How Does a Trapped-Ion Quantum Computer Work?
Coleman Collins explains that IonQ can entangle any two ions in its chain, whereas chip-based qubits are limited to what they are physically wired to. We don't have any wires. The lasers are the wires and the physics is the wires.
In this episode · 20 chapters
- What IonQ actually builds
- DiVincenzo's five criteria
- Cooling ions with lasers
- Explain it at the Christmas dinner table
- Why trapped ions
- Algorithmic qubits and physical qubits
- A tuned television, not a fuzzy screen
- Quantum volume, and what it doesn't tell you
- Logical qubits, and what they mean for real problems
- SDKs, and the common language problem
- Where the private investment goes
- Daisy
- Hot buttons
- Willow, and why Coleman picked it
- Microsoft's topological bet
- The garage in Palo Alto
- Qiskit, and getting started
- What commercial utility means
- When does quantum break Bitcoin?
- Backstage
One of the challenges of quantum computing is that you quite literally need to isolate the quantum state from the universe.
Coleman Collins is a director of product management at IonQ, which has been around since 2017 and makes trapped-ion quantum computers. He walks through David DiVincenzo's five criteria for a quantum computer and why IonQ uses atoms over fabricating things that act like atoms.
Collins explains what algorithmic qubits measure, why he picks Google's Willow over Microsoft's topological approach, and why he wants quantum computing to become boring. He also keeps expectations in check: “We're still trying to build vacuum tubes.”
Coleman Collins, a director of product management at IonQ, explains trapped ion quantum computing on the Thinking On Paper podcast, from lasers that act as wiring to IonQ's algorithmic qubit metric and Microsoft's topological qubit. He argues quantum computing succeeds when it becomes boring: when someone picks a quantum computer because it is the right tool, not because the technology is interesting.
How do lasers replace wiring in IonQ's computers?
Lasers replace wiring. Because IonQ steers laser beams along a chain of ions, he says it can entangle any two ions, whereas chip-based qubits can only link to the qubits they are physically wired to.
How does IonQ differ from D-Wave and IBM?
Mark asks how IonQ differs from D-Wave and IBM. Collins says a qubit can be built from photons, neutral atoms or superconducting circuits, and that IonQ uses single ions of ytterbium or barium addressed with lasers, betting on controlling qubits where superconducting companies focus on fabricating them. EeroQ takes another route, with single electrons floating on superfluid helium.
Why does IonQ build qubits from atoms?
IonQ uses atoms instead of building things that behave like atoms. Collins says trapped ions carry no fabrication errors because nature makes them, so the challenge is engineering, not new physics.
What is IonQ's algorithmic qubit metric?
Qubit counts say little on their own. IonQ's algorithmic qubit metric, built on industry benchmarks, tries to describe how many qubits are useful for real algorithms, which Collins compares to judging a TV by its pictures rather than by static.
How close is Microsoft's topological qubit?
Microsoft's topological qubit is a promising step with a long road behind it. Collins says Microsoft might now have one qubit where it had zero, that the jury is still out on the evidence, and that Google's Willow approach offers a shorter path.
Which quantum software kits does IonQ support?
IonQ backs every major software kit because no one yet knows which will win. Collins calls the approach strategically promiscuous, and says the field still lacks the layers that would let developers solve useful problems without writing raw quantum circuits.
Where Mark and Collins disagree
Mark reads out a claim that IonQ's Tempo system will reach quantum advantage and asks whether it holds. Collins says those results will come on demonstration systems, commercial availability will follow in 2026, and IonQ is not yet sure the advantage will be big enough to sell as a production service.
Links from this episode
Questions
How does a trapped-ion quantum computer work?
Lasers replace wiring. Because IonQ steers laser beams along a chain of ions, he says it can entangle any two ions, whereas chip-based qubits can only link to the qubits they are physically wired to.
Who is Coleman Collins?
Coleman Collins is a director of product management at IonQ, which has been around since 2017 and makes trapped-ion quantum computers.
When does Collins say quantum computing will succeed?
He argues quantum computing succeeds when it becomes boring: when someone picks a quantum computer because it is the right tool, not because the technology is interesting.
When will IonQ's Tempo be commercially available?
Collins says those results will come on demonstration systems, commercial availability will follow in 2026, and IonQ is not yet sure the advantage will be big enough to sell as a production service.
Transcript
Jeremy Gilbertson Disruptors and curious minds welcome to another episode of thinking on paper where we actually Get you our curious mind listeners behind the scenes Backstage on some of the latest and greatest new technologies that are going to change the way we look at the world Why do we do it number one mark? And I would do it anyway if it was just he and I but we're doing it to offer you a path to see what's coming up What's going on in the future? And that's why we do it some of these will be a little more hard to listen to, maybe some technological bits and widgets kind of thrown at you, but they will always be interesting. They will always be impactful and get you using this thing right here. Mark Fielding, how are you today, man? What are we learning about?
Mark Fielding Yeah, think for yourself at thinking on paper. After a few weeks in space, we're going back down to the quantum realm today. Jeremy and our listeners are going to be learning about full stack quantum computing, application driven quantum, the difference between algorithmic qubits and physical qubits. I have something written on a piece of paper here called quantum imaginary time evolution algorithms.
might get into that. Whoa, don't go anywhere. We're talking to IonQ. Coleman Collins, he's a director of product management at IonQ. And Jeremy, I have my bell again, and this is more for me perhaps today, because if we start talking about sending our consciousness into the deepest, darkest depths of the universe, using superposition to time travel there, stop me, stop you. Let's stay in reality a little bit.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well, if I need to harness some sort of superposition so I could take control of your bell and ring it because I can't, you know, I can't do that. I don't have a bell on my side, but yes, let's do that.
Mark Fielding I'll both ring the bell and not ring the bell.
Jeremy Gilbertson Fair enough, fair enough. Is the cat alive or dead? All right, so without further ado, Coleman Collins will bring you on. Let's talk about IonQ. Let's talk about your approach and get into quantum.
Coleman Collins Sounds good. Sorry. Morning.
Mark Fielding It's okay. Just for our listeners, Coleman is joining us from the West Coast of America, so it's quite early for him. So maybe we should start off a little bit easily this morning, Jeremy. And what is IonQ and how are you different to our former guest D-Wave, IBM, Horizon? Let's start there.
Jeremy Gilbertson Outstanding.
What IonQ actually builds
Coleman Collins Yeah, so there are a few answers to that question. Most practically, we are a company that makes quantum computers, as well as a number of other supporting technologies that we sell in different packages and bundles, depending on who's using it, why, and where. We've been around since 2017. We were spent out from university research at University of Maryland in Duke.
And we'd make trapped ion quantum computers specifically. what sort of the two big ways were different. One is our hardware approach. And then one is our sort of philosophical approach to solving the problems. The hardware approach, we use trapped ions. So trapped ion quantum computing, there's a lot of different ways to make a qubit, right? All you really need, there's this list called DeVincenzo's criteria. You need five things plus two, if you want to do network quantum computing. And as long as you have those five, you can use a photon, you can use a non-abelian anion, which is the thing that's in the news with Microsoft recently. You can use neutral atoms. You can use superconducting circuits. So basically a loop of wire that, I mean, in on the chip that has this discontinuity called the Joseph's junction that you use to then sort of create atom like behavior. We use trapped ions. We use physical single ions of uterbium or barium, depending on which generation of system you're talking about.
And then we address those with lasers and that does math, turns out.
Mark Fielding Okay, hold on, right. We'll get to Microsoft later. For me, those five steps, we need to know what those five things are.
Jeremy Gilbertson I'm sorry Mark, I'm gonna stop you.
Jeremy Gilbertson Real quick, real quick, Koma, before that, Mark, have you ever been addressed by a laser before?
Mark Fielding I was addressed as Mark Fielding five seconds ago and that was weird enough so no I've never been addressed by a laser. Have you?
DiVincenzo's five criteria
Jeremy Gilbertson I have it. Coleman, talk about Devin Chenza's criteria?
Coleman Collins Yeah, so DiVincenzo, David DiVincenzo is a theoretical physicist. I forget where he works or worked. But basically, this is the list of the things you have to have to have a quantum computer. And so you need a well-characterized qubit. So you need a two-level system, quantum system that you can either be in like a fiducial one, a zero, or somewhere in between superposition. You need to be able to initialize those qubits.
Coleman Collins to a single state to know where they are. You kind of know where your zero is. And that's just like, so you have a reference point to then do all of the other stuff. You need long coherence time. So what this means is, you may be talked about this before, but many different types of two quantum states sort of relax over time, right? One of the challenges of quantum computing is that you quite literally need to isolate the quantum state from the universe.
And there are many reasons why that stops being true. One is sort of coherence from interference of like electrical fields, magnetic fields, know, solar radiation, cosmic rays is actually a real problem in, in superconducting systems. and you also just the, depending on what kind of quantum state you're using, sometimes those relax, right? so you, start losing the ability to tell the difference between your one and your zero again. and you're just, you're going back to basically random.
And so you need both kinds of coherence there. That's three. You need to be able to measure, ideally individually, but at least all of them. And then you need what's called a universal set of quantum gates. And so you need an entangling gate and you need a single-qubit rotation of some form. And generally that's kind of enough. And that's basically so you can kind of explore the entire, what's called the Hilbert space, the sort of the mathematical space that you're trying to compute in kind of efficiently.
And so you need all five things, but there's a lot of different ways to do that. You can do that with photons, you can do that with squeeze states. You can do it. So on we use trapped ions and the kind of the reason, the logic behind this is that, we are qubits don't have any fabrication errors, right? They are made by nature. Good to go. All of the errors that come in are from environmental control, environmental interference, and then basically our inability to actually perfectly. Cause like you can like literally we are trapping ions on a chip.
They're floating like, I don't know, it's like 40 microns above a chip that we designed and then fab with a partner. And then we're shooting lasers at them and they're effectively a single point source, but we need to be able to exactly hit those with exactly the right wavelength, exactly the right phase, drive these transitions between multiple ions to entangle them. All of which is that's the engineering challenge, right? Like our founders, like to say that like we have no new novel physics to figure out just a lot of really hard engineering.
Coleman Collins but to be clear, it's pretty hard engineering, like we're getting there, but, so yeah, so we use trapped ions and that's, that's a philosophical choice. Basically there's a lot of the way I like to describe it is there are everyone who is sort of driving, especially kind of in the big commercial space, everyone is picking the hard problems they think are the easiest. And we think that's sort of cubic control rather than cubic fabrication, which is what a lot of your kind of superconducting people are thinking about.
Jeremy Gilbertson I think that that goes without saying like a lot of people focus on the easier thing than the hard thing sometimes just to get the things done. Look, we're doing things. We're doing things. A couple quick thoughts. Disruptors and curious minds don't ever say we didn't give you anything. We actually, thanks to Coleman, you now have the checklist to build a quantum computer. So brought to you by Thinking on Paper. Secondly, Coleman, I've always thought we've read a lot about
Jeremy Gilbertson quantum mechanics. I've been a quantum mechanical nerd for a long time. I mean I'm not a physicist but I'm like I love the idea of science that is emergent and not hierarchical and that kind of just does stuff because that's what it does. More jazz, less classical. So let's unpack the natural aspect of using ions, right? Because we I've always thought man nature does quantum better than any man-made type of quantum. So you're now kind of harnessing a bit of nature and hoping to get results that nature does because there's no, there's no cooling, there's no massive cooling challenges that you have with this type of technology, right? Or they're not as, not as difficult to overcome.
Cooling ions with lasers
Coleman Collins They're not as difficult, that's correct. So we do, actually we just, I think, announced maybe today some of our work to get back to room temperature. we use what we sort of call easy cryo, but the reason we use that is primarily for vacuum pressure purposes, because you need to isolate your ions. If you have a collision, then you lose an ion and then you lose your computation. We don't need to be like inherently in...
You can actually cool ions with lasers. It's called Doppler cooling, which is a pretty neat idea. It uses the same effect as like, you know, the Doppler effect, like an ambulance is driving by. Yeah. So specifically what you can do is basically detune a laser such that it only is seeing the ion is only seeing the laser. So it's only resonant in one kind of emotional direction. And then you can use that to basically bleed off all of this motion over time, because only when it's going towards the laser, does it kind of get a photon and then release it? But it's moving randomly. So over time, you can compress that down to basically a couple of quanta of energy in that ion. And then that's actually better than trying to use a cryostat to do it.
Jeremy Gilbertson Is this a little path integral kind of thing happening? Like instead of just having all of these different options that this laser and this ion can kind of interact with, you're limiting it to the ones that actually work really well or? Okay.
Coleman Collins It's actually the opposite. So based on the species of ion, there is just math you can do that lets you know what that wavelength is. Yeah. And then to detune it, you're just moving it slightly off. And that's then the Doppler effect redshifting then lets you only in one emotional direction. Are you catching that wavelength that the right perceived, the ion sees it now at the right wavelength rather than the slightly wrong one?
Explain it at the Christmas dinner table
Mark Fielding Can I, so, Jeremy used to ask this really great question to our guests and then we learned and then we didn't ask it anymore. But you lost me, like the quality over quantity that IonQ, but then you say you don't need these calling mechanisms, which we all as quantum curious kind of, that's what we imagine. So is that like this contradiction there between what we think we know and what you're doing? Could you explain it?
Coleman Collins Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Mark Fielding as you would explain it at the family dinner table at Christmas to your uncle when he asks, so Coleman, tell me about iron Q. Why is it different to IBM? Like it's just so we can break it down to a more understandable.
Coleman Collins Sure. Yeah. I, this is kind of a, well, I know the question you're actually asking, but I'll note that my uncle works in an accelerator lab. So. Doesn't quite work. I'll pick a different uncle. Yeah. Exactly. So, we, yeah, we, we are ultimately trying to do the same thing, right? Which is build large quantum computers and then also create, basically make them very easy to use.
Mark Fielding Okay, what do the rest of the family do when you two start talking to each other?
Jeremy Gilbertson no, pick a different relative. Pick a different relative.
Why trapped ions
Coleman Collins such that not only our really phenomenal applications research team can develop use cases that actually impact the world, but everyone else can too. This is the way in which we are the same. The ways in which we are different, primarily is hardware technology. So this is the trap dye and stuff I'm talking about. And basically rather than choosing to fabricate things that act like atoms, we choose to use atoms. And that comes with a different set of benefits, but also a different set of challenges.
some of the benefits are we think it's going to be better, easier to scale. we think it, is it's definitely easier to fabricate the qubits cause we can just basically, all you need to do is get a pure source of whatever metal you're using. it's to some extent easier to measure, read out control. on the flip side, the crosstalk is much better normally, but that's actually kind of an architectural decision on the flip side.
also, sorry. One of the big things about trapped ions, at least the way that we do it is connectivity. So effectively, because we're using an ion chain and we're using the emotional modes of the ion chain to drive our entangling gates, we can pick any two on the chain and have them entangled as opposed to a chip layout qubit where you're limited by what you're actually physically connected to by wires. We don't have any wires. The lasers are the wires and the physics is the wires.
Jeremy Gilbertson And the lasers can actually be, so you're not hardwiring something in, they can be changed to coordinate the qubits differently? Is that the idea?
Coleman Collins That's correct. So we use what's called the acoustic optic deflector technology to basically steer laser beams.
Jeremy Gilbertson Wow, super cool.
Coleman Collins Yeah, I think so too. Like to be clear, my background is not in physics and I'm not one of the people that designs those optomechanical systems, but I love going to the design reviews.
Algorithmic qubits and physical qubits
Jeremy Gilbertson Can we go into this idea of algorithmic qubits and physical qubits? And I want to start off by maybe using an analogy that came into my brain as I was learning about these things, right? So qubits, no matter what way they're put together or the type of qubits they are, it's this new way of computing that we're trying to get better at what we do than we do today. But the challenge is knowing whether the qubits are actually useful, right?
Would this be akin to testing the capabilities of a race car before you got in and ran a race with the race car? Is that kind of the same idea what algorithmic qubits do is test the usefulness? Is that what we're getting with this?
Coleman Collins Yes, yes, exactly. we are, Algebraic Qubits is just sort of our shorthand single number metric to try and describe the number of useful qubits we have in our system. And the short version of how we do that is we take a set of benchmarks that were developed by the QEDC, which stands for Quantum Economic Development Council, I'm pretty sure. And then,
We did a little bit of extra stuff to basically be able to distill that to a single number that describes kind of how big your kind of run box of your quantum circuit can be as actually measured by specific kind of reference algorithms that we know to have some potential interesting use cases in the future. things like phase estimation, things like, amplitude estimation.
these sort of algorithmic quantum Fourier transforms, these algorithmic primitives that then you can kind of use as building blocks to solve interesting problems. And so AQ is just our way of kind of describing that run box. There are other ways to do it. They all sort of have their pros and cons, right? Like as an example, quantum volume, we have nothing wrong with quantum volume. It's just that is actually trying to describe
Sort of the latent space run box. kind of all of the randomness inside of that. it's, um, it's, uh, I blanked for a second. Um, it's a useful test, but it's a less useful test because it's not as focused on what are going to do with this? Right. Because, um, I don't buy a TV to just like look at random static. I look, I buy a TV to look at pictures. And so you could actually, if you're, if you allow yourself to,
Without actually specifically optimizing for any individual algorithm that's sort of against the rules in the rules that we wrote for ourselves I am at least able to optimize for the fact that I'm trying to solve problems rather than just explore randomness
A tuned television, not a fuzzy screen
Mark Fielding So it's like a tuned television as opposed to a fuzzy screen. So Jeremy, you're very good at summarizing. So summarize for me an algorithmic qubit, how you understand it.
Jeremy Gilbertson I just see it as, I would kind of lean on my previous analogy and maybe tie into what Coleman was saying just a little bit before that you could have 500 qubits, but if only two of them can be put together to point to useful compute, the volume isn't working. It's a quality over quantity approach and finding a way to define in their own terms.
What is a quality qubit, I think? How'd I do?
Quantum volume, and what it doesn't tell you
Coleman Collins Yeah. And so like quite well, I think. So volume is sort of an interesting one because it actually, that's a really challenging benchmark too, to be clear. But it's not as useful from like a customer perspective or a user perspective of what can I do with this aside from like run quantum volume at that size. It's similar to like the, cross entropy benchmarking, some of the stuff that Google has used to benchmark their systems, which is to be clear, a really fascinating scientific result.
but doesn't tell you a ton about how useful it will be to actually solve meaningful problems. all the Willowchip stuff I don't want to hate on because it's really cool for a bunch of other reasons. Lambda greater than two is actually a really cool story there in my mind. But it gives you this really big number. It is a genuine, interesting scientific result. It's just not quite as close to applicability as we like to talk at IonQ.
Logical qubits, and what they mean for real problems
Mark Fielding Can I just read it? I don't know if this is correct, so please correct me if I've mis-found this. IonQ expects their 64 tempo system to achieve quantum advantage for certain use cases, and they also anticipate reaching a 5 nines, 99.999 % success in logical 2 qubit gate fidelity by the end of this year. Are both of those correct? And if they are, what...
Mark Fielding does that mean for solving these real world challenges, which you hope to?
Coleman Collins Yeah, it's a good question. So, the logical qubit thing, is yes, the thing that we're, so as a note, these, this will be on demonstration systems. This is not like commercially available quite yet. That'll happen in 26 sometime. and sort of the capability of commercial advantage, it's sort of a weird thing because commercial advantage, it's like a thing we spent a ton of time thinking about, right? Like a lot of how we do,
Development in our DITI and Q is what we kind of call application driven or application kind of first. And what we mean by that is we are trying to, by working with customers, as well as within our own applications research team, which kind of splits their time between customer engagements and internal research. We're trying to find these promising algorithms and approaches that we think actually can provide commercial advantage in like a NISQ regime in a, in an early small quantum computer regime, because we all know what we can do.
with a few thousand high quality logical qubits. And logical qubits is actually a word worth unpacking too, I'll come back to that. But what can we do with like two or 300? Or even a hundred? So Tempo is supposed to have a hundred qubits, 64 AQ, maybe better, but we're trying to set expectations appropriately.
and we think there is some stuff, there's definitely stuff in that run box that is not simulatable classically. what that actually means in terms of commercial advantage, we're still working on, right? Because there's, it's, it's a much harder problem. Cause like you can do these theoretical, calculations and at this size, you, it's hard to like prove a theoretical, like definite speed up. But we think there are practical things that, that will be very close, but the problem is you actually need to look at.
price, power, performance, time to solution, all these different things. And then find, not just have your sort of compute layer, but also then your application or sorry, your algorithm layer. And then you also your application layer as it fits into a real workflow for a real customer. And so we were pretty positive that we can show some like benefits from like quantum over classical and at least one of these things in the temporary regime. But if it's going to be enough to actually drive like a production service that you can
Coleman Collins like actually kind of trade dollar for dollar for, we're not sure yet. We continue to turn that crank to get closer and closer to that answer. Um, but it's, it's a really hard problem that we may not actually know until we have the system built and we start trying stuff. But that's kind of why we have this whole other piece of like broad access, open access, because we also want to bet on the field. We don't want to just our, you know, 18 really smart applications researchers to be helping or trying to solve this problem. want systems in people's hands. So a bunch of people can try and solve that.
SDKs, and the common language problem
Jeremy Gilbertson So that's where the SDKs kind of come in and the software that you guys have and you let people kind of jump in and play around and share what they've learned and hopefully build a little bit of a think tank. I think about this a lot with quantum because like we all know like holy smokes like the potential is there for quantum systems because quantum powers nature. Nature does amazing things right that we don't understand even how it works and for us to kind of harness a little bit of nature's magic and point it to big problems that traditional compute can't solve, I think is super powerful. But I think here, I want to throw this out and the question's kind of forming in my head as I'm talking, so bear with me. With how we're tracking who's doing better at quantum, investment powers all of this stuff, right? You have to have money to be able to experiment, to be able to test, to be able to build. So you have to attract investment. Attracting investment requires speaking a common language.
the common language is how many qubits do you have, right? And now it's starting to change a little bit. Like, well, are these good? Are these useful? So like, how do you balance like doing really innovative stuff with communicating in a language where, you know, the financial side might be like, yeah, I'm gonna take a bet. Like, cause I think that's where the stalemate kind of comes, right?
Coleman Collins It does. Yeah, it's really hard, right? We are one of only three pure play public quantum companies. And that creates a lot of interesting benefits for us as a business, but also like a lot of challenges in this, sort of communicating to the street one is a big part of it. The thing that I think we found to your point is it's just so much education, right?
We have to, like AQ, it was sort of one of our earliest examples of trying to do this, but there's others too of basically laying out the roadmap and saying, here are the things we, here are the hard problems we need to solve to get to the promised land. And then updating on how we're doing on those. Because yeah, to your point, you can, you can describe kind of the vision for 2030, 2035. But then like, what's going to happen next year.
is a much harder question. so being able to like efficiently communicate. Okay. What we need to do is we need to advance networking so that we know how to connect these systems together to scale. We need to advance qubit count. need to advance fidelity, but we need to do both at the same time. Right. We're not just trying to make a really big system. We're also not just trying to make us very small, perfect system. because you actually do need both. Right. And that's sort of this like volumetric, like run box thing.
Short version, it's really hard. we're, yeah, it's education mostly.
Mark Fielding We're going to get to the hot burns in a second. Don't worry. Just want to ask on the investment side though, and I think maybe quantum is becoming like blockchain a few years ago and AI now where the hype, the conversation, the media exposure has created a point where investment VCs are just throwing money into quantum. that really happening? Is the investment 10X, 100X, 1000X upon two years ago?
Where the private investment goes
Coleman Collins So that's an interesting question. Yeah, the private investment continues to increase. The big thing we've actually seen recently is that we have reached some sort of tipping point from if to when where the public money is actually increasing pretty rapidly too. So this is basically nation states, including the United States, although some recent science funding stuff notwithstanding.
including nation states, who basically want to make sure that they don't miss this wave. And so are starting to invest at different levels, whether that's sort of trying to build a, the, the world economic forum calls like a quantum economy. And you see this even in the States and in places like Chicago and places like Maryland, where they're trying to build a nexus of people, of work, of research at different layers. So down the supply chain, people who make lasers, make components.
up to people who are trying to make applications, um, as well as sort of different versions of this, which is investing in more basic science to support, um, these broader things. So that's actually, think where the big boom has come, but also yes, private investment has, I don't have the numbers offhand, but definitely continued to grow significantly. Right. Um, when I started at IonQ in 2017, a kind of reasonable check size for a
Even a quantum hardware company, right? Which is like very capital intensive was tens of millions of dollars. And now they're now you're looking at like a hundred million for Q control. They just raised a hundred million dollar round, which like they don't make hardware and actually they might make some sensing stuff now, but to be clear and that's not to denigrate Q control. Cause I think they're doing a bunch of really incredible stuff, but like the numbers have gone up. sorry. That's my dog.
Daisy
Mark Fielding I have to draw attention to the dog. Who's got a dog? that you? What sort of dog is it?
Coleman Collins One sec. She's a golden doodle.
Mark Fielding Golden- what's a golden doodle?
Coleman Collins So she's a cross between a golden and a poodle.
Mark Fielding Wow, okay. I'm trying to, I'm picturing something in my head which may or may not be,
Coleman Collins Yeah, if you'd like me to, can pause for one second and get her to calm down. I think there's just someone at the door.
Jeremy Gilbertson yeah, no worries. Yeah, that's fine. We're good. We're not live so we can we can cut and edit all good. Yep. Sure
Coleman Collins Okay, give me one sec.
Mark Fielding Hopefully we can see the golden poodle, the golden doodle. My brain is melting.
Jeremy Gilbertson I feel good about my kind of grasp of this. Hey, there you go.
Coleman Collins This is what she looks like.
Mark Fielding Okay, yes. That is the first dog I'm thinking on paper. What's her name? Daisy. same as my niece.
Coleman Collins That's Daisy.
Jeremy Gilbertson Daisy, welcome to Thinking on Paper.
We just need to get Daisy some opposable thumbs so she could write. We've got to do that to think on paper.
Coleman Collins Yeah, same thing.
Jeremy Gilbertson There you go, there you go. I think it's hot buttons time, Mark, what do you think?
Mark Fielding Yeah, that's a perfect break for some hot buttons and then we'll get back into the quantum. Yes, let's do it. You got a clock? So just to explain common, is five questions, 30 seconds, one word answers. It's the Daniel Kahneman thinking fast of the thinking fast thinking slow.
Jeremy Gilbertson Alright, so-
Hot buttons
Jeremy Gilbertson Are you ready? Timer's on.
Mark Fielding What's more likely, AGI or alien contact?
Mark Fielding Jazz or classical? Willow or magerana?
Coleman Collins Willow, I'll explain why later.
Coleman Collins Feynman, hard one though.
Coleman Collins sport, but again, like both.
Mark Fielding Sport and beer. Boom, boom, boom. That's it. You absolutely aced it. Hot buttons. Done.
Jeremy Gilbertson Well done, well done. That was awesome. That was awesome. Well, I guess right now we could fold straight into the news.
Mark Fielding And we can frame that with Coleman's answer to the hot button, Willow or Margerana. He said Willow, which maybe we are surprised about. But Jeremy, hit us with the news.
Willow, and why Coleman picked it
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, so we, it actually is great that we've tied together news and hot buttons in such a way. That's why I wanted to go into it quickly. So Microsoft's in the news. We've all seen it. We've all heard about it. They've got something called Margerin. No, I'm just kidding. It's Margerana, right? So they've claimed to do something different in quantum. There's a path to a million qubits. There's a lot of people on both sides of their enthusiasm for their announcement. Coleman, can you break this down?
for people that don't really know much about quantum that, you know, what this could mean possibly.
Microsoft's topological bet
Coleman Collins Yeah. So I think there's kind of two, the short version as to why I said Willow is because I think that path is shorter and more concrete basically to the, like the, the promised land, if you will. so yeah, major on a cubits or topological cubits are this thing that's like been around in kind of people's heads for, I think like 20 years. And Microsoft has been kind of working on it that whole time. it's sort of been in the background, you know, we,
Microsoft like, well, I don't think we get to say this anymore, but for a long time we were, you know, we always are aware of Microsoft. have a great science team. They have a great platform with Azure quantum, but they didn't have any qubits. Now they might have one, which is more than zero. and I say might because sort of the, interesting, so topological qubits are this slightly different approach to making a qubit that still sort of follow the rules that we talked about earlier. and if you can actually.
do them, if you can actually create them and then get them to be able to be interacted with efficiently. They have a bunch of sort of natural benefits because you're using these sort of special, what are called? Sorry, dog. she is, with these, non-abelian anions, these things that are neither fermions nor bosons. So they're a different kind of quantum particle that
Jeremy Gilbertson Daisy's passionate about quantum.
Coleman Collins The way you have them actually do your, your gates, your computation is via this thing called braiding and braiding has this really, this is like the topology thing. Braiding has this really cool quality of being hard to unbraid harder than sort of a lot of the other ways you would do a gate. And so this is literally like, if you think about taking a, a, well, literally making a braid, right. Or tying a knot in a rope where you have a circle and you put something through it. This is topologically bound.
I can't without cutting this, which is a harder thing than just, you know, taking them apart, for the podcast listeners, I'm making little rings with my fingers. and then pulling them apart, like I'm a magician. that's much harder to do. there's this really cool quality of it sort of naturally being protected from certain types of noise that really impact other types of quantum computers. The hard part is that to date, we're only pretty sure you can actually create these things in nature. So you can do a simulation. They've actually done a simulation on, I'm not sure if it was Willow or Sycamore. You can do a simulation to prove that like this state of matter does exist theoretically, but then actually getting it and making it well controlled is very, very hard. And so the Microsoft announcement is basically, hey, we did it. We made a qubit. There is some, I think rightly, a lot of...
Kind of back and forth in the community that is like kind of above my head in terms of these are like the capital P physicists around there. Basically it's, it's, it's hard to prove that you actually did it. And so there's some conversation about the there's cause there's a paper in nature, right? And that has some data. And then there's also this other sort of update that they, did in a, in a smaller session in this group called station Q that has some additional data. And so that's this, this back and forth of,
Did they actually have they actually sort of done the thing and made a topological cue, but even just a single one, which is like an incredible step forward. And it's obvious that they're way, way closer than they've ever been, but it's like, that's your zero to one problem. And then your one end problem is the next one. That is again, why I sort of at least, you know, today, knowing what I know, even though topological oversuperconducting, I think has some clear benefits, actually being able to build that system is, is pretty hard, right? It took IonQ.
Coleman Collins We're able to double our cubic count roughly every 18 to 24 months. So if they're at one right now.
Also, topological qubits kind of require error correction to be effective, much like superconducting. That's not entirely true. That's a little bit of a gloss on a complicated statement, but broadly speaking. And so it's really exciting. And if they've done it, you know, god damn. But I think the jury's still out a little bit. I'm sure they'll get there eventually. And then even when they do, there's still a long road between that and a useful quantum computer. So like, without like sort of stamping on the excitement at all, cause it's really exciting. It's just worth noting that it's still pretty far away from actually having useful quantum computer for a couple of different reasons.
Jeremy Gilbertson Here's a couple quick things that just, I'm just gonna give you full access to what's going on in my head right now, Coleman. So he's got a bell ready. So I think, I see this cartoon, right, with a bunch of lion tamers. Picture a lion tamer. And each lion tamer has like the Microsoft logo, the IonQ logo, the, you know, pick your quantum, and they're in the corner trying to tame.
Jeremy Gilbertson this cubit and they're trying to wrangle it and like whoever can wrangle it the quickest. I don't know. I'm just sure there's not a question in there. was it was a pure Daisy loves it. Daisy loves my analogy. But that's what I'm thinking because these things are hard to like to wrangle and point to point to use and it's not like something's going to happen in three weeks in the garage somewhere in Palo Alto. This is like this is going to be a bit of a line of kind of working through some of the stuff which is the exciting part to me.
The garage in Palo Alto
Coleman Collins Yeah, I agree. There is actually one garage in Palo Alto that I'm keeping my eye on, which is PsyQuantum. But they've been working on it for about a decade, to be clear. It's not. And it's, think, quite a bit more than a garage at this point. So they're doing photonic quantum computing, which is really interesting because one of the hard scaling problems is networking systems together, and they sort of get it for free. The hard part is that it's a very Big Bang sort of approach.
Jeremy Gilbertson What can you tell me about those guys?
Coleman Collins you're going to need basically to come online with everything you expect to have. All the cubits, everything. And also there's like a ton of interesting, hard sort of environmental problems with them. Like their cubits don't need to be cold, but their sensors do. And so as a result, you end up with this huge like rack of cryo-cooled sensors. But...
Again, that's another one, much like topological, with like, if they can pull it off, and I think it's still an if at this point, like I would describe superconducting and ions and neutrals as sort of a when, if they can pull it off, it's gonna be amazing. It's gonna be really cool. I am like, officially because I work for IonQ, I am, you know, an ions fan, and that's true, but I'm like, I want the industry to succeed, so I have a lot of sort of opinions and love for all the different qubit modalities, because I also think, like to some extent, A,
We're all still trying to like to use the classical analogy. We're still trying to build vacuum tubes. Like there's going to be a thing after this. and, it's also likely that in the medium term, it's going to be multimodal, right? this is some of the work we're doing with the airport's research lab actually is creating the networking infrastructure to allow for multimodal quantum computing. using ions and neutrals or ions and superconducting, although that,
That one's a hard one. But so yeah, I'm excited about it all as well. And yeah, it's there's a lot of qubits out there.
Qiskit, and getting started
Mark Fielding It's a callback to book club quantum supremacy. thinking on paper. X, Y, Zed a few months ago, Jeremy and I did a chapter by chapter breakdown of quantum supremacy and one of the chapters was on the different modalities of that. So we cover some of those. Head to the website to get that. I love that you're your passion for the space and you want the space to succeed. You want the technology to succeed. You want quantum to succeed. We don't always see that. I think that's quite clear in even just with the recent announcements. Not everybody is, it's not a team sport all the time. But could we take it back to like the integration, the classical hybrid integration. When we had IBM on a bit ago, they were speaking about having like 600,000 hobbyist coders on their
I don't know how on KissKit platform. Do you, IonQ doing something different if we have some developers watching this who work in Rust or something else they want to get involved in quantum algorithms? Yeah. Can you speak us through that a bit?
Coleman Collins Yeah, on KissKit,
Sure. Well, first of all, we support Qiskit. So some of those 600,000 are running on IonQ. And there's other hardware partners that Qiskit uses. Qiskit is open source software. We actually, our approach is we're sort of strategically promiscuous is the phrase I use internally. And I'll use it on the podcast too.
Coleman Collins with a lot of these SDKs because we're just not sure what's going to win and we don't honestly care. We just want to get quantum in people's hands. And so that's important to us. So we support Qiskit, Cirq, which is the SDK that Google makes, and about half a dozen others of smaller and larger user bases. And the access layer, like you're saying, is really important. I think.
Coleman Collins Getting started is a really kind challenging thing right now, because every kind of intro to quantum computing or algorithm design development kind of textbook or resource is like, OK, quantum is going to solve these amazing problems. How much linear algebra do you know? That's step one, step two. And right, same. Well, I've got a little bit now, but I didn't even just a few years ago. And so.
Coleman Collins We are still, and I think this is true of most of the SDKs out there, we are still missing sort of these abstraction layers between like raw writing quantum circuits. So gates to be run like physically on systems and actually sort of solving useful commercial problems or even just useful scientific problems. And building those abstraction layers is pretty hard, right? Because you mentioned Rust. Like Rust is a really interesting programming language.
for a bunch of reasons, but one is because like most good programming languages, it's trying to solve a specific problem or set of specific problems, right? Which is like memory safety, all these different things as opposed to C. And I don't know that we have enough of the algorithmics or the primitive building blocks to be able to build those abstractions in a useful way right now. So you can't, like, I don't know what the quantum programming language sort of in the middle is, right? We have these great libraries that people are starting to write, including the IonQ team.
about, how do we kind of package all this all the way into something that solves optimization problems or solves chemistry problems or whatever, but kind of being able to actually operate at that building blocks level and have an intuition about it, I think is just something that no one is doing very well at this point. And we are trying to find different ways to engage with that community and find these things and build these abstractions, these kind of composable pieces.
our cloud platform now has this set of things called quantum functions and quantum solvers, which are trying to sort of kind of allow to build these building blocks. But it's a work in progress, I think, because it requires us to have a better picture of what we're trying to build. So that's kind of the access and SDK question. The hybrid and integration question is maybe...
a longer one than we have time for, because you have to break it down quite a bit. Because broadly speaking, what you're talking about is, we want to use classical computers to make quantum computers better, or we want to use quantum computers to make just classical or just any sort of computational workflow better. They're both slightly different. Both are sometimes called hybrid quantum computing. And they're also a virtuous cycle. the edges are blurry.
Coleman Collins because you are adding capabilities at the low level, error mitigation, better control, which then allows you to improve your algorithmic design to do these like quantum accelerated applications and back and forth like this. so breaking it down into useful pieces of conversation to talk about like, how do we integrate with HPC to do quantum accelerated workloads versus how do we expand the instruction set to do these very low level, fast feedback like during.
a quantum circuit while your quantum information is still coherent, things like mid-circuit measurement and dynamic circuit execution, which you actually need to do error correction to do all these other really important things as we scale. There's a bunch of different interesting pieces in that if you want to pick one, or we can just sort of leave it at a glossier call.
Jeremy Gilbertson I want to partner with a caricature artist because now I'm seeing like there's a guy doing calculations and there's a guy spinning a wand holding two cubits together and the guy with the cubits is like, yo, hurry up and finish, hurry up and finish, they're starting to decouple, right? Like there's an urgency to this that is like mind-blowing and how do you, God, yeah, anyway.
Mark Fielding Coleman, let's save that and publicly invite you back for part two where we perhaps start there and go from that point because I don't know about you, Jeremy, but the last four minutes have been incredible. I think it's one of the best conversations we've been part of on quantum on thinking on paper. So thank you for that. You've mentioned the promised land twice. What is the quantum promised land?
What commercial utility means
Coleman Collins For? Yeah, it is commercial utility. It's having someone choose to use a quantum computer because it is technically, economically, just sort of practically the right choice, as opposed to right now where most people are interested in quantum computing.
because it's an interesting technology to explore, which I very much agree with. Like in a sense, and this is like, I don't know if this is an official IonQ messaging statement, but it's a Coleman Collins one. It's making quantum computing boring, right? It's, I just want it to be part of the toolbox of things I can use to solve problems. That sort of, to me is the promise line. And in practice, that means being able to solve interesting.
commercially and scientifically useful problems at meaningful scale.
Jeremy Gilbertson So humans, humans, is still hope. Mark and I unpacked Paci McCormack's the most human wins paper talking about how humans survive in the realm of AI and the realm of emerging technologies. Humans, we still have to figure out what questions, what those problems are to find those problems that we can point all these new technologies like quantum computers to. So I feel that Coleman, you've...
most succinctly explained a lot of things related to quantum.
Mark Fielding And that's a call out for our listeners, anyone who's listening. If you have any ideas of what they are, put them in the comments wherever you're watching or listening to this. I love the Coleman Collins isms. Can we call the show IonQ is strategically promiscuous? Can we use that a title for the podcast? We won't.
Coleman Collins I'd be fine with it, but I think our comms director might have something to say.
When does quantum break Bitcoin?
Jeremy Gilbertson Maybe little heartburn in there. All right, let's get to carry over question from last week. This is a simple one. Well, simple relative to someone who's been in the space. So we talked about space data centers with a, with a gentleman named Philip yesterday. They're, they're putting data centers on rockets and they're doing compute in lower earth orbit, which apparently isn't as crowded as everyone thinks it is. So everything's going to be fine up there. We talked about space elevators, all kinds of, but Philip is asking Coleman.
Mark Fielding Shout out to where that question came from, Jeremy.
Jeremy Gilbertson When will Quantum break up Bitcoin?
Coleman Collins so this is such a, I don't want to harsh on Philip's vibe, but this is such a common question that we have a shorthand for it, which is Q Day.
Which is effectively, the other way to describe this is when will we have a cryptographically relevant quantum computer? So one of the things we have known for a very long time, in fact, one of the things that spurred the initial sort of push into quantum computing technology development in the 90s is this algorithm called Shor's algorithm. And Shor's algorithm is actually a period finding algorithm. It lets you...
See how far apart things are because you're using this like basically a fourier quantum fourier transform to do some, special tricks. The cool thing about that is you can map that problem to finding the constituent co-primes of a very large number that is made up of two prime numbers. Well, why does that matter? That is the basis for most cryptographic algorithms that are used for, you know, securing Bitcoin wallets as well as regular wallets and banking and telephony and all these different things.
And so that's a really, really important question that a lot of people have on their mind quite a lot. In the specific case of Bitcoin, the likely attack vector is going to be actually breaking the public keys and then using those to access wallets rather than breaking the chain itself. And that's just because where is the easiest thing that you can sort of find. That, I'm pretty sure I forget exactly. I don't think Bitcoin is RSA. So there are some of these cryptographic algorithms. There's RSA, ECC, AES are the three big ones.
Coleman Collins I'm pretty sure Bitcoin is either AES or ECC, I forget. In any case, the answer is kind of the same for all of them, plus or minus a factor of maybe two, which is we're going to order. think it's like, so you, it's like double the number of bits in the bit string you're trying to solve in logical qubits, like, not just sort of like logical qubits is a bit of a, funny word because it really just means it's good enough to solve the problem you need to solve. Right. So,
You can have a logical qubit that isn't like 10 nines or 12 nines of perfection, depending on your approach. But ions can definitely do this. But for this, are talking about, need like 10, 12, 19, like basically a perfect qubit, which requires error correction, which is a thing that we are just now as an industry starting to actually do cool demonstrations on like in the past 18 months. And so broadly speaking, kind of the most.
like error corrected or logical qubits anyone has at this like level of quality is zero at any level of quality is like maybe 10 maybe a dozen and we're gonna need them to be way better and we're gonna need like 4,000 of them so it's not tomorrow it's probably not the day after that either in terms of actually predicting a timeline I'm always really wary to do that because
One of my jokes is that the only thing we know about the future is that it's not going to be like the present, and it's not going to be what we expect. And so.
Jeremy Gilbertson What about if I make this a little lighter lift? we had the the post quantum cryptography expert from IBM on a few shows ago, or a while ago actually, and she predicted what, 2032?
Mark Fielding I think that was in line with IBM's Bluebird chip. I think that with Bitcoin, there's maybe because Satoshi's, the original Bitcoin, the early Bitcoin aren't under the same cryptography as the later. Something changed, didn't it? OK, we don't want to put a down now. I just want to move much, further into the future then. It is a quantum
Currency possible is there any way I was listening to a podcast a big idea was bankless shout out to bankless and now speaking about this idea a long way in quantum money is that something you've ever thought about or
Coleman Collins Yeah, there's a, man, that's a great question. There is, so there's a paper, a sort of a proposal from the 90s. And I want to say it's, God, what's his name? At IBM, Charlie.
Coleman Collins We're going to do some live Googling. One sec. Charlie Bennett. I'm pretty sure.
Coleman Collins Well, because I just need a data point, not an answer that is described to me. I use all those tools quite a lot. Yeah, so yeah, it's basically a very early idea in quantum information theory, which is, you could theoretically use entangled pairs to create some sort of proof of work, proof of ownership.
doing that in a way that is, again, back to our defincenso criteria, is long-term coherent, is practical. I wouldn't bet on it for this century, but I don't think it's impossible. Far from it.
Jeremy Gilbertson My money is already quantum. Coleman, it's entangled with bills and invoices. There's quantum entanglement there. That's right, that's right.
Coleman Collins There's quite a lot of entanglement there, yes.
Mark Fielding Yeah, my money is there and then it's not as well.
Jeremy Gilbertson man, what a great chat Coleman. This has been a blast. Can you leave us as a final takeaway a carryover question for our next guest who I believe Mark, do we have the world folks on?
Mark Fielding And that's in two weeks. Next week we have Diego on AI and blockchain.
Jeremy Gilbertson Got it, got it. Carryover question, can be about anything Coleman, whatever's on your mind that you'd like to send down the line.
Coleman Collins Okay, so okay, for someone.
that is focused on AI and blockchain. Maybe an interesting question would be, where do our current approaches break? Can we just keep scaling forever or are we gonna have to do something different at some point?
Jeremy Gilbertson Very interesting, like, and where are those break points and like what's going for, like what dominoes fall in first? Really interesting, man, I love that.
Mark Fielding Yep, great question, great interview. Thank you very much, Coleman Collins. Round of applause from the Thinking on Paper audience there.
Coleman Collins Yeah, thanks for having me. Sorry about the dog. She's sweet, but she's loud.
Mark Fielding Personality, character, we can put emoji on the screen.
Jeremy Gilbertson First dog, first dog I'm thinking on paper. Coleman, come back and join us again and let's continue to unpack the future together. Appreciate it. All right, take it easy, bye.
Coleman Collins Sounds great, I'd love to. Bye.
Backstage
Jeremy Gilbertson All right, Mark Fielding, we are backstage. How's your brain feeling? Scrambled eggs or what? Like, what are you, talk to me.
Mark Fielding Yes, yes we are, Jeremy Gilmerson. So there was something he said, my brain kind of, there was a moment after about three minutes of Coleman speaking and he said, I think it was on the five steps that you need to have a qubit. And he said something about separating the process from the universe. He said, separate it from the universe. And my brain just went, what?
And I'm go back and listen to exactly like in what context he said that but yeah It was very informative a bit the first 15 minutes was very technical and I enjoyed that I have to go back and listen again to try and understand some of it, but I thought it was great show
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, separating something. Like there's an edit tool, right, in the quantum algorithm process where it's like, okay, now separate from universe, boop, and.
Mark Fielding separate from the universe, I mean, what a sentence that is.
Jeremy Gilbertson I guess that comes from wanting to keep noise out of the equation and wanting to kind of, because back to my analogy of the lion tamers in the cubit in the corner, they're trying to kind of keep all the noise away and keep it from decohering, which I think is interesting. I always think about, there's a great analogy in Michio Kaku's book that we unpacked in book club, Quantum Supremacy. He talked about the idea of a radio tuning in.
Jeremy Gilbertson Right. And, and coherence is when it actually lands on the station and you know, decoherence is kind of the in-between stations and you know, the image, if you think about that, like the in-between States as you roll through and, and, friends, like if you go back to where you actually had a radio with a dial, right. That you, that you can literally turn the dial going from, Oh my gosh. But like, as you, as you run through that, that's basically communication.
Jeremy Gilbertson Attempts right attempting to cohere in between states that we don't that we can't actually lock into so I rolled back on that
Mark Fielding It's a really good analogy. You can really see it and then you extend the frequency out to infinity on each end. It's not just like 92 to 104 on a car radio. It goes forever and you have to fine tune it to that one bit. I thought you did a really good job on the algorithmic qubits versus the physical qubits, Jeremy. It's obviously all the shows that something's stuck in your head. Well done.
Jeremy Gilbertson something's clicking. Yeah, I like the idea of this being like them kind of trying to get the natural process of all of this together, because nature beats us in quantum every day of the week, right? And by taking these ions that are natural, right, and allowing them to be what they are, and trying to work within that system, maybe we can enable the emergent qualities of nature that we all find so fascinating and wonderful, but we don't know how they work.
Mark Fielding Well, yeah, we've had quite a few conversations about that, we? At thinkingonpaper.xyz, you can go there. So, through flows, I know that every week now, something rings a bell from a previous Thinking on Paper episode, and there was two today that he mentioned. The first was from yesterday. So, at the beginning, mentioned that solar rays were a problem for quantum, essentially they cause...
Errors don't name, dis-coherent. then, but yesterday with the data centers in space, solar arrays weren't a problem. So solar arrays weren't a problem for the big, but they were a problem for the very, very, very small. So that was a nice throwback to that. And the other one was you speaking about making quantum boring. And it reminded me of Jonathan, I remember his surname, we speaking about NFTs and blockchain and making NFTs boring and this way of like making the technology that's really hyped.
kind of boring, but they don't mean making it boring, they mean making it kind of like just part of the landscape, don't they? Yeah.
Jeremy Gilbertson Accessible too, accessible, easy to use. So the way I think about it, back to Paki McCormack's paper, think about moving to higher levels of abstraction, right? So when these things become easier and more commonplace, they're just Lego blocks for us to piece things together at higher levels of abstraction.
Mark Fielding Yeah, I think that works a lot more easily with NFTs than it does with quantum computers because honestly, it was another reminder of just... It is just ridiculously complex and I wonder maybe some of us just shouldn't really keep going because we're never going to really go heads around it because it's just so wonderfully complicated and yeah, I was reminded of that again today.
Mark Fielding I love being confused. It was like, my gosh, I know nothing.
Jeremy Gilbertson That's the beauty in quantum systems in nature. Like we don't understand it, but they're there and they're beautiful. it's, it's, it creates, it generates wonder in our head. We talked about wonder a couple of episodes ago, uh, as well, and that we're in a deficit of wonder. Activate your wonder by listening to thinking on paper, thinking on paper. X, Y, Z. We read books together. We have book clubs. We've, we've gone through seven or eight different books. Stay tuned for the next book that's coming up. We've got two chapters left of, uh, Mr. Harari's book that is, uh, been
Jeremy Gilbertson Whew, been dark and, but.
Mark Fielding The most depressing book on artificial intelligence I hope I will ever read. And just because I say it's depressing doesn't mean it's not good because it's very, very good. It's very important and some very, very, very vital things for humanity to think about. We've got two chapters left.
Jeremy Gilbertson Amazing.
Jeremy Gilbertson Tell us about the guest we have coming up, Mark. We've got some killer guests over the next couple of weeks. Tell them what's...
Mark Fielding Yeah. Next week we're speaking about the intersection of AI and blockchain, how blockchain can perhaps secure AI or perhaps AI can just use blockchain to take over the world. We'll find out after that. We've got world ID, the orb, that's going to be amazing. AJ Patel, can't remember his job title, but AJ Patel is going to be breaking down world ID.
Jeremy Gilbertson Come scan your retinas.
Jeremy Gilbertson Ajay, Ajay.
Mark Fielding Kevin Kelly, thinking on paper.xyz. You can win tickets for the screening of that. So yeah, a lot of good things to come.
Jeremy Gilbertson Be curious, stay disruptive.
Mark Fielding Keep thinking on paper.




