What Makes a Good Question?

Pia Lauritzen has analysed more than 30,000 questions, and her advice for opening a conversation is to skip the question. Commenting on your surroundings is actually typically way better conversation starters than asking a question, because then you have a shared moment.

Clips and outtakes on Instagram ›

In this episode · 14 chapters

  1. Different ways of asking
  2. Questions are powerful
  3. The serpent
  4. Kids ask why
  5. Admitting we do not know
  6. The big question family
  7. A rhythm to questioning
  8. Some surprising tips
  9. What do you want to do when you grow up?
  10. Why we lead with polarisation
  11. The double-edged sword of AI
  12. Can you use AI to think better?
  13. Three things we need
  14. What could humans be?
But if you consult the old thinkers and not just the engineers and technologists, then you will have a really hard time finding anyone who would say that a machine could ever think. And if it cannot think itself, why should it be able to help us think?
Pia Lauritzen

Almost 80% of the questions Pia Lauritzen has collected start with what or how, and only about 6% ask why. She explains why the serpent's question in Eden shows that questions are never innocent, and how cultures use them to hand over responsibility.

She draws a hard line between prompting a machine and asking a question, and doubts AI can help anyone think better. Her reminder to herself, from her LinkedIn Learning course: “You can be the one who knows the least and learns the most.”

Pia Lauritzen, a philosopher of the question who has analysed more than 30,000 questions, explains on the Thinking On Paper podcast what makes a good question. She argues that questions are never innocent, since they carry power and hand responsibility to others, and that prompting AI is not asking, warning of “the risk that we confuse our own thinking with what a machine can do”.

What makes a good question?

Pia Lauritzen argues questions are never innocent: they carry power and hand responsibility to others. She also says prompting an AI is not the same as asking.

What is the what how bias in questions?

Lauritzen has found what she calls a “what how bias”: she says almost 80% of the questions she collected are what and how questions, and only about 6% are why questions. That matters, she argues, because why questions “do things to our thinking that no other kind of questions do”.

How do cultures use questions to shift responsibility?

Language cultures teach people to use questions to move responsibility in opposite directions, according to Lauritzen's postdoctoral research. English and Danish speakers ask to put the onus on the other person, she says, while Chinese children are taught that a teacher's question means the teacher already has the answer.

What was the first question in the Bible?

The first question in the Bible, Lauritzen says, belongs to the serpent: “did God really say that you cannot eat of any tree in this garden?” She uses it to show that a purposeful question creates “a very clear before and after”.

What is the best way to start a conversation?

Her advice for opening a conversation is to skip the question: “Commenting on your surroundings is actually typically way better conversation starters than asking a question, because then you have a shared moment.” She compares a good exchange to a dance, and a barrage of questions to an interrogation.

What is the difference between prompting and asking?

Prompting, in Lauritzen's definition, means adapting your question to what a machine can answer, whereas asking means you have no idea whether an answer exists. She reads Alan Turing's 1950 paper as designing a machine to deceive people into thinking it thinks, so the Turing test “was never about the machine, it's about us”.

Where Mark and Lauritzen disagree

Mark presses Lauritzen on whether AI can help anyone think better or more clearly, and she holds her position. Humans think, she says, because “There's a gap between what I know and what I want to know”, while a machine “doesn't know that it doesn't know”. Earlier she rejects Mark's premise that people lose the ability to ask good questions as they age: “I don't think we do. I don't agree.”

Questions

What makes a good question?

Pia Lauritzen argues questions are never innocent: they carry power and hand responsibility to others. She also says prompting an AI is not the same as asking.

Who is Pia Lauritzen?

Pia Lauritzen, a philosopher of the question who has analysed more than 30,000 questions, explains on the Thinking On Paper podcast what makes a good question.

Are questions ever innocent, according to Pia Lauritzen?

She argues that questions are never innocent, since they carry power and hand responsibility to others, and that prompting AI is not asking, warning of “the risk that we confuse our own thinking with what a machine can do”.

Do people lose the ability to ask good questions as they age?

Earlier she rejects Mark's premise that people lose the ability to ask good questions as they age: “I don't think we do. I don't agree.”

Transcript

Mark Fielding disruptors and curious minds. Quote, I have collected and analysed more than 30,000 questions asked by people from all over the world. That's what our guest does. She is an expert.

philosopher of the question. Welcome to the show, Pia Lauritzen, philosopher, TEDx talker, Forbes writer, LinkedIn learning author, thinkers, 50 Radar and AI philosopher. Welcome to Thinking on Paper. Thank you for thinking on paper with us.

Pia Lauritzen Thank you very much. It's a pleasure to be here.

Mark Fielding Could you categorize them into three, four, five different domains? Is there a way to think about 30,000 questions in a more digestible format?

Different ways of asking

Pia Lauritzen Yeah, so I started out by looking at different ways of...

kicking off a question. do we ask how or what or why, who, where and when, and fairly quickly identified what I call the what how bias. So almost 80 % of all the questions are what and how questions actually. And we only have about 6 % or something like that is why questions, which can be, it's a pity because why questions are pretty amazing. They do things to our thinking that no other kind of questions do. And then that was actually this finding of this how-what bias inspired me to do a postdoctoral study of how different language cultures teach us.

to understand and use questions. So I also found some patterns in how we use questions to distribute responsibility. Sometimes, or some people use questions to impose responsibility on others. That's what you do. So when you pose a question as English speaking people, also Danish speaking people like myself, it's to tell the other person, it's your turn. Now it's on you. You are responsible for coming up with an answer, to come up with a response.

while the Chinese children, they were taught the exact opposite. When the teacher asks a question, it's to tell the students that now I know, now I'm going to tell you I have the answer and I'm just testing if you know the same thing I know. So it's the exact opposite, using questions to take responsibility. So yes, I found some interesting patterns, both in terms of what we ask and how we ask and why we ask.

Jeremy Gilbertson the idea of questions being something that can be dividing and how questions can actually be something that connect people. Can you explain the difference between that?

Questions are powerful

Pia Lauritzen yeah, so I realized that questions are extremely powerful and we tend to forget that. Especially that we have, you know, sayings like, I'm just asking or, well, you can just ask, everybody is allowed to ask a question or we have these ways of thinking and talking about questions as if they are innocent and they're not. I actually tried at some point, I turned...

Because as a philosopher, if there's no data and typically there isn't when it comes to philosophical questions, you have to do something else. what we typically do is turn to old myths or old stories. So I turned to the Bible and looking for the very first question to figure out who actually did ask the first question in the history of humanity. If we just look at the Bible. And I don't know, do you know who it was who asked the first question?

The serpent

Mark Fielding it Eve saying why can't I pick the... ⁓ no, that's the New Testament. Old Testament, I don't know. Cain.

Pia Lauritzen So ⁓ it was the serpent asking, did God really say that you cannot eat of any tree in this garden? And then, of course, Eve started asking questions. But the very first question was the serpent. And for me, it's a brilliant example of how questions are not innocent. In fact, they are the exact opposite. When we ask a question, at least if we ask a question that really has some intention or purpose or direction in it, then there is a very clear before and after. So in this case it's the fall, right? Before we were in the Garden of Eden and after we were not and we have to die and all these crazy things that came with eating that apple. So it's an example of how questions are anything but innocent and in fact they're very powerful and with great power typically comes a bright side and a dark side and the same is the case with questions. So the bright side is that when we ask questions we

We do it from an honest place. We do it to connect with each other. We do it to commit to shared purpose. We also do it to figure out our own way, to consider who am I, why am I here, where am I going, who should I join, all these basic questions about being human. So that's the bright side. The dark side is that we can also use questions to manipulate, to...

to get people to think the same way we are thinking, to disguise that I want you to do something and I don't want to ask you directly because you probably say no, but I can do this in a way so you will not notice or they can be used to divide people to say, okay, every time you ask a question, there's a potential yes or no in the same way there's a me and you and us and them. And so we can actually use questions to the exact opposite. Instead of connecting, it's disconnecting. And instead of committing, it's polarizing and making it difficult for us to solve problems together. So that's my research really ⁓ falling in love with this magnificent power of questions for good and for bad and understanding how we need to pay more attention to questions.

Of course, that's what a lot of people asking whether or not machines can think. But if you look into Alan Turing's imitation game, you will also find that it's a lot about asking and answering questions. And we also know that we asked the chat about a question and comes up with an answer. So there's a lot going on with this thinking responsibility, being human, thinking like a machine or being able to think as a machine, thinking like a human being. And it's all about questions and answers. And that's why I made the two by two to demonstrate that we can do a lot of good things and lot of harm by not understanding these basic structures that comes with questioning and answering and being man and being machine.

Kids ask why

Mark Fielding Kids ask why 300 times a day. They the archetypal question Why do we lose the ability to ask good questions the older we get?

Pia Lauritzen I don't think we do. I don't agree. know a lot of people are saying that, but I don't think we do. We don't lose the ability, but we realize that the consequence of questions not being innocent is that it comes with a responsibility. Asking a

Admitting we do not know

Pia Lauritzen And it's also when we ask a question, we admit it's not only acknowledging, it's also admitting that there's something we don't know. That's why we ask. So it's admitting ignorance. And that's not something that we are being.

We're not being promoted for being ignorant. not getting good grades for saying, don't know, please ask someone else. That's not how we ⁓ progress. That's not how we achieve things in school and in work life. So I think we just...

stop sharing the questions. It's not like we don't have the ability to ask them. When I give keynotes, I typically start out by inviting people to write down a question. I haven't said anything. I've just said, hi, nice to be here. I'm glad to be here. Nice to see you guys. I want to start by inviting you to write down a question. And it takes about a minute. Then everybody in an audience have written down a question. I don't tell them how, I don't tell them what to do. I don't even give them examples. I just say, I'm going to trust you to know how to write a question.

please write down a question. It needs to be relevant to why we're here today but it also needs to have some kind of importance to you. That's the only two rules. Everybody knows how to do that.

Mark Fielding so many forces pushing on my brain in that split second to come up with a question which I think is wise or funny or profound or relevant or Jeremy, what question did you have in your mind just when she asked?

Jeremy Gilbertson Why is the current system driving us to not want to ask questions because we're scared of looking like we don't know the answer? think that's where my head goes in a lot of this, think is there's a Tom Waits quote I reference a lot Tom Waits says, we're operating in a deficit of wonder. So how does wonder and curiosity come into the art of asking really good questions.

The big question family

Pia Lauritzen I actually like to talk about it as the big question family because we have these there are some things we automatically think when we talk about questions people say curiosity or creativity or you know these are the nice cousins in the family these are the ones we want to play with we want to sit next to at the family dinner but it's just as I mentioned before the bright and the dark side ⁓ doubt and skepticism

They are also part of the question family. And I think that is part of the reason why we get more careful not to ask questions all the time of all kinds of people, because we know that in addition to showing off our ignorance, we are putting some kind of pressure on the people we are asking. also referring back to this distribution of responsibility that I know that when you ask a question, the spotlight is on me.

and you know that I know that so we can set it up like this in a formal setting this is a podcast we agreed to do this you prepared some questions I prepared some answers now we're gonna do it but if you just met me you know some place and you started asking me all these questions then it would start looking like something else and that is an interrogation and that is you know when we want to hold someone responsible for something and that's not a nice situation to find yourself in on that you are a lawyer and and and this is your job so there are so many traditions and cultural dimensions to asking questions and because it's kind of a blind spot in our culture when we talk about questions it's like it's a tool for journalists or it's something that can be used to do a poll or to do a survey but we rarely talk about these cultural philosophical basic human existential and ethical dimensions of questions but they constantly have an impact on whether or not we ask and how

A rhythm to questioning

Jeremy Gilbertson Is there a rhythm or a cadence to questioning, kind of stepping in that leads us more to the questioning to connect versus the questioning to divide?

Pia Lauritzen I like to think about it as a dance, a conversation and a question and answer exchange as a dance, you know, I can take two step in my direction and my dancing partner will have to go back a few steps. But if I continue, then my dancing partner will kind of end up with his back against the wall, right? And that probably won't feel very nice. So I will have at some point step to the side or to go backwards myself in order to make the dance work. I also have to listen to the music, you know, that's the What is the what is the what's the word? You know, are we are we dancing? Is this a salsa or is this is jazz? What is it? What what is what are we supposed to do here? At least in the beginning of the conversation because if if I just ignore all these basic dancing lessons Then we won't get very far Then then we will you will find find an excuse to go somewhere else or to talk to the person on the other side of you. So I would have to play along with some of these basic rules and maybe at the end of the evening we realize that, okay, I probably asked 80 % of the questions. Is that a bad thing? Not necessarily, but it is a sign that I might want to, next time I join a conversation, make room for other people to ask their questions because the thing about questions is that

I ask you a question? I make it very hard for you to talk about something else. So if you have something on your mind or something you want to share, then it's actually pretty hard for you if I'm constantly bombarding you with questions. Again, then it's the interrogation format rather than the dance.

Mark Fielding Okay. Is that I have two left feet and we did a show last week on AI generated music. So as long as there is no AI generated music at this party and I can find somebody else to dance with who has two left feet, then the conversation and the questions will flow smoothly. You probably get asked this all the time, but could we spend just one minute giving some tangible advice to people like me who have two left feet?

Some surprising tips

Pia Lauritzen I think there are a few a bit surprising tips when it comes to thinking about questions and one is that you might...

don't want to start out by a question, start out asking a question because as I just mentioned it can feel a bit ⁓ overwhelming or uninteresting. So sometimes the people I know who are really really good at this, are not having left feet but are just you know natural born conversationalists and really everybody, whether it's kids or young people or old people, they just want to be around these guys. You probably know people like that too. And what I've noticed is that they're really good at not taking pressure out of the situation. So instead of, they rarely have these standard questions, especially when talking to young people, for instance, it's always the same. So how's school and how did you, are you still playing soccer?

⁓ and what about that friend what do you want to do exactly it's the exact we have it's like we have this list in our head and I know

What do you want to do when you grow up?

Jeremy Gilbertson What do you want to do? What do you want to do when you grow up?

Pia Lauritzen for a fact from a lot of young people that they hate this list. It's really annoying talking to someone because it does the exact opposite of what we want as adults. It doesn't show, care, I see ⁓ you, I want to know about you. It's not what it says. It says something along the lines of, now we are playing this role and when we're done, I will move on to talk to a real person, someone who's adult, someone whose interests I share. But these people who are really good at it, they typically talk about what they see. So it can be, you know, what we're eating at the moment. It can be a little funny thing happening, going as something that you can just comment on your surroundings. Commenting on your surroundings is actually typically way better conversation starters than asking a question, because then you have a shared moment. Then you have some you are establishing that we are both here right now.

It's as simple as that. We're both right here. We're not thinking about what we should say, what we should do, where we should go. We're just being right here right now and we're both supposed to tap in to this situation. So that's it. It's a bit, I don't think it's a tip people expect to get from a question ⁓ lover like myself, but it really truly works not to use questions as ⁓ a tool slash weapon to take over the conversation, but to that why the Brits always talk about the weather when they meet?

so, I think so. Yeah, because it works and then we'll see, know, depending on how people respond to that then maybe we can also talk about the bus being laid or, you know, we can take it different steps.

Jeremy Gilbertson It's almost like when people get together, you're trying to like, you're lobbing these things up to try to find the commonality. Like you're lobbing these things up and trying to see what tract you can land on with somebody. I think what's interesting to me is what you're talking about is creating a space, right? When we write and we're talking about thinking on paper, our thinking spaces, right? We create these thinking spaces that allow your brain to work in a really interesting way. Would you say there's a correlation to a conversation and a dialogue that is a space to explore like that? Is that the right way to look at it?

Pia Lauritzen Definitely, it's the exact same thing. It's exploring on paper, it's exploring my relationship with myself or with my own thinking or with what I'm...

who I am right now and in a conversation it's doing that in the company of another human being who are probably asking the same questions of themselves. So sometimes we're just trying too hard to look, as you said, to look for these commonalities when in fact they're right there because we are here right now in this place at this time.

So we already established that now we can just be here and see what happens. So it takes some trust in yourself and in the person sitting next to you. But that's also, I would say that's about it.

Why we lead with polarisation

Jeremy Gilbertson why do we lead conversations and interactions with such polarizing subjects like

Politics when we're talking about something I think that I to let me explain this a little bit and maybe the question will come out a little bit better But when you believe in something, right you subscribe to a belief It's no longer someone else's fact. It's yours and it's something I believe in I'm gonna defend with my ego, right? My ego is gonna come out and say hey, I believe in this thing. You're attacking this thing We're gonna we're not gonna be open. We're going down the path of division and not the path of connection. think politics is like such a big thing because any discourse or conversation in politics is someone asking a question, which is really not a question. They're just driving something that they can reload a response that they already have in their head and nobody gets anywhere. do you see the same thing? Do you get frustrated by the same thing? And how does your work flow into helping the world figure out how to not do that.

Pia Lauritzen I definitely see the same thing. I don't get frustrated, at least not as much as I used to. And I think it's just because I think I found a way to seek out ways to be around people where it doesn't happen as often, at least where something else can happen. And you just mentioned the LinkedIn learning course I did earlier this year, and it actually kicks out by saying, don't need to know best. You can be the one who knows the least and learns the most. And then elaborating by saying, this is a sentence that I say to myself. This is not something I want to teach. This is something I want to remind myself because it is so difficult for us to be the one who knows the least.

But when you think about it as that will probably be the one who learns the most, then it kind of shifts, right? Then it gets somewhere else. And I think there's just some domains where this will maybe never or at least later than everywhere else.

⁓ This will be something we will see in practice. Politics is one of them. Traditional ⁓ journalism also has some restraints and limitations. Law, for instance. But when and if we are going to talk about education, education is probably a place where this shift could happen and where it is happening right now. There's something going on.

because of the advent of AI, that could pave the way for us seeing a different pattern unfold. A pattern that has more to do with accepting, acknowledging, and admitting that we don't know, and we therefore have a lot to learn from each other, but also from just being human.

trying to accept this silence or this confusion, this frustration of not knowing how to ask a different question or not knowing how to take this in a different direction and just embracing that and say ⁓ now something is happening now there's a ⁓ small but significant sign that we are moving into fields that we haven't been in before and I want to grab that I want to go with that rather than hurrying back and saying back to back to where I feel safe and that's where I just pretend that I know a lot of things that I don't know ⁓ and another I get a lot of outcomes that I think I want but I actually don't know why I want them and I'm not sure they will they will be of help

Jeremy Gilbertson you talked not wanting to know not wanting to be the person who doesn't know the answer right and I think it's conditioned We are rewarded for coming up with the answer the fastest Remember, we're in a classroom someone asks a question. You're like, You want to answer that question the first you get rewarded for answering it first?

Jeremy Gilbertson if you don't answer it first, you're kind of in another pile. Is that a point of reinvention that we could explore that would be beneficial in the long run?

Pia Lauritzen that education and educators that their job is to pass on knowledge, their job is to know something that the students or the kids don't. It's the same with an expert when people say, we have this question expert here and then people expect me to know something about how to ask good questions or how to use questions for good or something like that. And the thing about questions is that it's the exact opposite. You cannot be a question expert because an expert is someone who knows something that other people

The whole idea about questions is that accepting that I'm the one who doesn't know. That's why I'm asking. ⁓ I'm the one who needs to learn, who needs to grow. And I think it's the same with teachers. Maybe their job was never to know something that the students didn't. Maybe their job was to...

Create a space, as we talked about, where students feel safe seeking out knowledge. Because if they don't feel safe seeking out knowledge, they will not learn what they're supposed to learn. They will not feel comfortable. They will not be able to survive and thrive as human beings in a changing environment, in a society with technology constantly changing all the rules and workplaces. they will not be able to navigate that. They will get anxious. They will feel lonely.

All these bad things will happen if we don't feel comfortable learning and growing. So maybe that was the job from the beginning. When we think about really cool teachers, the ones who really made a difference in our lives, we don't necessarily remember what they knew and what they were really good at, what their expertise was. We remember how they made us feel like someone who were worth spending time on, who was who was worth investing in. So I think the education system is facing an existential crisis. And the thing about existential crisis is that you have to re-ask some of the basic questions. Who am I as a human? Who am I as a scientist? Who am I as a teacher? And why? And that's basically thanks to AI, we are starting to ask these questions.

questions and we probably should have a long time ago but now we are and I think it's thanks to AI.

The double-edged sword of AI

Mark Fielding that double-edged sword of AI gives us the opportunity to realize that we are the least smart in a room, or it gives us the ability to try or prove that we are, in fact, the smartest person in any room. And how do you engage with it and use it and think about it so that you're using it for the first of those, not the latter?

And then to your second point about teachers, we all have one teacher that we remember and it's about how they made us feel,

Does that weaken the AI should be used in school argument? Because it doesn't matter if the bad teachers are using AI, they're still not going to have the impact that a good teacher without AI could have. It's another how question. Why should we be changing? Why should parents and teachers be changing how they think and use AI in the classroom?

Pia Lauritzen the way AI is being offered to us at the moment comes with a lot of ⁓ risk. Not only the risk that everybody's talking about, about data or about people using it for bad purposes or even super intelligence coming to wipe us all out. That's not the kind of risk I'm talking about it. It's the risk that we confuse our own thinking with what a machine can do. It's the risk of us. Basically technology is a medium, right? It's something that mediates and manipulates our relationship.

with it can be with our surroundings with the world you know the old technologies it was about ⁓ mediating and manipulating ⁓ nature so we could survive in nature social media for instance it's about mediating and manipulating our relationship with each other so that comes something in between as before you know when i not that's still the case but but when i'm with other people i look them in the eye there is nothing maybe that you know pair of glasses, but it's not like there's technology between us. I can touch them or, and we can look at each other. But with social media, it's not only the algorithm and the use of data. It's simply there's something in between me and you when we communicate that has its own life, so to speak. And with AI, there's technology between the relationship I have with myself.

So, so I, when I use, if I use a chat bot to think differently or to ⁓ write a paper or to ⁓ solve a task in some way, then I'm, and sometimes, you know, some people are even building AI with the assumption that.

AI can help us be better at thinking, that it can help us be better at critical thinking or ⁓ thinking in all kinds of ways. And that is putting technology, letting technology mediate and manipulate my relationship with myself, ⁓ my own thinking. And that is so easy to forget that technology is not, just as questions are not innocent, technology is definitely not.

innocent either. And if we just think of technology as something we use, then we forget that it has this impact on how we think and how we understand not only our surroundings but also each other and how we understand ourselves. So we start adapting to the technology. We even have a word like prompting. Prompting is something completely different than asking a question. Prompting is adapting your questions or your search to the machine. So you you are trying to figure out how can I give the machine this task? How can I give the machine this, ask the machine this question in a way that it will be able to answer? That's what prompting is about. Asking questions is the exact opposite. It's about asking questions that might not, where I don't, I have absolutely no idea whether there is an answer or what the answer is. I'm asking because I don't know, because I don't have any experience with these.

dealing with this, need someone else to help me understand this. So I'm not adapting because I don't know what I should adapt it to. I'm simply exploring and simply experimenting. if we are not aware of that, difference between prompting and asking, the difference between being born to think and being built to think, the difference between letting technology guide our questions and let our inner insecurity or uncertainty and the unknown guide our questions. If we're not aware of these differences, then we will not learn and grow as humans. Then we will become something else, which is really scary for me at least, because I see so much beauty in what happens when we do it ourselves,

Mark Fielding being aware enough though? Is being aware of these differences in of itself enough to use AI to think better or think more critically?

Can you use AI to think better?

Pia Lauritzen I don't think you can use AI for that. I think it's a mistake to think... No, no, no, I don't think so. Because thinking is something else. know, when we ask if machines can think, I think the first question should be, why do humans think? Why do we think?

Mark Fielding You don't think can use AI to think better or clearer at all?

Pia Lauritzen ⁓ For me, it's fairly simple. We think because we know there's something we don't know. We have a problem, right? There's a gap. There's a gap between what I know and what I want to know. So I have to start thinking. That's why I ask these questions and that's why I put up with this pain in my head of trying to figure something out that I don't know. If you think about it, the machine doesn't have that problem.

It doesn't know that it doesn't know. It's kind of like it's like an animal, right? It doesn't know that it doesn't know. It doesn't even know. So and we're not like gods, know, gods know that he knows or she knows everything. So that's a completely different domain. But humans are the only the French philosopher, Merleau-Ponty said this fragile mixture of animals and gods who knows that they don't know. So they have to ask questions. They have to use their own thinking, come up with their own ways of navigating.

and the second we think ⁓ but I can make it easier by using a machine we're letting go of the very basic condition that forces us to think so I think it's very when I talk to young people in the sample I don't I don't use chat to cheat or anything I just when I get a task I'm not sure how to start I just you know ask the machine and then it gives me a few starting points so I don't have this black you know this blank sheet

But the whole point is that the blank sheet is what forces you to think. So of course it's a matter of how you understand thinking. But if you consult the old thinkers and not just the engineers and technologists, then you will have a really hard time finding anyone who would say that a machine could ever think. And if it cannot think itself, why should it be able to help us think? We're the only ones who know how to do that.

Jeremy Gilbertson so something that seems like it can think for us. Let's, let's think about that just for, for a minute. what happens down the road with that is, is we get used to doing that. We forget how to do the hard part of that first part of thinking where it's like blank page. What do I do? How do I do it? Why do I do it? we're going to kind of lose that muscle.

we as humans keep that muscle going while leveraging the technology as a support mechanism, as an adjunct?

Three things we need

Pia Lauritzen I think we need three things basically. We need to understand technology. And when I say technology, very concretely mean what Martin Heidegger, the German philosopher called the essence of technology. understanding what if we don't assume that technology is just made for us to use but it actually the second it's here it has an essence of itself it has its own purpose so to speak and it can be a concrete purpose like I'm a hammer use me for hammering but it can also it's also a more basic something that's true for all technologies which is that

It comes with the promise of human beings being better off using technology than not using technology. So it's a promise that you can achieve more by doing less if you use this technology. by with this promise, we automatically start asking a specific kind of questions. Like, what is it? How can I use it? What would it, how would it improve my ways of doing things? How will I, will I be faster? Will I be better at doing some things? These are the kind of questions we ask when we're given this promise of achieving more by doing less. But what we tend to forget is that at the same time, we forget to ask questions like, why would I need technology for this? For instance, when it comes to thinking or it comes to human connection, why would we need technology for that? Couldn't I just reach out? Couldn't I just, you know, when I meet someone at the street, say, hello, what a lovely day and try to strike up a conversation, you know, this kind of this idea that we need technology to connect with each other because we need to be connected across the globe and we need to be connected you know on a large scale which has proven we're not very good at that we are not very good at connecting on a large scale but we have really good at connecting on a very small scale so why would I need technology how does this technology impact my way of living my way of feeling like a human being or or even questions like what will I stop doing when I start using this technology? Is this something that's important for me that I will no longer be doing because now I will spend my day using this technology, whether it's playing a computer game or it's being on TikTok or whatever. So what will I stop do? And I think it's very important for us to understand that this is not something that comes from Mark Zuckerberg or Elon Musk or Sam Altman. This is not about evil people in Silicon Valley designing technology.

something that has to do with this, it has to do with that, but that's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about the basic essence of technology that comes with this promise that makes it very difficult for us to ask a certain kind of questions. And that is the basic existential, ethical, epistemological questions about who we are, why we're here, what we want to do, and how do we know the difference between truth and false and right and wrong and what's worth and not worth spending our time on.

So we need some basic education into that understanding the essence of technology. And that also comes with understanding the essence of AI, because we live in the technological era we live in is about AI. So we also need to understand the basic essence of AI. And I went to Alan Turing to understand that because I thought he was, you know, the founding father of AI, who better to consult in understanding these basic things. And he himself started out by saying, I'm not going to discuss the question can machines think because I consider it too meaningless to deserve discussion. But then he said, we will within a few years start to think and talk about machines as if they are thinking. That will happen. And the reason that will happen is because we will design this machine to deceive us. That's the whole point. From the very beginning, 1950 in his paper, the machine is designed to deceive human beings into thinking that it is thinking. So what's happening right now is just that we're being fooled. We are the ones that's put on a test. It's not the machines, we talk about the Turing test, but it was never about the machine, it's about us. Can we pass the test of not thinking that the machine is thinking?

and hold on to this basic distinction between being born to think and being built to think. Being born to think means that there are so many things we don't need to learn. We don't need to be programmed. We don't need to be taught. We just know it because we were born into this world. We see it from within. We know how the world works because we work the same way. You know, we get old, we get tired, we get hungry, we get, you know, the trees are changing throughout the year. So are we. And at some point we won't be here anymore. Sustainable, all these things has to do with we don't need to be taught it we know the machine is just never gonna get there so it's so important that we understand this the essence of technology and just as important is that we understand ourselves

And we have not invested trillion of investor dollars in understanding the human being for the past 75 years. We've been investing in developing AI, but we have not been investing in understanding ourselves. I think the good news is that it doesn't take that much for us to remember.

Because we were born to know these things. We were born to navigate these difficulties, to navigate uncertainty. That's in our DNA because we were born without knowing why and for how long. So that's just, that's the name of the game. We know we will need to figure out and we've been dealing with deception forever. know, Plato wrote about it in his allegory of the cave. Descartes wrote about it when he talked about the evil deceiver. You know, we've been dealing with these problems forever. We know how to navigate.

a world that is uncertain. ⁓ So I'm not that afraid. And the good news is that AI has made us ask a of questions.

Mark Fielding I want to leave with one final question, Pia we end all our shows with this question. What should humans be? And I'm scared to add the caveat here, and how does technology help us get there?

Pia Lauritzen Yeah, so that's just the thing, right? When it comes to being human, there's no should. We were not born with a purpose or a clear goal that we were supposed to achieve. ⁓ We were supposed to figure out along the way. So there is no should.

What could humans be?

Mark Fielding what could humans be?

Pia Lauritzen Well, human beings are acknowledging that we don't know.

That's the basic, that's the... And it sounds like something that's bad, but it's not. It's the core, it's the key driver, it's what sets us apart, that we know that we don't know. So we just keep on searching and we will always have more questions than answers. And that's the good news. So every time a technologist say, well, we will solve all the problems, super intelligence will save us, humanity will become better. It's just like...

Well, don't listen because that's not gonna happen and even if it was, then we would no longer be here. We would no longer be humans.

Mark Fielding Thank you. Great answer.

Jeremy Gilbertson That was awesome. That was awesome. Thanks so much for spending time with us. Pia, I hope you enjoyed it as well. We'll get some of this stuff carved up and sent out to you if you wanna use it for any of your promotional stuff. But I would love, love, love to stay in touch and keep tabs on your work and maybe we can, because I think we're on the same mission. We're on the same mission is how to keep humans human.

Jeremy Gilbertson and let them get back to the root of self-discovery, emergent nature, all of that fun stuff. So this was so fun. Thank you. Thank you for being here.

Pia Lauritzen Thank you so much, I really enjoyed it. See you guys!