Can Satellites Watch Earth in Real Time?

Fintan Buckley says Ubotica has asked itself what it would do if someone wanted its technology for offensive military use. And we have made the decision that that would not be something we would be willing to support.

Thinking On Paper

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 18 chapters

  1. What space shows us about Earth
  2. The LA wildfires, and what satellites could have done
  3. From image to insight in five minutes
  4. Live Earth intelligence and dynamic targeting
  5. What Ubotica actually builds
  6. First to fly commercial silicon in space
  7. The service: watching one area continuously
  8. Can you predict a fire before it spreads?
  9. Connecting the dots, and the last mile
  10. Taking the human out of the loop, and putting them back
  11. Hot buttons
  12. On wonder, and being bored
  13. Is low Earth orbit getting too crowded?
  14. Deorbiting, servicing and dead satellites
  15. When Google changed its AI principles
  16. Can a satellite really read a piece of paper?
  17. How should we think about data in a thousand years?
  18. Backstage: what we learned
I think our technology, which we have developed over the past 40 years has actually caused us not to think, not to have quiet time, not to have downtime. And I think that’s a problem.
Fintan Buckley, Ubotica

Fintan Buckley's company Ubotica runs AI on board satellites, so a satellite sends down insights where it would otherwise send raw images. “And we have demonstrated that we can go from image to insight to ground within five minutes.”

Buckley explains how Ubotica worked with the European Space Agency to qualify commercial off-the-shelf silicon for space, and how work with JPL lets a satellite skip a cloudy target and reorient itself. He also argues for servicing old satellites over destroying them.

Fintan Buckley, co-founder and CEO of Ubotica, argues on the Thinking On Paper podcast that Earth observation satellites should use onboard AI to process images in orbit and send down answers, not raw pictures, so responders to fires, floods and maritime threats get insight in minutes instead of days. Ubotica, which works with NASA's JPL on dynamic targeting, calls the goal “live earth intelligence”.

Can satellites watch Earth in real time?

Fintan Buckley argues they can if satellites process images in orbit with onboard AI and send down answers, not raw pictures. Responders to fires, floods and maritime threats would get insight in minutes instead of days.

How fast can onboard AI deliver satellite insights?

Onboard AI cuts the wait from days to minutes. Buckley says that downlinking raw images, which can be five gigabytes each, and processing them on the ground can take hours to days, while Ubotica's own satellite has shown it can go “from image to insight to ground within five minutes”, using inter-satellite links to send the result down.

What is dynamic targeting for satellites?

Ubotica is working with NASA's JPL in Pasadena on “dynamic targeting”, where the satellite decides for itself what to photograph. Buckley says the satellite takes a low-resolution look ahead, uses AI to check whether the target is under cloud, and turns to a clearer target with no human intervention, so it does not waste its limited power budget on useless images. Once it spots something of interest, it can call other satellites in the constellation to keep watching.

Where did the Ubotica founders come from?

Ubotica's founders came from the company that built the first vision processing unit, a chip that captures images and runs AI on them in the same piece of silicon; Buckley says Intel acquired that company in 2016. Ubotica then worked with the European Space Agency to qualify commercial off-the-shelf chips for space, and Buckley says it was the first company to do so.

Where are satellites most useful for Earth monitoring?

Satellites earn their place where ground monitoring is hard and speed matters. Buckley says comparing a city's road network before and after a flood, as in Valencia, is “one of the easier applications” of onboard AI, and that maritime security for naval services is now Ubotica's focus, while much agricultural satellite data does not need to arrive in real time.

Will Ubotica support military uses of its technology?

Ubotica has decided it will not support offensive military uses of its technology. Buckley says that stance is easier for “a small company in a neutral country” such as Ireland than for large companies in larger countries, and declines to comment on Google changing its AI principles. He adds: “I personally think we always need the human in the loop somewhere.”

Where Mark and Buckley disagree

Mark asks whether dead satellites can simply run out of fuel and burn up, since even small particles are a hazard. Buckley shifts the question: “I think it's not about how we destroy them. I think we have to be thinking about reuse”, arguing for servicing satellites because launch is the biggest cost and environmental impact. Asked whether a satellite could read a page held up in Mark's hand, he says Ubotica's current satellites see about five metres per pixel, so they could not, but commercial imagery is reaching one metre and less.

Questions

Can satellites watch Earth in real time?

Fintan Buckley argues they can if satellites process images in orbit with onboard AI and send down answers, not raw pictures. Responders to fires, floods and maritime threats would get insight in minutes instead of days.

Who is Fintan Buckley?

Fintan Buckley, co-founder and CEO of Ubotica, argues on the Thinking On Paper podcast that Earth observation satellites should use onboard AI to process images in orbit and send down answers, not raw pictures, so responders to fires, floods and maritime threats get insight in minutes instead of days.

What does Ubotica do?

Fintan Buckley's company Ubotica runs AI on board satellites, so a satellite sends down insights where it would otherwise send raw images.

What is live earth intelligence?

Fintan Buckley, co-founder and CEO of Ubotica, argues on the Thinking On Paper podcast that Earth observation satellites should use onboard AI to process images in orbit and send down answers, not raw pictures, so responders to fires, floods and maritime threats get insight in minutes instead of days. Ubotica, which works with NASA's JPL on dynamic targeting, calls the goal “live earth intelligence”.

Transcript

Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds, welcome to another episode of Thinking On Paper where we take you, the curious entrepreneur, thinker, worker, doer, behind the scenes of the latest technology that we're seeing, where we see the world going, and peek behind the scenes a little bit, figure out what it means to all of us, to our lives, to our families, to our jobs, and all of that fun stuff. My name is Jeremy. This is Mark. We have a fun episode today. And remember, guys, we have all of our different segments that we've turned on this year. Number one, the hot buttons, the Mark Fielding hot button section. Very soon, fan favorite, we have the Thinking On Paper news. And at the very end of the show, Mark and I unpack what we learned in full disclosure, in full fumbling through understanding. Join us for that at the very end. Mark, what are we getting into today?

Mark Fielding Today, Jeremy, we're speaking about a technology which, and no understatement, might change humanity, save civilization. As you know, people, we're reading Nexus in our book club. Check out Thinking On Paper at .xyz for the second pillar in our framework for understanding emerging technologies. And listener, it's been a story of doom and gloom in Nexus of late. We've been talking about the nefarious dark side of AI. And today, I'm very happy to say the positivity is back, the optimism is back. We're talking about AI in a good light. We're talking about faster disaster response times, environmental protection, maritime safety, precision agriculture, national security, urban planning. I think the technology we're speaking about today almost knows no end. Of course, there are some disadvantages, we're going to talk about that. But on the whole, it's an awesome technology. Jeremy, what are we on?

Jeremy Gilbertson We're going to space. Space, space. So real quick, before we introduce our guests, I've been a fan and a nerd of Carl Sagan's perspective of the pale blue dot, which is basically looking back at the earth from way far in space and seeing this giant thing, this giant rock that we're sitting on as a tiny blue dot. So I'm excited to learn from our guests, what is the most important thing we can learn from a space perspective on things. So without further ado, let's let's get into it. I'm asking questions and our guest isn't even here yet. Mark, how about an intro?

Mark Fielding Yeah, bring on Fintan Buckley from Eubotica, AI, satellites combined. We're going to find out more. Welcome to the show. Fintan, thank you for thinking on paper with us.

Fintan Buckley Great, thank you, Mark and Jeremy. Thank you for having me on the show today and look forward to the conversation.

What space shows us about Earth

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, so we sprinkled Carl Sagan into the conversation already. Let's start with that first question with like, what can we learn from the perspective of outer space about the planet Earth, about the systems, about the climate, about all of that stuff? What's important from the view from space for us?

Fintan Buckley The most important thing that that we have from space is through various modalities. We have the ability to have 24 seven, 365 days of the year, constant surveillance of the Earth. And from that, develop the technologies to provide the systems, the structures to keep our Earth safe. We are going through a time of tremendous change in terms of our climate, in terms of, you know, geopolitical issues that are going on in the world. The world is changing dynamically. And we have the ability through satellites and particularly Earth observation satellites to observe and to take action in near real time to the events that are happening around us. You know, you think about, you know, what are the pressing issues in the world today? Climate is a big one.

Fintan Buckley You know, you look at, you know, the fires that we have in Los Angeles, which are actually very personal to me, because A, I lived in Los Angeles. My sister lives in Los Angeles. She lost her house in the fire in the Palisades. With Earth observation technology, you know, we can see and observe in real time exactly what's happening in an event like that to assist in supporting what's going on on the ground in terms of fighting the threat that is happening in real time. We have lots of issues around maritime security. What's also very, very close and personal to us here in Ireland is we are the gateway for a lot of the telecommunication infrastructure that comes across the Atlantic. Right. And we have to be able to defend that, right, protect it against accidental and nefarious harm to those cables.

Fintan Buckley We can see these things from space. And we need to be able to react to these threats in real time. And that's really what Eubotica is all about, being able to deploy technology, onboard satellites, to react to these events and to provide systems and structures to those who are going to respond to the humans who are going to respond to this.

The LA wildfires, and what satellites could have done

Mark Fielding Let's double click, as they say, on the L.A. wildfires. And I'm sorry to hear about your sister losing her house. I hope that the healing is coming along. OK, if we double click on those fires from Eubotica, what are Eubotica doing? And if, say, five years in the future, what would you have done or could you have done to make those fires less impactful, less dangerous? What could you have done to have helped more?

Fintan Buckley So from satellite, right, with the precision coverage, you can detect and predict the movement of the fires. Right. And that early warning systems you can provide to the fire responders. That's the key thing that you can do, because you have visibility, right, from space to actually provide that level of warning. Now, granted, you know, what happened in the Palisades was very, very quick. Right. It was, you know, with the winds and everything, it moved so fast. But with the ability to see this stuff happening in real time, you can help in terms of the evacuation and the deployment of the resources on the ground. And a key part of that is with the satellites, it's not just doing the imaging on board, but actually doing the processing on board as well. Right. So it's not getting images down.

Fintan Buckley It's actually getting the insights for the direction that the fire is moving, you know, the density of the fire, all those types of stuff. That's the type of thing that you can do when you employ AI technology on board these EO satellites.

From image to insight in five minutes

Jeremy Gilbertson That's a really important thing to think about, too, because, you know, getting images and then sending the images down to Earth and then having those images or that kind of data processed on Earth, that's time lag. That takes a lot of time to happen. But if you're real time processing all of this stuff, let's think about this like turning data into information. Right. We humans don't use data very well. We use information very well. Right. So how much does that speed things up? Did I read correctly that the cloud cover actually slows down a lot of this? Is that true as well?

Fintan Buckley So it's a combination of technologies that you need to be able to to generate this persistent observation. Right. So, you know, it's it's complicated. It's not cheap. But the benefits of doing this are well worth the investment in doing this. And then when you apply the onboard processing on top of that, you now get real time responses to what's going on. And Jeremy, you asked about the latency from image to insight. So, you know, one of the key things that we have done is we have invested in our own satellite to prove out this capability. And we have demonstrated that we can go from image to insight to ground within five minutes. You do they use the AI to process the image and then use inter-satellite links to get the the output of that information down to ground. So that's that's the key.

Fintan Buckley You're dealing with five giga images. These things are big. All right. And then you've got a way to get over a ground station to actually get the information down. And then you've got to gather from the ground station to wherever the processing is going to be. So it could be hours to days. All right. So and when you're dealing in a disaster scenario, you can't afford to wait. You need to get this information.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, in the case of the wildfires, too, like things you mentioned, the world is changing, the environment changes so rapidly. So by the time that old image gets eventually processed, we're on to something new already. So having that real time access is really important.

Fintan Buckley Yeah. And then another example of this is, you know, in a similar type of scenario, you know, you can you can use satellite imagery, process it on board the satellite to figure out, you know, what's the best route to get out of a situation? Maybe not so much with fires, but, you know, in flooding and things like that, like in like in Valencia, you know, where's your road network after this event? Imaging on the satellite, you can actually process the image and determine, you know, what has changed in your road network, right? Before and after the event and to get that down to the responders. So, you know, the applications here are really significant and the benefits are huge.

Live Earth intelligence and dynamic targeting

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah. So we talked about the real time processing and kind of this idea of, you know, edge compute, edge AI to process these these information, these these sets of data, turning them into information. I ran across the term in our research, Live Earth Intelligence, which I think is amazing. That's that's really, really cool. It's like we're tapping into the subconscious of the planet in a way. It's really interesting. I want to talk about dynamic targeting, because a lot of things happen quickly and they change quickly. And if you're looking at one spot or if a satellite's looking at one spot, you know, how do you quickly make sure that moves or moves based on a tracking pattern? So you have some partnerships that you've put together, right? That to make that happen?

Fintan Buckley Yeah, we well, just to segue into that. So, you know, the the name of the company is Ubotica. And where that comes from is ubiquitous robots, right? That's where we made the name from. And it the the end goal is to have these satellites to have them autonomous, right? To turn them from today, they're essentially dumb cameras, right? They will image, you know, based on input that's coming from the ground where, you know, a human, you know, does the orchestration and the scheduling that you will, you satellite will take an image when you're over this part of the earth. So part of the vision of live earth intelligence is that the satellites make these decisions themselves. Okay. And what we're we're working with. Sorry, distracted.

Fintan Buckley If we're working with JPL there in Pasadena in the US on this concept of dynamic targeting. And this encapsulates a number of concepts. The first concept is where your operator on the earth schedules the satellite to take an image over over a certain part of the world. Okay. Certain area of interest. And if that area of interest happens to be cloudy, you will end up taking an image consuming valuable satellite resources, primarily the power budget, because you're constrained on how many images you can take during an orbit. Okay. So you will waste your power budget on an image that's useless.

Fintan Buckley So the idea of dynamic targeting is, first of all, to have a look ahead capability using the same image sensor to look ahead and to take a low resolution image and say, and then use the AI process that and say, is the area of interest coming up cloudy or not? Okay. And if it is, then you reorientate the satellite. Okay. With no human intervention and oriented to send the imager on the satellite to take the the the the image of the area that you're interested in. So that's the first part of the dynamic targeting. And, and then we, we, we segue that into, um, you know, which, uh, we call this the, the NASA, the, the novel observing strategies is, is that once, once you, you, you have taken an image of an area of interest, you analyze that image. And now, you know, it's something of interest. Okay.

Fintan Buckley So this is a trigger. And now you want to marshal other satellites in your constellation. Right. To all start looking at this area of interest. So using either satellite inter-satellite links or using ground stations, start to bring other resources in, in, in the constellation to focus on the area of interest. So you imagine, you know, you detect, you know, in, in a maritime situation, you detect a vessel that, uh, is nefarious. Right. So now you want to keep all your resources in your constellation monitoring that vessel as it moves. And then the second part of the dynamic targeting is actually using other, other satellites resources to, uh, maintain constant vigilance on, on the area of interest.

Jeremy Gilbertson So the, so the nefarious vessels, I got a, I got a kick out of this when I, when I was doing my, doing my show prep, um, the idea of dark ships. Right. So I don't know if you guys have teenage kids yet, but you know, there's this thing called life 360 that's on phone. So where you could see where your kids are and that if it happened in my day, it would have been such a pain in the butt, but they disable life 360 and they turn into dark ships. Right. And you don't know where they are and you have to call them. And, but I thought that was, uh, that's just a silly analogy, but.

What Ubotica actually builds

Mark Fielding In my house, dark ships are called pirate ships. Could I just, could just back up a little bit and play my, my stupid card. Just, I want to be clear on what Ubotica is actually building. Are you building the satellites? Are you building the software that goes into the satellites? Are you doing both? Can that software be used in Starlink satellites or the Amazon Kuiper satellites? Can that be used everywhere? What's the actual technological stack here?

Fintan Buckley Yeah. So, so when we, when we started off on, on, on this journey, um, you know, the, uh, the, the, the key brains, um, uh, behind the company, um, were involved, um, and founded the first company that actually developed what's called a vision processing unit. So this was a piece of silicon that, that, that integrated, um, the ability to take images plus the ability to run, uh, AI applications on those images in the same piece of silicon. So, so the very first, what's called a BPU. Right. Um, the company was, was, uh, acquired by Intel in, uh, 2016. And, um, at the same time, there was an opportunity, uh, perceived to take that same silicon technology and actually look to deploy it on board satellite.

Fintan Buckley That in itself was fairly novel, um, because, you know, historically, when, when you're, when you're developing silicon systems for, for space applications, you design them to, uh, to be resistant and resilient to the conditions that, that you expect to experience. Experience in space in terms of radiation and, and what have you. So we work with the European space agency to qualify what's known as COTS silicon. So commercial off the shelf silicon, um, to qualify to, to assess how it would perform in space before it actually got flown. And then we, you know, through the qualification, we, we assured ourselves that, that it would, it would fly and it would perform with very little mitigation. Um, and so we were the, we were the first company to do that. Okay. And so our initial focus was developing the hardware and the software that will allow us to, to run AI algorithms on board satellites.

First to fly commercial silicon in space

Jeremy Gilbertson Fenton, I just want to clarify one thing. So you and this group that you were with were the first people to test and make sure commercial off the shelf silicon doesn't fall apart and can actually function in space. AI processors. Yes, that's big. Okay, cool. Continue.

Fintan Buckley Absolutely. Well, you know, and, and you now, you know, since we have done that, there are many other people doing it and saying, Hey, the guy took the pain and now we're following on. So, um, so, so now what, you know, what we, you know, what, what we're much more focused on now is not just the deployment of the platform to run AI applications, but actually it's developing the products, the end user solutions for, um, uh, for, for our customers. So our customers, you know, with naval, naval services and things like that for, um, for maritime security. So that's, that's where our focus is going now.

Jeremy Gilbertson So is that moving towards like, all right, so we have the ability to have AI processing on satellites in space. Um, and now it's like, okay, what are, what are some of these use cases and how can you make the, the, the user experience easier, the app or some kind of delivery of that service to these folks? Is that, is that what I'm hearing?

Fintan Buckley Yeah, that's, that's exactly right. And it's, it's, uh, I wouldn't call it an app. It's more, um, um, a, a service, right? So it's, it's the ability to, to provide, um, information. And I think you said it yourself earlier on, Jeremy, it's, we don't want images. We don't want big reports. We actually want information that we consume and we want it when we need it. And, and so the, so the services that we're envisaging is been able to, to monitor particular areas of the earth on a continuous basis. Knowing, using the onboard AI, when an event come, occurs, right? And then on ground mining, you know, all of the, the, the, uh, traditional databases of EO data and, uh, to provide a, a narrative, a history of what happened up to that point.

Fintan Buckley And then using the, uh, the, the satellites on orbit to then provide the ongoing monitoring once that event has been triggered. That's the, that's the service that we are offering, that we are building to offer, I should say.

The service: watching one area continuously

Mark Fielding Well, with the naval, with the, the, the national water security, I can envisage that surface. I can see the boats on the ocean. I can see the real time information saying there is a dark ship here. There is an oil spill here. There is this here. You need to go here, here and here. I can visualize that and I can see that being an operation very quickly. When you were speaking earlier about the floods in Valencia, the wildfires in Los Angeles, especially the floods, and you were talking about kind of escape routes almost where the satellites can view what's happening in real time. And I was in my, in my silly head, imagining an almost like mission impossible scene where a, someone is on the streets in Valencia, the water's coming in and they're like, the satellite says, go left, go left. You go left. And they go, go straight on up here, up those steps right here. And describing that escape process almost. And that's a much further, a long way off compared to the service of, or is it not?

Fintan Buckley It's not, Mark. And it's actually one of the easier applications to, to, to, to implement in AI. It's, you know, the, you know, it's basically you're doing a before and after comparison, right, on, on your road networks within, within the city. So, uh, that is actually a fairly straightforward application. As long as you have, you know, you, you need your assets over the area at the time.

Mark Fielding That's where Jamie's friends Waze comes in. Maybe there's some kind of layer upon an app like Waze, which makes it accessible for these more human everyday use cases.

Jeremy Gilbertson That's, that's brilliant. You know where, you know, where you got me thinking in that regard. I don't know if you remember the show with, um, Todd Hazlehorse with HEAL, H-E-A-L-E. I do remember, yeah. Logistics. The final mile. They have a blockchain based logistics company where they, where they track things from source to final, final user. Right. And like this, this middle mile thing. Right. Um, that, that would seem like it could be an interesting application of like tying in, you know, some of these route optimizations or, you know, route optimizations based on weather, based on, you know, shipment and that sort of thing. Do you ever think about logistical cases as well?

Fintan Buckley Yeah. What we're really thinking about is, is, um, situations where it is, uh, hard to impossible to have ground-based monitoring. So, you know, when, you know, with, with, with vessels, you know, with, with, uh, with logistics, with containers, you can put trackers into containers. Right. And, and, you know, that's an easier solution than, than actually using, um, satellites for the observation. With us, it's more about, it's, it's the unexpected. Right. It's the, um, how do, how do I monitor my maritime? How do I, how do I react very quickly when, when there's a, a, a, a, a climate issue of some description? How do I react to that and get visibility and be able to make decisions?

Fintan Buckley And, and also it, it needs to, from a commercial perspective, it needs to be, you know, a, a, a, an application, a requirement where real-time information is a key. You know, there, there are lots of, um, uh, use cases for, for satellite data in the agricultural space. But in, in those scenarios, in, in, in many cases, the real-time element is not important. So if you're getting your data a day later, it actually doesn't matter. And then you, you know, you, you, you apply your ground processing and make your decision. So it's really about.

Jeremy Gilbertson You're saving your power. Yeah. Saving your power budget there too. Cause you don't need it.

Fintan Buckley That's exactly right. That's yeah. Yeah. That's, that's correct.

Can you predict a fire before it spreads?

Jeremy Gilbertson Let's go back to, let's go back to the wildfire piece. Cause I know that's a, I mean, it's, it's, it's just a problem that never goes away and it gets worse and it gets worse. And so, um, I don't, I don't know a lot about like the, the. What people track related to the potential or likelihood of a fire happening, but I get an analogy in my head, like what we do today for tornadoes. Right. And there are predictive things that weather can use for tornadoes. Okay. We're starting to see a little cycle happen. Here's a warning. Here's a potential likelihood. Are there some of those data points that you could monitor in real time in high fire, high wildfire areas that you could create these early alerts for that?

Fintan Buckley When we talk about the optical, uh, imagers, um, that, uh, that we would work with, they, they are, they're hyperspectral. Okay. So you have multiple, um, wave bands that you can, you can analyze, use to analyze the situation. I mean, typically we use the RGMB because they're the optical ones. They're the ones that we humans can see. So your question is, can you, can you analyze weather conditions to, uh, to predict events beforehand? Possibly. Right. But I would suspect that, that the, the modeling that's done by meteorological services on ground is probably much more efficient at doing this. You know, going, going back to, you know, the, the, uh, the wildfires, the Pasadena wildfires.

Fintan Buckley Um, and forgive me my harping on this, but, you know, I know the area, but, um, you know, I was sitting at home on my, on my couch and, and my sister WhatsAppped me. She said, just to let you know, I'm leaving the house. There's an evacuation order. The people on the ground, she had no idea how serious the situation was. But if you observed it from, from a satellite, you could see, right, in time shift, how quickly this fire was moving and how dangerous the situation was. And that's where satellite imagery, EO data and applying AI onboard the satellite to get the insight down to ground as quickly as possible. That's where the real benefit is. And even, you know, another minor case when, when people were evacuating, um, uh, from the Palisades, because, you know, it's, uh, it's not your typical area of Los Angeles.

Fintan Buckley It's not a freeways going through the middle of it. It's, you know, it's, it's small streets and, and traffic was getting backlogged and stuck because you had so much traffic, too many cars trying to get out of the area at the same time. A satellite overlooking that, right, could actually help to, to route the traffic out of the area rather than people getting stuck and, and, and gridlock or whatever. So, so these are all of these things that you can do if you have the satellites on, uh, on orbit, looking, uh, looking at the scene.

Connecting the dots, and the last mile

Mark Fielding On that, maybe we talk about connecting the dots and holistic approaches to technology here and how technologies can work together to solve a problem. And perhaps AI on its own, isn't specifically for wildfires, the solution, rather than that top down, you have that bottom up where there's some kind of infrastructure on the ground where people. If we've spoken about this in quantum season, about posting on social media, maybe there's these patterns that emerge in the data of social media or the texting or the WhatsApp or information about, you know, sort of changes in the pressure, changes in the wind, changes in.

Mark Fielding Certain aspects of nature, which kind of then a quantum computer picks up on and feeds it to the AI and the satellites and the satellites come over and they do that imagery testing. And then a bit like the dishes, then you have that last kind of mile problem where getting the information to the people on the ground who are in danger.

Fintan Buckley Yeah, I mean, that's, that's the, uh, the ISL link. So you're, you're tapping into your starlings and your, your, um, uh, your, your Kuiper networks, right. To get the information down through essentially the internet down to the end user as quickly as possible. I mean, you, you're not broadcasting this information, but you're getting it to the first responders. Right. And then they decide what they're doing with this information. You know, you don't want this going to everyone's phone saying turn left at the street, you know, at the end of the street. You don't want to instill panic in the ground population. Yeah, exactly. That's exactly right. Yeah.

Jeremy Gilbertson Fenton, that that's been a theme on this show for since we, since Mark and I started since episode one, just this balance between hierarchical systems and emergent systems, top down, bottom up, and like where the successful handoffs come into this. And I think solving that, or at least trying to figure out how that is incorporated is probably going to be a big thing in, in what you do and how you apply some of this stuff.

Taking the human out of the loop, and putting them back

Fintan Buckley A lot of what we're doing is trying to take the human out of the loop, particularly with the dynamic tasking and the observing strategies, but at the end of the day, we always do need the human in the loop, you know, and I know we're in this, you know, era of mass deployment of AI, questions over AI. I personally think we always need the human in the loop somewhere.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, we're saving the human. The human's at the end being saved. That's the part they pay is the unwilling or willing victim or savior. Again, a massive, massive theme, Fenton, we actually broke down I don't know, I'm not sure if you've ever read Paki McCormick's not boring newsletter, we broke down his call to humanity, related to AI and how you could prepare yourself for the AI revolution. It was a great breakdown that we got involved with. And then we talked about your thoughts are completely aligned with our we call it our host, and author of our book club, Noah, Yuval Harari, as we talk about sapiens and this idea of keeping keeping humans in the loop. But Mark, I think it's time for hot buttons.

Hot buttons

Mark Fielding Yeah, let's do the hot buttons. So this is the five questions, 30 seconds, system one thinking there's no wrong answer. We just have to finish the five questions in 30 seconds. Have you got that clock? Can I see the clock? Star Wars or Star Trek?

Fintan Buckley Wars.

Mark Fielding Is Elon going to Mars? Yes or no?

Fintan Buckley No.

Mark Fielding Crop circles, aliens or farmers?

Fintan Buckley Farmers.

Mark Fielding What's the best book on technology, fiction or nonfiction?

Fintan Buckley Sold a new machine.

Mark Fielding When you look up at the sky, what one word describes how you feel?

Fintan Buckley Wonder.

On wonder, and being bored

Jeremy Gilbertson Let's talk about wonder. We are deficient in our sense of wonder. Whenever a question is asked, we go right to our phone, right to our computer and get the answer. Sure. That makes sense if we want to know how quickly, how long the drive is going to take from Atlanta to Charlotte, what time the next movie is. But man, how can we enable wonder in people? What do we do with that? I know it's a bigger question, but how would you enable wonder in anyone you're talking to?

Fintan Buckley I think my generation is responsible for this. I think our technology, which we have developed over the past 40 years has actually caused us not to think, not to have quiet time, not to have downtime. And I think that's a problem. Do nothing. Sit on a chair and and just ponder and think. And I think that's a problem. And I'm guilty of it myself. If I have two seconds, take out the phone and look. And I think it's a problem. Social media, which I shy away from, I think is a real problem because it just occupies the mind. And sometimes we just need to sit and think. So how do you inspire that? I don't know. Take away the phones, shut off the internet for an hour every night, maybe something like that.

Mark Fielding Don't be bored. Whatever you do, don't be bored. Don't be bored.

Jeremy Gilbertson Well, great. Thanks for entertaining that question. I've just been thinking about it a lot and the sense of wonder and that sort of thing. All right. So next we are on to thinking on paper news. A couple of things that have been in the news lately that we've been talking about a little bit ourselves. Would love to get your thoughts on. The first thing I've been tracking for quite a while, but there's a lot of news out there about the potentially crowded nature of lower earth orbit. And that there are even technologies out there that people are designing to help remove space junk. Like how big of a concern is the congestion of lower earth orbit at the moment based on what you know?

Is low Earth orbit getting too crowded?

Mark Fielding Got some numbers for you there, which might not be in date. Starlink, November 2024 had 6,676 satellites up there. The Space Development Agency, 200. Amazon Kuiper Systems, 3000. You've got the small satellites market, India, China. There's a lot up there.

Fintan Buckley Yeah, I think what we need to think about, particularly in the low earth orbit, is that all of these assets have a finite life cycle, right? Three to five years. So I personally don't think the problem is going to be the number of operational assets, but it's what happens to those assets when they are no longer operational. And that is a big threat. So how are they de-orbited or how are they retrieved from the low orbit? And there are companies that are, and this is, you asked me, Star Wars or Star Trek. One of the things that really maybe stop back and say, wow, this is an amazing time that we're in in the space industry. When you have companies talking about developing space tugs, refueling, re-orbiting, all of this technology.

Fintan Buckley So in your mind, you can see in 10, 20 years, space is going to be just like a harbor, just going to be like San Pedro in Los Angeles or whatever, that you are going to be managing all of the assets that are in space. So I'm not overly concerned at this point. But I think it's what do you do when the assets are decommissioned is a bigger issue as far as from what I can see.

Jeremy Gilbertson So this again, I'm going to sprinkle up in a couple of things that I've read over time that are very pertinent to this discussion. If anyone's interested in space and how things are progressing in space, there was a book written a long time ago called The High Frontier in the seventies that Gerard O'Neill, I think, or Gerald O'Neill. And it was a plan to basically build human colonies in lower earth orbit. Fascinating, approved by NASA. NASA was like, yeah, this sounds great. No one ever funded it. It was possible, but no one ever funded it. But that's a great book. And I've got a free business idea brought to you by Thinking on Paper, brought to you by The Power of Three, Disruptors and Curious Minds.

Deorbiting, servicing and dead satellites

Jeremy Gilbertson So if we need to figure out how to deorbit some of this stuff, we need to build satellites that over three to five years start to just fizzle away, just kind of like that spy message. Hey, this message will self-destruct in 30 seconds. This satellite will self-destruct over the next five years.

Mark Fielding But isn't the problem that even microparticles are a hazard? So you don't need to, you need it to really come down in one piece. Can they not be just fueled? They run out of fuel or run out of energy and whatever, and then just fall to earth and burn up?

Fintan Buckley Well, I think the biggest problem is the batteries, right, that you can't recharge them. I think that's the problem. But actually, I think it's not about how we destroy them. I think we have to be thinking about reuse, right? So it's servicing of these things. You know, I saw something recently about one of NASA's long-range missions that's gone out to outer space. I can't remember which one it was, but they talked about the redundancy and resilience they built into the satellite. So they had failbacks and failbacks, because they couldn't predict what was going to happen over the lifetime of the satellite. It turned out they didn't need the redundancy in the system, because the systems and the design worked really well. So you have these satellites. They're designed to last, right?

Fintan Buckley Why not just service them and keep them going again? And I think that's the way we should be going, rather than thinking about the deorbiting and destruction of them. Because the biggest costs and the biggest impact to earth is actually getting the things up there, right? So once they're up there, let's use them for a long time.

Mark Fielding Just on that, how much is that coming down in price, getting them up there?

Fintan Buckley I think you'd want to ask Elon Musk that. I think SpaceX have really got this down to a T.

Mark Fielding Do you know him? Can you put us in contact?

Fintan Buckley No, I do not. I do not know him.

Jeremy Gilbertson But it is relatively cheap compared to where it's been, right?

Fintan Buckley It is cheap to put them up, but it's the environmental cost of putting them up as well.

When Google changed its AI principles

Jeremy Gilbertson Let's transition from the hardware perspective back to the software perspective. So in talking about AI, another thing that's been in the news quite a bit, and Mark and I've been unpacking and talking about a lot, Google AI has changed their principles. And some of the things that have come out of their documents without a lot of notice have come out of their documents stating that use for surveillance, use for wartime stuff, use for things not great for humanity are now suddenly out of the principles. But as Mark highlights every time we talk about this, they still have the pretty butterflies on the document and everything looks great. What do you think the implications of changing philosophies like that this early on in the game?

Fintan Buckley It is a conundrum. And we have, even though we're a small company, we have had to ask ourselves the same questions. What if someone came to us and said, we want to use your technology in an offensive military scenario? And we have made the decision that that would not be something we would be willing to support. Having said that, I think it is easy for us being a small company in a neutral country, right, which historically has never gone to war, has never been aggressive to take this stance. I think it's much harder for larger countries to take that stance. And we know if you're operating, so for Alphabet headquartered in the US, the priorities are different. And I could not criticize or condone decisions that are made by other companies in other countries. There are lots of factors at play. So that's a long winded way of saying, I actually don't want to comment on this.

Mark Fielding Jeremy, a question for tomorrow's book club, where we are talking about democracy and AI, part nine of Nexus. And that's a very interesting point, that how does the history of a country dictate what it will do going forward? And I think that's very interesting, because the historic and geopolitical history of a country will influence their philosophy, their ethics, their principles on what happens next. So yeah, we'll talk about it more tomorrow.

Jeremy Gilbertson Absolutely. And Fenton, I think you answer that question actually really well and generated a new perspective in my mind on it, because you go back to like Cold War, right, US and USSR, right? And everyone's like, oh, we're there building this, we got to build this, and we got to build this, and we got to build this. And there was a real kind of fear back in the day of that kind of stuff. So staying on top of certain things can kind of make a bit of sense. It does scare me when things get yanked out of that. But there's always the other perspective that I don't see. I'm not the chief guy making sure the US is safe every day, right? So I appreciate that perspective.

Fintan Buckley But also, the opposite concern is also there that we're in this agentic world, right, where you have, you know, AI agents, right, generating code and generating other agents. So, you know, we are getting very close to it feels like the point where machines are going to be doing things, and we don't know why they're doing them. You know, we already have this problem with models, but trusted AI, but now you layer on top of this models, making more models, right? You know, it's a concern.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, that Russian doll of AI agents teaching other AI agents what to be, what they should be doing, what their incentives are, what they're like, what they're aligned to do. Yeah. Like, it's going to be really tough to find the audit trail on that, I think. And then will you believe the audit trail? Right? Exactly right. Yeah.

Jeremy Gilbertson So again, we keep pointing back to this book that we're unpacking, Nexus, and it talks exactly about some of those things that are just really, really interesting in the financial system. Think about the financial system, like we don't, like a small percentage of the world knows how the financial system like really works. That's why we got into trouble in, you know, the financial crisis recently and that sort of thing. But what about when like agents upon agents are creating things financially that we can't even begin to understand? So that's like, we could sit here and talk for hours about all this stuff. It's super intelligent. They'll be building satellites.

Can a satellite really read a piece of paper?

Mark Fielding Can I just bring it back to satellites to with a soft, silly question. When you're watching James Bond and the satellites, they're moving the satellites from MI6 headquarters in London, and they move the satellite and they zoom in on some guy who's carrying a map on a phone in Lisbon, and they go right down and they can read it on his in his hand. When you watch those kind of films, do you think, oh, that's really realistic? Or do you think that's completely impossible? And this is just make believe, like how accurate are they in terms of what satellites can do today?

Fintan Buckley If you'd asked me that question 10 years ago, I would have said it's pure fiction. The capabilities of the satellites today is impressive and getting more impressive. And there's two elements to this.

Mark Fielding Could they read that from space? Just for our listeners who aren't watching, I'm holding a piece of paper with some words which are written in maybe font 12 or 13 on a computer for your reference.

Fintan Buckley Maybe. Because you have two different sectors in the earth observation. You have the military sector and you have the commercial sector. You actually don't know what the military sector is capable of doing. So when I say maybe, if not, it's pretty close. The satellites that we were working on right now couldn't read that. We would have a resolution of about five meters. So each pixel would be the equivalent of five meters. But we're getting to the one meter and less. So it's coming in the commercial space. It may already be there in the military.

Jeremy Gilbertson Point back, Fenton, like what you guys are looking at and what you guys are trying to do with live earth intelligence. I mean, I think that's really a compelling thing, right? Especially if we want to solve these big problems, we need to get the information. We need to get the information when it's usable, not when it's old, and apply it to things that we can make quick decisions about in real time. So Fenton, I want to hit on that. I think what you guys are leaning into is really, really cool. Mark, let's hit the carryover question. And then Fenton, if you could leave us a question and we'll try and land this satellite.

How should we think about data in a thousand years?

Mark Fielding Yep. So the carryover question from our last guest is a nice, easy one for you, Fenton. It is, how should we be thinking about data today so that it is still private in a thousand years' time?

Fintan Buckley I think we shouldn't be thinking at all, because I'm not sure it's going to be relevant at all in a thousand years' time. So don't worry about it. It's of no relevance.

Mark Fielding Why not? Because data won't exist or we'll all be dead or another reason?

Fintan Buckley I'm not sure it would be of any relevance and any interest to us. You think about how the world has changed in the last thousand years. Go back a thousand years. Is there any data that would be relevant to us now, except for historical? It would be nice to know. But actually, do we need it? No. It's not something I would lose sleep over.

Jeremy Gilbertson So in a thousand years, Mark, maybe we move to an omnipresent super intelligence that we're all real-time connected to, and we don't need to store anything anywhere. It's just always everywhere. That's what we call a pregnant pause, Disruptors and Curious Minds. All right. So carryover question for you, Fintan. Anything you're thinking about? It could be on any, like we talked about, anything from surfing to what pasta you prefer to technology to something you read yesterday that's puzzling you.

Fintan Buckley Since my head is thinking technology, I would like to ask the next contributor, what do they think is the next invention that's going to impact our lives as much as the mobile phone?

Mark Fielding For all our listeners and our next guest, maybe nothing.

Jeremy Gilbertson Fintan, thank you so much for joining us today. I think we have some great insights as to what you're building, and we'd love you to stay in touch with us and keep us posted as you're building these solutions for these different industries using the technology that you've already proven. Stay in touch.

Fintan Buckley It's been great chatting with you.

Mark Fielding It has. Thank you. And for all our listeners, stay tuned because we're moving into Star Trek season. We will be interviewing and speaking to more people, building more interesting things in space. So stay tuned to ThinkingOnPaper.xyz to learn about all of those. Sign up.

Backstage: what we learned

Jeremy Gilbertson Friends and neighbors, we are now backstage. We just had a conversation with Fintan Buckley, with Ubotica, talking about real-time data processing, image processing from satellites to enable better decision-making, quicker decision-making, being able to tackle really tough problems that have a lot of data points. And we as humans struggle with things that have multiple interdependencies, right? That's what I think AI can do better than we can, is pull all of these things together. That's how the computer that beat the best Go player in the world figured out something crazy outside of the pattern of what we think, right? So Mark, first takeaways, first impressions. What did you learn today that you didn't know about before we got here?

Mark Fielding I have to tell you about my holiday last year in order to get to that point, because last year I was on holiday in the south of France, watching shooting stars with my daughter and my brother. And at about 10 o'clock, half 10 at night, the sky went a bit like the blue of my background. There was a streak of blue indigo bright light that shot across the sky. And for a moment, we thought they were here, they've come. Finally, it was very eerie, very strange, very unexpected. Obviously, we very quickly worked out that it was Starlink deploying satellites into low Earth orbit. And I went on the internet and found out how many hundreds had just been deployed. And that's what it was just passing overhead. And ever since we saw those, I've been eager to have a satellite expert on the show to tell us. Honestly, what did I learn?

Mark Fielding Beyond the technicalities of it, I learned to remember about the positive, optimistic side of what is possible with artificial intelligence. As I said during the show, after eight months and eight episodes of the Nexus, to think about AI being used for disaster response, we've all seen the fires, that helping people on the ground for when an oil spill might happen, like getting people there because they know about it, because the satellites and the AI have worked together to know it. Maritime safety, urban planning, like the positive things, the life changing civilization, extending humanity, whatever that word is, the kind of hope of the technology. So that's what I learned. I learned to remember.

Jeremy Gilbertson That's great. That's great. And I think about it, if you've ever written a song before... That's great. No, it is. I think it's great. So if you've ever written a song before, and I've written many, many bad songs. And writing a sad song, writing a darker song is easier than writing a happy song. And we really think about this, like a lot of the magnetism for discussion points related to AI, it's easy to think about all the scary stuff. It's easy to think about like, oh man, what if this stuff gets in the wrong hands? What happens? But it's really cool to highlight people thinking about this differently and applying the technology to change the world, right? To be able to enable this real time data, right? And turn it into information and keep humans in the loop, to use that information to make good decisions.

Mark Fielding That real time Earth intelligence was something that was important. Maybe I knew that cloud cover is very detrimental to the flow of information between satellites and Earth, taking it, you know, if it's a cloudy day, two days, but maybe with this real time Earth intelligence with AI analyzing the photographs up there, saving days. I didn't know that. So it was good to learn the importance of real time satellite imagery and what it can do and how it can change.

Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, and taking it into, so you don't lose power, you don't lose like your power budget, like you talk about, you don't waste time, you don't waste energy and resources by pointing a satellite to clouds, you know, when you can't see through it, knowing that the imaging you're gonna get is not good. It would be great if we could apply something like that to how our discussions and our conversations go. If we see us going on a ramble zone, if only if AI could redirect us, right?

Mark Fielding I've got a question for you, which I'd like to introduce into these post-show VIP. We maybe get a beer and we ask, what would you like to have asked Fintan now that we didn't ask? Is there any questions that immediately spring to mind? We should have asked him that, because it'd be nice to know.

Jeremy Gilbertson The only thing that was swirling around in my brain, and I knew it would be super like wrong side rabbit hole is all I can think about is, you know, this, this idea of the satellites pointing to earth and, you know, live earth intelligence. What would happen if we just went and turned them around the other way? And has anyone done that? Has anyone applied that to astronomy, astrophysics, all of that kind of stuff? I'm sure they have, but it would be really interesting just to shift that perspective outward instead of inward towards us.

Mark Fielding Space telescopes. Optimization of space telescopes, maybe, right? Optimization of that stuff. I'm sure somebody has thought of pretty much everything that they could do. I wanted to ask how thick the lower earth orbit was. I wanted to know like how much space all these satellites are playing in. I don't think it's very much space, but I wanted to know that.

Jeremy Gilbertson And we just have to wonder about it, Mark.

Mark Fielding Yeah, I will wonder with awe.

Jeremy Gilbertson Wonder and awe. Take it for a walk. Well, awesome. Well, there you have it, friends and neighbors. This is a, this has been another episode of Thinking on Paper. My name's Jeremy. Mark is with me as always. We're backstage post talking to Fintan Buckley from Eubotica. It's been a great conversation. We're staying in the space realm. I'm looking forward to finding more space people to talk to. If you know space people, drop us a note. Hello at thinkingonpaper.xyz. Check out all of our stuff on our website. We have podcast versions of this. We have YouTube versions of this. If you prefer seeing our faces or you just want to hear us. So this is about you, not about us. Let us know how we're doing. Send us a note. Tell us what you want to see changed. Do you like the hot buttons? Do you like the news section? Do you like this post game report? Let us know. This is about you, not about us. Stay disruptive. Be curious. Keep thinking on paper.