What Is the Electric Stack?

Michael Faraday built the first electric motor in 1821, and it took until 1983 for the neodymium magnet to arrive. We've been waiting 162 years for magnets to get really good.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 15 chapters

  1. October the sixth, 1973
  2. The first rechargeable lithium battery
  3. John Goodenough
  4. Akira sells the patent to Sony
  5. Japanese consumer products
  6. From handycam to the next step
  7. Steady discharge
  8. Bankruptcy, and bringing the IP home
  9. Battery powered buses
  10. The chemistry war
  11. Magnets
  12. Neodymium
  13. Seagate
  14. Domination
  15. What would happen to the stack
The future is too important for me versus you. The future is too important for what I can keep you from doing and what you can keep me from doing.
Jeremy Gilbertson

We read an essay on the electric stack, from the 1973 oil embargo that sent Exxon's lab into battery research to Sony putting lithium-ion batteries in the Handycam and BYD testing battery buses at the Beijing Olympics.

The essay says China produces more than 90% of the world's neodymium magnets, which drones, cars and humanoid robots rely on. Jeremy asks what would happen to the US economy if China stopped selling them. “The future is too important for nation states.”

Packy McCormick's essay on the electric stack, the lithium-ion batteries and neodymium magnets inside electric products, traces how both began as American and Japanese inventions but now depend on China for large-scale production. Mark Fielding and Jeremy Gilbertson work through it on the Thinking On Paper podcast, from Exxon's 1970s battery lab to BYD, CATL and rare earth magnets.

What is the electric stack?

The electric stack is Packy McCormick's term for the lithium-ion batteries and neodymium magnets inside electric products. Both began as American and Japanese inventions and now depend on China for large-scale production.

How did the 1973 oil embargo lead to the lithium battery?

The rechargeable lithium battery grew out of the 1973 oil embargo, Mark recounts, when Exxon's corporate lab in New Jersey hired Stan Whittingham to research what happens if the oil runs dry. Jeremy says Whittingham's first lithium-ion battery in 1976 exploded; John B. Goodenough and Akira Yoshino improved it, and Sony put it in the Handycam.

What is an LFP battery, and what happened to A123?

LFP, a lithium iron phosphate battery chemistry, is safer but stores less energy, Jeremy explains. He says A123, a US battery company with solid patents, went bankrupt and China bought it cheaply, while BYD used electric buses at the Beijing Olympics as “rolling battery labs”.

How many of the world's batteries do BYD and CATL make?

Two Chinese companies make most of the world's batteries: Jeremy says BYD makes 17.8% and CATL 37.9%, nearly 56% between them. He cites the International Energy Agency as saying the US is unlikely to win more than 15% market share even if every planned project is built, and Mark notes that BYD's Blade battery, introduced in 2020, is now used in Teslas.

Who invented the neodymium magnet?

The neodymium magnet is, in Jeremy's words, “the breakthrough that makes the electric motor possible”, after 162 years of slow progress since Michael Faraday's first electric motor. He says Masato Sagawa in Japan and John Croat at General Motors developed it simultaneously, and Mark calls the three and a half inch hard disk drive its first product.

How much of the rare earth supply does China control?

China controls the magnet supply, Mark says, reading figures from the essay: it mines roughly 70% of global rare earths, processes 85 to 90% and produces more than 90% of neodymium magnets. With drones and humanoid robots built on these magnets, he argues “the future wars are going to be drone wars and they're going to need magnets”.

Where Mark and Jeremy disagree

Jeremy asks what would happen to the US economy if China stopped selling neodymium magnets. Mark doubts a trade war would work, because China would “simply create a probably soon better version”, and Jeremy argues that “the future is too important for nation states”.

Questions

What is the electric stack?

Packy McCormick's essay on the electric stack, the lithium-ion batteries and neodymium magnets inside electric products, traces how both began as American and Japanese inventions but now depend on China for large-scale production.

Why do drones and robots depend on neodymium magnets?

The essay says China produces more than 90% of the world's neodymium magnets, which drones, cars and humanoid robots rely on. With drones and humanoid robots built on these magnets, he argues “the future wars are going to be drone wars and they're going to need magnets”.

Is BYD's Blade battery used in Teslas?

He cites the International Energy Agency as saying the US is unlikely to win more than 15% market share even if every planned project is built, and Mark notes that BYD's Blade battery, introduced in 2020, is now used in Teslas.

Transcript

October the sixth, 1973

Mark Fielding here we go. The electric stack. October the 6th, 1973. On Yom Kippur, Judaism's holiest day, Egyptian President Anwar Sadat and Syrian President Hassaf al-Assad launch a coordinated surprise attack on Israel. 11 days later, on October 17th, King Fassal of Saudi Arabia, a cautious monarch who has resisted using oil as a weapon for years, announced that OPEC would cut oil production by 5 % each month until Israel withdrew from occupied territories. More dramatically, Arab oil producers declared a complete embargo on oil shipments to countries supporting Israel, primarily the United States and Netherlands. Oil prices quadrupled practically overnight from $3 to $12 per barrel. Gas stations ran dry. Americans sat in for hours. Perhaps you remember that Jeremy, sometimes fighting over fuel. President Nixon imposed a national speed limit of 55 miles an hour. Christmas was cancelled. Christmas lights were banned.

Jeremy Gilbertson I wasn't that old.

Mark Fielding And that led to Exxon and their corporate lab in New Jersey getting a 30 year old British Oxford and Stanford graduate called Stan Whittington to Whittingham to research what happens if the oil runs dry. And that led him to battery research. And that was the beginning of the electric stack.

Jeremy Gilbertson Wittingham, right? Wittingham?

prices go crazy, right? Everything you just said. Three years later, on the year of my birth, 1976, Whittingham makes the first lithium-ion battery. And it does something amazing. It explodes. It explodes. It explodes.

The first rechargeable lithium battery

Mark Fielding it was rechargeable, it was the first rechargeable lithium battery. Eventually he'd co-share Nobel Prize, for that with two other people. But his exploded, so what happened?

John Goodenough

Jeremy Gilbertson A guy named John Goodenough, the name is great. John Goodenough. John B. Goodenough. John B. Goodenough. Yeah, he's an Oxford guy, right? Right? So he gets in there and finds a way to increase the voltage, He does some things to improve upon what Whittingham did.

Mark Fielding John B. John B. Good enough.

Jeremy Gilbertson but it still explodes and then enter but it explodes it explodes less but it still explodes right

Mark Fielding I love how you approach, you want to get into the science and the physics of this. my notes, I've just put, John B Goodenough change the ingredients a little bit.

Jeremy Gilbertson It's a perfect way to think about it, right? Perfect way to think about it. Alright, so there's this instability to this thing that has been invented. Enter Akira Yoshino and kind of sprinkle some magic in he finds a way to to stabilize And make it a little better. Again, step by step by step by step.

Akira sells the patent to Sony

Mark Fielding Akira sells the patent to Sony and the lithium ion battery was put inside the Sony Handycam, which I remember those Sony Handycam ads. You must remember them. And that was the first alpha product, wasn't it, of the lithium ion rechargeable battery that now you could film your family.

Jeremy Gilbertson your Christmases and yeah, which I remember we'd always set it up and just, you know, yeah, I mean, that's a big part of a big part of growing up for

Jeremy Gilbertson So what do you think about this idea? This quote was great. Or this philosophy is a really interesting idea. Lateral thinking with withered technology.

Jeremy Gilbertson kind of cool. So basically it's like Sony didn't really invent anything new right with this. They took this existing quote "withered technology" which again you know what they developed was pretty powerful but again we haven't it was the idea that needed the what the energy and the action right? Idea and the energy and action. So Sony applied the energy and action becomes a product the Handycam and now suddenly this insatiable demand for people to need hours of battery life to capture all the moments in their family. Demand explodes, So again, we have this idea of Western research turning into Japanese products.

Japanese consumer products

Mark Fielding we all remember those Japanese products, Panasonic, Sony, that in technological might has shifted over because he in this essay, he kind of puts Japan in the same bucket as America and Europe, doesn't he? And it's really it's not Japan and China. It's really Japan, America and Europe and China doing this other stuff. And those big Japanese companies that really changed. Changed.

the game of consumer products that's now being done in China rather than Japan.

From handycam to the next step

Jeremy Gilbertson So let's go from handy cam to the next step

Mark Fielding got involved, somebody started putting Handycam batteries in a car, essentially. I don't know, who is that guy? What is that car company? So you had the rechargeable lithium ion batteries, it in the Handycam, and Tesla,

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, let's yeah, who's that guy? Let's talk through it.

Mark Fielding put them in a car, but the problem was obviously that they...

It didn't really work, did they? Not to the level that they wanted. so that caused Tesla to make it better.

Jeremy Gilbertson go from of single batteries trying to figure out the power thing all together to a bunch of batteries together in a pack and tying the batteries into like a collective versus a bunch of tiny cells working independently,

Mark Fielding And so they worked with Panasonic. Yeah, we were.

Jeremy Gilbertson Our friend comes back.

Well, we have another friend come back doesn't doesn't doesn't Gooeednough come back at nearly the age of John B Goodenough comes back at nearly the age of 90 and you know, continues to do some tweaks into the battery type and we're not going to the essay like you said the essay does a great job of talking through the different battery technologies, but he tweaked the chemistry a little bit to ⁓ for what's called LFP lithium ion phosphate and kind of reduced some of those explosions.

Mark Fielding Just jump in, good enough.

Steady discharge

Jeremy Gilbertson steady discharge, a little safer, lower energy and the conductivity was a little bit less than what they wanted, but those were acceptable because the use was working good enough. It was working John B. good enough.

the next little beat on this story There was an American, or US company, think, A123 was US, right? US battery company. ⁓ That went bankrupt, again, had solid tech, good patents. China buys it for real cheap.

Bankruptcy, and bringing the IP home

Mark Fielding Yeah, went bankrupt.

Jeremy Gilbertson and kind of brings the IP home. was a really interesting ⁓ inflection point, I think, when there's a company called BYD in China that is battery maker. I think it was the Olympics and they started deploying these big batteries on buses, right? So they essentially used the Olympics as a way to test

Mark Fielding Yeah, it was the Olympics.

Battery powered buses

Jeremy Gilbertson battery powered buses. I thought that was really interesting. And with a bus, there's some forgiveness because it's huge. So the form factor doesn't have to be really small. basically favor a safe environment versus range, right? Buses don't have to go 8 million miles. They're usually kind of spinning in a nice little loop around the city, right? So I thought that was a really interesting way to test the technology and also probably get paid or have some government

⁓ help as it's building infrastructure for the Olympics.

Mark Fielding China pretty much fund that whole bus... scheme?

Jeremy Gilbertson I think so, yeah, I think so.

So yeah, so he's got these rolling battery labs, That they're using to test and prove this technology. The owner of BYD, I thought it was really interesting, Wang... I'm gonna butcher this. Xuanfu. Warren Buffett called him Edison plus Jack Welch. Thought that was a pretty powerful statement.

The chemistry war

Jeremy Gilbertson It was a big compliment. So then there's a chemistry war, There are people betting on different types of batteries for different reasons. We're not going to go into all the technical pieces of that puzzle. Again, read the essay if you want to dig in to more of that. But we're talking versus LFPs and who made the bet on the right chemistry? Some say BYD did. Some say the other, who's the other company?

CATL, I think was the other company. Yeah. Is that cattle, huh?

Mark Fielding the timing of all this is so serendipitous as well. the Olympics hadn't been in Beijing, then the Chinese government wouldn't have been perhaps so ready to spend all the money on the batteries for the buses that coincided. It was just a perfect timing for the technology for the five-year plan of China. It was just amazing timing. And

China's got good at batteries, like really, really good at making batteries, cheaply and efficiently. And what they did, they, I don't know if they flashed their eyes at Germany, but it ended up with BMW. ⁓

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, there was a quote by what like Mr. BMW, I guess, or whatever that was in there. It was like, okay.

Jeremy Gilbertson how the F do we get 3 million batteries in two years or something crazy like that? So the serenity, he was like the, he had the aha moment, I guess, right?

Mark Fielding And a businessman and he realized, know, okay, yeah, they've got better batteries. How do we get some for our because we got to make some electric cars.

Jeremy Gilbertson BYD makes 17.8 % of the world's batteries. CATL or cattle, I'm not sure how you say that one, is 37.9 % of the world's batteries, all totaled up to 55, nearly 56 % of global battery production. So, domination.

Well, last little thought on the battery as we kind of come to the close of the battery story a bit. And again, the depth in Packy's breakdown is tremendous. If you have time, I encourage you to read it. The International Energy Agency had an interesting quote in here. I just mentioned the numbers, 56 % of global battery production. So even if all of the US projects that actually come to bear that are in the pipeline today related to production. The IEA, International Energy Agency said the U.S. isn't likely to win more than 15 % market share even if all of those projects come to bear and we all know every idea that turns into a company doesn't last very long, right?

Mark Fielding it's so hard to see anything changing.

BMW, so what's left of the European car manufacturing industry is using Chinese made batteries in their cars. In 2020, BYD introduced the Blade now are in Teslas, they're using Blade batteries.

Mark Fielding Does anybody care? people want a car that doesn't break down. People want a drone that stays in the air. People want, some people want an electric vacuum cleaner that doesn't just break when it's dusting the hallway. Most people, regardless of what the political media narrative might be about buying your own, don't really care. And I think that if the...

think of batteries in this thing? It just works. It just works. We just want it to work, no, I don't see a will on the battery side of it to fight back. we should probably move on to part two of the electric stack.

Magnets

Jeremy Gilbertson Let me set the stage guys. Let me set the stage. We've been waiting 162 years for magnets to get really good. It starts with a gentleman named Michael Faraday, 1821. Builds the first electric motor. It was pretty cool, pretty revolutionary, but from a magnet perspective, kinda meh, kinda meh, right? So over the next 162 years, magnets have been getting better.

Alnico magnets, you know came out in 1955. They're in your, if you have a Gibson, they're in your humbuckers mark. They're in your humbucker pickups.

Mark Fielding Well, they're in all my home bookers.

They're in my home bookers on my Gretsch.

Jeremy Gilbertson You got the Gretsch there you in 1955 they're Magnets all the way down. So a hundred times better than Faraday in 1955, then in 1983 1983 was an interesting year. So you have two scientists you have one in Japan one in General Motors and like so many things in history a simultaneous innovation happens

Mark Fielding It's magnets all the way down.

Mark Fielding without the other knowing. this, you know, there's an order to it, Jeremy. The way things happen is the way things happen. You can't...

Jeremy Gilbertson All right. So the Sadi and the One, are we going back to Federico Faggin dare I say? So okay. So they discover simultaneously a compound that's 360 times stronger than Faraday's original motor. You know, the magnet, is the breakthrough that makes the electric motor possible, right?

Mark Fielding Well, you'll get laughed out of town.

Neodymium

Mark Fielding Are you talking about the neodymium magnet?

Jeremy Gilbertson teasing into that, right? So that thing stepped in with a bunch of different innovations too, but just general casting, over the last 162 years, there's been innovations in

Masato Sagawa in Sumitomo, Japan, right? On one side. And John Croat from General Motors.

Idea or his process right he uses this centering method of creating this magnet, right? So you're mixing power you're mixing powders press them under high pressure and then you heat them until they kind of come together and The magnetic strength was pretty good in in what he pulled together and then croat has another method that's the that's the metal spinning method

You still kind of melt some stuff down, but you spray this spray what's melted under a copper wheel. It cools pretty quick into crystals. Then you grind the ribbons, And you mix it with a resin and it almost kind of looks like Sagawa's magnets are stronger, this injection molding idea is a bit easier to produce, right? So you've got these

Mark Fielding Yeah, quotes, they're

Jeremy Gilbertson Right. So here's an interesting piece of the puzzle. So they actually kind of end up working together in a weird way.

Mark Fielding you get the alpha product first, don't you? The three and a half inch hard disk drive is the alpha product of the magnet.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, but again, the alpha product is this hard drive and...

there was an innovation in, know, one was like a five and a half inch and kind of the newer one was like the three and a half inch, right? But it was kind of like, Hey, the five and a half inch is great. Like we're good. We don't need anything bigger, better and better. But what led them Mark to, to find that three and a half inch one being a little bit better. What was the, what was the inflection point? Do you remember?

Seagate

Jeremy Gilbertson What is it? Finis Connor? The guy that started Seagate? So in 1985, the inflection point was as these bigger personal computers were kind of getting down in smaller form factor, compact, he lands the deal to put his hard drives into compact portable computers. I think this number, this number is crazy to me, but in the late 80s, he had 1.3 billion in sales. Am I reading that right?

Mark Fielding Yeah, 1.37 billion in revenue, making it the fastest growing manufacturing startup in United States history.

Jeremy Gilbertson or in rev, yeah, yeah, In the 80s.

Mark Fielding And these alpha products, this inflection point you speak of causes this mass influx of investment and research to make the in this case, the magnet cheaper and more readily accessible.

these neodymium magnets make drones possible without them, there would be no drones. Humanoids are gonna be reliant completely. So since our guess says it's gonna be like 5 billion humanoids in the next 10 years, that's a lot of magnets. And...

Domination

Mark Fielding Complete domination by China. Rare Earths. So China quote mines roughly 70 % of global rare earth, processes 85 to 90 % of them and produces 90 % plus of the world's neodymium magnets. China makes at least 50 % of the world's electric motors.

Jeremy Gilbertson heard this story before. There's definitely a theme in this. So A123, American innovation, gets sold for pennies on the dollar to the Chinese with the IP, and they innovate and they do great things with that technology. So we have Croat and GM and Magnequench. What a name, Magnequench.

And Magnequench is building magnets and motors for defense market, for cars, And there was a, there are some investment decisions, I think, that GMA, and this is not a case study on GM in the 80s and 90s, but there was a point while Magnequench was going, doing its thing, making batteries for GM cars, Department of Defense, GM starts buying a bunch of things, not little companies, like gigantic companies like EDS, Ross Perot, company, Hughes Motors, they decide to launch GMAC mortgage financing, right? They invest $90 million in an automated factory. and then do you know what hits the fan? The Christmas massacre, I think is what they called when GM basically had to lay off 74,000 workers, they closed 21 plants and they had

8.5 billion dollar, they had an 8.5 billion dollar loss in their North American automotive group in 1991. So it's a fire sale. We got to get back to what we do best. We build cars. We don't care about anything else. So allegedly, I don't know that there wasn't any data to back this up, but when GM was looking to offload everything, Magnequench was one of those things on the docket.

China was pretty interested in MagnaQuench. GM needed somewhere else to sell their cars. They needed relationships. Potentially, the MagnaQuench deal was in part to get access to the Chinese market to sell cars. Little did they know the trade-off was massive related to magnets.

Mark Fielding At beginning I joked that it's magnets all the way down.

It is. There's a sentence in the essay which I think should make some people sit up and pay attention. thanks to the war in Ukraine, drones are widely recognized as a key piece of the military arsenal of the future. only possible because of neomagnets. 90 % of the world's neomagnets are made in China. So, yeah.

Okay, we don't need to go into the military thing, but you know, the future wars are going to be drone wars and they're going to need magnets and all the magnets are made in China. Then there are the robots. Humanoids use actuators like humans use joints. Tesla's Optimus robot uses a total of 40 electromagnetic mechanical actuators, 28 structural and there's some others for the arm and leg. All of them use neo magnets. He calls it here, Neo China.

The story of the research, development and commercialization of neomagnets, like the story of the research, development and commercialization of lithium-ion batteries is an American and Japanese story. And like the lithium-ion battery story, modern scale and production dominance of neomagnets now belongs to China.

robots, drones, cars, phones. What else is there?

Jeremy Gilbertson These are the ingredients that build build the future of the world. When you think about it, batteries and magnets, And, the control is significantly with China related to energy and action. They figured out ways to take an idea, scale it and make it, make it work really, really well. The U S did have a company called mountain pass that, ⁓ that was focused on magnets. It failed.

Jeremy Gilbertson kind of respawn up, failed again, and then it became what's called MP materials, which is, you know, from a US perspective is getting a lot of attention now, but still is kind of pale in comparison of what to what China is able to do there. So my question for you, Mark, as we land the plane,

What would happen to the stack

Jeremy Gilbertson My question for you is what would happen to the US economy if China said F you and stop selling Neo Mags?

Mark Fielding Well, that's the political hot potato. mean, the public one is rare earths, but it's all connected, isn't it? You go back to the primary ingredients and the rare earth. It's why America was dancing around, invading Greenland, wasn't it? So I assume the sourcing of the rare earth changes.

and you get into a trade war and try to battle China with some of the things that America did, Nvidia chips as we've seen. But such is their manufacturing might that whatever you stop the flow of, they will simply create a probably soon better version than what the America does. So.

Jeremy Gilbertson Get your politics in order. That's a shirt, man. Holy cow. Yeah.

Mark Fielding if America focused everything on the intelligence part of this so that in however many years is all of these machines that are made in China, made in China with an American brain.

Or do we end up with made in China with a Chinese brain?

Jeremy Gilbertson or some various degrees of both. I think the future is too important to...

Mark Fielding That's a t-shirt. The future is too important.

Jeremy Gilbertson The future is too important for, this is gonna be a hot take, but the future is too important for nation states, I think. The future is too important for nation states. The future is too important for me versus you. The future is too important for what I can keep you from doing and what you can keep me from doing. We talked about the coordination problem. Technology has...

Mark Fielding Tremendous potential to solve the coordination problem if humans Can get there, you know what together, but there you have it ⁓ if there is no global coordination, it doesn't matter what technology we're speaking about, it can be AI, can be batteries, can be electric kites. It doesn't matter if there's no global communication, if there's no global accord, if there's no global consensus on what's best for humanity, then yes, there is no solution. And you're right, the future is too important. So sort your politics out.

Jeremy Gilbertson Sort your politics out. Well, this was this was fun mark. Hope you guys have enjoyed it as well This is we'll have a part two to figure out the other two pieces of the stack But I guarantee a little little teaser You're gonna see some similar patterns as we as we move through the stack. That's all I've got for today mark any closing thoughts

Mark Fielding I'm going to see if I can test drive a Model 3 before next week's show because it's all about the Model 3.

Jeremy Gilbertson Fair enough. Hey, stay curious.

Jeremy Gilbertson Keep thinking on paper and learning in public.