What Is a Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computer?
IBM plans to link modules of qubits with a cable that, Oliver Dial says, you can pick up with your hands and bend. That's running a quantum gate across a cable.
In this episode · 13 chapters
- Inside IBM Research: the chandelier
- The Starling announcement
- Why quantum computers make so many mistakes
- Error mitigation versus error correction
- Quantum and classical, working together
- Physical qubits versus logical qubits
- Magic states
- The roadmap beyond Starling
- A physicist's view
- Who will use these machines?
- Bits, neurons and qubits
- What quantum data centers will look like
- Why quantum? The dinner party answer
It’s still a bunch of really difficult engineering problems. But it’s engineering problems that we’re confident we can tackle. And we can tackle them on a timeline.
Oliver Dial, chief technology officer at IBM Quantum, explains Starling, IBM's plan for a fault-tolerant, scalable quantum computer by 2029. He sets out the difference between error mitigation, correcting errors statistically after the fact, and fault tolerance, correcting them as you go.
He explains why a new code needs about 400 physical qubits for a dozen logical ones, what magic states add, and why Starling should be only about three times the size of the Quantum System 2 behind him. Anyone gets 10 free minutes a month on it.
Oliver Dial, chief technology officer at IBM Quantum, argues on the Thinking On Paper podcast that a more efficient quantum error correction code turns Starling, IBM's planned large fault-tolerant quantum computer for 2029, from science fiction into an engineering problem. He walks through the test devices before it, Loon, Kookaburra and Cockatoo, and the Poughkeepsie data centre that will house it.
What does fault tolerance mean in quantum computing?
Fault tolerance means correcting a quantum computer's errors while the calculation runs, rather than statistically after the fact. Dial says this stops errors compounding, and accounts for the factor of 20,000 IBM expects from Starling in 2029.
How often do today's quantum computers make errors?
Today's quantum computers get somewhere between one in 1,000 and one in 10,000 operations wrong, which Dial calls a “ridiculously high error rate”. IBM copes for now by running many variants of the same calculation and correcting the results statistically, and he expects this to show quantum advantage this year or next.
How many physical qubits does IBM's new code need?
IBM's new code stores a dozen logical qubits in about 400 physical qubits, where the best codes of a couple of years ago needed around a thousand physical qubits for each logical one. Dial says about ten of the machines in IBM's lobby would beat the most powerful classical computer in the world.
What test devices will IBM build before Starling?
IBM plans a test device for each step before Starling: Loon to demonstrate the hardware the codes need, Kookaburra as a logical memory, and Cockatoo to make two 12-packs of logical qubits work together, linked by a cable. Dial calls that link “running a quantum gate across a cable”.
How big will IBM's Starling quantum computer be?
Dial says Starling will be only about three times the size of the machine behind him, and IBM is remodelling an old building in Poughkeepsie, New York, into the data centre to house it. He argues this makes quantum computing look less like a space programme and more like a traditional IT system.
Where Mark and Dial disagree
Mark suggests AI and quantum share a synergy because both contain a lot that people do not understand. Dial disagrees: “we do know how quantum mechanics works”, and he adds that IBM already uses AI-powered tools to improve quantum circuits.
Links from this episode
Questions
What is a fault-tolerant quantum computer?
Fault tolerance means correcting a quantum computer's errors while the calculation runs, rather than statistically after the fact. Dial says this stops errors compounding, and accounts for the factor of 20,000 IBM expects from Starling in 2029.
Who is Oliver Dial?
Oliver Dial, chief technology officer at IBM Quantum, argues on the Thinking On Paper podcast that a more efficient quantum error correction code turns Starling, IBM's planned large fault-tolerant quantum computer for 2029, from science fiction into an engineering problem.
What is IBM's Starling quantum computer?
Oliver Dial, chief technology officer at IBM Quantum, explains Starling, IBM's plan for a fault-tolerant, scalable quantum computer by 2029.
Does IBM use AI to improve quantum circuits?
Dial disagrees: “we do know how quantum mechanics works”, and he adds that IBM already uses AI-powered tools to improve quantum circuits.
Transcript
Mark Fielding disruptors and curious minds, CEOs, founders, technology lovers. Welcome to Thinking on Paper. I'm Mark. This is Jeremy. And this is Pocket Edition, a shorter, more concise exploration of a single technology news story of the moment. And we have a very special guest from a very special location today. We're talking about quantum computing, widely expected to solve the biggest challenges, the biggest problems that humanity faces. If there's a question that goes unanswered at the moment,
Mark Fielding Quantum might be our holy grail, mine it Jeremy. And today we have IBM making the most powerful quantum computers on the planet right now. They've just announced $150 billion investment in technology as a whole in America, 30 billion of that directed into their quantum program. goal, do you know what the goal is Jeremy?
Jeremy Gilbertson What's the goal, Mark? What are they trying to do?
Mark Fielding fault tolerant, scalable quantum computers by 2029, the Starlink quantum chip. That's the goal. And today we have Oliver Dial, who is the chief technology officer at IBM quantum. Welcome to thinking on paper, Oliver. Thank you very much for thinking on paper with us today. And...
Mark Fielding Where are you and what is that behind you Oliver?
Inside IBM Research: the chandelier
Oliver Dial So I'm at the IBM Research Headquarters in Yorktown Heights, New York, and I'm actually in our Think Lab, which is a technology showcase that we use with clients and researchers from around the world. And behind me, we actually have IBM's Quantum System 2. This is the biggest, the most powerful, the most sophisticated quantum computer anywhere in the world. And it's something that we're actually really excited that it's not just here in Yorktown Heights, New York anymore, but it's something that we can actually put on premises with and with interested researchers all around the planet.
Mark Fielding very exciting and I'm sure I'll let you go first but last week we had Katia Moskvitch on it, she spoke about the first time she saw a quantum computer, I think it was in IBM in Australia, it was a big golden chandelier, that doesn't look like that.
Oliver Dial So the chandelier that everyone loves to talk about is actually what's inside of this.
Oliver Dial The quantum cubit here itself needs to be protected from the world. We're trying to do computation with some of the most sensitive electronic circuitry on the planet. And so we need to keep light away from it. We need to keep radiation away from it. We actually cool it to very close to absolute zero to get that circuitry to work. So if you gave me two or three days to warm this system up and let the air back in, we could open the door and show it to you. But I don't think that the researchers using it would be very happy with me.
The Starling announcement
Jeremy Gilbertson Fair enough, fair enough. Let's talk about this announcement that just came out and some of the things that jump out to me, there's been a lot of great research and innovation in quantum, especially as of late. I think there's an exponential scale that we're starting to hit with a lot of the exciting work that you guys have been doing for a long, time. So what jumped out at me is the roadmap you announced will actually have these quantum machines being 20,000 times more powerful.
Jeremy Gilbertson And in order to basically show what this system can do with today's computers, need, did I see 10 to the 48th time size memory just to demonstrate what the possibility of these things could be? mean, those blow my mind a little bit. Is that somewhat accurate?
Oliver Dial That's actually very accurate.
Oliver Dial that the reason why people are interested in investing in quantum computers is there are some problems that scale exponentially on classical computers. Every time you take the problem and make it just a little bit bigger, gets twice as hard for the classical computer. For some of those problems, they don't scale exponentially on quantum computers. So although these things are slow, finicky, and expensive, which trust me, somebody that works with these things every day, all three of those are true, the fact that there are some problems that are simply unsolvable with the classical computer that are possible, the quantum computer, justifies all the investment that everyone's making in these things.
Jeremy Gilbertson And the cool thing about this announcement too, and there's a lot of interdependencies with this stuff, I realize. mean, this is very tricky technology to be able to put forth, but IBM has kind of put a flag in the ground, so to speak, and said, hey, here's where we're headed in 2029, and we believe we have the steps in our roadmap to get to this kind of computational superpower down the road. So step us through the roadmap a little bit and tell us why you guys are so confident.
Why quantum computers make so many mistakes
Oliver Dial Well, so we've actually been keeping published roadmaps for a number of years as part of making it clear to people that we kind of know where we're going and what we think is reasonable, because there is honestly a lot of hype in this space. There are two parts to a roadmap. One is near-term devices. We passed a milestone a couple of years ago that we call quantum utility, the point where you can no longer directly simulate these quantum computers on a classical computer. And if you think about it, that's the bare minimum bar. Until you can hit that point, then you'd be better off using a classical computer, it's just cheaper. In the next couple of years we're going to be showing advantage and we're going to be doing that with systems like the Quantum System 2 behind me. What makes that possible are set of techniques called error mitigation.
Oliver Dial Quantum computers make a lot of mistakes. The typical error rate for operations is someplace between 1 1,000 and 1 in 10,000. So imagine trying to do a computation on a computer that 1 in 1,000 calculations is just wrong. It's a ridiculously high error rate.
Jeremy Gilbertson How does that error rate compare to classical computers?
Oliver Dial I don't actually have the error rate for a transistor off the top of my head. It's something on the order of 10 to the minus 15. So enough orders of magnitude between them that it's just an unfathomable number. In practice on your classical processor, you typically don't do anything to correct for the errors other than maybe in the memory and the communication.
Mark Fielding Not very often.
Error mitigation versus error correction
Oliver Dial So to do calculations today, we use something called error mitigation. And what that means is we run the same calculation a lot of times. We run small variants of the same calculation, and we can use that to statistically correct the errors. So even though each individual run had mistakes in it, at the end of the day, we can tell you what the answer would have been without those. That process is pretty expensive. You end up needing to run it an exponential number of times in the size of the circuit. And so you have the same overall scaling that you do with a classical computer, but the pre-factor is better, so you end up winning. So this is sort of something that you can do to get into the game. We think it's going to work well enough that we'll show quantum advantage this year or next year. And that would be the point where we're doing something better, faster, cheaper on the quantum computer than we can do on a classical computer.
Jeremy Gilbertson So is that what you mean by quantum advantage? Is that essentially the definition of that? We talked about quantum utility first and now quantum advantage.
Oliver Dial yep, quantum utility, something that you can't directly simulate, quantum advantage, something done better.
Mark Fielding There was a quote in the new announcement. quote, advancing error mitigation capabilities will be essential for reaching advantage before fault tolerance. So for our regular listeners who aren't into quantum computers, what does that sentence actually mean? What is fault tolerance? It was a big highlight in a lot of the announcement, fault tolerance, fault tolerance. We spoke about that last week with our guests. Could you unpack that for us, please?
Oliver Dial Yeah, sure. So error mitigation, we're correcting the air statistically after the fact. Fault tolerance, you correct them as you run.
Oliver Dial And that is such a huge difference because it means the errors aren't compounding over the course of the computation. Fixing them as you do the calculation gives you ability to go to enormously larger circuits. That's that factor of 20,000 that we're talking about in 2029 with Starling is the difference between error mitigation, correcting after the fact, fault tolerance, correcting as you go. And that really shows up in our roadmap as an absolute step function in what these machines are capable of.
Quantum and classical, working together
Jeremy Gilbertson So in quantum, I see a lot of quantum and classical bridging, meaning you kind of get something happening in the quantum world and you bounce it to classical to take advantage of that. Is the error correction, the stuff you're talking about, error correction, mitigation bouncing back to classical or is this still staying in the quantum realm?
Oliver Dial So it's a mixture of quantum and classical that when you're doing this correction of the errors on the fly as you go, you actually need a substantial classical computer to work out what the errors were and to correct the calculation going forward. And you have to do that real time. So the classical computer has to be able to keep up with the quantum computer while you're doing that. This is, if you look at our roadmap, what we're talking about when we say real time decoding in 2026 is demonstrating the capability to have that classical part of the compute keep up.
Oliver Dial But there's more bouncing back and forth than that. For both the advantage applications and for these long-term fault-tolerant applications, anything you can do on a classical computer, you should do on a classical computer. We really want to reserve the quantum computer, this precious resource, for just the parts of the problem that it's really the only thing that it can solve. And so this concept of tied together a big quantum computer with classical high-performance computing is just a super important part of this technology going forward. It's something we talk about when we talk about quantum centric supercomputing.
Mark Fielding Could we understand that as a ratio at the moment, when you say it's a hybrid classical quantum, as a ratio, a percentage, is it possible to say how much goes to which?
Oliver Dial Jeez, there's such different resources, it's kind of hard to put your finger on that.
Oliver Dial One application a lot of people like right now for advantage is something called SQD. It's a technique for simulating chemistry. And in it, you use the quantum computer to choose what we call a basis, to choose basically how you represent the electrons in the chemical, but then you use the classical computer to actually work out what the energy levels are. And the reason why it works really well is the classical computer, when it does that actual calculation of the energies, does that calculation accurately. And so you don't need to correct for the kind of faults on the fly like you normally would. And so it's sort of an interesting example of error mitigation. In that, we're typically seeing runtimes on the quantum computers that are measured in hours and runtimes on the classical computers that are also measured in a few hours. But you can trade them off against each other a little bit. If you have a lower noise quantum computer, you can also make the classical part cheaper. If you have a noisier quantum computer, you can make up for that by throwing additional classical supercomputing power at it. That's part of why it's such a neat application.
Oliver Dial in the near term that you can trade the two off.
Physical qubits versus logical qubits
Jeremy Gilbertson Very cool. Now I know we don't want to get down into the nitty gritty of Cubits in and of themselves, but talk to us a little bit about the physical to logical Cubit thing and how you guys are connecting them, connecting these to scale the performance and that sort of thing.
Oliver Dial Yeah, so in these fault tolerant... the world of quantum puns is just so huge. I don't know. I'm neither here nor there on that one. Okay, that got a groan. I'm also a dad.
Mark Fielding You can't say connecting, Jeremy. have to like entangle is the new verb, I think. What's your favourite?
Jeremy Gilbertson That's right, that's right. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Mark Fielding At least we got it, it means we're learning something, Jeremy.
Jeremy Gilbertson That's right, that's right.
Oliver Dial Okay, so when we're doing large-scale fault-tolerant quantum computing, we're doing this quantum error correction. The way we correct the errors is we use more than one physical qubit to store each logical qubit. And that lets us do parity checks, right? We can compare the values on the physical qubits and see if one of them is flipped and fix it.
Oliver Dial The ratio of the number of physical qubits you need to the number of logical qubits you get people call the rate of the code and it's super important because the bigger that ratio it is the harder it is to build the quantum computer that you want right that if you look at the best error correcting codes people were talking about a couple of years ago for a useful logical qubit you needed on the order of a thousand physical qubits per logical qubit
Oliver Dial To put that in perspective, this big machine behind me right now, that guy has about 450 qubits in it.
Oliver Dial So you needed something about twice as big as that in terms of number of qubits to store even one logical qubit. And one logical qubit is useless. I can simulate that on my iPhone, right? You really need about a hundred of them before you're even doing anything interesting. So part of this announcement was an architecture for this computer built with a code that's about 10 times more efficient. And so that means for this code to store, in this case, a dozen logical qubits, they come in 12 packs, we need about 400 physical qubits.
Oliver Dial So again, referring to the system behind me, that's about a 12 pack of qubits. If I had about 10 of those systems, I would have something that's more powerful than the most powerful classical computer in the world. Now, to put that in perspective, this is in the lobby of our building. When people are talking about large scale fault tolerant quantum computers, a lot of time you'll see pictures of like a football field.
Oliver Dial and say, if we fill this with a quantum computer, we can make this work. And I'm telling you, it's a few times bigger than this guy we've got in the lobby. And that's why we're saying we're so excited about this, because it seems practical. Right, that this is not a piece of science fiction to make this into reality. It's still a bunch of really difficult engineering problems. But it's engineering problems that we're confident we can tackle. And we can tackle them on a timeline.
Jeremy Gilbertson So physical and logical qubits, the physical qubits are behind you, tucked into this nice little arrangement that you guys have, protective environment for them, right? And these logical ones, is that where the classical quantum bridge lives? Because they're simulated, right? Am I thinking about that right?
Oliver Dial You're on the right path here. So each logical qubit is made up of a bunch of physical qubits and together we're using them to correct the errors on each other. So there is the quantum part of it which is that collection of qubits and then there's a classical part of it measuring all these parities constantly figuring out what errors happened and correcting the calculation for those errors. And so it's this interplay between this real-time decoding and this bucket of physical qubits that makes 12 logical qubits that makes the whole thing work.
Jeremy Gilbertson And the logical ones are doing double checks on the physical ones, kind of going, hey, they're wrong, real time error correction, kind of making sure they stay on the tracks, right?
Oliver Dial Yeah, that's pretty good. mean, imagine I was trying to send you data and there were a lot of mistakes. One thing I could do is instead of sending each number once, I could send it to you three times. You could look at it and you could say, well, you were trying to send me seven because I see here seven, seven, six. The six is probably wrong.
Oliver Dial So in this, the numbers that I'm sending you would be equivalent to the physical qubits. They're kind of extra copies of things, but quantum says you can't copy, so it's a little bit more complicated. And then the logical qubit is a group of three together that you can then figure out what mistakes I made.
Magic states
Jeremy Gilbertson That sense. That makes sense. What can you tell me about a magic state? that seems to me like we got pulled into quantum mechanics a while back and just are so enthralled by what quantum is that is so different from what we see in the real world. So the magic state, you know, tell us about that. Yeah.
Oliver Dial So there are some quantum computations that are easy to simulate. And again, if you can simulate it on a classical computer, you should use a classical computer. And it turns out for each one of these error correcting codes, whether it's the surface code, that old one, or the gross code, our new one, there's some set of gates that are easy to do. They're called transversal. You can do them without unpacking the numbers, basically.
Oliver Dial For all of these codes, the set of gates that you can do for simple codes are also easy to classically simulate. So I've gone to all this work to make this air corrected quantum computer, but at the end of the day, the only complications that it can do are ones that you can run on your laptop. You need one extra ingredient that comes from outside of the error correcting code to make what we call a universal quantum computer. Universal quantum computer is one that can run any quantum algorithm.
Oliver Dial And the most well-known way of doing that is something called magic states. And it's a way of adding sort of one extra operation that comes from outside of the encoded space that lets you lift you up into this magical regime of being able to do these super complicated calculations. And so the way that you do that is you prepare the magic state on physical qubits, and then you keep on protecting it little bit more. You build it into a small error correcting codes. You fix some mistakes. You build it into a bigger error correcting code. You fix some mistakes until ultimately you get it into the error correcting code that you want it to be in.
Oliver Dial So the capability of protecting data, logical memory, doing these easy computations, in our case they're called Clifford computations. They give it Clifford the big red dog, easy. And then adding these magic states to get you to newer roles in computation are sort of the three super important steps for going from a physics experiment to a computer. And we have a plan for all three of those.
The roadmap beyond Starling
Mark Fielding Okay. And that plan is starting by 2029. Bluejay by... Is Bluejay the end goal?
Oliver Dial Well, BlueJ is as far in the future as we feel confident we can plan. Like, the end goal suggests that someday we're going to be done, and we'll have made the final quantum computer, and we'll just be like, that was fun, let's go do something else. Like, we think these things are going to keep getting more powerful, more complicated, cheaper over time. But yeah, BlueJ 2033.
Oliver Dial But it's kind of important to realize we're not just saying, well, we're going to sit here and work really hard in 2029. We're going to pull a sheet back and show this to you. We have some steps along the way that we want to demonstrate to show to the world that this is not just a real plan and a practical plan, but that we're executing on it. So later this year, we're going to have a device called Loon. It's being worked on by a guy we call the chief lunatic, actually. And the job of Loon is to demonstrate the qubits and all the stuff that they need to run these error correcting codes. So it's basically an engineering demo. It's not really going to do anything. Next year we want to make a device called Kookaburra. That'll be a logical memory. And so it's going to show us able to protect quantum information using all these parity checks, using this real-time decoding for seconds. That's to me just sort of amazing to talk about a quantum state that's like lives for long enough that we can have a conversation about it.
Oliver Dial Then the next year we're going to be building a device called Cockatoo. And the key thing for Cockatoo is I mentioned that in the gross code our qubits come in 12 packs. 12 is not enough. We're going to demonstrate getting two 12 packs to work together. Logical communication. That's really the building block in going, it's really key to building a modular computer is the ability to connect the modules together. That's the L coupler, exactly.
Jeremy Gilbertson Is that the L-coupler that's referenced? Got it.
Oliver Dial And that is such a bizarre thing. That's running a quantum gate across a cable. Like you could actually pick this thing up with your hands and you can bend it. You can connect two things together and we can get quantum information to go across that. So much fun. And then finally, Starling showing this magic state distillation, bringing us to universal computation and then getting it out to the world. Because all those steps building up to it, there's great technology demos are going to show memory. They're going to show this Clifford computation, but they're not going to do anything that your classical computer couldn't do. They're not going to be useful.
Oliver Dial for our clients. And so at the same time that we're doing all of this, we're going to have these near-term air-mitigated devices like the one behind me doing more and more useful things in quantum chemistry and material science and optimization and showing quantum advantage in the next two years.
Jeremy Gilbertson So showing the, it's almost like the proof of performance for some of these things you're putting together that are the building blocks of proof of quantum. There you go. No, absolutely. is super exciting. So, all right, you're in a spot where a lot of researchers come together, a lot of scientists come together, a lot of clients of yours that are interested in leaning into quantum. What'd you call it, the Think Lab? Think Lab, so.
Mark Fielding PoQ, proof of quantum.
A physicist's view
Jeremy Gilbertson What are the researchers buzzing about this announcement? Because they start probably thinking about, this is how we could maybe use quantum in 2029. What's the buzz? What are you hearing?
Mark Fielding Well, what's Oliver buzzing about? Because I don't think we've ever had a happier looking guest sitting before us. You seem genuinely excited and genuinely happy with what's happening.
Oliver Dial What do do to your guests that they're all so unhappy,
Mark Fielding They all work in crypto and AI.
Oliver Dial No, seriously, you my background, I'm a physicist, condensed matter physics, study like weird quantum states of matter. And I got into quantum computing to build that Blue J system. It was like the dream, you know, this large scale fault tolerant quantum computer, the first quantum computer that can really run any quantum algorithm that you want to throw at it.
Oliver Dial And so it's always been kind of a game of, we're working really hard on the qubits, we're working really hard on small error correcting codes, all these little technology proofs, or these air mitigated systems that they're computationally useful, but they're tricky to use well, in all honesty. And to have the technology have advanced so far that at this point in my career, I can say, you know what? I think that in eight years we'll have built that thing. That's just amazing that it's watching this entire field come to a pinnacle in the next decade that has me just delighted, tickled pink. Tickled pink.
Mark Fielding But like, so I was going to go off on a little detour. What's a regular day for you? So you arrive in the think tank or wherever your office is. What does a regular day look like for the CTO of IBM Quantum?
Oliver Dial that's a horrible question. There's so many meetings. No, no, seriously.
Mark Fielding Okay, let's take the meetings out of the equation when you're not in a meeting.
Oliver Dial We have a really complicated system here that we have quantum hardware that gets manufactured in semiconductor fabrication facilities, a lot like what you'd use for a CMOS chip. We have classical control hardware that we manipulate these things with a whole bunch of microwaves. And so it looks a lot like an enormous number of cell phone transmitters, huge rack of them. We have software to tie it all together. We have software to let users take their problems, translate them to quantum circuits, the quantum circuits to our computers.
Oliver Dial over the internet and get the answers back. Yeah, by the way, this whole thing's cloud accessible. And somehow it has to make sure all of these things work well together. And so ultimately my main job is taking the hardware, taking the quantum hardware, taking the software, making sure it all plays nice together and gives our users the results that they expect.
Jeremy Gilbertson And this is the accessibility through the Qiskit.
Who will use these machines?
Oliver Dial So, yeah, so if you wanted to run a quantum algorithm, Qiskit has the tools to take your, Qiskit is a software package. It's written in Rust, but has a Python API. It has the tools to take your problem, translate it to a quantum circuit. Then Qiskit runtime gives you tools to take your quantum circuit, send it over the internet to one of our machines, run it, get the answers back.
Oliver Dial Building up a group of people that know how to operate these machines is incredibly important to us. To the extent that actually everyone in the world, including you, gets 10 free minutes a month, you can actually just log in and play with the system behind me for a little while if you want to. Beyond that, we have what we call the IBM Quantum Network, which is a group of 300 companies, academic labs, government labs, that are getting...
Oliver Dial more time on these systems as well as support on how to map their applications into quantum circuits and get the answers they're interested in. And that's all about making sure that when we get to quantum advantage next year, when we get to Starling in 2029, when we get to BlueJ in 2033, we have users that will know how to use those systems. Because if some alien came down and dropped one of these systems in front of us today, I think we'd all sort of look at it and go, huh, what now?
Mark Fielding power is nothing without control. And who will those customers be? We've mentioned material science, chemistry, physics in 2029 beyond. Who will be the IBM Quantum customers?
Oliver Dial So the goal is to have these systems in 29 and 2033 look a lot like what we already provide today, that you'll use the same software to access them, you'll just be able to do more. And so the expectation is that the customers are going to be, well, hopefully a bigger group than those 300 people we have right now. That includes big companies you might recognize the names of, like banks, like aerospace contractors, it includes national labs, it includes
Oliver Dial Gosh, I'm drawing a blank right now on specific names, I'm sorry. Part of what I have to juggle here is some of them really want to brag about the fact that there are clients. Boeing falls into that category. And some of them would rather keep it little bit quiet because they want to build up some advantage for themselves in the meantime.
Jeremy Gilbertson Totally get it. Totally get it. So, all right. So if we're casting it, you mentioned the fact that it's super important to have people on your team that will be able to manage and work and support this kind of compute as you're building it up into 2029. If you're talking to the folks in school right now that are hearing about quantum, are computer science majors or theoretical physics, physics majors, what do you want to tell them about, you know, a direction to point?
Mark Fielding understandable.
Jeremy Gilbertson their learning, their understanding of where this is headed.
Oliver Dial Well, it's really just a hugely multidisciplinary effort. Like I told you, my background's from physics. You have chemists on the team that are really more focusing on the processing of the device, as well as applications you can run on it. A lot of software developers, a lot of electrical engineers. I think the most important thing I'd say is pick something you love and hack away at it. If you want to join our team, the best thing we could ever see is that you found a technology that you cared about, you went out on your own, and you learned how to do something with it, whatever that is.
Jeremy Gilbertson Oliver, that echoes everything we say nearly on a weekly basis that curiosity can power a lot of things, including a great career in any field. So that's really cool.
Bits, neurons and qubits
Mark Fielding quantum curiosity. The IBM announcement was 150 billion across technology in America. I don't think we can have a conversation without mentioning the two letter or three letter word if you're talking plause. Like does AI play a role in the IBM roadmap? And if so, how?
Oliver Dial So we talk about bits, neurons, and qubits. Classical computer, AI, and quantum as being what's going to power the future of computing. And at the end of the day, IBM and IBM research in particular is all about the future of computing, figuring out how it's going to influence all of our lives together for the better. I think there's going to be some really interesting stuff in quantum plus AI, actually. We talked a little bit about scaling and quantum advantage and being able to do something faster, better with a quantum computer than a classical. There are actually some very specific AI problems for which you can prove that a quantum computer would have an advantage. And that's sort of surprising to me. mean, AI is very heuristic. It's very much we do all this stuff and it kind of works, but it's really hard to prove why. And so beyond that, as we get quantum computers big enough to explore AI problems, I think we're going to see heuristics where quantum and AI play together very nicely as well. So it's definitely a thing that we're researching both ourselves and with our partners inside of that I.
Mark Fielding I like that idea that those two unknowns they're AI has it so Sam Altman will come on stage and say we don't know how AI works and then perhaps in quantum there's a lot you don't understand how it works so there's quite a nice synergy there maybe the two can work each other out.
Jeremy Gilbertson Makes sense.
Oliver Dial Well, I mean, we do know how quantum mechanics works. It's just, it's...
Oliver Dial hard to talk about all the possible applications when right now for a lot of them you have to prove that it works on a chalkboard. There's also, by the way, a flip side of this that is always a little bit slower to come to mind for me, is also that we use AI a lot in quantum. We talked a little bit about compiling quantum circuits, and it's a lot like a classical compiler for software that we have an optimizing compiler. It finds places where you have redundant things inside of your quantum algorithm, simplifies them so that it runs faster. Right now, because we have such high error rates,
Oliver Dial If your circuit runs faster, it runs better. That's super important. And actually we have a lot of AI-powered, what we call transpiler passes that go through and improve quantum circuits. So the reinforcement goes in both directions.
Jeremy Gilbertson Outstanding. No, it's good to think about it in that way because a lot of it a lot of the mainstream media is thinking the opposite of that So it's good to good to hear that. what is what is one? Did we miss anything important in this announcement that we have an uncovered? I know there's a great roadmap. You feel confident in this roadmap. You got milestones You got checkpoints that you're gonna prove certain performance aspects of this as we head to 2029 as we head to 2033 What what is there anything we missed in in this?
What quantum data centers will look like
Oliver Dial Well, I mean, one thing that's really fun about it to me is I mentioned, you this is the lobby of our building, basically. This is a system that we think is going to fit in a reasonable amount of space, even BlueJ. We're actually building a data center in Poughkeepsie, New York, which is about a 40 mile drive up the road from here, that's designed to house system twos today. So those terms machines for near term quantum advantage, as well as Starling and BlueJ in the future. And it's actually an absolutely beautiful space, but it's also sort of, again, indicative this is practical. Like this is something that fits into an old building that IBM had off to the side that we can remodel into a data center as opposed to having to build some massive warehouse out in the Midwest to house a system like this.
Jeremy Gilbertson Yeah, so the form factor and the footprint of quantum data centers is looking very different than traditional data center footprints.
Oliver Dial Well, and it's looking very different from how anyone would have predicted it would have looked two years ago. That this advancement in the error correcting codes and the idea of building these modular fault tolerant quantum computers is really bringing this from the kind of large scale engineering you would think of like a space program or something like that into something that looks much more like a traditional IT sort of system.
Mark Fielding Even looking at the backdrop behind you, from there, that looks like it's happening. Yeah, exactly as you described it. It doesn't look like a futuristic alien technology.
Oliver Dial Our designers will be kind of disappointed to know you don't think it looks futuristic.
Mark Fielding Well, yeah, looks... It looks like something from 2001,
Oliver Dial But that having been said, again, Starling is only going to be about three times as big as this guy. It's something very human, very approachable.
Jeremy Gilbertson When, who knows, maybe in a hundred years, it'll be something in a handheld situation like we've seen in form factors where old school computers were giant rooms, vacuum tubes, the whole nine yards, and now we can see stuff in our hand. Probably the cycles will repeat themselves, maybe just a hair differently this time.
Oliver Dial Hopefully so, but you know in the meantime, know one question we get asked a lot is why should this matter to me? Like this is some huge computer that's could be sitting in a data center in New York. It's not on my phone. You know, it's not on my laptop. But the reality is when you're using AI today, it's not on your phone or your laptop anyway. The communication is so good that it almost doesn't matter where the resources are that you can take advantage of it. That's you what we're doing with Qiskit with these 10 free minutes a month. It's what we're doing with AI when you use some large language model to write your homework for you. Sorry my kids are in high school.
Mark Fielding They're not using AI. They're not cheating. Of course not. You just mentioned, you just said, why does it matter to me? And I think that that's probably the best question for most of our listeners is why IBM investing $30 billion in quantum? Why does that matter to me?
Why quantum? The dinner party answer
Mark Fielding You're at a dinner party, what do you say to people though? Why quantum? Why does it matter to me? Why does it matter to humanity?
Oliver Dial I really like to pick on just one of those applications that I mentioned, material science. How do we simulate semiconductors, superconductors, strange novel materials? The reason why I like to pick that one is what are the ages of man named? We have the Stone Age, we have the Iron Age, we have the Bronze Age. That is how important materials are to us because it dictates what we can build. And so if quantum computers can bring forward material science so we can develop new, lighter, stronger materials, superconductors that work higher temperatures, any of those things, just one run that invents one thing has the potential to change everything for everyone. going back to why am I smiling, it's great to be involved in a project that has that kind of potential.
Jeremy Gilbertson I've always thought too, one last thought that always swims around my head when we talk about quantum computing and quantum mechanics, right? So nature does quantum really, really well. Like natural systems do quantum really, really well. And we're trying to kind of emulate those natural systems. I think, isn't there like some kind of cyclical thing that, you know, our quantum computing could help us figure out nature, but nature could help us figure out quantum. Do you ever think about that, that circle?
Oliver Dial Hmm, that is, I've got to say this is the first time anyone has ever asked me that question.
Oliver Dial You know, at the end of the day, like many people on the team, I'm a scientist. Studying nature, studying what it gives to us, and studying kind of some of the really surprising and complex things that happen is really core to what I do. And indeed, there's a lot of science in these computers. We didn't talk about what the qubits were at all, but at the end of the day, our qubits are made out of superconductors, which is this really highly entangled, novel state of matter that doesn't pop out on a day-to-day basis.
Oliver Dial we would not be building these computers without having had a lot of people do a lot of very basic research on things with no obvious applications. Now we're trying to turn this into a means of computing and yes, I absolutely expect one of the huge applications of these systems to be going back and studying nature. In fact, one of our partners in that IBM Quantum Network is studying high energy physics with these things, trying to study the basic interactions that give rise to reality using these quantum computers. so, yeah, I absolutely expect that loop to close.
Mark Fielding Don't go there, Jeremy.
Jeremy Gilbertson No, I'm good. We'll keep it. Yeah, we'll keep it here. well, Oliver, this has been a fantastic conversation. running through this, thanks for stepping us through the roadmap. think it's, I think it's really cool to be able to have the confidence based on your research, based on the work your team has done for a long, long time to kind of say, Hey, here's, here's where we're headed and here's how we're going to get there. And here's how there's why we're confident that we're going to get there. So really cool. We look forward to following those steps and those milestones. Maybe we can jump back in together. And, when you, when you hit some of these performance,
Oliver Dial I would love to do that. Thank you very much.
Mark Fielding We're have to do a live show from upstate New York. Thinking on paper.xyz, we have some great quantum conversations there. We actually have some of Oliver's colleagues. Blake Johnson was on the show. Who else? There were a few IBM guests. So thinking on paper.xyz, I'll put the links in show notes. We have a book club, which we're reading at the moment, which follows on from Oliver's last thing about studying quantum is the building blocks to consciousness and existence. So come and join us for that.
Jeremy Gilbertson So Oliver, have you read Irreducible yet?
Oliver Dial I have not. It's definitely going go next onto my list.
Jeremy Gilbertson Fascinating you I think you would love it. You would love it It did it dips into the consciousness side a little bit more But I would love to hear your thoughts if you choose to read it We do it as a book club when we unpack it we've been doing it for the last month or so But there's my rec for you Appreciate you joining us
Mark Fielding We'd love to have you on that. Thank you very much.
Jeremy Gilbertson All right, that's it. Thinking out paper.xyz. Be curious, stay disruptive.
Mark Fielding Keep thinking on paper. Bye bye.




