark Fielding Calm down, Jeremy, we'll get to all of that. Every time human nature gets in the way, but before we get there, let's paint our audience a picture of what we can achieve and how quickly and how affordable it is.

The phases

Jeremy Gilbertson So here's the deal, here's what I got out of this and let's kind of just outline where we're going. So we can start a space industry, a space economy that does things in space eventually better and more efficient than we can do them on the planet that can mine resources that are external to the planet that actually help keep the planet functioning longer and lets us be humans on the planet longer. So it's really interesting.

But it comes into a couple of phases. starting small, so getting stuff off the earth, onto the moon, and then starting simple with this process of, he calls it tele-operating. So basically like remote operating these systems that are built on the moon in small scale, and then scaling those systems with robotics, with AI, and eventually to where we have, we're leaving our jump off point on the moon.

and then going to the solar system and asteroids and all of that stuff. So that's kind of where we're headed with this. I thought it was really interesting. I'm a super nerd on the high frontier stuff. I reference it a lot. I think it's literally a moonshot idea. It's really, really a cool idea that won't take a whole lot to get kicked off the ground, which is why it's called bootstrapping. Where do you want to start, Mark? What grabs your attention early?

Mark Fielding Well, it's not a moonshot, it? mean, growing populations, climate crisis, energy demands. We can't live here forever. Can we live here for another few hundred years? Sometimes that's debatable. So.

Mark Fielding I think so the solar system's resources are the key to humanity's future. So in the introduction, they are outlined the fact that all of the natural resources that we've used on planet Earth are in fact exist in the solar system in multiples of billions. So we don't need to be harnessed to planet Earth and all our resources. They are all out there in space. The initial problem, so with this rapid bootstrapping, essentially there's, he talks about generations.

steps from step zero to fully autonomous self replicating robots out in space with a giant manufacturing industry mining resources in one part of the solar system taking to the other expanding our footprint expanding our reach out into space but that starts with generation one and that involves going to the moon and starting with a kind of hybrid moon-based, earth-based technology and using current existing technologies, 3D printing, to start building on the moon, essentially, and going from there.

It sounds like science fiction

Jeremy Gilbertson So reminder listeners that this might sound very sci-fi, if you go back and look, we've interviewed a tremendous amount of really smart people who are doing things today that are very in line with this stuff, space-based solar power. We've had multiple guests on how that technology has come along. And actually the application of AI to something like this, to robotics and the...

Robotics is a realm we're going to start to explore a little bit more on the show as well. yeah, so

Mark Fielding I think it is science fiction, that's just the design of our species, isn't mean, just reading through this paper, there's so much vocabulary that we're used to seeing, humanoids, robotic laborers.

off chain, off world colonies. When we're used to seeing also, yes, it is very science fiction because a lot of the movies and the books that we read speak about this.

life imitating art imitating life imitating art.

Metric tons as the measure

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, yeah, yeah. let's, the paper references metric tons as a metric, as a piece of the puzzle of the formulas that they kind of go through. It's like, how much stuff do we need to get started with something on the moon that could eventually get us to a point where we're manufacturing in space, we're doing what they call, what do they call, closed loop or full loop? Basically meaning that everything, manufactured is happening in space and nothing is happening with resources from the earth. It's kind of doing it all on its own. Full closure, that's what it was. Yep.

Mark Fielding Full closure, isn't it? So you have these different, you have part, full closure, partial closure and sub replicating. So you have full closure, everything is done automatically self replicating by machines in space. You have partial, which is people on earth remotely orchestrating some of this. And then you have like sub replicating, which is a combination of the two, which this paper is essentially number three, isn't it? Because it starts with.

So why is the weight part so interesting and so important, Joe and me?

Jeremy Gilbertson Because I think where it always lands and where it landed, you know, why High Frontier, I don't think caught on as quickly as it could have is launch costs, right? Exit velocity of getting the needed pieces and parts to build these systems. know, launch costs were super challenging, you know, in the 80s, but like launch costs are coming down right now. And I think I looked at today, the 2025 launch costs based on SpaceX's numbers per kilogram, it was like 4,000 bucks per kilogram today if you wanted to put something into space, which

Twelve metric tons, and what that costs

Mark Fielding And Falcon 9 and our guess they would SpaceX goal is kind of $10 a kilo, their initial long-term goals. And obviously that makes a few differences. Were you surprised by the actual weight? I was surprised by the weight that they suggest is what we need to begin.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, 12 metric tons.

Mark Fielding It seems, doesn't seem like too much.

Jeremy Gilbertson It really doesn't. It really doesn't. it's interesting too, the way they together, this group of people, outline the scaling of this is it actually is a two steps forward, four steps back initially kind of thing, right? So when they put this, wow, well played, well played. So 12 metric tons of stuff gets on the moon.

Mark Fielding Paul of Abdul in space.

Jeremy Gilbertson We do some stuff remote operated, we get some robots doing some basic things. And then the next generation of that, because we're basically trying to replicate systems. So the first replication of that system is actually less productive than the system we ship up there. And then as we move through cycles of that replication, it gets better, it gets more efficient. The robotics get better, the launch costs come down and all of those things, right? But.

According to the paper, it says within a few decades, we could have millions of times the industrial capacity of the United States, which is like, wow, okay. So we talk a lot about, you know, the effect of technology on climate, on, you know, the, the, the, the life cycle of humanity on the earth. This seems like a really compelling, thing to consider given that, Hey, we can move all of the industrial things.

off of the planet and mitigate the effects on climate change and things that could make Earth uninhabitable eventually seems really interesting.

The goal from that point

Mark Fielding So on that, just to quote from the paper, the goal from that point is to initiate a spiral of technological advancements until the moon achieves its own mature capabilities like Earth's. This evolving approach will provide several benefits. First, industry on the moon can develop differently than on Earth, the environment, the manufacturing materials, the operators, robots, and the products and target markets are all different.

It gives it time to develop. Second, the evolving approach supports the development of automation so that industry can then spread far beyond the moon. The technological spiral will develop the robotic workers in parallel with the factories. It will also improve automated manufacturing techniques, which is 3D printing. And then the third is obviously the economic one that the advantages of building on the moon.

Jeremy Gilbertson And what this pay as we're as we're working through this this paper what the goal the stated goal of the paper was to figure out how much mass you know how much mass we need to blast off of earth to land on the moon and how much time is needed to create what they call the ignition point of self-sustaining and expanding industry right so the what's the catalyst to enable this stuff over time right and again

You know, they reference thinking on paper in an interesting way, not the show, but they organize their thinking on this topic by writing a paper. Imagine that. Imagine that.

We are going to print out the moon

Mark Fielding to my sound bite take home of the paper, we're going to print our way to the future. It seems that humanity is very much based on 3D printing. Obviously when they say 3D printing and...

we'll get to the generations of lunar industry in a minute, but quite quickly in this generational arc, there are self replicating robots using 3D printers to print themselves, to rebuild themselves and the machinery and the infrastructure that they need, which is just stunning, basically. Just robots creating.

updated versions of themselves out on in the Kuiper belt somewhere.

Jeremy Gilbertson Right, well here's the thing, like what it references to and once they get to the moon and establish stuff on the moon, there's ice on the, I guess polar ice caps on the moon, so there is stuff to work with but it's limited, right? So, you know, once that stuff is gone, it's kind of gone, right? But that's when they have to jump off and hit the Kuiper belt and hit all these other places to kind of continue.

what's going on in here, but they referenced it a bunch of times in the paper. You know, the key is that we get significant advancement in robotics to basically be able to do the things, not just build these giant machines that will initially need to bootstrap, but they're talking about being able to print or being able to manufacture computer chips eventually is the goal, right? So these lithography machines, we're going to land those on the mood and robots are going to be making chips. So,

Here's a quote too I reference, remember the Paul Abdul, two steps forward, four steps back. The objective for the first robotic colonists on the moon to fabricate a set of say 1700s era machines and then advance them steadily through the equivalent of 1800s, 1900s and finally back to the 2000s, which is really interesting to think about. And we were not landing there just trying to.

you know, do stuff that is 10 steps ahead. This is kind of a thoughtful process of getting from A to B.

We will not start at the beginning

Mark Fielding there's a very nice quote that they, we will not start at the beginning and we will not begin at the end. So they will start very in the 1700s and then we'll very quickly, rapidly update, upgrade, advance that technology through the centuries. I just wonder how many of our listeners we've lost with our Paula Abdel references.

Jeremy Gilbertson No, 90s? Dude, we're 90s dads. Remember 80s 90s dads? Like, come on, No, so

Mark Fielding Speak to me about the generations of lunar industry. I think it's very important to outline the six generations or the one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight generations that they mentioned.

Jeremy Gilbertson When, what, where on the paper are you there so I can, page five. Yes, yeah, yeah, yeah. Let me get there.

Mark Fielding I think the generations is key. If we do the generation part and then what we need, what they want to build, then because then it lists all of the things that we need, the solar cell manufacturing, the metal and ceramics, power stations, robo-nolls. So if we kind of speak about the generations.

Moravec, and the intelligence framework

Jeremy Gilbertson Whose artificial intelligence framework is, it was referenced here, but the insect-like, through lizard-like, through mouse-like, through monkey-like, and human-like?

Mark Fielding I have highlighted that. Table 1, Moravec. No, Moravec, yes. Hans Moravec.

Jeremy Gilbertson Moravec. Yeah, that's right. That's right. apparently I haven't, I haven't researched his stuff yet, but it sounds like there are different levels of artificial intelligence enablement for, for robots, for systems and that sort of thing. So, yeah, let's run through these. so generation one is we've got some stuff on the moon there. it's could be locally out. Maybe we've got some humans on the moon as well to initially kick this thing off with a couple of robots.

most of the systems are kind of operated from Earth, right? You know, similar to some of the things that happen on the, know, space station, think there's some remote operation stuff that happens there, but that teleoperation continues through the first three generations. And we're in, yeah.

Mark Fielding What kind of things are they manufacturing in generation one and two? What materials?

Jeremy Gilbertson So generation one to me looks like all of the systems that in that 12 metric tons that land on the moon are the industry, are the manufacturing, right? So the materials would be gases, water, crude alloys, ceramics and solar cells. But basically we're importing these fully put together machines and we're doing that in generation one with insect-like artificial intelligence. The levels of that, I'm not sure what that enables or translates to, but you then we move into a little bit more crude fabrication. Some bigger things get imported from Earth. Stage or generation two and a half. Let's see, we're getting into plastics and rubbers, some chemicals.

By generation two, no humans

Mark Fielding Interesting to note that by generation two, there are no human outposts. It's all tele-operated. Like the second generation, humans are out of the loop on the ground, on the moon, and it's all tele-operated from...

Jeremy Gilbertson Does he talk about the years between these stages?

Mark Fielding Yeah, did that month, two years, it depends though, because later on you get wrote slow robonauts and you get person I imagine like personality driven robonauts that are a bit slow. and different materials and different things that they need to take different amounts of time. So it's not always linear, but between months and years.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, so we get, know, in, in, in generation three, we still have teleoperation, some experiments in autonomy. maybe we're locally building PC cards and chassis on the moon. That's pretty fricking awesome. and then generation four, we've got some autonomy continuing to happen with some close, close supervision, right? And we're, we're into large plants for chemicals and manufacturing and, and metals.

Lithography machines on the moon

Jeremy Gilbertson And ooh, this is where the potential lithography machines land on the moon from Earth, right? And we start figuring out, can we make chips? Can the robots, is the dexterity there enough? Can they, you the precision there enough? And then we have more loosely supervised autonomy.

Mark Fielding And that's when, so the good news very quickly becomes bad news because I was thinking reading this paper, I've lost my job because of AI. If you can't work on the earth, then you work in space. And there's a lot of jobs tele-operating all of this industry, all of this manufacturing, high labor costs. So for four generations, we're dancing all the way to the bank. But then as soon as the autonomy kicks in, then once again humanity will be suffering a change in employment.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, think it would be, I think to me that is a getting robots to do stuff like that off the planet that doesn't affect the planet. That is a happy offload. I think for me, at least in my understanding of how everything operates at this point, then we can do things like host podcasts and we could read books and we could teach and we could write and we could.

Mark Fielding Well, yeah, but it's just an interesting dynamic that we're seeing with AI, or at least people are talking about with AI taking everyone's jobs and what will it replace those jobs with? And a lot of the theories of what the jobs AI takes will be replaced with don't hold water for me. But this is a good opportunity to employ thousands, possibly hundreds of thousands, possibly millions in space manufacturing.

And then we'll go through another shift like we might do with AI in terms of those jobs disappearing.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, you know what we could do is you I was tagged on a comment on LinkedIn. I think you tagged me on it about OB. I think it's basically this AI class content, you could build your own class. So what we'll do is create thinking on paper university with a first course being tele operated remote manufacturing from Earth to the moon. That's our first class Mark. So there we go.

Mark Fielding PS early did that because I want to get that guy on the show.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, right, right, right, right. Okay, so let's run through these other stages. So, you five and six, we're near at full autonomy in generation six, where artificial intelligence scale according to, what was that guy's name again? Mironov? No.

Mark Fielding Hands are more of a

Jeremy Gilbertson Moravec, Moravec, we're in monkey-like, right? So we've got large scale self-supporting, so that's really interesting. And now we're starting to do little jaunts to the Kuiper belt off the moon.

Mark Fielding Yeah, exporting industry to asteroid main belt, yes.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, we say that we chuckle at this, it's really cool at the same time. It's really cool. And then the phase beyond that, we're in autonomous robots that we've set up stations here and there. We're bringing resources back from the asteroid belt. We're zero gravity manufacturing. Who knows, maybe we have a mass launcher from Gerard O'Neill that we fire stuff off the moon and

You know, it lands and maybe we have, have you read about L4 and L5? What is that? It's not your, it's not in your back, but it's these points in space that allow when you have two bodies, know, two bodies say earth and the moon, there are two points in space or no, maybe four points in space that allow stuff to sit there without being yanked out or spun in gravity. It's basically a consistent zone that you can literally park shit in.

Mark Fielding Yeah, you need to make this clear for the listeners.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, fire on. I'll look it up. Fire on to the next thing that you want to chat about.

Mark Fielding You say it's cool, but it's also very, very important for the long-term survival of humanity. I mean, the long, long, long, long term, the sun is going to end one day. And in the very, very slim likelihood that we are still here, we will need to be elsewhere. We cannot be here. So the idea of self-replicating robots taking their diggers from the moon, two asteroids on the Kuiper belt hitching a ride on an asteroid into the deepest, darkest depths of the solar system and then jettisoning off, slingshotting around Jupiter and catapulting themselves off into the heart of the solar system is actually probably the only way that our strange curious culture will live forever.

So bring on the human-like robust exports, imports through zones of solar system, material factories specialised by zoners of the solar system, electronic factories made in space by robots.

L4 and L5

Jeremy Gilbertson Yes. All right. So I got more information on our, L four and L five. So it's called a Lagrange point, a Lagrange point.

Mark Fielding A la grange, I mean, in French.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yes, you can say that as well if you prefer. but yeah, with two bodies, you have this, these points where basically the, it's a, it's a stable, it's a stable place in between those two bodies where things don't shift around and move. so that, that was really interesting. yeah, let's, let's continue to flip through this stuff. So then, then on page seven, we talk about

Mark Fielding Hold on, let's get to that. So, okay. Little pause.

Mark Fielding It's necessary to vastly diversify material manufacturing as quickly as possible and this is accomplished by creating different generational hardware that is more sophisticated than the previous one. The technologies needed for mining, chemical processes and metallurgy are for the most part already existent in Earth's industry. The feasibility of adapting them to the lunar environment has been and is currently been demonstrated. So a lot of these...

materials, lot of these industries, a lot of this know-how we're just taking from earth. So to build take manufacturing in space to the next level we need a lot of things and I jokingly at the beginning said diggers but the first thing that they need is excavators. The excavators will travel between the digging site and the resource processing site delivering sufficient lunar regolith each hour to maintain production rates of the other assets. The details of the excavators are unimportant.

Mark Fielding In our modelling we assumed for specificity that they are small and operate in a swarm.

So we need diggers. What else do we need, Jeremy?

Power, diggers, chemical plants

Jeremy Gilbertson We need power, right? We power on a consistent basis. I'm jumping back ahead to space-based solar power, but...

Mark Fielding What about chemical plants, ceramics, manufacturing, and then power? To speak to us about power, Joe, and we can't do everything, can we? So yeah, let's skip them.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, yeah, so we're back on the pieces and the parts needed to make all this stuff happen and sustain. So we've done a bunch of episodes on space-based solar power. We could link to them in this show, I think, if you want to learn more about it. But that's a tech that's proven and happening now and being tested for further use and implementation down the road. think we talked to some guys that are like five years out.

for doing some meaningful beaming of power from space to earth by converting sun, the energy of the sun, which, so you have that, you have the resources from the moon that can feed the carbon, the water, the little pieces, the chemical pieces and parts that we need for a certain amount of time, right? The interesting thing of this that, where was it? was another reference point. So not just metric tons, but it's like basically how fast,

How fast things can be printed. Where was that? I know we're bouncing around a lot guys, hang with us. We're real time processing this information live for you guys and us really. Let me get to my.

Mark Fielding So we can edit this out, take your time, keep forgetting there's no...

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, yeah, Well, here's another one. I keep, yeah. So a couple interesting things that are related to Moravec. So we can tie the Moravec stuff back into the other Moravec stuff. So here's a little bit more on insect, lizard, mouse, monkey, right? So this is basically a prediction of...

robotics and AI getting to a point to guide motor skills, right? So he predicted, Moravec predicted, this is a quote from the paper, lizard level occurring by 2020. So I guess I'm wondering if we're at lizard level yet. Mouse level by 2030, monkey level by 2040, and human level by 2050, meaning robotics.

the the compute the the software driving the robotics will have gotten to such a point that It can do what we can do dexterity wise I think

How do you coordinate with a delay?

Jeremy Gilbertson But how do you coordinate, Mark? How do you tell, what are the challenges in tele-operating something from Earth to the moon?

Jeremy Gilbertson How much delay?

Mark Fielding Two and a half seconds.

Jeremy Gilbertson Two and a half seconds doesn't seem like a tremendous amount, but could affect some things, right?

Mark Fielding Well, if I have some robot robonauts, as they're called, we'll call them humanoids now. I think let's update this to humanoid. I've there's humanoids and teleoperating a humanoid from Earth, two and a half seconds might not seem a lot, but if they're, for example, building computer chips on the moon, then two and a half seconds seems a lot for a very dexterous task. If they're driving diggers around, if they're building chemical plants for volatiles or chemical plants for solids is a need or refining ceramics, building solar panels, then that two and a half seconds is a long time. And reading the solution is the metaverse.

Jeremy Gilbertson my gosh. Buh! There's that word again. Good lord.

Digital twins, and the M word

Mark Fielding Virtual reality, the metaverse, digital twins, he's... Well, their solution is they don't say the metaverse, he says...

Jeremy Gilbertson That's dead, right? Like metaverse is dead, right? The word?

Mark Fielding Resynchronization will occur in the virtual world using a rubric designed to prevent operator confusion. Similar schemes are being developed for telesurgery with large communication latency. This will make teleoperation manageable for lunar operations, but it will require a growing and expensive workforce of teleoperators on Earth plus sufficient communications bandwidth and it will not be extendable to the asteroid belt or beyond.

Jeremy Gilbertson See the first course in thinking on paper university teleoperators for lunar objects.

Mark Fielding Start learning now, get to the front of the job queue. But that is essentially the metaverse, okay, virtual reality. Yeah, you get rid of that delay. Interesting that you're... Yeah, and you're...

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, training could happen there too, right? Because this real world modeling, training, that sort of thing could happen as well, right?

Mark Fielding Two and a half seconds seems to be the limit there. I you can't be tele-operating these humanoids out in the solar system, even out on the Kuiper Belt, the delay will be too much, which is why they have to be autonomous, self-replicating very quickly so that...

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, let's talk, let's add some context to that delay. I know this because I did a bunch of development and research into real-time music performance over geographically dispersed distances, right? So phone calls have an inherent, I think, 40 to 50 millisecond delay. So in a phone call when you're talking, that's the level of that delay. So, you know, multiply.

that which is which is not really you can't really perceive that anything below 50 milliseconds is kind of tough to perceive when you're just talking to someone on the phone but musically anything more than you know six to ten milliseconds will cause you to be offbeat so just a just a little nerd session on that

Mark Fielding It's important to know that delays need to be overcome.

Just before we move on to the modeling of the bootstrapping, there was a lot of...

I don't if these people are, they obviously understand the manufacturing industry, but there's a lot of talk of metal refineries adding processes and material streams to improve the mechanics of the materials. It's this flywheel of manufacture as the tech gets better, it feeds into the system, it gets better oxygen and other gases produced by metal refining will be sent to the chemistry plants that they've already built somewhere else. Electrical power is augmented with thermal power collected by solar concentrators.

You know, you've got a lot going on here. It's a very ambitious paper, isn't it? It takes a very ambitious mind to say, you know what, if we're gonna go colonise the universe, this is what we need. And they're not joking, there's a lot going on. And so when they bootstrap it on a spreadsheet, which they said, they kind of...

Mark Fielding makes it all sound plausible.

The jump off point is not the hard part

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, the jump off point isn't really the hard part. mean, think launch costs are getting to a point where it's, I think they based launch costs and their model on like 10,000 bucks a kilogram, I wanna say. And this was done, what, was this a 2016 study-ish? Is that right? So now we're down to 4,000 bucks-ish per kilogram, right?

So that becomes better. I think the interesting thing is when you read something like this, it's a great outline of the potential of a good first step. But then, man, this is gonna require, like they said, this is just a first cat, this is them thinking this out on a piece of paper. The next step has to be funded. All right, what does it look like to actually do this? And could you set up almost like a...

almost like a think tank with robotics people, with some AI people, with some chemists, with some...

astronauts with some, know, and really kind of take it to the next level and figure it out. And would people want to, would people want to lean into this? Or are they more concerned with building robots that, you know, will help people build cars and, you know, that'll help, you know, that'll be novelty items in the front lobby of a hotel that'll, that'll carry a drink to you, you know, and

Mark Fielding Yeah, the reality of the situation is from my perspective, I would be very surprised if I see humanoids on the moon doing even the most rudimentary tasks. I can't imagine they'll be building water processing plants and then sending that water out to the Kuiper Belt.

This is very, very long term humanitarian goals, isn't it? It's like we said at beginning, do we want to stay on planet earth or do we want to go out and really take ourselves to the universe? And this is what you're gonna need. think we're gonna, so if listeners, obviously there's a link below for all, there's a lot of graphs that get into how many robots we'll need, what the exponential growth is.

how many robots we'll need compared to how much mass each generation will take to get out there. The number of robot, we're talking about 10,000 robo-nauts by generation three. So anyway, not gonna go into that. Unless you wanna jump in.

Jeremy Gilbertson No, there's, there's, there's, no, there is, there's data, in there that that's really, really interesting. And it, and it balances the, the, economics of launch costs of, of how quickly something can be printed or put together, how quickly those robots could evolve. there's, there's a lot of really interesting metrics on there. one thing, one thing it got me noodling on.

Is you know, like you just said a second ago What are we gonna do? Are we are we gonna try as a as a a as species? Try to figure out how to not fuck up our own house You know and stay here and be good, right? Or do we just say damn the torpedoes and you know who cares about the next generation? You know, this planet's gonna be fine for me for the next, know, 40 50 years if i'm lucky, right? and

Or do we look at things like there's a whole nother sect looking at Mars, right? And looking at colonizing Mars, but in order to colonize Mars, have you looked at Mars terraforming? Terraforming Mars yet? Have you heard much about that?

Mark Fielding Only from our guests.

Jeremy Gilbertson I mean, it's basically like the idea of influencing the existing environment on Mars to make it, to force it, to coax it into the environment we have on Earth, right? So there's issues like, yeah, I mean, I think it's a little more than that, but I had Claude pulled up here and I was like, hey, what do you guys think about space?

Jeremy Gilbertson based manufacturing, robot based space manufacturing and economy versus Mars terraforming. Which do you think has the more likelihood of happening? And it landed.

Terraforming, or space manufacturing

Mark Fielding I'm going to turn, from what I know about terraforming, it's trillions and trillions of dollars. And I would say that this is a much more likely scenario.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yes, the verdict is space based manufacturing is a better near term solution, technically more feasible with existing tech. It addresses earth submission problem by relocating the sources of pollution. Like we were talking about, right? manageable timelines, decades versus centuries, right? Doesn't wait. This is, this one's funny. This one's funny. It doesn't require making another planet livable.

Mark Fielding And also, since we haven't really spoken about AGI and super intelligence, obviously, of course, during this timeline, artificial intelligence will have got to wherever it has got to do. And depending on whose theory of AGI we believe, if those humanoids are blessed with artificial intelligence and they are out on their own, who knows where in the solar system with infinity ahead of them, they might well start terraforming.

under their own guises like, we've long since got rid of those idiots back on earth. Let's terraform.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, do they all get together and they're like, yo, we're doing all this stuff for those people over there. Let's go live our own life. Let's get in that. Yeah, that's more, that's more consciousness singularity that we're not going to kind of, kind of get into here. But, let's see, how do we want to land the plane with this one, Mark? This is, this was an ambitious read, I think, but a, but a cool one. I did send, I did send a note to, one of the authors to get him on the show to help us unpack it. So we'll see.

Jeremy Gilbertson See if we hear anything.

Landing the plane

Mark Fielding I how we can land this plane.

Mark Fielding paper outlines.

how we bootstrap the beginnings of a space manufacturing industry. It outlines what we need, how we're gonna get it.

It outlines the challenges, launch costs. It outlines the timeline.

The robotic industry in space leads to a grand vision. After the industry becomes self-supporting, it can be sent to other parts of the solar system. The asteroid belt has everything necessary for it. Water, carbon, silicate, metals, oxygen, solar energy. Robotic space industry will also bring great dividends back to Earth. For example, it can create space-based beams, solar power satellites in Earth orbit.

The modelling also indicates a significant national security risk. On Earth, the industry of a nation is limited by its resources, including real estate, energy, ores, and the education and size of its labour pool. In a robotic industry occupying a solar system, the resources and real estate are a billion times greater. Space industry will fundamentally change the status of humanity in the solar system. Humans are a species adapted to living at the top of the food chain, and we need something analogous.

Mark Fielding to the food chain in space to process its resources for us. Every conversation we have, this sounds great, but for one small piece of the human pie, doesn't it? Isn't it? Whatever, Jeremy. So I wanna speak about aliens. I wanna speak about Blade Runner. I wanna speak about Total Recall, Corp Ambition.

outruns ethics and government. Government, doesn't it? I mean...

Wayland, the company Aliens, it's a mass space sized, faceless corporate monster. Humanity is left back on earth fending for itself. Swarms of autonomous machines, self replicating and all the money going back to these giant corporations. That and human nature is the obstacle, isn't it?

Jeremy Gilbertson Man, I think that's why blockchain is always so compelling because it's the enablement of individuals against the machine. Maybe, I don't know, but good grief. Yeah, we're gonna get in there.

Mark Fielding Machines do the colonizing, corporations exploit it, and we're all left back on Earth like in Elysium, as the sun melts the Earth, trying to survive while the powers that be, the 0.1%, sit in their... spaceships.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, here's where it lies too. You reference, didn't get quite get to the point at the end of the paper where, you know, if one nation or one entity controls the ability of this, it's going to run into the same situation that we're dealing with right now. And these, this human dynamic, this power struggle, this, this, Hey, if I can control this, I can manipulate that it's carrot, it's stick, it's controlling and,

Mark Fielding pulling the strings, no?

Jeremy Gilbertson Man, I think that's the original problem. Where's the paper on that? Let's go find one on that and figure it out.

Mark Fielding We should write a thinking on paper or our tech vision. It's all perfect just for one slight problem and that's human nature and.

In praise of grandiose ambition

Mark Fielding I'm a huge, huge fan of grandiose, massive human ambition. I'm a huge sci-fi nerd. I'm a huge fan of...

almost ridiculous solutions to our problems. And maybe it's growing up in the era that we grew up. Maybe, I don't know if 20 year olds of today look up to the stars and look up to the sky and go, we got to be out there. We've to be doing this. We've got to be, we've got to be there. Are they, are they even looking up? But like, they, maybe at some point,

Jeremy Gilbertson They're looking down.

Mark Fielding We stopped looking up and we stopped looking to the stars and maybe it's a, maybe I'm just, that's my ego talking and maybe the 20 year olds of today do look up and if you're listening, tell us because.

Mark Fielding I've been not doing a very good job down here, some days.

Jeremy Gilbertson there you have it. Yeah, I I like that. I like that finish. It requires a little bit of willingness to be playful and be silly and talk about things that are way beyond our capabilities of today, right?

Mark Fielding Okay, so yes, you hit the nail on the head

Jeremy Gilbertson So be silly. We're gonna continue to be silly reading some of the papers that are over our skis, but that are very interesting and compelling to solving some of the biggest challenges that we have. So stay tuned, we're gonna do more.

Mark Fielding Do you find you probably get, so do you find you probably, might get a silly look if the next dinner party you go to, the next time you go out with your friends, say, you know what we need? We need self replicating humanoids with diggers out in the Kuiper belt, mining for ore. We need to make this happen.

Jeremy Gilbertson I silly looks every time I talk at dinner parties, Mark. It's like, yeah, it's the same thing, but there you have it, Pocket Edition. We're talking about space, we're talking about robots, we're talking about putting about what? How many metric tons? 12 metric tons? 12 metric tons on the moon, and that'll kick off everything for us. Stay tuned, hopefully we'll get some of these really smart people that wrote this paper on the show to help us kick it down the line. Mark.

Mark Fielding That's all it takes.

Jeremy Gilbertson That's all we have.

Mark Fielding Stay disruptive, be curious.

Jeremy Gilbertson Keep thinking on paper.