What Would Regenerative Housing Change?
Chris Moeller was heavily involved in office buildings before COVID, and realised quickly that they were going to be short-lived. So I always say that COVID cracked the windshield, but Hurricane Helene smashed the glass.
In this episode · 18 chapters
- What stable housing means
- It is getting harder
- How many people can actually afford a house?
- Size, and what the price tag follows
- Stablecoins, and blockchain
- Drones building houses
- Responsible finance
- Separating the land from the structure
- The road to serfdom
- Emergence, and regenerative by birth
- The project, and local producers
- Does it work in the inner city?
- A recovering office developer
- Lease rates, and capital markets
- Infrastructure
- Pathway Communities
- COVID cracked the door
- What Chris wants
What I’m aiming for is that stable living becomes infrastructure and it’s investable as infrastructure.
Chris Moeller, a recovering office developer, argues for stable living built on ownership. He explains how separating the land from the structure, through community land trusts and deed restrictions borrowed from Habitat for Humanity, could keep homes within reach.
He describes Hudson Commons in North Carolina, where a grandmother's brick ranch becomes a community kitchen, coworking space and short-term rooms. The homes are aimed at civil servants: teachers, nurses, police, fire and medics who cannot afford to live where they serve.
Chris Moeller of Pathway Communities, a self-described “recovering office developer”, argues on the Thinking On Paper podcast that affordable housing should give way to “stable living”, an ownership model for housing, food and other basic needs. He explains how community land trusts and factory-built homes fit in, and is testing the model at Hudson Commons in Hudson, North Carolina.
What is the Maslow mismatch?
Mark frames the episode around a “Maslow mismatch”. Maslow's hierarchy of needs ranks human needs from physical basics such as food and shelter up to self-actualisation, and Mark argues the tech frontier is obsessed with the top while most of humanity is stuck on the bottom two layers.
Why is buying a first home in America getting harder?
Moeller says buying a first home in America is getting harder. He puts US median income at about $68,000 against a median home price of about $440,000, and says the average American home is 41 years old, so buyers also take on maintenance costs.
How does a community land trust work?
A community land trust separates ownership of the land from ownership of the home on it. Moeller says impact investors can buy land and “sink your money in for a hundred year lease”, while residents own only the structure, which he says “gives back all that value”.
What is industrialised construction in housing?
Industrialised construction means building homes in a factory rather than assembling them on site. Moeller says Pathway Communities is using it on its first project in Hudson, North Carolina, after Mark calls the idea of drone swarms building houses “so incredibly naive”.
Who is Hudson Commons designed for?
Hudson Commons is designed for civil servants such as teachers, nurses, police, fire crews and medics, with 56 units on three acres and an estimated 80 to 100 residents. Moeller traces his move away from office development to two events: “COVID cracked the windshield, but Hurricane Helene smashed the glass”.
Where Mark and Moeller disagree
Mark asks what the disadvantage is of a deed restriction, the Habitat for Humanity rule that owners must sell back to the organisation, which keeps the home affordable but caps its resale value. Moeller concedes the obvious cost, that “your home is how you get, you know, wealthy”, and says new investment vehicles are needed to replace that locked-up equity.
Links from this episode
Questions
Who is Chris Moeller and what is stable living?
Chris Moeller of Pathway Communities, a self-described “recovering office developer”, argues on the Thinking On Paper podcast that affordable housing should give way to “stable living”, an ownership model for housing, food and other basic needs.
Why did Chris Moeller move away from office development?
Moeller traces his move away from office development to two events: “COVID cracked the windshield, but Hurricane Helene smashed the glass”.
Where is Hudson Commons and what is planned there?
He describes Hudson Commons in North Carolina, where a grandmother's brick ranch becomes a community kitchen, coworking space and short-term rooms.
Transcript
Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds, welcome to another episode of Thinking on Paper. This is a special one. We've got a great guest today. We're all gonna be...
Not only thinking on paper, but thinking in public. Mark, who do we have today?
Mark Fielding have Chris Moeller who is an explorer and a thinker and he is a friend of the show. We've spoken to him a few times and what he's building and what he's creating and how he's thinking is a perfect match for today's mismatch. The Maslow mismatch we're talking about. between what technology is promising and what the reality on the ground is for billions, not hundreds, billions of people.
So the main AI, especially tech narrative, is for tools of creativity, tools of production, tools of status, tools of brand building, tools of finance. We've built this weird mismatch where the tech frontier is obsessed with the top players of Maslow's hierarchy, Whereas the book...
of humanity, it's stuck on the bottom two layers of the hierarchy. Housing, employment, health, resources, and a sense of connection. Chris, welcome to Thinking on Paper. Thank you for thinking on paper with us. And before we get into all of this, I just wanna read a tweet
And it's from today and I think it is a beautiful...
almost museum-esque showpiece of the disconnect between Big Tech, between Sam Altman, Elon Musk, and Zuckerberg, and Google, and Nvidia that goes on. It's from Mustafa Suleyman, who normally I think does a really good job of the human side of tech, or at least showcasing what Microsoft thinks is the human side of tech. quote, geez, there's so many cynics. It cracks me up when I hear people call AI underwhelming.
I grew up playing Snake on a Nokia phone. The fact that people are unimpressed that we can have a fluent conversation with a super smart AI that can generate any image or video is mind blowing to me. Now, of course, like Microsoft, it's a business, they have to scale. But that isn't cynicism, it's criticism because people don't care or people don't want or a super intelligence that can create image or video isn't...
top of mind for so many people, more people who are worried about rent and food and jobs, not creativity. Are they not, Chris? Your thoughts before we get into this.
Chris Moeller That was a warm up there.
Mark Fielding That's a long intro.
Chris Moeller No, that's good. It was a great warm up there. You know, it's right. We're such an apropos topic right now and it's so timely when we're really sort of operating at the physiological need level. But yet everybody's talking about self-actualization, ⁓ you know, and the amount of privilege that comes with playing Snake on that Nokia phone.
⁓ right from the very beginning, you know, is just a very interesting place to start the conversation.
Mark Fielding and I probably have better memories playing Snake on my Nokia in class than I do of anything that chat GPT has given me so far. Jeremy, you are the expert on Maslow's hierarchy of needs, so why don't you explain to our listeners what it is and what we're gonna be focusing on today.
Jeremy Gilbertson Whoa, says who?
the expert in it. ⁓ That's not entirely accurate, but I will run with it. So here's the thing. What we're getting into today is this idea of ⁓ base level needs being met. And we're talking about base level needs. This is like, ⁓ I in a secure environment where my life isn't threatened? Do I have access to food and water?
Okay, let's just think about those two things and those land like Chris said on the physiological need level, which is the very bottom. And let's talk about what if like, I know all of us, like the three of us on this call certainly privileged as well to not be in the fight or flight mindset of trying to find food and making sure people aren't, you know, attacking you and threatening your life, right? So
Think about, let's just think about the mindset of that, right? On the base level of need. So how do you think about that, Chris? Like, and where does your head go? you, how easy is it to start thinking big and being all grandiose while you're trying to literally fight for your life?
Chris Moeller Yeah, it's a fantastic question. It's really, you know, my concept here is stable living. You see a lot of hashtag posts for me with stable living. ⁓ I was at that creativity, personal growth, moral development level of self-actualization down the path of understanding how to build these complex systems.
And what I realized was that none of that messaging was landing. was just wasn't resonating. It was an echo chamber of conversation. So I started kind of coming back down to like, what are the basic things we need to get by? Right. And what's what's interesting is that housing, you food, shelter, clothing, these things in a lot of developing countries are actually starting to work against us in a lot of ways. Our housing systems are not really actually circular or regenerative, our food systems are industrialized and they're really focusing more on GDP and export. Our clothing is synthetic and it's kind of becoming a sustainability issue. So we don't really need to go very far outside of those physiological needs that Maslow talked about to start solving for stability. And that's where I've chosen to focus at least the next decade of my career is really talking about like the purity and the natural regenerative process of physiological needs.
What stable housing means
Mark Fielding Stable housing. What do you mean by hashtag stable housing? Stable living. What do you mean by the hashtag stable living?
Chris Moeller Stable living. ⁓ it's yeah.
Yeah, stable living. So, you know, in our in our first pathway communities model right now, we're just trying to tackle a couple of things. One, obviously, people talk about affordable housing, which is only as good as its occupants and only as good as the ownership model that's created. There's a there's a dependency on certificates.
and a massive government subsidy to keep you there, and it's a rental model, there's no opportunity for what I like to think of as stability or even upward mobility because the ownership model is completely missing.
We always use the example of renting a car, not treating it maybe as well on a boys trip or, you know, go into a hotel and turn the air conditioning real low and leaving the lights on when you leave. You know, that relationship with that asset or that opportunity to engage in that is just sort of contractual and it's short term. But when we have an ownership perspective on something, we take care of something a little bit more. So ⁓ stable living to me is starting to bring that ownership model.
⁓ into all the things, all housing, food, water, shelter, clothing, and really kind of proliferate this concept of ownership.
Jeremy Gilbertson So the, ⁓ the idea here too, that, that you're, that you're talking about resonates because there's, you know, tons of studies shown that, you know, homeownership is the, is the quickest path or the most tried and true path to wealth creation. Right. So having a, having, having ownership, homeownership, that's largely a lot of people's net worth. Right. So the path to well through the path to getting above physiological, getting above safety and moving into this bridge that I like to call in this hierarchy, this love and belonging bridge in between esteem and self-actualization. Home ownership is a key piece to that, is it not?
It is getting harder
Chris Moeller Yeah, and it's getting harder. And it's actually getting, in my opinion, irresponsible. You know, it's harder and harder to have 20 % to put down on a 30-year fixed term mortgage to be well qualified. That's one part.
The other part is that wage right now in America anyway is trailing 60%. So there's a lot of numbers out there right now. The average salary right now in America is $68,000. I'm sorry, the median income. The median home price is about $440,000. So just to get to that opportunity to buy that first home, you are going to be strapping in to a long-term commitment for sure.
and it doesn't pay respect to things like insurance that go up and taxes that go up plus the average home in America is 41 years old so you're gonna have maintenance costs associated with that ownership model so just getting to that ownership perspective now especially if you're saddled with debt from school you haven't even thought about having kids yet you have probably don't you know you probably got an old car if you're anything like me getting out of college you started kind of with nothing
You know, getting to the point where we have security or safety nets just seems like such a far leap off of that bottom plateau.
How many people can actually afford a house?
Mark Fielding Do you have any data on how many people, what percentage of the American population are homeowners versus renters?
Chris Moeller I don't, but I do know this. ⁓ Only 13 % of the United States population has a salary, which is crazy. ⁓ know, and 13 won 3%. ⁓ So, you know, most of the folks that work in the United States now are either gig or contract ⁓ or hourly.
Crazy facts. 13%. The other the other crazy fact ⁓ is is that our our home ⁓ inventory is so old. You know, we're going to have this great resurgence real soon because the baby boomers are going to age out of their homes. But you know what that means. We're going to have an inventory of product that's on the market that goes back to as is buyer beware.
⁓ So, you know, there's a tidal wave coming in a lot of ways in America because we had that population boom ⁓ in the 40s ⁓ post-war and that population boom is aging, which is starting to impact a lot of things, right? A lot of our systems. ⁓ So the home ⁓ inventory that's coming onto the market being in its 40s ⁓ is going to take a lot of work to get these houses back to comfortable and livable.
Mark Fielding the UK and the rest of the world it's dire compared to that as well. it's again it doesn't correspond to the higher Masmo levels that we're all fed. Sorry Jeremy.
Size, and what the price tag follows
Jeremy Gilbertson No, no, you're good. One quick thing that I never really thought about till you just mentioned it, Chris, is the boomer generation homes largely are massive and just way bigger than, it's like when your parents start getting rid of their old giant clunky furniture and they're like, hey, do you want this? I'm like, no, it weighs 40,000 pounds and it's dark wood.
maybe a little depressing and, but like these homes are like probably 3000, 4000, 5000, 6000 square foot homes where like it's an inventory mismatch, right? For what people.
the price tag corresponds to that size. So who buys up all of these homes when they become available? It's the investment companies, the VCs, and then they're rented out on booking.com and Airbnb, and the problem is exacerbated more.
Jeremy Gilbertson We're back to extraction. Yeah.
Chris Moeller Yeah, exactly. They're micro economies, right? So short-term, long-term, private equity, venture capital, these are all different micro economies that are happening inside of the housing market. Affordable housing is its own micro economy, and it works off of a very different model. Area median income and needs as defined by affordability, as defined by the federal government. But the reality is those numbers are so archaic.
And those models are so archaic that quite frankly, everybody right now qualifies for affordability because life isn't really affordable. So, you know, what's happening is everything is becoming your immediate income and everything is becoming ⁓ a requirement for for, ⁓ you know, ⁓ qualification anyway for aid and that's not good right we we're not going to be able to spend our way out of this we're gonna have to repurpose or rethink another micro economy inside of housing first again food shelter air water that physiological need level that can get to stable living. Once we have stable living, we can start to think about security. We can start to think about stability and finances and safety and then move our way up to love and belonging and esteem. But like we're not at sustainable. So that word was buried along with affordable at our board retreat a few months ago. I buried two words literally at our farm, took the words, dug a hole, buried them.
And the first word was sustainability because we're not, this isn't a place that we want to sustain currently unless we're at the top of the triangle. If we're at self-actualization, yes, we want to sustain, but most aren't. There's eight billion people on the planet. The second one is affordability because I think it's too subjective.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, and affordability is real. mean, like, know, we're, most of us on this call are in fortunate positions, but they're still like, I run into like, the world is way more costly than it used to be. And I can't imagine like someone that is at half of what I earn or even less, which is a large percentage, perhaps, that how they make that stuff work, right? So we know it's a problem. We know it's a challenge.
Let's focus on the housing piece. Let's point it back to the framework we're trying to align with this mismatch between Maslow's and tech. I want to ask, can technology be used to point to this housing problem and solve it? And if so, how?
Chris Moeller ⁓ great bridge there. ⁓ So another hashtag you see me use a lot is total tenancy. ⁓ You know, I'm a recovering office developer and we used to talk about tenants and tenancy all the time.
And what was working with those micro ⁓ economies was that ⁓ an office term would be five to seven years. After five to seven years, we would completely gut the environment and come back and build it again, right? So it was this amazing volatility machine inside of the building that just created this economic ⁓ engine, so to speak.
⁓ And you know, really we don't do that with our homes at all. We buy a house We have a 30-year fixed we might do an addition We might put some cosmetic upgrades to something a new roof maintenance, but then 30 years later by and large it looks exactly the same ⁓ so a long way of getting to the technology part total tenancy is about Is about technology it's about how can we move more towards if we're gonna try to get to stable living Can we use better money?
Stablecoins, and blockchain
Chris Moeller ⁓ We hear the word stable coin, right? So we know that a lot of the technology that's persistent and interoperable in decentralized finance is just better because it's disintermediated. So there's efficiencies associated with it. ⁓ But then also in the US now, we've got the Genius Act and the Clarity Act that are starting to define beyond commodities into real world assets.
⁓ So I think there's a huge future in blockchain technology, decentralized finance, ⁓ even stable coins and cryptocurrency to help push along some of these efficiencies as long as we don't extract that value and profit and we return that efficiency back to a long-term stable model.
Drones building houses
Mark Fielding So this conversation reminds me of a conversation I was listening to on a competitor's podcast last week. And they were talking about technology and housing. And this is, I've got two issues with.
big tech at the moment. One is the timelines, the time horizons, where everything's going to be fixed in two to seven years. They're so precise and it's so near term. And it's got to the point now, if you speak about AI and you say 10 years, people are like, no, no, 10 months. And it's that kind of really short-sighted time horizon, which I'm worried about. And then the second part of this podcast was using, so I don't know if you saw, it was a few last week, that China had...
36 or something thousand drones all working together in a swarm to create a big screen over and they talking about they could use this robotic drone technology to build infrastructure, to build houses, to build new energy and data and it seemed so incredibly naive.
But maybe that's me that I'm being naive. Do you see any proof of these cutting edge robotic technologies being used to bring down the cost of housing, to speed up the production of the housing? Or are we looking at a more old fashioned, traditional way to solve this problem?
Chris Moeller ⁓ Absolutely, not to that level, not to the abstraction of like to the example that you just gave, but industrialized construction is something that we are absolutely using. ⁓ We can build a better home and a factory. And we're proving that with our first project in Hudson, North Carolina, which hopefully we'll be announcing very, very soon. ⁓
You know, the rest of the world really does develop and build mostly homes and factories. The United States really still cobbles a lot of things together in terms of material sticks delivered out to the woods. And then the crews come out and then they assemble and over a year and a half time or more, ⁓ it turns into a home. The reality is we can do a lot of that with better quality control, with better materials management, with better with better project management inside of a controlled environment.
⁓ So there's a huge difference between building with 40,000 drones into some amazing object that's a real world asset versus bringing a bunch of guys into an interior of a factory and building the same way under one roof.
And I think the middle of that is really where the most important innovation is happening right now and a lot of the roboticized processes, because once we figure out that repetitive motion and action and we can train ML to know that everything is precisely done, we're moving into a world where Henry Ford did in the early teens, right? We're gonna start to be able to build quality.
Jeremy Gilbertson The drone thing that you referenced, Mark, I think about it solving the coordination problem, right? So it's like this, in coordination is emergent as much as it is hierarchical and it's a theme. say those two words on nearly every episode that we talk about. They'll be in our book, I know as a chapter two. how does, listen, I understand the process of like, we can build systems to make housing better and cheaper and more rapidly deployed. But let's talk about, I think the bigger challenge, Chris, to me is how do we unlock access to that for people that don't have traditional, I almost think about the coordination problem applied to how people get financing for projects like that and how those modes kind of.
collapse into smaller amounts instead of being these large, unattainable $400,000 loans for people. What could that look like?
Responsible finance
Chris Moeller So responsible finance is a big part of this. impact, it's going to take some impact investing ⁓ to create a healthier financial model around housing. ⁓ So let me start by telling you some of our secret sauce. ⁓ Community land grants ⁓ and deed restrictions are huge. That's a page from the playbook of private equity that we're seeing a lot. Separating the land.
Jeremy Gilbertson Can you explain those two?
Separating the land from the structure
Chris Moeller Yeah, sure. Separating the land and having a land owner or a land grant from the structure itself. So when you rent an apartment or buy a condominium, you are in the structure and you are either renting or owning that structure, but you're not renting or you don't own the land below it.
So you can, on a community deed, or on a community land trust, you can find impact investors that are foundations that have, or family office that have.
long-term thinking in mind that are saying I have this money, have this resource, how can I do good with it? How can I do good to you know, how can I do well to do good? And one of the responses that I have for that is impact investment into community land grants. You can go in and buy a ton of land, sink your money in for a hundred year lease and let me build on top of it. And then create an ownership model for those assets, for those tenants, for those community members to own just the structure.
and decoupling the land from the structure gives back all that value, right? So now they're not burdened with the cost of the land and the cost of the structure, a la single-family home. So that's one way. The deed restriction is another one. And the reason that we're going down that path is Habitat for Humanity did this so well. When those habitat owners want to sell and move, they're obligated to sell back to Habitat.
If they put that house on the open market, it would be subject to traditional market dynamics. So it restricts the actual value of the home in perpetuity. ⁓ so it's counterintuitive, but it maintains that affordability over a longer period of time.
Mark Fielding What's the disadvantage of that? Is there a disadvantage to that? Other than the obvious.
Chris Moeller Yeah, capitalism and you know, why would you want to do that? And you your home is how you get, you know, wealthy and that's where you know, your equity is locked into that. So what we have to do is also introduce new vehicles of investment and new opportunities to make money in other ways. ⁓ You know, the financial planners in my life that have been consulting into our stable living model, you know, we shouldn't be spending more than 25 % of our gross income on our housing.
⁓ And we are at some some ⁓ age in place of the boomers are spending 50 60 70 percent right now You know as their income continues to go down over time because they're simply receiving benefits in their retirement their retirement starts to run out You know all of a sudden they're spending more and more trying to maintain ⁓ their their stability so ⁓
That's the obvious. I think that if we can start to reimagine a stable living model that's less extractive as it relates to housing, I think that would be a good start.
The road to serfdom
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, tech man just the way it works. The way it works. I'm reading a book right now by Tim Wu, who ⁓ kind of came up with the net neutrality concept related to, you know, the path to information on the internet shouldn't be guided and restricted by the people that own the pipes kind of thing. And he presents this really, I'm going to share this. I'm going to share this quick framework that we can maybe try to fold in, but he calls it the slow road
Jeremy Gilbertson to serfdom and kind of number one related to technology related to platforms. Technology systems, these big platforms tend to move towards monopolization, right? So we move towards these monopolies, right? And these monopolies are platforms and they're extractive, meaning, you know, they create these two buckets, they create winners and they create losers and they pull from the losers to feed the winners. And it's just, kind of this sorting of society based on tech. then you have the third step is this emergence. He calls it the emergence of mass resentment. So everyone's like everyone on the loser side is going, man, this I can't, I can't tread water here. And I keep, I can't get above to this next level because I'm feeding these systems that aren't, that aren't feeding me back. Right. Last two.
Mark Fielding are the cynics that Mustafa Suleiman is referring to in his tweet.
Jeremy Gilbertson 100 % in these last two and I'll stop after these last two to get your thoughts and then and then we move towards some scary stuff we move towards something like the failure of democracy which we talk about all the time on this show we talk about it with multiple guests related to privacy related to ⁓ a lot of different things so you have a democratic failure as a as a as a response to this resentment right and then you have what he calls a strong man coming in and saying hey I'm gonna fix everything and continues to move everything from democracy to autocracy and the whole cycle continues. We go back, we maintain monopolization, we maintain extraction. ⁓ So I thought that was really interesting. What do you guys think about those beats to the story related to the discussion on housing?
Mark Fielding Well, you've just explained the modern malaise. I mean, yeah. I mean, that,
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah. Well, Tim Wu did.
Chris Moeller Yeah, and I've got a way that I like to frame this in my head is, know, you guys probably listen to some of Ray Dalio's work or at least have come across some of his work. ⁓ First principles, yeah. know, principles, yeah, principles. We always go to first principles because Ilan owns that right now and he just keeps talking about first principles. But this is just principles and it's Ray Dalio's work.
Jeremy Gilbertson I've read his book, what, First Principles, right? Or principles? Principles.
Chris Moeller ⁓ And he just said something that I'd heard a thousand times at one point and it hit me different about two months ago and it was this notion of revisiting the growth mindset. And the growth mindset traditionally is capitalism, quarterly annual reports, shareholder value, growth, bottom left, top right, two dimensions, x y, graph up.
Mark Fielding Sorry, my growth mindset
Jeremy Gilbertson Nice, well played.
Chris Moeller you're not the average, which is beautiful. ⁓ But the growth mind...
Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds, welcome to the intersection of frameworks. We're just, we're just firing them. Go ahead. Yeah.
Emergence, and regenerative by birth
Chris Moeller Yeah, so getting into emergence and starting to think about, you know, re-evaluating your relationship with the growth mindset is what comes to mind first. And that's really what happened for me. You know, food systems, when I'm a natural systems thinker, so everything has an input and output and an intended result. But I also don't want to extract because I have a farm and soil is soil quality goes straight into nutrition.
I'm regenerative by birth. ⁓ I didn't learn this. It was inside of me somehow. Thanks, mom and dad. ⁓
But when you revisit that business capitalism growth mindset and you start to think about things naturally through emergence, you start to create a little bit of a hierarchy of need, right? You start to realize, wow, water is a resource and soil microbes are a resource and the quality of our soil and the value of the quality of our soil.
is really important, but yet the commoditized system says it's a per acre price. If my neighbor has been doing industrialized farming for 50 years and I've been doing regenerative farming for 50 years, my soil structure is way better, my yield is higher, I have no inputs, I don't have to use fertilizer, I don't have to use chemical ⁓ pesticides or insecticides, is my land value actually higher? I would argue yes, the bank would tell me no.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, it's quantitative versus qualitative. Sorry, Mark?
Mark Fielding So would the supermarkets.
So would the supermarkets, would imagine, judging by the state of them over here in Europe.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, here's a thing too, Chris. I I love all of that stuff and I love the way you think about it. ⁓ But the unfortunate piece is not everyone's able to think like that because we're, let's go back to Maslow's and the physiological and safety needs, right? So think of someone living in an urban area ⁓ and the only access to food in that urban area is a convenience store. The only food at that convenience store comes in a wrapper.
and you know, no vegetables, nothing. It's like, hey, I'm trying to freaking survive. You know, if I get a can of of spam and some Doritos to fill me up so I can go to work, that man, how, this is a big question. How do we use tech to flip the script? How do we use that? know, tech talks about, yo, we can do all of these things. We can solve the cancer puzzle. We can do all.
Mark Fielding implants, Jeremy, in the shop when you're going to buy the Doritos and the neural implant is saying, hold on, wait a minute, for the same price as that bag of Doritos you could get this, this, this and this, why don't you think about your longevity rather than...
Jeremy Gilbertson No, but there's no this, this or that. There's just Doritos and honey buns in this convenience store, right? So, like, I'm thinking systematic. I'm thinking, like, what can tech do to coordinate better? It's a coordination problem. So how do we coordinate better to make sure there's, you know, and people are doing it, but not at scale.
The project, and local producers
Chris Moeller I'll speak to it again with our project, the Hudson Commons. We have a community kitchen as part of our amenity space. So there's an old, know, grandma's 2,600 square foot, single story, brick ranch house on the property. And we were getting ready to imagine this project. Everybody scrapped it off the plans. And I was like, we're not scrapping that house. They said, what do you mean? I said, we're going to reimagine grandma's house as the future.
And they said, what do you mean? said, we're going to take that brick ranch and we're going to turn it into different use cases inside of that house. We're not going to use it as a single family home. We're going to turn the kitchen into a community kitchen. We're going to do industrialized stainless steel so that we can do prep work in there. We can bring in folks to talk about food. We can bring in a chef. We can bring in a local producer, whatever it might be. We're going take the living room, which is the heart of the home with the hearth. And we're going to turn that into a coworking space so everybody can get out of their apartment or their unit and they can come meet.
somewhere to do some heads down work and we're going to take the three bedrooms and we're going to use the short-term rental model so that when Jeremy comes to visit because he's got a project in Charlotte he can crash in one of those places because I have access to it on the app.
Right? So that home is being re-imagined. The technology that it takes to coordinate that is the answer to your question. Right? I think. And we get into the better food systems by creating a CSA for an entire community. have 56 units in that our property on three acres. ⁓ We estimate that we'll probably have anywhere between 80 and 100 residents on that three acres. So now all of a sudden I can produce protein and ⁓ veg from two or dairy.
from three of our small local producers, can provide us food at one centralized location and they don't have to worry about going to seven farmers markets during the week to try to make 300 bucks at each one. So that disintermediation through technology and the coordination piece is super important to getting to better shelter, better food, better water, better air, and just making that our baseline is our goal.
Does it work in the inner city?
Mark Fielding Do you see that model working in high density inner city housing complexes?
Chris Moeller Not as well. ⁓ And mostly because that missing middle product. So a lot of times when we're talking about the missing middle, there's two different perspectives. One is missing middle class, like the middle class is shrinking. That's happening too. But they share that terminology in real estate. The missing middle is actually a product type. So 500 square foot efficiency studio apartment doesn't or studio doesn't really exist in rural America.
It does exist in the city in many forms from impoverished all the way up to like super fancy building. So that missing middle product is upward mobility, 500 square feet, 750 square feet, two bedroom townhouse walkout, three bedroom walkout family home. All of that isn't going to be incorporated into our community so that we can provide the opportunity to sort of quote unquote move up as life gets more complex.
A recovering office developer
Jeremy Gilbertson So you mentioned being a recovering office developer. Let's talk about what's happening in commercial real estate right now. there was ⁓ an ebb and flow of like, everyone's, COVID came around, we're okay with working remotely. The technology got great, so no one had to go in the office. But then all of a sudden, the owners of these real estate investments are going, man, you know, no one's in this office, we're paying a ton for it. Yo, hey, everyone's got to come back in the office. Now we have this thing and there's this interesting dynamic flowing in and out of that. But with the lack of utilization of commercial properties, you know, think like high rise towers, right? Leasing is probably down still there. Could you apply, how would you apply your model that you're testing here to like 10 floors of an office building?
Chris Moeller Yeah, it doesn't work for us. ⁓ It doesn't work for a lot of people. It works for luxury. ⁓ It works for experience. If you've got, you know, three million dollars start and a fifteen million dollar penthouse, those buildings were not built that way. We like air. We like walkout areas. We like window lines in our in our homes. Those buildings are big glass boxes that are sealed. ⁓ So kind of very tough to take a a high rise central business district high rise and turn it into housing. Definitely not affordable housing without massive subsidies because it's a very expensive lift. Those buildings were built for different functions. Where there is big opportunity, Jeremy is. ⁓ is in the outskirts, 25 miles, 35 miles outside of town, where there's a three-story, four-building office park that is kind of run down. It's got the basic infrastructure for plumbing, it's got, or for water, for utilities, and it's steel and concrete, a three-story mid-rise. There's opportunity there because the cost basis is lower. Those small businesses are not renting small offices to five, 7,000 square foot spaces.
as much because they're working this way. ⁓ So there's a huge opportunity for adaptive reuse but the central business district as I mentioned already has a missing middle product. They have options for people to live in a 500 square foot studio or a three bedroom walkout.
So for our model, we see a bigger opportunity at the fringe of the city, really almost more so even out into the rural towns that have a main street, the Hallmark movie towns of America.
Lease rates, and capital markets
Jeremy Gilbertson Could, two follow on questions. ⁓ One, are lease rates down far enough to make any kind of economic viability for a move for an owner of that building to do something different or no?
Chris Moeller ⁓ Yeah, rates are a mess. Capital markets are a mess. ⁓ And there's a future, know, if people are looking at the horizon, they're looking at the supply demand curve and realizing we have a ton of supply and the demand is going to wane over time because people are going to figure out remote distributed hybrid work models. ⁓ So what's happening really right now is that distressed debt is going out to capital markets and it's going to auction off.
So there'll be a huge opportunity, I think, for opportunistic infill to re-adaptive reuse, to rethink and reimagine a lot of these assets in the future. ⁓ But to do it with the affordability lens, a la Maslow's physiological needs.
They just those those two forces don't usually get along very well because capitalism tends to be how do we maximize profit and IRR for the GPLP and Affordability tends to be a little bit too far on the how do we give it away? How do we give a roof over someone's head and let them stay here without an opportunity for ownership? So the middle is the hard part. That's state. That's to me. That's stability
Infrastructure
Jeremy Gilbertson So second follow on question to that, the idea of, so you move it out, you know, to the outskirts, 20, 30, 40 miles from the city. Certain people live in the city because of proximity to work, right? So now you have a transportation issue, right? I'm not saying it, it's all great stuff, but I'm just thinking, okay, that's awesome, but how do we solve this next piece of the puzzle?
Chris Moeller It's a great question. ⁓ you know, infrastructure, infrastructure, infrastructure, infrastructure. So if you look at the big, the biggest REITs, if you look at the wealthiest people, the people who are making the biggest plays right now, they're all investing in infrastructure. So I like to think that our pathway communities model takes process and turns it into product and then turns that product into technology so that we can drive the cost down over time.
What I'm aiming for is that stable living becomes infrastructure and it's investable as infrastructure.
That takes a lot to get there. You have to have, for example, a microgrid, right, without the capacity and distribution issues associated with our utilities. I'm going to put 56 dwelling units now where there were two. Our infrastructure and the utility is freaking out saying, man, we're going to have to put up a substation. We're going to put in a microgrid. So that's infrastructure investment. Rural broadband is another one.
Chris Moeller Space-based solar power microgrid maybe, you know, five
Mark Fielding sovereign power, That's what I thinking.
Chris Moeller years maybe, sure. So we're gonna start with zero to one, figure it out. It'll probably be wrong or obsolete, that's okay. ⁓ The infrastructure will be in place, process to product, product to technology, drive cost down.
⁓ rural broadband's huge. You know, that infrastructure in the stability of an internet for us right now, again, privileged, we're still online. We're streaming probably we're at high def. I can hear you and see you well. It's because I have a stable internet connection, fiber to the premise. Everybody in this world should have fiber to the premise. In my opinion, access to information can help us get past so many hurdles. You can be underprivileged and have access.
and have a curiosity and have access to information and do fine. But if you're underprivileged and you don't have access to information, then you're gonna find something else to occupy your time and it's probably not gonna be productive. So rural broadband, those initiatives are huge.
Mark Fielding Man, but here's- gonna tie into the docs, use space-based solar power. AST Space Mobile, Jeremy, that ⁓ connecting to the grid from anywhere. I love this ground-up grassroots community-driven solution, and I'm sure that when Maslow was creating his hierarchy, he had that.
at the back of his mind. I'm sure that any solution came from the bottom up, not from the top down. Are you alone? Who else is doing what you're doing? Is this happening in every American city? Is this happening across Europe? Is this something that can work in the Sudan as well as it can in Pittsburgh? How is this community of like-minded builders like you growing and developing?
Pathway Communities
Chris Moeller It's a great question. ⁓ You know, it reminds me of those old shirts, right? ⁓ Think globally, drink locally. So right now we're definitely drinking locally, ⁓ but so is everybody else. So the network note effect is starting to take place where we have a community of people around our.
process of pathway communities and Hudson Commons and stable living. And all of a sudden we're hearing from another community that's in Gratz. And they've been thinking this through because their process and their affordable housing models are totally different than ours and they can relate to.
They have stable shelter, but they might have inefficiencies or instability with their food system. So they're all of a sudden tied to interesting conversations. We by taking that concept of affordable housing and turning it into stable living, we're now having great conversations with a lot of different network node effect people. And it's growing sort of exponentially, which is exactly what we wanted to do. Like we're not going to nail all of it, but we're going to focus on stable living instead of just affordable so that other people can come in and say ⁓ you already figured out the know the enclosure or the microgrid situation or the technology that's amazing like we're struggling with this but we know that and we're starting to share so it is definitely global ⁓ feels very similar to the Dow days early Bitcoin days early l2 discussions where people were all working on sort of the same stuff and then they would come together and was like holy mackerel
Mark Fielding type of people though or not or similar type of people.
Chris Moeller Yeah, definitely different type of people, different needs, those physiological needs, you know, our water quality, our food quality and our shelter quality are very different. And somebody that's living in an impoverished world can go into something that we might consider less than and be perfectly happy. So if it's good and that physiological need is taken care of and they feel shelter is safe and safety, then we move on. There's no reason to overbuild at that point.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah. And then you can start thinking, you mentioned earlier about curiosity and, and, ⁓ again, a keyword that comes up on nearly every, every episode. It's very difficult to be curious if you're not secure and you don't have food and your physiological needs aren't met. I think getting to that sense of belonging, getting to that sense of love and belonging, which is that next little piece of the puzzle, your, development that you're putting together 50 plus structures, I think you said community kitchen in the middle, like
Talk to me about, with this being, you're not saying just affordable housing, you're saying stable living, right? Who, give me a, paint me a character. Who is this gonna serve? What do they do for work? How much do they make? ⁓ Talk me through, give me a little character rep of this.
COVID cracked the door
Chris Moeller I'm glad you asked that. So I always say that COVID cracked the windshield, but Hurricane Helene smashed the glass. ⁓ You know, I was very heavily involved in the office product before COVID. I realized pretty quickly with the way that those buildings were built and the way that we shared indoor air quality, ⁓ they were going to be short-lived. So I started sort of exploring other opportunities.
The quick answer to your question, Jeremy, is civil servants. So our model is going to be built specifically around those who have chosen to serve their communities first. So we're qualifying that currently loosely as teachers, ⁓ nurses, police, fire, medic, first responders to stabilize the community. So where we're doing this.
Chris Moeller Sure, we call them frontline workers during COVID, right, which was ridiculous. But at the end of the day, it's folks who have chosen to give to their communities or serve their communities more so than participate in traditional economic cycles and follow corporate structure and leadership growth and that kind of thing.
⁓ So that's what we're doing and that's why we're teaming up with different towns around the country because they love that story of how can we create workforce development to attract and retain the right talent and the right talent being we can't get people to drive our ambulances, we can't get people to stay in schools long enough to teach, and we can't get nurses to stay here to take care of our elderly because they can't afford to be here. So workforce development through civil service for upward mobility is absolutely our ICP.
Jeremy Gilbertson That's so cool, man.
Mark Fielding that we've got a we got sorry do we got it yeah right I'm gonna gotta go pick up kids guys so Chris thank you like I've learned a lot from you perhaps more than I thought I could learn about housing and quite a detour for thinking on paper in terms of that deep heavy space tech that we've been looking at recently. So this is a re-grounding of what it means to be human amongst all of this. So thank you. As with all I guess, the closer from Kevin Kelly. You've had lots of time to prepare for this Chris, since you were one of the first to hear of Ask It. And I think possibly you've already answered this question.
in the last 40 minutes. But what do we want humans to be? And how does technology help us get there?
What Chris wants
Chris Moeller Yeah, I want stability more than anything else. I just want to create that physiological level. ⁓ You know, I was privileged enough to be brought into this world with love and belonging already on the third rung.
⁓ And I think that there's a way for us to sort of discover and revisit those physiological needs and get that stabilized. That's what I'm working on. I won't use the L word because legacy is not what I'm doing. What we're doing is really trying to build the long now.
Mark Fielding You're emo. Love it. Thank you. ⁓
Mark Fielding Anything you want to add, Jomi? Any closing thoughts?
Mark Fielding So, Chris, what you've done is opened a huge can of Maslow worms. We've barely touched the hierarchy. We've skimmed across level one. There's another four to go. So, yeah, thank you for creating another series where Thinking on Paper goes into the hierarchy of Maslow and finds out how tech is influencing it or hindering it. So thank you for that one. So until then, listener, be disruptive, stay curious.
keep thinking on paper. Chris, good to see you, man. Take it easy.
Chris Moeller for sharing this space, guys. This was great.
Jeremy Gilbertson You got it, Mark. I'll hang on to grab that stuff if you need it.
Mark Fielding Chris, can you, would you mind? Chris, just before you go, could you look at the camera, you don't have to do this, but look at the camera and say, I'm Chris Moeller of, I think on paper with Mark and Jeremy.
Chris Moeller I'm Chris Moeller of Pathway Communities and I think on paper with Mark and Jeremy.
Jeremy Gilbertson Thanks buddy. Have a great day, sir.
Mark Fielding Thank you. One day we'll
Chris Moeller That's awesome guys. Have a good day. We'll talk to you soon
Mark Fielding One question Chris, at some point we're going to want to come to you




